Positive correlations between soil C stabilization and loss are regulated by roots, minerals, and microbes
Modern conceptual models of soil organic carbon (SOC) cycling place a strong focus on the microbe-mineral interactions that regulate C stabilization. However, the formation of ‘stable’ soil organic matter, which consists mainly of microbial residues bonded to mineral surfaces, is inextricably linked to C loss through microbial respiration. Therefore, what is the net impact of microbial metabolism on the total quantity of C held in the soil? To address this question, we constructed artificial root-soil systems to identify controls on C cycling across the plant-microbe-mineral continuum, simultaneously quantifying the formation of persistent mineral-associated C and C losses to respiration. Roots and minerals interacted to regulate these processes: while roots stimulated respiratory C losses and depleted mineral-associated C pools in low-activity clays, roots triggered formation of stable C in high-activity clays. Moreover, we observed a strong positive correlation between the formation of mineral-associated C and respiration. This suggests that the growth of persistent C pools which can resist subsequent disturbance comes at the expense of C loss from the system.