Engineering PapersSearch

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “RMP”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Access and limits of RMP ELM suppression with n = 1 fields in DIII-D

This work reports on DIII-D experiments aimed at extending resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) suppression of edge localized modes (ELMs) to n = 1 fields, where n is the toroidal mode number. Modeling of the 3D ideal MHD plasma response to the RMPs using the GPEC code is used to quantify edge and core resonant fluxes, guiding experimental strategies to increase plasma resilience against core error field penetration, optimize multicoil phasing, and explore higher q 95 operation. In DIII-D, ELM mitigation is regularly observed across a wide range of n = 1 RMP scenarios. A ∼100 ms phase of complete ELM suppression was achieved at q 95 ∼ 3.9 using an odd-parity coil configuration. The suppressed phase exhibited clear signatures of RMP ELM suppression, including the elimination of Dα spikes, increased pedestal rotation, enhanced magnetic response, and elevated broadband density turbulence. An optimized coil configuration for edge-to-core resonant flux did show increased edge resonance indicated by increased density pumpout, but did not yield RMP ELM suppression. At q 95 ∼ 5.1, a bifurcation to a grassy-like ELM regime occurred, while large type-I ELMs persisted. These results demonstrate progress in experimental access to n = 1 RMP ELM suppression in DIII-D, motivating further study for robust access. This work also highlights the potential role of 3D edge stability as well as rational surface alignment in RMP ELM suppression access, which has important implications for the use of low-n RMPs in future reactor-scale devices.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

Extending the operational boundaries of RMP-ELM suppression with optimized 3D field control

The use of 3D magnetic fields is one of the promising approaches to control edge localized modes (ELMs), and ITER has plans to utilize a flexible 3D coil set for ELM suppression using 3D fields. This study focuses on optimizing the 3D field spectrum to expand the operational window for n = 1 resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) ELM suppression in KSTAR. The optimized n = 1 RMP effectively suppresses ELMs throughout the entire H-mode discharge, including the first ELM crash, while avoiding the onset of disruptive locked modes in low-density L-mode plasmas. The predicted suppression window aligns well with experimental data, highlighting the challenges and solutions of using n = 1 RMP at low densities. Moreover, the optimization successfully achieved n = 1 RMP ELM suppression for the first time in ITER-relevant q 95 and shaping conditions, including cases with q95 as low as 3.6, as well as other q 95 and shape configurations. This highlights the importance and utility of 3D coil optimization while emphasizing the potential of long-wavelength low-n RMP, which will be valuable for ex-vessel coils designed to avoid complications of nuclear degradation.

3D magnetic field control

Predicted thresholds for RMP ELM suppression access in double-null configurations

Modeling of DIII-D plasmas spanning shapes from single to double-null (DN) reveals new insights into the nature of resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) conditions necessary for edge-localized mode (ELM) suppression. The suppression of ELMs with RMPs has proven difficult in DN configurations, where no device has thus far reported any hints of suppression. Modeling using the GPEC code finds a reduced high-field side response closer to DN shaping. The resulting synthetic diagnostic measurements are consistent with what has been observed in experiments on DIII-D, validating the plasma response model in this regime. While common metrics for suppression do not illustrate a clear distinction between single-null (SN) and DN cases, the pedestal top resonant field does show a ∼20% decrease at DN shaping in modeling. Field penetration is assessed using linear tearing theory, which demonstrates a lack of sufficient pedestal top resonant flux in the DN shape, requiring at least 1.5 × greater RMP coil currents than what was used in experiment. Analysis from drift kinetic simulations further indicate up to 2 × larger critical island widths are required at the pedestal top for tearing mode growth compared to SN cases. Effective island widths inferred from 3D ideal MHD are also analyzed, where maximum widths in lab coordinates indicate a threshold of ∼18–24× the ion gyroradius for sufficient profile flattening for ELM suppression. These results suggest that ELM suppression may be possible in DN with sufficiently large RMP coil amplitude. Future prospects of achieving RMP ELM suppression in the DN configuration may involve going to lower triangularity, which is also highlighted in this work.

