Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “green gap”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Solutions to Droop and the Green Gap by Novel Carrier Injection

Long-wavelength (green, yellow, red) visible light-emitting diodes (LEDs) have historically been inefficient compared to blue light-emitters in the III-nitrides. This is due to many factors, including poor material quality due to the low growth temperatures required for high Incomposition InGaN quantum wells (QWs), and the polar nature of the III-nitride crystal structure. Spontaneous and piezoelectric polarization in the III-nitrides causes enhanced quantum-confined Stark effect (QCSE), which spatially separates electrons and holes and reduces radiative recombination (ie: light output) from the devices. Polarization in the crystal also induces additional potential barriers that electrons and holes must cross over before entering the QWs where they can recombine to emit light. Both of these polarization effects worsen as emission wavelength increases, making blue III-nitride LEDs are the most efficient and red III-nitride LEDs the least efficient. The focus of this project has been solving the latter polarization-related issue through the implementation of V-defects in long wavelength LEDs. V-defects are morphological defects which are commonly observed in c-plane III-nitrides. They are observed as hexagonal pyramid-shaped depressions on the c-plane surface, with six semipolar sidewalls. They typically form at the apex of threading dislocations (TDs) under conditions of kinetically-limited growth and low growth-temperature. They were initially thought to be detrimental to LED performance and much early work focused on eliminating them entirely from III-nitride devices. However, over the past decade work has emerged that indicate that they can improve LED performance by allowing electrons and holes to bypass the polarization-induced barriers present in the c-plane and directly enter the QWs of an LED. This is due to the semipolar nature of the V-defect sidewall: these sidewalls are thin and lack the polarization-induced barriers which prevent carriers easily moving between layers. V-defects have since been determined to be an efficient avenue by which to inject electrons and holes into the c-plane QWs where they can recombine to emit light. Throughout this project we have explored lateral injection through a variety of methods: simulation (Task 2), epitaxial growth of V-defect and non-V-defect LEDs (Tasks 1, 3, 4, 5, 6), and advanced characterization methods (Task 7). All tasks have been completed. A description of each task completed follows from this section.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

High Performance Green LEDs for Solid State Lighting

The development of white LEDs for solid state lighting (SSL) has been driven in recent years by phosphor converted LEDs (pc-LEDs). However, losses (known as Stokes’ losses) between the blue pump LED and phosphor impose a fundamental efficiency limit of ~300 lm/W on pc-LEDs. White light can also be generated from color mixed LEDs (cm-LEDs), which employ red, green, blue, and amber LEDs and have a fundamental efficiency limit of ~400 lm/W. Efficient group III-nitride materials are used for the blue LED, while efficient group III-phosphide materials are used for the red LED component. Currently, the poor efficiency of green and amber LEDs (i.e. the “green gap”) is the primary limitation for cm-LEDs. Relative to nitride-based blue LEDs, green and amber nitride LEDs suffer from lower radiative recombination rates and higher nonradiative recombination rates, which ultimately lead to reduced internal quantum efficiency (IQE). The IQE represents the portion of all electron-hole recombination events that result in a photon. In addition, long-wavelength LEDs have lower electrical efficiency (EE) compared to their blue counterparts. Addressing the green gap, would ultimately enable cm-LEDs that rival or exceed the performance of pc-LEDs. Our project focused on III-nitride materials growth and characterization, device fabrication and testing, and semiconductor physics to understand efficiency limitations of green LEDs and develop solutions to these challenges. Insights gained during our research has led to novel long-wavelength LED designs which will enable efficient solid-state lighting.

30 DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION↗

Green Light Emitting Diodes for the Ultimate Solid-state Lighting

Light-emitting diodes (LEDs), in particular InGaN-based LED devices, have achieved remarkable success in solid-state lighting, contributing to 25% of energy savings already. However, more than two thirds of the electricity is still lost as heat in current white LEDs today. Furthermore, expected population growth and increasing demand for lighting necessitate a more efficient approach, which can only be realized by solving the issue of the green gap (i.e., the inefficiency of the state-of-the-art green LEDs). This green gap is a fundamentally limiting issue in conventional hexagonal nitride LEDs, leading to 19% wall-plug efficiency (WPE) at 100 A/cm 2 , while the department of energy goal is 30% (in 2025) and 55% (in 2035).

