Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “design”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,657 records · Page 92

Integrating Safety, Operations, Security, and Safeguards (ISOSS) into the design of small modular reactors : a handbook.

The existing regulatory environment for nuclear reactors impacts both the facility design and the cost of operations once the facility is built. Delaying the consideration of regulatory requirements until late in the facility design - or worse, until after construction has begun - can result in costly retrofitting as well as increased operational costs to fulfill safety, security, safeguards, and emergency readiness requirements. Considering the scale and scope, as well as the latest design trends in the next generation of nuclear facilities, there is an opportunity to evaluate the regulatory requirements and optimize the design process for Small Modular Reactors (SMRs), as compared to current Light Water Reactors (LWRs). To this end, Sandia has embarked on an initiative to evaluate the interactions of regulations and operations as an approach to optimizing the design of SMR facilities, supporting operational efficiencies, as well as regulatory requirements. The early stages of this initiative consider two focus areas. The first focus area, reported by LaChance, et al. (2007), identifies the regulatory requirements established for the current fleet of LWR facilities regarding Safety, Security, Operations, Safeguards, and Emergency Planning, and evaluates the technical bases for these requirements. The second focus area, developed in this report, documents the foundations for an innovative approach that supports a design framework for SMR facilities that incorporates the regulatory environment, as well as the continued operation of the facility, into the early design stages, eliminating the need for costly retrofitting and additional operating personnel to fulfill regulatory requirements. The work considers a technique known as Integrated Safety, Operations, Security and Safeguards (ISOSS) (Darby, et al., 2007). In coordination with the best practices of industrial operations, the goal of this effort is to develop a design framework that outlines how ISOSS requirements can be incorporated into the pre-conceptual through early facility design stages, seeking a cost-effective design that meets both operational efficiencies and the regulatory environment. The larger scope of the project, i.e., in future stages, includes the identification of potentially conflicting requirements identified by the ISOSS framework, including an analysis of how regulatory requirements may be changed to account for the intrinsic features of SMRs.

98 NUCLEAR DISARMAMENT, SAFEGUARDS, AND PHYSICAL P↗

Effect of Tip-Speed Constraints on the Optimized Design of a Wind Turbine

This study investigates the effect of tip-velocity constraints on system levelized cost of energy (LCOE). The results indicate that a change in maximum tip speed from 80 to 100~m/s could produce a 32% decrease in gearbox weight (a 33% reduction in cost) which would result in an overall reduction of 1%-9% in system LCOE depending on the design approach. Three 100~m/s design cases were considered including a low tip-speed ratio/high-solidity rotor design, a high tip-speed ratio/ low-solidity rotor design, and finally a flexible blade design in which a high tip-speed ratio was used along with removing the tip deflection constraint on the rotor design. In all three cases, the significant reduction in gearbox weight caused by the higher tip-speed and lower overall gear ratio was counterbalanced by increased weights for the rotor and/or other drivetrain components and the tower. As a result, the increased costs of either the rotor or drivetrain components offset the overall reduction in turbine costs from down-sizing the gearbox. Other system costs were not significantly affected, whereas energy production was slightly reduced in the 100~m/s case low tip-speed ratio case and increased in the high tip-speed ratio case. This resulted in system cost of energy reductions moving from the 80~m/s design to the 100~m/s designs of 1.2% for the low tip-speed ratio, 4.6% for the high tip-speed ratio, and 9.5% for the final flexible case (the latter result is optimistic because the impact of deflection of the flexible blade on power production was not modeled). Overall, the results demonstrate that there is a trade-off in system design between the maximum tip velocity and the overall wind plant cost of energy, and there are many trade-offs within the overall system in designing a turbine for a high maximum tip velocity.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Preliminary Evaluation of Alternate Designs for HFIR Low-Enriched Uranium Fuel

