Engineering PapersSearch

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “roughness”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Uniting Surface Properties With Hydrodynamic Roughness in Shallow Overland Flow Models

Describing flow resistance from the properties of an underlying surface is a challenge in surface hydrology. Runoff models must specify a resistance formulation or “roughness scheme”—describing the functional relationship between flow resistance and flow depth/velocity—and its parameters. Uncertainty in runoff predictions derives from both the selected roughness scheme (e.g., Darcy Weisbach, Manning's, or laminar flow equations), and its parameterization with a roughness coefficient (e.g., Manning's n). Both choices are informed by model calibration to data, usually discharge, and, if available, velocity. In this study, a Saint Venant Equation-based runoff model is calibrated to discharge and velocity data from 112 rainfall simulator experiments. The results are used to identify the optimal roughness scheme among four widely-used options for each experiment, and to explore whether surface properties can be used to select the optimal roughness scheme and its coefficient. Among the tested roughness schemes, a transitional flow equation provided the best fit to the plurality of experiments. The most suitable roughness scheme for a given experiment was not related to measured surface properties. Regression models predicted the calibrated roughness coefficients with adjusted values between 0.48 and 0.54, depending on the roughness scheme used. Litter cover was the best predictor of the roughness coefficient, followed by soil cover and average canopy gap size. The results suggest that selection of an optimal roughness scheme based on surface properties alone remains difficult, but that once a scheme is selected, roughness coefficients can be estimated from surface properties.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES

Engineering Assembly Kinetics and Line Roughness in Solvent Vapor-Annealed Block Copolymer/Homopolymer Blends

Block copolymer (BCP) directed self-assembly (DSA) is a promising route to enhance lithography resolution by multiplying nanopattern density and reducing feature roughness. Eliminating kinetically trapped self-assembly defects requires fast self-assembly. However, acceleration strategies like solvent vapor annealing or homopolymer blending broaden domain interfaces, implying a trade-off in increased feature roughness. In this work, we experimentally investigate this apparent dilemma between self-assembly kinetics and line roughness for solvent vapor-annealed thin films of a lamellar poly(styrene-block-2-vinylpyridine) (PS-b-P2VP) BCP blended with PS and P2VP homopolymers. Binary blends with PS or P2VP homopolymers and ternary blends incorporating both in equal weight fractions were solvent vapor annealed using acetone, a near-neutral solvent for PS and P2VP, followed by P2VP-selective vapor-phase infiltration with alumina (AlOx) and polymer etching. Binary blends with P2VP exhibit a modest kinetic enhancement but also higher line-edge and -width roughness due to the increased frequency of P2VP protrusions and bridge defects in the alumina line patterns. In contrast, binary blends with PS self-assemble noticeably faster, while domain asymmetry from the added PS homopolymer reduces roughness by curbing the number of alumina protrusions and bridge defects. Ternary blends maintain DSA line patterns across a wider composition window and, at higher homopolymer loadings, reduce roughness at length scales near the lamellar period, consistent with a reduced impact of intradomain compositional fluctuations. These findings provide important insights for codesigning blend compositions and process flows to achieve high-resolution, defect free patterns with minimal roughness through BCP DSA.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH

Wafer-scale waveguide sidewall roughness scattering loss characterization by image processing

Photonic integrated circuits (PICs) are vital for developing affordable, high-performance optoelectronic devices that can be manufactured at an industrial scale, driving innovation and efficiency in various applications. Optical loss of modes in thin film waveguides and devices is a critical measure of their performance. Thin film growth, lithography, masking, and etching processes are imperfect processes that introduce significant sidewall and top-surface roughness and cause dominating optical losses in waveguides and photonic structures. This roughness, as perturbations couple light from guided to far-field radiation modes, leads to scattering losses that can be estimated from theoretical models. Typically, with UV-based lithography, sidewall roughness is significantly larger than wafer-top surface roughness. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) imaging measurement gives a 3D and high-resolution roughness profile, but the measurement is inconvenient, costly, and unscalable for large-scale PICs and at wafer-scale. Here, we evaluate the sidewall roughness profile based on 2D high-resolution scanning electron microscope (SEM) imaging. We characterized the loss on two homemade nitride and oxide films on 3-inch silicon wafers with 12 waveguide devices on each and correlated the scattering loss estimated from a 2D image-based sidewall profile and theoretical Payne model. The lowest loss of guided fundamental transverse electric (TE 0 ) mode is found at 0.075 dB/cm at 633 nm across 24 devices, a record at visible wavelength. Our work shows 100% success (edge continuity span exceeding 95% of image width/height) in edge detection in image processing of all images to estimate autocorrelation function and optical mode loss. These demonstrations offer valuable insights into waveguide sidewall roughness and a comparison of experimental and 2D SEM image processing based loss estimations with applications in loss characterization at wafer-scale PICs.

