Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “DIFFUSION”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 217 records · Page 12
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2021

First-principles studies of the concentration-dependent tritium diffusion in the zirconium hydrides with and without Sn impurity

We performed first-principles calculations to study the 3 H diffusion in the zirconium hydrides with or without Sn impurity. Our results show that the formation of Zr 3 H x becomes preferable as the 3 H concentration increases. Based on the most stable configurations of Zr 3 H x (x = 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0), we studied the interstitial 3 H diffusion with or without Sn impurity. The results show that the interstitial 3 H diffusion becomes less probable in the hydrides with a higher 3 H concentration. When introducing a substitutional Sn impurity, the diffusion barriers increase. Therefore, the substitutional Sn in the diffusion pathway hampers the 3 H diffusion in Zr hydrides.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

An efficient reconstruction algorithm for diffusion on triangular grids using the nodal discontinuous Galerkin method

High-energy-density (HED) hydrodynamics studies such as those relevant to inertial confinement fusion and astrophysics require highly disparate densities, temperatures, viscosities, and other diffusion parameters over relatively short spatial scales. This presents a challenge for high-order accurate methods to effectively resolve the hydrodynamics at these scales, particularly in the presence of highly disparate diffusion. A significant volume of engineering and physics applications use an unstructured discontinuous Galerkin (DG) method developed based on the finite element mesh generation and algorithmic framework. This work discusses the application of an affine reconstructed nodal DG method for unstructured grids of triangles. Solving the diffusion terms in the DG method is non-trivial due to the solution representations being piecewise continuous. Hence, the diffusive flux is not defined on the interface of elements. The proposed numerical approach reconstructs a smooth solution in a parallelogram that is enclosed by the quadrilateral formed by two adjacent triangle elements. The interface between these two triangles is the diagonal of the enclosed parallelogram. Similar to triangles, the mapping of parallelograms from a physical domain to a reference domain is an affine mapping, which is necessary for an accurate and efficient implementation of the numerical algorithm. Thus, all computations can still be performed on the reference domain, which promotes efficiency in computation and storage. This reconstruction does not make assumptions on choice of polynomial basis. Reconstructed DG algorithms have previously been developed for modal implementations of the convection–diffusion equations. However, to the best of the authors’ knowledge, this is the first practical guideline that has been proposed for applying the reconstructed algorithm on a nodal discontinuous Galerkin method with a focus on accuracy and efficiency. As a result, the algorithm is demonstrated on a number of benchmark cases as well as a challenging substantive problem in HED hydrodynamics with highly disparate diffusion parameters.

Computational efficiency↗
DOE OSTI2020

Persistent compositions of non-stoichiometric compounds with low bulk diffusivity: A theory and application to Nb3Sn superconductors

Non-stoichiometric compounds may develop a composition gradient when they are formed by reactive diffusional processes. This paper reports an interesting phenomenon that in compounds with low bulk diffusivities, which rely mainly on grain boundary diffusion for their growth, the final bulk compositions may be far from equilibrium, with a very low bulk diffusivity leading to fixed (persistent) compositions – one such example is Nb 3 Sn, a superconductor. We investigated the microchemistry at the reactive interface using atom probe tomography to clarify the diffusion reaction mechanism for this low-bulk-diffusivity case and thus propose a theory for what determines the compound composition, using Nb 3 Sn as an example for concreteness. Using certain approximations, we derive an explicit analytical equation that illustrates what factors determine its composition profile. We compare our model with the known facts of Nb 3 Sn and see good agreement. In particular, this model predicts that internal oxidation may lead to higher Sn contents than conventional, non-oxidized Nb 3 Sn. Our measurements show that this is indeed true, and that the internally-oxidized Nb 3 Sn also has higher upper critical fields, achieving up to 28.2 T at 4.2 K. We discuss the general applicability of this model to non-stoichiometric compounds with low bulk diffusivity, and propose it as a tool to help in the design and processing of such materials for compositional control.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2019

