Engineering PapersSearch

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “taggants”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

Synthesis and characterization of isotopically barcoded nickel, molybdenum, and tungsten taggants for intentional nuclear forensics

Intentional nuclear forensics is a concept wherein the deliberate addition of benign and persistent material signatures to nuclear material can be used to reduce the time between the discovery of material outside of regulatory control and determination of its original provenance. One concept within intentional nuclear forensics involves the use of perturbed stable isotopes to generate unique isotope ratio “barcodes” to encode information (e.g., production batch, location, etc.) and track material throughout the nuclear fuel cycle. Synthesis of taggant species of nickel (Ni), molybdenum (Mo), and tungsten (W) was undertaken via a double-spike mechanism, wherein two highly enriched isotopes of interest per elemental taggant were mixed to form an enriched “double-spike” which was subsequently isotopically diluted with bulk material having a natural isotopic composition. Two taggant species perturbing isotopic ratios, alpha (α) and beta (β), for each of Ni, Mo, and W were synthesized. Independent measurements of double spikes and alpha and beta taggant species agreed within uncertainty and are clearly resolvable from natural compositions. High-precision analyses were independently performed by MC-ICP-MS at two U.S. National Laboratories, with consensus values and uncertainties calculated for all samples. Observed isotopic perturbations in the final taggant species measured on the order of hundreds to thousands of permille (‰) with respect to natural for isotope ratios of interest (e.g., 60 Ni/ 58 Ni, 100 Mo/ 98 Mo, 186 W/ 183 W). Discrepancies between modeled and measured isotopic compositions were observed and are largely attributed to imprecise vendor assay values for starting materials. Using measured starting material compositions as inputs for the mixing model improved the level of agreement between predicted and measured α and β taggant isotope ratios. Overall, characterization of all taggant species demonstrates that this “barcode” concept could have viability for use in nuclear forensics. Finally, it is expected that for any two-isotope mixing array dozens of isotopic barcodes could be encoded into a material system and subsequently resolved utilizing modern mass spectrometric methods.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P

Recovery of stable isotope taggants along a wet production pathway of uranium dioxide

Stable isotope taggants added to nuclear materials could be utilized as diagnostic nuclear forensics signatures; however, intentionally adding taggants is a relatively new and untested concept with respect to the nuclear fuel cycle. Here, in this study, we added trace amounts of stable Mo and W isotope taggants to starting materials used to synthesize UO 2 along a wet synthesis pathway. Successful incorporation and recovery of the Mo and W taggants was achieved in the UO 2 product and all its precursors. This study demonstrates the efficacy of stable isotope tagging along a wet UO 2 production pathway.

Nuclear forensics

Transition Metal Taggants in UO 2 from First Principles

The incorporation of transition metals into nuclear fuel has gained attention both to improve fuel properties and as a possible nuclear forensics tool. Recent experimental studies by Ulrich et al. and Adorno Lopes et al. have investigated Ni and Fe as candidate transition metal dopants for potential nuclear forensics purposes and found that there is minimal alteration to key UO 2 fuel properties. In the present work, we performed density functional theory (DFT) investigations into possible defect structures for Ni and Fe incorporation. The dynamic stability of these defect structures was validated by calculating the phonon density of states. We found that transition metal incorporation likely occurs via substitution at U sites in the fluorite crystal structure with a nearby O vacancy for charge-balancing, which agrees with experimentally proposed structures. Additionally, this defect structure does not cause long-range alterations to the crystal parameters—an important consideration for use as a nuclear fuel taggant. Future needed work involves computational investigation of additional defect concentrations using larger supercells, additional transition metal charge states, and thermal effects. Such investigations can be carried forward into sintering models for a more complete understanding of the suitability of Ni and Fe as fuel taggants.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS

Natural isotopic compositions of titanium, iron, and nickel observed in commercial fuel pellets – Promising candidate elements for stable isotope tagging