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Unexpected origin of the quantum efficiency reduction in long-wavelength (In,Ga)⁢N light-emitting diodes

Differential carrier lifetime (DCL) measurements were performed on c-plane In 𝑥 ⁢Ga 1−𝑥⁢ N/Ga⁢N single-quantum-well (QW) light-emitting diodes (LEDs) with varying indium-content QWs (x = 13.5%, 16%, 22%), emitting with violet, blue, and green wavelengths. The recombination lifetimes of LEDs were found to increase with increasing indium composition, resulting in increased carrier densities n measured by DCL. Extraction of the A coefficients, which are assumed to not vary with n, and of the effective B(n) and C(n) coefficients of the ABC model of the internal quantum efficiency (IQE) of QWs showed no significant changes in the A coefficient with increasing indium content [In] in the In 𝑥 ⁢Ga 1−𝑥 ⁢N QW, and a reduction in the B(n) and C(n) coefficients with increasing [In]. When looking at the Shockley-Read-Hall (SRH) recombination rate An, the radiative recombination rate B(n)𝑛 2 , and the Auger-Meitner (AM) recombination rate C(n)𝑛 3 , we observed that at any given n, the SRH rate is the same for the three [In] measured, while the radiative rate decreases (by up to approximately 9 times) and the AM rate decreases (by up to approximately 7 times) with increasing indium content. This shows that the larger reduction in radiative recombination rates relative to nonradiative recombination rates with increasing [In] is the largest contributor to the decreased quantum efficiencies of LEDs (the “green gap”) at any given n. While some of the reduction in the effective recombination coefficients B(n) and C(n) can be explained by the reduced wave-function overlaps of the QW with increasing indium content, the larger reduction of B(n) relative to C(n) motivates further study of the intrinsic recombination coefficients 𝐵 0 and 𝐶 0 of bulk In 𝑥 ⁢Ga 1−𝑥 ⁢N alloys and how they are related to the effective recombination coefficients B(n) and C(n) in QWs. The relative contributions of nonradiative recombination are enhanced at any given current density due to the sublinear relationship between the carrier density n and the current density. Thus, the solution to the green gap, up to any intrinsic limitations set by the indium content of the QW, from an IQE perspective, requires the design of long-wavelength (In,Ga)⁢N LEDs with improved wave-function overlaps that can operate with a lower carrier density at any given current density.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Efficiency Improvement Progress in Green, Yellow and Red III Nitride LEDs

Large improvements in the efficiencies of visible light emitting diodes (LEDs) have been realized over the last decade. Extending the range of wavelengths over which efficient emission can be realized continues to be a goal of active research. Efficiency droop refers to a non-thermal decrease in internal quantum efficiency with increasing current density that affects III-nitride LEDs in general, but more severely those with longer emission wavelengths. The so-called green gap is mainly related to the wavelength dependence of efficiency droop. The peak EQE in commercial green LEDs exceeds 60% but corresponds to a current density that is an order of magnitude lower than required for applications. In this presentation, we will review some of the underlying physics that contribute to the wavelength dependence of droop. We will discuss some challenges in the development of long wavelength III-nitride LEDs and possible strategies to mitigate efficiency droop based on the understanding that nonradiative Auger recombination is the root cause. One general strategy is to engineer the multi-quantum well active region to minimize the average carrier density. Another approach is to design wells with a more favorable balance between the radiative and Auger coefficients. Finally, we will present the current status of the performance of green, yellow and red III-Nitride LEDs.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Demonstration of multi-active region p-down green LEDs with high quantum efficiency

Abstract Longer wavelength emitters such as green LEDs display a pronounced efficiency drop at higher current densities, resulting in relatively low wall-plug efficiency (WPE). Multi-active region approach can improve the WPE significantly and tackle the “green gap” challenge. This work reports multi-active region p-down LEDs with high external efficiency operating entirely in the green wavelength. Devices were developed using p-down topology, where the PN junction is oriented such that electric fields from depletion and built-in polarization dipoles are aligned. Ga-polar multi-active region green LEDs with excellent voltage and external quantum efficiency scaling, and significantly higher WPE is demonstrated in this work.