Engineering design studies of the feasibility of conversion of the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) from high-enriched uranium (HEU) to low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuel are ongoing at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) as part of an effort sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy s Global Threat Reduction Initiative (GTRI)/Reduced Enrichment for Research and Test Reactors (RERTR) program. The fuel type selected by the program for the conversion of the five high-power research reactors in the U.S. that still use HEU fuel is a new U-Mo monolithic fuel. Studies by ORNL have previously indicated that HFIR can be successfully converted using the new fuel provided (1) the reactor power can be increased from 85 MW to 100 MW and (2) the fuel can be fabricated to a specific reference design. Fabrication techniques for the new fuel are under development by the program but are still immature, especially for the complex aspects of the HFIR fuel design. In FY 2012, the program underwent a major shift in focus to emphasize developing and qualifying processes for the fabrication of reliable and affordable LEU fuel. In support of this new focus and in an effort to ensure that the HFIR fuel design is as suitable for reliable fabrication as possible, ORNL undertook the present study to propose and evaluate several alternative design features. These features include (1) eliminating the fuel zone axial contouring in the previous reference design by substituting a permanent neutron absorber in the lower unfueled region of all of the fuel plates, (2) relocating the burnable neutron absorber from the fuel plates of the inner fuel element to the side plates of the inner fuel element (the fuel plates of the outer fuel element do not contain a burnable absorber), (3) relocating the fuel zone inside the fuel plate to be centered on the centerline of the depth of the plate, and (4) reshaping the radial contour of the relocated fuel zone to be symmetric about this centerline. The present studies used current analytical tools to evaluate the various alternate designs for cycle length, scientific performance (e.g., neutron scattering), and steady-state and transient thermal performance using both safety limit and nominal parameter assumptions. The studies concluded that a new reference design combining a permanent absorber in the lower unfueled region of all of the fuel plates, a burnable absorber in the inner element side plates, and a relocated and reshaped (but still radially contoured) fuel zone will allow successful conversion of HFIR. Future collaboration with the program will reveal whether the new reference design can be fabricated reliably and affordably. Following this feedback, additional studies using state-of-the-art developmental analytical tools are proposed to optimize the design of the fuel zone radial contour and the amount and location of both types of neutron absorbers to further flatten thermal peaks while maximizing the performance of the reactor.

Renfro, David G.↗

Preliminary Evaluation of Alternate Designs for HFIR Low-Enriched Uranium Fuel

Engineering design studies of the feasibility of conversion of the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) from high-enriched uranium (HEU) to low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuel are ongoing at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) as part of an effort sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy’s Global Threat Reduction Initiative (GTRI)/Reduced Enrichment for Research and Test Reactors (RERTR) program. The fuel type selected by the program for the conversion of the five high-power research reactors in the U.S. that still use HEU fuel is a new U-Mo monolithic fuel. Studies by ORNL have previously indicated that HFIR can be successfully converted using the new fuel provided (1) the reactor power can be increased from 85 MW to 100 MW and (2) the fuel can be fabricated to a specific reference design. Fabrication techniques for the new fuel are under development by the program but are still immature, especially for the “complex” aspects of the HFIR fuel design. In FY 2012, the program underwent a major shift in focus to emphasize developing and qualifying processes for the fabrication of reliable and affordable LEU fuel. In support of this new focus and in an effort to ensure that the HFIR fuel design is as suitable for reliable fabrication as possible, ORNL undertook the present study to propose and evaluate several alternative design features. These features include (1) eliminating the fuel zone axial contouring in the previous reference design by substituting a permanent neutron absorber in the lower unfueled region of all of the fuel plates, (2) relocating the burnable neutron absorber from the fuel plates of the inner fuel element to the side plates of the inner fuel element (the fuel plates of the outer fuel element do not contain a burnable absorber), (3) relocating the fuel zone inside the fuel plate to be centered on the centerline of the depth of the plate, and (4) reshaping the radial contour of the relocated fuel zone to be symmetric about this centerline. The present studies used current analytical tools to evaluate the various alternate designs for cycle length, scientific performance (e.g., neutron scattering), and steady-state and transient thermal performance using both safety limit and nominal parameter assumptions. The studies concluded that a new reference design combining a permanent absorber in the lower unfueled region of all of the fuel plates, a burnable absorber in the inner element side plates, and a relocated and reshaped (but still radially contoured) fuel zone will allow successful conversion of HFIR. Future collaboration with the program will reveal whether the new reference design can be fabricated reliably and affordably. Following this feedback, additional studies using state-of-the-art developmental analytical tools are proposed to optimize the design of the fuel zone radial contour and the amount and location of both types of neutron absorbers to further flatten thermal peaks while maximizing the performance of the reactor.

