Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Criticality”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,729 records · Page 96

Role of Core Exit Axial Reflectors for NTP Full Submersion Criticality Accident Mitigation

One of the only design basis accidents currently codified into law for space nuclear systems is the full-submersion criticality accident. This accident scenario prescribes that the reactor core must remain sub-critical in the event of a full water submersion with the control system in the shut-down position. This accident scenario is of particular interest and relevance for nuclear thermal propulsion (NTP) reactors because of their unique core periphery and internal design considerations. In previous work it has been shown that this accident is particularly sever for low-enriched uranium (LEU) fueled NTP cores due to their moderated spectrum and the minimization of parasitic neutron absorption. These then add to the existing problems associated with the numerous voids within the core and the extensive neutron leakage due to its compact size. In this abstract we examine the role of a core exit axial reflector in minimizing the submersion worth of a graphite composite LEU-NTP core. The neutronics simulations were done using the ENDF/B-VII cross-section library in conjunction with MCNP6.1. The MCNP calculations were done using 20000 particles per cycle with 50 inactive and 300 active cycles. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Impact of Concrete Composition on Criticality at Nuclear Power Plants

There is no standard concrete composition for criticality analysis. Concrete is a composite material composed of aggregate bonded together with cement which hardens over time. Aggregate consists of large chunks of material in a concrete mix, generally coarse gravel or crushed rocks such as limestone or granite, along with finer materials such as sand. Water is mixed with the dry powder cement/aggregate blend. The concrete solidifies and hardens. After the concrete is hardened there can be water loss with time. The main components in concrete generally have small neutron cross sections so the absorption cross section is often dominated by the impurities. The content of the impurities are rarely documented in a manner that is generally needed for crediting in a criticality analysis. This paper assesses the impact of conservative concrete on a sample dry storage rack and a spent fuel pool. The SCALE computer code has four types of concrete in the Standard Composition Library.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

UPF Data Book: A Resource for Standard Data, Dimensions, Equations, and Practices used at UPF for Nuclear Criticality Safety Analyses

A new Uranium Processing Facility (UPF) is being designed at Y-12 in Oak Ridge to replace the existing facilities. As part of this design, new and existing processes need to be evaluated using Criticality Safety Process Studies (CSPS) to ensure they remain subcritical for both normal and credible abnormal conditions. This requires a great many sets of calculations using both MCNP and SCALE to model the various configurations, concentrations, and processes being designed. At UPF these calculations are contained within Design Analysis and Calculation (DAC) documents. Without a standard guide different nuclear criticality safety (NCS) engineers were modeling the same system using parameters familiar to them from past experience. Often this resulted in significantly different assumptions on things such as: materials, uranium enrichment, reflection conditions, and maximum uranium concentrations for calculations in DACs supporting essentially the same process but in a different CSPS. It became apparent that, for DACs to be useful for more than the CSPS they were written to support, a common set of guidelines, for use by all NCS engineers, was needed. A Data Book DAC is now used at UPF to help standardize the common UPF system parameters used for all calculations. This makes it possible to use existing calculations from one CSPS in another CSPS having similar processes. It also simplifies the requirements imposed by NCS on things like pipe diameters, tank size and spacing, and component placement on the design and process disciplines. Finally, for a given parameter, once it is determined the parameter is valid for a UPF process it becomes valid for all similar processes without the need for further calculational analyses. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

New Version of the MCNP Analytic Criticality Benchmark Suite

Analytical benchmarks provide an invaluable tool for verifying computer codes used to simulate neutron transport. Several collections of analytical benchmark problems are used routinely in the verification of production Monte Carlo codes such as MCNP{sup R}. Verification of a computer code is a necessary prerequisite to the more complex validation process. The verification process confirms that a code performs its intended functions correctly. The validation process involves determining the absolute accuracy of code results vs. nature. In typical validations, results are computed for a set of benchmark experiments using a particular methodology (code, cross-section data with uncertainties, and modeling) and compared to the measured results from the set of benchmark experiments. The validation process determines bias, bias uncertainty, and possibly additional margins. Verification is generally performed by the code developers, while validation is generally performed by code users for a particular application space. The VERIFICATION-KEFF suite of criticality problems was originally a set of 75 criticality problems found in the literature for which exact analytical solutions are available. Even though the spatial and energy detail is necessarily limited in analytical benchmarks, typically to a few regions or energy groups, the exact solutions obtained can be used to verify that the basic algorithms, mathematics, and methods used in complex production codes perform correctly. The present work has focused on revisiting this benchmark suite. A thorough review of the problems resulted in discarding some of them as not suitable for MCNP benchmarking. For the remaining problems, many of them were reformulated to permit execution in either multigroup mode or in the normal continuous-energy mode for MCNP. Execution of the benchmarks in continuous-energy mode provides a significant advance to MCNP verification methods. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