Diffusion behaviors between metallic fuel alloys with Pd addition and Fe

Fission product lanthanides (Lns) in metallic fuel is the primary cause of fuel-cladding chemical interaction (FCCI). Palladium (Pd) is being explored as a potential additive to reduce or mitigate FCCI by forming stable Pd-Ln compounds. The current study is an investigation of diffusion behaviors between UZrPd, UZrPdLn, UPuZrPd, and UPuZrPdLn alloys (Ln = 53Nd-25Ce-16Pr-6La wt. %) and iron (Fe). Diffusion couple tests were performed followed by microstructural analysis using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). It is found that the diffusion of Fe into the fuel is reduced by PdZr2 precipitates randomly dispersed throughout the fuel matrix. Ln-Pd compounds form in UZrPdLn alloys, and (Ln,Pu)Pd forms in the UPuZrPdLn alloy. In both diffusion couples with Ln, small amounts of Lns are diffusing into the Fe. This could be due to small amounts of dissolved Lns in the precipitates, or could be due to the Ln-Pd compounds decomposing. In either case, diffusion caused by Lns is greatly reduced.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2021

Radiation driven diffusion in γU-Mo

A monolithic fuel design based on a U-Mo alloy has been selected as the fuel type for conversion of the United States High-Performance Research Reactors (HPRRs). A critical phenomenon of interest with U-Mo monolithic fuel is the large amount of swelling that takes place during operation, particularly at high fission densities. The accurate prediction of fuel evolution under irradiation requires implementation of correct thermodynamic and kinetic properties into mesoscale and continuum level fuel performance modeling codes. One such property where there exists incomplete data is the diffusion of relevant species under irradiation. Fuel performance swelling predictions rely on an accurate representation of diffusion in order to determine the rate of fission gas swelling and the local microstructural evolution. In this work, we present molecular dynamics simulations of the radiation driven diffusion of U, Mo and Xe in U-Mo nuclear fuels. Diffusion coefficients for each species are determined over a range of temperatures and compositions. In this work, updated diffusion coefficients are presented that are applicable under irradiation that incorporate both intrinsic and radiation driven diffusion.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2020

Thermal diffusivity of irradiated tungsten and tungsten-rhenium alloys

The Japan-US PHENIX project irradiated tungsten materials in the RB-19J capsule experiment in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). A gadolinium (Gd) shielding was used to absorb the thermal neutrons and reduce rhenium and osmium generation in tungsten. Pure tungsten and K-doped W-3% Re samples were irradiated at 532 – 662 °C to dose of 0.21-0.46 dpa, with the grain orientation perpendicular or parallel to the disk surface. Thermal diffusivity measurements were performed from 100 °C to 500 °C. Furthermore, additional measurements followed after annealing up to 900 °C. Irradiated pure tungsten specimens showed similar thermal diffusivity results compared with an unirradiated W-1% Re specimen in another study. The transmutation amount of Re was calculated to be about 0.52% for those specimens that showed good agreement with this study. Specimens irradiated in this study to different doses presented almost the same thermal diffusivity. Annealing up to 800 °C resulted in no recovery of thermal diffusivity. These results show that the contribution of crystalline defects to degradation of thermal diffusivity is quite limited. In addition, the thermal diffusivity of the irradiated specimens was getting close to that of the unirradiated specimens at elevated temperature.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Modeling fission product diffusion in TRISO fuel particles with BISON

Diffusion of fission products in intact TRISO particles depends on particle geometry, fission product source rates, time, temperature, and temperature-dependent diffusion coefficients. Simulating this diffusion process requires models for source rates and diffusion coefficients, plus computation of the temperature field if not prescribed. In addition, simulation quality depends on discretization of the geometry, appropriate time stepping, and the accuracy of the solution method. In this paper, we explore the simulation of fission product diffusion in TRISO fuel particles using the finite element method via the fuel performance code Bison. Recent material model development has occurred in Bison for each material present in tri-structural isotropic (TRISO) fuel particles: the buffer, inner pyrolytic carbon, silicon carbide, and outer pyrolytic carbon layers, as well as the fuel kernel. Also, new mesh generation and fission product release fraction capabilities have been added. Diffusion capabilities are shown to converge to the correct solution via formal verification tests. A large number of code benchmarking problems are also given, with good results, showing that Bison’s computed release fractions closely match those of other software tools. Finally, a significant validation effort is detailed in which fission product release, measured as part of the AGR-1 capsule experiments, is compared to Bison outputs. Bison outputs compare very well to the experimental data and to PARFUME results.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2022