38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗

A BASIS FOR MODIFYING THE TANK 12 COMPOSITE SAMPLING DESIGN

The SRR sampling campaign to obtain residual solids material from the Savannah River Site (SRS) Tank Farm Tank 12 primary vessel resulted in obtaining appreciable material in all 6 planned source samples from the mound strata but only in 5 of the 6 planned source samples from the floor stratum. Consequently, the design of the compositing scheme presented in the Tank 12 Sampling and Analysis Plan, Pavletich (2014a), must be revised. Analytical Development of SRNL statistically evaluated the sampling uncertainty associated with using various compositing arrays and splitting one or more samples for compositing. The variance of the simple mean of composite sample concentrations is a reasonable standard to investigate the impact of the following sampling options. Composite Sample Design Option (a). Assign only 1 source sample from the floor stratum and 1 source sample from each of the mound strata to each of the composite samples. Each source sample contributes material to only 1 composite sample. Two source samples from the floor stratum would not be used. Composite Sample Design Option (b). Assign 2 source samples from the floor stratum and 1 source sample from each of the mound strata to each composite sample. This infers that one source sample from the floor must be used twice, with 2 composite samples sharing material from this particular source sample. All five source samples from the floor would be used. Composite Sample Design Option (c). Assign 3 source samples from the floor stratum and 1 source sample from each of the mound strata to each composite sample. This infers that several of the source samples from the floor stratum must be assigned to more than one composite sample. All 5 source samples from the floor would be used. Using fewer than 12 source samples will increase the sampling variability over that of the Basic Composite Sample Design, Pavletich (2013). Considering the impact to the variance of the simple mean of the composite sample concentrations, the recommendation is to construct each sample composite using four or five source samples. Although the variance using 5 source samples per composite sample (Composite Sample Design Option (c)) was slightly less than the variance using 4 source samples per composite sample (Composite Sample Design Option (b)), there is no practical difference between those variances. This does not consider that the measurement error variance, which is the same for all composite sample design options considered in this report, will further dilute any differences. Composite Sample Design Option (a) had the largest variance for the mean concentration in the three composite samples and should be avoided. These results are consistent with Pavletich (2014b) which utilizes a low elevation and a high elevation mound source sample and two floor source samples for each composite sample. Utilizing the four source samples per composite design, Pavletich (2014b) utilizes aliquots of Floor Sample 4 for two composite samples.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Synergistic Computational and Microstructural Design of Next- Generation High-Temperature Austenitic Stainless Steels

