Quantitative investigation of gas flow, powder-gas interaction, and powder behavior under different ambient pressure levels in laser powder bed fusion
Not Available
Li, Xuxiao (ORCID:0000000323293435)↗
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Results for “Powder”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Electrostatic powder spreading for metal powder bed fusion applications
Typical powder bed fusion processes spread each layer of powder by pushing it across the build area with a spreader bar or roller. While simple, these methods require good flowing powder and do not have the ability to place more than one powder type per layer. This naturally limits the ability to incorporate more than one material onto each powder layer in powder bed additive manufacturing processes. Here we demonstrate electrostatic powder spreading, a method to deposit a powder layer without mechanical contact with the previous layers. Electrostatic powder spreading (ESPS) uses an electric field formed between a powder container and a counter electrode to move powder particles from the container to the powder bed. We show that the rate at which powder is deposited can be controlled by adjusting the strength of the electric field. Correspondingly, the deposited layer thickness is controlled by the strength of the electric field and the recoating speed. To demonstrate the feasibility of ESPS for laser powder bed fusion powder spreading, nearly fully dense (> 99.8%) coupons were built in a commercial L-PBF machine using the ESPS setup. Finally, we achieve 2D patterning of a single layer by using an array of electrodes and switching the applied electric field on and off. ESPS represents a method to produce an arbitrary patterned multi-material powder bed without complicated powder removal steps and easy implementation into existing L-PBF machines. Furthermore, ESPS presents an opportunity to build parts with 3D gradients in material properties.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Quantifying Trapped Powder in Electron Beam Powder Bed Fusion
Abstract Electron beam powder bed fusion (PBF-EB) shows great potential for manufacturing complex parts including those with internal cavities for heat exchanger, manifold systems, or energy absorption purposes. PBF-EB allows for the manufacture of channel geometries without the need for support structures. Due to the nature of the powder spreading process, powder feedstock is often trapped in intentionally manufactured cavities. This trapped powder can often be difficult to remove and can disturb the intended flow of fluid through the cavity or damage downstream components in its use case. These trapped powder particles present a risk of contamination and component failure if not completely evacuated. Ti6Al4V is a choice material for aerospace applications due to its high strength to weight ratio and its composition as a nonferrous metal; however, in weight sensitive applications excess entrapped powders or powders loosely attached to the surface could cause undesirable weight increases. The inherent spreading process of PBF-EB is different than laser powder bed fusion (PBF-LB) in its operational temperature, sintering. In addition, PBF-EB is less commonly studied in literature compared to its PBF-LB counterpart, and as a result the complexity of the semi-sintered powder and its spreading behavior are not well understood. Prior work has investigated the difficulty in removing trapped powder from PBF-EB, but these studies do not address how to quantify the amount of trapped powder in the cavity. Thus, an accurate method to measure the amount of trapped powder in the cavity must be investigated. In this work, Ti6Al4V coupons were manufactured with horizontal and vertical cavities of three different sizes. Archimedes testing allows for the determination of density differences caused by porosity and trapped powders by measuring mass and volumetric dispersion. Computed tomography (CT) is well suited for segmenting the internal structure and features of a part and has been studied for applications including voids, porosity, and dross. Thus, CT was explored as a method for evaluating trapped powder content in this work. The volumetric representation of the segmentation of the reconstructed CT volume can vary greatly depending on the input filter and thresholding methods. In this study, four different types of segmentation approaches were evaluated to determine the best approach for segmenting the volume as compared to an operator labeled ground truth. The percentage density results from the Archimedes testing were compared to the volumetric percent density from the computed tomography approach. Differences in packing density between two different internal channel features were investigated. Overall, this work sought to validate the use of computed tomography for the detection of trapped powders and present a framework for volumetric segmentation.
