Engineering Papers⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Messner, M. C.

Publications and source records attributed to Messner, M. C..

At least 37 records · Page 2

Combined crystal plasticity and grain boundary modeling of creep in ferritic-martensitic steels: I. Theory and implementation

This paper presents a physically-based microstructural model for creep rupture at 600 degrees °C for Grade 91 steel. The model includes constitutive equations that reflect various observed phenomena in Grade 91, and it is incorporated into a mesoscale finite element model with explicit geometry for the prior austenite grains and grain boundaries. Creep within the grains is represented using crystal plasticity for dislocation motion and recovery along with linear viscous diffusional creep for point defect diffusion. The grain boundary models include physics-based models for cavity growth and nucleation that accurately capture tertiary creep and creep rupture. Simulations of creep at 100 MPa are performed, and the contribution of each mechanism is analyzed. The overarching goal is to gain a mechanistic understanding of the material to improve the prediction of creep rupture for long service lives in elevated temperature operating conditions. The creep response of the material at different stress levels, stress states, and temperatures is studied in Part 2 of this paper in order to determine the implications of the simulations on high temperature design practice. Furthermore, the second part explores the effect of triaxial stress states on the creep response and finds a transition from notch-strengthening behavior at high stress to notch-weakening behavior at lower stresses.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Combined crystal plasticity and grain boundary modeling of creep in ferritic-martensitic steels: II. The effect of stress and temperature on engineering and microstructural properties

This paper describes a series of physically-based crystal plasticity finite element method (CPFEM) simulations of long-term creep and creep rupture of Grade 91 steel. It is Part 2 of a two part series of papers. Part 1 describes the simulation framework; this part focuses on specific simulations and on how the predicted long-term creep properties of Grade 91 compare to the assumptions used in current high temperature design practices. This work extends the model developed in Part 1 to look at creep properties at different temperatures, principal stresses, and multiaxial stress states. The simulations show that empirically extrapolating creep rupture stresses from short-term experimental data may substantially over predict the actual long-term creep properties of Grade 91. Additionally, the CPFEM calculations predict a transition from notch strengthening creep behavior for high values of maximum principal stress and moderate notch severity to notch weakening behavior for low principal stresses and more severe notches. The latter regime better categorizes conditions in engineering components designed for long term elevated temperature use, which implies Grade 91 may be a notch weakening material in actual service. This would have a significant impact on high temperature design practices, though confirmatory test data on long-life, low stress notched specimens is difficult to obtain. Finally, one advantage of the physically-based modeling approach adopted here is that the simulation results also elucidate the microstructural mechanisms causing the macroscopic trends in engineering properties predicted by the simulations. This paper shows that the detailed micromechanical mechanisms predicted by the CPFEM simulations can be abstracted with a simple micromechanical model that can be used to both explain the detailed results and make improved predictions of engineering properties from experimental data.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Inelastic analysis procedure based on the Grade 91 unified viscoplastic constitutive model for ASME implementation

This report describes a design by inelastic analysis procedure for Grade 91 to be proposed for incorporation in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code. The package of proposed additions includes guidance on inelastic modeling and a reference constitutive model for Grade 91 to be used with the existing Section III, Division 5, Subsection HB, Subpart B rules for design by inelastic analysis. The current Code specifies acceptance criteria for design by inelastic analysis but does not provide an acceptable constitutive model for Grade 91 or any of the other Class A materials. The proposed Nonmandatory Appendix would provide such a reference model, greatly easing the use of design by inelastic analysis. As the inelastic methods produce significantly less overconservative designs than the design by elastic analysis rules this proposed Code change could reduce the design and fabrication cost of future high temperature reactors.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Initial Development of an Improved Creep-Fatigue Design Method that Avoids the Separate Evaluation of Creep and Fatigue Damage and Eliminates the Requirement for Stress Classification

This report describes a method for capturing the effect of strain range, temperature, hold time, and elastic follow up on the cyclic life of a material undergoing uniaxial load. Developing design correlations of this type requires methods for extrapolating experimental data as a function of hold time and follow up factor. Various extrapolation methods are developed and discussed here and recommendations are developed for the final approaches to be adopted for design use. The report also describes comparisons between the new creep-fatigue design method, described here, and current creep-fatigue design methods in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code and associated nuclear Code Cases. These comparisons demonstrate several advantages of the new method: it is easier to execute and is less over conservative than many current approaches. This report, along with a companion on extending these results to multiaxial load and on combining load cycles, represents the accumulation of several years of work on the development of this new approach to creep-fatigue design, combining an elastic perfectly plastic analysis method with simplified model tests measuring the effect of elastic follow up on creep-fatigue cyclic life. The conclusions to this report describe a path forward to developing the required design data for high temperature advanced reactor structural materials and guiding the adoption of the new method in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code and related standards.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Draft ASME Section III Division 5 Code Cases to extend EPP strain limits and creep-fatigue design methods to Grade 91