Europium diffusion in IG-110 nuclear graphite

Europium diffusion in graphite has been recognized to be of interest in high-temperature gas reactor safety analysis, particularly as an indicator of strontium diffusion. However, no measurements of europium diffusion coefficients have been reported in the literature. In this work, the effective diffusion coefficient of europium was measured using a time-release method. Natural europium was loaded into pre-milled unirradiated IG-110 graphite spheres using a pressurized acid digestion vessel. The time-release experiments were performed in the temperature range 1823 K – 1973 K using a SiC diffusion cell connected to an inductively-coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS) via a He gas line. Finally, the results of this work are: D Eu, IG-110 = (1.5 x 10 -3 m 2 /s) exp $(\frac{-2.87\mathrm{x}10^{5} J/mol}{RT})$ This effective diffusion coefficient can be used to aid in predictive modelling of europium transport in HTGRs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Effect of Mg and Ni impurities on tritium diffusion in lithium ceramics through cluster dynamics simulations

This study investigates the impact of Mg and Ni doping on tritium diffusion in LiAlO 2 and LiAl 5 O 8 ceramics, that are used in tritium-producing burnable absorber rods (TPBARs). Utilizing Centipede simulations across a broad temperature range (500 K to 1250 K), we explore the interplay between defect dynamics, cluster formation, and tritium mobility. In LiAlO 2 , Mg doping significantly enhances tritium diffusivity by increasing tritium interstitial concentrations and diffusion coefficients of key species, thereby doubling the overall tritium diffusivity. Ni doping, while shifting the dominant defect to Li vacancies, maintains high tritium mobility due to the low binding energy of Li vacancy-tritium complexes, which ensures effective tritium migration. In LiAl 5 O 8 , Mg and Ni doping results in a slight reduction in the diffusion coefficients of key species, yet the dramatic increase in tritium interstitial concentrations compensates, leading to a net small increase in tritium diffusivity. In conclusion, the findings highlight the critical role of defects in tritium transport and the effect of Mg and Ni defects on the performance of these ceramics in demanding nuclear environments.

Cluster dynamics↗
DOE OSTI2025

First-principles investigation of cerium and neodymium diffusion in BCC chromium and vanadium via vacancy-mediated transport

Lanthanide transport plays a crucial role in the performance and longevity of metallic nuclear fuels. This study examines the diffusion behavior of Ce and Nd—two major fission products—in body-centered cubic (BCC) Cr and V, which are potential liner or coating materials for mitigating fuel-cladding chemical interactions (FCCI). Using density functional theory (DFT) calculations and self-consistent mean-field (SCMF) analysis, the vacancy-mediated diffusion coefficients are evaluated. Our findings reveal that Ce and Nd act as oversized solutes and are strongly bound to vacancies in BCC Cr and V, with diffusivities in Cr significantly lower than in V and in hexagonal closed-packed (HCP) Zr, as investigated in our previous work. The activation energies for Ce and Nd diffusion are 3.39 and 3.32 eV, respectively, in BCC Cr, and 2.56 and 2.33 eV, respectively, in BCC V. Analysis of vacancy drag and partial diffusion coefficient ratios indicates a strong tendency for lanthanide enrichment at vacancy sinks in BCC Cr, and to a lesser extent in BCC V, with this effect persisting up to the melting point in Cr and remaining substantial for Nd in V at high temperatures. Under irradiation, the increase in vacancy concentration is expected to enhance lanthanide transport, potentially accelerating interactions at liner-cladding interfaces. Although BCC Cr exhibits relatively low lanthanide diffusivities under equilibrium conditions, the expected segregation tendencies under irradiation suggest that Zr liners may be a more favorable option. Further investigations using rate theory, cluster dynamics, and phase-field modeling are required to quantitatively assess the performance of these materials in reactor environments.