Johnstone, Brian↗
Variations in GARS powder microstructure as a function of powder chemistry and particle size
The properties of metal produced through powder metallurgy depends on the feedstock used. Powders produced via gas atomization reaction synthesis (GARS) are used to produce oxide dispersion strengthened alloys. The desired powder size range can vary for each consolidation technique. However, powder microstructure also can vary with powder particle size, which in turn can impact the microstructure and properties of the consolidated parts. In this study, GARS powders are characterized via inductively coupled plasma mass spectroscopy, inert gas fusion, and high-resolution x-ray diffraction to determine variations in elemental and phase compositions. Transmission electron microscopy was used to understand microstructure variations as a function of chemistry and size. Across the three batches tested intermetallic content was 0.73–1.35 wt% in the 0-20 μm powder batch and increased to 2.46–3.80 wt% in the coarse 45-106 μm batch. Across all batches, volume percent of surface oxidation decreased with powder diameter, with volume percents within the range of 0.75–1.2 % across 10 μm powder particles, and below 0.4 % across coarse powder particles approximately 100 μm in diameter. These observations were supported by inert gas fusion measurements. However, the oxide layer was thicker in coarse powder particles due to a slower cooling rate. Increasing oxygen content in atomization gas to 2000 ppm and adding yttrium increased both the surface oxidation content and yttrium intermetallic content. Lastly, intermetallic phases within the powder coarsened with powder size. Intermetallic morphology changed from fine spherical intermetallic and columnar dendritic growth to a cellular structure with finer spherical intermetallic, to coarse irregular intermetallic and intermetallic along grain boundaries as a result of slower cooling rate and solidification rate in coarse powder particles. Furthermore, the addition of zirconium does not appear to significantly change intermetallic morphology, but the composition changed from a Y-Fe rich intermetallic to a Y-Zr-Fe intermetallic.
42 ENGINEERING↗
A Simulated Evaluation of Powder Flowability Through a Partially Obstructed Consumable in Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition Systems
Abstract In the interest of continued industrialization of metal additive manufacturing in modern production environments, cost is often referenced as a primary deterrent to new adopters. Conventional economic models for additive systems, processes, and supply chains often focus on specific process applications with little generalizability, or they neglect significant costs associated with production such as machine maintenance and consumable part replacement. Compounding the latter issue are substantial knowledge gaps in consumable part wear characterization for additive and other convergent manufacturing systems. In coaxial blown powder directed energy deposition systems, gas atomized metal powder is wasted during material deposition at a rate that is partly dependent on present wear phenomena in a consumable nozzle housed in the cladding head assembly. The price and lead time required to replace the nozzle incentivizes its reuse even when visibly worn. Often this initiates a process quality decline in the form of underbuilt geometry and internal defects due to losses in powder catchment efficiency. While depositing H13 steel using a hybrid manufacturing machine tool equipped with such a deposition system, a unique partial clog with a bridge-like structure formed at the consumable nozzle exit when supporting argon gas flows failed mid-process. To further understand coaxial multi-phase powder flow in the event of support gas failure, a computational fluid dynamics simulation is tailored to relevant process parameters, H13 powder material profile, and machine operator observations collected after the incident. The resulting differences in powder flow compared to control gas flow parameters is presented and discussed. The powder flowability and performance of the clogged nozzle is then assessed by using an optical profilometer to extract the profile of the clog and recreate the clog geometry within the simulation environment. In past work this simulation has been experimentally validated for a 316L steel powder material profile and used specifically for analyzing powder stream geometry and catchment efficiency. After the initial powder flow characterization, the clog is removed, and the nozzle is reprofiled. After removing the obstructing clog, the newly unobstructed nozzle geometry, the original off the shelf nozzle geometry, and additional nozzle profiles exploring different consumable refurbishment strategies are reevaluated in the simulation. Powder catchment efficiency for all variant nozzle geometries and relevant flow variables are compared and discussed, along with potential mitigation strategies for optimizing powder flowability with worn consumables. This work expands on the known morphology of blown powder obstructions and wear defects present in consumable coaxial nozzles while discussing pragmatic simulation driven responses to unanticipated subsystem failure in hybrid manufacturing machining platforms.