Khurana, Mohit (ORCID:0000000207898672)

Predicting roughness effects in additively manufactured coolant channels with helical enhancements

Additive manufacturing (AM) is a promising technique for fabrication of complex geometries such as those expected to be utilized in the blanket, first wall, and divertor. In the case of cooling, metallic AM may be exploited to embed geometric enhancements (ribs, rifling, etc.) to improve cooling performance. However, due to the roughness of these unfinished internal AM surfaces, prediction of thermal hydraulic performance in such channels is difficult. In this work, we consider a methodology for predicting pressure drop and heat transfer in AM channels containing helical enhancements (e.g. helical ribs, twisted tapes) that allows the incorporation of roughness data through conventional pipe flow correlations. This methodology is tested using experimental friction factor and heat transfer coefficient data from high-pressure helium coolant flow measurements in AM stainless steel tubes fabricated by laser powder bed fusion. Both a featureless AM tube and one containing helical ribs were considered alongside a conventionally manufactured smooth tube. The AM surface roughness is obtained by profilometry and used to predict an equivalent sand-grain roughness, with this equivalent roughness confirmed through AM featureless tube measurements. Under the proposed methodology, this roughness information is incorporated into predictions of friction factor and Nusselt number for the rifled tube. Furthermore, these predictions agree well with experimental data across a large range of Reynolds numbers, encouraging the use of this methodology for thermal hydraulic analysis of similar systems and design of future coolant channel geometries.

Additive manufacturing

Surface roughness and dimensional evaluation of laser powder bed fusion additively manufactured shell and tube heat exchangers

The growing interest in additively manufactured (AM) heat exchangers drove the need to understand how this construction technique impacts heat exchanger performance. Two primary factors driven by AM that influence heat exchanger performance are surface roughness and geometry. To better understand these parameters, a range of shell and tube heat exchangers constructed using laser powder bed fusion were evaluated. Of those evaluated, the surface roughness throughout a fourteen-tube, zero-baffle heat exchanger was measured using computed tomography. Between the inner and outer tubes, the inner tube surfaces had a greater surface roughness than the outer by 8.07 μm, while the surfaces at the top of the build volume had higher surface roughness values than the bottom. Dimensionally, the inner tube diameters of this heat exchanger were 0.15% different from the design value, while the outer diameters were within a 0.84 % difference. Manual measurements across seven other heat exchangers yielded a maximum 1.15% difference between the design and measured diameters. Across the build volume for all heat exchangers studied, the tube diameters at the top were larger than at the bottom by a maximum of 1.24% difference. Inconsistent melting throughout the individual parts and the build volume, as well as particle splatter and thermal gradient variation were attributed to the surface roughness and dimensional changes seen. These results strengthen the knowledge of dimensional and surface roughness considerations when designing AM heat exchangers.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Competition between roughness and strength for scale-dependent surfaces