This report describes the drafting of Code Cases extending the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section III, Division 5, Subsection HB, Subpart B design by elastic perfect-plastic (EPP) analysis methods to Grade 91 steel. The primary technical challenge is that Grade 91 steel is a cyclic softening material and so modifications to the current ASME design approach for austenitic stainless steel were required to produce conservative designs. Previous work established the technical basis required to support these modifications. This report provides the full package for balloting by ASME – both revised Code Case language and associated background documentation for two nuclear code cases: N-861 covering ratcheting strain limits and N-862 covering creep-fatigue damage. The completion of this work and successful balloting at ASME, currently underway, allows designers to apply the efficient EPP methods to Grade 91 high temperature structural components.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Development of the Technical Basis of a Unified Viscoplastic Model of 316H Stainless Steel for Incorporation into ASME Division 5

This report describes the development of a unified viscoplastic model describing the deformation of 316 stainless steel. The model was developed for incorporation into Section III, Division 5 of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code covering the design and fabrication of Class A high temperature nuclear reactor components. The current version of the Code does not provide reference inelastic models, leaving the responsibility of defining an adequate model up to either the plant owner or designer. This approach represents a substantial barrier to using the ASME design by inelastic analysis methods. As historical practice demonstrates these methods produce much more efficient designs, compared to the design by elastic analysis methods, eliminating this barrier could result in safer, more effective, and more efficient structural designs thereby lowering the cost of future advanced reactors. This report summarizes the process of gathering experimental data, calibrating the candidate inelastic model against that data, and validating the model. The report also summarizes work on a new method of calculating the sensitivities of history dependent nonlinear constitutive models that was used to calibrate the 316H model using gradient-based optimization.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Development of a multiaxial deformation measure and creep-fatigue damage summation for multiple load cycle types in support of an improved creep-fatigue design method

This report describes methods for extending the elastic perfectly plastic (EPP) simplified model test (SMT) approach to cover multiaxial load conditions and methods to combine EPP+SMT use fractions for multiple loading cycles. The completion of this work, in conjunction with companion reports on constructing and validating SMT design curves, marks the development of a complete methodology for assessing creep-fatigue damage in high temperature nuclear reactor structural components. This EPP+SMT method aims to better account for elastic follow up effects, simplify the design process, and reduce overconservatism when compared to current simplified bounding approaches in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section III, Division 5, Subsection HB, Subpart B covering high temperature nuclear reactors.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

The role of material modeling on strain range estimation for elevated temperature cyclic life evaluation

High temperature nuclear reactors operating in the creep regime are designed to withstand numerous cyclic events. Current ASME code rules provide two basic paths for evaluating creep fatigue and ratcheting under these conditions; one based on full inelastic analysis intended to provide a representative stress and strain history and the other based on elastic material models with adjustments of varying complexity to account for inelastic stress and strain redistribution. More recent developments have used elastic-perfectly plastic analysis to bound the effects of cyclic service. However, these methods still rely on the separate evaluation of fatigue and creep damage utilizing a damage interaction diagram. There is a procedure under current development that uses creep-fatigue data from key feature test articles directly without the use of the damage interaction diagram. However, it requires a reasonable representation of the strain range in a structure as an input. This work develops a simplified procedure based on elastic perfectly-plasticity analysis that can be used to represent the strain range in a structure in the steady state under cyclic loading conditions.

Messner, M. C.↗

The mechanical interaction of clad and base metal for molten salt reactor structural components

Cladding structural components with a corrosion resistant material may greatly extend the design life of molten salt reactor concepts. A complete design methodology for such cladded, high temperature nuclear components will require addressing many issues: fabrication, corrosion resistance, metallurgical interaction, and the mechanical interaction of the clad and base materials under load. This work focuses on the final issue: the mechanical interaction of the base and clad under creep-fatigue conditions. Depending on the relative mechanical properties of the two materials the clad may substantially influence the longterm cyclic response of the structural system or its effect might be negligible. To quantify the effect of different clad material properties we develop an efficient method for simulating pressurized cladded components in the limiting case where the section of interest is far from structural discontinuities. Using this method we evaluate the mechanics of the clad/base system and identify different regimes of mechanical response. The focus is on situations relevant to high temperature nuclear components: thermal-cyclic Bree-type problems and similar axisymmetric structures. The insights gained from these structural studies will form the basis for developing design rules for high-temperature, nuclear, cladded components.

