Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Hf”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,747 records · Page 97

Electronic structures, elastic properties, and minimum thermal conductivities of cermet M{sub 3}AlN

The electronic structures and elastic anisotropies of cubic Ti{sub 3}AlN, Zr{sub 3}AlN, and Hf{sub 3}AlN are investigated by pseudopotential plane-wave method based on density functional theory. At the Fermi level, the electronic structures of these compounds are successive with no energy gap between conduct and valence bands, and exhibit metallicity in ground states. In valence band of each partial density of states, the different orbital electrons indicate interaction of corresponding atoms. In addition, the anisotropy of Hf{sub 3}AlN is found to be significantly different from that of Ti{sub 3}AlN and Zr{sub 3}AlN, which involve the differences in the bonding strength. It is notable that Hf{sub 3}AlN is a desired thermal barrier material with the lowest thermal conductivity at high temperature among the three compounds. - Graphical abstract: 1.Young's moduli of anti-perovskite Ti{sub 3}AlN, Zr{sub 3}AlN, and Hf{sub 3}AlN in full space. 2.Electron density differences on crystal planes (1 0 0), (2 0 0), and (1 1 0) of anti-perovskite Zr{sub 3}AlN. - Highlights: • We calculated three anti-perovskite cermets with first-principles theory. • We illustrated 3D Young modulus and found the anomalous anisotropy. • We explained the anomaly and calculated the minimum thermal conductivities.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