Physics↗

Improving luminescence response in ZnGeN 2 /GaN superlattices: defect reduction through composition control

Abstract Color-mixed (cm) light-emitting diodes (LEDs) are theoretically the most efficient white light emitters, projected to improve white light luminous efficacy by 34% compared to incumbent phosphor converted LEDs. Since white light technology is pervasive and essential, small improvements in LED technology can result in energy savings. However, cm-LEDs are not yet realized due to poor efficacy in green and amber emitting materials, a spectral region colloquially referred to as the Green Gap. ZnGeN 2 is nearly isostructural and closely lattice-matched to GaN and can be heteroepitaxially integrated with existing GaN devices; ZnGeN 2 /GaN hybrid structures are theorized to emit green (~530 nn) light with a spontaneous emission rate 4.6–4.9 times higher than traditional InGaN LEDs when incorporated into III-N LED structures. In this report we demonstrate the molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) growth of GaN and ZnGeN 2 superlattices, an important step towards realizing multiple quantum well structures required for efficient LEDs. Elemental analysis, including atom probe tomography, shows that Ga and Ge are observed in both ZnGeN 2 and GaN layers, degrading the structural uniformity. The lack of elemental abruptness also leads to increased defect luminescence and reabsorption of band edge luminescence. The source of unintentional Ga distributed throughout the ZnGeN 2 layers was identified as excess flux escaping from around the closed MBE shutter. The source of unintentional Ge, which tended to incorporate as a single delta-doped layer in GaN, was identified as Ge riding along the cyclical metal-rich Ga adlayer used for high quality GaN, incorporating during subsequent nitrogen-rich growth step. Modifying the growth strategy results in improved structural quality, elemental abruptness, and luminescence response. This realization of structurally and elementally abrupt interfaces demonstrates the potential of heteroepitaxially integrated binary and ternary nitrides for energy-relevant devices.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Carrier dynamics in blue, cyan, and green InGaN/GaN LEDs measured by small-signal electroluminescence

We study the carrier dynamics for c-plane InGaN/GaN light-emitting diodes (LEDs) with various emission wavelengths near the green gap using a small-signal electroluminescence method. The LEDs were grown by Lumileds using state-of-the-art growth conditions. Radiative and non-radiative recombination rates are numerically separated, and the carrier recombination lifetime and carrier density are obtained. Experiment shows that the causes of efficiency reduction at longer wavelength in the present structures are injection efficiency decrease, radiative recombination rate decrease, and imbalance of the increase in Auger–Meitner and radiative terms due to the interplay between the carrier–current density relationship and the quantum-confined Stark effect (QCSE). Here, the effects of QCSE, phase-space filling, and the carrier–current density relationship on efficiency reduction at longer wavelengths are examined separately with experimental data and Schrödinger–Poisson calculations. In addition, we confirm the scaling law between C(n) and B(n) under electrical injection and find that the increase in carrier density at a given current density is the primary cause for lower radiative efficiency at high current density in longer wavelength LEDs. Conversely, we do not observe a significant efficiency reduction at longer wavelengths from extrinsic material degradation.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Efficiency droop contributors in InGaN green light emitting diodes

Here, efficiency droop contributors (i.e., inherent Auger–Meitner recombination, polarization-induced effects, thermal effects, and light extraction) in InGaN green light emitting diodes (LEDs) are decoupled and quantified. First, a modified ABC model is developed, and external quantum efficiency measurements are taken under constant and pulsed currents (⁠ EQE Constant and EQE Pulsed ⁠, respectively). The LED internal quantum efficiency with and without thermal effects (⁠ IQE$^{ABC}_{Constant}$ and IQE$^{ABC}_{Pulsed}$⁠, respectively) is extracted using the modified model. Then, using Raman spectroscopy, the LED junction temperature is extracted. Finally, using the optical-electrical model (OEM), the polarization- and temperature-independent LED internal quantum efficiency (⁠ IQE OEM ) is calculated from the modified ABC model and the extracted junction temperature. By comparing external (⁠ EQE Constant ⁠) and the three internal quantum efficiencies (⁠ IQE$^{ABC}_{Constant}$, IQE$^{ABC}_{Pulsed}$⁠, and IQE OEM ), the impacts of inherent Auger–Meitner recombination, polarization-induced effects, thermal effects, and light extraction on the efficiency droop are decoupled and quantified. It is found that inherent Auger–Meitner recombination-induced droop is approximately 49% of the total efficiency droop in commercial green LEDs, while polarization-induced effects contribute about 35%, and thermal droop accounts for nearly 16%. Lastly, these findings suggest, to quash the green gap, it is critical to search for materials and device designs with low inherent Auger–Meitner coefficients and polarization fields, respectively.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Carrier Dynamics of Polar, Semipolar, and Nonpolar InGaN/GaN LEDs Measured by Small-Signal Electroluminescence

