Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “reflectometry”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 649 records · Page 36

CORRTEX Analysis Techniques

Continuous Reflectometry for Radius versus Time Experiments, or CORRTEX, is a diagnostic that was developed during nuclear testing to measure the distance at which rock walls were disrupted by an explosive device as a function of the time at which disruption occurred. Distances recorded are dynamic measurements of cable length as the shockwaves from an explosive event crush the experiment cables, reducing their usable length. Applications of the CORRTEX diagnostic have been expanded in recent times to include instrumentation of the explosive device itself, to record phenomena such as the speed of the detonation wave in the explosive charge and the crushing or disassembly of material in the charge housing. The diagnostic has likewise been used to monitor explosive performance in rock blasting and oil well hole-clearing activities.

42 ENGINEERING↗

High-Fluence Active Irradiation and Combined Effects Testing of Sapphire Optical Fiber Distributed Temperature Sensors

The goal of this work was to investigate the in-core performance of sapphire optical fiber temperature sensors and to develop clad sapphire optical fibers for in-core instrumentation. We fabricated clad sapphire optical fibers and evaluated the distributed sensing performance of these sensors via optical backscatter reflectometry under high fluence and combined radiation and temperature effects. A series of irradiations was completed to evaluate the effect of irradiation on sapphire optical fiber temperature sensors and to determine the operational limits of these sensors. (1) Objective 1: Fabricate sapphire optical fiber sensors. (2) Objective 2: Evaluate the clad sapphire fiber to verify single-mode behavior and determine and characterize the light modes supported by optical fibers. (3) Objective 3: Characterize the in-core temperature sensing of sapphire optical fiber, as well as the combined temperature and irradiation effects. (4) Objective 4: Evaluate the lifetime and performance of the sensor under irradiation to high neutron fluence. Objectives 1, 2, and 3 were completed during the first 2 years of the project. Due to the Covid pandemic, Objective 4, a high-fluence irradiation performed at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Research Reactor (MITR), was delayed, as partner facilities were subject to mandatory shutdowns and required a 1 year, no-cost extension. This irradiation was eventually completed on December 12, 2022. This work indicates that sapphire optical fiber sensors may be a solution for ultra-high-temperature applications in which traditional silica optical fibers are prone to fail. Sapphire sensors are potentially suitable for experiments featuring temperatures above 700°C for long periods of time, or for any length of time above 1000°C. Experiments featuring a low total fluence, such as irradiations conducted in the Transient Reactor Test (TREAT) facility, also represent good applications for sapphire optical sensors. Additional work is required to characterize the sapphire fiber cladding performance, which falls outside the scope of this project, as well as the effects of high temperatures on the response of the fiber. A comprehensive material study is recommended as future work to evaluate the attenuation in sapphire under irradiation, and how that attenuation changes with irradiation temperature. The drift and attenuation in the fiber at temperatures of up to 1600°C and a total fluence of up to 2.9 x 10 17 n/cm 2 was minimal, and the fibers returned to baseline after being heated to 1600°C under irradiation. This is promising for the future use of sapphire optical fibers in advanced reactors.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Distributed Temperature Profiles of Silicon Carbide Catalyst Bed in a Microwave Reactor using Fiber-optic Sensor

Microwave heating is of great interest for reducing greenhouse gas emissions of catalytic chemical conversion processes because it can heat up the reactants rapidly and efficiently and accelerate reaction rates. In microwave-assisted catalytic thermochemical conversion processes, accurate internal temperature measurement would help facilitate effective process control. Metallic thermocouples interfere and spark in the microwave heating environment, so they are not an option. Infrared pyrometers typically provide a single temperature value by averaging over a finite surface area of the catalyst bed. In this work, we use fiber-optic sensors passing through the catalyst bed to provide more accurate temperatures along the height of the catalyst bed. The fiber optic sensors are immune to the electromagnetic microwave radiation and provide temperature profiles along their length. Here, custom fiber-optic sensors were coupled to the optical distributed temperature sensing devices to measure the temperature profiles along the height of the catalyst bed at high temperatures with ~1 mm spatial resolution. The sensing devices use optical frequency domain reflectometry (OFDR) technique for distributed temperature measurement. This work shows the temperature profiles along the height of the silicon carbide powder catalyst bed in the variable and fixed frequency microwave reactors.