Rocks famously have scale-dependent strength, yet the actual dependence is notoriously hard to measure or incorporate into any theoretical framework. Natural rough surfaces present an opportunity to solve the problem. Surfaces sliding in shear evolve as protrusions collide. These asperities can deform or break, thus creating a new surface shape. In particular, natural surfaces have roughness at all scales as well as scale-dependent strength. Based on a scaling analysis, we have previously suggested that the scale-dependent aspect ratio of steady-state surfaces should be proportional to the scale-dependent shear strain at yield. If true, scale-dependent strength could easily be inferred from natural surfaces. Thus, moving beyond the scaling argument to a rigorous treatment of scale-dependent strength for multiscale rough surfaces in shear is important. However, analytic frameworks for analyzing multiscale problems are challenging, as conventional continuum mechanics typically involves a single value for a material property across scales. Here, in this work, we build on the formalism of Persson (2001) that presents a method to compute contact area for rough surfaces with a prescribed topographic spectrum using a stochastic differential equation. The Persson formalism allows for plastic yield under normal loading of otherwise elastic materials and leaves open the possibility of scale-dependent yield stress. In this study, we pursue this route to develop a theory and numerical results for the yielding of a rough, elastoplastic surface with scale-dependent yield stress. Here, we examine surfaces for which the power spectrum of the topography 𝐶 and yield stress 𝑌 follow power laws as a function of scale 𝜆, such that 𝐶∼𝜆 −𝑚 and 𝑌∼𝜆 −𝑛 , respectively. In this formal treatment of the problem, we focus on surfaces in contact and the resulting yield and do not impose shear. Numerical solutions show that the deviation from the elastic scaling solution is bounded as expected by the prior 1D heuristic scaling argument that anticipates the Hurst exponent as 1−𝑛. We also show that the plasticity is expected to erode the contacts if 𝑚 is lower than 𝑛−3, which corresponds to a Hurst exponent lower than 1−𝑛/2. This result is rigorously sound for 2D, i.e., realistic surfaces, and quantitatively different than the prior scaling argument. The theory now permits a correspondingly quantitative approach to interpreting natural surfaces.

elasticity

Identifying the Accuracy of Surface Roughness for Metal Additive Manufacturing Parts Captured with Computed Tomography Scanning

Conventional surface roughness measurement techniques require direct access to internal surfaces, often necessitating destructive sectioning of test articles. Computed tomography (CT) offers a non-destructive alternative for internal surface characterization, but its application in metrology remains unstandardized and sensitive to machine resolution and operator technique. This study investigates the feasibility of using CT scanning to quantify areal surface roughness in metal AM heat exchanger tubes with three distinct internal geometries: ribbed, discrete W, and featureless. CT-derived surface parameters were extracted using custom Python scripts and compared to measurements obtained from a focus variation microscope calibrated against a known standard. Results show that CT-based roughness measurements closely matched microscope values for the discrete W specimen, deviations between CT and microscope measurements were minimal—less than 1 µm—indicating reliable reconstruction. In contrast, the ribbed and featureless specimens, with lower roughness values showed greater discrepancies. The findings suggest that CT scanning can be a viable non-destructive metrology tool for AM parts with surface roughness above approximately 8 µm. For smoother surfaces, current CT capabilities may not provide sufficient accuracy, highlighting the need for resolution-aware workflows and further standardization in CT-based surface metrology.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Effect of pattern transfer process on roughness of block copolymer patterns from directed self-assembly

Block copolymer-directed self-assembly (DSA) remains promising for improving pattern quality and reducing the stochastic variations that challenge high numerical aperture extreme ultraviolet lithography. Equally critical is refining pattern transfer methods for accurately transferring the rectified DSA features to the underlying substrate. We compare two atomic layer deposition (ALD)-based techniques: sequential infiltration synthesis (SIS) and dry liftoff, applied to polystyrene-block-poly(methyl methacrylate) (PS-b-PMMA) DSA patterns. Both methods utilize aluminum oxide hard masks, with one synthesized through infiltration into the PMMA domains and the other through conformal ALD coating. High-resolution scanning electron micrographs were analyzed to measure line edge, width, and placement roughness for both the line (PMMA) and space (PS) features. Although both methods yielded similar overall 3σ rms roughness, they differed significantly in the frequency-dependent power spectral density (PSD) profiles. SIS reduced line placement roughness at length scales associated with the polymer pitch, but increased space width roughness at low frequencies, whereas dry liftoff mimicked the frequency content of the original guiding pattern. This study underscores the importance of PSD evaluation in selecting optimal pattern transfer strategies for specific applications.

