Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Code Validation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,729 records · Page 96

Comparing Sensitivity/Uncertainty Analysis Results for LR-0 Salt Experiments with Salt Reactor Models

Recent reactor physics measurements conducted at Research Centre Rez (RC Rez) used the LR-0 low power nuclear reactor to investigate neutronic impacts and uncertainties of FLiNa (60 mol% LiF and 40 mol% NaF) and FLiBe (2 LiF + BeF{sub 2}) salt targets. This included using FLiBe originally from the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), which contained enriched lithium (99.994 mol% {sup 7}Li). In collaboration with RC Rez, ORNL performed sensitivity/uncertainty (S/U) analyses of these LR-0 experiments with salt targets. Molten salt reactor technologies can be categorized into two general types: solid-fueled or liquid-fueled. Solid-fueled molten salt technologies are perhaps best represented by fluoride-salt-cooled high-temperature reactors (FHRs), which are solid-fueled and salt-cooled. They are potentially promising because they offer high-temperature outlet heat using a low-pressure, high-power-density system (relative to high temperature gas-cooled reactors). However, FHRs have never been built; therefore, no direct neutronic benchmarks exist for code or cross section validation work. Liquid-fueled molten salt reactors (MSRs) use a liquid salt as both fuel and coolant. MSRs can be designed to use a variety of fertile or fissile species as nuclear fuel, different neutron energy spectra, and a multitude of approaches for adding or removing material from the salt. The MSRE generated some operational data for fluoride salt MSRs, but no formal benchmarks currently exist based on the MSRE data, and the data available do not cover all operational conditions. Given these data limitations, ORNL performed S/U analyses using application models for FHR and MSR concepts to (1) identify potential sources of bias in FHR and MSR simulations resulting from cross section uncertainties and to (2) compare the sensitivity of neutron multiplication in FHR and MSR concepts to cross section data on an energy-dependent basis for specific nuclides against similar sensitivity results from LR-0 with a FLiBe salt target. In the future, these S/U analyses could inform the design of additional salt experiments or provide part of the basis for follow-up work to refine nuclear data. Please see the final project report for additional details beyond this paper.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Proposed Semi-Analytic Benchmark for Coupled Neutronics/Thermal-Hydraulics Feedback in Multiphysics Simulations

The past decade has seen considerable advancements in multiscale and multiphysics simulations that account for nonlinear effects of feedback between different physical processes within a single calculation. One area of particular interest has been multiphysics simulations that include both neutronics and thermal-hydraulics effects to accurately model the thermal feedback effects present in nuclear reactors. During this time, many groups have successfully modeled thermal feedback effects by coupling a variety of different types of neutron transport and thermal-hydraulic solvers together. However, formal verification and validation of these coupled code systems has proven challenging due to a lack of benchmark problems with well-characterized reference solutions. One approach is to confirm gross energy balance using bulk coolant properties (outlet temperature/enthalpy) for code verification purposes. Alternatively, code-to-code comparisons of results for a predefined reference/challenge problem have been used to establish reasonability of local results (neutron flux, heating, enthalpy rise) for various implementations, for example the VERA Core Physics Progression Problems. While community solutions are valuable for assessing the relative performance and fidelity of different implementations, they are not guaranteed to provide a measure of the absolute accuracy of a given implementation. In fact, these code-to-code comparisons can give a false sense of confidence by masking the effects of errors or approximations that are common to all of the solution methods tested. This is a particular concern when many methods derive from a common approach, such as Picard iteration. To this end, an analytical benchmark would be very valuable for verifying individual coupled physics implementations, as well as for providing a formal assessment of algorithm accuracy and sensitivity to model approximations such as mesh size and number of convergence iterations. However, creation of an analytical benchmark is difficult due to the complex nature of the eigenvalue form of the neutron transport equation (which does not permit a simple analytical solution for non-trivial cases) as well as the variety of different empirical closure relationships used in thermal-hydraulic modeling. In this paper we propose a benchmark for coupled neutronics/thermal-hydraulics simulations. The proposed benchmark overcomes the challenges associated with a multiphysics benchmark problem by using a fixed-source (rather than eigenvalue) formulation of the neutron transport equation and limiting fluid properties to the single-phase regime where the density and temperature of the coolant are related to enthalpy by a known relationship, while still preserving significant nuclear/thermal feedback effects within the simplified problem. The new benchmark is easy to simulate using existing coupled physics implementations, and allows for a direct comparison with a reference solution, as provided in this summary.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Development and benchmarking of transient nodal code SIMULATE5-K neutron kinetics solver