Thapa, Juddha↗

Millimeter-Wave Imaging Technology Development for Real-Time 2D and 3D Fusion Plasma Diagnostics

Including a one year No-Cost Extension, The University of California, Davis has been funded since 2020 to advance innovative millimeter-wave diagnostics for fusion plasma research. This work includes: (1) Developing and applying cutting-edge System-on-Chip millimeter wave Integrated Circuit (IC) technology for Electron Cyclotron Emission Imaging (ECEI) and Microwave Imaging Reflectometry (MIR) on the DIII-D tokamak and the NSTX-U spherical tokamak. (2) Development of radiation-hardened millimeter-wave chip for diagnostics in harsh environments, utilizing wide bandgap Gallium Nitride (GaN) semiconductors. (3) Integrating forward-modeling synthetic diagnostics to enable advanced, real-time plasma prediction and feedback control. Originally planned as a three-year program (2020–2023), the project was granted a one-year no-cost extension, extending its duration through the end of 2024.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

SSTDR and FDR Detection of Un-Energized and Energized Cable Anomalies Including Thermal Degradation Using Machine Learning

Historically, cables are initially qualified for nuclear power plant use for 40 years. As plants extend their operating license to 60 and 80 years, continued use of these cables must shift to a performance-based approach since it is cost prohibitive to completely replace cables that are likely still capable of performing their design function. A variety of cable tests are available and are commonly applied during outages when the cables can be taken out of service. Frequency domain reflectometry (FDR) is one of these test methods that is being more broadly accepted and used because it not only detects anomalies along the cable with a low-voltage signal that does not stress the cable insulation, but the technique also locates the anomalies. This supports follow-up local inspection and local repair or partial replacement of a damaged cable segment. Currently, FDR testing is only applied to cables that are taken out of service since the test instrument would be damaged by operational voltages.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Nickel-incorporated Oxide Composites for Fiber-Optic Based Gas Sensing

Numerous high-value applications within the energy sector involve environmental conditions that are incompatible with traditional sensor technology due to degradation of electrical interconnects, packaging, or the sensors themselves. These can include chemically harsh conditions, high temperature operation, or the presence of electromagnetic interference due to high voltage. The fiber optic platform, constructed of robust, electrically insulating glass or single crystal oxides, offers a versatile and often low cost per node solution to this problem, especially with the integration of distributed sensing techniques such as optical time-domain and frequency-domain reflectometry (OTDR, OFDR). A major challenge of gas and chemical sensing on the optical fiber platform is the fabrication of robust and stable sensing materials that interact quickly and reversibly to the presence of the target analytes. In this work, we discuss the utilization of nickel-incorporated oxides on evanescent-field optical fiber sensors for gas sensing under harsh conditions relevant to multiple energy infrastructure applications. This paper will discuss a Ni/GDC (Ni / Gd-doped ceria) based sensing layer targeting conditions relevant for high-temperature (up to at least 800 oC) hydrogen sensing applications (e.g., for operation within a solid oxide fuel cell or electrolyzer). The impact of hydrogen at elevated temperatures on the optical properties of Ni/GDC will be shown and the material mechanisms for the optical response will be discussed.

gas sensors↗

Pilot-Scale Validation of Distributed Optical Fiber Sensors for Underground Pipeline Monitoring

Monitoring parameters such as hoop strain, pressure, and acoustic vibrations is key to detecting potential leaks, intrusions, or structural issues. Distributed optical fiber sensor (DOFS) systems provide a compelling solution for continuous, real-time monitoring over long distances. This paper details the development and pilot-scale implementation of DOFS systems for underground pipeline monitoring, evolving from a proof-of-concept stage. Multiple custom-designed DOFS interrogator units—such as optical frequency-domain reflectometry (OFDR), Brillouin optical time-domain analysis (BOTDA), and multimodal interferometer-based fiber acoustic sensor systems were tested to measure the key parameters, such as hoop strain, pipe pressure, surrounding soil temperature, and acoustic vibrations. The underground product pipeline’s outer diameter is 30 inches, the wall thickness is 1.28 inches, and 3 feet deep from the surface. The fiber deployment strategies and sensing data acquisition methods for these systems are discussed. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of DOFS in detecting hoop strain, temperature changes, and acoustic vibrations, showcasing their potential for real-time monitoring and enhancing pipeline safety. These findings from pilot-scale testing offer valuable insights into advancing pipeline monitoring technologies and improving the reliability of underground pipeline systems.