Block copolymers

Tailoring copper current collector roughness and crystallographic orientation to improve lithium plating

Secondary lithium metal batteries are of great interest due to a high theoretical energy density, but rechargeability is limited by the formation of lithium dendrites that lead to internal short circuits and catastrophic cell failure. Mitigating dendrites through uniform current distribution at the current collector is a promising solution to enabling long cycle life of lithium metal electrodes. Here, the impact of copper crystal orientation and roughness on electrochemically deposited lithium morphology is studied. For 50 cycles, the capacity retention from greatest to least followed polycrystalline copper 95 ± 1 % (MC-PC) ≥ 94.55 ± 0.01 % Cu (110) > 93.0 ± 0.4 % Cu(111) > 75.8 ± 0.1 % Cu(100). Cu(100) performed the worst in all cases with shorts occurring frequently before reaching 50 cycles. Cryo-scanning electron microscopy images showed that after 50 cycles, MC-PC Cu had the best lithium morphology, but at early cycles, Cu(111) formed the densest lithium layer. MC-PC Cu had the most uniform lithium nucleation which may have been caused by increased roughness relative to the single crystal samples. When polycrystalline Cu (F-PC) roughness was systematically controlled, the cumulative Coulombic efficiency increased from about 0.3–0.5 with increasing roughness from an Ra of about 10–40 nm. Lastly, plating rates were studied. Slower rates of 0.25 mA/cm 2 exhibited denser lithium morphology in all cases as compared to 0.5 and 1.0 mA/cm 2 , but the relative porosity of Li deposited on the different current collectors depended on the rate applied.

Copper

Characterizing Stress Roughness at Utah FORGE Through Simulation of Hydraulic Fracture Growth During 16A Stage 3 Stimulation

In most geologic formations, the vertical gradient of the minimum horizontal stress (𝜎 h ) exceeds the hydrostatic gradient, often driving hydraulic fractures to propagate upward. However, observations indicate that the upward growth of real hydraulic fractures is less pronounced than theoretical predictions based on smoothly varying 𝜎 h fields. In fact, the layered structure of sedimentary rocks hinders fracture propagation across layers, partially explaining the limited height growth observed in practice (Zoback et al., 2022). While crystalline rocks lack the pervasive layered fabric of sedimentary formations, they still possess structural fabric formed over their geologic history, resulting in inherently "rough" in situ stress fields. Recent studies have identified another key factor: the "roughness" of in situ stress, characterized by temporal, relatively short-wavelength fluctuations superimposed on the overall stress gradient. This stress roughness leads to apparent toughness anisotropy, where the vertical toughness appears significantly larger than the horizontal toughness (P. Fu et al., 2019; Dontsov & Suarez-Rivera, 2021). Neglecting the effects of rock fabric and stress roughness can yield inaccurate predictions of hydraulic fracture geometry and growth rates at larger length scales.

58 GEOSCIENCES

Aperture and roughness govern iron oxide passivation in olivine fractures during carbon mineralization

Efficient carbon dioxide mineralization in silicate-rich formations depends on reaction rates within fracture networks, yet the role of fracture microstructure remains poorly constrained. We investigated how fracture aperture and surface roughness influence mineralization by reacting synthetic forsteritic olivine fractures with controlled apertures (0.5–1.6 millimeters) and roughness (6–16 micrometers) with supercritical carbon dioxide at 13.7 megapascals and 185 degrees Celsius. Optical microscopy and Raman spectroscopy showed that rougher fracture surfaces promoted iron oxide precipitation, which passivated olivine surfaces, limiting magnesium availability for carbonate formation while removing iron as a reactant. These effects were more pronounced in smaller-aperture fractures. A geochemical model incorporating surface topography and passivation reproduced the observed trends, confirming that increased roughness can reduce reactivity despite greater surface area. Our results demonstrate that fracture microstructure strongly influences iron oxide passivation and carbon dioxide mineralization, with important implications for predicting long-term performance of engineered carbon dioxide storage systems.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES

Chemical and Chemical-Mechanical Polishing of Surface Roughness on L-PBF/GRCop-42 Cu-Cr-Nb Additive Manufactured 10-GHz RF Structures