RMP ELM suppression

Drift-kinetic effects of tungsten on plasma response to RMP in ITER

Here, effects of high- Z ( Z is the particle charge number) tungsten impurity ions on the plasma response to the resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) field are numerically investigated for the ITER 15 MA baseline scenario, where the tungsten contribution to the plasma response is computed with a drift-kinetic model while the bulk thermal particle contributions follow the fluid approximation. The study yields three highlights: (i) the drift-kinetic contribution of the tungsten impurity exerts minor influence on the plasma response compared to that computed by the pure fluid model without tungsten; (ii) a new figure of merit, based on the resonant spectrum perturbation at the plasma boundary surface, results in different optimal coil phasing compared to that previously obtained by maximizing the edge-peeling plasma response; (iii) the optimal $n = 3$ RMP (for edge localized mode (ELM) control, $n$ is the toroidal mode number) is found to induce a large tungsten particle influx near the plasma edge associated with the neoclassical toroidal viscosity. The study thus provides useful data on the compatibility of the full tungsten wall with RMP ELM control in ITER.

ITER

Low- n stability and plasma response to RMP in various STEP scenarios

The low-n (n is the toroidal mode number) magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) stability and plasma response are numerically investigated for various scenarios designed for STEP, that are relevant for the H-mode pedestal analysis. Control of the edge-localized modes (ELMs) with externally applied resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) is considered. Optimization of the ELM control coil current configuration, based on the computed plasma MHD response and well-established figures of merit validated on present-day experiments, finds reasonable robustness of a fixed coil phasing (for a given n-number) to control ELMs in all five STEP plasmas considered. Based on certain semi-empirical criteria, the required coil current to achieve ELM suppression is estimated to be about 10–20 kAt with the n = 1 or 2 RMP configuration and about 100–200 kAt for the n = 4 RMP. Systematic linear stability calculations are used to map out stability windows for the low-n kink-peeling modes, in terms of the ideal-wall location and variation of the edge safety factor q 95 with respect to the target design. The kink-peeling stability boundary is found to be generally sensitive to the q 95 variation, which has implications for achieving the quiescent H-mode regime in STEP. Full toroidal quasilinear initial-value simulations for these STEP plasmas find that generation of the edge-harmonic oscillations (EHOs) depends sensitively on the plasma scenario, the initial linear stability of the kink-peeling modes, the initial plasma toroidal flow and q 95 . In general, it is easier (more robust) to access the EHO-regime for two of the cases considered with smaller plasma volume and higher on-axis safety factor. Finally, quasilinear simulations find robust density pumpout due to applied RMPs in these STEP plasmas, but the effect on the plasma toroidal flow varies among different cases.

EHO

Real-time reconstruction and control of pedestal-top electron density using RMP and gas puff at KSTAR

We report the experimental results of controlling the pedestal-top electron density by applying resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) with in-vessel control coils and the main gas puff in the 2024-2025 KSTAR experimental campaign. The density is reconstructed using a parameterized $ψ_N$ grid and five channels of line-averaged density measured by the two-colored interferometer (TCI). The reconstruction procedure is accelerated by deploying a multi-layer perceptron to run in approximately 120 µ s and is sufficiently fast for real-time control. A proportional-integral controller was adopted, with the controller gains estimated from the system identification procedure. The experimental results demonstrate that the developed controller can follow a dynamic target while exclusively using both actuators. The absolute percentage errors between the electron density at $ψ_N$ = 0.89 and the target were approximately 1.5% median and a 2.5% average, respectively. The developed controller can even lower the density by using the pump-out mechanism under RMP, and it can follow a more dynamic range of density targets than a single actuator controller. The developed controller will enable experimental scenario exploration within a shot by dynamically setting the density target or maintaining a constant electron density within a discharge.

EFIT

Error field measurements with rotating RMP fields for DIII-D H-mode

3D magnetic sensors are employed to identify the amplitude and toroidal phase of error fields (EF) by analyzing the torque balance for magnetic islands entrained by rotating resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) in DIII-D H-mode plasmas. This technique of torque balance allows for efficient error field identification, offering a valuable tool for scenario-specific and optimized error field compensation (EFC) and requires only magnetic diagnostics. The torque balance used in this work includes the contribution from electromagnetic torque due to error fields, wall response, RMP fields, and viscous. Results show that viscous torque plays a crucial role, particularly during locked modes and H-mode plasmas, ensuring accurate data fits with lower residuals. The torque balance technique reveals that the L- and H-mode plasmas have distinct EF configurations, and consistent with a model-based EF analysis including MHD response in IPEC and the SURFMN EF simulation. This technique shows great robustness in measuring the intrinsic EF amplitude regardless of its amplitude or toroidal phase. Repeated discharges with EFC disparities exhibit consistent results of intrinsic error field within a reasonable range near the “standard” error field compensation. Additionally, the use of a rotating n = 1 resonant magnetic perturbation offers the advantage of reducing disruption risks by entraining saturated magnetic islands. These findings are instrumental for optimizing EF correction in fusion devices, thereby enhancing tearing mode suppression and overall plasma stability.