The Criticality Safety Studies of Joonhong Ahn

The recent passing of UC Berkeley professor Joonhong Ahn at the age of 57 has been a dear loss to the community of nuclear scientists at large. His contributions to studies on advanced fuel cycle development and the societal and ethical aspects of nuclear technology were known around the world and fostered a great reputation. He produced at least fifty peer-reviewed journal papers, authored or contributed to ten books, and organized a considerable number of international meetings. Ahn's studies led to his eminence in the area of nuclear waste management, where he focused on repository performance assessments along with their impact on society. These assessments included the development of analytical models for nuclide transport phenomena and evaluation of the possibility of criticality events imparting a dose to the biosphere. This paper will summarize his achievements in criticality safety along with developments before his passing.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Analysis of COBRA-TF Critical Heat Flux Models for Triangular Fuel Assembly Pitch

The Coolant Boiling in Rod Arrays-Two Fluid (COBRA-TF) code is a best estimate code which is used to perform thermal-hydraulic analyses of a light water reactor vessel. The COBRA-TF heat transfer package has models calculating the critical heat flux (CHF). In order to verify code's predictive capability for CHF for triangular nuclear fuel assembly pitch, experiment results and system parameters of KS-1 test facility that is single loop model of the VVER primary system located in Kurchatov Institute were simulated using COBRA-TF. In order to calculate CHF for triangular nuclear fuel assembly pitch there is a look-up table generated. In addition, there are some correction factors for critical heat flux values listed the table. In this study, once KS-1 experiment results were simulated using COBRA-TF, correction factors were used to correct CHF results from COBRA-TF calculations.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Methodology of Experiment Design for Improving Transient Critical Heat Flux Model Development

One phenomenon that contributes to nuclear fuel and clad failure mechanisms is the departure from nucleate boiling (DNB). Accident scenarios such as reactivity-initiated accidents (RIAs) provide conditions where the frequency of boiling crisis is much more likely to occur and on much shorter time scales than loss of coolant (LOCA) or loss of flow (LOFA) accidents. Here, boiling crisis in the form of DNB is attributed to transient-induced heat flux values that exceed the critical heat flux (CHF). The resulting effects, such as bubble crowding and eventual dryout, can affect flow boiling heat transfer and compromise the structural integrity of nuclear reactor materials. The focus of the work proposed here lies in developing a rigorous process using out-of-pile testing, under simulated RIA conditions, to determine the transient critical heat flux of cladding materials, without contributions from aforementioned radiation-induced effects that have been observed during in-pile experiments. This study provides a road-map for developing and performing experiments that simulate the power profile and energy deposition aspects of transient events, specific to RIAs, on the laboratory scale. The goal of our project is to observe and measure DNB in an annular flow channel around a single heater rod that is operating and nominal thermal hydraulic conditions of a PWR. It is also an aim of these experiments to determine how to quantify the gap between SS and transient CHF cases, based on state-dependent properties of the cladding material type that is being interrogated. Traditionally, CHF is determined as a combination of four factors: hydraulic diameter, system pressure, mass flow, fluid quality. The authors propose that an additional measureable quantity, which is dependent on the structural properties of the cladding material itself, is partly reasonable for the difference between measured and model-developed CHF values. Using a carefully metered approach will allow for several key concepts to be realized: compensation for transient-based effects to current models for CHF; adaptation of current models for different cladding material types, including Gen-IV concept materials; and implementation of a correction factor to account for both power transient-based and radiation-induced effects on the CHF that have not yet been accounted for.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Update of the nuclear criticality slide rule calculations: studies with common shielding materials - 25467