The Ho–Ni–Ge system: Isothermal section and new rare-earth nickel germanides

The Ho–Ni–Ge system has been investigated at 1070 K and up to ~60 at% Ho by X-ray diffraction and microprobe analyses. Besides the eight known compounds, HoNi{sub 5}Ge{sub 3} (YNi{sub 5}Si{sub 3}-type), HoNi{sub 2}Ge{sub 2} (CeAl{sub 2}Ga{sub 2}-type), Ho{sub 2}NiGe{sub 6} (Ce{sub 2}CuGe{sub 6}-type), HoNiGe{sub 3} (SmNiGe{sub 3}-type), HoNi{sub 0.2÷0.6}Ge{sub 2} (CeNiSi{sub 2}-type), Ho{sub 37÷34}Ni{sub 6÷24}Ge{sub 57÷42} (AlB{sub 2}-type), HoNiGe (TiNiSi-type), Ho{sub 3}NiGe{sub 2} (La{sub 3}NiGe{sub 2}-type), the ternary system contains four new compounds: Ho{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4} (Sc{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4}-type), HoNi{sub 3}Ge{sub 2} (ErNi{sub 3}Ge{sub 2}-type), Ho{sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} (Hf{sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Si{sub 3}-type) and ~Ho{sub 5}Ni{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} (unknown structure). Quasi-binary solid solutions were observed at 1070 K for Ho{sub 2}Ni{sub 17}, HoNi{sub 5}, HoNi{sub 7}, HoNi{sub 3}, HoNi{sub 2}, HoNi and Ho{sub 2}Ge{sub 3}, but no detectable solubility was found for the other binary compounds in the Ho–Ni–Ge system. Based on the magnetization measurements, the HoNi{sub 5}Ge{sub 3}, HoNi{sub 3}Ge{sub 2} and Ho{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4} (and isostructural (Tb, Dy){sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4}) compounds have been found to show paramagnetic behavior down to 5 K, whereas Ho{sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} exhibits an antiferromagnetic transition at ~7 K. Additionally, the crystal structure of the new isostructural phases (Y, Yb)Ni{sub 3}Ge{sub 2} (ErNi{sub 3}Ge{sub 2}-type), Er{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4} (Sc{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4}-type) and (Y, Tb, Dy, Er, Tm){sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} (Hf{sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Si{sub 3}-type) has been also investigated. - Graphical abstract: The Ho–Ni–Ge system has been investigated at 1070 K and up to ~60 at.% Ho by X-ray and microprobe analyses. Besides the eight known compounds, i.e. HoNi{sub 5}Ge{sub 3} (YNi{sub 5}Si{sub 3}-type), HoNi{sub 2}Ge{sub 2} (CeAl{sub 2}Ga{sub 2}-type), Ho{sub 2}NiGe{sub 6} (Ce{sub 2}CuGe{sub 6}-type), HoNiGe{sub 3} (SmNiGe{sub 3}-type), HoNi{sub 0.2÷0.6}Ge{sub 2} (CeNiSi{sub 2}-type), Ho{sub 37÷34}Ni{sub 6÷24}Ge{sub 57÷42} (AlB{sub 2}-type), HoNiGe (TiNiSi-type), Ho{sub 3}NiGe{sub 2} (La{sub 3}NiGe{sub 2}-type), the ternary system contains four new compounds: Ho{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4} (Sc{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4}-type), HoNi{sub 3}Ge{sub 2} (ErNi{sub 3}Ge{sub 2}-type), Ho{sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} (Hf{sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Si{sub 3}-type) and ~Ho{sub 5}Ni{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} (unknown structure). Quasi-binary solid solutions were found to form at 1070 K from the binary Ho{sub 2}Ni{sub 17}, HoNi{sub 5}, HoNi{sub 7}, HoNi{sub 3}, HoNi{sub 2}, HoNi and Ho{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} compounds, while no detectable solubility was observed for the other binary compounds in the Ho–Ni–Ge system. Based on the magnetization measurements, the HoNi{sub 5}Ge{sub 3}, HoNi{sub 3}Ge{sub 2} and Ho{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4} (and isostructural (Tb, Dy){sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4}) compounds have been found to show paramagnetic behavior down to 5 K, whereas Ho{sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} exhibits an antiferromagnetic transition at ~7 K. Additionally, the crystal structure of the new isostructural phases (Y, Yb)Ni{sub 3}Ge{sub 2} (ErNi{sub 3}Ge{sub 2}-type), Er{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4} (Sc{sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4}-type) and (Y, Tb, Dy, Er, Tm){sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} (Hf{sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Si{sub 3}-type) has been also investigated. - Highlights: • Ho–Ni–Ge system has been investigated at 1070 K and up to ~60 at% Ho. • Eight known ternary holmium nickel germanides were confirmed in Ho–Ni–Ge. • Four new holmium nickel germanides were detected in Ho–Ni–Ge. • Eight new rare earth nickel germanides were detected in (Y, Tb, Dy, Er–Yb)–Ni–Ge. • HoNi{sub 5}Ge{sub 3}, HoNi{sub 3}Ge{sub 2},(Tb, Dy, Ho){sub 3}Ni{sub 11}Ge{sub 4} and Ho{sub 3}Ni{sub 2}Ge{sub 3} are paramagnet down to 5–7 K.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Effect of anodization parameters on the structural morphology of titanium in fluoride containing electrolytes

In the present work, formation of titania nanopores on titanium substrate was investigated in aqueous (sulphuric acid) and neutral organic (glycerol) electrolytes containing different concentrations of HF (0.1-0.2 M). The surface morphology, topography and phase structures were analyzed using scanning electron microscopy, atomic force microscopy and X-ray diffraction techniques, respectively. Under optimized electrolyte conditions, titania nanopore is obtained with the average pore diameter of 64 nm and 84 nm for aqueous and organic electrolytes, respectively. Atomic force microscope investigation shows that the porous layer forms under a competition of titania formation and oxide dissolution up to a limiting thickness of {approx} 75 nm and 100 nm respectively for aqueous and organic electrolytes. The porous structure was observed at 0.15 M HF concentration. It was found that depending on the electrolytes the pore diameter alters and also its concentration effected the porous structures formation. Compared to aqueous electrolytes, organic electrolytes showed larger diameter pores. From the X-ray diffraction measurement it is evident that the as prepared titania nanopores are amorphous in nature, whereas the anodized heat treated titania nanopores are in anatase phase. - Highlights: Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer Aqueous and organic electrolytes were used to synthesize nanoporous titania. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer The surface morphology varies with various concentrations of HF. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer Nanopores were formed at optimum HF concentration of 0.15 M. Black-Right-Pointing-Pointer Nanopore diameter was found to be affected by the electrolyte used.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Mechanistic mass transfer in hollow fiber membrane solvent extraction for bio-based isobutanol