3D magnetic sensors

Effects of plasma squareness on RMP response in MAST-U

The effect of the squareness of the plasma boundary shape on the plasma response to the applied n = 2 (n is the toroidal mode number) resonant magnetic perturbation, and consequently on controlling the edge-localized mode (ELM) in MAST-U in the double-null configuration, is numerically systematically investigated. The modeling is performed utilizing three different plasma response models: the single-fluid model, the two-fluid model and the magnetohydrodynamic-kinetic hybrid model. The effect of the plasma squareness on ELM control is found to depend on the equilbrium kinetic profiles. Fixing the equilibrium radial profiles to that from a recent MAST-U discharge, the experimental plasma shape is found to be close to optimal for ELM control in terms of squareness. The optimal coil phasing does not significantly vary with varying plasma squareness. These findings robustly hold with (i) two figures of merit (FoMs) defined for predicting the ELM control feasibility, and (ii) three plasma response models employed for evaluating these FoMs.

MAST-U

Gyrokinetic PIC Study on RMP Affected Neoclassical Transport in Toroidal Plasmas

In magnetically confined fusion plasmas, the breaking of ‘magnetic flux-surfaces’ due to resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) can generate magnetic islands and alter field topology to significantly impact plasma confinement and transport. Here, this work investigates the effect of magnetic islands on neoclassical radial energy transport within the core plasma of an analytic circular tokamak using the XGC-S global gyrokinetic particle-in-cell code. Findings from our simulations revealed substantial enhancements in electron neoclassical radial energy diffusivity in and around the islands, in addition to a newly observed two-peak structure at the O/X-points and outer island boundary in the electron diffusivity profile.

RMP

3D modeling of n = 1 RMP driven heat fluxes on the SPARC tokamak PFCs using HEAT

3D heat flux calculations at the lower outer divertor plate of SPARC using the HEAT code show that 3D fields generated from error field correction coils can lead to enhanced peak heat fluxes up to 15 times larger compared to the axisymmetric case. Previously employed to simulate axisymmetric heat flux on 3D plasma facing components, the HEAT code can now predict 3D heat flux generated by non-axisymmetric plasmas. This is achieved via a new HEAT module which leverages the 3D field line tracing capabilities of MAFOT starting from an M3D-C1 (MHD resistive code) perturbed equilibria. The resulting heat flux is assigned using the magnetic footprint and the heat flux layer model, an extension of the 2D heat flux model also known as the Eich, to 3D non-axisymmetric plasmas. For SPARC, the new capabilities of HEAT are used to calculate the 3D heat loads resulting from n = 1 perturbation fields (with n indicating the toroidal periodicity) applied through a toroidal array of six picture frame coils with different amplitude. The comparison with the unperturbed case shows significant changes in shape and intensity of the heat flux profile. The results show that the application of n = 1 3D field leads to a localized enhancement of the heat flux peak, influenced by the wetted area impacted by the magnetic footprint, and the appearance of a secondary heat flux peak, whose intensity depends on amplitude of the applied 3D field and toroidal location.

3D heat flux

Comparison of plasma response models for RMP effects on the divertor and scrape-off layer in KSTAR

Resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) are beneficial for control of edge localized modes (ELMs) in tokamaks. Nevertheless, a side effect of RMPs is the appearance of helical striations in the particle and heat loads onto divertor targets. The extent and field line connection of these striations is significantly altered by the plasma response to external perturbations. For an ELM suppressed high confinement (H-mode) plasma at KSTAR, magnetic footprints are computed by FLARE based on plasma response from GPEC, MARS-F, M3D-C1 and JOREK with substantial differences in the resulting footprints (from 2 cm to 14 cm). This is reflected in EMC3-EIRENE simulations of the resulting heat loads: it is found that either the peak value or the extent of the striations appears to be overestimated compared to infrared camera measurements. Reasonable agreement can only be achieved for the smallest footprint for lower input power and lower cross-field transport, or for higher upstream density and radiative power losses.