Laser-based powder bed fusion (L-PBF) allows additive manufacture (AM) of lower hybrid current drive (LHCD) radio-frequency (RF) launchers from Glenn Research Copper, a Cr 2 Nb precipitation-hardened alloy (GRCop-42) in configurations unachievable with conventional machining. Rough surfaces in AM components increase RF losses and lead to arcing in high-power vacuum RF applications. Chemical polishing, chemical-mechanical polishing, or a combination of both were utilized to planarize the internal surfaces of RF structures, resulting in surface roughness as low as R a = 0.2 µm. Refinement in polishing techniques now enables GRCop-42 alloys (4 at. % Cr, 2 at. % Nb) to achieve similar surface roughness to GRCop-84 (8 at. % Cr, 4 at. % Nb) and equivalent cavity losses to extruded oxygen-free copper waveguides at 10 GHz.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

Predictive numerical modeling of plasma-induced surface roughness and wettability evolution in LM-PAEK/CF tape

Plasma surface modification effectively enhances adhesion in thermoplastic composites, yet its impacts on high-performance polymers like low-melting polyaryletherketone (LM-PAEK) remain inadequately quantified. Here, this study integrates experimental analysis and numerical modeling to characterize surface roughness and wettability changes in LM-PAEK/carbon fiber composites treated with atmospheric plasma. Atomic Force Microscopy quantified surface topography (n = 10 per condition for contact angles), while static contact-angle assessments measured wettability. Roughness rapidly increased from ∼0.2 nm to 1.6 nm, and contact angle reduced from ∼90° to 24°, both stabilizing after 25–30 s of exposure. A semi-empirical, physics-informed framework was calibrated to these data, coupling surface chemistry via the Owens–Wendt decomposition with topography via the Wenzel roughness factor, and evaluated using out-of-sample (cross-validated) tests, while static contact angle assessments measured wettability. Numerical predictions matched experimental results closely (RMSE <5%, R 2 > 0.95). Incorporating material-specific parameters, the calibrated model supports plasma-treatment optimization and provides quantitative guidance for improving interfacial adhesion in thermoplastic composite manufacturing.

Atomic Force Microscopy

Estimating and Evaluating Roughness Length and Displacement Height in Heterogeneous Urban Environments

The roughness length (z 0 ) and displacement height (z d ) are essential surface-layer parameters in numerical models (e.g., weather, climate, wall-modeled LES, etc.). This work evaluates the consistency of z 0 and z d estimates from morphometric and anemometric methods using data from two eddy-covariance flux towers (AmeriFlux US-INg and US-INc) in Indianapolis, IN. Results show inconsistencies in estimated z 0 and z d values depending on the chosen method. The two evaluated anemometric methods estimate non-physical values of z d when compared to roughness elements surrounding both towers. Additionally, predictions of mean wind speed using surface-layer similarity theory with morphometric estimates exhibit a bias during near-neutral and stable conditions relative to observations. The overestimation of mean wind speed by surface layer similarity theory is consistent with previous observational and modeling studies in urban areas, suggesting that the application of similarity theories to urban environments may have limitations. Differentiation of vegetation from built structures appears to impact morphometric z 0 and z d estimates, particularly where vegetation is abundant; however, it has little impact on correcting biases in the similarity theory. Specifically, we find that existing similarity theories using morphometric estimates underestimate integral velocity and length scales, and the degree of underestimation depends on the stability conditions. Accounting for the degree of anisotropy in surface-layer turbulence helps reduce the biases between similarity theories and observations during unstable conditions, but not in near-neutral cases. Future work is needed to identify the cause of such biases for near-neutral conditions.

Aerodynamic roughness length

Decoupling the effects of substrate hardness and roughness upon particle adhesion in cold spray

There are two stages of particle adhesion relevant to cold spray: adhesion of the first layer to the substrate, followed by inter-particle adhesion during subsequent deposition. In this work we study the second of these, in which particles strike a previously-deposited layer that is roughened and hardened by prior particle impacts. Specifically, we decouple the effects of surface roughness and hardness on particle adhesion for copper-on-copper impacts. We measure changes to the critical velocity, V cr , in single particle impacts produced by the Laser Induced Particle Impact Test on several surfaces including a cold sprayed surface and a polished version of that surface. We find that increases in both substrate roughness and hardness suppress particle adhesion to higher velocities, indeed in rather equal proportion by ∼10–15% each. This suggests that there is a higher V cr associated with coating build-up (particle-particle bonding) that is overall ∼30% higher than V cr for particle-substrate adhesion.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Coalescence-Induced Spontaneous Shedding of Microdroplets on Superhydrophobic Surfaces Featuring Enclosed Micropillars with Hierarchical Roughness

