Comparison of Exhibited Wear in Tefzel?, Kynar?, and UHMWPE Valve Seats Exposed to Cyclic Operations with Abrasive Slurry - 17519
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) conducted abrasive-wear testing of ball valves used for double valve isolation in nuclear waste process lines. The valve seat materials consisted of Kynar{sup R}, Tefzel{sup R}, and ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene (UHMWPE). Cycle testing was conducted for 1500 operating cycles for the Kynar{sup R} and Tefzel{sup R} valve seats and 5500 cycles for the UHMWPE valve seats. A valve operational cycle consisted of slurry flow, slurry gravity drain, flush water flow, and flush water gravity drain. Both two-way and three-way valves were evaluated, and valves were configured in simulated manifolds so the impact of serving various operational functions (e.g., slurry, flush, or drain control) could be evaluated as some valves are flushed prior to being cycled and others are not. Testing was conducted in PNNL's Multi-Phase Transport Evaluation Loop Facility using a performance-based simulant developed by PNNL specifically for this test program to emulate abrasive slurries for Hanford Tank Farms Waste Transfer System during single-shell tank retrieval and waste feed delivery to the Hanford Tank Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant. Pre- and post-test valve tear-down evaluations were conducted to observe changes in the condition of internal components for the various seat materials. The various forms of physical wear observed for the different seat materials are presented. The wear results can be used to assess seat materials and valve configurations for application to waste transfer operations, and the observed wear mechanisms can provide insight into assessing valve service life. This information will be used to identify and select additional valve designs that should be evaluated for certification for future use. (authors)