Messner, M. C.↗

Detection of ratcheting in finite element calculations

The distinction between a ratcheting and non-ratcheting response is critical for many high temperature design methods. Non-ratcheting is generally considered safe deformation remain bounded over the lifetime of the component while ratcheting is undesirable. As a particular example, the elastic perfectly plastic (EPP) design methods described in recent ASME Section III, Division 5 code cases require a designer to distinguish ratcheting from non-ratcheting for finite element analyses using a relatively simple, elastic perfectly-plastic constitutive response. However, it can be quite difficult to distinguish these two deformation regimes using finite element (FE) analysis particularly in the case where the actual ratcheting strain is small. In practice FE analysis of structures that are analytically in either the plastic shakedown or ratcheting regimes will result in small, cycle to -cycle accumulated strains characteristic of ratcheting. Distinguishing false ratcheting the structure is actually in the plastic shakedown regime from true ratcheting can be challenging. We describe the characteristics of nonlinear FE analysis that cause these false ratcheting strains and describe practical methods for distinguishing a ratcheting from a non-ratcheting response.

Messner, M. C.↗

A basis for applying elastic perfectly-plastic design methods to cyclic softening materials

Design approaches using elastic perfectly-plastic (EPP) analysis have recently been approved as Code Cases for the Section III, Division 5 design of high-temperature nuclear reactor components made from austenitic stainless steel. These methods bound the ratcheting strain and creep-fatigue damage accumulated over the life of a component with a simplified, elastic perfectly plastic analysis using a special pseudo-yield stress often not equal to the true material yield stress. The austenitic materials specified in the existing Code cases are cyclic-hardening for all allowable operating temperatures. However, other Section III, Division 5 materials, such as Grade 91 steel, are cyclic softening at expected advanced reactor operating temperatures. This work describes the extension of EPP methods to cyclic softening materials through the use of a postulated saturated material state and softening factors to be applied to the pseudo yield stress. We demonstrate the conservatism of the modified EPP method against a series of inelastic simulations of two bar tests, using a constitutive model that captures work and cyclic softening.

Messner, M. C.↗

A unified inelastic constitutive model for the average engineering response of Grade 91 steel

Grade 91 steel has been called out for use in advanced reactor intermediate heat exchangers and other components. The material has good high temperature creep resistance and thermal properties but has a complex microstructure that manifests as cyclic softening, work softening, and tension/compression asymmetry in its engineering mechanical response. We describe a unified viscoplastic model for the deformation of Grade 91 for an expected operating temperature range spanning from room temperature to approximately 650 C. The model transitions from a rate independent response at low temperatures and high strain rates to a rate dependent, unified viscoplastic response at high temperatures and low creep strain rates. The model captures work and cyclic softening in the material through combined isotropic kinematic hardening and captures observed tension/compression asymmetry and related anomalous ratcheting effects through a non-j2 flow term. A particular focus of the model is on capturing the average response of Grade 91 as determined from a wide collection of experimental data at many different temperatures, rather than the response of a single set of experiments at a particular temperature. The final model is suitable for the engineering design of nuclear components via inelastic analysis using the ASME Section III, Division 5 procedures.

Messner, M. C.↗

Establishing temperature upper limits for the ASME Section III, Division 5 design by elastic analysis methods

ection III, Division 5 of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code provides two broad paths for the design of high temperature, safety-critical nuclear components: design by elastic analysis and design by inelastic analysis. The design by elastic analysis approach, as the name suggests, uses a linear elastic stress analysis of the component and applies design rules designed to bound response of the actual structure, which will undergo both creep and plasticity. Currently, the Code allows the use of the elastic approach for all operating temperatures up to the maximum use temperatures in the Code. The bounds used in the elastic approach assume an uncoupled material response combining rate dependent creep with rate independent plasticity. However, at elevated temperatures creep and plasticity are coupled, rate dependent mechanisms and so the elastic analysis rules may become non-conservative. We present several examples of potential non-conservatism in the elastic analysis rules at high operating temperatures. Then we describe a systematic method for determining a temperature cutoff describing the transition from non-unified, rate independent plasticity material response to a rate dependent, unified plastic response. Logically, this transition temperature sets the upper bound for the allowable, conservative use of the design by elastic analysis approach and so we propose these temperatures, determined for all the Section III, Division 5 Class A materials, as Code limits for the applicability of the elastic approach.