DeWitte, Lisa↗
Investigation of Mechanical Properties of Parts Fabricated with Gas- and Water-Atomized 304L Stainless Steel Powder in the Laser Powder Bed Fusion Process
In this report the use of gas-atomized powder as the feedstock material for the Laser Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF) process is common in the Additive Manufacturing (AM) community. Although gas-atomization produces powder with high sphericity, its relatively expensive production cost is a downside for application in AM processes. Water atomization of powder may overcome this limitation due to its low cost relative to the gas-atomization process. In this work, gas- and water-atomized 304L stainless steel powders were morphologically characterized through Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM). The water-atomized powder had a wider particle size distribution and exhibited less sphericity. Measuring powder flowability using the Revolution Powder Analyzer (RPA) indicated that the water-atomized powder had less flowablility than the gas-atomized powder. Through examining the mechanical properties of L-PBF fabricated parts using tensile tests, the gas-atomized powder had significantly higher yield tensile strength and elongation than the water-atomized powder, however, their ultimate tensile strengths were not significantly different.
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Modeling powder spreadability in powder-based processes using the discrete element method
Powder-bed fusion (PBF) processes refer to a subset of Additive Manufacturing (AM) techniques where powder is spread on the build-plate before melting (by a laser or electron beam). While PBF processes are attractive due to their ability for realizing complex structures that are either difficult or impossible to create through conventional means, the parts fabricated with these techniques can exhibit defects such as pores, inclusions, and excessive surface roughness. To minimize these defects, much research has been dedicated towards process maturation by optimizing laser or electron beam parameters. However, these developmental efforts typically do not address the recoating process where achieving dense and uniform layers of powder is a necessity for ensuring process repeatability and part quality. While the recoating process can be studied through experimentation, the dynamics of particle movement are difficult to analyze experimentally. Therefore, here, in this study, powder spreading in PBF was simulated through the Discrete Element Method (DEM) to elucidate the mechanisms that control powder-bed quality. Utilizing the Buckingham Pi theorem, a dimensionless metric referred to as the spreading index is developed that combines powder-bed density, roughness, and particle size to assess the quality of powder layers. The formulated spreading index is then related to several dimensionless quantities that provide insight into the mechanisms dominating powder spreading in PBF. The DEM simulations conducted in this work focused on the scenario where powder is spread onto an existing powder bed and revealed that a reduction in the recoating velocity causes an increase in the spreading index while little to no impact on the spreading index was observed when varying layer thickness from 30 μm to 75 μm.Particle size effects on the powder-bed quality were also investigated.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Cookoff of Black Powder and Smokeless Powder
We have completed a series of both vented and sealed cookoff experiments of black powder and smokeless powder in our Sandia Instrumented Thermal Ignition (SITI) apparatus at bulk densities of 1078 and 729 kg/m 3 , respectively. The confining aluminum cylinder was ramped from room temperature to a set point temperature and then held at the setpoint temperature until ignition. The setpoint temperatures varied between 495 to 523 K for the black powder and 401 to 412 K for the more sensitive smokeless powder. The vented experiments show a significant delay in thermal ignition, indicating that the ignition is dependent on pressure. Post experimental debris shows greater violence for our smokeless powder experiments than our black powder experiments. A simplified universal cookoff model (UCM) was calibrated using the black powder and smokeless powder SITI data and used to predict pressurization and thermal ignition. The current work presents the first calibration of the UCM with a double base propellant. Finally, this work also presents the first pressure-dependent cookoff model for black powder and smokeless powder.
42 ENGINEERING↗
Fatigue of laser powder bed fusion processed 17-4 stainless steel using prior process exposed powder feedstock
The rapid pace of development seen in the metal additive manufacturing (AM) process of laser powder-bed fusion (LPBF) requires in-step advances in processes qualification to enable full-scale adoption. This particularly applies to quantifying how powder feedstock conditions impact end-component quality. Here this study examines how in-machine 17-4 stainless steel powder feedstocks are affected by prior LPBF processes, and how these effects impact subsequent builds. Examinations of powder morphology, chemistry, flowability, and rheology were conducted to characterize the powder conditions. The resultant effects of powder feedstock condition on produced component quasi-static tensile and high-cycle fatigue properties were analyzed. Fatigue life was analyzed using a reliability modeling approach that enabled a robust statistical comparison of life. Powder characteristics were found to evolve with powder exposure to prior LPBF processes, particularly in the extremes of powder size distribution and measures of bulk flow. No significant effects of these changes on tensile properties were observed. Reliability modeling methods, including the lognormal and Weibull distributions as well as the empirical survival function, are shown to be effective tools for modeling fatigue variability in LPBF manufactured components. Through these tools, fatigue life was found to be invariant with changes in powder condition.