Membrane solvent extraction (MSE) has emerged as a promising method for selectively recovering bioproducts from complex aqueous streams. Bio-isobutanol, a next-generation feedstock for biofuel, remains challenging to recover because of its low concentration and the presence of inhibitory substances. This study explores the potential of hollow fiber (HF) MSE for bio-isobutanol recovery and systematically examines the coupled effects of fiber packing, shell-side flow dynamics, and aqueous chemistry on performance. A resistance-in-series model is applied to understand mass transfer in the HF MSE modules, quantify local resistances, and validate overall performance. The results show that increasing the fiber packing provides a larger interfacial area but induces poor flow distribution and channeling, hindering effective isobutanol transport. Meanwhile, increasing the shell-side velocity improves isobutanol recovery due to reductions in the boundary layer thickness. The presence of salts, added to mimic fermentation broth, increases the partition coefficient through salting-out effects, further improving isobutanol flux. A modified correlation for the shell-side mass transfer coefficient (k s,ϕ+v ), integrating geometric and hydrodynamic effects, was developed and validated. The proposed model achieves highly predictive accuracy (r 2 = 0.9808) across a wide range of conditions, outperforming previous models. The findings provide mechanistic insight into the interaction of geometric packing, hydrodynamics, and chemistry in governing mass transfer in HF MSE. Overall, this work demonstrates the potential of HF MSE for efficient bio-isobutanol recovery and also provides practical guidelines on critical factors (packing fraction, partition coefficient, and shell-side velocity), aiding in the design and scaling of MSE systems for resource recovery.

Aqueous chemistry↗

Nuclear Data Sheets for A = 179

Nuclear structure data pertaining to all nuclei with mass number A = 179 (Yb, Lu, Hf, Ta, W, Re, Os, Ir, Pt, Au, Hg, Tl) have been compiled and evaluated, and incorporated into the ENSDF database. This evaluation for A = 179, which considers data available by 15 November 2008, supersedes the previous complete publication (E. Browne, Nuclear Data Sheets55, 483 (1988), cutoff September 1987) and the update-mode publication (C. Baglin, Nuclear Data Sheets72, 617 (1994), cutoff date September 1994), as well as the subsequent evaluations of Ta, Ir and Tl by C. Baglin (literature cutoff dates January 2000, October 1998 and February 2001, respectively). The newly evaluated literature provides new Coulomb excitation data for Hf, transfer reaction data for Hf and Ta, new information on Au and Hg from {alpha} decay and significant (HI,xn{gamma}) reaction data for Hf, Ta, Re, Au and Hg. At the time of the 1994 evaluation, no {gamma}-ray information was available for Au or Hg; that situation has now changed dramatically, although additional work on details of the low-lying structure of Au could be instructive.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Nuclear Data Sheets for A = 168