This study investigated water vapor condensation on superhydrophobic surfaces (SHSs) featuring micropillars enclosed by wall lattices and having three-tier hierarchical roughness. A total of five samples were created with three (NW-J, W200-J and W400-J samples) having large micropillar depth (~6 μm) and two (NW-S and W200-S samples) having small micropillar depth (~1 μm). Two distinct condensate removal modes were observed during condensation: coalescence-induced jumping on samples with large micropillar depth and coalescence-induced shedding on samples with small micropillar depth. The results showed that the diameter of the shedding droplet on the W200-S sample having small micropillar depth could be as small as 107 μm, as compared to the theoretical critical diameter of 267 μm for gravitational shedding on the same sample. The enhanced functionality of the three-tier nanotextures on the W200-S sample could effectively suppress localized pinning of the three-phase contact line and Wenzel neck formation during the growth of condensate droplets. Consequently, during multidroplet coalescence, the released surface energy easily overcomes the solid–liquid adhesion, leading to spontaneous shedding of merged droplets. The inclusion of the wall lattice aids condensate growth by the droplet self-alignment along the walls and promoting coalescence. As a result, the W200-S sample exhibited the highest condensate collection as well. In conclusion, the proposed surface design has great potential for scaling up and implementation in heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning equipment due to the simplicity of the surface morphology and the facile spray-coating method used to achieve hierarchical roughness.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH

Controlling Deformation in Al/Ti: How Interface Roughness and Orientation Drive Bimetal Mechanics

The microstructural characteristics and morphology of interfaces in metals can be crucial in governing the initiation of plasticity and early deformation mechanisms under extreme conditions. During high-strain-rate deformation, these interfaces significantly affect dislocation nucleation, twinning, and other mechanisms that directly impact material strength and failure. Despite their importance, a substantial knowledge gap remains between the observed macroscopic material behavior and the underlying role of bimetal interfaces in plasticity initiation. Here, to address this gap, large-scale molecular dynamics simulations are performed on Al/Ti bimetal structures to examine the effect of interface characteristics on the onset of plasticity under uniaxial compression. Specifically, this study investigates how interface roughness (flat vs waveform interfaces) modifies the initiation of plastic events in the microstructure. Atomistic simulations indicate that interface roughness (a microscopic behavior) reduces the stress required for dislocation nucleation, thereby reducing the peak stress relative to a flat interface. For the square interface, the step height strongly influences plasticity initiation by setting the separation of locally flat regions. Varying the interface rotation relative to the loading direction (macroscopic behavior) reveals that the peak stress for both flat and waveform interfaces initially decreases and then increases with rotation, accompanied by a shift in dominant mechanisms—from Al twinning (flat) to interface sliding and Ti-dominated phase transformation and twinning at lower angles. The change in the stress-strain slope during initial compression reflects how rotation alters the resolved shear stress and activates different slip systems. Overall, the study provides valuable insights into the role of bimetal interfaces in controlling plasticity initiation and early deformation pathways for Al/Ti under extreme loading conditions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Mediation of Colloidal Encounter Dynamics by Surface Roughness

Rigorous understanding on the self-assembly of colloidal nanocrystals is crucial to develop tailored nanostructured materials for energy storage, sensing, and optical fields. Despite extensive studies on the self-assembly, a mechanistic understanding of self-assembly under an external field still remains an ongoing challenge. Here, in this work, we used optical tweezers that impose an external attractive force field, resulting in the self-assembly of alpha-phase sodium yttrium fluoride nanocrystals. The dynamic force that is strongly dependent on the surface roughness of the nanocrystals is shown to be a decisive factor for a direct contact between the nanocrystals, manifested by the roughness-dependent hydrodynamic resistivity and Langevin dynamic simulations. Our study provides direct evidence that the role of dynamics is equally important in understanding the self-assembly, which has been rarely observed in the self-assembly in contrast with many studies on the equilibrium forces. These results may have further impact in other fields, such as having explanatory power for the probability of nonclassical crystal growth or the structure of viral spike proteins that affect the probability of viruses binding with cells.

Felsted, Robert G. [Univ. of Washington, Seattle,