Stable isotope taggants would constitute unique identifiers for nuclear fuel cycle materials, resulting in expedited timelines and high confidence provenance assessments for nuclear forensics investigations. However, reliably identifying and interpreting stable isotope taggants in nuclear materials recovered from outside of regulatory control will largely be predicated on the assumption that the taggant element intrinsic to the untagged nuclear material exhibits natural isotopic ratios. Here, we present high-precision Ti, Fe, and Ni isotope compositions in 13 commercial low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuel pellets to assess the suitability of these transition metals as stable isotope taggants. Our investigations reveal limited isotope variations among the fuel pellets in all three elements, which are consistent with small mass-dependent isotope fractionations, comparable to variations previously reported for natural samples. In practice, isotopically tagged nuclear materials are expected to fall along isotopic mixing lines, since intrinsic background levels of taggant elements dilute the taggant towards natural isotope compositions. Furthermore, the observation that Ti, Fe, and Ni isotope compositions in a suite of LEU fuel pellets are close to or indistinguishable from estimates for the Bulk Silicate Earth demonstrates that a two end-member mixing assumption would be valid for these transition metals, indicating that all three are promising candidate elements for stable isotope tagging. Finally, we present mass balance calculations to quantify isotopic perturbations expected from admixing isotopically anomalous Ti, Fe, and Ni taggants to assess the interplay between elemental and taggant concentrations and find favorable compromises for facilitating successful taggant identification with current analytical methods.

Intentional forensics

Effects of grain size and porosity on cladding failure in high-burnup UO 2 : A sensitivity and uncertainty study

Isotopic taggants are being studied to aid in the provenance assessment of nuclear materials. However, these taggants must be selected such that they do not adversely affect fuel performance during normal operation or accident scenarios. Taggants are known to affect the fuel’s grain size and porosity. In the work described in this paper, the BISON fuel performance code was used to assess the potential effects of taggants (i.e., grain size and porosity) on fuel rod behavior and cladding failure during a high-burnup, large-break loss-of-coolant accident. Here, 281 individual fuel rods from the same reactor core were modeled for a sensitivity study, a parametric study, and uncertainty quantification. The cladding failure predictions often exhibited stochastic behavior. After additional study, it was found that the cladding failure model is highly sensitive to residual error inherent to numerical approximation solvers. Some strategies to mitigate this sensitivity are discussed. The study found no relationship between known taggant effects and cladding failure status. However, taggants were found to affect the time and location of failure in certain rods. In conclusion, future work to continue investigating and validating these findings is briefly discussed.

Doped UO 2

Rolling Behavior of Surface Tagged Aluminum 6061 using Photoluminescent Oxides

Physical tagging of nuclear fuel is potentially one way of tracking throughout the fuel lifecycle. The process of tagging can take many forms, but one promising method is to embed a small amount of photoluminescent particles in the surface of a material which are not detectable under normal illumination but are readily visible under excitation by ultraviolet light. The goal of this project was to explore the potential to tag simulated nuclear fuel cladding with small ceramic particles, via laser beam welding or gas tungsten arc welding, and measure the photoluminescent response. Surface tagging using this method has demonstrated viability and detectability throughout this project; work in FY24 focused on the survivability of these tags through subsequent deformation processing similar to what taggants in a fuel manufacturing environment would be subjected to. This work demonstrated that particles are readily visible in the as-welded state (i.e., before subsequent rolling treatment to represent mechanical processing of a fuel material), but visibility is reduced as the deformation is induced. Despite the reduction in photoluminescence, the taggants are still visible after rolling processes are performed, making this surface tagging technique a promising candidate for nuclear fuel cladding tagging. This work demonstrated, though, that targeted optimization work would be necessary to develop a robust taggant depending on the fidelity and luminescent properties required.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

RIMS analysis of isotopically tagged uranium particles with application to Intentional Forensics

Traditional nuclear forensics approaches leverage isotopic measurements for characterizing nuclear forensics signatures in fuel cycle materials. To aid in provenance assessment, isotopically perturbed transition metal taggants can be added to fuel cycle materials. We present a case study for examining natural uranium oxide powder that was tagged with isotopically perturbed Mo before and after irradiation using resonance ionization mass spectrometry. In conclusion, this method accurately and precisely measures taggant and uranium compositions, rapidly enabling the ability to clearly discriminate between tagged particles and other material with application for robust assessment of material provenance.