Nuclear structure data pertaining to all nuclei with mass A=168 (Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Yb, Lu, Hf, Ta, W, Re, Os, Ir, Pt) have been evaluated and incorporated into the ENSDF data file. This evaluation supersedes the previous publication (V.S. Shirley, Nuclear Data Sheets 71, 261 (1994) (literature cutoff date July 1993)) and subsequent ENSDF file revisions for Tb and Dy (C. Baglin, literature cutoff date of 15 June 1999) and Hf (B. Singh, literature cutoff date of 30 April 2001), and includes literature available by 15 June 2010. Since the above evaluations, the first excited states in {sup 168}Pt have been identified (1998Ki20, 2009Go16) and {alpha} decay from {sup 172}Hg has been observed (2009Sa27, 2004Ke06, 1999Se14). New levels in {sup 168}Dy have been excited using the {sup 170}Er({sup 82}Se,{sup 84}Kr{gamma}) reaction (2010So03). (HI,xn{gamma}) studies have significantly expanded our knowledge of level structure in {sup 168}Lu (1999Ka17, 2002Ha33), {sup 168}Ta (2008QiZZ), {sup 168}Yb (1995Fi01), {sup 168}Tm (2007CaZW), {sup 168}Hf (2009Ya21), {sup 168}Os (2001Jo11, 2009Od02) and, for {sup 168}Tm, important information has come also from (d,2n{gamma}) and ({alpha},n{gamma}) reactions (1995Si20). Revised decay schemes are available following new studies of {sup 168}Hf {epsilon} decay (6.7 min) (1997Ba26), {sup 168}Lu {epsilon} decay (1999Ba65), {sup 168}Ta {epsilon} decay (2007Mc08) and {sup 172}Au {alpha} decay (2009Ha42). Significant new information for {sup 168}Er is available from (p,t) (2006Bu09), (d,p) and (t,d) (1996Ma50), ({gamma},{gamma}') (1996Ma18), (136Xe, X{gamma}) (2010Dr02), ({sup 238}U,{sup 238}U{sup '{gamma}}) (2003Wu07) and (n,n{sup '{gamma}}) (1998Be20, 1998Be62) reactions, and the availability of {gamma}{gamma} coin data (1994Ju02, 1996Gi09) for the (n,{gamma}) E=thermal reaction has resulted in some significant level scheme revisions.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Nuclear Data Sheets for A=164

Experimental nuclear structure data for the known A=164 isobaric nuclides (Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Yb, Lu, Hf, Ta, W, Re, Os, Ir) have been evaluated, and presented together with Adopted properties of level energies, and associated γ rays. The decay data for these nuclides have also been evaluated, providing Adopted values of γ and β radiations, and log ft values. No excited states are known in 164 Eu, 164 Tb, and 164 Ir. Information for 164 Gd, 164 Re and 164 Os is limited due to insufficient experimental data. For radioactive nuclides, decay schemes of 164 Sm, 164 Gd and 164 Re are not known, and those of 164 W, 164 Tb, 164 Lu, 164 Hf, 164 Ta and 164 W are incomplete. The decay schemes of 164 Ho and the two activities of 164 Tm seem fairly complete. The decay scheme of 164 Yb presents a major problem that the Q(ε) value of 887 keV 29 recommended in 2017Wa10 is in disagreement with the population of levels at 928, 952 and 1060 keV in the daughter nucleus. This decay scheme, which so far has been mainly reported in a secondary reference (1982AdZZ) needs further investigation. Also the masses of 164 Yb and 164 Tm need either new measurements or a re-evaluation to resolve discrepancy of about 220 keV in the Q value of 164 Yb decay to 164 Tm. The reactions and decays for which no new experimental information has become available since the 2001 update have undergone revisions to incorporate conversion coefficients from BrIcc code, and evaluated Q values from 2017Wa10, but the essential content of such datasets may have remained the same as in previous evaluations. Finally, in this respect the present work greatly benefited from all the previous NDS evaluations (2001Si27,1992Sh07, 1986Sh03,1974Bu30), but at the same time data presented herein supersede all the previous published evaluations.

