SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
The scope of this work is to gain a baseline in membrane characterization for common rare earth elements. Electrochemical processes and techniques for rare earth elements have already been implemented in some cases, but the fundamental behavior has not been thoroughly investigated. With an understanding of the behavior that occurs within the membrane, a better electrochemical device can be developed.
Membrane technologies can enhance the efficiency and selectivity of chemical separations in energy-water systems. Advanced characterization tools are critical for discerning separation mechanisms, revealing degradation processes, and designing novel materials and material systems for new and emerging challenges. The pursuit of next-generation membranes for water and energy applications requires understanding phenomena at the molecular scale, mesoscale, and macroscale. This perspective highlights advanced characterization techniques for elucidating and enhancing membrane performance, while addressing fundamental trade-offs involved in characterizing membranes under realistic conditions.
Characterization of ordered water in hydrophilic membrane pores
Developing a fundamental understanding of the effects of varying ligand chemistries on mass transport rates is key to designing membranes with solute-specific selectivity. While permeation cells offer a robust method to characterize membrane performance, they are limited to assessing a single membrane chemistry or salt solution per test. As a result, investigating the effects of varying ligand chemistries on membrane performance can be a tedious process, involving both the preparation of multiple samples and numerous, time-consuming permeation tests. This study uses digital light processing (DLP) 3D printing to fabricate a millifluidic flow-based permeation device made from a hydrogel active ester network that can be easily functionalized with ion-selective ligands. Without the need for bonding or assembly steps, ligands can be introduced and tested in the permeation device by simply injecting a small volume of a ligand solution. Various salt concentrations and molecular species can be cycled through a single device by switching the solution feeding into the salt reservoir, thereby reducing the number of samples needed for permeability and selectivity screenings. This research sets the groundwork for formulation development and postprocessing methods to 3D-print functional millifluidic devices capable of assessing solute selectivity in membranes and polymer adsorbents for aqueous separations. In this work, comparable salt permeability trends were observed with both 3D-printed devices and traditional assays. Devices were functionalized with an imidazole ligand to investigate salt permeability and selectivity of monovalent and divalent salts. Measurements showed increasing permeability for monovalent salts (NaCl) relative to divalent salts (MgCl 2 , CuCl 2 ) in functionalized membranes, with higher monovalent/divalent selectivity at increasing imidazole grafting densities. Here, the methods and findings described here represent a step toward developing higher-throughput methods with 3D-printed devices for screening the effects of ligand chemistry on mass transport rates in membrane materials.
The present deficiencies in the fluorocarbon sulfonic acid membrane used as the solid polymer electrolyte in the H2/O2 fuel cell are studied. Considered are: Adhesives selection, elastomeric formulations, scavenger exploration, and membrane characterization. The significant data are interpreted and recommendations are given for both short and long range further investigations in two of the four major areas: membrane adhesives and membrane stabilization.
The goal of achieving energy-efficient, precise molecular separations has motivated interest in developing and employing porous crystalline frameworks as membrane materials. Covalent organic frameworks (COFs) are ordered crystalline matrices composed of covalently bonded organic monomers and are synthesized via reversible reticular chemistry. COFs possess high porosity, structural tunability, and chemical and thermal stability, making them ideally suited for emerging, high-value membrane separation processes, such as ion separations, organic solvent nanofiltration, and gas separations. Although a range of COF membranes have been fabricated and tested in the past decade, these membranes are primarily polycrystalline, weakly crystalline, and/or discontinuous, resulting in suboptimal performance. In this review, we identify the properties that make COFs well-suited as membrane materials, while critically outlining the shortcomings of existing disordered COF membranes. We then highlight the recent emergence of highly crystalline, continuous, oriented two-dimensional COF membranes as a promising path forward for highly selective molecular separations. These continuous, oriented COF membranes exhibit tunable one-dimensional nanochannels, allowing for ultrafast molecular transport and precise species selectivity, thereby expanding the set of separations that can be practically achieved with membrane systems. We discuss synthesis and modification techniques that result in continuous, oriented COF membranes and evaluate the performance of such membranes for a variety of molecular separations. We conclude by identifying ongoing challenges in the development of COF membranes and outlining the future of their applications in molecular separations, which will necessarily rely on advancements in the synthesis of continuous, oriented membranes.