Forensic Anthropology

An approach for spent nuclear fuel containment integrity verification using gas tagging

Verification of containment integrity is required for spent nuclear fuel (SNF) managed by the commercial nuclear industry and U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), especially after extended storage. Certain SNF storage systems, such as the DOE road-ready dry storage system, hold several packaged containments within a welded over-canister. These packaged containments are called Department of Energy Standard Canisters (DOESCs). DOESC leakage identification is challenging because their containment boundary cannot be accessed for testing and their contents (i.e., SNF and fill gas) are often similar. There are concerns that this could result in costly characterization and repackaging operations of DOE road-ready dry storage systems if compromised DOESCs are suspected. Here, to address these concerns, this paper presents an approach for applying a gas tagging process using xenon to uniquely identify compromised inaccessible containments following extended storage. The containments considered for this application are seven DOESCs, each packaged within a single over-canister. Two different SNF loading configurations from the Advanced Test Reactor and Fort Saint Vrain nuclear power plant are considered. These configurations are used to represent research reactor aluminum-clad spent nuclear fuel (ASNF) and TRi-structural ISOtropic (TRISO) SNF types. Results for this application show that for ASNF and TRISO type fuels for which the selected fuels are representative, the volume of taggant required at loading is determined primarily by the lower detection limit and leak rate of taggant from a compromised DOESC, rather than the amount of fission-generated xenon in the loaded fuel. While the application presented is suited for larger leaks, smaller leaks could be detected by modifying certain design parameters. This gas tagging approach can also be applied to other DOE containments and advanced reactor SNF storage systems.

07 - ISOTOPES AND RADIATION SOURCES

Investigation of UO 2 doped with Fe 2 O 3 sintered under a reducing atmosphere

Nuclear fuel produced with trace amounts of transition metal additives is of potential interest for introducing intentional signatures for accelerating nuclear forensics. In this work, we investigate the effects on microstructure, grain size, crystal structure, and stoichiometry when trace amounts of Fe in the form of Fe 2 O 3 are added to UO 2 . Sintering of compacts with different concentrations, from 250 to 3000 ppmw, was performed under a reducing atmosphere at 1773 K. The persistence of the taggant during the fuel fabrication process as well as its impact on grain size, crystal lattice, and first-neighbor chemistry was evaluated using inductively coupled plasma–optical emission spectroscopy, powder X-ray diffraction (pXRD), Raman spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy–backscatter electron spectroscopy, energy dispersive spectroscopy, and thermogravimetric analysis. We observed that a negligible amount of Fe was lost during sintering. Our results indicate that the feedstock, Fe 2 O 3 transforms into Fe and FeO under the test sintering conditions. For all compositions, metallic Fe precipitate was found in grain boundaries as a secondary phase. In conclusion, the potential incorporation of ionic Fe into the UO 2 unit cell was determined by pXRD and Raman spectra.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS

The influence of iron incorporation on the microstructure and crystal chemistry of UO 2 fuel

The incorporation of dopants into UO 2 is of interest for both doped advanced fuel and nuclear forensics research. Suitable forensics dopants, or taggants, for nuclear fuels are ones that do not adversely affect the performance of the parent material while still being traceable during key stages of the fuel’s life cycle. In this paper, we present our efforts to understand the effects of doping UO 2 with Fe 2 O 3 under multiple parameters, such as Fe concentration (0–3000 wppm), sintering temperature (1673 K, 1773 K, and 1973 K), sintering time (2–12 h), and atmosphere (reducing and inert). Here, we investigated densification behavior, microstructure evolution, and lattice defects based on the geometric densities, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), X-ray diffractograms, and Raman spectra. The effect of Fe on the microstructure and crystal chemistry of UO 2 is very complex, especially at the intermediate temperature (1773 K), where we found that densification kinetics are enhanced and that lattice contraction occurs for doping concentrations greater than 1000 wppm Fe.

Crystallography