Deep glassy state dynamic data challenge glass models: Elastic models
The idea of an “ideal” glass transition temperature has persisted at least since the work from Kauzmann when it was observed that the entropy of glass-forming liquids extrapolated to below that of the crystal, thus suggesting the need for a phase transition at a finite or non-zero absolute temperature. This thermodynamic paradox was also found to be related to the observations of a diverging of the extrapolated viscosity or relaxation times at a temperature near to this ideal glass transition. Recently, however, we have carried out experiments using both an ancient amber material and an ultra-stable amorphous fluoropolymer that challenge the ideas of the divergence of the viscosity or relaxation times at this ideal glass transition. In the present manuscript we have evaluated two theories of the glass transition that are based on ideas related to elasticity of the amorphous glass-forming material. We find that the models from both J. Dyre and his group and of K.S. Schweizer and his group not only show non-diverging behavior but are also in some agreement with the new data, though still showing somewhat slower dynamics than those observed in the experiments. The work shows that the data are good enough to distinguish between theories and it is suggested that other mechanisms may be needed to fully describe the non-diverging responses of the ultra-stable glasses.