The carrier dynamics in InGaN/GaN light-emitting diodes (LEDs) are directly tied to their efficiency and maximum modulation speed, which are important metrics for solid-state lighting, displays, and optical communication. In this work, we measure the carrier dynamics of a variety of InGaN/GaN LEDs using small-signal electroluminescence methods [1]. A rate equation approach and associated small-signal circuit are used to model carrier injection, recombination in the active region, recombination in the cladding regions, and carrier escape. The model is fit to the measured optical frequency response (S21) and input impedance (S11) of the LEDs to extract the various carrier lifetimes, the carrier density, and the radiative and non-radiative recombination rates. We specifically study planar nonpolar and semipolar LEDs, which show record-high modulation speeds for III-nitride LEDs and present the modulation characteristics of core-shell nanowire-based LEDs. The planar nonpolar m-plane ($101\bar{0}$) micro-LEDs achieve a record-high -3dB modulation bandwidth for a III-nitride LED of 1.5 GHz [2]. The -3dB response of an electrically injected nanowire-based micro-LED with nonpolar facets is also reported, showing a -3dB bandwidth of 1.2 GHz [3]. The high speed is attributed to the shorter carrier lifetime associated with the nonpolar orientation. We also study the carrier dynamics in semipolar ($20\bar{2}\bar{1}$) LEDs for various temperatures [4]. Finally, we present carrier dynamics measurements on commercial-grade c-plane epitaxy for various active region designs, including a wavelength series and a growth quality series. The wavelength series offers insight into the contributions of the quantum confined Stark effect (QCSE) and InGaN material quality on the green gap [5]. The growth quality series investigates the role of non-radiative centers on the LED performance. Extraction of the carrier dynamics using small-signal electroluminescence offers insight into the factors limiting the efficiency and high-speed performance of III-nitride emitters and can be leveraged to ultimately improve the devices.

LEDs, InGaN, electroluminescence, bandwidth, modul↗

Carrier Dynamics of Polar, Semipolar, and Nonpolar InGaN/GaN LEDs Measured by Small-Signal Electroluminescence

The carrier dynamics in InGaN/GaN LEDs are directly tied to their efficiency and maximum modulation speed, which are important metrics for solid-state lighting, displays, and optical communication. We measure the carrier dynamics of nonpolar, semipolar, and commercial c-plane InGaN/GaN LEDs using small-signal electroluminescence methods. Rate equations and a small-signal circuit are used to model the carrier dynamics. The model is fit to the optical frequency response and input impedance of the LEDs to extract the carrier lifetimes and the recombination rates. The results offer insight into the underlying causes of efficiency droop and the green gap, and inform device design strategies.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Improving the efficiency of GaP LED's which emit green light

A study of techniques for preparing n-type material and junctions which yield the most consistent high diode efficiency values high lighted the role that Ga vacancies and/or associated defects play in reducing the green luminescent efficiency of n-type GaP. A useful method for obtaining good quality material was developed. It is shown that junction formation at high temperatures in a process where the n to p transition occurs without removing the substrate from the furnace yields devices superior to those obtained by diffusion or double epitaxy in the conventional manner previously used for GaP junction formation.

