Engineering PapersSearch

Engineering topics

Nelson, Andrew T. [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), Oak Ridge, TN (United States)] (ORCID:0000000240713502)

Publications and source records attributed to Nelson, Andrew T. [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), Oak Ridge, TN (United States)] (ORCID:0000000240713502).

C‐Cracking of Brittle‐Material Spheres From Eccentric Hertzian Contact

Contact of brittle-material spheres can occur while they are manufactured, handled, or used in operation as roller elements or in deformably processed composite material. Statistically, the directional contact between two spheres will nearly always be oblique or eccentric in an unconfined and mobile sphere population. Although analyses of oblique contact exist, the portrayal of its maximum (tensile) first principal stress ( S 1 ) field is lacking. This information is needed for improved judgment of the prospect of crack initiation. Given these, the S 1 due to eccentric contact and subsequent crack initiation was analyzed using finite element analysis (FEA) and corroborative demonstration of c-crack creation. The FEA shows that an asymmetric S 1 field is created about the contact patch and is caused by superimposed shear intrinsic to eccentric contact. A crack will initiate if the maximum S 1 exceeds the material's tensile strength, and its field will cause the crack to propagate and arrest to form a C-shaped crack, or c-crack. C-crack initiation trends with lower applied forces, with greater amount of contact eccentricity, higher coefficient of friction, and smaller spherical radius. Finally, these metrics deserve recognition, especially when c-cracked brittle-material spheres are used in a system whose functionality or reliability is potentially compromised by the c-cracks.

Hertzian contact

Multi-material direct ink writing and co-sintering of gadolinium oxide – zirconium oxide components

Methods for fabrication of multi-material or functionally graded ceramic composite architectures are of interest for numerous applications. However, conventional co-sintering of multi-material ceramic parts is a challenge because differences in the sintering behavior of the two materials leads to interfacial strain and, ultimately, component failure. Direct ink writing (DIW) is an extrusion-based additive manufacturing process that excels at multi-material printing because multiple extrusion nozzles can be installed on the same gantry system. Furthermore, the use of DIW as a method to fabricate multi-material ceramic green bodies offers an additional variable for controlling and potentially matching sintering kinetics in the slurry formulation used for two dissimilar feedstocks. In the work documented in this manuscript, we explored two strategies to successfully co-sinter multi-material ceramic oxides: slurry optimization to match sintering kinetics and material gradients to step from one material to another. This manuscript also quantifies the allowable mismatch that avoids part cracking in solid solution forming multi-material systems and discusses best strategies to reduce mismatch during co-sintering. Inks composed of gadolinium oxide (Gd 2 O 3 ) and zirconium oxide (ZrO 2 ), a surrogate for uranium oxide (UO 2 ), were thermally matched, which resulted in a sintering mismatch reduction of over 10%. It was found that ~1% mismatch is tolerable during debind cycles and that ~5% mismatch is manageable during sintering cycles after slurry formulations are optimized to match the sintering behavior. Use of continuous gradients is shown to reduce sintering mismatch, although geometric resolution may be lost due to solid solution formation.

Snarr, Patrick L. [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (

Ductility evaluation of nitrided Zircaloy-4 cladding by ring compression testing

Here, this study evaluated the embrittlement of Zircaloy-4 cladding by dry air and dry nitrogen environments as a function of process temperature and duration of exposure. A Netzsch thermogravimetric analyzer was used to measure the mass gain of cladding sections over time with specified temperature and gas flow programs. Oxidation of Zircaloy in dry air produced a brittle ZrO 2 layer with ductile unreacted metal. In contrast, nitridation of Zircaloy had a slower reaction rate but produced a brittle cladding that was more easily breached during ring compression tests. The ring compression tests demonstrated that ductility of Zircaloy cladding decreases as nitrogen pickup increases; a ductile-to-brittle transition occurs near a mass gain of 2.1 wt %. Nitridation showed minimal temperature dependency in ductility degradation, whereas oxidation showed significant temperature dependency in ductility degradation, with severe embrittlement occurring at 1200 °C. Optical micrographs confirmed the formation of uniform ZrN layers (approximately 12 µm thick) on the cladding surface, indicating that cladding embrittlement is primarily the result of nitrogen diffusion rather than metal layer thinning.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Design Report on the MiniFuel Instrumented Test Apparatus for Understanding Radiation Effects