Summary and main accomplishments 1. Screening of available polybenzimidazole (PBI) membranes for photoelectrochemical (PEC) hydrogen production. 2. Two main candidate membranes selected and synthesized. 3. Selected membranes characterized, including assessment of electrochemical properties (conductivity) and mechanical properties (creep and creep compliance). 4. Single cell PEC system successfully fabricated. 5. Electrochemical cell tested with initial water decomposition results obtained under ‘dark electrolysis’ conditions. 6. Recommendations given for future test and work.
Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) from Halobacterium salinarum has been a model system for structural biology and is a structural template for the characterization of membrane G-protein couple receptors (GPCRs) in particular. Here, in this study, wild-type bacteriorhodopsin and two single-residue mutants were characterized by native top-down mass spectrometry (nTD-MS) with Orbitrap-based high-energy collision dissociation (HCD) and electron capture dissociation (ECD). After in-source dissociation ejected the membrane protein from detergent micelles, high-resolution native MS measurement allowed for identification of multiple proteoforms as well as lipid-bound forms. Further top-down MS measurements by HCD produced a large number of product ions for in-depth sequencing and unambiguous localization of post-translational modifications. For the first time, native TD-MS with ECD was used to characterize an integral membrane protein. ECD yielded fragments originating from all helices and loop regions, even accessing a sequence stretch that HCD could not. Combining HCD and ECD fragmentation patterns significantly enhanced the sequence coverage of bR. We propose bR to be a model analyte for testing nTD-MS performance for membrane proteins.
Membrane-based separations are widely used for wastewater treatment due to their low cost and efficiency. However, membrane fouling, which is the unwanted deposition or attachment of contaminants on membrane surfaces and/or within membrane pores, remains a major challenge as it increases the mass transfer resistance and reduces membrane productivity. Membrane fouling is typically probed by macroscopic performance metrics, such as flux decline, and ex situ characterization. However, this does not capture the membrane and fouling layer evolution under operating conditions, potentially masking important mechanisms and nonequilibrium pathways that impact fouling. Here, we present a remotely controlled crossflow membrane system and a custom membrane cell for operando fouling characterization using transmission small/wide angle x-ray scattering (SAXS/WAXS). This approach allows direct observation of the nanoscale changes occurring at the membrane surface during pressurized water treatment processes, enabling a new way to understand the connections between dynamic fouling behaviors and membrane performance. Nanoparticle fouling of porous membranes during ultrafiltration was investigated using operando SAXS, and mineral scaling of reverse osmosis membranes was investigated using operando WAXS. Furthermore, this system allows for tracking membrane fouling in real time and under realistic conditions, providing fundamental physical insights into how water chemistry and operating conditions affect macroscopic membrane performance. Moreover, this system opens the door for future in situ and operando studies, and it serves as a testbed for evaluating novel materials/processes for membrane-based separations.
We introduce a stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) methodology designed for rapid, real-time, and in situ monitoring of RO membrane scaling adapted for bench-scale desalination flow cells. The methodology can provide new insights into membrane scaling dynamics by offering time-resolved reflection imaging of inorganic crystal growth, coupled with chemical identification from Raman spectral data. These capabilities allow for direct local measurement of the membrane surface area covered by different scalants as well as an approximation of the scalant volume using three-dimensional, integrated Raman intensity. The 2D and 3D SRS results obtained from CaSO 4 scaling experiments are compared to and are in reasonable agreement with those provided by confocal microscopy. The real-time physical and chemical characterization capabilities presented here could be extended to study combinations of inorganic, organic, and biological fouling. Overall, the SRS methodology represents an advancement in real-time sensing of membrane fouling that offers the potential for improved operation, lower cost, and more resilient RO membrane systems for sustainable water management.
