Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Criticality Evaluations”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Overview of Experiments for Physics of Fast Reactors from the International Handbooks of Evaluated Criticality Safety Benchmark Experiments and Evaluated Reactor Physics Benchmark Experiments

Overview of Experiments to Study the Physics of Fast Reactors Represented in the International Directories of Critical and Reactor Experiments John D. Bess Idaho National Laboratory Jim Gulliford, Tatiana Ivanova Nuclear Energy Agency of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development E.V.Rozhikhin, M.Yu.Sem?nov, A.M.Tsibulya Institute of Physics and Power Engineering The study the physics of fast reactors traditionally used the experiments presented in the manual labor of the Working Group on Evaluation of sections CSEWG (ENDF-202) issued by the Brookhaven National Laboratory in 1974. This handbook presents simplified homogeneous model experiments with relevant experimental data, as amended. The Nuclear Energy Agency of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development coordinates the activities of two international projects on the collection, evaluation and documentation of experimental data - the International Project on the assessment of critical experiments (1994) and the International Project on the assessment of reactor experiments (since 2005). The result of the activities of these projects are replenished every year, an international directory of critical (ICSBEP Handbook) and reactor (IRPhEP Handbook) experiments. The handbooks present detailed models of experiments with minimal amendments. Such models are of particular interest in terms of the settlements modern programs. The directories contain a large number of experiments which are suitable for the study of physics of fast reactors. Many of these experiments were performed at specialized critical stands, such as BFS (Russia), ZPR and ZPPR (USA), the ZEBRA (UK) and the experimental reactor JOYO (Japan), FFTF (USA). Other experiments, such as compact metal assembly, is also of interest in terms of the physics of fast reactors, they have been carried out on the universal critical stands in Russian institutes (VNIITF and VNIIEF) and the US (LANL, LLNL, and others.). Also worth mentioning is the critical experiments with fast reactor fuel rods in water, interesting in terms of justification of nuclear safety during transportation and storage of fresh and spent fuel. These reports provide a detailed review of the experiment, designate the area of their application and include results of calculations on modern systems of constants in comparison with the estimated experimental data.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Identification of Integral Benchmarks for Nuclear Data Testing Using DICE (Database for the International Handbook of Evaluated Criticality Safety Benchmark Experiments)

Typical users of the International Criticality Safety Evaluation Project (ICSBEP) Handbook have specific criteria to which they desire to find matching experiments. Depending on the application, those criteria may consist of any combination of physical or chemical characteristics and/or various neutronic parameters. The ICSBEP Handbook contains a structured format helping the user narrow the search for experiments of interest. However, with nearly 4300 different experimental configurations and the ever increasing addition of experimental data, the necessity to perform multiple criteria searches have rendered these features insufficient. As a result, a relational database was created with information extracted from the ICSBEP Handbook. A users’ interface was designed by OECD and DOE to allow the interrogation of this database. The database and the corresponding users’ interface are referred to as DICE. DICE currently offers the capability to perform multiple criteria searches that go beyond simple fuel, physical form and spectra and includes expanded general information, fuel form, moderator/coolant, neutron-absorbing material, cladding, reflector, separator, geometry, benchmark results, spectra, and neutron balance parameters. DICE also includes the capability to display graphical representations of neutron spectra, detailed neutron balance, sensitivity coefficients for capture, fission, elastic scattering, inelastic scattering, nu-bar and mu-bar, as well as several other features.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Critical Evaluation of a Novel Analysis Technique for Assessment of Printed Circuit Heat Exchangers in High-Temperature Nuclear Service