Most nuclear fuels irradiations at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) over the past decade have been conducted using MiniFuel—a static capsule design employing subscale fuel specimens to collect separate-effects irradiated fuel performance data. Irradiation conditions for MiniFuel experiments are predicted pre-test using reactor physics, and thermal models are verified post-irradiation via SiC dilatometry and various spectrometry methods. Relevant fuel performance parameters are also observed post-irradiation in a hot cell, thereby providing a single data point for each parameter representing the cumulative effects of the irradiation conditions. Substantially more data can be harvested from a single test and within a shorter duration by instrumenting irradiation vehicles and measuring desired quantities in situ. This report presents the design and analysis of the MiniFuel INstrumented Irradiation Test Apparatus for Understanding Radiation Effects (MINITAURE)—an instrumented test rig based on the separate-effects MiniFuel concept that aims to capture fission gas release (FGR) and thermal conductivity degradation of fuel specimens during irradiation in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). MINITAURE will be integrated with the Materials Irradiation Facility (MIF) located in the HFIR building outside the reactor containment. The MIF will act as the instrumentation and control center for the experiment, enabling real-time feedback from in situ sensors and control of irradiation temperatures via a gas delivery system. Two unique capsule designs were developed to capture each phenomenon: the thermal conductivity capsule, which uses a thermopile method to estimate fuel specimen thermal conductivity, and the fission gas release capsule, which will have continuous flowing gas communication to high-purity germanium detectors that are housed in the MIF for monitoring FGR. This report details the reactor physics and heat transfer modeling activities that were used to inform the experiment design and predict capsule performance. It also describes out-of-pile activities conducted to stand up this new capability and verify the measurement techniques. Modeling efforts to date have demonstrated the feasibility of the in situ measurement techniques and supported the development of the MINITAURE assembly configuration. Out-of-pile testing of the thermal conductivity measurement shows promise in capturing relative changes in thermal conductivity. However, significant errors exist in the measured absolute value, posing a need for further refinement.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS

Oxygen Defect Configurations in Single-Phase UO 2.15

Hyperstoichiometric UO 2.15 was characterized by neutron total scattering at high temperature in the single-phase UO 2+x region of the U/O phase diagram. The diffraction data confirmed a single-phase fluorite structure at high temperature. Analysis of the short-range data showed that the same structural model does not fit the pair distribution functions well. Instead, structural models containing specific configurations of oxygen defect clusters best represent the local atomic arrangement. In conclusion, prevalent defect clusters previously proposed were fit to the experimental data, and moderately distorted oxygen cuboctahedra hypothesized by recent molecular dynamics simulations fit the data most accurately.

neutron pair-distribution function analysis

A machine learning approach to quantify degradation of nuclear fuels and the effects of fission products

Nuclear fuel performance is critically dependent on understanding the evolution of fuel properties under operational conditions, a complex challenge driven by chemical changes and substantial radiation damage during fission. Traditionally, property evolution has been determined via empirical data collected following irradiation. However, these empirical correlations are limited in their applicability beyond the specific conditions in which they were obtained. This study explores a novel approach to address this challenge by applying materials informatics to develop a machine learning random forest (ML-RF) model that captures the effects of fission products on fuel compounds. The model predicts formation enthalpy (ΔH f ) by leveraging extensive quantum materials property data and correlating it with material descriptors such as composition, atomic and site features, and crystal lattice properties. This ML-RF model enables rapid interpolation across the compositional and structural spaces covered by the training data, thus supporting high-throughput screening and energetic ranking of candidate phases. The model demonstrates the ability to predict ΔH f with a mean absolute error (MAE) of approximately 0.1 to 0.2 eV/atom across a wide range of compounds, including key nuclear fuel systems (U-O, U-N, U-C, U-Si, and U-Mo). For example, it was used to assess shifts in stoichiometry for UO 2 (O/M) and UN (N/M) fuels, revealing their distinct tendencies in chemical potential variation and enabling preliminary convex hull analyses. Furthermore, the model provides insights into how individual fission products affect fuel properties. Results indicate that larger fission products (e.g., Nd, Pu, Ce) have a more pronounced impact on UO 2 , while lighter ones (e.g., Zr) strongly influence UN. Here, the model developed in this work can be used to support the Accelerated Fuel Qualification approach by facilitating preliminary evaluations prior to extensive materials modeling and experimentation. To this end, the trained model has been made available to the fuel community to support ongoing fuel development efforts.

Accelerated fuel qualification

Role of Accelerated Burnup Irradiation Testing in Support of Accelerated Fuel Qualification

Accelerated fuel qualification has gained attention as a means to reduce the time needed to realize new nuclear fuel concepts and expand the operating windows of existing fuel forms. A key component of this approach is accelerated burnup irradiation testing. Although the concept of accelerated burnup has been familiar to the community for many decades, the specifics about how the increasing fission rate may be used as a qualification tool have not yet been elucidated. The present work provides a vision of how accelerated fission rate testing can enable accelerated fuel qualification. Technology readiness levels (TRLs) are reintroduced to demarcate the stages of traditional fuel qualification, and accelerated fuel qualification is presented in this context. The critical steps needed to achieve each TRL are reframed within the context of modern nuclear materials research and development, as revolutionary fuel concepts are more common than previous eras. The practical impacts of accelerated fuel qualification approaches as applied to contemporary fuel qualification efforts are illustrated. Examples are given to illustrate how accelerated burnup irradiations are being used currently and could be applied in the future to support qualification and licensure. Finally, outstanding challenges in the application of accelerated burnup methods to nuclear fuel qualification are summarized, with priority placed on understanding how fission rate impacts diffusion, microstructure evolution, and other critical mechanisms that dictate fuel performance.

Accelerated fuel qualification

Fracture toughness measurement of ceramics with fuel pellet geometry

The crack initiation of nuclear fuel pellets, driven by extreme temperature gradients, is a critical factor impacting reactor performance. Although this fact is widely acknowledged, there is limited fracture toughness data for specimens with representative geometry and fabricated using relevant processing methods. Here, to address this, a new chevron-notched short-rod specimen configuration with diameter and length both equal to 10 mm, representative of a conventional fuel pellet and tested in tension, was developed in an attempt to validly measure Mode I fracture toughness, K Ic . Test calibration was carried out by testing polycrystalline ZrO 2 , SiC, and Si 3 N 4 ceramics fabricated with conventional fuel pellet geometry and known fracture toughnesses. The results suggest that the method described in this paper produces valid K Ic measurements using conventional ceramic fuel pellets.

Ceramics

Direct ink writing of aqueous-based Gadolinium (III) oxide slurries

Gadolinium (III) oxide (gadolinia, Gd 2 O 3 ) has recently been identified as an intriguing material for applications in the medical, solid oxide fuel cell, and nuclear industries. This interest drives the need for developing and understanding manufacturing techniques that can produce dense Gd 2 O 3 structures. Direct ink writing (DIW), an extrusion-based additive manufacturing method, has also garnered interest because of its capability to produce dense ceramic parts with increased complexity in an economical manner. In this study, DIW was explored as a manufacturing technique for Gd 2 O 3 . Experiments were performed to develop Gd 2 O 3 bearing inks capable of being processed via DIW. Ink solids loading and sintering temperatures were varied to assess their impact on the final density and microstructure. Optimum sintering conditions are proposed and were experimentally verified at a dwell temperature of 1500°C. Gd 2 O 3 samples were successfully manufactured using DIW, achieving densities greater than 96 % of the theoretical density.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Statistical fracture behavior of doped UO 2 using a ball-on-ring equibiaxial flexure test method

Metal oxide dopants, such as titanium and chromium oxides, have garnered considerable attention for their potential to increase grain size (≥ 30 µm) in UO 2 fuel, purportedly enhancing fission gas retention during reactor operation. Fuel performance is significantly impacted by fuel fracture behavior, so it is important to understand the effects of enhanced grain size and dopant content on UO 2 fuel fracture. UO 2 pellets were doped with 0.1 wt% TiO 2 and 0.3 wt% Cr 2 O 3 to alter density and grain size. Inductively coupled plasma mass spectroscopy measured dopant levels pre- and post-sintering. X-ray diffraction revealed lattice changes and microstrain via Rietveld refinement. Field emission scanning electron microscopy determined grain sizes of approximately 30 µm for TiO 2 doping and 7 µm for Cr 2 O 3 doping. Transverse rupture strength tests were performed on over 30 samples per dataset to obtain characteristic strength and Weibull modulus. Results indicate no statistical difference in fracture strength between 0.1 wt% TiO 2 doped UO 2 and undoped UO 2 , while 0.3 wt% Cr 2 O 3 doped UO 2 exhibited a 20% decrease in fracture strength. Doped UO 2 samples also showed reduced Weibull modulus compared to undoped UO 2 , suggesting increased scatter in fracture strength. This study's findings suggest that titanium and chromium oxide doping in UO 2 , regardless of grain size, induce residual stresses, decreasing fracture strength and increasing variability in fracture behavior.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS

Investigation of UO 2 doped with Fe 2 O 3 sintered under a reducing atmosphere

Nuclear fuel produced with trace amounts of transition metal additives is of potential interest for introducing intentional signatures for accelerating nuclear forensics. In this work, we investigate the effects on microstructure, grain size, crystal structure, and stoichiometry when trace amounts of Fe in the form of Fe 2 O 3 are added to UO 2 . Sintering of compacts with different concentrations, from 250 to 3000 ppmw, was performed under a reducing atmosphere at 1773 K. The persistence of the taggant during the fuel fabrication process as well as its impact on grain size, crystal lattice, and first-neighbor chemistry was evaluated using inductively coupled plasma–optical emission spectroscopy, powder X-ray diffraction (pXRD), Raman spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy–backscatter electron spectroscopy, energy dispersive spectroscopy, and thermogravimetric analysis. We observed that a negligible amount of Fe was lost during sintering. Our results indicate that the feedstock, Fe 2 O 3 transforms into Fe and FeO under the test sintering conditions. For all compositions, metallic Fe precipitate was found in grain boundaries as a secondary phase. In conclusion, the potential incorporation of ionic Fe into the UO 2 unit cell was determined by pXRD and Raman spectra.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS

Micromechanical response of SiC-OPyC layers in TRISO fuel particles

Tristructural isotropic (TRISO)–coated particle fuel is a proposed fuel for multiple advanced reactor concepts. The performance of the particle depends on whether the silicon carbide (SiC) layer remains intact to prevent the release of metallic and gaseous fission products. Mechanical fracture of the SiC layer is a potential failure mode under various fuel configurations and operating environments, including the potential transmission of matrix-originating cracks through TRISO particles. Furthermore, this study uses instrumented indentation techniques on cross-sectioned surrogate particles to examine the mechanical stability of the critical interface between SiC and the outer pyrolytic carbon (OPyC) layer. The observed behavior at the interface is rationalized by examining the radially dependent fracture behavior of the SiC layer and performing a numerical analysis to quantify the residual stresses that develop during the processing and cross-sectioning of the as-fabricated particle. Characterizing the SiC-OPyC interface of surrogate TRISO particles using nanoindentation provides unique insight into the interface's room-temperature residual stress and mechanical stability. The modeling efforts were used to investigate the experimental procedure further, and the results are presented herein to validate this fuel form's potential mechanical failure modes.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS