Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Criticality Calculations”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Unbiased Ratio Estimator for k-Eigenvalue in Monte Carlo Criticality Calculations

In criticality calculations, the effective multiplication factor (k{sub eff}) is an important parameter for reactor analysis. It can be interpreted as the ratio of the neutron production rate to the loss rate in a reactor core. In Monte Carlo (MC) criticality calculations, k{sub eff} is obtained for each active cycle i as: k-i = P{sub i}/L{sub i} for I = 1 to I where P{sub i} and L{sub i} are the production rate and the loss rate at cycle i, respectively, and they are normalized by the nominal source size for cycle. Since all neutron particles in a cycle will be absorbed or leaks out at the end, the loss rate, L{sub i}, can be set as the source rate, which is the unity. Thus, in MCNP5, k{sub i} is simply calculated with P{sub i} by using three conventional estimators; collision, absorption, and track-length estimators. In domain decomposed MC criticality calculations based on the fission and surface source (FSS) iteration method, k{sub i} is calculated by a ratio of P{sub i} and L{sub i}, where both P{sub i} and L{sub i} are random variables, sampled by using the same particle histories. When the numerator and the denominator are correlated, the variance of the ratio can be smaller than that of the numerator. Then, the final estimate of k{sub eff} is provided as the sample mean of k{sub i}, which will be referred as 'simple' ratio estimator in this paper. In Ref., it is shown that this ratio estimator converges faster and fluctuates less than the conventional estimator. A similar ratio estimator is also used in Serpent 2, as an implicit estimate of k{sub eff}. However, this type of 'simple' ratio estimator is biased, which means that the expectation of the ratio is different from the ratio of the expectation of the numerator and that of the denominator. In this paper, an unbiased ratio estimator which was originally derived in the cytometry analysis is introduced to estimate k{sub eff} and is tested on a continuous-energy UO{sub 2} pin-cell problem. In this test problem, it is shown that the variance of the unbiased ratio estimator is smaller than those of the conventional estimators provided by MCNP5, while the simple ratio estimator can be significantly biased when the number of histories per cycle is too small. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Criticality calculations of the Very High Temperature Reactor Critical Assembly benchmark with Serpent and SCALE/KENO-VI

Within the framework of the IAEA Coordinated Research Project on HTGR Uncertainty Analysis in Modeling, criticality calculations of the Very High Temperature Critical Assembly experiment were performed as the validation reference to the prismatic MHTGR-350 lattice calculations. Criticality measurements performed at several temperature points at this Japanese graphite-moderated facility were recently included in the International Handbook of Evaluated Reactor Physics Benchmark Experiments and represent one of the few data sets available for the validation of HTGR lattice physics. Here, this work compares VHTRC criticality simulations utilizing the Monte Carlo codes Serpent and SCALE/KENO-VI. Reasonable agreement was found between Serpent and KENO-VI, but only the use of the latest ENDF cross section library release, namely the ENDF/B-VII.1 library, led to an improved match with the measured data. Furthermore, the fourth beta release of SCALE 6.2/KENO-VI showed significant improvements from the current SCALE 6.1.2 version, compared to the experimental values and Serpent.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

A Review of Monte Carlo Criticality Calculations - Convergence, Bias, Statistics

Monte Carlo criticality calculations have been performed for over 50 years for reactor physics and criticality safety applications. With today's faster computers, these calculations are being carried out to greater precision (smaller uncertainties) in k eff ; and detailed distributions of power and reaction rates are being computed routinely. This paper provides a review of the fundamental theory of Monte Carlo criticality calculations, with guidance on practical methods for: (1) assuring convergence of both k eff and the source distribution, (2) minimizing the bias in k eff and reaction rate distributions, and (3) dealing with the underprediction bias in uncertainties for k eff and reaction rate distributions.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

TRIPOLI-4 criticality calculations for MOX fuelled SNEAK 7A and 7B fast critical assemblies