36 - MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Tensile behavior of diffusion bonded AA6061 - AA6061 with variation in cooling method

Hot isostatically pressed AA6061 cladding is an important structural component of the high performance, Zr-laminated U-10Mo monolithic fuel system for the application in research and test reactors. In this study, the mechanical behavior of two diffusion bonded aluminum alloy, AA6061, was examined using tensile testing. Solid-to-solid diffusion bonding between two pieces of AA6061 was performed by isothermal annealing at 560 °C for 1.5 h, and diffusion couples were subsequently cooled via three different cooling methods: furnace cooling, air cooling, and water quenching. Dog-bone shaped tensile specimens, with 10 mm in gauge length (with diffusion bonded interface in the middle), and 1.5 × 1.5 mm 2 gauge cross-sections, were fabricated from the diffusion bonded AA6061 by electro-discharge machining. Yield strength (% EL at failure) of furnace cooled, air cooled and water quenched tensile specimens determined was 82 ~ 89 MPa (10 ~ 30%), 112 ~ 116 MPa (10 ~ 14%), and 149 ~ 164 MPa (10 ~ 17%), respectively. This variation in mechanical behavior was examined with cooling-rate dependent, concentrated precipitation of Mg 2 Si at the diffusion bonded interface, with due respect for mechanical properties of the AA6061 alloy that inherently vary as a function of cooling rate from 560 °C. Finite element analysis using ABAQUS was employed to augment experimental findings with the appropriate microstructural constituents and alloy properties. Results suggest that the strength is dominated by matrix/bulk properties of AA6061, while ductility is strongly influenced by the cooling method dependent presence of Mg 2 Si precipitates at the interface.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2019

Flux Equations for Osmotically Moderated Sorption–Diffusion Transport in Rigid Microporous Membranes

The development of non-aqueous reverse osmosis separations via the use of rigid microporous membrane materials suggests that flux equations originally developed for swellable polymeric membranes should be revisited. This paper demonstrates that the gradient of fractional occupancy of penetrant molecules within the micropores of the membrane is the driving force for permeation without requiring assumptions about pressure within the membrane. Flux equations are derived using both Fickian and Maxwell-Stefan approaches, and different behavior in the permeate flux versus upstream hydraulic pressure relationship is shown to arise as a result of differences in the loading dependence of the single component Maxwell-Stefan diffusivity. Molecular modeling results available in the literature and experimental data obtained from carbon molecular sieve (CMS) membranes showcase that these loading-dependent changes in the Maxwell-Stefan diffusivity are possible. This loading dependence is separated into three regimes: so-called “weak confinement” diffusion and “strong confinement” diffusion, both of which have been discussed at length in the literature, and a new “hybrid confinement” diffusion, which is introduced here. Furthermore, the separation mechanism of solvent molecules through a rigid bimodally microporous membrane is studied using xylene molecules passing through CMS membranes fabricated under different conditions as examples. Altogether, this study provides fundamental insight and guidance into osmotically-moderated sorption-diffusion transport of solvent molecules through rigid microporous membranes.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Diffusivity and Structure of Room Temperature Ionic Liquid in Various Organic Solvents