fiber optic sensors↗

Single Crystal Optical Fiber and Perovskite Oxide Sensing Materials for Gas Monitoring above 500 °C

A wide range of high-value applications, including power generation and chemical manufacturing, involve harsh chemical conditions and extreme temperatures. In this work, we discuss the pairing of single crystal optical fiber with optically responsive, high-temperature stable perovskite oxide materials for monitoring of oxidizing and reduction gas streams up to 1000 °C. Optical sensing will be presented for hydrogen and oxygen monitoring in this temperature regime. Strategies will be discussed for improving stability and eliminating drift via multi-wavelength detection. The application of spatially resolved interrogation techniques, such as optical time domain reflectometry (OTDR) will be addressed for these sensors.

Wuenschell, Jeffrey↗

Novel High Resolution High Temperature In-Line Sensors for Steel Manufacturing

To support efficiency, productivity, yield improvements, and future industry 4.0 and SMART manufacturing objectives for a competitive and prosperous steel industry, this program has embarked on an effort to develop, demonstrate and deploy several novel sensing technologies based on fiber optics for use in production steel facilities. Over the duration of this program, our team has successfully demonstrated three of these technologies: (1) near continuous Rayliegh Scattering optical frequency domain reflectometry (OFDR) sensing with single mode silica fibers for temperature sensing to 700 C, (2) semi-distributed fiber Bragg grating (FBG) sensing with multimode sapphire fibers for temperature sensing to >1600 C, and (3) remote in-situ Raman analysis for slag and flux chemistry analysis at steelmaking temperatures >1550 C. Each of these sensor and interrogation systems was developed, refined, and tested in our labs at Missouri S&T and then successfully deployed at SSAB’s production facilities at two sites, one in Montpelier, IA and one in Mobile, AL.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Development of High-Temperature Bonding Techniques to Enable High-Temperature Static or Dynamic Strain Measurements

Current light-water nuclear reactors rely on a variety of different sensors and sensor applications to meet their structural health monitoring needs throughout the entirety of the reactor primary, secondary, and containment systems. Optical fiber–based sensor technologies could provide solutions to reduce the sensor system footprint while enhancing the measurement fidelity and spatial resolution by leveraging distributed monitoring techniques. Moreover, advanced reactors may require optical fiber–based sensors for structural health monitoring because their operating temperatures will exceed the limits of conventional transducers used to acquire dynamic strain or acoustic data in nuclear power plants. Therefore, this report describes experiments targeting the development of high-temperature bonding techniques that would allow for potentially long lengths of fibers to be bonded to metallic reactor components in advanced reactor systems. The high temperatures experienced within target application, next-generation nuclear reactors, necessitate a high-temperature resistant bond to limit the amount of tension on the fiber at the target application temperature. The primary bonding method investigated in this work is brazing; hot-rolling has also been investigated to a lesser extent. Both techniques are well-suited to bonding optical fibers to large reactor components such as primary coolant piping, pressure vessels, or heat exchangers. Optical frequency domain reflectometry was used to monitor the strain in metal-coated optical fibers before, during, and after the high-temperature bonding process. On select optical fibers that were successfully bonded, additional thermal cycling was performed to assess the extent to which the fiber remained bonded based on the expected thermal expansion of the test specimen material. The results of the various experiments yielded the following general conclusions: (1) brazing is a viable technique for bonding and allows significant compressive strain to be applied to the fiber at room temperature; (2) hot-rolling is a viable technique as well, which has been more optimized than the brazing technique for bonding, but less residual compressive strain has been observed with this technique; and (3) both techniques will need further development and optimization to demonstrate bonding of a long length of fiber that can provably operate at relevant temperatures for an advanced nuclear reactor application.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Embedding of Optical Fibers with Electric Field Assisted Sintering

