Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “EMBRITTLEMENT”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

High Fluency Low Flux Embrittlement Models of LWR Reactor Pressure Vessel Embrittlement and a Supporting Database from the UCSB ATR-2 Irradiation Experiment

Reactor pressure vessel embrittlement may limit the lifetime of light water reactors (LWR). Embrittlement is primarily caused by formation of nano-scale precipitates, which cause hardening and a subsequent increase in the ductile-to-brittle transition temperature of the steel. While the effect of Cu has historically been the largest research focus of RPV embrittlement, there is increasing evidence that Mn, Ni and Si are likely to have a large effect at higher fluence, where Mn-Ni-Si precipitates can form, even in the absence of Cu. Therefore, extending RPV lifetimes will require a thorough understanding of both precipitation and embrittlement at higher fluences than have ever been observed in a power reactor. To address this issue, test reactors that irradiate materials at higher neutron fluxes than power reactors are used. These experiments at high neutron flux can reach extended life neutron fluences in only months or several years. The drawback of these test irradiations is that they add additional complexity to interpreting the data, as the irradiation flux also plays a role into both precipitate formation and irradiation hardening and embrittlement. This report focuses on developing a database of both microstructure and mechanical property data to better understand the effect of flux. In addition, a previously developed model that enables the comparison of data taken over a range of neutron flux is discussed.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Tritium embrittlement of austenitic stainless-steel tubing at low helium contents

Austenitic stainless steels are the standard materials for containment of hydrogen and tritium because of their resistance to mechanical property degradation in those environments. The mechanical performance of the primary containment material is critical for tritium handling, processing, and storage, thus comprehensive understanding of the processes of tritium embrittlement is an enabling capability for fusion energy. This work describes the investigation of the effects of low levels of tritium-decay-helium ingrowth on 304 L tubes. Long-term aging with tritium leads to high helium contents in austenitic stainless steels and can reduce fracture toughness by 95 %, but the details of behavior at low helium contents are not as well characterized. Here, we present results from tensile testing of tritium pre-charged 304 L tube specimens with a variety of starting microstructures that all contain a low level of helium. The results of the tritium exposed-and-aged materials are compared to previously reported results on similar specimens tested in an unexposed condition as well as the hydrogen precharged condition. Tritium precharging and aging for a short duration resulted in increased yield strengths, ultimate tensile strengths and slightly increased elongation to failure, comparable to higher concentrations of hydrogen precharging.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Meso-scale magnetic signatures for nuclear reactor steel irradiation embrittlement monitoring

Verifying the structural integrity of passive components in light water and advanced reactors will be necessary to ensure safe, long-term operations of the existing U.S. nuclear fleet. This objective can be achieved through nondestructive condition monitoring techniques, which can be integrated with plant operations to quantify the “state of health” of structural materials in real-time. While nondestructive methods for monitoring many classes of degradation (such as fatigue or stress corrosion cracking) are relatively advanced, this is not the case for degradation caused by irradiation. The development of nondestructive evaluation technologies for these types of degradation will require advanced materials characterization techniques and tools that enable comprehensive understanding of nuclear reactor material microstructural and behavioral changes under extreme operating environments. Irradiation-induced degradation of reactor steels causes changes in their microstructure that impacts their micro-magnetic properties. In this paper, we describe preliminary results of integrating advanced material characterization techniques with meso-scale computational models. In the future, this will help to provide an interpretive understanding of the state of degradation in structural materials. Microstructural data are presented from monocrystalline Fe and are correlated with variable-field magnetic force microscopy and micro-magnetic measurements. Ongoing research is focused on extending the measurements and models on thin films to gain insights into the structural state of irradiated materials and the resulting impact on magnetic properties. Preliminary conclusions from these correlations are presented, and next steps described.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Friction Stir Dovetailing of AA7099 to Steel with AA6061 Interlayer for Reduced Zn Embrittlement at Dissimilar Interface

Joining of high strength Al alloy (AA7099) to steel (rolled homogeneous armor) with and without AA6061 interlayer was achieved using a friction stir dovetailing (FSD) method. Detailed investigations were conducted to establish correlations between mechanical performance and microstructural evolution of FSD joints. Lap shear tensile testing revealed that incorporation of the AA6061 interlayer combined with tailored processing methodology significantly improved both mechanical interlocking and load transmission across the dovetail interface. Following incorporation of the interlayer, the maximum load carrying capacity and peak extension (of the AA7099/AA6061/steel joint) are 60% and 210% higher, respectively, than results obtained from an AA7099/steel joint without an interlayer. Without an AA6061 interlayer, formation of zinc rich intermetallic compounds led to brittle interfacial failure of the AA7099-steel FSD joint. Incorporation of novel tool and joint configuration eliminated asymmetric joint performance as a function of loading direction, which is generally observed in friction stir lap welding. The efficacy of the use of an AA6061 interlayer in joining AA7099 to steel was demonstrated through mechanical testing as well as high resolution analytical electron microscopy characterization.

Dissimilar metal joining, Friction stir dovetailin↗

Spectrum of embrittling potencies and relation to properties of symmetric-tilt grain boundaries

Grain boundaries in metallic materials can exist in a wide range of stable and metastable structures. In addition, the properties of a grain boundary may be altered through solute segregation. In this work, we present a formulation that combines the spectrum of embrittling potencies associated with solute segregation with site-occupancy statistics. As a prototype problem, we illustrate the relation between segregation and embrittlement in the case of S segregation to grain boundaries in Ni. To obtain a population of site segregation energies, we perform molecular statics calculations on 378 different symmetric-tilt grain boundaries and their free surface equivalents, using an embedded-atom method interatomic potential developed specifically for studying embrittlement. Our results show that it is important to consider both the energies associated with embrittlement and the probability of occupancy to describe the general embrittling nature of a grain boundary. When analyzed in isolation, certain grain boundaries show large embrittling potencies; however, that effect is diminished when the probability of S segregation to that grain boundary is considered within a polycrystal. We propose a new quantity, the embrittling estimator, which not only categorizes grain boundaries as embrittling or strengthening, but also considers site occupancy probabilities, so that the embrittlement behavior of grain boundaries within a network of grain boundaries can be compared. Finally, we examine the relationship between embrittlement behavior and innate grain boundary properties, such as the free volume, and find statistical evidence that the complex nature of embrittlement cannot be explained by linear correlations with excess volumes or energies. Ultimately, this combined approach provides a theoretical tool to assist grain boundary engineering of metastable alloys.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Statistical perspective on embrittling potency for intergranular fracture

Embrittling potency is a thermodynamic metric that assesses the influence of solute segregation to a grain boundary (GB) on intergranular fracture. Historically, authors of studies have reported embrittling potency as a single scalar value, assuming a single segregation site of importance at a GB and a particular cleavage plane. However, the topography of intergranular fracture surfaces is not generally known a priori. Accordingly, we, in this study, present a statistical ensemble approach to compute embrittling potency, where many free surface (FS) permutations are systematically considered to model fracture of a GB. The result is a statistical description of the thermodynamics of GB embrittlement. As a specific example, embrittling potency distributions are presented for Cr segregation to sites at two Ni $\langle 111 \rangle$ symmetric tilt GBs using atomistic simulations. We show that the average embrittling potency for a particular GB site, considering an ensemble of FS permutations, is not equal to the embrittling potency computed using the lowest energy pair of FSs. A mean GB embrittlement is proposed, considering both the likelihood of formation of a particular FS and the probability of solute occupancy at each GB site, to compare the relative embrittling behavior of two distinct GBs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Consideration of Thermal Embrittlement in Alloy 316H for Advanced Non-Light Water Reactor Applications

To construct advanced non-light water reactors (ANLWRs) operating in the temperature range above that for the traditional light water reactors (LWRs), Alloy 316H is one of the candidate materials because of its inexpensiveness, significant service experience, and qualification for nuclear applications by the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME). However, during the life span at temperatures expected for the ANLWRs, the alloy is likely to experience thermal embrittlement that has not been a concern for the traditional LWRs. To prepare for the development, the possibility of adverse thermal embrittlement effects on Alloy 316H performance in the ANLWRs must be evaluated and a technical basis regarding thermal embrittlement, if necessary, must be established for structural integrity analysis to provide reasonable assurance of adequate nuclear safety protection.In this paper, current technical basis for nuclear applications of Alloy 316H deterioration from thermal aging is briefly introduced. The likelihood of adverse thermal embrittlement effects on Alloy 316H performance is evaluated through historical data on microstructural and mechanical property evolution. Characterization of thermal embrittlement is then discussed, followed by a review of predictive models and trend curves for alloy embrittlement. Based on the review and evaluation, technical gaps for addressing thermal embrittlement issues are identified and gap-filling actions are recommended for establishing a technical basis to enable adequate consideration of thermal embrittlement in Alloy 316H applications to the ANLWRs.