Room-temperature ionic liquids (RTILs) hold promise for applications in electric double layer capacitors (EDLCs), owing to a much wider potential window, lower vapor pressure, and better thermal and chemical stabilities compared to conventional aqueous and organic electrolytes. However, because the low diffusivity of ions in neat RTILs negates the EDLCs’ advantage of high power density, the ionic liquids are often used in mixture with organic solvents. In this study, we measured the diffusivity of cations and anions in RTIL, 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl) ([BMIM + ][TFSI – ]), mixed with 10 organic solvents, by using the pulsed-field gradient NMR method. The ion diffusivity was found to follow that of neat solvents and in most studied solvents showed an excellent agreement with the predicted values reported in the recent molecular dynamics (MD) study [Thompson, M. W.; J. Phys. Chem. B 2019, 123, 1340-1347]. In two solvents consisting of long-chain molecules, however, the MD simulations predictions slightly underestimated the ionic diffusivities. The degree of ion dissociation was also estimated for each solvent by comparing the ionic conductivity with the molar conductivity derived from the diffusion measurements. The degree of ion dissociation and the hydrodynamic radius of ions suggest that the ions are coordinated by ~1 solvent molecule. Finally, the scarcity of solvent–ion interactions explains the fact that the diffusivity of ions in the mixture significantly depends on the viscosity of the solvent.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2022

NMR and Theoretical Study of In-Pore Diffusivity of Ionic Liquid–Solvent Mixtures

We report despite having a lower energy density than common batteries, electric double-layer capacitors (EDLCs) offer several advantages for high-power applications, including high power density, quick charge and discharge time, and long cycle life. Room-temperature ionic liquids (RTILs) have been intensely studied as promising electrolytes for applications in ELDCs because of their wide potential window, low volatility, as well as thermal and chemical stability. The main deficiency of neat RTILs in such applications is the sluggish diffusivity, which restricts the EDLCs’ power density. To alleviate the slow diffusivity, RTILs can be used in a mixture with organic solvents. In this study, we applied two-dimensional exchange nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (2D EXSY NMR) and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to investigate the diffusivity of anions of an RTIL, namely, 1-butyl-3-methyl-imidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide (BMIM + –TFSI – ), dissolved in five different organic solvents, in the micropores of activated carbon. We determined that the relative concentrations of ions in solutions in the micropores were higher than those in the bulk solutions and were also solvent-dependent. The ion diffusivities in the pores were found to be almost 2 orders of magnitude slower than in the bulk solutions, with methanol showing the largest relative disparity. These results suggested that the interactions of solvents with the activated carbon are critical not only to the power density of EDLCs but also to the energy density. The comparisons of ion diffusivities between the experiments and the MD simulations suggest the need to consider also the surface functionalities of activated carbon for the simulation of ion diffusion in the micropores of activated carbon.

electric double layer capacitors↗
DOE OSTI2024

Adsorption and Solvation Modulate Rhodamine B Diffusion in Ethanol/Water-Filled Anodic Alumina Nanopores

Confinement of solvents and solutes within nanoporous materials frequently leads to the emergence of unique mass transport behaviors that, once fully understood, may lead to improved chemical separations. Here, the diffusion of Rhodamine B (RhB) dye within 10 and 20 nm diameter anodic aluminum oxide (AAO) nanopores filled with binary ethanol/water mixtures is investigated. Mixture compositions spanning from pure ethanol to pure water are employed. The results of confocal fluorescence correlation spectroscopy studies reveal that RhB diffusion occurs by a two-component mechanism comprising composition-dependent fast and slow motions, characterized by diffusion coefficients D f and D s . The results are consistent with those of previous studies performed under more limited conditions [J. Phys. Chem. C, 2023, 127, 411-420]. The fast component scales with mixture viscosity and is assigned to hindered bulk-like diffusion in central pore regions. Slow diffusion likely involves adsorption of RhB to the pore surface and may be described by a desorption mediated mechanism. The occurrence of RhB adsorption to the AAO surface is verified at the single-molecule level by wide-field fluorescence imaging of membrane cross-sectional surfaces. Unique composition dependent trends in the autocorrelation amplitude and in D s that mimic bulk RhB solubility are revealed. D s is found to be smallest in pure ethanol and pure water and largest in intermediate mixtures. These results suggest that RhB surface adsorption is strongest in the pure liquids and weakest in mixtures of intermediate composition, where the dye is least soluble, and most soluble, respectively. As a result, molecular dynamics simulations reveal that a water layer appears on the pore surface under most conditions, while RhB is solvated primarily by ethanol. The composition dependence of RhB diffusion is concluded to reflect its solvation dependent interactions with the pore walls.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Machine Learning-Based Upscaling of Finite-Size Molecular Dynamics Diffusion Simulations for Binary Fluids