Application of printed circuit heat exchangers (PCHEs) to very high-temperature reactors (VHTRs) requires mechanical performance assessment methodologies. The PCHE morphology consists of thousands of millimeter-scale channels, for enhanced thermal efficiency, enclosed in a meter-scale PCHE core. PCHE geometry under thermomechanical creep-fatigue transients results in multi-axial interactions between its different segments, such as channeled core, walls, and headers. These global-level interactions influence the local channel-level responses. Hence, developing a PCHE performance assessment methodology, following the ASME Code, Section III, Division 5 provisions, is a critical gap to be filled. There is no analysis or design methodology available in ASME Code to assess a PCHE for its global and local level performances under high temperature and pressure loadings. This paper critically evaluates a recently proposed two-step analysis technique to estimate global interactions and local channel-level responses of PCHEs. In this novel analysis technique, the channeled PCHE core is replaced with orthotropic solid blocks of representative stiffness properties for the global thermomechanical analysis. Here, subsequent channel scale submodel analysis with detailed channel geometry, loading, and elastic-perfectly plastic (EPP) material model estimates the local responses for PCHE performance assessment. This paper critically evaluates this novel technique for its effectiveness in PCHE performance assessment. Finite element (FE) models imitating various analysis issues are developed, and FE analysis results are scrutinized. An important outcome of this study is the validation of the novel two-step PCHE analysis technique for application to the performance assessment of PCHEs in VHTRs.

42 ENGINEERING↗

A critical evaluation of worst case optimization methods for robust intensity-modulated proton therapy planning

Purpose: To critically evaluate and compare three worst case optimization methods that have been previously employed to generate intensity-modulated proton therapy treatment plans that are robust against systematic errors. The goal of the evaluation is to identify circumstances when the methods behave differently and to describe the mechanism behind the differences when they occur. Methods: The worst case methods optimize plans to perform as well as possible under the worst case scenario that can physically occur (composite worst case), the combination of the worst case scenarios for each objective constituent considered independently (objectivewise worst case), and the combination of the worst case scenarios for each voxel considered independently (voxelwise worst case). These three methods were assessed with respect to treatment planning for prostate under systematic setup uncertainty. An equivalence with probabilistic optimization was used to identify the scenarios that determine the outcome of the optimization. Results: If the conflict between target coverage and normal tissue sparing is small and no dose-volume histogram (DVH) constraints are present, then all three methods yield robust plans. Otherwise, they all have their shortcomings: Composite worst case led to unnecessarily low plan quality in boundary scenarios that were less difficult than the worst case ones. Objectivewise worst case generally led to nonrobust plans. Voxelwise worst case led to overly conservative plans with respect to DVH constraints, which resulted in excessive dose to normal tissue, and less sharp dose fall-off than the other two methods. Conclusions: The three worst case methods have clearly different behaviors. These behaviors can be understood from which scenarios that are active in the optimization. No particular method is superior to the others under all circumstances: composite worst case is suitable if the conflicts are not very severe or there are DVH constraints whereas voxelwise worst case is advantageous if there are severe conflicts but no DVH constraints. The advantages of composite and voxelwise worst case outweigh those of objectivewise worst case.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Critical evaluation and modeling of algal harvesting using dissolved air flotation. DAF Algal Harvesting Modeling

In our study, Chlorella zofingiensis harvesting by dissolved air flotation (DAF) was critically evaluated with regard to algal concentration, culture conditions, type and dosage of coagulants, and recycle ratio. Harvesting efficiency increased with coagulant dosage and leveled off at 81%, 86%, 91%, and 87% when chitosan, Al 3+ , Fe 3+ , and cetyl trimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) were used at dosages of 70, 180, 250, and 500 mg g -1 , respectively. The DAF efficiency-coagulant dosage relationship changed with algal culture conditions. In evaluating the influence of the initial algal concentration and recycle ratio revealed that, under conditions typical for algal harvesting, we found that it is possible that the number of bubbles is insufficient. A DAF algal harvesting model was developed to explain this observation by introducing mass-based floc size distributions and a bubble limitation into the white water blanket model. Moreover, the model revealed the importance of coagulation to increase floc-bubble collision and attachment, and the preferential interaction of bubbles with larger flocs, which limited the availability of bubbles to the smaller sized flocs. The harvesting efficiencies predicted by the model agree reasonably with experimental data obtained at different Al 3+ dosages, algal concentrations, and recycle ratios. Based on this modeling, critical parameters for efficient algal harvesting were identified.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗

Fast Algorithm for Evaluating Critical Current of High-Temperature Superconducting Pancake Coil