The Electric Field Assisted Sintering (EFAS) technique was used for embedding the fibers, involving rapid heating via an electric current and pressure, reducing fiber exposure to high temperatures. Stainless steel guide tubes were inserted at the fiber-matrix junctions to prevent fiber breakage during the sintering process. The study varied key EFAS parameters—temperature (800°C to 980°C), pressure (40-50 MPa), and hold time (5-10 minutes)—to assess how they influenced fiber embedding. After embedding, the fibers were inspected using optical frequency domain reflectometry (OFDR) to evaluate optical losses and strain along the fiber length. The OFDR scans confirmed that the fibers remained intact, and subsequent transmission tests demonstrated no macroscopic fractures. The embedded samples were also analyzed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and X-ray computed tomography (CT) scans. These tests confirmed good bonding between the fiber and matrix with no cracking, though some porosity was present in samples fabricated at lower temperatures. At higher temperatures (980°C), the fiber-matrix bonding was continuous and defect-free, with metal coatings aiding in the bonding process. Elemental analysis showed interdiffusion between the fiber coatings and matrix materials, particularly between the gold coating and stainless steel. Helium leak tests revealed that lower sintering temperatures resulted in matrix porosity, causing leaks, but samples fabricated at 980°C were leak-tight.

46 - INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AN↗

Evaluation of Damage in Medium Voltage Cable Using Machine Learning

Developments in cable test instrumentation coupled with artificial intelligence and machine learning (ML) to aid in interpretation of cable test signals supports the feasibility for automated analysis of reflectometry tests for low voltage power cables. This work seeks to leverage prior ML work and success for low voltage cables to evaluate potential application to medium voltage (2kV to 10kV) installations. The Accelerated and Real-Time Environmental Nodal Assessment (ARENA) Cable Motor Test Bed at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) was used to test a medium voltage cable with several types of damage including thermal aging and low resistance conductor-to-shield faults. The cable was tested using an inductive clamshell coupler to protect the test instruments from the energized cable voltages that would damage the test instruments if coupled directly to the energized conductor.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Dielectric Spectroscopy Cable NDE for Unequal Aging Over Different Lengths

This Pacific Northwest National Laboratory milestone report assesses the effect of unequal aging over different lengths of cable on dielectric spectroscopy (DS) bulk impedance measurements from the cable end. DS measurements can indicate the remaining useful life of cables; however, most benchmark tests are based on accelerated aging of the entire cable. If only a portion of the cable is exposed to a harsh environment (as is frequently the case), the DS measurement will indicate a significantly less-aged cable than if the entire cable were exposed to a uniform environmental stress. The DS measurement is primarily related to the intrinsic insulation material relative permittivity—typically between 1.5 and 3.0. Insulation aging increases permittivity and, correspondingly, the cable’s overall capacitance measured from the cable end. To judge the health of the overall cable system, operators are primarily interested in the condition of the most severely aged section since that is where a failure is most likely to occur. This can be expressed as the dimensionless relative permittivity of the severely aged section divided by the permittivity of a pristine cable. This relative permittivity is an intrinsic material parameter independent of cable length and can serve as a quantitative indication of the insulation condition. If the relative percentages of cable exposed to a harsh and benign environment are known, the DS measurement of the entire cable length, including both pristine and aged sections, can be compensated to predict the relative permittivity (relative to pristine permittivity) of the most severly aged segment. A test was performed on three 50 ft (16 m) cables with 10%, 50%, and 90% of the cable inside a thermal aging oven. Predictably, the aging effect on the DS response was greatest in the 90% sample, followed by the 50% sample, and then the 10% sample. The more interesting result is the ratio of the aged insulation permittivity to the pristine insulation permittivity. Based on prior work, an end-of-life cable has a value of approximately 1.35. If the relative percentages of pristine and severely aged cable lengths are known, and the total cable-length capacitance of the initial pristine cable and the combined pristine plus aged cable are known, the relative aged permittivity (ratio of aged section permittivity / pristine section permittivity) can be estimated. The relative cable lengths exposed to a harsh environment may be known or estimated based on plant layout drawings or cable reflectometry tests that can locate the oven entry and exit points. The compensation was verified using a lumped-parameter model to predict the aged-segment permittivity e2/e1, where e2 is the aged-segment permittivity and e1 is the pristine-segment permittivity. For all three percentages of aged cable lengths, the ratio was quite similar, as would be expected since all cable segments were exposed to the same aging environment. This ratio of aged permittivity to pristine permittivity can be compared to other damage indicating tests, including elongation at break, to assess cable condition.