The purpose of this project was to: 1) study deformation twinning, its evolution, thermal stability, and the contribution on mechanical response of the new advanced stainless steels, especially at elevated temperatures; 2) study alumina-scale formation on the surface, as an alternative for conventional chromium oxide, that shows better oxidation resistance, through alloy design; and 3) design new generation of high temperature stainless steels that form alumina scale and have thermally stable nano-twins. The work involved few baseline alloys for investigating the twin formation under tensile loading, thermal stability of these twins, and the role of deformation twins on the mechanical response of the alloys. These baseline alloys included Hadfield Steel (Fe-13Mn-1C), 316, 316L and 316N stainless steels. Another baseline alloy was studied for alumina-scale formation investigations. Hadfield steel showed twinning but undesired second phases formed at higher temperatures. 316N stainless steel did not show signs of deformation twinning. Conventional 316 stainless steel demonstrated extensive deformation twinning at room temperature. Investigations on this alloy, both in single crystalline and polycrystalline forms, showed that deformation twins evolve in a hierarchical manner, consisting of micron–sized bundles of nano-twins. The width of nano-twins stays almost constant as the extent of strain increases, but the width and number of the bundles increase with increasing strain. A systematic thermomechanical cycling study showed that the twins were stable at temperatures as high as 900°C, after the dislocations are annealed out. Using such cycles, volume fraction of the thermally stable deformation twins were increased up to 40% in 316 stainless steel. Using computational thermodynamics and kinetics calculations, we designed two generations of advanced austenitic stainless steels. In the first generation, Alloy 1, which had been proposed as an alumina-forming austenitic stainless steel, is fully austenitic, but possesses carbides that were not dissolvable and could not be controlled. This alloy also did not show deformation twinning. Alloy 2 was designed based on alloy 1, but was not fully austenitic and had significant traces of uncontrollable precipitates as well. Alloy 3, also designed based on alloy 1, was mainly austenitic with evolution of a second phase along the grain boundaries, but also had precipitates that were not controllable. Based on the knowledge gained from the first generation of the designed steels, two more steels, called PGAA1 and PGAA2, were proposed using genetic algorithms that, based on the modelling, were supposed to exhibit alumina-scale formation. PGAA1, however, did not demonstrate a fully austenitic structure. PGAA2 could achieve a mostly austenitic structure through thermo-mechanical processing, and was then used for oxidation tests. The oxidation tests of PGAA2, with and without nitrogen impurities, along with alloy 1, suggested that PGAA2 can form alumina-scale similar to alloy 1, but N impurity will prevent formation of such a scale, probably through formation of aluminum nitrides. For the above mentioned genetic algorithm framework of alloy design, separate models were developed for specific design criteria. For prediction of alumina formation in stainless steels, a model was constructed based off of two criteria – effective valence and third element effect. These criteria capture the thermodynamics and kinetics of alumina formation in steels. To test the efficacy and robustness of this model, they were tested against alloys in the literature which had been experimentally verified to exhibit alumina formation and the predictions were in excellent agreement with the experiments. Another meta-model for prediction of twinning in unknown steel compositions was developed by an informatics based machine learning/data mining approach. Stacking Fault Energy data was captured from the literature for a large number of steel compositions and then this data was used to build a classifier to predict deformation mechanisms. Here a training set-test set based analysis was performed to test performance. The above genetic algorithm based optimization framework for alloy design was exhibited to be a successful methodology for accelerated materials discovery in the context of alloy design.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Prototype Design, Analysis, and Results for a Liquid Radiological Waste Control Room

Human factors researchers at Idaho National Laboratory are collaborating with a utility partner to address human factors in the modernization of their radiological waste control room. The collaborating utility, Palo Verde, plans to remove all control boards associated with the liquid radiological waste system, which include controls, indicators, and alarm systems, and replace them with modernized digital instrumentation and controls and displays. To be sure the new system either supports current operational performance or enhances it, researchers have carried out three planning and analysis activities: expert operator review, function allocation analysis, and human factor principles and design applications. Researchers utilized access to expert operators to gain information about the system. Operators were asked to detail a procedure exemplifying typical interactions with the liquid radiological waste system and provide it to Idaho National Laboratory with a list of functionalities to incorporate (Section 4.1). Later, operators were asked to provide additional feedback to inform a prototype with adequate realism to support sound analysis of the system design (Section 4.2). Other operators not associated with the utility partner were also involved in experiment design and prototype evaluation (Section 4.2). Due to the extent of the upgrade, care was given to measure the change in the operator’s role (Section 7). As part of the modernization, some plant systems are expected to be equipped with automation or sensors that send information directly to the control where previously operators were required to enter controlled areas to find the information. Such updates made slight changes to operator role requirements, but the impact was negligible. The way the system is operated will remain largely the same, but operator convenience and safety is expected to increase. Additionally, to map operator tasks during the selected procedure, an Operational Sequence Diagram was created (Section 7.1). The diagram helped to account for every interaction and piece of equipment needed to create the prototype design. Alternatively, the diagram can be created following the final design to identify any function reallocations due to redesign. Human factors principles were also applied to the design. An ergonomic assessment was performed on the workspace resulting in various recommendations for placing and designing the new workstation (Section 6). A 3 D mockup of the control room was created to depict the options available with in-depth descriptions of each. Furthermore the prototype design incorporates well known human factors principles. However, to be sure the principles are sound in the control room context, the researches have designed an experiment to measure the impact design decision has on operator performance. The experiment is described in detail in Section 5. Lastly, a tool emerged as this effort began called the NUREG 0711 Crosswalk (Section 8). The tool has multiple uses, but it was primarily intended to communicate how the researcher’s action directly mapped to specific results suggested in the Nuclear Regulatory Commission review guideline. The tool also maps how current results impact future decisions in the modernization process.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗

Alternate Design Concepts for the High Flux Isotope Reactor using Low-Enriched Uranium Fuel Systems: Scoping Analysis

The Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) is a multi-mission research reactor dedicated mainly to isotope production, neutron scattering experiments, material irradiation, testing and activation. In the framework of non-proliferation policies, the international community is currently aiming to reduce or even eliminate, when and where possible, the use of Highly Enriched Uranium (HEU: 235 U/U ≥ 20 wt. %) in civilian applications. In that context, most research reactors worldwide still operating with HEU fuel are actively engaged in an effort to convert to Low Enriched Uranium fuel system (LEU: 235 U/U < 20 wt. %). Within the US, the High Performance Research Reactor (USHPRR) fleet (which includes HFIR) is expected to convert to LEU fuel using the UMo “monolithic” fuel system currently under development. ORNL is responsible for the development of a LEU design for HFIR. In the past years, Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) offered technical assistance to the ORNL LEU design team whenever deemed appropriate. Due to their complex nature, acceptable HFIR LEU designs identified so far, all based on the UMo monolithic fuel system, would require a substantial fabrication development effort before being proven commercially viable. In order to mitigate technical risks and reduce cost/schedule uncertainties, it appears appropriate to study alternate design solutions and alternate fuel systems as possible backup options for the HFIR conversion to LEU fuel. In that context, ANL has been exploring alternate design concepts for HFIR. Complementing the ORNL design activities, the goal is to find the best design solution for HFIR in term of cost, performance and safety. The present report summarizes the findings regarding two types of alternate conceptual design: U 3 Si 2 designs and un-contoured UMo design. Based on available tools and methods, preliminary analysis show that both concepts could probably meet performance and steady-state safety requirements but element fabrication would remain complex and would require a non-trivial fabrication development effort.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Status Report on the Water-Based NSTF RCCS Capability: Preparations and Design for the Transformation of the Natural Convection Shutdown Heat Removal Test Facility (NSTF) From Air to Water-based Cooling

The following report provides an overview of the current status of the water-based transformation, including details of the design, geometry, and fabrication of the test section and network piping, for the ½ scale water-based NSTF program at Argonne National Laboratory. In early FY2015, efforts towards a water-based design began in parallel with on-going air-based work, and began by identifying top level objectives of the transformation. Scaling studies and preparation tasks with computational modeling were carried out to guide the design decisions, minimize distortions, and ensure relevant data among scales. This entailed close collaboration with AREVA, whose water-based RCCS (included as part of their 625 MWt SC-HTGR) served as the primary design basis for incorporation into the NSTF. A literature review of previous works was made, with an emphasis placed on similar facilities, relevance to passive decay heat removal, and details pertaining to two-phase flow and measurement techniques. The study focused on input from key designers and a thermal analysis of existing cooling panels (e.g. at TAMU and UW-Madison) and two proposed AREVA cooling panels. A base case was used as a reference point for parametric studies of effects from varying tube spacing (pitch), tube diameter, fin thickness, and materials. Then, a structural analysis was performed to ensure safe material stresses during high temperature operation. Details of the pipe network geometry and guidelines for design of the water storage tank are finally presented, followed by engineering drawings in the appendix. The results of this study have identified a suitable configuration to support both the ANL/DOE project goals and the DOE vision to provide AREVA with data suitable for characterizing the RCCS of their full scale HTGR design. The dimensions were not selected for optimal RCCS performance, but instead to serve as a representative yet bounding configuration for future implementation into a full scale design. Scaling distortions are unavoidable; however, they can be accurately predicted based on earlier works of derived similarity solutions. Flexibility remained a primary design philosophy, and will allow the test facility to easily accommodate future alterations. The final design for the test section and network piping is as follows: riser tubes: 1.5” Schedule 160, 5.91” (150-mm) pitch, 304L stainless, heat transfer panels: 5/16” plates, 4.01” (102-mm) width, full penetration weld to risers, 304L stainless, split into 4 panels per riser separated by horizontal 1/8” gaps, test section: Eight (x8) riser tubes and nine (x9) heat transfer panels, fabricated into banks of two (x2) riser tubes and three (x3) fins, joined to form single section, and network geometry: 4.0” Schedule 40, 304L stainless. Details of the water storage tank will reflect competing effects such as thermal hydraulic phenomena during single and two-phase operation. These considerations include mixing during single-phase jet penetration, condensation of rising bubbles during two-phase discharge, bubble entrainment into the liquid outlet, and liquid carry-over into the steam outlet.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Exhaust runner soot diagnostic conceptual design for in-line time-resolved soot mass measurements