Second-generation (2G) high-temperature superconducting (HTS) tapes are now capable of carrying very high transport current and promising for a wide range of applications. The critical current of HTS coils is important for applications, such as superconducting electric machines, superconducting magnetic energy storage, and superconducting magnets. Therefore, precisely and quickly calculating critical current of HTS coils is very important for designing HTS devices. This paper provides a fast algorithm for evaluating critical current of HTS pancake coil. The fast algorithm is realized through a stationary model, which is based on finite element method (FEM) software. The stationary model means that the model is solved by stationary study instead of time-dependent study. To validate this method, a pancake HTS coil was wound and its critical current was measured. Meanwhile, an axial symmetric stationary model was built according to the geometry of the measured HTS coil. By comparing measured and calculated results, the effectiveness of the stationary model was demonstrated. Moreover, the stationary model is compared with H formulation model. The calculated results by the two models are nearly the same. However, by using stationary calculation, the stationary model can remarkably speed up the computational process. Due to the advantage of calculating speed, the stationary model can be used to characterize and design large-scale HTS applications.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Opinion: A critical evaluation of the evidence for aerosol invigoration of deep convection

Deep convective updraft invigoration via indirect effects of increased aerosol number concentration on cloud microphysics is frequently cited as a driver of correlations between aerosol and deep convection properties. Here, we critically evaluate the theoretical, modeling, and observational evidence for warm- and cold-phase invigoration pathways. Though warm-phase invigoration is plausible and theoretically supported via lowering of the supersaturation with increased cloud droplet concentration in polluted conditions, the significance of this effect depends on substantial supersaturation changes in real-world convective clouds that have not been observed. Much of the theoretical support for cold-phase invigoration depends on unrealistic assumptions of instantaneous freezing and unloading of condensate in growing, isolated updrafts. When applying more realistic assumptions, impacts on buoyancy from enhanced latent heating via fusion in polluted conditions are largely canceled by greater condensate loading. Many foundational observational studies supporting invigoration have several fundamental methodological flaws that render their findings incorrect or highly questionable. Thus, much of the evidence for invigoration has come from numerical modeling, but different models and setups have produced a vast range of results. Furthermore, modeled aerosol impacts on deep convection are rarely tested for robustness, and microphysical biases relative to observations persist, rendering many results unreliable for application to the real world. Without clear theoretical, modeling, or observational support, and given that enervation rather than invigoration may occur for some deep convective regimes and environments, it is entirely possible that the overall impact of cold-phase invigoration is negligible. Substantial mesoscale variability of dominant thermodynamic controls on convective updraft strength coupled with substantial updraft and aerosol variability in any given event are poorly quantified by observations and present further challenges to isolating aerosol effects. Observational isolation and quantification of convective invigoration by aerosols is also complicated by limitations of available cloud condensation nuclei and updraft speed proxies, aerosol correlations with meteorological conditions, and cloud impacts on aerosols. Furthermore, many cloud processes, such as entrainment and condensate fallout, modulate updraft strength and aerosol–cloud interactions, varying with cloud life cycle and organization, but these processes remain poorly characterized. Considering these challenges, recommendations for future observational and modeling research related to aerosol invigoration of deep convection are provided.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Critically evaluated theoretical energies, lifetimes, hyperfine constants, and multipole polarizabilities in {sup 87}Rb

Systematic study of Rb atomic properties is carried out using a high-precision relativistic all-order method. Excitation energies of the ns, np, nd, and nf (n{<=}10) states in neutral rubidium are evaluated. Reduced matrix elements, oscillator strengths, transition rates, and lifetimes are determined for the levels up to n=8. Recommended values and estimates of their uncertainties are provided for a large number of electric-dipole transitions. Electric-dipole (5s-np, n=5-26), electric-quadrupole (5s-nd{sub j}, n=4-26), and electric-octupole (5s-nf{sub j}, n=4-26) matrix elements are calculated to obtain the ground state E1, E2, and E3 static polarizabilities. Scalar polarizabilities of the ns, np, and nd states, and tensor polarizabilities of the np{sub 3/2} and nd excited states of Rb are evaluated. The hyperfine A and B values in {sup 87}Rb are determined for the first low-lying levels up to n=9. These calculations provide recommended values critically evaluated for their accuracy for a number of Rb atomic properties useful for a variety of applications.