ARENA Test Bed↗

Post-Closure Inspection and Monitoring Report for Corrective Action Unit 110: Area 3 WMD U-3ax/bl Crater, Nevada Test Site, Nevada, For the Period July 2007-June 2008

This Post-Closure Inspection and Monitoring Report (PCIMR) provides the results of inspections and monitoring for Corrective Action Unit (CAU) 110, Area 3 WMD [Waste Management Division] U-3ax/bl Crater. This PCIMR includes an analysis and summary of the site inspections, repairs and maintenance, meteorological information, and soil moisture monitoring data obtained at CAU 110 for the period July 2007 through June 2008. Site inspections of the cover were performed quarterly to identify any significant changes to the site requiring action. The overall condition of the cover, perimeter fence, and use restriction (UR) warning signs was good. However, settling was observed that exceeded the action level as specified in Section VII.B.7 of the Hazardous Waste Permit Number NEV HW021 (Nevada Division of Environmental Protection, 2005). This permit states that cracks or settling greater than 15 centimeters (6 inches) deep that extend 1.0 meter (m) (3 feet [ft]) or more on the cover will be evaluated and repaired within 60 days of detection. Two areas of settling and cracks were observed on the south and east edges of the cover during the September 2007 inspection that exceeded the action level and required repair. The areas were repaired in October 2007. Additional settling and cracks were observed along the east side of the cover during the December 2007 inspection that exceeded the action level, and the area was repaired in January 2008. Significant animal burrows were also observed during the March 2008 inspection, and small mammal trapping and relocation was performed in April 2008. The semiannual subsidence surveys were performed in September 2007 and March 2008. No significant subsidence was observed in the survey data. Monument 5 shows the greatest amount of subsidence (-0.02 m [-0.08 ft] compared to the baseline survey of 2000). This amount is negligible and near the resolution of the survey instruments; it does not indicate that subsidence is occurring overall on the cover. Soil moisture results obtained to date indicate that the CAU 110 cover is performing well. Time Domain Reflectometry (TDR) data show regular changes in the shallow subsurface with significant rain events; however, major changes in volumetric moisture content (VMC) appear to be limited to 1.8 m (6 ft) below ground surface or shallower, depending on the location on the cover. At 2.4 m (8 ft) below the cover surface, TDR data show soil moisture content remained between 9 and 15 percent VMC, depending on the TDR location. The west portion of the cover tends to reflect a lower moisture content and less variability in annual fluctuations in moisture content at this depth. Results of soil moisture monitoring of the cover indicate that VMC at the compliance level (at 2.4 m [8 ft] below the cover surface) is approaching a steady state. If the moisture content at this level remains consistent with recent years, then a recommendation may be made for establishing compliance levels for future monitoring.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Fast Transient Simulations for Multi-Segment Transmission Lines with a Graphical Model

This paper studies a computationally efficient algebraic graph theory engine for simulating time-domain one-dimensional waves in a multi-segment transmission line, such as for reflectometry applications. Efficient simulation of time-domain signals in multi-segment transmission lines is challenging because the number of propagation paths (and therefore the number of operations) increases exponentially with each new interface. We address this challenge through the use of a frequency-domain, algebraic graphical model of wave propagation, which is then converted to the time domain via the Fourier transform. We use this model to achieve an exact, stable, and computationally efficient (O(NQ), where N is the number of segments and Q is the bandwidth) approach for studying one-dimensional wave propagation. Our approach requires the reflection and transmission coefficients for each interface and each segment's complex propagation constant. Furthermore, we compare our simulation results with known analytical solutions.

