Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Catalytic reactions”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

PFOA catalytic reaction mechanisms on zerovalent iron (Fe 0 ): A DFT investigation

In this study, density functional theory (DFT) calculations with dispersion corrections are employed to investigate catalytic reactions of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) onto zerovalent iron (Fe 0 ). The main goal of this investigation is to explain the reaction mechanisms, including bond dissociation energies, activation barriers, and rate-determining steps (RDSs), of PFOA degradation. Additionally, we aim to reveal the catalytic effects of Fe 0 by comparing the reaction energy profile for the degradation of PFOA both in solution (i.e., isolated) and after adsorption on Fe 0 . Along with investigating previously reported pathways, this study proposes a new PFOA degradation pathway on Fe0. Overall, the results revealed that Fe 0 plays a key role in the catalytic degradation of PFOA, significantly affecting the RDSs and increasing defluorination rates. For instance, the activation barrier for the decarboxylation step significantly decreased from 3.08 eV to 1.11 eV over the Fe0 surface, while the activation barrier for F dissociation decreased from ∼5 eV to 0.54 eV. Additionally, the proposed pathway in this study (i.e., successive defluorination) was found to be the most favorable pathway for PFOA degradation on Fe 0 . Taken together, the DFT results are consistent with reported experimental findings and provide critical insights that will help advance the design of catalysts for PFAS degradation.

Catalysis↗
DOE OSTI2026

Transient Catalytic Reaction Analysis Through Signal Defragmentation

The Temporal Analysis of Products (TAP) pulse response technique provides valuable insights into catalytic function and reaction kinetics. However, complex fragmentation patterns in the TAP mass spectrometry signals can complicate precise quantification, particularly when analyzing transient gas flux data typical of TAP experiments. This work demonstrates a standard defragmentation method that deconvolves transient TAP signals while maintaining the temporal resolution of the experiment. First, the integrals of calibration gas fluxes are used to determine the fingerprint fragmentation pattern and construct a fragmentation matrix. This matrix is then used to defragment experimental flux data at each recorded time point via a non-negative least squares regression. The effectiveness of this method is demonstrated using virtual data and control experiments with a TAP reactor system. The defragmentation is then applied to the more complex propane dehydrogenation reaction on a chromia/alumina catalyst, which can contain up to ten significant gas species in the reactor outlet. Initial propane pulsing reveals an induction period during which propane is fully oxidized to CO2, followed by partial reduction to CO. Afterwards, there is a transition in chemistries towards coking and propylene production. Our example illustrates a practical method for the accurate determination of the time-dependent reactant/product concentrations and rates for a thorough analysis of the propane dehydrogenation kinetics. This approach can be broadly applied to any transient mass spectrometry experiment for a better understanding of catalyst-reaction dynamics.

36 - MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Catalytic Reaction Intermediates Revealed with Femtosecond M-edge XANES (Final Technical Report)

The major goals of this work were to measure the electronic structure of earth-abundant catalysts at key steps in their catalytic cycles using ultrafast UV/Visible, Extreme Ultraviolet, and X-ray spectroscopy. Our central idea was that by using these sophisticated probes, we could uncover hidden reaction mechanisms and provide guidance for catalyst design. A second major goal was the development of Extreme Ultraviolet (XUV) spectroscopy as an accessible, tabletop probe of transition metal electronic structure. Spectra in this 30-100 eV energy range probe 3d→3p transitions in 3d metals and 5p/4f→5d transitions in 5d metals, and share the oxidation state, spin state, and ligand field specificity of hard X-ray spectroscopy. The Vura-Weis group previously established the basic utility of this technique for measuring the excited-state cascades of transition metal chromophores, and in this grant we intended to extend its scope to catalytic intermediates.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Mechanistic Insights into Adsorptive and Catalytic Reactions from Controllable Distributions of Metal Cations (Pd, Pt, Ni, Cr, Cu) as [M‐OH] +1 /1Al or M +2 /2Al in Zeolites