42 ENGINEERING↗
Influence of Powder Characteristics and Processing Methods on Creep Performance of Powder Metallurgy Hot Isostatic Pressed SS316
The U.S. nuclear energy expansion goals are driving the demand for manufacturing routes that can rapidly produce large, complex, near net shape components. Powder metallurgy hot isostatic pressing (PM HIP) is an advanced manufacturing technique that can be economically scaled-up, while alleviating the supply chain challenges that forging and casting face in terms of cost and lead time constraints. This makes PM-HIP a viable technology to aid and accelerate large-scale part manufacturing for nuclear applications. However, large-scale qualification and deployment of this technology require a thorough understanding of the influence of powder feedstock quality, powder handling history, hot isostatic pressing (HIP) parameters, and subsequent heat treatment on microstructural evolution and elevated temperature mechanical performance. The present work focusses on 316 austenitic stainless steel (SS316) which is most commonly used in high temperature environments for nuclear applications Results from this study show that PM HIPed SS316 meets ASME tensile requirements at room temperature and at elevated temperature. However, creep performance of PM-HIPed SS316 remains inferior to its wrought counterpart, demonstrating that tensile performance alone is not a reliable metric for long duration high temperature integrity. Further, this report delineates powder derived microstructural features that govern creep damage, with key evidences pointing to “microstructural inheritance” from gas atomized powder feedstocks. Commercial SS316 powders of varying chemical compositions and recycling histories were studies, and the results showed large differences in elemental segregation, oxide surface layers and secondary phase distributions. Multi-scale characterization revealed segregation of chromium, molybdenum, manganese and silicon at the boundaries and the precipitation of manganese-, silicon-, and molybdenum-oxides. During HIP consolidation, these surface oxides transform into decorated prior particle boundaries (PPBs) and grain boundary inclusions that persist through conventional post-HIP solution annealing treatment. The retained oxides in post-HIP microstructures were found to influence grain growth, precipitation behavior, and ultimately creep cavitation and fracture. Such post-HIP heat treatments are therefore limited by a complex trade-off between grain growth, and oxide coarsening which aggravate creep damage by acting as nucleation sites for cavities. The objective of this work is to establish an integrated processing–structure–property framework for PM-HIP 316 stainless steel by investigating the influence of powder feedstock characteristics in pre- and post-HIP processing as well as to understand the significance of post-HIP heat treatment on microstructural evolution and creep properties. The results from this report emphasize the significance of powder feedstock integrity in improving creep performance of PM-HIPed SS316, by highlight the effect of rapid solidification, elemental segregation, oxide formation and powder recycling on microstructural defect inheritance following HIP consolidation. Rather than considering HIP processing, solution annealing, and mechanical performance independently, this report treats powder production, HIP consolidation, post-HIP thermal processing, and creep deformation as interconnected stages within a continuous metallurgical process. The resulting framework will provide a scientific basis for developing feedstock engineering strategies capable of improving long-term reliability of PM-HIP stainless steels and accelerating their qualification for advanced nuclear applications.