Molecular diffusion coefficients calculated using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations suffer from finite-size (i.e., finite box size and finite particle number) effects. Results from finite-sized MD simulations can be upscaled to infinite simulation size by applying a correction factor. For self-diffusion of single-component fluids, this correction has been well-studied by many researchers including Yeh and Hummer (YH); for binary fluid mixtures, a modified YH correction was recently proposed for correcting MD-predicted Maxwell–Stephan (MS) diffusion rates. In this study we use both empirical and machine learning methods to identify improvements to the finite-size correction factors for both self-diffusion and MS diffusion of binary Lennard-Jones (LJ) fluid mixtures. Using artificial neural networks (ANNs), the error in the corrected LJ fluid diffusion is reduced by an order of magnitude versus existing YH corrections, and the ANN models perform well for mixtures with large dissimilarities in size and interaction energies where the YH correction proves insufficient.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Polymer Conformations and Diffusion Through a Monolayer of Confining Nanoparticles

We present coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations to probe chain-scale polymer conformations and diffusion between confining nanoparticles (NPs). By constructing a monolayer of hexagonally-packed NPs in a polymer melt with athermal interactions, we observe the magnitude and length-scale over which homogeneously confining NPs impact the polymer behavior, which provides fundamental insights into more complex polymer nanocomposites. We show that polymer conformations are more perturbed under strong confinement (i.e. when the interparticle distance, ID, is less than twice the polymer radius of gyration, 2R g ) as compared to around an isolated NP, and the effect depends on the ratio of R NP /R g rather than either independently. In fact, these conformations can be quantitatively replicated by executing a simple random walk in a similarly confining environment. We also show that polymer diffusion is slowed by the presence of NPs and the slowing persists far beyond the length-scale over which polymer conformations are perturbed. Although the slowing is strongest ~R g from the NPs, the diffusion coefficient is slower even beyond ~5R g from the NPs. Furthermore, by analyzing the directional van Hove distributions, we show polymer diffusion away from the NP monolayer is bulk-like while diffusion through the monolayer is slower with increasing NP confinement. Furthermore, these molecular dynamics simulations provide fundamental insights into the temporal and spatial effect of confining, athermal NPs on chain-scale polymer conformations and diffusion.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2019

Increased Polymer Diffusivity in Thin-Film Confinement

In this work, the behavior of polymer melts under planar confinement was investigated using molecular dynamics simulations. Polymers with a range of lengths, from unentangled to highly entangled (N = 25-400), were confined between two discrete-bead parallel walls to create thin films with thicknesses (h = 3.5-40σ, where σ is the unit length) ranging from much larger to much smaller than the polymer size. These simulations were used to measure polymer-chain conformations, entanglement densities, and center-of-mass diffusion, and the results were compared with previous simulations of polymer melts under cylindrical confinement. Changes to the entanglement density and radius of gyration in thin films follow the same behavior as in cylindrical confinement: decreased entanglements per chain, decreased R g perpendicular to the confining wall, and increased R g parallel to the confining wall, though the deviations from bulklike conformations are smaller. Despite similarities in conformation and entanglement behavior between thin-film and cylindrical confinements, the diffusion behavior differs. Under planar confinement, the diffusion coefficient increases monotonically up to 6 times the bulk diffusivity with decreasing film thickness, while it behaves nonmonotonically in cylinders. This is due to the increased degrees of freedom afforded to the polymer chains in a thin film compared to those in a cylinder, allowing chains to diffuse around one another rather than through, as found in cylindrical confinement. Normalized diffusion coefficients, D norm , can be well described by a master curve with an exponential dependence on confinement after scaling D norm by a thickness dependent term.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