SIMULATE5-K is Studsvik's next generation best estimate transient code. The time dependent diffusion equation is solved with a nodal method consistent with that implemented in the licensed core design code SIMULATE5. Arbitrary number of neutron and delayed neutron precursor groups can be used. For the solution of the spatial problem, the coupling coefficients used to relate the node leakages are found by first converting the time dependent diffusion equation to a static diffusion equation with the use of flux and delayed neutron precursor dynamic frequencies. Once the static-like equations are obtained, the multi-group analytical nodal model is used to obtain the coupling coefficients, expressing the node leakage in terms of adjacent node average fluxes. The coupling coefficients are then inserted into the time dependent nodal balance equation. For the time integration, the time dependent neutron balance equation is solved with the frequency transformation method. The treatment of the temporal dependence yields a fixed source problem which can be solved utilizing the existing fixed-source methodology. The primary purpose of this paper is to describe the neutron kinetics methodology implemented in SIMULATE5-K. The accuracy of the method is demonstrated for a series of well-known, neutronic-only benchmark problems. (author)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Modeling Heat Pipes with Non-Condensable Gases

The report showcases advancements in modeling heat pipes, considering both scenarios with and without non-condensable gases. To achieve this, two distinct modeling approaches are juxtaposed. Firstly, the effective conduction model, implemented in the MOOSE-based code Sockeye, is employed. Secondly, a first-of-a-kind two-phase Euler-Euler Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) model is developed using the STAR-CCM+ code. Both models undergo validation against experimental data, acknowledging the inherent uncertainties associated with each modeling assumption. Interestingly, the non-tuned CFD model surpasses the performance of the calibrated conduction model for heat pipes operating under both conditions: with and without non-condensable gases. It's worth noting, however, that the CFD models entail significantly longer runtimes compared to the conduction models. Nevertheless, the insights garnered from the CFD model shed invaluable light on the intricate operational dynamics of heat pipes. Future work involves broadening the validation scope of these models and continuing their development to enhance their utility as robust tools for heat pipe design and operational support.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Integrated Molten Salt Reactor Modeling Capabilities in NEAMS Thermal Hydraulics Tools

The DOE neams program supports a full range of computational thermal fluids analysis capabilities and code developments for a broad range of advanced reactor concepts. The research and development approach under the thermal fluids technical area synergistically combines three length and time scales in a hierarchical multi-scale approach. To enable multi-scale thermal fluids capability using these codes, a key joint effort has been underway to develop an integrated system- and engineering-scale thermal fluids analysis capability, through integration of SAM and Pronghorn codes, both based on the MOOSE framework. This report summarizes recent advances in developing an integrated system- and engineering-scale modeling capability for the msr concept, which has gained significant interest in recent years. A consistent framework was established by coupling Pronghorn and SAM through the Saline interface, with thermophysical properties provided by the Molten Salt Thermal Property Database (MSTDB-TP). Further improvements were made to the coupling schemes and domain-overlapping strategies, enhancing the stability and robustness of multi-code simulations. Verification and validation efforts demonstrate the accuracy of this integration across a range of benchmark problems, including one-dimensional heated pipe flows, three-dimensional natural convection loops with evolving isotopic compositions, and \gls{msre} demonstration cases. Within Pronghorn, new capabilities were introduced to model corrosion and noble-metal plating phenomena, supported by an extended thermal-hydraulics framework and refined turbulence treatments. To capture two-phase flow behavior, a multiphase Euler–Euler model was implemented in Pronghorn, including advanced closure relations, high-resolution advection techniques, and capillary force reconstruction. Preliminary verification cases confirm the fidelity of the approach, while planned validation efforts target canonical multiphase benchmarks and application to msr components such as the msre pump bowl. Finally, updates to SAM’s msr mass transfer modeling were extended to consider noble gas migration into porous structures like graphite. The point kinetics model was updated to include reactivity feedback contributions from any defined species, such as xenon. The gas transport model was expanded for applicability to gas mixtures, bubble efflux phenomena, and species transport between liquid and gas phases. A selection of multi-scale Sherwood number correlations from MOSCATO/NekRS and multi-phase correlations from literature have been added for improved accuracy in calculating mass transfer coefficients. A companion effort on developing system-level redox corrosion has also been incorporated into SAM. Collectively, these enhancements strengthen the predictive capability of SAM and Pronghorn for simulating MSR thermal-hydraulics, corrosion, multiphase behavior, and fission-product transport, providing a more complete toolset for design, safety analysis, and licensing support of next-generation \gls{msr}s.