38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗

Characterization of the alumina scale formed on a commercial MCrAlYHfSi coating

A commercial NiCoCrAlYHfSi coating deposited on a Ni-base superalloy substrate was characterized before and after high temperature oxidation. The combination of Y, Hf and Si additions is reported to improve coating performance. Advanced characterization techniques including scanning-transmission electron microscopy were used to study the segregation behavior of Y and Hf ions to the alumina grain boundaries after 200 h at 1050 C and 100 and 200 h exposures at 1100 C. After both exposure times, two distinct oxide layers were observed. The outer transient layer included many Y- and Hf-rich oxide particles. The inner layer consisted of columnar -Al2O3 grains normal to the surface of the coating. Segregation of Y and Hf ions was found on the alumina grain boundaries as has been observed in model alloys with similar compositions. Isothermal exposures for up to 200 h at 1050 and 1100 C caused a minimal increase in surface roughness. However, 200 1-h cycles at 1100 C resulted in a more significant increase in surface roughness.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Site Dependency of the High Conductivity of Ga 2 In 6 Sn 2 O 16 : The Role of the 7-Coordinate Site

The 6-coordinated cation site is the fundamental building block of the most effective transparent conducting oxides. Ga2In6Sn2O16, however, maintains 4-, 6-, 7-, and 8-coordinated cation sites and still exhibits desirable transparency and high conductivity. To investigate the potential impact of these alternative sites, we partially replace the Sn in Ga2In6Sn2O16 with Ti, Zr, or Hf and use a combined approach of DFT-based calculations, X-ray diffraction, and neutron diffraction to establish that the substitution occurs preferentially on the 7-coordinate site. In contrast to Sn, the empty d orbitals of Ti, Zr, and Hf promote spd covalency with the surrounding oxygen which decreases the conductivity. Pairing the substitutional site preference with the magnitude of this decrease demonstrates that the 7-coordinate site is the major contributor to the conductivity. The optical band gaps, in contrast, are shown to be site independent and composition dependent. Continued replacement of Sn after all 7-coordinate Sn has been substituted results in the formation of a 7-coordinate In antisite or replacement of 6-coordinate Sn, depending on the identity of the d0 substitute.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Impact of Electromagnetic Fields on Gypsum and Silica Scaling in Reverse Osmosis

Electromagnetic field (EMF) is a cost-effective, simple, and energy-efficient method for scale control in reverse osmosis (RO) systems. However, its effects on gypsum and silica scaling, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remain poorly understood. This study systematically investigates the effects of EMF treatment on gypsum and silica scaling in RO systems, utilizing synthetic brackish water and natural RO concentrate (ROC) from a desalination facility. For gypsum, EMF changes the crystal morphology, resulting in the formation of a porous, less compact scaling layer. It is more readily removed through hydraulic flushing (HF), enhancing scaling reversibility and water recovery. In the case of silica scaling, EMF promotes homogeneous polymerization in the bulk solution, producing larger silica particles that inhibit the formation of a dense, cross-linked gel layer on the membrane surface, mitigating flux decline. This study thus demonstrates EMF’s effectiveness in controlling gypsum scaling in undersaturated feedwaters when combined with HF and in mitigating silica scaling under both HF and non-HF conditions for supersaturated feedwaters. These findings underscore EMF’s versatility as a nonchemical approach for scale control in RO desalination and show its substantial potential to enhance membrane performance and operational efficiency in real-world water treatment applications.

Du, Xuewei [New Mexico State University, Las Cruce↗

Improving Predictions of Spin-Crossover Complex Properties through DFT Calculations with a Local Hybrid Functional

We conducted a study on the performance of the local hybrid exchange-correlation functional PBE0r for a set of 95 experimentally-characterized iron spin crossover (SCO) complexes. The PBE0r functional is a variant of PBE0 where the exchange correction is restricted to on-site terms formulated within the basis of local orbitals. We determine the free parameters of the PBE0r functional against experimental data and other hybrid functionals. With a Hartree-Fock (HF) exchange factor of 4%, the PBE0r functional accurately reproduces the electronic and free energy trends predicted in prior DFT studies for these 95 complexes using the B3LYP functional. Larger values of HF exchange stabilize high-spin states. The PBE0r-predicted bond lengths tend to exceed the experimental bond lengths, and bond lengths are less sensitive to HF exchange. The predicted SCO transition temperatures T 1/2 from PBE0r correlate moderately with the experimental transition temperatures, showing a slight improvement compared to the previous modB3LYP-predicted T 1/2 . Furthermore, this study suggests the PBE0r functional as computationally cost-effective and offers the possibility of simulating larger complexes with accuracy comparable to other global hybrid functionals, provided the HF exchange parameter is carefully optimized.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Revised M11 Exchange-Correlation Functional for Electronic Excitation Energies and Ground-State Properties