A prototype Generation IV fast neutron reactor is under design and development in France. The MOX fuel will be introduced into this self-generating core in order to demonstrate low net plutonium production. To support the TRIPOLI-4 Monte Carlo transport code in criticality calculations of fast reactors, the effective delayed neutron fraction {beta}eff estimation and the Probability Tables (PT) option to treat the unresolved resonance region of cross-sections are two essentials. In this study, TRIPOLI-4 calculations have been made using current nuclear data libraries JEFF-3.1.1 and ENDF/B-VII.0 to benchmark the reactor physics parameters of the MOX fuelled SNEAK 7A and 7B fast critical assemblies. TRIPOLI-4 calculated K{sub eff} and {beta}eff of the homogeneous R-Z models and the 3D multi-cell models have been validated against the measured ones. The impact of the PT option on K{sub eff} is 340 {+-} 10 pcm for SNEAK 7A core and 410 {+-} 12 pcm for 7B. Four-group spectra and energy spectral indices, f8/f5, f9/f5, and c8/f5 in the two SNEAK cores have also been calculated with the TRIPOLI-4 mesh tally. Calculated spectrum-hardening index f8/f5 is 0.0418 for SNEAK 7A and 0.0315 for 7B. From this study the SNEAK 3D models have been verified for the next revision of IRPhE (International Handbook of Evaluated Reactor Physics Benchmark Experiments). (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Sensitivity and uncertainty analysis for a combined depletion and criticality calculation chain of a BWR FA

This paper examines the prerequisites and boundary conditions for extending burnup credit from pressurized water reactors to boiling water reactors with validated depletion codes by performing uncertainty and sensitivity analyses on a modern boiling water reactor fuel assembly design. We developed a computational chain consisting of an axial boiling water reactor axial irradiation model, followed by a series of depletion calculations and a three-dimensional criticality calculation. The irradiation model puts into relation the profiles of power, burnup and moderator density of the fuel assembly at 24 axial locations. In a simplified fashion it also includes the insertion of control blades. The depletion calculations of the fuel assembly were performed in axial slices with the 2D-depletion code HELIOS 1.12. The criticality calculations were done in 3D-geometry with KENO-Va from the SCALE 6.2.1 package, in which several fuel assemblies are placed into a generic transport cask. For the uncertainty and sensitivity analyses a Monte Carlo sampling based approach is used applying the GRS tool SUnCISTT. We performed several generic investigations testing the capabilities and the limitations of the whole computational chain. The impact of variations of the irradiation model on the resulting reactivity of the fuel assemblies inside a transport cask or storage pool was investigated using an uncertainty and sensitivity analysis on the whole computational chain. Geometrical uncertainties were also included in the evaluation and a parameter study on the use of control blades during irradiation was performed. The goal was to develop the procedures and tools to be able to obtain quantitative uncertainty data which can be used in the future to derive conservative irradiation profiles without unnecessary excess reactivity margins. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Diagnostics for Undersampling and Clustering in Monte Carlo Criticality Calculations

For the past 40 years, it has been known from the theoretical work of Gelbard [1] and Brissenden [2] that the results from Monte Carlo (MC) criticality calculations are biased if the number of neutrons per generation is not sufficiently large. The computed k-effective eigenvalue will be lower than the actual eigenvalue, and the computed eigenfunction will be too low in high-importance regions and too high in low-importance regions. This difficulty is commonly called the undersampling problem for criticality calculations. The biases for undersampling were confirmed for practical, realistic problems with modern MC codes by Brown [3]. The solution to undersampling is simple - use a larger number of neutrons per generation to reduce the biases to levels that are negligible. Over the past few years, the OECD-NEA-WPNCS Expert Group on Advanced Monte Carlo Techniques (EGAMCT) [4,5,6] investigated an extreme form of undersampling called clustering. When the number of neutrons per generation is small, neutrons in successive generations tend to group together (cluster) due to correlations, and the clusters tend to migrate through the problem space. While the problems of undersampling and clustering are well known and well understood theoretically, there were no existing diagnostics for MC codes to determine whether a given calculation is using sufficient neutrons per generation to eliminate these problems. That is, no tools were available to diagnose biases due to undersampling or clustering. The tools described herein resolve this longstanding problem by providing 2 robust methods for detecting undersampling and clustering in MC criticality calculations. The diagnosis of undersampling and clustering is part of a larger effort to thoroughly overhaul the calculational methods for criticality problems, providing for automated sampling of the initial fission distribution, acceleration of the iteration convergence process, automated detection of convergence in the iterations and starting of the active tally cycles, and the diagnosis of undersampling. All of these new methods have been prototyped in a local modified version of mcnp6.2 [7] and tested on a variety of critical systems.