Ladany, I.↗

NASA 2018 Green Propulsion Roadmap

The Green Propulsion Working Group (GPWG) is a technical guidance working group formed April 2017 under the Agency's Capability Leadership Team The GPWG was tasked with recommending an agency road map and providing guidance to NASA on green propulsion technology development and infusion The GPWG's efforts focus on ionic liquid propellants and related technologies The GPWG was chartered with three representatives from NASA Centers currently exploring green propulsion technologies As other Centers may explore programs that utilize green propulsion, membership of the working group can be expanded to include more interested parties Working group also solicits and coordinates with other government agencies (e.g. AFRL, MDA) In 2015, JANNAF hosted a Technical Interchange Meeting (TIM) on Green Monopropellant Alternatives to Hydrazine (GMAH) Included both Government and non-Government contributions on the State-of-the-Art in Green Propulsion Technology Following the TIM, a Government-only session (USAF/AFRL/NASA/MDA/DLA) reviewed and identified remaining technical gaps in Green Propulsion In 2016, an inter-agency team (AFRL/NASA/MDA) worked together to develop an informal inter-agency "roadmap" based on the outcome of the TIM Approach consisted of near-term, mid-term, and long-term technology advancement areas, approaching incrementally larger thrust classes The NASA Green Propulsion Working Group reviewed the work of the 2016 Inter-Agency Working Group, and concurs that the identified technical gaps and technology development areas are still relevant and necessary to see green propulsion technology advanced The GPWG recommends the 2016 roadmap be adopted as baseline for NASA needs, with some additions The focus of the 2016 inter-agency roadmap was primarily on the thruster technology. The Agency must also invest in understanding the broader propulsion system-level technology gaps in parallel. Timeframes are considered suggested from a priority standpoint, but are also flexible as some efforts will need to occur in the nearer term or concurrently in order to meet specific mission requirements The GPWG developed 2018 roadmap breaks down the technology development goals into Technology Development Areas (TDA's), and identifies the near-, mid, and long-term sub-goals within those areas. Those TDA's are: Thruster Hardware Development Modeling & Tools Development Materials Properties and Compatibility Propellant Development.

Cavender, Dan↗

A novel xylosylated fucoglucuronan in Penium reveals structural parallels to rhamnogalacturonan-I and its broad evolutionary footprint in lower plants

Green algae inhabit aquatic environments across the planet and play a crucial role in sustaining the global ecosystem. Ancestors of some Charophytes adapted to terrestrial conditions and eventually evolved into land plants. Extant green algae have inherited traits from their ancestors and evolved into their current morphological and chemical forms, as reflected by their cell walls with distinct shapes and compositions. To illuminate the evolution of plant cell walls and bridge the gap between green algae and land plants, we investigated the charophyte Penium margaritaceum, a close relative of terrestrial plants. We discovered a previously unknown polysaccharide in both its culture medium and cell wall. This polysaccharide, termed xylosylated fucoglucuronan (XFG), possesses a rhamnogalacturonan-I (RG-I)-like backbone composed of repeating [-3-α-Fucp-(1,4)-α-GlcpA-] disaccharides that are extensively xylosylated and acetylated. Surveying approximately 20 non-vascular plants revealed that XFG and RG-I (or related structures) first emerge in certain Chlorophyceae and subsequently co-occur throughout lineages along the evolutionary trajectory to bryophytes, thereby bridging aquatic green algae to early land plants. The striking structural parallels between XFG, RG-I, and ulvan suggest a shared evolutionary origin, offering new insight into how plant cell walls adapted during the transition from marine to freshwater environments and ultimately to land.

Algae↗

Monte Carlo Explicitly Correlated Second-Order Many-Body Green’s Function Calculations of Semiconductor Band Gaps