This paper presents preliminary results from the third phase of the current update to the nuclear criticality slide rule, in which MCNP, MAVRIC/Monaco, and COG have simulated the prompt neutron and photon dose from critical spheres of 4.95% enriched uranyl fluoride solution and 93.2% enriched uranium metal. New to this phase is the inclusion of various thicknesses of lead, steel, concrete, and water shielding. This phase also evaluated the effects of humidity on the unshielded configurations in the first phase, as well as the effects of changing the ground composition used in the first phase from concrete to dry soil. The small sample of results presented show that MCNP, MAVRIC/Monaco, and COG results are statistically the same or different by only a few percent. The impact of the shielding materials depends on their thickness, but doses decreased by nearly a factor of 100 are presented. In a few instances, buildup of gamma doses occurs due to neutron interactions in shielding materials. (authors)

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Consideration for the application of artificial neural networks to criticality code validation - 14270

The artificial neural network (ANN) is a consistent example for non-parametric parameter estimation and regression, with powerful universal approximation properties, that is distribution independent. ANN application to criticality code validation centers on aligning mathematical relationships between code validation parameters and neural network prediction for those parameter values. Two specific goals are: (1) an appropriate ANN architecture to determine validation parameter values, and (2) bootstrapping individual ANNs as a 'Prediction Interval' (PI) technique to estimate the Calculation Margin and Upper Subcritical Limit. The individual ANN workflow is segregated into Training, Validation (network), and Testing Sets, where the network predictive properties and performance are expressed in the latter set. The Bootstrap ANN replicates a large set of individual ANNs (taken from the original data distribution) where (1-α/2)100% PI estimates can be determined. Results from the ANN method are compared to a variety of validation examples: a 'toy example' from ANSI/ANS-8.24, Appendix D, a variety of methods noted in a Nuclear Criticality Safety Division 2009 paper, and several validation campaigns for highly enriched uranium and plutonium systems. The ANN method is robust and can be applied to single or multivariate inputs. A trained ANN can provide both an average estimate (e.g., single value) and an estimate over a range of independent variable values where the kUSL can be formed in a regression relationship suitable for extrapolation. The input dependence has been tested, ranging from 15 to over 400 sample size distributions. An expanded Shapiro-Wilk test (for sample sizes up to 5000) was implemented to confirm that the ANN method is transparent to distribution function. The Principle Component Analysis method was applied as an input preprocessing step embedded within the ANN in order to reduce dimensionality and correlation for multivariable inputs. This can potentially aid in determining accurate margins over applying arbitrary margins. The automatic optimization of the Bootstrap ANN PI is left for future consideration. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

The unforeseen component of risk when considering the need for a criticality accident alarm system - 14281

This paper sets out a concept for estimating the size of the contribution of the unforeseen component of criticality accident risk to that of the totality of criticality risks for a process involving fissile materials. By performing this, and considering this estimate alongside those risks known and evaluated as part of the safety justification for the process, a more informed and justifiable basis to the arguments for installing, or not installing a CAAS may be made. This works in in development, further work to identify the detailed means of estimation will be made and presented in a future paper provided the concept as set out is considered reasonable. (author)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Optimization of a dry, mixed nuclear fuel storage array for nuclear criticality safety - 14339