The growing demand for critical minerals and materials requires atom- and energy-efficient, selective separations to overcome the challenges posed by the similar chemical and physical properties of the rare earth elements (REEs) and their low concentrations in unconventional domestic feedstocks. Here, in this study, we developed diethylenetriamine-functionalized graphene oxide (DETA-GO) as a membrane material for REE adsorption and separation. Synthesis conditions were optimized to maximize nitrogen incorporation while also preserving GO dispersibility for facile membrane fabrication. We investigated the mechanism of amine functionalization, the nitrogen-bonding configurations, the organization of the interlayer transport channels, and the resulting effects on ion and water transport for REE separations. Neat-GO and DETA-GO multilayer laminate membranes were fabricated by vacuum filtration onto polymer supports. To investigate the effects of amine functionalization, the membranes were characterized using scanning electron microscopy, Raman, Fourier transform infrared, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, as well as grazing-incidence X-ray diffraction measurements. Ion permeation experiments with representative lanthanum (La 3+ ) and ytterbium (Yb 3+ ) solutions revealed enhanced ion adsorption and water transport through DETA-GO membranes compared to neat-GO. The strong affinity of the membranes for multivalent REEs was also validated with conductivity and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry measurements. Atomistic insight into the role of amine functionalization in modulating nanochannel architecture and long-term stability, optimizing adsorption sites, and regulating REE and water transport was obtained using classical molecular dynamics simulations. Collectively, our joint experimental and theoretical study demonstrates the potential of DETA-GO membranes for selective REE separations, offering insights into ion-binding mechanisms, water-transport properties, and nanochannel optimization for the recovery of critical materials from aqueous feedstocks.
The selectivity of porous membranes is often characterized using solute rejection tests, where membranes are challenged with dilute aqueous solutions of neutral solutes at operating conditions that minimize concentration polarization and fouling. In single solute tests, a membrane is challenged with one molecular weight (MW) solute at a time from low to high MW. Since single solute methods are time-intensive, mixed solute tests have become more common, where a mixture of several MW solutes challenges a membrane at once. However, the presence of large solutes in a mixture increases the rejection of smaller solutes. Furthermore, there are no universally accepted operating conditions or standard methods used by membrane manufacturers or researchers for the experiments, leading to difficulty in pore size and pore characteristic comparisons. In this paper, commercial ultrafiltration membranes were challenged with single and mixed solute polyethylene glycol (PEG) and dextran aqueous solutions. First, rejection values determined using total organic carbon (TOC) and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) from single solute filtration experiments are compared. Differences in rejection curves obtained by the two techniques are attributed to solute polydispersity. Mixed solute filtration experiments with binary mixtures of solutes showcased co-solute interactions, which increase with both the size and weight percent of large solute in the mixture. Mixed solute filtration experiments at varying operating conditions (i.e., stir speed and flux) were conducted to determine operating conditions that mitigate co-solute interactions. Stir speed had a minimal effect on co-solute interactions. In contrast, low flux conditions can help minimize co-solute interactions, leading to pore size distributions that closely resemble results observed in single solute filtration using narrowly dispersed solutes. Additionally, at low flux conditions, the predicted membrane pore size distributions utilizing mixed solute experiments with PEG and dextran were similar.
Electrochemical CO 2 reduction is a promising conversion process for producing value-added fuels and chemicals from electricity and CO 2 as a sustainable carbon feedstock to domestically produce fuels and chemicals from industrial waste. Having reached industrially viable performance metrics with small-scale CO 2 electrolysis cells, the field must now increasingly focus on extending the device durability of large stacks to achieve equivalent metrics for 35,000+ hours to decrease maintenance and capital costs. Reported device lifetimes have increased in recent years, with the longest stability studies for CO, ethylene, and formic acid production being published in 2024–2025 with operation times of 4500, 1000, and 5200 h, respectively. Unfortunately, significant extension of the device durability is still required. Here, we provide an overview of ion-exchange membranes (IEMs) and provide insight into the variety of degradation mechanisms that must be overcome to enable the community to meet durability targets. In an effort to accelerate the extension of device lifetimes, we propose a general approach for characterizing CO 2 electrolysis cell degradation before and after durability testing to better elucidate the mechanisms and failure modes of IEMs in zero-gap cells. Furthermore, we encourage the adoption of operando characterizations in tandem with accelerated stress and durability tests, postulating that their combined applications will be increasingly valuable. We hope that this perspective motivates future durability studies to evaluate degradation across the entire electrolysis cell.
The objective of NAS 3-20108 was the development and evaluation of improved anion selective membranes useful as efficient separators in a redox power storage cell system being constructed. The program was divided into three parts, (a) optimization of the selected candidate membrane systems, (b) investigation of alternative membrane/polymer systems, and (c) characterization of candidate membranes. The major synthesis effort was aimed at improving and optimizing as far as possible each candidate system with respect to three critical membrane properties essential for good redox cell performance. Substantial improvements were made in 5 candidate membrane systems. The critical synthesis variables of cross-link density, monomer ratio, and solvent composition were examined over a wide range. In addition, eight alternative polymer systems were investigated, two of which attained candidate status. Three other alternatives showed potential but required further research and development. Each candidate system was optimized for selectivity.