74 ATOMIC AND MOLECULAR PHYSICS↗

Experimental validation of the Cristal V2.0 French criticality calculation package - 14587

A new version of the CRISTAL criticality calculation package, named CRISTAL V2.0 [1], has been developed by IRSN and CEA, in collaboration with AREVA and EDF. Four calculation routes are now available, using nuclear data issued from the JEFF-3.1.1 evaluation: two multigroup routes based on 281 groups cross-sections (APOLLO2 - MORET 5 or APOLLO2-Sn calculations), a pointwise Monte Carlo route (TRIPOLI-4{sup R}) and a criticality standard calculation route. The CRISTAL V2.0 package, which will be delivered soon to OECD/NEA data bank, benefits from a broad validation database covering almost all areas of criticality-safety applications, from fuel fabrication to reprocessing, including transportation. 3,127 critical experiments, corresponding to 342 series, either issued from the OECD/ICSBEP Handbook or performed in French facilities (confidential data) were selected for the CRISTAL V2.0 validation database. Currently, more than 2,300 experiments are already part of the validation database. This validation work highlights an overall consistency to experimental data and inter-comparisons between the different calculation routes mainly show good agreements on a large set of common experiments. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Validation of Scale 6.2 criticality calculations using KENO V.A and KENO-VI - 14603

SCALE 6.2 provides enhancements for criticality calculations relative to SCALE 6.1, especially with updated nuclear data libraries, resonance self-shielding options for multigroup (MG) calculations, and problem-dependent temperature treatments for continuous-energy (CE) calculations. Benchmark experiments from the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project that are available in the Oak Ridge National Laboratory Verified, Archived, Library of Inputs and Data (VALID) were applied in this validation effort to examine the impact of the SCALE 6.2 enhancements. Over 300 cases are drawn from the VALID library for testing KENO V.a, and a more limited set of approximately 50 configurations is used for validation of KENO-VI. A total of 401 unique critical experiments are used in this validation effort. In some cases, the KENO V.a models were converted to KENO-VI models so that the performance of both codes could be assessed for the same systems. Validation results for the SCALE 6.2 ENDF/B-VII.1 nuclear data libraries are presented, including MG neutron data in 56- and 252-group structures as well as CE data. The performance of all three multipurpose neutron libraries in calculating k{sub eff} is examined with critical experiment models covering a wide range of fuels, moderators, reflectors, absorbers, and neutron spectra. The SCALE 6.2 ENDF/B-VII.1 coupled neutron-photon library, primarily developed for shielding applications with 200 neutron groups and 47 gamma groups, provides additional energy resolution for fast systems relative to the MG neutron libraries which were developed to produce low biases for thermal neutron systems. The applicability of this library to criticality calculations for fast neutron spectrum systems is not investigated here but will be addressed in the final SCALE 6.2 validation report. The results of these calculations demonstrate that SCALE 6.2 generally provides lower biases than SCALE 6.1 and that the two versions of KENO provide equivalent results on the same suite of problems. SCALE 6.2 also includes an updated neutron cross-section covariance library based on the ENDF/B-VII.1 covariance data. The effect of these updated covariances on the uncertainty in k{sub eff} due to cross section uncertainties is also presented for some cases. A more thorough investigation of the updated covariance data is presented in a companion paper. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Statistical Uncertainty Analysis Applied to Criticality Calculation