74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗

Critical Evaluation and Thermodynamic Optimization of the Li{sub 2}O-Al{sub 2}O{sub 3} and Li{sub 2}O-MgO-Al{sub 2}O{sub 3} Systems

The thermodynamic and phase diagram data of the Li{sub 2}O-Al{sub 2}O{sub 3} and Li{sub 2}O-MgO-Al{sub 2}O{sub 3} systems were critically evaluated and optimized to obtain a set of consistent Gibbs energy functions for all phases in the systems. The LiAl{sub 5}O{sub 8}-MgAl{sub 2}O{sub 4} spinel solid solution was modeled with the two-sublattice compound energy formalism by considering the cation distribution between the tetrahedral and octahedral sites and excess vacancy in octahedral sites. The liquid phase and monoxide solid solution were also described using the modified quasichemical model with pair approximation and the Bragg–Williams random mixing model, respectively. The thermodynamic models with optimized model parameters enable the reproduction of all reliable thermodynamic and phase diagram as well as spinel structural data in the system.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Criticality Evaluation of Low Density Product Oxides for Air Transport for the ES-3100 Package

This document presents the criticality safety evaluation of the Y-12 National Security Complex (Y-12) Model ES-3100 package for the addition of lower bulk density limits for HEU product oxides transported by air. The current authorized oxide density range for air transport is 2.0 to 6.54 g/cm 3 . The analysis in this report looks at lower densities, specifically in the range of 1.0 to 2.0 g/cm 3 . For reasons presented in this report, it was decided to present the entire range of oxide densities (1.0 to 6.54 g/cm 3 ) as a series of sub-ranges. The lowest density in each range was evaluated. Thus calculations were performed for the following oxide densities: 5.0 g/cm 3 , 4.0 g/cm 3 , 3.0 g/cm 3 , 2.0 g/cm 3 , 1.5 g/cm 3 and 1.0 g/cm 3 . Calculations presented herein were performed using a third generation computing platform; the Microway Parallel Linux Cluster ENGHPC workstation using the Monte Carlo Criticality Safety Analysis Sequence (CSAS5) criticality code sequence and 238-group ENDF/B-VII cross-section library of Standardized Computer Analysis for Licensing Evaluation (SCALE) 6.1.3 (ORNL/TM-2005/39, SCALE: A Comprehensive Modeling and Simulation Suite for Nuclear Safety Analysis and Design).

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Critical Evaluation of the ISCCP Simulator Using Ground-Based Remote Sensing Data

Given the known shortcomings in representing clouds in Global Climate Models (GCM) comparisons with observations are critical. The International Satellite Cloud Climatology Project (ISCCP) diagnostic products provide global descriptions of cloud top pressure and column optical depth that extends over multiple decades. The necessary limitations of the ISCCP retrieval algorithm require that before comparisons can be made between model output and ISCCP results the model output must be modified to simulate what ISCCP would diagnose under the simulated circumstances. We evaluate one component of the so-called ISCCP simulator in this study by comparing ISCCP and a similar algorithm with various long-term statistics derived from the Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM) Southern Great Plains (SGP) Climate Research Facility ground-based remote sensors. We find that were a model to simulate the cloud radiative profile with the same accuracy as can be derived from the ARM data, then the likelihood of that occurrence being placed in the same cloud top pressure and optical depth bin as ISCCP of the 9 bins that have become standard ranges from 30% to 70% depending on optical depth. While the ISCCP simulator improved the agreement of cloud-top pressure between ground-based remote sensors and satellite observations, we find minor discrepancies due to the parameterization of cloud top pressure in the ISCCP simulator. The primary source of error seems to be related to discrepancies in visible optical depth that are not accounted for in the ISCCP simulator. We show that the optical depth discrepancies are largest when the assumptions necessary for plane parallel radiative transfer optical depths retrievals are violated.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Review of Criticality Evaluations for Direct Disposal of DPCs and Recommendations