Ren, Weiju↗

An embedded-atom method potential parameterized for sulfur-induced embrittlement of nickel

The embrittling or strengthening effect of solute atoms at grain boundaries (GBs), commonly known as the embrittling potency, is a necessary thermodynamic property for characterizing the effects of solute segregation on GB fracture. One of the more technologically relevant material systems related to embrittlement is the Ni–S system where S has a deleterious effect on fracture behavior in polycrystalline Ni. Here, we develop a Ni–S embedded-atom method (EAM) interatomic potential that accounts for the embrittling behavior of S at Ni GBs. Results using this new interatomic potential are then compared to previous density functional theory studies and a reactive force-field potential via a layer-by-layer segregation analysis. Our potential shows strong agreement with existing literature and performs well in predicting properties that are not included in the fitting database. Finally, we calculate embrittling potencies and segregation energies for six [100] symmetric-tilt GBs using the new EAM potential. We observe that embrittling potency is dependent on GB structure, suggesting that specific GBs are more susceptible to sulfur-induced embrittlement.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

On the kinetics of transgranular particle embrittlement during simulated carburizing in steel containing grain-refining additions of aluminum and niobium plus aluminum

Here, the kinetics of toughness degradation resulting from transgranular particle embrittlement are evaluated as a function of composition and processing history for simulated carburizing operations in air-melt steel containing grain-refining additions of aluminum and aluminum plus niobium. The kinetics of particle embrittlement are inherently linked to the ripening of AlN precipitates after extended austenitization in steel containing carbon contents representative of both the case and core of a carburized component. Embrittlement in steel containing AlN occurs with an activation energy similar to the value for aluminum diffusion in austenite, although an AlN volume fraction effect on the embrittlement kinetics is manifested as decreases in activation energy with decreases in the [Al]/[N] ratio of steel. In contrast, the presence of niobium substantially retards the kinetics of particle embrittlement in steel containing 120–200 ppm N. Observations of AlN precipitates coated with Nb(C,N) indicate that the decreases in embrittlement kinetics are related to a reduction in the potential for AlN ripening during austenitization.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Low Temperature Irradiation Embrittlement of Reactor Pressure Vessel Steels

The project on irradiation embrittlement of reactor pressure vessel (RPV) steels irradiated at low temperatures (<93°C) was carried out with three major tasks; (1) data collection to match that used in the HFIR steel embrittlement trend curve study published in 1994 by Remec et. al, (2) new embrittlement data of A212B steel that are not included in the earlier HFIR RPV trend curve, and (3) the adjustment of nil-ductility-transition temperature (NDTT) shift data with consideration of the irradiation temperature effect. A low temperature RPV steel irradiation embrittlement predictive curve was developed, as described below. ΔNDTT(°C) = 23.85 log(x) 2 + 203.3 log (x) + 434.7, with 2-σ uncertainty of 34.6°C, where parameter x is total dpa. The low temperature RPV steel irradiation embrittlement curve has a higher embrittlement rate compared to that of the HFIR trend curve developed in 1994.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Hydrogen embrittlement of structural steels.

Carbon-manganese steels are candidates for the structural materials in hydrogen gas pipelines, however it is well known that these steels are susceptible to hydrogen embrittlement. Decades of research and industrial experience have established that hydrogen embrittlement compromises the structural integrity of steel components. This experience has also helped identify the failure modes that can operate in hydrogen containment structures. As a result, there are tangible ideas for managing hydrogen embrittement in steels and quantifying safety margins for steel hydrogen containment structures. For example, fatigue crack growth aided by hydrogen embrittlement is a key failure mode for steel hydrogen containment structures subjected to pressure cycling. Applying appropriate structural integrity models coupled with measurement of relevant material properties allows quantification of safety margins against fatigue crack growth in hydrogen containment structures. Furthermore, application of these structural integrity models is aided by the development of micromechanics models, which provide important insights such as the hydrogen distribution near defects in steel structures. The principal objective of this project is to enable application of structural integrity models to steel hydrogen pipelines. The new American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) B31.12 design code for hydrogen pipelines includes a fracture mechanics-based design option, which requires material property inputs such as the threshold for rapid cracking and fatigue crack growth rate under cyclic loading. Thus, one focus of this project is to measure the rapid-cracking thresholds and fatigue crack growth rates of line pipe steels in high-pressure hydrogen gas. These properties must be measured for the base materials but more importantly for the welds, which are likely to be most vulnerable to hydrogen embrittlement. The measured properties can be evaluated by predicting the performance of the pipeline using a relevant structural integrity model, such as that in ASME B31.12. A second objective of this project is to enable development of micromechanics models of hydrogen embrittlement in pipeline steels. The focus of this effort is to establish physical models of hydrogen embrittlement in line pipe steels using evidence from analytical techniques such as electron microscopy. These physical models then serve as the framework for developing sophisticated finite-element models, which can provide quantitative insight into the micromechanical state near defects. Understanding the micromechanics of defects can ensure that structural integrity models are applied accurately and conservatively.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Methodology for Estimating Thermal and Neutron Embrittlement of Cast Austenitic Stainless Steels During Service in Light Water Reactors

