Rethinking of Zircaloy Embrittlement Criteria for Improving Safety Margin of Light Water Reactor
Zircaloy embrittlement criteria have become a basis for the current emergency core cooling system (ECCS) criteria to maintain the coolable geometry. U.S. NRC has considered that retaining adequate cladding ductility is a simple and effective way for ensuring the structural integrity of fuel rods under the accident conditions. Considering this, the current ECCS criteria limits the peak cladding temperature(PCT) to be 1204 deg. C, and equivalent cladding reacted (ECR) to be 17%, calculated by the Baker-Just equation. However, the criteria were established based on the experimental investigations in early 1970's and it has inevitably limitations, in particular, about hydrogen embrittlement with burnup. As a consequence, the new draft-rule proposes a relation that gives rise to a decreasing ECR limit with respect to pre-transient hydrogen content by U.S NRC. The regulation of Japan is quite different from that of U.S. NRC. This rule is set to assure structural integrity of ruptured fuel rods upon water-quenching. Recently, Japanese Atomic Energy Agency (JAEA) conducted integral fuel rod thermal shock tests with high burnup claddings. These investigations confirmed that the original criteria (PCT 1200 deg. C, ECR 15% calculated by Baker-Just equation ) still successfully guarantee fuel rod structural integrity upon thermal shock and concluded that the high-burnup effects are inconsiderable as the thermal-shock fracture boundary is not significantly reduced. Hence, there exists an obvious disagreement between the embrittlement-based and the thermal shock fracture-based criterion particularly when it comes to the high burnup consideration. The one of them can be adopted to define safety limit and safety margin which is the difference between the regulation limit and actual value of the parameter. Also, it is worth noting that the temperature limit (1204 deg. C) of the Zircaloy embrittlement criteria has not been altered since it was first determined in 1970's. Such a qualitative concern alone should not limit further discussions on the potential increase in the temperature limit. Indeed, there is ample experimental evidence that supports the possibility that Zircaloy ductility can be maintained beyond 1204 deg. C if it is oxidized for a limited time period. The increase in the temperature margin can lead to a reactor power uprate, or allow an increased accident coping time. This paper aims to achieve a comprehensive understanding of an engineering compatibility between nuclear fuel behaviors, safety system, and safety criteria, in the pursuit of increasing safety margin of LWRs. Specifically, this study presents a revision the current temperature limit (1204 deg. C) with adjustable ECR levels through an extensive literature review. And the impact of this temperature limit on the actual design basis accident margin is discussed. (authors)