Messner, M. C.↗

Assessment of passively actuated in-situ cyclic surveillance test specimens for advanced non-light water reactors

The use of surveillance specimens was identified in a roadmap (Sims, 2010, ASME HTGR Code Development Roadmap, STP-NU-045, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York, NY) developed for the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission for non-light water reactors that are intended to have very long design lives on the order of 500,000 hours. Creep rupture, long term strain accumulation, creep-fatigue damage, and their interaction with environmental effects require significant extrapolation from shorter term tests. Surveillance specimens provide a means for confirmation of these extrapolations in-situ. The effects of cyclic service on creep-fatigue damage would be particularly challenging based on conventional mechanical testing. Proposed herein is a passive cyclic testing methodology that lends itself well to in-situ surveillance applications. The concept is based on utilizing the difference in the thermal expansion coefficient of candidate materials to generate cyclic loading based on operational thermal transients. Prototypical specimen designs are proposed and their in-situ response to representative plant operation are evaluated.

Messner, M. C.↗

{ital n}-bar problems as approximations to the Bree problem

The Bree solution to the problem of a ratcheting cylinder under constant pressure and cyclic thermal load is a fundamental result in nuclear engineering and widely used as the technical basis for the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code and other design methods. However, because the loading conditions in the Bree problem are difficult to achieve experimentally there have been relatively few works experimentally examining the problem and extending it to other relevant design situations, for example cladded components. In contrast, 2-bar problems are widely studied experimentally and are relatively easy to setup. These 2-bar problems are thought to be representative of Bree-type geometries, but a formal connection has not been demonstrated. This work formally establishes the connection between the Bree cylinder and an n-bar problem a coupled bar experiment with, in general, more than two bars linked in parallel. The connection suggests that n-bar experiments using a fairly limited number of bars might be an experimentally-accessible setup that better represents ratcheting phenomenon in actual nuclear pressurized components. Such experiments could test surrogate cladded or multi-material components by using bars of different materials. Finally, this work suggests control schemes that yield optimally efficient n-bar experiments experiments that best replicates a Bree cylinder with a limited number of bars.

Messner, M. C.↗

Evaluation of statistical variation of microstructural properties and temperature effects on creep fracture of Grade 91

This report describes three improvements made to a physically-based model for creep and creep rupture in Grade 91 steel developed as part of the Advanced Reactor Technologies program: 1. Progress on transitioning the model framework to the MOOSE finite element package to improve parallel scalability, increase the physical size of the simulations, and incorporate multiphysics effects into the model. 2. The development of a physically-based method of scaling the model parameters to accurately capture creep in Grade 91 for temperatures in the range of 450° to 500° C. 3. Extending the model to account for microstructural statistical variations, specifically capturing the effect of grain boundary energy on the physical parameters underling the model for grain boundary void nucleation and cavitation. Put together, these improvements result in an accurate, predictive model for the physical response of Grade 91 steel over the expected use temperature range for the material in future liquid metal cooled fast reactors. The model can be used to more accurately predict engineering properties of the material for very long service lives, which could lead to safer, more economical future advanced reactors.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Report on the completion of the development of processing map from as-cast Alloy 709 materials

This report provides details on the completion of the development of the processing map from the as-cast Alloy 709 materials. The report is a Level 4 deliverable in FY18 (M4NT18AN050502012), under the Work Package NT-18AN05050201, “A709 Development” performed by Argonne National Laboratory, as part of Advanced Structural Materials Program for the Advanced Reactor Technologies (ART). The report describes the development of a processing map to guide the development of hot work regimens for A709. The maps combine high-temperature flow stress measurements, described in a companion report by Oak Ridge National Laboratory, and metallographic observations, described here, into a single diagram that can be used to select hot working parameters to avoid regions of plastic instability and to avoid the development of unfavorable microstructures. This report describes the process of creating the map, provides the final map for A709, and uses the processing map to describe two potential hot work regimens that could be used in processing a DOE round ingot into bar stock.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Development of Grade 91 inelastic model for incorporation in ASME Division 5

This report describes a unified viscoplastic model for Grade 91 suitable for use with the Section III, Division 5 design by inelastic analysis procedures in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code. The report identifies several key features a successful design inelastic model must capture along with critical aspects of the response of Grade 91 for elevated temperature loading conditions typical of expected reactor operating conditions. An inelastic model for Code design must capture the average response of a material including heat-to-heat and product form variations. This work develops a method for calibrating such a model to a large experimental database using genetic algorithm optimization. Finally, the report compares the final model to several specialized experimental tests to validate that it will be suitable for use in high temperature structural design. The techniques developed here can be applied to the remaining Section III, Division 5, Class A materials to develop a nonmandatory appendix to the Code describing inelastic material models suitable for use with the design by inelastic analysis procedures.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