42 - ENGINEERING↗

COMPUTATION FLUID DYNAMICS ANALYSIS FOR GENERIC SMALL MODULAR REACTOR CONTAINMENT SEPARATE EFFECTS TEST

It is desirable for fourth-generation Small Modular Reactors to be passively cooled in standard and accident operations. Passive Containment Cooling Systems can reject heat from the containment structure, without using pumps or blowers. The targeted design containment structure is a large, domed, stainless steel, cylindrical vessel. In a postulated Design Basis Accident, steam will flash inside containment. Steam condensation occurs on the inner containment wall and transfers heat through the steel containment into a large body of water known as the annular reservoir (AR) surrounding the vessel serving as the ultimate heat sink. Natural circulation drives the flow in the AR and heat will be released to the environment by evaporation of water. Unique containment geometry requires a separate effects test (SET) facility for the verification and validation of the computer code and evaluation model development and assessment for reactor licensing efforts. In this study, STAR-CCM+, a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code was used to inform the decision-making process on the design of the SET. The CFD simulation modeled, a two-phase turbulent flow with fluid film development and heat transfer for different containment geometries. The Reactor Excursion and Leak Analysis Program will also be used in a code-to-code verification against the CFD results.

21 - SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLAN↗

Multi-scale modeling of wastage layer formation in metallic fuel cladding

Fuel-cladding chemical interaction (FCCI) is a major concern for U-Zr metallic fuels' performance, primarily due to the formation of a brittle layer (wastage) in the cladding. This brittle layer, resulting from intermetallic compounds between cladding constituents Fe, Cr, and lanthanide fission products, significantly impacts the cladding's mechanical integrity. Recent efforts focus on developing a mechanistic modeling framework to understand lanthanide production, transport to the fuel-cladding interface, and phase transformation to intermetallic phases. A multi-scale computational approach has been used to calculate lanthanide transport rates, with atomistic calculations determining Nd diffusivities through the solid fuel matrix and along pore surfaces. These diffusivities inform a mesoscale model to determine an effective diffusion coefficient, accounting for porosity and infiltration with bond sodium. This effective diffusivity is used in engineering-scale simulations via the BISON fuel performance code, which has been validated against EBR-II and FFTF reactor experiments.

11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Coupled simulation of kinetic pedestal growth and MHD ELM crash

Edge pedestal height and the accompanying ELM crash are critical elements of ITER physics yet to be understood and predicted through high performance computing. An entirely self-consistent first principles simulation is being pursued as a long term research goal, and the plan is planned for completion in time for ITER operation. However, a proof-of-principle work has already been established using a computational tool that employs the best first principles physics available at the present time. A kinetic edge equilibrium code XGC0, which can simulate the neoclassically dominant pedestal growth from neutral ionization (using a phenomenological residual turbulence diffusion motion superposed upon the neoclassical particle motion) is coupled to an extended MHD code M3D, which can perform the nonlinear ELM crash. The stability boundary of the pedestal is checked by an ideal MHD linear peeling-ballooning code, which has been validated against many experimental data sets for the large scale (type I) ELMs onset boundary. The coupling workflow and scientific results to be enabled by it are described.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗

Blades and Towers Modal Analysis Code (BModes): Verification of Blade Modal Analysis Capability

BModes is a finite-element code we developed to provide coupled modes for flexible blades, rotating or non-rotating, and for towers, onshore or offshore (supported either on floating platforms or on monopile foundations). Both the blade and the tower allow a tip attachment, which is modeled as a rigid body with mass, six moments of inertia, and a mass centroid that may be offset from the blade or tower axis. Examples of tip attachments are aerodynamic brakes for blades and nacelle-rotor subassemblies for towers. Allowable supports for the tower include tension wires, floating platforms, and shallow-water monopiles with elastic foundation. Coupled modes (implying coupling of flap, lag, axial, and torsion motions) have several applications. Examples are: modeling of major flexible components for modal-based aeroelastic codes such as FAST, validation of turbine models using experimental data, modal-based fatigue analysis, and understanding of aeroelastic-stability behavior of turbines. This paper presents verification of the blade modal analysis capability of BModes. Verification begins with simple uniform beams, rotating and non-rotating, and progresses to realistic blades. BModes-computed modes for all models are compared with analytical modes, if possible to obtain, and with modes generated by RCAS. All results, presented in terms of frequencies and mode shapes, show excellent agreement.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Sockeye Validation Support Using the SPHERE Facility

The engineering-scale heat pipe application Sockeye, being developed through the Nuclear En- ergy Advanced Modeling and Simulation program is concurrently undergoing code development and verification and validation activities. The Single Primary Heat Extraction and Removal Emu- lator (SPHERE) facility at Idaho National Laboratory has performed numerous sodium heat pipe experiments, one of which is modeled in this work to support Sockeye validation. Heat pipe data produced by the SPHERE facility was found to be very useful not only for Sockeye validation but also as a useful resource for model development. A Sockeye simulation performed using Sockeye’s conduction model modeled an experimental run at SPHERE and was found to be able to accurately reproduce the steady temperature distribution but revealed discrepancies in transient behavior after shutoff of the power. This effort also revealed a number of challenges of modeling an experimental setup such as SPHERE, for example, the importance of details in the setup such as possible gaps in insulation. Also, continuous collaboration between Sockeye developers and SPHERE experimentalists has been established, which allows future experiments to be refined in response to questions and challenges found by simulating earlier experiments.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Model uncertainty in accelerator application simulations

Monte-Carlo nuclear reaction and transport codes are widely used to devise accelerator-based nuclear physics experiments; at the same time, many experiments are performed to validate the Monte-Carlo codes, which can be used for the design of full-scale nuclear power applications or the design of new benchmark experiments. Dedicated model benchmark studies investigate a broad range of nuclear reactions and quantities. Examples of these include isotope formation or secondary particle fluxes that result from the interactions of GeV-range hadrons with monoisotopic targets, which can be used to assess the respective systematic uncertainty of models. Such benchmark studies, as well as many nuclear application experiments and simulations carried out by various groups over the last few decades, enable us to draw methodological lessons. In this work, model uncertainty determined based on available experimental data allow us to identify the effects of practitioner expertise as well as the design of codes (user access to micro-scale parameters) on the range of uncertainties. We found that in cases when simulations are performed by code developers or users that are very experienced in performing simulations, the model to experiment quantity ratios generally agree with the limits determined by dedicated benchmark studies. In other cases, the ratios generally tend to be either smaller (underestimation of model error) or larger (overestimation of model error). A plausible explanation of the aforementioned effects is suggested.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Wing design for a civil tiltrotor transport aircraft

The goal of this research is the proper tailoring of the civil tiltrotor's composite wing-box structure leading to a minimum-weight wing design. With focus on the structural design, the wing's aerodynamic shape and the rotor-pylon system are held fixed. The initial design requirement on drag reduction set the airfoil maximum thickness-to-chord ratio to 18 percent. The airfoil section is the scaled down version of the 23 percent-thick airfoil used in V-22's wing. With the project goal in mind, the research activities began with an investigation of the structural dynamic and aeroelastic characteristics of the tiltrotor configuration, and the identification of proper procedures to analyze and account for these characteristics in the wing design. This investigation led to a collection of more than thirty technical papers on the subject, some of which have been referenced here. The review of literature on the tiltrotor revealed the complexity of the system in terms of wing-rotor-pylon interactions. The aeroelastic instability or whirl flutter stemming from wing-rotor-pylon interactions is found to be the most critical mode of instability demanding careful consideration in the preliminary wing design. The placement of wing fundamental natural frequencies in bending and torsion relative to each other and relative to the rotor 1/rev frequencies is found to have a strong influence on the whirl flutter. The frequency placement guide based on a Bell Helicopter Textron study is used in the formulation of frequency constraints. The analysis and design studies are based on two different finite-element computer codes: (1) MSC/NASATRAN and (2) WIDOWAC. These programs are used in parallel with the motivation to eventually, upon necessary modifications and validation, use the simpler WIDOWAC code in the structural tailoring of the tiltrotor wing. Several test cases were studied for the preliminary comparison of the two codes. The results obtained so far indicate a good overall agreement between the two codes.

Rais-Rohani, Masoud↗

Tone Noise Predictions for a Spacecraft Cabin Ventilation Fan Ingesting Distorted Inflow and the Challenges of Validation

A fan tone noise prediction code has been developed at NASA Glenn Research Center that is capable of estimating duct mode sound power levels for a fan ingesting distorted inflow. This code was used to predict the circumferential and radial mode sound power levels in the inlet and exhaust duct of an axial spacecraft cabin ventilation fan. Noise predictions at fan design rotational speed were generated. Three fan inflow conditions were studied: an undistorted inflow, a circumferentially symmetric inflow distortion pattern (cylindrical rods inserted radially into the flowpath at 15deg, 135deg, and 255deg), and a circumferentially asymmetric inflow distortion pattern (rods located at 15deg, 52deg and 173deg). Noise predictions indicate that tones are produced for the distorted inflow cases that are not present when the fan operates with an undistorted inflow. Experimental data are needed to validate these acoustic predictions, as well as the aerodynamic performance predictions. Given the aerodynamic design of the spacecraft cabin ventilation fan, a mechanical and electrical conceptual design study was conducted. Design features of a fan suitable for obtaining detailed acoustic and aerodynamic measurements needed to validate predictions are discussed.

Koch, L. Danielle↗

Tone Noise Predictions for a Spacecraft Cabin Ventilation Fan Ingesting Distorted Inflow and the Challenges of Validation

A fan tone noise prediction code has been developed at NASA Glenn Research Center that is capable of estimating duct mode sound power levels for a fan ingesting distorted inflow. This code was used to predict the circumferential and radial mode sound power levels in the inlet and exhaust duct of an axial spacecraft cabin ventilation fan. Noise predictions at fan design rotational speed were generated. Three fan inflow conditions were studied: an undistorted inflow, a circumferentially symmetric inflow distortion pattern (cylindrical rods inserted radially into the flowpath at 15deg, 135deg, and 255deg), and a circumferentially asymmetric inflow distortion pattern (rods located at 15deg, 52deg and 173deg). Noise predictions indicate that tones are produced for the distorted inflow cases that are not present when the fan operates with an undistorted inflow. Experimental data are needed to validate these acoustic predictions, as well as the aerodynamic performance predictions. Given the aerodynamic design of the spacecraft cabin ventilation fan, a mechanical and electrical conceptual design study was conducted. Design features of a fan suitable for obtaining detailed acoustic and aerodynamic measurements needed to validate predictions are discussed.

Koch, L. Danielle↗

Comprehensive framework for data-driven model form discovery of the closure laws in thermal-hydraulics codes

The two-phase two-fluid model is a basis of many thermal-hydraulics codes used in design, licensing, and safety considerations of nuclear power plants. Thermal-hydraulics codes rely on the closure laws to close the system of conservation equations and describe the interactions between phases. These laws, derived from years of experimental investigations, are semi-empirical correlations that lack generality and have a limited range of applicability. Increase of computational power, availability of new experiments, and development of high-fidelity simulations has increased the number of validation data. The discrepancies between the code predictions and the validation data are a great source of knowledge. Missing physics that are not included in the model but are important for the considered phenomena can be discovered by propagating the information from the experimental results through the model. Furthermore, physics-discovered data-driven model form (P3DM) methodology integrates available integral effect tests and separate effects tests to determine the necessary corrections to the model form of the closure laws. In contrast to existing calibration techniques, the methodology modifies the functional form of the closure laws. Based on the functional form of the correction, the missing physics that were not included in the original model can be discovered. The methodology provides the alternative to the machine learning approach, in which the model is discovered in the form of the intractable black-box relation. In this work, the methodology was applied to the CTF subchannel code to improve the prediction of the two-phase flow phenomena.

42 ENGINEERING↗

A spectrally accurate boundary-layer code for infinite swept wings

This report documents the development, validation, and application of a spectrally accurate boundary-layer code, WINGBL2, which has been designed specifically for use in stability analyses of swept-wing configurations. Currently, we consider only the quasi-three-dimensional case of an infinitely long wing of constant cross section. The effects of streamwise curvature, streamwise pressure gradient, and wall suction and/or blowing are taken into account in the governing equations and boundary conditions. The boundary-layer equations are formulated both for the attachment-line flow and for the evolving boundary layer. The boundary-layer equations are solved by marching in the direction perpendicular to the leading edge, for which high-order (up to fifth) backward differencing techniques are used. In the wall-normal direction, a spectral collocation method, based upon Chebyshev polynomial approximations, is exploited. The accuracy, efficiency, and user-friendliness of WINGBL2 make it well suited for applications to linear stability theory, parabolized stability equation methodology, direct numerical simulation, and large-eddy simulation. The method is validated against existing schemes for three test cases, including incompressible swept Hiemenz flow and Mach 2.4 flow over an airfoil swept at 70 deg to the free stream.

Pruett, C. David↗

SCALE 6.3 Validation: Reactor Physics

This study was performed to validate the SCALE/Polaris v6.3.0–PARCS v3.4.2 code procedure with the ENDF/B-VII.1 AMPX 56-group library for light-water reactor analysis by comparing the simulated results with the measured data for critical experiments and operating light-water reactors. Uncertainties of the SCALE/Polaris–PARCS code procedure for light-water reactor physics analysis were evaluated in the validation for key nuclear parameters such as reactivity, control bank work, temperature coefficients, and pin and assembly power peaking factors. In addition, the SCALE/TRITON v6.3.1 procedure with the ENDF/B-VII.1 and VIII.0 252-group and continuous-energy cross sections was validated for non-lightwater reactors including the HTR-10 reactor, the High-Temperature Test Reactor, the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment, and the Experimental Breeder Reactor II.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Computational solution verification and validation applied to a thermal model of a ruggedized instrumentation package

This study details a methodology for quantification of errors and uncertainties of a finite element heat transfer model applied to a Ruggedized Instrumentation Package (RIP). The proposed verification and validation (V&V) process includes solution verification to examine errors associated with the code's solution techniques, and model validation to assess the model's predictive capability for quantities of interest. The model was subjected to mesh resolution and numerical parameters sensitivity studies to determine reasonable parameter values and to understand how they change the overall model response and performance criteria. To facilitate quantification of the uncertainty associated with the mesh, automatic meshing and mesh refining/coarsening algorithms were created and implemented on the complex geometry of the RIP. Automated software to vary model inputs was also developed to determine the solution’s sensitivity to numerical and physical parameters. The model was compared with an experiment to demonstrate its accuracy and determine the importance of both modelled and unmodelled physics in quantifying the results' uncertainty. An emphasis is placed on automating the V&V process to enable uncertainty quantification within tight development schedules.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