The Exhaust Runner Soot Diagnostic (ERSD) system is an in-line, time-resolved soot mass measurement system designed to allow rapid measurement of soot mass flux to detect and measure cyclic variability. The ERSD system design was generally split into two sections: conceptual mechanical design and measurement design—meaning the relevant calculations to demonstrate the feasibility of our planned measurement approach. For measurement design, the Beer-Lambert Law was the central focus for design justification. With measured values for the Filter Smoke Number (FSN) and a conversion to soot mass concentration, the required effective optical path length can be calculated for a desired light attenuation percentage. For mechanical design, the key constraints were space and modularity. The design must be placed into an existing mechanical setup with relative ease, as well as being modular enough to be implemented on other engines. The crux of the mechanical design was proper sealing and optical access, as both are crucial to the system's effectiveness. For proper sealing, extensive thermal expansion calculations were performed alongside O-ring design guides to produce the desired sealing and custom gland dimensions. For maximizing optical access, many iterations were modeled to provide full optical access while maintaining effective gas sealing.

02 PETROLEUM↗

Design and Development of Low Weight, Titanium Aluminide Airfoils for High Performance Industrial Gas Turbines meeting 65% Combined Cycle Efficiency (Final Report)

This project funded under DOE-FOA-0001816 was performed with the intent of evaluating the potential of utilizing a low density, high specific strength Titanium Aluminide (TiAl) alloy in a large annulus last stage gas turbine blade with the intent of improving combined cycle gas turbine efficiency toward a goal of reaching 65% efficiency. The project consisted of identifying a potentially suitable TiAl material for manufacture of such a large blade by investment casting. This included estimation of design properties for the selected alloy, trade studies using a baseline design created for a nickel based alloy cast in the TiAl alloy to evaluate potential design changes required for the use of this material and optimization of a prototype design for the same baseline application using the selected TiAl alloy. Several rounds of optimization were completed with the intent of meeting the baseline design targets with a resulting design that showed at least equivalent performance in terms of creep, LCF/TMF, HCF and aerodynamic damping potential. While it was found that significant reductions in blade loading on the disk were possible, the design resulting from the optimization met most lifing targets at the baseline size, but showed a reduction in margins in some areas in comparison to the Ni-based baseline design. Additionally, it was found that the low strain tolerance of the TiAl alloy for temperatures at and below the operational temperature of the attachment resulted in marginal, although still acceptable, creep rupture performance of the design. Due to results indicating the reduced potential for increasing turbine annulus compared to expectations a Phase II award was not proposed and it is not recommended to pursue additional design optimization efforts until further material advances with TiAl materials are achieved.

03 NATURAL GAS↗

U.S. Domestic Pebble Bed Reactor: Security-by-Design

U.S. nuclear power facilities face increasing challenges in meeting dynamic security requirements caused by evolving and expanding threats while keeping cost reasonable to make nuclear energy competitive. The past approach has often included implementing security features after a facility has been designed and without attention to optimization, which can lead to cost overruns. Incorporating security in the design process can provide robust, cost effective, and sufficient physical protection systems. The purpose of this work is both to develop a framework for the integration of security into the design phase of High Temperature Gas Reactors (HTGRs) that utilize pebble-based fuels and increase the use of modeling and simulation tools to optimize the design of physical protection systems. Specifically, this effort focuses on integrating security into the design phase of a model HTGR that meets current Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) physical protection requirements and providing advanced solutions to improve physical protection and decrease costs. A suite of tools, including SCRIBE3D©, PATHTRACE© and Blender© were used to model a hypothetical, generic domestic HTGR facility. Physical protection elements such as sensors, cameras, barriers, and guard forces were added to the model based on best practices for physical protection systems. Multiple outsider sabotage scenarios were examined with four-to eight adversaries to determine security metrics. The results of this work will influence physical protection system designs and facility designs for U.S. domestic HTGRs. This work will also demonstrate how a series of experimental and modeling capabilities across the Department of Energy (DOE) Complex can impact the design of and complete Safeguards and Security by Design (SSBD) for SMRs. The conclusions and recommendations in this document may be applicable to all SMR designs.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

U.S. Domestic Microreactor Security-by-Design

U.S. nuclear power facilities face increasing challenges in meeting dynamic security requirements caused by evolving and expanding threats while keeping cost reasonable to make nuclear energy competitive. The past approach has often included implementing security features after a facility has been designed and without attention to optimization, which can lead to cost overruns. Incorporating security in the design process can provide robust, cost effective, and sufficient physical protection systems. The purpose of this work is both to develop a framework for the integration of security into the design phase of a microreactor and increase the use of modeling and simulation tools to optimize the design of physical protection systems. Specifically, this effort focuses on integrating security into the design phase of a model microreactor that meets current Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) physical protection requirements and providing advanced solutions to improve physical protection and decrease costs. A suite of tools, including SCRIBE3D©, PATHTRACE© and Blender© were used to model a hypothetical, generic domestic microreactor facility. Physical protection elements such as sensors, cameras, barriers, and guard forces were added to the model based on best practices for physical protection systems. Multiple outsider sabotage scenarios were examined with four-to-eight adversaries to determine security metrics. The results of this work will influence physical protection system designs and facility designs for U.S. domestic microreactors. This work will also demonstrate how a series of experimental and modeling capabilities across the Department of Energy (DOE) Complex can impact the design of and complete Safeguards and Security by Design (SSBD) for microreactors. The conclusions and recommendations in this document may be applicable to all microreactor designs.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Outreach to Industry on Safeguards by Design Concept for Small Modular Reactors

"Safeguards by Design" (SBD) is the process of incorporating safeguards features into the design of a nuclear facility during the design stage. The goal of SBD is to increase the safeguardability of a facility, which is a qualitative measure of the degree of ease with which a nuclear energy system can be effectively and efficiently placed under international safeguards. During the past decade, the National Nuclear Security Administration's (NNSA) Next Generation Safeguards Initiative funded the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), Brookhaven National Laboratory, and several consultants to develop the Facility Safeguardability Assessment (FSA) process. FSA is a screening process used by a facility designer to focus attention on the aspects of their facility or process design that would most benefit from application of SBD principles and practices. The process identifies the most relevant guidance within the SBD tools for enhancing the safeguardability of the design. During FY 2014, NNSA sponsored BNL and LANL to introduce the FSA to Westinghouse designers of their small modular nuclear power plant design. This report documents the interactions with Westinghouse Electric Company LLC ("Westinghouse") staff. The report describes the Westinghouse safeguards design concept with a view towards eventual application of the FSA to their design.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Artificial Intelligence for Multiphysics Nuclear Design Optimization with Additive Manufacturing

The geometric flexibility of additively manufactured metals and ceramics generates a very large and open design space that requires advanced modeling and simulation tools for physics simulations and the rigorous definition of design problems. This effort deploys artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) algorithms to understand the design space, evaluate potential designs, and more efficiently generate optimized results. The Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) program is leveraging advances in several scientific areas—including materials, manufacturing, sensors and control systems, data analytics, and high-fidelity modeling and simulation—to accelerate the design, manufacturing, qualification, and deployment of advanced nuclear energy systems. Through a manufacturing-informed design approach, the TCR program seeks to integrate digital data for rapid nuclear innovation; accelerate the adoption of advances in manufacturing, materials, and computational sciences for nuclear applications; and dramatically reduce deployment costs and timelines for new nuclear reactor technologies. This report documents efforts under the TCR program to leverage advanced modeling and simulation techniques driven by AI/ML algorithms on high-performance computing (HPC) systems to yield more optimized TCR core designs. A multiphysics ML surrogate model was developed to run on the HPC architectures. The surrogate model is trained on high-fidelity simulation data of coupled neutronics and thermofluidics and is used to quickly evaluate thousands of candidate core designs in parallel, which drives the evolution of the cooling channel shapes to minimize temperature peaking and material stress. Outcomes from these activities provide design information and feedback into the core design efforts.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Development of Creep-Fatigue Design Methodology for Base Metal and Weldments of G91

This report provides an update on research activity at the Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) in the area of high temperature materials design methodology for advanced ferritic-martensitic steels for advanced Small Module Reactor (aSMR) Concepts. This is a Level 2 report delivered in FY15 (M2AT-15AN1602013) under the work package AT-15AN160201 “Materials Design Technology for Advanced SMR Concepts” performed by ANL for the Department of Energy, Office of Nuclear Energy. The overall objective of the Materials for Advanced SMR Concepts is to address key long-term design needs for applications of advanced materials. Advanced materials are a critical element in the development of advanced SMR concepts. High temperature materials design technology must be developed to realize the benefits of advanced materials in advanced reactor designs. Among a number of technical issues relevant to materials performance criteria and high temperature design methodology, creep, creep-fatigue, weldment design methodologies, and long-term thermal aging effects are of the highest priority. The effort in this project has focused on improvement of current ASME creep-fatigue design rules and development of a mechanism-based creep-fatigue design method for ferritic-martensitic steels, G91 and G92. This report presents the development of a fundamentally new creep-fatigue life model for G91 base metal and improvements of understanding of creep-fatigue interactions and creep-fatigue design rules for G91 weldments.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Learning Optimal Aerodynamic Designs

This project created a framework for efficient, accurate, and scalable deep neural network representations of design optimization problem solutions. The inputs to these DNN representations are the vector of design requirement parameters, the outputs are the optimal design variables, and the goal is to learn the map from inputs to outputs (i.e., inverse design). The team addressed the problem of the optimal shape design of aerodynamic lifting surfaces—in particular aircraft wings—using a Reynolds-Average Navier Stokes model to govern the CFD-based aerodynamic shape optimization. The inverse design map for such problems is very complex and high-dimensional, involving inputs and outputs on the order of 1000s. To approximate this inverse design map, the team developed algorithms to construct parsimonious DNN architectures, which automatically identify low-dimensional manifolds in which design requirements affect optimal shape parameters, and trained these architectures with multifidelity optimization methods. The resulting methodology accurately and automatically designs optimal aerodynamic lifting surfaces with very high accuracy (99%) at interactive speeds, of the order of milliseconds, resulting in factors of one million or more speedup relative to CFD-based design optimization.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Preliminary Design Process for Networked Microgrids

Changes in economic, technology, and environmental policies are resulting in a re-evaluation of the dependence on large central generation facilities and their associated transmission networks. Emerging concepts of smart communities/cities are examining the potential to leverage cleaner sources of generation, and the potential to integrate electricity generation with other municipal functions. When grid-connected, these generation assets can supplement the existing interconnections with the bulk transmission system, and in the event of an extreme event, they can provide power via networks of microgrids. While the design process for a single stand-alone microgrid is relatively well understood, the process of designing the infrastructure for networked microgrid operations has not been well studied. Because of the wide range of potential operational goals for microgrids, it is typical to follow the engineering process of developing an initial conceptual design, a preliminary design, a detailed design, and then a final as-built design. The conceptual design is typically completed without detailed engineering analysis, and the preliminary design is the first stage that requires it. This paper presents a process for developing the preliminary design for networked microgrids, which can then be used as a basis for the final as-built design.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