42 ENGINEERING↗

10 Boron-film-based gas detectors at ESS

The development of detectors for the European Spallation Source is an important parallel element to the effort put into the design and construction of the neutron source and instruments. The 10Boron-film-based detector developments that started over a decade ago as basic detector concepts have now reached technical maturity after intense prototyping work and numerous testing campaigns. Several of the ESS beamlines that will soon enter the commissioning phase started welcoming the detector systems built with the 10 B-film converter technology. The real-size demonstrators evolved in the last 2–3 years into a diverse suite of gas proportional counters for use in diffraction, reflectometry and small-angle scattering studies in spite of the operational complexity posed by the requirements for large-area coverage, low material budget and robustness for operation in the high-flux and high-radiation environment of ESS. The detectors are now being shipped to ESS or undergoing the last performance and calibration tests before being handed over to the instrument teams for installation in the host beamlines. A common feature of these detector systems is the very large number of readout channels that they are instrumented with in order to fulfill the demanding requirements for sensitivity, spatial resolution and count-rate capability. Across all of the detector types that will operate at ESS, the integration, testing and commissioning of the read-out technologies and software tools for data reduction, calibration and analysis are the focus of the detector and integration teams. These will yield a wealth of knowledge about their operation as well as initial results on the in-situ performance, a very important asset to ensure rapid commissioning of the detectors when neutrons from the ESS source become available. In this paper we will give an overview of the 10 B-film-based detector technologies included in the ESS detector suite that are currently facing the transition from the production phase to installation and integration with the other beamline components, which comes with its own specific challenges of both organizational and technical nature.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Biomembrane Structure and Material Properties Studied With Neutron Scattering

Cell membranes and their associated structures are dynamical supramolecular structures where different physiological processes take place. Detailed knowledge of their static and dynamic structures is therefore needed, to better understand membrane biology. The structure–function relationship is a basic tenet in biology and has been pursued using a range of different experimental approaches. In this review, we will discuss one approach, namely the use of neutron scattering techniques as applied, primarily, to model membrane systems composed of lipid bilayers. An advantage of neutron scattering, compared to other scattering techniques, is the differential sensitivity of neutrons to isotopes of hydrogen and, as a result, the relative ease of altering sample contrast by substituting protium for deuterium. This property makes neutrons an ideal probe for the study of hydrogen-rich materials, such as biomembranes. In this review article, we describe isotopic labeling studies of model and viable membranes, and discuss novel applications of neutron contrast variation in order to gain unique insights into the structure, dynamics, and molecular interactions of biological membranes. We specifically focus on how small-angle neutron scattering data is modeled using different contrast data and molecular dynamics simulations. We also briefly discuss neutron reflectometry and present a few recent advances that have taken place in neutron spin echo spectroscopy studies and the unique membrane mechanical data that can be derived from them, primarily due to new models used to fit the data.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

The Thermal Response of a Packed Bed Thermal Energy Storage System upon Saturated Steam Injection Using Distributed Temperature Sensing

The effectiveness of a thermal energy storage (TES) system is typically characterized with the help of thermal stratification or temperature gradients along the direction of heat injection, which is typically the flow direction of heat transfer fluid. The steepness of temperature gradients are a direct indicator of the effectiveness or efficiency of the heat storage or dispatch process. The temperature gradient evolution along the packed bed of ceramic particles upon saturated steam injection is presented in this work. Distributed temperature sensing based on optical frequency domain reflectometry was deployed in a packed bed of ceramic particles to capture the thermal front evolution in the axial direction. The physical processes accompanying steam injection in packed beds are complex due to phase change, transitioning two-phase flow, and changes in condensate accumulation. Therefore, the variation of thermal response of the TES system for various steam injection flow rates was experimentally studied using a high-resolution distributed temperature sensing system in a chemically inert alumina particle-packed bed. Distinct zones of different heat transfer modes were observed during the steam injection experiments. A distinct conduction zone, evident from diffuse thermal fronts, was observed at low flow rates, and these thermal gradients became sharper as the flow rate increased. The diffuse thermal fronts in the heat storage media suggest a low exergy efficiency of the TES system, as energy losses started initiating before a significant fraction of the bed was saturated with steam.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