In this paper, we present an uncertainty methodology based on a statistical approach, for assessing uncertainties in criticality prediction using monte carlo method due to uncertainties in the isotopic composition of the fuel. The methodology has been applied to criticality calculations with MCNP5 with additional stochastic input of the isotopic fuel composition. The stochastic input were generated using the latin hypercube sampling method based one the probability density function of each nuclide composition. The automatic passing of the stochastic input to the MCNP and the repeated criticality calculation is made possible by using a python script to link the MCNP and our latin hypercube sampling code.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

CRISTAL V2: New package for criticality calculations

A new release of the CRISTAL French criticality calculation package, named CRISTAL V2, has been developed and intensively validated by IRSN and CEA, in collaboration with AREVA. This package was designed to cover the needs of criticality practitioners in the fields of nuclear fuel cycle facilities and transportation of fissile materials. Based on an optimized modular architecture in an updated software development environment, the design of CRISTAL package V2 integrates new generation of cross-section libraries, new calculation schemes consistent with new applications, and up-to-date calculation codes capabilities. Four calculation routes are currently available allowing multi-group and continuous energy calculations. The validation database is composed of more than 3000 critical experiments, in order to cover a wide range of configurations. The CRISTAL V2 package also includes customer services covering a large scope of activities like documentations, hotline, maintenance and training courses. A significant promotion and an increased recognition referred both nationally and internationally are foreseen, including the provision of the CRISTAL V2 package to the OECD / NEA Data Bank. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Acceleration of Monte Carlo Criticality Calculations Using Deterministic-Based Starting Sources

A new automatic approach that uses approximate deterministic solutions for providing the starting fission source for Monte Carlo eigenvalue calculations was evaluated in this analysis. By accelerating the Monte Carlo source convergence and decreasing the number of cycles that has to be skipped before the tally's estimation, this approach was found to increase the efficiency of the overall simulation, even with the inclusion of the extra computational time required by the deterministic calculation. This approach was also found to increase the reliability of the Monte Carlo criticality calculations of loosely coupled systems because the use of the better starting source reduces the likelihood of producing an undersampled k eff due to the inadequate source convergence. The efficiency improvement was demonstrated using two of the standard test problems devised by the OECD/NEA Expert Group on Source Convergence in Criticality-Safety Analysis to measure the source convergence in Monte Carlo criticality calculations. For a fixed uncertainty objective, this approach increased the efficiency of the overall simulation by factors between 1.2 and 3 depending on the difficulty of the source convergence in these problems. The reliability improvement was demonstrated in a modified version of the 'k eff of the world' problem that was specifically designed to demonstrate the limitations of the current Monte Carlo power iteration techniques. For this problem, the probability of obtaining a clearly undersampled k eff decreased from 5% with a uniform starting source to zero with a deterministic starting source when batch sizes with more than 15,000 neutron/cycle were used.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Criticality Calculations with MCNP6 - Practical Lectures

These slides are used to teach MCNP (Monte Carlo N-Particle) usage to nuclear criticality safety analysts. The following are the lecture topics: course information, introduction, MCNP basics, criticality calculations, advanced geometry, tallies, adjoint-weighted tallies and sensitivities, physics and nuclear data, parameter studies, NCS validation I, NCS validation II, NCS validation III, case study 1 - solution tanks, case study 2 - fuel vault, case study 3 - B&W core, case study 4 - simple TRIGA, case study 5 - fissile mat. vault, criticality accident alarm systems. After completion of this course, you should be able to: Develop an input model for MCNP; Describe how cross section data impact Monte Carlo and deterministic codes; Describe the importance of validation of computer codes and how it is accomplished; Describe the methodology supporting Monte Carlo codes and deterministic codes; Describe pitfalls of Monte Carlo calculations; Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of Monte Carlo and Discrete Ordinants codes; The diffusion theory model is not strictly valid for treating fissile systems in which neutron absorption, voids, and/or material boundaries are present. In the context of these limitations, identify a fissile system for which a diffusion theory solution would be adequate.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Automated convergence detection in Monte Carlo criticality calculations using student's bridge statistics based on K{sub eff} or Shannon entropy