Cast austenitic stainless steel (CASS) materials, which have a duplex structure consisting of austenite and ferrite phases, are susceptible to thermal embrittlement during reactor service. In addition, the prolonged exposure of these materials, which are used in reactor core internals, to neutron irradiation changes their microstructure and microchemistry, and these changes degrade their fracture properties even further. This paper presents a revision of the procedure and correlations presented in NUREG/CR-4513, Rev. 1 (Aug. 1994) for predicting the change in fracture toughness and tensile properties of CASS components due to thermal aging during service in light water reactors (LWRs) at 280–330 °C (535–625 °F). The methodology is applicable to CF-3, CF-3M, CF-8, and CF-8M materials with a ferrite content of up to 40%. The fracture toughness, tensile strength, and Charpy-impact energy of aged CASS materials are estimated from known material information. Embrittlement is characterized in terms of room-temperature (RT) Charpy-impact energy. The extent or degree of thermal embrittlement at “saturation” (i.e., the minimum impact energy that can be achieved for a material after long-term aging) is determined from the chemical composition of the material. Charpy-impact energy as a function of the time and temperature of reactor service is estimated from the kinetics of thermal embrittlement, which are also determined from the chemical composition. The fracture toughness J-R curve for the aged material is then obtained by correlating RT Charpy-impact energy with fracture toughness parameters. A common “predicted lower-bound” J-R curve for CASS materials of unknown chemical composition is also defined for a given grade of material, range of ferrite content, and temperature. In addition, guidance is provided for evaluating the combined effects of thermal and neutron embrittlement of CASS materials used in the reactor core internal components. The correlations for estimating the change in tensile strength, including the Ramberg/Osgood parameters for strain hardening, are also described.

Chopra, O. K.↗

Advanced Models of LWR Pressure Vessel Embrittlement for Low Flux-High Fluence Conditions

Neutron embrittlement of reactor pressure vessels (RPVs) is an unresolved issue for light water reactor life extension, especially since transition temperature shifts (TTS) must be predicted for high 80-year fluence levels up to approximately 1,020 n/cm 2 , far beyond the current surveillance database. Unfortunately, TTS may accelerate at high fluence, and may be further amplified by the formation of late blooming phases that result in severe embrittlement even in low-copper (Cu) steels. Embrittlement by this mechanism is a potentially significant degradation phenomenon that is not predicted by current regulatory models. This project will focus on accurately predicting transition temperature shifts at high fluence using advanced physically based, empirically validated and calibrated models. A major challenge is to develop models that can adjust test reactor data to account for flux effects. Since transition temperature shifts depend on synergistic combinations of many variables, flux-effects cannot be treated in isolation. The best current models systematically and significantly under-predict transition temperature at high fluence, although predominantly for irradiations at much higher flux than actual RPV service. This project will integrate surveillance, test reactor and mechanism data with advanced models to address a number of outstanding RPV embrittlement issues. The effort will include developing new databases and preliminary models of flux effects for irradiation conditions ranging from very low (e.g., boiling water reactor) to high (e.g., accelerated test reactor). The team will also develop a database and physical models to help predict the conditions for the formation of Mn-Ni-Si late blooming phases and to guide future efforts to fully resolve this issue. Researchers will carry out other tasks on a best-effort basis, including prediction of transition temperature shift attenuation through the vessel wall, remediation of embrittlement by annealing, and fracture toughness master curve issues.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Slow Strain Rate Testing for Hydrogen Embrittlement Susceptibility of Alloy 718 in Substitute Ocean Water

The hydrogen embrittlement susceptibility of near-peak-aged UNS N07718 (Alloy 718) was evaluated by performing slow strain rate tests at room temperature in air and substitute ocean water. Tests in substitute ocean water were accomplished in an environmental cell that enabled in situ cathodic charging under an applied potential of −1.1 V versus SCE. Some specimens were cathodically precharged for 4 or 16 weeks at the same potential in a 3.5 wt.% NaCl-distilled water solution at 50 °C. Unprecharged specimens tested in substitute ocean water exhibited only moderate embrittlement with plastic strain to failure decreasing by about 20% compared to unprecharged specimens tested in air. However, precharged specimens exhibited significant embrittlement with plastic strain to failure decreasing by about 70%. Test environment (air or substitute ocean water with in situ charging) and precharge time (4 or 16 weeks) had little effect on the results of the precharged specimens. Fracture surfaces of precharged specimens were typical of hydrogen embrittlement and consisted of an outer brittle ring related to the region in which hydrogen infused during precharging, a finely dimpled transition zone probably related to the region where hydrogen was drawn in by dislocation transport, and a central highly dimpled ductile region. Fracture surfaces of unprecharged specimens tested in substitute ocean water consisted of a finely dimpled outer ring and heavily dimpled central region typical of ductile fracture.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