A systematically converging series of ab initio, post-density-functional, size-consistent, electron-correlated approximations is desired for predictive computing of felectronic band structures of insulating, semiconducting, and metallic solids. A series that meets all of these desiderata (except the applicability to metals) is ab initio many-body Green's function theory based on Gaussian-type-orbital (GTO) basis sets. Here, its leading-order approximation, the second-order Green's function (GF2) method in the diagonal and frequency-independent approximations with the aug-cc-pVDZ basis set, is applied to the fundamental band gaps of three semiconductors (diamond, silicon, and silicon carbide in the zincblende structure) using cluster models. Corrections are made to the basis-set-incompleteness errors by the explicit-correlation (F12) ansatz (GF2-F12) for the valence band edges. The crystals are modeled as surface-passivated clusters of increasing sizes, whose wave functions are expanded by up to 2709 GTO basis functions. Immense computational costs of these calculations are overcome by the highly scalable stochastic algorithm of the Monte Carlo GF2-F12 method, whose operation cost per state increases only as a cubic power of system size, which has a tiny memory footprint and easily achieves near-perfect parallel efficiency on thousands of CPUs or on hundreds of GPUs. The correlated, F12-corrected highest-occupied and lowest-unoccupied molecular-orbital energy (HOMO-LUMO) gap is 5.78 ± 0.07 eV for C 87 H 76 as compared with the experimental value of the fundamental (indirect) band gap of bulk diamond at 5.48 eV. The correlated, F12-corrected HOMO-LUMO gaps for Si 75 H 76 and Si 32 C 43 H 76 are 2.56 ± 0.15 eV and 3.50 ± 0.12 eV, respectively, which are expected to decrease further with increasing cluster sizes. As a result, the experimental fundamental (indirect) band gaps of bulk silicon and silicon carbide are 1.17 eV and 2.42 eV, respectively.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Generation of shock trains in free liquid jets with a nanosecond green laser

Shock wave trains in liquid jets were previously generated only by ablation with femtosecond x-ray lasers. Here we show that shock trains in water microjets can be also generated using nanosecond green laser pulses with 1- to 10-mJ energy. Furthermore, the ablation of 15-, 20-, 30-, and 70-μm water microjets opened a gap in the jets and launched an initial shock wave. Fully developed shock trains were observed in the 30- and 70-μm jets up to 250-ns delays, and these trains were also transmitted inside the nozzles. A few tens of nanoseconds after the pulse, the shock dynamics and its pressure became similar to the ones generated by x-ray lasers, with a more rapid pressure decay in thinner jets. At time delays exceeding 100 ns in the 30-μm jets, the leading shock pressure stabilized to an approximately constant pressure of 40 MPa. The energy density deposited in the jets was estimated at 30 MJ/cm 3 by comparing the jet gaps in the green and x-ray laser experiments, and matched previous estimates for optical ablation in water. Here, the pressure decay in the 30-μm jets was modeled based on the pressure decay observed in x-ray laser experiments.

74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗

Electronic characterization of defects in narrow gap semiconductors

We use a Green's function technique to calculate the position of deep defects in narrow gap semiconductors. We consider substitutional (including antisite), vacancy, and interstitial (self and foreign) deep defects. We also use perturbation theory to look at the effect of nonparabolic bands on shallow defect energies and find nonparabolicity can increase the binding by 10 percent or so. We consider mercury cadmium telluride (MCT), mercury zinc telluride (MZT), and mercury zinc selenide (MZS). For substitutional and interstitial defects we look at the situation with and without relaxation. For substitutional impurities in MCT, MZT, and MZS, we consider x (the concentration of Cd or Zn) in the range 0.1 less than x less than 0.3 and also consider appropriate x so E(sub g) = 0.1 eV for each of the three compounds. We consider several cation site s-like deep levels and anion site p-like levels. For E(sub g) = 0.1 eV, we also consider the effects of relaxation. Similar comments apply to the interstitial deep levels whereas no relaxation is considered for the ideal vacancy model. Relaxation effects can be greater for the interstitial than the substitutional cases. Specific results are given in figures and tables and comparison to experiment is made in a limited number of cases. We find, for example, that I, Se, S, Rn, and N are possible cation site, s-like deep levels in MCT and Zn and Mg are for anion site, p-like levels (both levels for substitutional cases). The corresponding cation and anion site levels for interstitial deep defects are (Au, Ag, Hg, Cd, Cu, Zn) and (N, Ar, O, F). For the substitutional cases we have some examples of relaxation moving the levels into the band gap, whereas for the interstitial case we have examples where relaxation moves it out of the band gap. Future work involves calculating the effects of charge state interaction and seeing the effect of relaxation on vacancy levels.

Patterson, James D.↗