Anchoring divalent metal ions in the same zeolite framework with similar Si/Al ratio selectively as zeolite-bound M +2 or [M +2 -OH] +1 cationic species enables critical comparison of the species’ intrinsic reactivity for industrially and fundamentally relevant reactions. H-BEA zeolites with similar Si/Al ratios but differing framework Al siting were used to anchored multiple divalent metal cations (Ni, Pd, Pt, Cr, Cu) in the zeolite micropores. State-of-the-art infrared (IR) spectroscopy, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) measurements, including two-dimensional pulsed HYSCORE EPR, extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS), and density functional theory (DFT) calculations together provide unambiguous evidence for the selective formation of divalent metal cations as M +2 /2Al species (for H-BEA prepared in the conventional hydroxide media), and [M +2 OH] +1 /1Al species for H-BEA prepared in HF. Solid-state proton-decoupled triple-quantum magic-angle spinning (3Q MAS) NMR measurements confirmed contrasting Al distributions in the two H-BEA zeolites, which led to a contrasting divalent cation speciation. The reactivities of the two cationic species were explored for catalytic and adsorptive applications in both organometallic homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis. This work demonstrates their divergent reactivity in ethylene dimerization, ethylene oxidation (Wacker process), selective catalytic reduction (SCR) of NO, NO adsorption, and methane oxidation. Both M +2 /2Al and [M +2 OH] +1 /1Al cations are both active for ethylene dimerization, but [M +2 OH] +1 /1Al species show higher reaction rates for each Pd, Ni, Pt. [M +2 OH] +1 /1Al is active for acetaldehyde formation in Wacker ethylene oxidation. A new active site for ethylene oligomerization is proposed that possesses a terminal OH group (Cr-OH) in Phillips catalysts evident by a nearly inactive isolated Cr +2 /2Al species that contrast an active Cr─OH motif.

Divalent metal cations in a zeolite↗
DOE OSTI2024

Catalytic Resonance Theory: The Catalytic Mechanics of Programmable Ratchets

Catalytic reaction networks of multiple elementary steps operating under dynamic conditions via a programmed input oscillation are difficult to interpret and optimize due to reaction system complexity. To understand these dynamic systems, individual elementary catalytic reactions oscillating between catalyst states were evaluated to identify their three fundamental characteristics that define their ability to promote reactions away from equilibrium. First, elementary catalytic reactions exhibit directionality to promote reactions forward or backward from equilibrium as determined by a ratchet directionality metric comprised of the input oscillation duty cycle and the reaction rate constants. Second, catalytic ratchets are defined by the catalyst state of strong or weak binding that permit reactants to proceed through the transition state. Third, elementary catalytic ratchets exhibit a cutoff frequency which defines the transition in applied frequency for which the catalytic ratchet functions to promote chemistry away from equilibrium. All three ratchet characteristics are calculated from chemical reaction parameters including rate constants derived from linear scaling parameters, reaction conditions, and catalyst state. The characteristics of the reaction network’s constituent elementary catalytic reactions provided an interpretation of complex reaction networks and a method of predicting the behavior of dynamic surface chemistry on oscillating catalysts.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Multifunctional Catalysts for the Tandem Reactions of Oxygenates