Ajjarapu, Pavan [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (OR↗
A Review on Metallic Alloys Fabrication Using Elemental Powder Blends by Laser Powder Directed Energy Deposition Process
The laser powder directed energy deposition process is a metal additive manufacturing technique, which can fabricate metal parts with high geometric and material flexibility. The unique feature of in-situ powder feeding makes it possible to customize the elemental composition using elemental powder mixture during the fabrication process. Thus, it can be potentially applied to synthesize industrial alloys with low cost, modify alloys with different powder mixtures, and design novel alloys with location-dependent properties using elemental powder blends as feedstocks. This paper provides an overview of using a laser powder directed energy deposition method to fabricate various types of alloys by feeding elemental powder blends. At first, the advantage of laser powder directed energy deposition in manufacturing metal alloys is described in detail. Then, the state-of-the-art research and development in alloys fabricated by laser powder directed energy deposition through a mix of elemental powders in multiple categories is reviewed. Finally, critical technical challenges, mainly in composition control are discussed for future development.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Transformations of Ti-5Al-5V-5Cr-3Mo powder due to reuse in laser powder bed fusion: A surface analytical approach
Reactive Ti-5Al-5 V-5Cr-3Mo (Ti5553) alloy feedstock powder is used in laser powder-bed fusion (LPBF). Due to the large quantity of powder necessary for LPBF, powder is reused numerous times under oxidizing environments. Transformations to the powder’s native surface oxide may impact the LPBF process and lead to deviations from expected behavior of printed parts. In this work, we present a multimodal characterization of new and reused powder by combining X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) of focused ion beam (FIB)-prepared cross sections of individual powder particles to understand how the surface oxide composition changes, grows, and becomes hydroxylated and hydrated due to reuse. We show that the native oxide film of Ti5553 powder is a hydroxylated mixed oxide composed of TiO 2 and Al 2 O 3 that grows from 5.6 +/- 0.7 nm to 8.3 +/- 1.1 nm due to reuse. Al oxide regions of the surface oxide become more hydroxylated during reuse in comparison to Ti oxide regions. This indicates that an outer oxide of pure TiO 2 may enhance recyclability of Ti5553 powder while the presence of Al oxides may decrease recyclability. Further characterization of surface transformations due to recyclability may eliminate unnecessary variation in LPBF.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Evolution of AISI 304L stainless steel part properties due to powder recycling in laser powder-bed fusion
Selective laser melting (SLM) is a powder-bed fusion process in Additive Manufacturing (AM) that uses a laser beam to selectively fuse layers of powder into near net-shape components with little porosity. However, inconsistencies in the part properties due to the presence of defects in as-built components has hindered the widespread adoption of SLM for industrial applications forcing researchers to study the sources of variation for quality control purposes. A critical area suspected of creating variation in the part properties is the feedstock, where batch-to-batch differences as well as changes in the powder properties with reuse have the potential to affect performance. During processing, laser spatter and condensate eject from the melt pool and deposit into the powder-bed surrounding the parts. These particulates, more commonly known as ejecta, differ morphologically and chemically from the virgin powder compromising its reusability. In this study, 304L stainless steel powder was recycled for a total of 5 times through a systematic approach aimed at accelerating powder degradation to reveal the influence on both the tensile and impact toughness properties. Through analysis of variance (ANOVA), it was found that tensile properties did not change with reuse, while the impact toughness showed a steady decline illustrating the differences in static and dynamic part properties due to powder recycling.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
An instrument for in situ characterization of powder spreading dynamics in powder-bed-based additive manufacturing processes
In powder-bed-based metal additive manufacturing (AM), the visualization and analysis of the powder spreading process are critical for understanding the powder spreading dynamics and mechanisms. Unfortunately, the high spreading speeds, the small size of the powder, and the opacity of the materials present a great challenge for directly observing the powder spreading behavior. In this study, we report a compact and flexible powder spreading system for in situ characterization of the dynamics of the powders during the spreading process by high-speed x-ray imaging. The system enables the tracing of individual powder movement within the narrow gap between the recoater and the substrate at variable spreading speeds from 17 to 322 mm/s. The instrument and method reported here provide a powerful tool for studying powder spreading physics in AM processes and for investigating the physics of granular material flow behavior in a confined environment.