Frerichs, H. [Univ. of Wisconsin, Madison, WI (Uni

Conceptual design of ELM control coils for the TCABR tokamak

An upgrade of the Tokamak à Chauffage Alfvén Brésilien (TCABR) is being designed to make it capable of creating a well controlled environment where the impact of resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) fields on edge localised modes can be addressed over a wide range of (i) plasma shapes, (ii) divertor configurations, (iii) RMP coil geometries and (iv) perturbed magnetic field spectra. To this end, a unique set of in-vessel RMP coils is being designed and, in this work, their conceptual design is presented. This unique set of coils is composed of three toroidal arrays of coils on the low field side and three toroidal arrays of coils on the high field side. Each of these six toroidal arrays is composed of 18 coils thus allowing for the creation of RMP fields with toroidal mode numbers n ≤ 9 and with increased control of the poloidal mode number spectrum. To study dynamical effects of RMP fields of different toroidal mode numbers, all rotating simultaneously with different velocities, each of the 108 RMP coils will be powered independently by power supplies that can provide voltages of up to 4 kV and electric currents of up to 2 kA, with frequencies varying continuously from 0Hz up to 10kHz. A set of physical criteria were used to determine the optimal coil geometry and their respective number of turns to reduce the coil currents and voltages during operation with alternate current. Further, the conceptual design was carried out using both the vacuum approach (no plasma response) and the single-fluid response approach, which accounts for the response of a linear, single-fluid, visco-resistive plasma calculated using the M3D-C 1 code.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

Unified ELM Suppression on KSTAR and DIII-D via Adaptive Feedback Control Strategies

This paper reports on the extension of our amplitude-based resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) edge localized mode (ELM) controller to support phasing control (relative toroidal phases of RMP waveforms between rows of coils), multiple toroidal mode numbers, and new ‘jump’ and ‘probing’ strategies, all deployed on KSTAR and DIII-D. By treating the control algorithm as device-independent and adjusting only the real-time interfaces to sensors and power supplies, we have confirmed that the same finite state machine—based feedback logic can be ported between machines with minor modifications. In experiments using n = 2 RMPs on KSTAR and n = 3 on DIII-D, the controller successfully modulated RMP amplitudes in real time to sustain ELM suppression while minimizing confinement degradation. Phasing control broadened the suppression window, as it permitted the system to avoid locked-mode regions and safely access ELM-free conditions. A rotating RMP phasing scheme, integrated into the same framework, distributes divertor heat loads more uniformly, making it a promising strategy for protecting plasma-facing components during long discharges. New ‘jump’ and ‘probing’ techniques demonstrate the possibility for the controller to preempt imminent ELMs and refine the minimum required RMP amplitude without returning to ELMy conditions. Taken together, these upgrades enable extended ELM-free operation while mitigating confinement degradation, providing a practical framework for real-time ELM control in future high-performance tokamaks.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

X-point effects on the ideal MHD modes in tokamaks in the description of dual-poloidal-region safety factor

The flux coordinates with dual-region safety factor (q) in the poloidal direction are developed in this work. The X-point effects on the ideal MHD modes in tokamaks are then analyzed using this coordinate system. Since the X-point effects mainly affect the edge region, the modes localized at the tokamak edge are particularly examined. Two types of modes are studied. The first is related to the conventional peeling or peeling-ballooning modes. The mode existence aligned with the local magnetic field in the poloidally core region as observed experimentally is confirmed. The X points are shown to contribute to a stabilizing effect for the conventionally treated modes with the surface-averaged q and with the tokamak edge portion truncated. The other is the axisymmetric modes localized in the vicinity of X points, which can affect the cross-field-line transport near the X points. The existence of axisymmetric modes points to the possibility of applying a toroidally axisymmetric resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) in the X-point area for mitigating the edge localized modes, which can be an alternative to the current RMP design. The dual q description also has important implications for the existing non-axisymmetric RMP concept. It helps to understand why the RMP suppression of edge localized modes is difficult to achieve in the double-null tokamak configurations and points to the possibility of further improving the current RMP concept by considering the alignment to the local q.

Fourier analysis

Metrics and extrapolation of resonant magnetic perturbation thresholds for ELM suppression

This large database study of resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) edge localized mode (ELM) suppression thresholds in the AUG, DIII-D, EAST, and KSTAR tokamaks details the key strengths and weaknesses of RMP metrics. The RMP ELM suppression database used for this work contains plasma information at the time of transition from ELMing to ELM suppressed states where a clear experimental threshold is identified. The experimental threshold distributions are compared for five metrics: (1) the island overlap width, (2) pedestal top Chirikov overlap, (3) peeling edge displacement, (4) pedestal top resonant drive, and (5) edge dominant mode overlap. The distributions, the regularity of the dependence on RMP coil currents, and the sensitivities of a given metric to equilibrium reconstruction details are compared. The overlap metric proves to be a good compromise between including the appropriate plasma response physics and maintaining a numerical robustness. This quantity does not exhibit clear power-law scalings for projection, but machine learning can assist in predicting thresholds within the existing parameter ranges and providing uncertainty quantification of those predictions. Two new first-principles models, one utilizing a threshold from the non-linear Modified Rutherford equation evaluated at the pedestal top and one utilizing the SLAYER code to calculate the linear tearing threshold from torque balance, offer possible paths to extrapolation beyond the existing database parameter space.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