Industrially-relevant catalytic reactions rarely consist of a simple sequence of elementary steps. Moreover, kinetic coupling of multiple reactions on a catalyst surface is highly desired for process intensification and improved energy efficiency for large scale chemical transformations. The shifting landscape of hydrocarbon chemical feedstocks in the US also motivates research on the selective conversion of more complex molecules. One desirable type of catalytic reaction is the reduction of carboxylic acids that are produced from biomass feedstocks to their corresponding alcohols. The proposed research explores the fundamental importance of hydrogen spillover on a multifunctional catalyst for carboxylic acid reduction with H 2 composed of metal particles coupled to metal oxide particles. Recent work has demonstrated the excellent performance of supported tungsten oxide clusters for carboxylic acid reduction, but only after they are promoted with a late transition metal such as palladium. Elucidating the active state of the catalyst and the associated reaction mechanism for acid reduction on that active state are the overall goals of the proposed project and successful completion will enable future design of efficient multifunctional catalysts. The critically important role of the metal promoter is hypothesized to be its ability to dissociate H2 and spillover atomic H to the support. Although hydrogen spillover is a well-recognized phenomenon in catalysis, its role in both catalyst activation and catalytic turnover are still unresolved. The study combined materials synthesis, characterization, reactivity testing, and molecular simulations, to explore the effect of hydrogen chemical potential on the formation of the active catalytic sites and on the steady state catalytic reduction of carboxylic acid. Varying the hydrogen chemical potential through modification of the gas conditions, support composition, and metal loading to modulated the structure and catalytic performance of the reducible metal oxide. Dual function catalysts containing supported Pd and WO x species co-located on a non-reducible carrier (silica) and a reducible carrier (titania) were synthesized and characterized by electron microscopy, temperature-programmed reduction, and chemisorption. Spectroscopic methods such as X-ray absorption and UV-vis were also used to evaluate the catalysts, which were used in the reduction of propionic acid to aldehyde and alcohol. Quantum chemical calculations, including ab initio phase diagrams provided molecular insights into the H spillover phenomenon.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗
DOE OSTI2026

Mechanistic Studies of an Iron-Catalyzed Intermolecular C–H Amination Reaction under Catalytic Conditions and Having a Large KIE

The conversion of C–H bonds into amines by nitrene insertion is an attractive transformation since it is both atom- and step-economical, and provides a direct route to functionalizing hydrocarbons. Using an iron catalyst [{( tBu pyrr) 2 pyr}Fe(OEt 2 )] (1-OEt 2 ) (( tBu pyrr) 2 pyr 2– = 3,5- t Bu 2 -bis(pyrrolyl)pyridine), we recently demonstrated the catalytic conversion of weak C–H bonds into secondary amines using aryl azides as the nitrene source [Zars, E.; Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2023, 62, e202311749]. Here, we describe detailed mechanistic studies of this intermolecular C–H amination reaction under catalytic conditions. We find by Variable Time Normalization Analysis (VTNA) that the conversion of xanthene (2-H 2 ) and 2,4,6-trimethyl-phenyl azide ( Me 3) catalyzed by 1-OEt 2 is an overall 3/2 order process, being 1 st order in 2-H 2 and half order in Me 3. A kinetic isotope effect study (KIE) using 2-d 2 results in a significant decrease in the rate (KIE = 61(15)), which clearly implicates the C–H insertion step as rate-determining. Furthermore, treatment of 1-OEt 2 with one equivalent of N 3 -2,6- i Pr 2 –C 6 H 3 yields the mixed-valence C–N coupled product [( tBu pyrr) 2 pyrFe-N═C(2,6 i Pr 2 –Ph)═N-(2,6 i Pr 2 –Ph))Fe tBu pyrrpyr(2-H-pyrr)] (5 iPr ). Quantum chemical calculations confirm the electronic structure of the mixed-valence dimer in 5 iPr and rationalize the Hammett correlation by a delicate balance in the dinuclearization of the catalytically active monomers. Calculations further indicate significant tunneling for the pivotal H atom abstraction by the iron-imidyl complex. Combining all these results allows us to propose a mechanism consisting of imido formation in equilibrium with a radical-coupled diiron system, followed by stepwise C–H insertion via a linear H atom abstraction transition state and subsequent radical rebound.

azides↗
DOE OSTI2026

Variations of Alloying Site Density in Pd 1 Cu Single‐Atom Alloy Catalysts Lead to Shifted Product Yields in Electrochemical CO Reduction

