Oxidant-assisted methane pyrolysis
Adding small amounts of CO 2 or H 2 O to methane pyrolysis boosts hydrogen and carbon yieldsviacyclic catalyst regeneration, enabling efficient low-carbon hydrogen and crystalline carbon production.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Gupta, Raghubir.
Adding small amounts of CO 2 or H 2 O to methane pyrolysis boosts hydrogen and carbon yieldsviacyclic catalyst regeneration, enabling efficient low-carbon hydrogen and crystalline carbon production.
The lab sorbent testing finalized the sorbent composition and operating conditions for the integrated unit. The bench unit design included COMSOL simulation to finalize the coil design and select initial operating conditions of the power supply system. Fluidized bed testing with the induction heating verified that a heating efficiency of up to 90% can be achieved. The integrated bench unit operations provided valuable data confirming the feasibility of using induction heating for the desorption of CO2. Major challenge observed was the limited working capacity of the sorbent, requiring additional development in future projects. In addition, a large-scale reactor demonstration is required to mitigate the risk of uniform temperature distribution and heating efficiency over a large cross-sectional area when using induction heating.
Presentation of project in progress (DE-FE0032216) and Sustenol(TM) solvent
The ARPA-E Methane Pyrolysis Project successfully developed a scalable technology for hydrogen production with low-CO x emission through methane pyrolysis, co-producing high-value carbon nanotubes (CNTs). The project focused on optimizing reactor design, enhancing catalyst performance, and assessing techno-economic feasibility to create a commercially viable and environmentally sustainable process. The fluidized bed reactor achieved over 90% methane (CH 4 ) conversion by using a 5% CO 2 co-feed, which stabilizes carbon yields and minimizes catalyst deactivation. This setup allowed for continuous operation across ten cycles, each consisting of a 14-minute pyrolysis phase followed by a 10-minute dislodging phase to remove a fraction of the accumulated carbon, resulting in stable performance and high-quality CNT production. In parallel, monolith reactors coated with Fe demonstrated a sustained methane conversion of 73% while producing CNTs with high crystallinity. Although promising for continuous operation, monolith reactors face challenges in coating durability and scalability, highlighting areas for further optimization in commercial applications. Catalyst formulation played a key role in enhancing process efficiency. The core catalyst used was 5%Fe/Al 2 O 3 (wt%), optimized through wet impregnation, which improved CNT morphology, yielding longer and more uniform CNTs. The catalyst's performance was further enhanced by adding promoters: 2.5 wt% Ni increased methane conversion close to the thermodynamic limit, while 2.5 wt% Mn improved CNT alignment and crystallinity, and 1.5 wt% NaCl boosted CNT morphology but slightly lowered methane conversion. These adjustments allowed the reactor to maintain high methane conversion while producing high-quality CNTs, enabling stable performance over multiple cycles. To address carbon buildup and ensure uninterrupted operation, a pneumatic conveying tube was implemented for effective carbon dislodging in the fluidized bed configuration. CO 2 and H 2 O co-feeds were also introduced to enhance carbon removal, with CO 2 boosting CNT yield by approximately 15%. This setup enabled stable reactor operation across multiple cycles, preventing clogging and minimizing catalyst wear, making the process suitable for industrial scaling. Techno-economic analysis (TEA) projected hydrogen production costs between $\$$1.00 and $\$$1.64 per kilogram, with CNT values assumed at $\$$375/ton and $\$$100/ton. The life cycle assessment showed that CO 2 emissions could be as low as 0.64 kg CO 2 e/kg H 2 at 95% methane conversion assuming an electricity input of 50 kg CO 2 e/MWh. Even at 50% methane conversion, emissions remained below 1 kg CO 2 e/kg H 2 , demonstrating the process's low-emission potential and making it a viable alternative to traditional steam methane reforming. Overall, the results from this project demonstrate the feasibility of a pyrolysis process where carbon is continuously removed from the catalyst surface and hydrogen is continuously produced until a catalyst regeneration step is required to fully clean the catalyst surface and renew catalyst performance. Major open challenges are related to avoiding the loss of catalyst material in the dislodged carbon during fluidized bed conditions, since our best result demonstrated a carbon purity of ~70 wt. % (rest being iron and alumina). A monolith reactor was used to favor dislodgement of carbon compared to fluidized bed conditions but our results do not demonstrate an advantage of the monolith configuration. Catalyst performance was similar to fluidized bed conditions with slower deactivation rates overall, but we could not observe carbon dislodging in any of the tens of experiments that were run at Stanford. Our results show that the most relevant areas of improvement are related to the fundamental understanding of the iron-carbon interface for dislodging, and the development of catalyst that can produce CNTs via a base-growth mechanism such that catalyst is not lost in the dislodgement steps. The final report documents all findings and methodologies in detail, providing a valuable resource for the scientific community. By building on these results, researchers can further advance methane pyrolysis technology, moving toward a more sustainable, scalable pathway for hydrogen production. This work lays the foundation for future research and commercial efforts to reduce emissions in hydrogen production while generating valuable carbon products.
