Effect of Specimen Thickness on Fracture Toughness and Plane Stress to Plane Strain Transition in Medium-Density Polyethylene
This study investigates the effect of specimen thickness on fracture toughness and the transition from plane stress to plane strain conditions in Medium-Density Polyethylene (MDPE) using Single Edge Notched Bend (SENB) specimens. Three thickness groups (7.5 mm, 9.0 mm, and 12.1 mm) were tested following ASTM D5045 protocol. Conditional stress intensity factors (KQ) increased from 2.2 MPavm to 2.8 MPavm with increasing thickness, demonstrating significant size dependency. Confocal microscopy revealed a 34% reduction in maximum crack tip opening displacement (CTOD) from 0.478 mm to 0.314 mm as thickness increased, with plastic zone lateral extent decreasing by 32%. This quantitative evidence validates Irwin's theoretical prediction of plastic zone size transition from plane stress r_y˜ (1/2p) (K_I/s_y )^2 to plane strain conditions r_y˜ (1/6p) (K_I/s_y )^2.Scanning electron microscopy confirmed progressive suppression of shear lips and evolution from ductile tearing with extensive polymer chain drawing in thin specimens to localized crazing in thick specimens. Despite all specimens satisfying the ASTM D5045 criterion (B = 2.5(KQ/s_y )^2 ) ,residual shear lips persisted even in the thickest specimens, demonstrating that nominal size requirements alone are insufficient for achieving complete plane strain conditions in highly ductile polymers. The findings emphasize the necessity of integrated analytical and morphological assessment for valid fracture toughness characterization, with critical implications for life assessment and integrity prediction in thick-section polymer components such as natural gas distribution pipelines.