There are currently 2,462 dual-purpose canisters (DPCs) containing spent nuclear fuel (SNF) across the United States. Repackaging DPCs into specialized disposal canisters can be financially and operationally costly with undue risks. Technical feasibility of direct disposal of DPCs has been evaluated by the Department of Energy (DOE) and industry over the past 15 years. A concerted effort most recently conducted by DOE Office of Nuclear Energy (NE) Spent Fuel and Waste Science and Technology (SFWST) research and development (R&D) programs is evaluating the technical feasibility of direct disposal of DPCs in various geologies. This report focuses on reviewing the work completed by SFWST for the criticality considerations of DPC geologic disposal. Disposal of DPCs is not only viable, but assured from a technical and assumed regulatory perspective (similar to 10 CFR 63). The analysis approach should be multi-faceted to ensure effective implementation of a licensing basis. Recommendations are provided in this report that could enhance the bases for direct disposal of DPCs by exploiting all technically attainable and regulatorily defensible options. The review objectives, including addressing several questions regarding the value of accumulating asloaded fuel and DPC design data, suitability of DPC designs for disposal, and reasonable modifications for loading of DPCs that could facilitate eventual disposal, are also addressed in this report.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Critical evaluation and thermodynamic modeling of the Pd–Sn system

The single crystalline material PdSn 4 , a homologue of the Dirac nodal arc semimetal PtSn 4 , is a promising candidate to search for new topological states with fascinating quantum physical properties. In the present work, the thermochemistry and phase diagram information of the Pd–Sn system published in the literature was collected and critically reviewed, two thermodynamic reassessments of the Pd–Sn system were carried out in the frame of the CALPHAD approach to optimize the Gibbs free energy of each phase presented in the system. The liquid phase was described using respectively the Bragg-Williams random mixing model and the associate solution model. All the reliable thermodynamic property and phase equilibria data can be generally described using the presently obtained thermodynamic descriptions of the Pd–Sn system. Issues related to the further improvement of the thermodynamic descriptions of the Pd–Sn system are discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

A critical evaluation of the NCRP COMMENTARY 27 endorsement of the linear no-threshold model of radiation effects

Highlights: • The linear no-threshold (LNT) model of radiation effects has fractured the scientific community. • This paper analyzes the latest review of the LNT model, NCRP Commentary 27. • Expert reviews of the LNT model rely on institutional inertia and numerous logical fallacies. • Recommendations to advance this debate in an objective future review are provided. Regulatory policy to protect the public and the environment from radiation is universally based on the linear, no-threshold model (LNT) of radiation effects. This model has been controversial since its inception over nine decades ago, and remains so to this day, but it has proved remarkably resistant to challenge from the scientific community. The LNT model has been repeatedly endorsed by expert advisory bodies, and regulatory agencies in turn adopt policies that reflect this advice. Unfortunately, these endorsements rest on a foundation of institutional inertia and numerous logical fallacies. These include most significantly setting the LNT as the null hypothesis, and shifting the burden of proof onto LNT skeptics. Other examples include arbitrary exclusion of alternative hypotheses, ignoring criticisms of the LNT, cherry-picking evidence, and making policy judgements without foundation. This paper presents an evaluation of the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements’ (NCRP) Commentary 27, which concluded that recent epidemiological studies are compatible with the continued use of the LNT model for radiation protection. While this report will likely provide political cover for regulators’ continued reliance on the LNT, it is a missed opportunity to advance the scientific discussion of the effects of low dose, low dose-rate radiation exposure. Due to its Congressionally chartered mission, no organization is better positioned than the NCRP to move this debate forward, and recommendations for doing so in future reviews are provided.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Valorisation of technical lignin in rigid polyurethane foam: A critical evaluation on trends, guidelines and future perspectives