Poster for project in progress
Presentation of project in progress (DE-FE0032216) and Sustenol(TM) solvent
The work performed under this project has resulted into development of a DAC technology utilizing a structured sorbent to capture CO 2 from ambient air with a key innovation of direct Joule heating of the sorbent for CO 2 desorption. A working SMA, fully integrated with an electrically resistive heating layer, high surface area support, and high CO 2 capacity sorbent coated onto a commercial ceramic monolithic substrate, was successfully developed and demonstrated over >200 adsorption-desorption cycles in a high-fidelity bench test unit directly using ambient air. A cordierite-based monolith was selected as a substrate owing to its high surface area, low bulk density, low heat capacity, and commercial availability. Reaction kinetics study conducted during this project led to development of a promoter for the base Na 2 CO 3 sorbent that could be incorporated into the sorbent to enhance to achieve higher CO 2 adsorption/desorption rates, greater working capacity, and reduced regeneration temperature. An accelerated aging study was conducted in a TGA to determine sorbent stability and no degradation in the sorbent performance was observed even after 250 adsorption-desorption cycles. An electrically resistive heating layer was developed with tunable electrical properties. The heating layer was coated onto the selected cordierite substrate. Aging studies performed showed the electrical properties and heating performance was stable after 500 heating and cooling cycles. The collective findings on the selected cordierite substrate, robust heating layer, promoter and sorbent selection were used to synthesize a full, 6”x6” SMA for bench-scale testing. The bench-scale DAC system was constructed to test full size SMAs using real ambient air for adsorption and joule heating for regeneration. After completing shakedown and commissioning of the 1 kg/day of CO 2 capacity DAC bench unit, an extended operation was performed to complete over 230 cycles with the full size SMA. This testing showed no observable degradation in sorbent performance. A detailed process model, TEA and LCA were developed for a conceptual 100,000 TPY CO 2 removal DAC facility. The LCA results show the net CO 2 e emissions from the DAC system are highly dependent on the electricity source. All other factors, including SMA manufacturing, materials for facility enclosure, etc., are minor cost contributors compared to the energy consumption required for CO 2 removal. With the successful development and validation of the SMA for the sustained performance for CO 2 removal from ambient air with joule heated regeneration in this project, a fully integrated 1 TPY bench-scale DAC system is currently in development with the support of DOE/FECM (DE-FE0032243). The project objective is to demonstrate the engineering design of the DAC system to produce a continuous, high purity CO 2 stream from ambient air. This project will address and validate key engineering features of the DAC system including the gas sealing mechanism and panels, enclosure and air contactor design, and automation sequence to achieve continuous CO 2 production.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Ethylene and propylene are critical pillars of the petrochemical and plastics industry. The current industrial route for producing these olefins, which is via steam cracking process, is extremely endothermic and highly CO 2 -intensive. In this work, Susteon, in partnership with the North Carolina State University (NCSU), New Castle University (NU), and SoCalGas, has investigate catalytic materials and process designs to produce propylene from propane by utilizing CO 2 as a soft oxidant in the presence of low temperature dielectric barrier discharge plasma. This route integrates the effect of catalysis and the presence of a plasma environment to intensify the production of the important three carbon olefin from propane at a lower temperature and near atmospheric pressure. This CO 2 oxidative dehydrogenation (CO 2 -ODH) process coproduces CO, which is a valuable by-product, critical for the petrochemical sector. Through this work, Susteon and the team have made significant progress in developing catalysts and gaining insights on the plasma-assisted CO 2 -ODH process.
Presentation of project in progress (DE-FE0032216) High Performance Solvent for Natural Gas Combined Cycle (NGCC) Flue Gas CO2 Capture
The presentation provides a status report of bench-scale development of a DAC technology, specifically sorbent washcoat optimization, sorbent stability, desorption method optimization, heating layer performance, and bench-scale design & testing.
Heterogeneous catalytic pyrolysis of hydrocarbons to produce CO 2 -free hydrogen and high-quality solid carbon have historically been stymied by issues related to catalyst deactivation by carbon formed during pyrolysis on the catalyst surface. In addition, a system that demonstrates sustained performance in terms of high conversion, high H 2 yield, and high quality of produced carbon has remained elusive. Here, we propose and demonstrate a semi-continuous methane pyrolysis process to H 2 and carbon nanotubes (CNTs) consisting of repeated pyrolysis and in situ (i.e., within the reactor) CNT dislodging by vigorous steam/argon fluidization. With this process, we demonstrate 10 process cycles with high H 2 yield from CH 4 and CNT dislodging in a fluidized-bed reactor with an Fe/q-Al 2 O 3 catalyst synthesized by an easily scalable incipient wetness impregnation process. We also identify and present opportunities for future catalyst and process development.