An overview of 3D field optimization for control of transport and edge instabilities on KSTAR

An international team from several laboratories and universities has made key advances over the last few years in the control of plasma transport and edge instabilities with applied 3D fields in the KSTAR tokamak to optimize long pulse operation scenarios. This overview begins with the optimization of both core and edge resonant magnetic perturbations (RMP) to improve fast ion confinement to avoid excessive limiter heat loads due to fast ion losses and successful modeling of the experimental results. Integrated and advanced plasma control techniques with machine learning (ML) and adaptive control were then used to optimize the 3D field spectrum in real-time to control edge localized modes (ELMs) while avoiding core locked modes that could disrupt the plasma. Accelerating the offline model of 3D fields with a surrogate ML model can optimize ELM suppression in the edge while limiting the impact of the applied RMP fields deeper in the plasma core in real-time. In addition, the impact of the 3D fields on the divertor heat load has been modeled and compared with experimental measurements. An analysis of a multi-machine database including KSTAR has been performed to better understand the metrics for the observed RMP thresholds for ELM suppression and the resulting plasma performance. Predictive modeling of the operational space for ELM suppression and density pumpout due to RMP has shown the importance of magnetic islands in the plasma edge and their impact on plasma turbulence. This research has culminated in the development of successful long pulse operational scenarios on KSTAR while attempting to overcome challenges of the new tungsten divertor.

3D fields

Effects of equilibrium pressure on plasma response to RMPs in a spherical tokamak

This study presents a comprehensive analysis of the equilibrium pressure on the plasma response to resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) in the spherical tokamak (ST) MAST-U, employing both single-fluid and MHD-kinetic hybrid models (implemented via the MARS-F/K codes). As a key finding, the study identifies two different pressure-driven eigenmodes, exhibiting Sturmian property, that affect the Troyon no-wall limits for the onset of the n = 1 and n = 2 ( n is the toroidal mode number) ideal external kink instabilities as well as the corresponding plasma response to the applied RMP. With increasing equilibrium pressure, the plasma response to RMPs is significantly enhanced in the ST plasma, particularly in the high-pressure regime where kinetic effects strongly stabilize the external kink instability. The Troyon no-wall limit divides the plasma response into two regions: well below the limit, the response amplitudes and trends (versus pressure) are similar between the fluid and kinetic models; as the equilibrium pressure approaches the Troyon limit, the kinetic model predicts significant amplification of the RMP field, up to 30 times for cases considered. A relatively weak dependence of the optimal coil phasing on the equilibrium pressure is computed in this ST plasma, similar to the trend obtained for the conventional aspect ratio devices. These findings underscore the importance of incorporating kinetic effects in accurate prediction of the plasma response to RMPs in high-pressure ST tokamak plasmas and provide a theoretical basis for optimizing RMP-based control of the edge-localized modes in future ST devices.

RMP

Impact of Resonant Magnetic Perturbations on the Toroidal Location of the Runaway Electron Final Loss Strike Point

It is demonstrated that the peak toroidal impact phase of the post-disruption runaway electrons (REs) can be varied shot-to-shot by means of applied static non-axisymmetric (3D) magnetic fields, or resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs). In the experiments, high-current (500 kA), purged RE plateaus (i.e. low impurity post-disruption plasmas with current carried completely by REs) were terminated on the DIII-D tokamak center post (CP). The global toroidal impact peak of the REs appears to be dominantly set by the toroidal phase of a wall-locked tearing mode, typically (m/n) = (2/1), but sometimes (m/n) = (3/2). In the absence of external RMP, the locked mode reliably locks close to a preferred toroidal phase Φ ≃ 75◦ probably set by intrinsic error fields. With applied RMP, the locked mode and RE impact phase is pushed to a new location. When the tearing mode is (m/n) = (2/1), the phase is well controlled and tracks the applied RMP phase, but in the case of an (m/n) = (3/2) tearing mode, the new phase location is not well controlled. These results could have application in ITER and other fusion power plant (FPP) - sized tokamaks as a method for spreading disruption first wall damage from REs

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY