Test Methods for Hoop Tensile Strength of Ceramic Composite Tubes for Light Water Nuclear Reactor Applications
No abstract available
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
No abstract available
No abstract available
Here, we report the development of a cone wedge ring expansion test method to determine the tensile hoop properties of irradiated nuclear fuel cladding in a hot cell. A closed-form solution was developed to explicitly relate the hoop stress σ θ to the axial piston loading using the scale factor χ and the shear stress correction factor α, where the χ and α factors are used to convert the applied piston load and the radial dilatation of the ring into the tensile hoop stress-strain curve. The applicability of this new test method was demonstrated by successfully evaluating ring specimens of Zr-4 alloy to failure. The ring specimens deformed uniformly in the axial and circumferential directions until onset of necking. The χ and α factors were successfully determined by using a finite-element stress analysis that benchmarked with applied test load and total work to account for frictional forces and the associated energies dissipation between the different sliding components of the testing system. The tensile hoop strength values obtained using the proposed cone-wedge-ring-expansion test method were 10% higher than values obtained from the tensile evaluation of the cladding material along the axial direction. In conclusion, the variability in results was found to be within the range reported in the literature.
The performance of SiC fiber composites made by a polymer infiltration and pyrolysis (PIP) process was investigated. Two types of tubular composites were manufactured using Hi-Nicalon and Nicalon-CG silicon carbide fibers infiltrated with SMP10 silicon carbide matrix. The fiber content in both composites was about 25 vol.% with an average density of 2.39 g/cc. The tubular SiC composites showed stable solar absorptance and emittance of 0.97 and 0.91, respectively, at 800 °C. The composites were thermally shocked at 900, 1000, and 1100 °C with a waterjet simulating raindrops. As a result, the hoop tensile strength of the composites revealed no loss of mechanical strength due to the thermal shock experiments up to 1100 °C.
Performance of Silicon Carbide Fiber Composite Receiver Tubes for Concentrating Solar Power
This contract reviewed the available literature on mechanisms of low velocity impact damage in filament wound rocket motor cases, MDE methods to quantify damage, critical coupon level test methods, manufacturing and material process variables and empirical and analytical modeling off impact damage. The critical design properties for rocket motor cases are biaxial hoop and axial tensile strength. Low velocity impact damage is insidious because it can create serious nonvisible damage at very low impact velocities. In thick rocket motor cases the prevalent low velocity impact damage is fiber fracture and matrix cracking adjacent to the front face. In contrast, low velocity loading of thin wall cylinders induces flexure, depending on span length and the flexure induces delamination and tensile cracking on the back face wall opposed to impact occurs due to flexural stresses imposed by impact loading. Important NDE methods for rocket motor cases are non-contacting methods that allow inspection from one side. Among these are vibrothermography, and pulse-echo methods based on acoustic-ultrasonic methods. High resolution techniques such as x-ray computed tomography appear to have merit for accurate geometrical characterization of local damage to support development of analytical models of micromechanics. The challenge of coupon level testing is to reproduce the biaxial stress state that the full scale article experiences, and to determine how to scale the composite structure to model full sized behavior. Biaxial tensile testing has been performed by uniaxially tensile loading internally pressurized cylinders. This is experimentally difficult due to gripping problems and pressure containment. Much prior work focused on uniaxial tensile testing of model filament wound cylinders. Interpretation of the results of some studies is complicated by the fact that the fabrication process did not duplicate full scale manufacturing. It is difficult to scale results from testing subscale cylinders since there are significant differences in out time of the resins relative to full scale cylinder fabrication, differences in hoop fiber tensioning and unsatisfactory coupon configurations. It appears that development of a new test method for subscale cylinders is merited. Damage tolerance may be improved by material optimization that uses fiber treatments and matrix modifications to control the fiber matrix interface bonding. It is difficult to develop process optimization in subscale cylinders without also modeling the longer out times resins experience in full scale testing. A major breakthrough in characterizing the effect of impact damage on residual strength, and understanding how to scale results of subscale evaluations, will be a sound micromechanical model that described progressive failure of the composite. Such models will utilize a three dimensional stress analysis due to the complex nature of low velocity impact stresses in thick composites. When these models are coupled with non-contact NDE methods that geometrically characterize the damage and acoustic methods that characterize the effective local elastic properties, accurate assessment of residual strength from impact damage may be possible. Directions for further development are suggested.
A method, referred to as the expanding plug test method, for determining the roomtemperature hoop stress-strain curves of irradiated nuclear fuel cladding has been developed and applied to evaluate tensile strength and ductility in the hoop direction of clad material irradiated to high neutron fluences. The test utilizes an incompressible plug fitted within a tubular cladding specimen. A cylindrical punch is used to compress the plug axially, which generates a radial displacement that acts upon the inner diameter of the specimen. Position sensors track the radial displacement of the specimen outer diameter as the compression proceeds. An auxiliary compression test of the plug alone is also performed. Using these two sets of data, a procedure was developed to determine the hoop stress in the clad specimen. The development of this simple, cost-effective, highly reproducible test method to determine stressstrain curves in the hoop direction of irradiated clad specimens represents a significant advancement in the mechanical characterization of irradiated cladding. This paper will present an overview of the expanding plug testing technique and will discuss tests performed on irradiated clad specimens to date.
Ferritic iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys are an accident tolerant fuel candidate to replace the incumbent Zr-based claddings. Nuclear grade FeCrAl alloys are marked by superior high temperature mechanical behavior and exceptional steam oxidation resistance, both of which increase safety margins during accident scenarios. In the present study, the loss of coolant accident (LOCA) burst behaviors of three un-irradiated commercially fabricated cladding materials in a simulated LOCA environment were compared: (1) T35Y2, a 1 st generation nuclear grade FeCrAl, (2) C26M, a 2 nd generation nuclear grade FeCrAl, and (3) Zircaloy-2. Both FeCrAl alloys showed improved mechanical strength and steam oxidation resistance compared to Zircaloy-2. C26M claddings burst at significantly higher temperatures for all tested engineering hoop stresses, had limited ballooning, and demonstrated preferential fuel retention behavior in terms of burst opening area and length. High temperature tensile data for C26M is also presented. For both un-irradiated FeCrAl alloys, it was found that a distinct “threshold” burst stress signified the transition between small and large openings. Finally, higher threshold hoop stresses were associated with higher uniaxial strength for the FeCrAl alloys, indicating that tensile data, rather than creep data, could be useful for predicting rupture size and assessing fuel dispersal concerns.
To determine the hoop tensile properties of irradiated fuel cladding in a hot cell, a cone wedge ring expansion test method was developed. A four-piece wedge insert was designed with tapered angles matched to the cone shape of a loading piston. The ring specimen was expanded in the radial direction by the lateral expansion of the wedges under the downward movement of the piston. The advantages of the proposed method are that implementation of the test setup in a hot cell is simple and easy, and that it enables a direct strain measurement of the test specimen from the piston’s vertical displacement soon after the wedge-clad contact resistance is initiated.
ORNL is developing advanced low-Cr oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) FeCrAlY alloys for accident tolerant fuel cladding, and this report describes the fabrication and characterization of a new ODS FeCrAlYZr (CrAZY) tube. This CrAZY tube was produced by successive steps of pilgering and annealing, in collaboration with a Japanese tube manufacturer. Very fine, elongated sub-grain structure in the as-received tube was consistent with the fine sub-grain structure observed for CrAZY foils fabricated by cold rolling at ORNL and led to very high tensile strength at room temperature. The elongated grain structure along the pilgering direction resulted in lower ductility in the hoop direction compared to the ductility along the tube. Similar anisotropic tensile behavior was also observed for the CrAZY foil with very limited ductility perpendicular to the rolling direction. The foil and tube were heat treated in the 850- 1100ºC range to reduce the residual stress. Recrystallization was observed at temperature as low as 900ºC, with an increasing number of recrystallized grains with increasing temperature. Exposure for 1h at 900ºC resulted in a significant improvement of the foil and tube, with a moderate decrease of strength. Atom probe tomographic analysis revealed the presence of many nano oxide precipitates but also areas with fewer precipitates due to the relatively high extrusion temperature (1100ºC). Finally, the CrAZY tube showed good oxidation resistance in steam at temperature up to 1400ºC.
For angleply composites, lamina tension and compression strengths are commonly determined by applying classical lamination theory to test data obtained from testing of angleply composite specimens. For textile composites such as 2D triaxial braids, analysis is more complex and standard test methods do not always yield reliable strength measurements. This paper describes recent research focused on development of more reliable tensile test methods for braided composites and presents preliminary data for various approaches. The materials investigated in this work have 0deg+/-60 2D triaxial braid architecture with nearly equal fiber volume fraction in each of the three fiber directions. Flat composite panels are fabricated by resin transfer molding (RTM) using six layers of the braided preform aligned along the 0deg fiber direction. Various epoxy resins are used as matrix materials. Single layer panels are also fabricated in order to examine local variations in deformation related to the braid architecture. Specimens are cut from these panels in the shape of standard straight-sided coupons, an alternative bowtie geometry, and an alternative notched geometry. Axial tensile properties are measured using specimens loaded along the 0deg fiber direction. Transverse tensile properties are measured using specimens loaded perpendicular to the 0deg fibers. Composite tubes are also fabricated by RTM. These tubes are tested by internal pressurization using a soft rubbery material sealed between the inside diameter of the tube and the load fixtures. The ends of the tube are unconstrained, so the primary load is in the hoop direction. Tubes are fabricated with the 0deg fibers aligned along the tube axis by overbraiding the preform on a mandrel. Since the loading is in the hoop direction, testing of the overbraided tube provides a measure of transverse tensile strength. Previous work has indicated that straight-sided coupons yield a transverse tensile strength that is much lower than the expected material strength because of premature edge-initiated failure. Full-field strain measured during transverse tensile tests clearly showed accumulation of edge damage prior to failure. In the current work, high speed video and testing of single layer specimens are used to investigate potential failure mechanisms in more detail. High speed video clearly shows the edge initiation in six layer transverse tensile test coupons. Specimens with the bowtie geometry and the notched geometry minimize this edge effect and yield significantly higher transverse tensile strength values compared to the straight-sided coupons. However, bowtie and notched specimens geometries are not ideal because of the non-uniform stress and strain fields in the region of failure. Testing of tubes using internal pressurization eliminates edge-initiated failure and provides a more uniform state of stress and strain. Preliminary results indicate that bowtie, notched, and tube specimens yield comparable values for transverse tensile strength and that these values are much higher than the strength measured using a straight-sided coupon.
A curved beam 'C-coupon' was used to assess fracture behavior in a Sylramic(tm)/melt infiltration (MI) SiC matrix composite. Failure stresses and fracture mechanisms, as determined by optical and scanning electron microstructural analysis, are compared with finite element stress calculations to analyze failure modes. Material microstructure was found to have a strong influence on mechanical behavior. Fracture occurs in interlaminar tension (ILT), provided that the ratio of ILT to tensile strength for the material is less than the ratio of radial to hoop stresses for the C-coupon geometry. Utilization of 3D architectures to improve interlaminar strength requires significant development efforts to incorporate through thickness fibers in regions with high curvatures while maintaining uniform thickness, radius, and microstructure.
Due to their high resistance to radiation damage and elevated temperature, silicon carbide fiber-reinforced, silicon carbide matrix composites (SiC f -SiC m ) are identified as potential cladding structures for use in nuclear reactors. In this study, four composite architectures with varying ply numbers along the thickness direction and different biaxial or triaxial plain weave orientations at either 45° or 60°, were systematically evaluated under various stress states to assess the influence of weave architecture on mechanical performance. Experiments were conducted on SiC f -SiC m composite tubes under tensile hoop, axial compression, and rotating flexural loading to evaluate the mechanical response and investigate the failure modes using high-speed imaging and digital image correlation (DIC) techniques. It was found that for tensile hoop burst and flexural loading, the braiding angle had the most significant influence on the strength of the composite, whereas the effect of fiber angle was more limited for compression testing. Under axial compression a unique failure mode where a microcrack nucleates and grows only to a length equal to the thickness of a single yarn was identified. This crack growth behavior is reflected as periodic oscillations in the load-displacement response. For both axial and hoop loading, regardless of weave angle and number of plies, failure always initiated parallel to the tube axis in a single yarn and the cumulative interaction of these microcracks lead to either axial burst or fracture at an angle to the tube axis along a yarn. Furthermore, these results point to the importance of customizing the design of tube architecture for enhanced performance in specified nuclear applications.
Tube Cyclic Extrusion–Compression as a novel severe plastic deformation technique for tubes was utilized for processing ultrafine grained 1050 aluminum alloy for the first time. In this method, aluminum tube is fully constrained and deformed between mandrel and chamber with a small neck zone. The material deformation during Tube Cyclic Extrusion–Compression processing analyzed and the grain refinement mechanism were described. The capability of Tube Cyclic Extrusion–Compression in grain refinement of the aluminum alloy was demonstrated by transmission electron microscopy observations and X-ray diffraction line profile analysis. The micrographs of the evolved microstructure show grain size of 850 nm and 550 nm after the first and second processing cycles of Tube Cyclic Extrusion–Compression, respectively. Mechanical properties of the initial and processed specimens were extracted from ring-hoop tensile tests. The documented results confirm grain refinement by showing remarkable increase in the yield and ultimate strengths. The main increase in strength and decrease in elongation take place after the first cycle. The microhardness assessments illustrate increase from the initial value of 29 Hv to 44 and 49 Hv respectively after the first and second cycles of Tube Cyclic Extrusion–Compression. There is a good homogeneity in peripheral microhardness and microhardness across the tube thickness. - Highlights: • Tubes of AA1050 for the first time were successfully SPD processed by TCEC. • The grain size was refined to 550 nm after two cycles of TCEC. • Notable increase in the strength and decrease in the elongation were documented. • The microhardness increased to 49 Hv from the initial value of 29 Hv. • Good homogeneity in the microhardness distribution was recorded.