A total of 18 different membranes were procured, characterized, and tested in a modified bench-scale vapor diffusion water reclamation unit. Four membranes were selected for further studies involving membrane fouling. Emphasis was placed on the problem of flux decline due to membrane fouling. This is discussed in greater details under "Summary and Discussion on Membrane Fouling Studies" presented in pages 47-51. The system was also investigated for low temperature application on wash-water where the permeated water is not recovered but vented into space vacuum.
Perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) membranes are critical components in proton exchange membrane fuel cells, where performance depends on balancing ionic conductivity, mechanical durability, and chemical stability. This study characterizes a composite membrane (NC700) featuring PFSA-impregnated expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) reinforcement and cerium-based radical scavengers, benchmarked against unreinforced NR211. Complementary techniques, including electron microscopy, X-ray scattering, infrared spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis, and dynamic mechanical analysis, identify the structural and compositional strategies employed in NC700. Water sorption isotherms reveal lower water uptake for NC700 across all conditions, attributed to reinforcement and cerium incorporation. Reinforcement reduces in-plane swelling from 11% to 2.1% at 90% RH, confirming strong swelling anisotropy, while maintaining mechanical properties at elevated temperatures. While the ionic conductivity of NC700 is approximately 10% lower than that of NR211, the reduced thickness yields a 40% decrease in calculated area-specific resistance, suggesting the composite architecture can favorably shift the conductivity-stability trade-off. The composite structure also reduces gas permeability, indicating potential for improved separator function alongside favorable transport properties. Systematic deconvolution of reinforcement and additive contributions shows that conductivity losses from cerium incorporation are largely offset by gains from the lower equivalent-weight polymer, providing quantitative relationships that may guide composite membrane design for fuel cells and other electrochemical applications.
CO 2 reduction cells are innovative devices that convert CO 2 into valuable chemicals, such as formate (OFm - ) and acetate (OAc - ), at the cathode. One of the key challenges in these devices is the development of ion exchange membranes that enable the transport of charge carriers between electrodes while minimizing the transfer of CO 2 reduction products. This study focuses on the preparation and characterization of crosslinked anion exchange membranes (AEMs) made of phenyl acrylate (PA) and (3-acrylamidopropyl) trimethylammonium chloride (APTA), crosslinked with either poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate (PEGDA) or N,N’-methylenebisacrylamide (MBAA). Here, the membranes are characterized to understand their physiochemical properties and corresponding transport behavior through characterization of water volume fraction, mechanical properties, ionic conductivity, ion exchange capacity, water contact angle, glass transition temperature as well as their permeability and solubility to formate and acetate. MBAA crosslinked membranes exhibit higher Young’s modulus and lower strain at break compared to PEGDA-crosslinked membranes, which is attributed to their shorter chain length. Within a series of membranes of varied comonomer content, for either PEGDA or MBAA as crosslinker, permeabilities generally follow free volume theory (increasing permeability with increasing water content where water content increases with decreasing crosslinker content). Interestingly, for membranes with different crosslinkers but analogous water volume fraction significant differences (∼2 orders of magnitude) in permeability are observed which we attribute to differences in chain mobility as characterized through the glass transition temperature.
This work introduces a novel, gradient-free metamaterial design method based on Gaussian process regression to represent the density field of a unit cell. The dimension of the design space is determined by the covariance matrix dimension in the Gaussian process regression. We propose compressing this matrix using an autoencoder, enabling the decoder to generate the density field and effectively reduce the originally large design space to a lower-dimensional subspace. In this compressed space, we employ an active learning method, Bayesian Adaptive Direct Search (BADS), for efficient exploration of the design space. We demonstrate that for simple 2D designs aimed at maximizing unit cell stiffness, our method yields results comparable to those of standard topology optimization. Furthermore, we extend our approach to various mechanical problems, from linear elasticity to hyperelastic large deformation and elasto-plasticity under finite deformation, to 3D metamaterial design. This illustrates the method’s versatility and effectiveness across a range of applications.