The ability of Kohn-Sham density functional theory (KS-DFT) to accurately predict various types of electronic excitation energies with (necessarily approximate) exchange-correlation functionals faces several challenges. Chief among these is that valence excitations are usually inherently multiconfigurational and therefore best treated by functionals with local exchange, whereas Rydberg and charge transfer excitations are often better treated with nonlocal exchange. The question arises of whether one can optimize a functional such that all three kinds of excitations (valence, Rydberg, and charge transfer – including long-range charge transfer) are treated in a balanced and accurate way. The goal of the present work is to try to answer that question and then to optimize a functional with the best possible balanced behavior. Of the variety of functional types available, we select range-separated hybrid meta functionals because (i) range separation allows the percentage of Hartree–Fock (HF) exchange to change with interelectronic separation, and therefore, one can have 100% HF exchange at large interelectronic separations, which gives good performance for long-range charge-transfer excitations, while the range separation allows one to simultaneously have smaller values of HF exchange at small and intermediate inter-electronic separations, which give good performance for valence and Rydberg excitations and (ii) meta functionals allow one to obtain better accuracy with high HF exchange than is possible with functionals whose local part depends only on spin densities and their gradients. Furthermore, this work starts with the range-separated hybrid meta functional, M11, and re-optimizes it (with stronger smoothness restraints) against electronic excitation energies and ground-state properties to obtain a new functional called revM11 that gives good performance for all three types of electronic excitations and at the same time gives very good predictions across-the-board for ground-state properties.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Cationic Pyridylamido Adsorbate on Brønsted Acidic Sulfated Zirconia: A Molecular Supported Organohafnium Catalyst for Olefin Homo- and Co-Polymerization

Here we report the combined application of high-resolution solid-state 13 C–CPMAS-NMR and FT-IR spectroscopy, elemental analysis, kinetic poisoning/active site counting, variable dielectric constant medium, and DFT computation to characterize the surface chemistry of a pyridylamido hafnium complex (Cat1, L 1 -HfMe 2 , L 1 = 2,6-diisopropyl-N-{(2-isopropylphenyl)[6-(naphthalen-1-yl)pyridin-2-yl]methyl}aniline) adsorbed on Brønsted acidic sulfated zirconia (ZrS). The spectroscopic and DFT results indicate protonolytic formation of organohafnium cations having a largely electrostatic pyridylamido-Hf-CH 3 + ···ZrS - interaction with elongated Hf···OZrS distances of ~ 2.14 Å. High-molecular-weight polyethylenes and ethylene/1-octene copolymers are obtained with this supported catalyst without an activator/cocatalyst. The DFT calculations reveal that the first ethylene insertion into the Hf-methyl bond has a lower barrier than the corresponding insertion into the Hf-aryl bond of this single-site heterogeneous catalyst.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Tests of Exchange-Correlation Functional Approximations Against Reliable Experimental Data for Average Bond Energies of 3d Transition Metal Compounds