Monte Carlo (MC) criticality calculations are based on an iterative method. It requires a converged fission source distribution before beginning tallying the effective multiplication factor (K{sub eff}) or other quantities of interest. However, it is pretty difficult to locate on the run, the end of the source convergence and scores may be biased by an initial transient. This paper deals with a method that locates and suppresses the transient due to the initialization in an output series, applied here to K{sub eff} and Shannon entropy. It relies on modeling stationary series by an order 1 auto regressive process and applying statistical tests based on a Student Bridge statistics. It should be noticed that the initial transient suppression only aims at obtaining stationary output series and cannot guarantee any kind of convergence. The truncation method is applied on both K{sub eff} and Shannon entropy on three test cases. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Statistical Tests for Diagnosing Fission Source Convergence and Undersampling in Monte Carlo Criticality Calculations [Slides]

There is a very strong need for statistical testing to determine fission source convergence in Monte Carlo criticality calculations. Automation of such tests will greatly streamline and support the work carried out by NCS practitioners. Recent R&D work has shown that no single statistical test for convergence is sufficiently reliable, robust, and “guaranteed.” However, a combination of several standard statistical tests for the similarity of distributions, coupled with a high-fidelity estimate of the fission-matrix source is sufficiently robust, reliable, and repeatable that convergence can be “guaranteed.” During the course of the EG-AMCT studies, a number of statistical metrics and tests were proposed for diagnosing clustering and undersampling. None of these was robust and reliable enough for practical use in production codes. However, the expert group efforts came close. Some recent R&D work stemming from those past efforts has been very successful and promising. This Sub-Group will provide international input and collaboration on the development and implementation of statistical tests for convergence, with the primary goal of having the MC codes automatically detect convergence (or lack thereof). Newly proposed statistical tests to detect undersampling (after convergence) will also be reviewed.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Statistical Tests for Convergence in Monte Carlo Criticality Calculations

This report describes methods for using statistical tests to automatically determine convergence of Monte Carlo (MC) iterations in criticality calculations. The methods described herein are intended to replace the traditional approach used for the past 60 years: make a trial run; determine convergence based on plots of k-effective and Shannon entropy vs cycle; adjust the input parameters for controlling the iterations; make a final run to obtain results and statistics.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

A hybrid Monte Carlo and response matrix Monte Carlo method in criticality calculation

Full core calculations are very useful and important in reactor physics analysis, especially in computing the full core power distributions, optimizing the refueling strategies and analyzing the depletion of fuels. To reduce the computing time and accelerate the convergence, a method named Response Matrix Monte Carlo (RMMC) method based on analog Monte Carlo simulation was used to calculate the fixed source neutron transport problems in repeated structures. To make more accurate calculations, we put forward the RMMC method based on non-analog Monte Carlo simulation and investigate the way to use RMMC method in criticality calculations. Then a new hybrid RMMC and MC (RMMC+MC) method is put forward to solve the criticality problems with combined repeated and flexible geometries. This new RMMC+MC method, having the advantages of both MC method and RMMC method, can not only increase the efficiency of calculations, also simulate more complex geometries rather than repeated structures. Several 1-D numerical problems are constructed to test the new RMMC and RMMC+MC method. The results show that RMMC method and RMMC+MC method can efficiently reduce the computing time and variations in the calculations. Finally, the future research directions are mentioned and discussed at the end of this paper to make RMMC method and RMMC+MC method more powerful. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