Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “undue conservatism”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

8 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS2012

Reducing Undue Conservatism in "Higher Frequency" Structural Design Loads in Aerospace Components

This study is intended to investigate the frequency dependency of significant strain due to vibratory loads in aerospace vehicle components. The notion that "higher frequency" dynamic loads applied as static loads is inherently conservative is perceived as widely accepted. This effort is focused on demonstrating that principle and attempting to evolve methods to capitalize on it to mitigate undue conservatism. It has been suggested that observations of higher frequency modes that resulted in very low corresponding strain did so due to those modes not being significant. Two avionics boxes, one with its first significant mode at 341 Hz and the other at 857 Hz, were attached to a flat panel installed on a curved orthogrid panel which was driven acoustically in tests performed at NASA/MSFC. Strain and acceleration were measured at select locations on each of the boxes. When possible, strain gage rosettes and accelerometers were installed on either side of a given structural member so that measured strain and acceleration data would directly correspond to one another. Ultimately, a frequency above which vibratory loads can be disregarded for purposes of static structural analyses and sizing of typical robust aerospace components is sought.

Knight, J. Brent↗
NASA NTRS1972

Evaluation of boron-epoxy-reinforced titanium tubular truss for application to a space shuttle booster thrust structure

Results of a study to demonstrate the applicability of boron-epoxy-composite-reinforced titanium tubular members to a space shuttle booster thrust structure are presented and discussed. The experimental results include local buckling of all-composite and composite-reinforced-metal cylinders with low values of diameter-thickness ratio, static tests on composite-to-metal bonded step joints, and a test to failure of a boron-epoxy-reinforced titanium demonstration truss. The demonstration truss failed at 118 percent of design ultimate load. Test results and analysis for all specimens and the truss are compared. Comparing an all-titanium design and a boron-epoxy-reinforced-titanium (75 percent B-E and 25 percent Ti) design for application to the space shuttle booster thrust structure indicates that the latter would weigh approximately 24 percent less. Experimental data on the local buckling strength of cylinders with a diameter-thickness ratio of approximately 50 are needed to insure that undue conservatism is not used in future designs.

Corvelli, N.↗
NASA NTRS2015

Coupled Loads Analysis of the Modified NASA Barge Pegasus and Space Launch System Hardware

A Coupled Loads Analysis (CLA) has been performed for barge transport of Space Launch System hardware on the recently modified NASA barge Pegasus. The barge re-design was facilitated with detailed finite element analyses by the ARMY Corps of Engineers - Marine Design Center. The Finite Element Model (FEM) utilized in the design was also used in the subject CLA. The Pegasus FEM and CLA results are presented as well as a comparison of the analysis process to that of a payload being transported to space via the Space Shuttle. Discussion of the dynamic forcing functions is included as well. The process of performing a dynamic CLA of NASA hardware during marine transport is thought to be a first and can likely support minimization of undue conservatism.

Knight, J. Brent↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Mass Mitigation in Structural Designs Via Dynamic Properties

Mass Mitigation in Structural Designs Via Dynamic Properties The reported efforts are focused on mitigating unnecessary mass in aerospace hardware via leveraging dynamic strength of materials and the frequency dependency of strain. Analytically predicted dynamic responses of structures are often applied as static loads in stress analyses that ultimately dictate the weight of a structural design. Assuming a dynamic response is a static load and then comparing resulting stress predictions to a static strength property is a long-standing engineering practice. Doing so is known to be, or is assumed to be, conservative. However, little indication of the order of magnitude of embedded conservatism has been identified. NASA/MSFC efforts in 2011, 2019, 2020, and now in 2021 have begun to qualitatively show the order of magnitude of that conservatism. A quick turnaround engineering method is pursued to leverage the subject facets of physics for the purpose of decreasing the weight of flight hardware. Tests performed using simple beams and significant observations are described.

mass mitigation↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Mass Mitigation in Structural Designs Via Dynamic Properties

The efforts reported here are focused on mitigating unnecessary mass in aerospace hardware. The approach to remove this undesired mass from the design is to leverage both the dynamic strength of materials and the frequency dependency of strain. Analytically predicted dynamic responses of structures are often applied as static loads in stress analyses that ultimately dictate the weight of a structural design. Assuming a dynamic response is a static load and then comparing resulting stress predictions to a static strength property is a long-standing engineering practice. Doing so is known to be, or is assumed to be, conservative. However, little indication of the order of magnitude of embedded conservatism has been identified. NASA/MSFC efforts in 2011, 2019, 2020, and now in 2021 have begun to qualitatively show the order of magnitude of that conservatism. A quick turnaround engineering method is pursued to leverage the subject facets of physics for the purpose of decreasing the weight of flight hardware. Tests performed using simple beams and significant observations are described.

conservative design loads↗
NASA NTRS1995

Aerothermodynamic testing requirements for future space transportation systems

Aerothermodynamics, encompassing aerodynamics, aeroheating, and fluid dynamic and physical processes, is the genesis for the design and development of advanced space transportation vehicles. It provides crucial information to other disciplines involved in the development process such as structures, materials, propulsion, and avionics. Sources of aerothermodynamic information include ground-based facilities, computational fluid dynamic (CFD) and engineering computer codes, and flight experiments. Utilization of this triad is required to provide the optimum requirements while reducing undue design conservatism, risk, and cost. This paper discusses the role of ground-based facilities in the design of future space transportation system concepts. Testing methodology is addressed, including the iterative approach often required for the assessment and optimization of configurations from an aerothermodynamic perspective. The influence of vehicle shape and the transition from parametric studies for optimization to benchmark studies for final design and establishment of the flight data book is discussed. Future aerothermodynamic testing requirements including the need for new facilities are also presented.

Paulson, John W., Jr.↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Undue Conservatisim in Structural Designs

Assuming that dynamic (transient/vibratory) loads are static in the design of structures is a long-standing engineering practice. The assumption is conservative for hardware that will have limited exposure to the specified dynamic environment and fatigue is not a concern. This is the case for most space flight hardware. Once out of the Earth’s atmosphere, significant vibrations are non-existent for most hardware and vibration cycles are limited. Mass is, and has always been, a concern with respect to flight hardware design. How much unnecessary mass due to the subject assumption may be in structural designs was questioned and numerous tests have been performed to qualitatively address that. Tests have been performed on simple aluminum beams, beams with bolted joints and beams with welded joints. Results of those tests are reported in this paper. The objective of these efforts was to demonstrate the order of magnitude of conservatism associated with this engineering process via comparing static to dynamic tests and the longer term endgame is to develop a new or modified quick turnaround structural design process that circumvents assuming dynamic loads are static and results in lighter structural designs. Test results qualitatively demonstrate notable conservatism. Activities to devise the new method are underway.

conservative loads↗