Single-atom alloy (SAA) catalysis research often reports that a SAA catalyst, in the general formulation of a single-atom metal M1 alloyed on the surface of the host metal M2, facilitates a probe reaction. However, for catalytic reactions that present decoupled rate- and selectivity-limiting steps, the alloying site density may significantly manipulate these independent steps, but it has rarely been explicitly examined for any SAA systems. Herein, using the electrocatalytic CO reduction as a probe reaction, we report that the nominal Pd 1 Cu cube SAA catalysts exhibit distinctive high reactivity toward ethylene or ethanol, respectively, depending on whether the Pd atoms are in dilute or crowded forms. Although the presence of single-atom Pd embedded on Cu uniformly promotes CHO* formation and C─C coupling, the dilute-Pd 1 Cu favors ethylene formation by enabling low-barrier C─O cleavage from a flat CH 2 CH 2 OH* intermediate, whereas the crowded-Pd 1 Cu promotes ethanol formation by stabilizing an upright hydrogenation transition state of the same intermediate. Furthermore, we present evidence that the catalytic chemistry of crowded Pd 1 species differs from that of the Pd 2 -dimer; the latter, albeit unstable, steers reaction selectivity to acetate instead. In conclusion, these results uncovered the underappreciated importance of controlling SAA catalytic chemistry from the perspective of single-atom site densities.

Jin, Zehua [Clemson University, SC (United States)↗
DOE OSTI2024

Spin-dependent electron transfer in electrochemically transparent van der Waals heterostructures for oxygen evolution reaction

Spin selective catalysis is an emerging approach for improving the thermodynamics and kinetics of reactions. The role of electron spins has been scarcely studied in catalytic reactions. One exception is the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) where strongly correlated metals and oxides are used as catalysts. In OER, spin alignment facilitates the transition of singlet state of the reactant to the triplet state of O 2 . However, the influence of strong correlations on spin exchange mechanism and spin selective thermodynamics of most catalytic reactions remain unclear. Here we decouple the strongly correlated catalyst from the electrolyte to study spin exchange in two-dimensional (2D) magnetic iron germanium telluride (FGT) heterostructure. We demonstrate that transmission of spin and electrochemical information between the catalyst and the reactant can occur through quantum exchange interaction despite the catalyst of FGT being completely encapsulated by graphene or hexagonal boron nitride (hBN). The strong correlations in FGT that lead to enhanced spin exchange in OER are observed in graphene or hBN layers with thicknesses of up to 6 nm. We demonstrate that spin alignment in FGT leads to a lowering of thermodynamic barrier for adsorption of hydroxide ion and electron transfer to the catalyst. This results in up to fivefold enhancement in OER performance and improved kinetics. Our results provide clear evidence that transmission of both quantum mechanical and electrochemical information through quantum spin exchange interaction in FGT leads to an enhancement in catalytic performance.

2D materials↗
DOE OSTI2026

Mitigation of polysulfide shuttle effect in Li-S batteries through catalytic disproportionation reaction

Polysulfides are poorly retained within porous cathodes and readily diffuse into the electrolyte over time, leading to the well-known shuttle effect that undermines the reversibility of Li-S batteries. Here, in this study, we demonstrate that catalytic disproportionation of polysulfides provides an effective pathway to suppress this process by rapidly converting dissolved species into solid sulfur and sulfides, thereby preventing their migration into the electrolyte. Fundamentally, the sluggish kinetics of sulfur redox reactions are responsible for the accumulation and redistribution of soluble polysulfides in the bulk electrolyte. By accelerating these kinetics, catalyzed disproportionation not only confines sulfur within the conductive cathode matrix but also promotes the homogeneous precipitation of Li₂S₂/Li₂S, which enhances electrochemical reversibility and cycling stability. Using nitrogen-doped carbon (NC800) as a model catalyst, we reveal its ability to drive a pseudo-16-electron reduction pathway, leading to a single dominant Li₂S product and uniform deposition within the porous framework. In contrast, a non-catalytic carbon (KB) yields multiple polysulfide intermediates and heterogeneous deposition. The mechanistic insights provided here highlight the pivotal role of catalytic disproportionation in reshaping sulfur redox pathways and offer a rational strategy for mitigating polysulfide shuttling in practical Li-S pouch cells.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2027

A multi-region approach for the analysis of porous materials and gas-solid reactions using USAXS-SAXS-WAXS: application to CaO carbonation