Recent studies have shown that fossil generators equipped with post-combustion carbon capture (PCC) systems are needed to reduce the cost of deep decarbonization. Such generators need to be flexible and responsive to grid conditions, particularly in a high variable renewable energy (VRE) environment. In this work, we evaluate the net present value (NPV) of retrofitting an existing natural gas combined cycle (NGCC) unit with a flexible PCC system while incorporating market signals from a high VRE grid. We use our industrial partner’s NGCC configuration as representative of existing NGCC units and Svante’s rapid-temperature swing adsorption (TSA) for PCC. Because of its ability to rapidly startup/shutdown and ramp-up/ramp-down, the chosen capture technology is very attractive for load-following operations. For a given set of market signals, we formulate a two-stage stochastic multi-period optimization problem, under the price-taker assumption, to simultaneously optimize the design of the capture system and operation of the entire plant. Rigorous models for the NGCC unit, PCC system, and compression system are developed using commercial process simulators and validated with either plant or vendor data. For computational tractability, we develop surrogate/reduced-order models for use in the optimization problem. The surrogate model for the NGCC plant is constructed by linearizing the rigorous dynamic model at 75% load, while data-driven nonlinear surrogate models for the capture and compression systems are constructed using simulation data from the rigorous models. The optimization problem, formulated as a mixed integer bilinear program, is implemented in the IDAES® integrated platform and solved to global optimality using Gurobi 9.5. Using this formulation, we determine the profitability of retrofitting an existing NGCC unit with the chosen capture system for multiple regions in the U.S. under two scenarios with different carbon prices. Importantly, the results show that the optimal decision strongly depends on the region and on the carbon price, thereby demonstrating the importance of the inclusion of market signals in the design process.
The high activation barrier of the C-H bond in methane, combined with the high propensity of methanol and other liquid oxygenates toward overoxidation to CO 2 , have historically posed significant scientific and industrial challenges to the selective and direct conversion of methane to energy-dense fuels and chemical feedstocks. Here, we report a unique core-shell nanostructured photocatalyst, silica encapsulated TiO 2 decorated with AuPd nanoparticles (TiO 2 @SiO 2 -AuPd), that prevents methanol overoxidation on its surface and possesses high selectivity and yield of oxygenates even at high UV intensity. This room-temperature approach achieves high selectivity for oxygenates (94.5%) with a total oxygenate yield of 15.4 mmol/g cat ·h at 9.65 bar total pressure of CH 4 and O 2 . The working principles of this core-shell photocatalyst were also systematically investigated. Finally, this design concept was further demonstrated to be generalizable for the selective oxidation of other alkanes.
The presentation was delivered at the 2022 American Institute of Chemical Engineers (AIChE) annual meeting.
Zinc oxide-based sorbents, and processes for preparing and using them are provided, wherein the sorbents are preferably used to remove one or more reduced sulfur species from gas streams. The sorbents contain an active zinc component, optionally in combination with one or more promoter components and/or one or more substantially inert components. The active zinc component is a two-phase material, consisting essentially of a zinc oxide (ZnO) phase and a zinc aluminate (ZnAl 2 O 4 ) phase. Each of the two phases is characterized by a relatively small crystallite size of typically less than about 50 nm (500 Angstroms). Preferably the sorbents are prepared by using an alkali metal base to convert a precursor mixture, containing a precipitated zinc oxide precursor and a precipitated aluminum oxide precursor, to the two-phase, active zinc oxide containing component, with the resulting sorbent having a sodium level within a desired range.
NETL developed a nanostructured Fe catalyst capable of converting syngas to olefins. Initial laboratory testing demonstrated this technology possessed high reactivity (~70% conversion), good olefin selectivity (~40 weight %), and a long-performance lifetime (greater than 500 h on stream with no degradation). Under CRADA Agreement 0988, NETL and Susteon collaborated to evaluate the commercial potential of this catalyst technology by scaling up the catalyst synthesis and collecting reactivity data to characterize the mass and energy balance associated with utilizing this catalyst in a Fischer Tropsch to Olefins (FTO) reactor. Research under CRADA Agreement 0988 illustrated there are technical barriers associated with synthesizing the catalyst that the team was not able to overcome. Reactivity testing with this material illustrated that the catalyst deactivated in less than 50 hours of time on stream. Due to this technical barrier, the team did not meet its Go/No-Go decision target of creating a FTO process that produces at least a 25% reduction in olefin production cost compared to the current state-of the-art technologies. As a result, the team has stopped all work on CRADA Agreement 0988.