Cladding Ring Tension Testing (RTT) of unirradiated cladding materials using Digital Image Correlation (DIC). RTT is an important tool for determining hoop strength of thin-walled tubing, especially in anisotropic materials such as zirconium fuel cladding. The goal is to set up a DIC system to a tensile test on these RTT specimens and study the mechanical properties.
SiC/SiC composites are excellent material candidates for high temperature applications where the performance requirements are high strength, high creep-rupture resistance, high environmental durability, and high thermal conductivity. In the past, the NASA UEET program has demonstrated fabrication of high-performance SiC/SiC flat panels reinforced by Sylramic-iBN SiC fibers. Currently NASA UEET is scaling up this SiC/SiC system by fabrication of more complex shaped components using the same fiber type. This paper reports the effects of various fiber architectures on the processing, mechanical, and durability behavior of small-diameter 0.5" ID SiC/SiC tubes, which are potential sub-elements for leading edges and cooling channels in turbine vanes and blades. Nine different fiber architectures were utilized for construction of seamless tube preforms, from simple 2D jelly-rolling to complex braiding, pin-weaving, filament-winding and 3D orthogonal weaving with approximately 5% fibers in the thru-thickness direction. Using the BN interphase and Sic matrix processing steps established for the flat panels, SiC/SiC tubes were fabricated with wall thicknesses of approximately 60 mils and total fiber fractions of approximately 35%. The "D" split ring tests for hoop tensile properties, micro-structural examinations for relationship between fiber architecture formation and matrix infiltration, and the low-pressure burner rig tests for the high temperature durability under thru-thickness thermal gradient were conducted. The better matrix infiltration and higher hoop strength were achieved using the tri-axial braided and the three-float pin woven SiC/SiC tubes. In general, it needs not only higher hoop direction fibers but also axial direction fibers for the higher hoop strength and the better infiltration, respectively. These results are analyzed to offer general guidelines for selecting fiber pre-form architectures and SiC/SiC processes that maximize tube hoop strength, thru-thickness thermal conductivity, and burner-rig durability under a high thermal gradient.
The ring tension test (RTT) is an experimental method for determining mechanical behavior in a material’s circumferential or hoop direction. It is a crucial test for testing anisotropic materials with tube geometry, such as nuclear fuel cladding or irradiated pipes. Several RTT configurations exist, each with their own advantages and disadvantages. However, this test is significantly more complex than traditional tensile testing and can be especially sensitive to small differences and inconsistencies in the test setup and geometry, ultimately affecting the derived mechanical properties. Previous research has focused on method development, and little work has been done on understanding the subtle differences between an ideal test and experiments, specifically when the tests are performed on highly irradiated materials in hot cells. In this work, a finite element-based investigation of the RTT is conducted to fill this gap. The two most used test configurations are investigated, comparing their ability to determine accurate material strengths through plastic deformation. Several non-ideal conditions and uncontrollable effects which are likely to occur during experimental testing such as machining tolerances, variations of specimen geometry from nominal dimensions, rotation of specimens and fixturing, and other test setup discrepancies are studied. The sensitivity of measured strengths to these conditions is presented. A mechanics-based approach to describing and correcting raw data to determine actual strengths is also included for one of the configurations, resulting in a robust correction method with highly accurate material strength measurements. Finally, based on these analyses, the hemicylindrical mandrel configuration is recommended with a gauge region oriented at a 45° angle.
The elastic and yield response of extruded thin-walled high-density polyethylene tubes with a density in the range of 0.961 to 0.964 gm/cu cm was investigated. Material properties in the axial and hoop directions were measured, and the tubes were found to be mildly transversely isotropic. The yield response was pressure sensitive, and was well predicted using the pressure-modified Hill criterion using a compressive to tensile yield strength ratio of 1:12.