The reaction rate of gas-solid non-catalytic reactions is typically investigated using reactant conversion data over time and ex-situ measurements of the porous solid reactant textural properties; these data enable the experimental estimation of the initial intrinsic reaction rate, whereas the evolution of the textural properties and the reaction rate over time are evaluated theoretically using reaction models. In this work, a different methodology is presented, based on: a) in-situ time-resolved USAXS-SAXS-WAXS measurements of the solid sample, and b) a multi-region modeling approach; this methodology allows for the estimation of the textural properties and the intrinsic reaction rate at any time during the reaction. Referring to a reaction in which a solid product is obtained from a solid reactant and a gaseous reactant, the porous particle is described as consisting of several distinct regions with different microstructural properties, and both a gas-solid reaction model and a SAXS model are derived and applied to the carbonation of porous CaO. The proposed reaction model highlights the role of the inaccessible reactant and accurately predicts the solid reactant conversion versus time profile. The SAXS model accurately predicts the measured linear trends of the Porod invariant and of the pre-factor of the power law scattering profile versus CaO mass fraction; in the absence of chemical reactions, the proposed equations extend classical SAXS theory to porous materials containing macropores and nonporous solid phases in addition to standard nanoscale inhomogeneous regions.

CO2 solid sorbents↗
DOE OSTI2024

Influence of Domain Size and Support Composition on the Reducibility of SiO 2 and TiO 2 Supported Tungsten Oxide Clusters

Supported tungsten oxides are widely used in a variety of catalytic reactions. Depending on the support, the cluster size, oxidation state, reducibility and speciation of the tungsten oxides can widely differ. When promoted with a platinum group metal, the resulting spillover of hydrogen may facilitate the reduction of supported tungsten oxide species, depending on the support. High resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy imaging showed nanometer scale WO x clusters were synthesized on SiO 2 whereas highly dispersed species were formed on TiO 2 . Results from H 2 -temperature-programmed reduction showed the presence of Pd lowered the initial reduction temperature of SiO 2 -supported WO x species but interestingly did not affect that of TiO 2 -supported WO x . X-ray photoelectron and absorption spectroscopies showed the W atoms in SiO 2 -supported WO x species reduce from a +6 oxidation state to primarily +5 after thermal treatment in 5% H 2 , while the fraction of W in the +5 oxidation state was relatively unaffected by reduction treatment of TiO 2 -supported WO x . The unusual behavior of TiO 2 -supported WO x was explained by quantum chemical calculations that reveal the lack of change in the oxidation state of W is attributed to charge delocalization on the surface atoms of the titania support, which does not occur on silica. Moreover, modeling results at <600 K in the presence of H 2 suggest the formation of Brønsted acid sites, and the absence of Lewis acid sites, on larger aggregates of WO x on silica and all cluster sizes on titania. These results provide experimental and theoretical insights into the nature of supported tungsten oxide clusters under conditions relevant to various catalytic reactions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

CO oxidation over a ligand coordinated single site Rh catalyst: identification of the active complex

Single atom catalysis has evolved as a promising strategy to enhance atom utilization efficiency, lower reaction temperatures, and control reaction pathways in heterogeneous catalytic reactions. An important challenge using supported single atom catalysts is the stability of metal single atoms during reactions. Here, we present an approach to stabilize single rhodium atoms on a titania support via a metal–ligand coordination strategy. We explore the reaction activity and mechanism of CO oxidation, as well as the stability under oxidative reaction conditions. Kinetic studies suggest that, with an excess of oxygen in the feed gas, oxygen activation is more facile on defective titania surfaces than on pristine titania surfaces. In situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) analysis shows that on the pristine titania surface, the 1,10-phenanthroline-5,6-dione (PDO) coordinated Rh catalyst (Rh–PDO/TiO 2 ) catalyzes CO oxidation via the formation of carbonate-like species, which is similar to what occurs on Rh nanoparticle catalysts. However, on the defective titania surface, no carbonate species form for Rh–PDO/def-TiO 2 . The supported Rh–ligand catalysts are also shown to be very stable in such a reaction environment at elevated temperatures, potentially allowing for wide applications.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Hydrogenation Reactions with Heterobimetallic Complexes

Abstract Hydrogenations are fundamentally and industrially important reactions that are atom economical paths to synthesize value‐added products from feedstock chemicals. The cooperative effects of two or more metal centers in multimetallic active sites is a successful strategy to activate small molecules and facilitate catalytic reactions, and this strategy has been recently applied to catalytic hydrogenation reactions. Furthermore, heterobimetallic complexes have been well‐documented to provide novel reaction pathways and improved selectivity, compared to their homo‐bimetallic and monometallic analogues. This minireview provides a historical perspective on the development of heterobimetallic catalysts for the hydrogenation of unsaturated substrates and describes recent developments in this burgeoning research area.

Abhyankar, Preshit C.↗
DOE OSTI2024

Hydrogenation Reactions with Heterobimetallic Complexes

Hydrogenations are fundamentally and industrially important reactions that are atom economical paths to synthesize value‐added products from feedstock chemicals. The cooperative effects of two or more metal centers in multimetallic active sites is a successful strategy to activate small molecules and facilitate catalytic reactions, and this strategy has been recently applied to catalytic hydrogenation reactions. Furthermore, heterobimetallic complexes have been well‐documented to provide novel reaction pathways and improved selectivity, compared to their homo‐bimetallic and monometallic analogues. This minireview provides a historical perspective on the development of heterobimetallic catalysts for the hydrogenation of unsaturated substrates and describes recent developments in this burgeoning research area.

catalysis↗
DOE OSTI2024

Unraveling the adsorption-limited hydrogen oxidation reaction at palladium surface via in situ electron microscopy

Palladium (Pd) catalysts have been extensively studied for the direct synthesis of H 2 O through the hydrogen oxidation reaction at ambient conditions. This heterogeneous catalytic reaction not only holds considerable practical significance but also serves as a classical model for investigating fundamental mechanisms, including adsorption and reactions between adsorbates. Nonetheless, the governing mechanisms and kinetics of its intermediate reaction stages under varying gas conditions remain elusive. This is attributed to the intricate interplay between adsorption, atomic diffusion, and concurrent phase transformation of catalyst. Herein, the Pd-catalyzed, water-forming hydrogen oxidation is studied in situ, to investigate intermediate reaction stages via gas cell transmission electron microscopy. The dynamic behaviors of water generation, associated with reversible palladium hydride formation, are captured in real time with a nanoscale spatial resolution. Our findings suggest that the hydrogen oxidation rate catalyzed by Pd is significantly affected by the sequence in which gases are introduced. Through direct evidence of electron diffraction and density functional theory calculation, we demonstrate that the hydrogen oxidation rate is limited by precursors’ adsorption. These nanoscale insights help identify the optimal reaction conditions for Pd-catalyzed hydrogen oxidation, which has substantial implications for water production technologies. The developed understanding also advocates a broader exploration of analogous mechanisms in other metal-catalyzed reactions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Autonomous Flow Electrochemistry for Accelerated Catalyst Discovery

Our objective is to develop an Autonomous Chemical Experimentation (ACE) platform that accelerates discovery of new catalytic transformations and other energy-relevant chemical reactions and processes. We intentionally designed ACE to be highly modular, both with respect to its rapid deployment to different chemistries and experimental workflows as well as incorporation of a wide range of different AI algorithms. In addition to the development of the core software architecture, initial efforts were made to incorporate Large Language Models to provide human-interpretable reasoning of the optimizer’s actions, and to develop a user-friendly graphical interface for experimental researchers. ACE was demonstrated using a flow electrocatalysis platform containing an inline FTIR spectrometer for real-time analysis and quantification of the reaction outcome. Human-in-the-loop experiments were performed in which a human researcher conducted an experiment using electrode potentials suggested by ACE, then fed the spectral data back to ACE for decision making. After confirming the successful function of the optimizer, efforts were next directed to automation of the hardware and performed full autonomy tests using three reactions: catalytic oxidation of formate, catalytic oxidation of cyclohexanol, and oxidation of hydroquinone. These studies confirm that ACE can close the loop between reaction execution, analysis, and optimization. They also reveal that more improved product detection methods will be essential for ACE to make well-informed decisions for reactions with low conversions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