A dry storage array of used nuclear fuel at the Idaho National Laboratory contains a mixture of more than twenty different types of research and test reactor fuels. Significant neutronic interaction occurs between fuel canisters within this large storage arrangement of 636 fuel storage canisters. Nuclear criticality safety is maintained primarily by moderation control and through control of neutron interaction and leakage provided by the credited geometry. Over the nearly forty years of operation the collected fuels are now arranged in a configuration that does not minimize the system neutron multiplication factor (k{sub eff}). This creates a concern since the entire remaining facility storage capacity cannot be utilized without exceeding the system minimum subcritical state (k{sub safe}) for ensuring nuclear criticality safety. This work determines a more optimal arrangement for the stored fuels with a goal to minimize the system k{sub eff}, but also with a minimum of potential fuel canister relocation movements. The ultimate goal is to establish a solution for this multiple-objective optimization problem by finding the Pareto Front for maximum k{sub eff} reduction versus the number of canister relocations. The process first required additional analysis of the array by Monte-Carlo neutron transport codes (specifically, MCNP) to gain a greater understanding of the interaction characteristics of the disparate fuel types. Some stored fuels are composed of primarily metallic and oxide components that provide very little inherent moderation, while other fuel types contain graphite or zirconium-hydride which can contribute a significant amount of moderation. These factors cause a complex relationship within a fuel arrangement with respect to thermal utilization and axial leakage probability. The new MCNP analysis was utilized to develop a simplified spreadsheet-based empirical model which simulates the array k{sub eff} result. This empirical model was benchmarked against additional MCNP calculations for various arrangements and then employed in the optimization analysis. A Tabu metaheuristic and stochastic approximation optimization was applied to the empirical model with the optimization function to minimize the array k{sub eff}. The optimization algorithm interrogated the empirical model to determine the optimal rearrangement for up to sixty canister movements. The Pareto Front was found, which shows that a limited number of canister relocation movements could allow the existing thirty-one empty array positions to be filled with common research reactor fuels while also yielding a reduction in the overall array k{sub eff} relative to the current arrangement. This will impart an improvement in the facility utilization while also offering an enhancement in the safety margin. The reduction in array reactivity has been confirmed by a final set of MCNP calculations with the proposed new arrangements. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Impact of new prompt fission neutron spectrum evaluations and the associated cross-correlations on critical assemblies using MCNP6 - 14385

Two recent re-evaluations of the neutron-induced prompt fission neutron spectrum (PFNS) of uranium and plutonium actinides have included some cross-correlated uncertainties that have not been released in a new nuclear data library. The first re-evaluation included cross-isotope correlations of the PFNS within each of the uranium and plutonium suites of actinides below the second-chance fission threshold. The second, more recent re-evaluation includes incident energy-dependent correlations of the {sup 239}Pu(n,f) PFNS. Both of these new evaluations and their cross-correlations, given the importance of these actinide quantities and because the impact of the incident energy-dependent correlations has never been studied previously, could have an impact on a variety of criticality safety applications. For example, the ke uncertainty due to the uranium PFNS uncertainties in the Big Ten critical assembly is underpredicted by ∼10% when the cross-isotope correlations in the uranium PFNS are ignored. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Storage and concentration of plutonium and uranium solutions in LES 401 hot cell (ATALANTE) - criticality safety considerations - 14414

ATALANTE, located in Marcoule, is one of the main nuclear facilities of the French CEA (Atomic Energy and Alternative Energies Commission). The LES 401 hot cell was built in the 1980's and, since then, has been operating only with low masses of fissile material. As part of the management optimization for purified Uranium and Plutonium solutions ('Fin U Pu' Project), the new functions provided in LES 401 are now expected to be the following: - Reception of Uranium and Plutonium solutions, - Concentration of these solutions, - Storage of the concentrates and distillates. From the criticality safety point of view, the equipment was originally designed in safe geometry for Plutonium Nitrate, considering only a 2.5 cm -thick water reflector. However, the new criticality safety case had to take into account the following points: - Reception of not only Plutonium solutions, but also highly enriched Uranium solutions, - Considering flood risk as a possible contingency, - Considering precipitation as a possible contingency. These more conservative assumptions have meant introducing a mass limit for the cell, in addition to the geometry control mode. For the equipment containing very low concentrations of fissile material in normal operation, it was necessary, using the double contingency principle, to take a concentration limit into account in the specific situation of water flooding the cell. Finally, given the mass and geometry control mode, it was necessary to perform all the calculations with both fissile media (Plutonium and Uranium), as it was found that depending on the selected mass, geometry, and reflection conditions, the most penalizing media is not always the same. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

A new dose assessment method for the UK system of criticality accident dosimetry - 14420

A new method for the measurement and interpretation of the Harwell criticality accident dosemeter has been developed. The new method treats the dosemeter components as individual detector elements with unique energy-dependent response functions generated with MCNP6. A bespoke deconvolution code was written that generates a parameterized neutron spectrum from the integral activities in each detector element. The spectrum can be folded with any set of fluence-to-dose conversion coefficients to determine an integral dose. The new method has been validated computationally using realistic neutron spectra and experimentally in a series of test irradiations using the Godiva-IV, CALIBAN and PROSPERO critical assemblies. The method was able to reproduce the true dose with a small positive bias and a combined relative uncertainty of 25 % across the full range of spectra considered (10 pGy cm{sup 2} to 45 pGy cm{sup 2}). (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Inter-code comparison of TRIPOLI{sup R} And MVP on the MCNP criticality validation suite - 14421