47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗
Effect of Blown Powder Directed Energy Deposition Angle On Overspray Contamination
Abstract Blown powder directed energy deposition (DED) hybrid machine tools are particularly beneficial when the net shape of a component is to be manufactured in an additive and machined interleaved fashion. This investigation seeks to analyze the effect of the additive head lean angle relative to the part on blown powder DED surface contamination due to overspray. These hybrid DED platforms are commonly installed on multi-axis machining systems where the lean of the deposition head relative to the component surface can be controlled by tilting the component. The blown powder DED process has a 10–50% lower catchment efficiency as compared to wire fed DED systems. This excess powder is still fed towards the deposition location where the particles are heated by the laser and rebound off the melt pool. Some of these heated particles impact the previously machined thin-wall surface. While the deposition process and tool path planning process has been evaluated, the effect of the overspray due to lean angle of the deposition head on the previously thin-wall machined surface is not yet fully understood. This investigation found that minimum lean angle coincides with minimal overspray effect with nearly no contamination. If a lean angle is required, the maximum lean angle possible should be implemented for the smallest effected overspray area on the machined surface which was found to decrease the affect zone by half compared to intermediate lean angles. A diameter divergence was also noticed as the deposition angle was increased. In this study, a thorough analysis of the surface and geometric effects when depositing thin-walled components at varying angles is completed. It has been shown that part quality can be significantly affected by lean angle and thus must be incorporated as an additional design consideration in the manufacturing process.
Heinrich, Lauren↗
Impact of Nozzle Condition on Powder Catchment Efficiency for Coaxial Powder Direct Energy Deposition
Blown powder directed energy deposition is well-designed for fine resolution additive manufacturing processing. Coaxial powder deposition heads use an outer layer of shielding gas directed by an outer nozzle to prevent oxidation occurring during the powder melting process. Powder blown feedstock catchment efficiency can be as low as 50-80% whereas wire deposition systems are closer to 98% efficient. The present study evaluates the impact of directed energy deposition nozzle condition on catchment efficiency. Changes in the overall outer shielding gas nozzle length has been found to increase material usage efficiency by 10% through convergence of the powder flow. The results of this experiment show that for coaxial powder deposition head design, if the standoff distance can safely be decreased, powder catchment efficiency can be increased as the outer shielding gas nozzle is increased in length, or the standoff distance is decreased.
Heinrich, Lauren↗
Impact of Nozzle Condition on Powder Catchment Efficiency for Coaxial Powder Direct Energy Deposition
Blown powder directed energy deposition is well-designed for fine resolution additive manufacturing processing. Coaxial powder deposition heads use an outer layer of shielding gas directed by an outer nozzle to prevent oxidation occurring during the powder melting process. Powder blown feedstock catchment efficiency can be as low as 50-80% whereas wire deposition systems are closer to 98% efficient. The present study evaluates the impact of directed energy deposition nozzle condition on catchment efficiency. Changes in the overall outer shielding gas nozzle length has been found to increase material usage efficiency by 10% through convergence of the powder flow. The results of this experiment show that for coaxial powder deposition head design, if the standoff distance can safely be decreased, powder catchment efficiency can be increased as the outer shielding gas nozzle is increased in length, or the standoff distance is decreased.
Heinrich, Lauren↗
Laser Powder Bed Fusion of ODS 14YWT from Gas Atomization Reaction Synthesis Precursor Powders
Abstract Laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) additive manufacturing (AM) is a promising route for the fabrication of oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) steels. In this study, 14YWT ferritic steel powders were produced by gas atomization reaction synthesis (GARS). The rapid solidification resulted in the formation of stable, Y-containing intermetallic Y 2 Fe 17 on the interior of the powder and a stable Cr-rich oxide surface. The GARS powders were consolidated with LPBF. Process parameter maps identified a stable process window resulting in a relative density of 99.8%. Transmission electron microscopy and high-energy x-ray diffraction demonstrated that during LPBF, the stable phases in the powder dissociated in the liquid melt pool and reacted to form a high density (1.7 × 10 20 /m 3 ) of homogeneously distributed Ti 2 Y 2 O 7 pyrochlore dispersoids ranging from 17 to 57 nm. The use of GARS powder bypasses the mechanical alloying step typically required to produce ODS feedstock. Preliminary mechanical tests demonstrated an ultimate tensile and yield strength of 474 MPa and 312 MPa, respectively.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