Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Messner, M. C.

Publications and source records attributed to Messner, M. C..

46 records · Page 3

Evaluation of methods to determine strain ranges for use in SMT design curves

This report describes progress on developing a new method for creep-fatigue design that reduces over conservatism, improves the treatment of elastic follow up effects, and simplifies the design procedure, when compared to the existing ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessels Code, Section III, Division 5 method for creep-fatigue design. Specifically, this report describes the development of one of the three components of the new creep-fatigue design method: a design analysis method to represent the steady cyclic strain range in a component in elevated temperature service. The method developed here uses an elastic perfectly plastic (EPP) analysis with a pseudoyield stress selected to bound the width of the steady state stress-strain hysteresis loop. The report also provides a description of the in-development creep-fatigue design method, including a plan to complete the method by developing design curves and a method to account for stress multiaxiality.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Initial development and extension of EPP methods to Grade 91

This report describes modifications to the existing elastic perfectly plastic (EPP) analysis ASME Nuclear Code Cases N-861 and N-862 required to apply the Code Case design methods to Grade 91 steel. The critical difference between the existing Code Cases, applicable only to 304H and 316H stainless steel, is that they do not account for material cyclic softening. Grade 91 is a softening material at elevated temperature. As such, modifications to the existing Code Case rules are required before they can be conservatively applied to Grade 91.This report describes modified EPP methods applicable to softening materials like Grade 91. Additionally, the report describes the specific technical and administrative changes to the existing EPP Code Cases that will be required to support Grade 91.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Finite element analysis of compliant cladding and base metal systems

This report describes a roadmap towards a design method for high temperature nuclear cladded components that does not require long term testing of clad materials. Molten Salt Reactors (MSRs) will operate using corrosive fuel or coolant salts. The existing Class A metallic materials qualified for ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section III, Division 5 design are not optimal for corrosion resistance when exposed to MSR salts. Corrosion could then severely limit the service life of MSRs. One option to alleviate this could be to Code qualify new corrosion resistant materials. However, this is a lengthy and expensive process and MSR developers have a near term need for a design solution that enables reactor designs with long service lives. An alternative would be to use cladded components – overlay some existing Class A material with a thin layer of some corrosion resistant material. This report describes the outlines of a design strategy that would enable this approach. The strategy relies on approximate design analysis methods for certain types of clad/base systems that avoids requiring long-term mechanical properties for the clad materials. This would allow the use of cladded components in the near term, without requiring long testing programs. However, it will limit the types of clad materials that can be used. This report describes the design framework, demonstrates the effectiveness of the approximate analysis methods, and confirms the approach using full scale finite element analysis of prototypical cladded high temperature components. It also describes a roadmap towards a complete design method and surveys available clad materials and bonding methods for suitably, considering only mechanical and not environmental effects.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Development of ASME Division 5 Code proposal on temperature limits for simplified design methods

This report establishes proposed upper temperature limits for the ASME BP&V Code Section III, Division 5, Nonmandatory Appendix HBB-T design by elastic analysis provisions for bounding ratcheting strain and creep-fatigue damage in Class A high temperature nuclear reactor components. Limitations on the use of these design options are required because the design by elastic analysis methods rely on bounding theories that assume a non-unified, decoupled model of creep-plasticity. However, at high temperatures creep and plastic deformation become coupled and bounding theorems relying a decoupled material response may fail. The report describes a method for selecting appropriate upper temperature limits, demonstrates directly through a comparison to full inelastic simulations that the existing Code provisions can be nonconservative at high temperatures, and develops the requisite Code language required to implement the temperature limits in Section III, Division 5.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

FY17 Status Report on the Micromechanical Finite Element Modeling of Creep Fracture of Grade 91 Steel

Advanced reactors designed to operate at higher temperatures than current light water reactors require structural materials with high creep strength and creep-fatigue resistance to achieve long design lives. Grade 91 is a ferritic/martensitic steel designed for long creep life at elevated temperatures. It has been selected as a candidate material for sodium fast reactor intermediate heat exchangers and other advanced reactor structural components. This report focuses on the creep deformation and rupture life of Grade 91 steel. The time required to complete an experiment limits the availability of long-life creep data for Grade 91 and other structural materials. Design methods often extrapolate the available shorter-term experimental data to longer design lives. However, extrapolation methods tacitly assume the underlying material mechanisms causing creep for long-life/low-stress conditions are the same as the mechanisms controlling creep in the short-life/high-stress experiments. A change in mechanism for long-term creep could cause design methods based on extrapolation to be non-conservative. The goal for physically-based microstructural models is to accurately predict material response in experimentally-inaccessible regions of design space. An accurate physically-based model for creep represents all the material mechanisms that contribute to creep deformation and damage and predicts the relative influence of each mechanism, which changes with loading conditions. Ideally, the individual mechanism models adhere to the material physics and not an empirical calibration to experimental data and so the model remains predictive for a wider range of loading conditions. This report describes such a physically-based microstructural model for Grade 91 at 600° C. The model explicitly represents competing dislocation and diffusional mechanisms in both the grain bulk and grain boundaries. The model accurately recovers the available experimental creep curves at higher stresses and the limited experimental data at lower stresses, predominately primary creep rates. The current model considers only one temperature. However, because the model parameters are, for the most part, directly related to the physics of fundamental material processes, the temperature dependence of the properties are known. Therefore, temperature dependence can be included in the model with limited additional effort. The model predicts a mechanism shift for 600° C at approximately 100 MPa from a dislocation- dominated regime at higher stress to a diffusion-dominated regime at lower stress. This mechanism shift impacts the creep life, notch-sensitivity, and, likely, creep ductility of Grade 91. In particular, the model predicts existing extrapolation methods for creep life may be non-conservative when attempting to extrapolate data for higher stress creep tests to low stress, long-life conditions. Furthermore, the model predicts a transition from notchstrengthening behavior at high stress to notch-weakening behavior at lower stresses. Both behaviors may affect the conservatism of existing design methods.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Report on an Assessment of the Application of EPP Results from the Strain Limit Evaluation Procedure to the Prediction of Cyclic Life Based on the SMT Methodology

The goal of the proposed integrated Elastic Perfectly-Plastic (EPP) and Simplified Model Test (SMT) methodology is to incorporate an SMT data based approach for creep-fatigue damage evaluation into the EPP methodology to avoid the separate evaluation of creep and fatigue damage and eliminate the requirement for stress classification in current methods; thus greatly simplifying evaluation of elevated temperature cyclic service. This methodology should minimize over-conservatism while properly accounting for localized defects and stress risers. To support the implementation of the proposed methodology and to verify the applicability of the code rules, analytical studies and evaluation of thermomechanical test results continued in FY17. This report presents the results of those studies. An EPP strain limits methodology assessment was based on recent two-bar thermal ratcheting test results on 316H stainless steel in the temperature range of 405 to 7050C. Strain range predictions from the EPP evaluation of the two-bar tests were also evaluated and compared with the experimental results. The role of sustained primary loading on cyclic life was assessed using the results of pressurized SMT data from tests on Alloy 617 at 9500C. A viscoplastic material model was used in an analytic simulation of two-bar tests to compare with EPP strain limits assessments using isochronous stress strain curves that are consistent with the viscoplastic material model. A finite element model of a prior 304H stainless steel Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) nozzle-to-sphere test was developed and used for an EPP strain limits and creep-fatigue code case damage evaluations. A theoretical treatment of a recurring issue with convergence criteria for plastic shakedown illustrated the role of computer machine precision in EPP calculations.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

FY17 Status Report on the Initial Development of a Constitutive Model for Grade 91 Steel

Grade 91 is a candidate structural material for high temperature advanced reactor applications. Existing ASME Section III, Subsection HB, Subpart B simplified design rules based on elastic analysis are setup as conservative screening tools with the intent to supplement these screening rules with full inelastic analysis when required. The Code provides general guidelines for suitable inelastic models but does not provide constitutive model implementations. This report describes the development of an inelastic constitutive model for Gr. 91 steel aimed at fulfilling the ASME Code requirements and being included into a new Section III Code appendix, HBB-Z. A large database of over 300 experiments on Gr. 91 was collected and converted to a standard XML form. Five families of Gr. 91 material models were identified in the literature. Of these five, two are potentially suitable for use in the ASME code. These two models were implemented and evaluated against the experimental database. Both models have deficiencies so the report develops a framework for developing and calibrating an improved model. This required creating a new modeling method for representing changes in material rate sensitivity across the full ASME allowable temperature range for Gr. 91 structural components: room temperature to 650° C. On top of this framework for rate sensitivity the report describes calibrating a model for work hardening and softening in the material using genetic algorithm optimization. Future work will focus on improving this trial model by including tension/compression asymmetry observed in experiments and necessary to capture material ratcheting under zero mean stress and by improving the optimization and analysis framework.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

FY17 Status Report on the Initial EPP Finite Element Analysis of Grade 91 Steel

This report describes a modification to the elastic-perfectly plastic (EPP) strain limits design method to account for cyclic softening in Gr. 91 steel. The report demonstrates that the unmodified EPP strain limits method described in current ASME code case is not conservative for materials with substantial cyclic softening behavior like Gr. 91 steel. However, the EPP strain limits method can be modified to be conservative for softening materials by using softened isochronous stress-strain curves in place of the standard curves developed from unsoftened creep experiments. The report provides softened curves derived from inelastic material simulations and factors describing the transformation of unsoftened curves to a softened state. Furthermore, the report outlines a method for deriving these factors directly from creep/fatigue tests. If the material softening saturates the proposed EPP strain limits method can be further simplified, providing a methodology based on temperature-dependent softening factors that could be implemented in an ASME code case allowing the use of the EPP strain limits method with Gr. 91. Finally, the report demonstrates the conservatism of the modified method when applied to inelastic simulation results and two bar experiments.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