One of the greatest challenges for the theoretical study of transition-metal-containing compounds is the treatment of intrinsically multi-configurational atoms and molecules, which require a multireference (MR) treatment in wave function theory. The accuracy of density functional theory for this kind of system is still being explored. Here, we continue that exploration by presenting the predictions of 42 exchange-correlation (xc) functionals of 11 types [local spin density approximation (LSDA), generalized gradient approximation (GGA), nonseparable gradient approximation (NGA), global-hybrid GGA, meta-GGA, meta-NGA, global-hybrid meta-GGA, range-separated hybrid GGA, range-separated hybrid meta-GGA, range-separated hybrid meta-NGA, and DFT augmented with molecular mechanics damped dispersion (DFT-D)]. DFT-D is tested both for Grimme’s DFT-D3(BJ) model with Becke-Johnson damping and for ωB97X-D, which has the empirical atom-atom dispersion parametrized by Chai and Head-Gordon. The Hartree-Fock (HF) method has also been included because it can be viewed as a functional with 100% HF exchange and no correlation. These methods are tested against a database including 70 first-transition-row (3d) transition metal-containing molecules (19 single-reference molecules and 51 MR molecules), all of which have estimated experimental uncertainties equal to or less than 2.0 kcal/mol in the heat of formation. We analyze the accuracy in terms of the atomization energy per bond instead of the enthalpy of formation of the molecule because it allows us to test electronic energies without the possibility of cancellation of errors in electronic energies with errors in vibrational energies. All the density functional and HF wave functions have been optimized to a stable solution, in which the spatial symmetry is allowed to be broken to minimize the energy to a stable solution. We find that Ï„-HCTHhyb has the smallest mean unsigned error (MUE) in average bond energy, in particular 2.5 kcal/mol, for the full set of 70 molecules, and it also gives the smallest MUE for MR systems. For single-reference systems, MPW1B95 has the best performance, with an MUE of 1.6 kcal/mol. Among local functionals, which are the least expensive, the best performance (MUE = 3.9 kcal/mol) for the total database is achieved by OreLYP, OLYP, M06-L, and τ-HCTH. It is observed that adding HF exchange does not guarantee better accuracy for GGAs or for the NGA, but inclusion of the kinetic energy densities can benefit the GGAs and NGA calculations. The metal hydrides and metal oxides are demonstrated to be most difficult bond types to predict, and CrO 3 , FeH, CrO, VH and MnS are found to be the most difficult molecules to predict. The middle transition metals (V, Cr, and Mn) lead to larger errors on average than either the early or late transition metals.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Can Kohn–Sham density functional theory predict accurate charge distributions for both single-reference and multi-reference molecules?

Dipole moments are the first moment of electron density and are fundamental quantities that are often available from experiments. An exchange–correlation functional that leads to an accurate representation of the charge distribution of a molecule should accurately predict the dipole moments of the molecule. It is well known that Kohn–Sham density functional theory (DFT) is more accurate for the energetics of single-reference systems than for the energetics of multi-reference ones, but there has been less study of charge distributions. Here, in this work, we benchmark 48 density functionals chosen with various combinations of ingredients, against accurate experimental data for dipole moments of 78 molecules, in particular 55 single-reference molecules and 23 multi-reference ones. We chose both organic and inorganic molecules, and within the category of inorganic molecules there are both main-group and transition-metal-containing molecules, with some of them being multi-reference. As one would expect, the multi-reference molecules are not as well described by single-reference DFT, and the functionals tested in this work do show larger mean unsigned errors (MUEs) for the 23 multi-reference molecules than the single-reference ones. Five of the 78 molecules have relatively large experimental error bars and were therefore not included in calculating the overall MUEs. For the 73 molecules not excluded, we find that three of the hybrid functionals, B97-1, PBE0, and TPSSh (each with less than or equal to 25% Hartree–Fock (HF) exchange), the range-separated hybrid functional, HSE06 (with HF exchange decreasing from 25% to 0 as interelectronic distance increases), and the hybrid functional, PW6B95 (with 28% HF exchange) are the best performing functionals with each yielding an MUE of 0.18 D. Perhaps the most significant finding of this study is that there exists great similarity among the success rate of various functionals in predicting dipole moments. In particular, of 39 functionals designed as general-purpose functionals and that do not have a global value of 100% HF exchange, the average MUE is 0.23 D, with a standard deviation of only 0.04 D. Among gradient approximations, which are especially interesting because of their speed and portability, the best overall performance is by PBE, HCTH/407, OLYP, OreLYP, and GAM, each with MUE of 0.22 D.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