Lignin is one of the most abundant aromatic natural polymers. Produced as a by-product from the biomass refinery industries, lignin remains largely underutilised in high-value industrial applications. The incorporation of lignin in rigid polyurethane foam (RPUF) has been the focus of much research, due to its potential to replace fossil fuel-based components of RPUF. However, the overall sustainability of RPUF depends on numerous factors including processability, cost-effectiveness, and retention of performance throughout the service life. To date, the incorporation of lignin has been explored either as filler particles (through direct incorporation) or as a blendable liquid polyol introduced after chemical modifications (such as oxyalkylation, functionalisation, or depolymerisation). However, the production of lignin incorporated foam with high performance through cost-effective processing is still an ongoing challenge. Herein, this review critically appraises the progress on the effective incorporation of lignin in RPUF. Firstly, this review briefly covers the essential raw materials, formulation, important properties, and sustainability aspects of RPUF for industrial applications. Secondly, it provides insights on the key parameters of lignin of relevance to incorporation into RPUF. Thirdly, it benchmarks the reported studies on incorporation of lignin in RPUF systems by evaluating their important properties and proposes potential strategies for addressing the key challenges in the incorporation of lignin in RPUF. By bridging the gaps that exist in the literature on the utilisation of lignin in RPUF this account will serve as a resource for both beginners and professionals in the polyurethane and biorefinery industries towards the successful development of lignin incorporated RPUF for industrial applications

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Critically Evaluated Energy Levels and Spectral Lines of Singly Ionized Indium (In II)

A comprehensive list of the best measured wavelengths in the In II spectrum has been compiled. Uncertainties of the wavelength measurements have been analyzed, and existing inconsistencies have been resolved. An optimized set of fine-structure energy levels that fits all observed wavelengths has been derived. Uncertainties of the energy level values have been reduced by an order of magnitude. An improved value of the ionization limit of In II has been determined by fitting quantum-defect and polarization formulas for several series of levels. Intensities of lines observed by different authors have been analyzed and converted to a uniform scale. A set of recommended values of radiative transition rates has been critically compiled, and uncertainties of these rates have been estimated. The hyperfine structure interval in the 5s 2 S ground state of In III has been determined from the measurements of the 5sng and 5snh series in In II.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Applicability of 1D site response analysis to shallow sedimentary basins: A critical evaluation through physics-based 3D ground motion simulations

One-dimensional site response analysis (1D SRA) remains the standard practice in considering the effect of local soil deposits and predicting site-specific ground motions, although its range of applicability to realistic seismic wavefields is still in question. In this 1D approach, horizontal and vertical ground shaking are assumed to be induced by vertically propagating shear and compressional waves, respectively. A recent study based on analytical two-dimensional (2D) plane waves and simple point source earthquake simulations has shown two mechanistic limitations in this 1D modelling technique for general inclined seismic waves, that is, systematic over-prediction of the vertical motion and wave trapping in the 1D soil column. In this article, we evaluate in detail the applicability of this 1D modelling approach to realistic three-dimensional (3D) simulated seismic wavefields in shallow sedimentary basins. Linear-viscoelastic 1D SRA predictions using two types of input motions that are commonly used in practice—rock outcrop and in-column motions, are compared with the reference true site response results from 3D earthquake simulations in terms of various measures in the frequency and time domain. It is shown that the horizontal motion in the 3D seismic wavefield exhibits dominant shear wave propagation phenomenon, while the vertical motion is a combined effect of compressional and shear waves and can be over-predicted by the 1D approach when the incident seismic waves are inclined. Direct evidence of the wave refraction process that leads to the vertical motion over-prediction is provided. 1D SRA with in-column inputs can yield motions that have significantly longer duration compared to the true 3D site response solution due to trapped waves, casting in doubt the frequent need for increased soil damping in existing site studies to compensate for wave attenuation due to scattering alone. Sensitivity investigation on the increase of soil profile damping by a multiplier D mul shows D mul values compatible with those found in the literature for both horizontal and vertical motions. It is shown that the level of D mul optimized for a best match of the spectral acceleration is dependent on the characteristic of the input motion and a larger D mul is typically required for the vertical component. In contrast, 1D SRA with outcrop motions predicts motions with shorter significant duration due to its inability to capture the basin-edge generated surface waves. A suite of ground motion simulations was performed to assess the sensitivity of the observations to the basin geologic structure including the velocity gradient, rock-basin impedance contrast and basin depth. The analysis results show that the accuracy of the simplified 1D procedure is dependent on the wavefield composition of both the input motions and the true 3D site response solution. While the horizontal motions in shallow sedimentary basins can, to the first order, be reasonably captured by the simplified 1D approach, 1D SRA for the vertical component is in general not reliable and contributions from inclined shear waves should be accounted for in site-specific evaluation of the vertical design ground motion.

1D assumption↗