This paper presents a joint work conducted at CEA Saclay and JAEA Tokai aimed at comparing the Monte Carlo codes TRIPOLI-4{sup R} and MVP on a selection of ICSBEP benchmarks. Our goal is to establish a common set of Monte Carlo input decks, as a basis for rigorous inter-code comparison in criticality-safety. As a reference, we will use the MCNP Criticality Validation Suite: other Monte Carlo developers might easily join this effort in the future. For the purpose of inter-code comparison, the TRIPOLI-4{sup R} and MVP input decks have been exactly translated from those of MCNP, without any further assumptions. Both TRIPOLI-4{sup R} and MVP have been run with the same ENDF/B-VII.0 evaluated nuclear data and, as far as possible, the same simulation options as in the original LANL work (same initial source, same number of active and discarded cycles and neutrons per cycle). (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Criticality calculation package and its use for a spent fuel storage pool with steam layer - 14324

Criticality studies need several calculations with small variations in a number of parameters. Therefore, a calculation package written at VTT in order to facilitate sensitivity studies in criticality calculations was used. This package is based on MCNP5 [1], and consists of a data transfer and analysis program written in Perl, and a set of pseudo inputs for the transport and storage systems including the fuel assembly. The pseudo inputs contain key words that are replaced by a given value for the specific parameter. In this paper, the package is described in more detail including the new modifications needed for this study. The usability will be demonstrated with a study of the fuel pool in the case of steam gathered under the support plates of the pool. In the new pool model the steam layer was added as a water layer with a very low density. The density of this layer, i.e. the steam density, could be varied as well as the thickness of the layer. This package was then used to study the reactivity effect of the moderator density, the steam density and the thickness of the steam layer. As can be expected the strongest effect was obtained with the moderator density. However, the steam density seemed not to affect the reactivity while the thickness of the layer had a small effect. (author)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Nuclear criticality safety of pipes networks containing uranium - 14437

In nuclear facilities, the transfer of fissile material in solution, gas or powder forms between process stages requires many transfer lines (called 'pipes' in this paper) which may be laid out into bundles or networks. In Nuclear Criticality Safety evaluations, it is usual to assimilate such networks as a unique cylinder which area bounds the sum of the surface of pipes making up the network. However, even if this geometric simplification appears intuitively safe, it is not conservative in all cases. The aim of this paper is therefore to explore the validity and limitations associated to the assessment of pipes networks by a unique cylinder. This paper presents the impact on the k{sub eff} value of a detailed modeling of a pipes network compared to a unique cylinder. Variables of interest considered in such calculations are pipes diameter, composition, pitches and layout. Fissile media taken into account are uranium systems enriched from 5 % to 93.5 % in {sup 235}U. Then, the impact on reactivity of pipes material, such as stainless steel or plastic, is discussed and the minimal or maximal safe thickness of material has been determined. Finally, this paper provides guidance on the nuclear criticality safety assessment of pipes networks for uranium systems. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Issues about implementation of geometry control to maintain nuclear criticality safety - 14438

The control of the geometry to establish and maintain Nuclear Criticality Safety (NCS) of a fissile unit is usually preferred by licensees and regulators since such a control is based on passive engineering and requires less operating constraints than other methods of control (mass, etc.). Nevertheless, several safety issues are associated with this method of control to ensure the geometry during all the unit lifetime, in normal and abnormal situations, from its manufacturing to its decommissioning. The first issue is to identify the dimensions defining the geometry, taking into account reflectors and mobile equipment, and the interaction conditions of the controlled unit to ensure the subcriticality. Thus, the dimensions important and to be controlled are identified in the NCS assessment. These dimensions are called Nuclear Criticality Safety Dimensions (NCSD) in this paper. Then, the second and the third issues are to define NCSD limits to be respected and to verify the compliance of the actual unit geometry with these limits at each stage of the unit life. Regarding the third issue, the challenges are the practicality of the control, its uncertainty and the management of non-compliances. Finally, the fourth issue is to properly document and record the NCSD and the compliance verification. This paper focuses on the main issues related to the implementation of geometry control on the NCS assessment and suggests advices to fulfill these challenges. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