Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “HANDBOOK”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,621 records · Page 90

Evaluating Age Effects on HEPA Filter Performance

Nuclear grade high efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters are routinely employed as the final control element in confinement ventilation systems. The traditional HEPA filter utilizes a pleated filter medium of fibrous glass that has been produced in a manner analogous to manufacturing paper. These filters are the physically weakest element in a containment ventilation system. Containment ventilation systems are designed to condition the air-stream (temperature, relative humidity, moisture, particle size distribution of aerosols, and aerosol concentration) to levels/conditions that fibrous glass HEPA filters can handle. Approximately 6000 nuclear grade HEPA filters are purchased each year for use in the DOE/NNSA complex. Additional filters are purchased for use in commercial nuclear power generation and ventilation systems of other nuclear applications. These filters are designed and tested in accordance with the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) AG-1 Code Nuclear Air and Gas Treatment. This code establishes design requirements and qualification procedures. Qualification testing of axial flow filters is described in paragraphs 5000 and following of AG-1. The series of qualification tests are intended to describe the operating envelope of HEPA filters and verify the reliability of a filter design. AG-1 qualification also confirms the pedigree of components used in manufacture for that filter design. The collective set of qualification tests establishes the assumed operating envelope for AG-1 filters. The effects of age on HEPA filter performance have been a concern for at least two decades. A combination of physical evaluation of aged filter media and a review of filter failure records resulted in Appendix C of the Nuclear Air Cleaning Handbook (NACH), Determination of HEPA Filter Life. This states that HEPA filters are not to be used beyond 10 years from the date of manufacture. Additionally, filters put into service in locations where they may become wet are to be taken out of service five years from date of manufacture. Filters that have become wet are to be taken out of service immediately. Finally, it should also be pointed out that filters held in Level B storage are subject to the same 10-year service life. Very limited bench-scale testing in the 1990's raised concern that aging HEPA filters do not have the strength to withstand an accident scenario. In May of 1999, the DNFSB released a Technical Report 23 entitled HEPA Filters Used in the Department of Energy's Hazardous Facilities. This report expressed concerns for the potential vulnerability of HEPA filters in vital safety systems. Concerns and uncertainty associated with degradation of HEPA filter performance over time led the DOE sites to limit HEPA filter service life to 10 years from the date of manufacture or five years in cases where filters may become wet. Establishment of a conservative service life needs to be based on data from a structured series of tests comparing the performance envelope of new and aged full-scale filters. A service life that is insufficiently conservative endangers workers and the public. One that is excessively conservative costs can cause hundreds of otherwise unnecessary filter changes. This increases exposure of employees, disrupts facility operations, and increase disposal costs by millions of dollars annually. Conclusive data are needed to resolve uncertainty associated with the damaging effects of aging on durability of HEPA filters. Therefore, this study needs to provide a sufficient body of evidence to allow DOE and site professionals to make prudent decisions. An updated version of ASME AG-1 Section FC included a non-mandatory appendix that would include the DOE guidance for service life of HEPA filters. Balloting of this revision generated significant resistance to inclusion of any kind of service life language citing the lack of supporting experimental data. Efforts to resolve negative votes failed and resistance to acceptance of the language increased. The result has been to not include service language in Section FC and requests to remove it from sections that already include such language. The recent activity of the ASME AG-1 Committee on Nuclear Air and Gas Treatment effectively de-emphasizes following DoE's service life guidelines. The DOE Office of Nuclear Safety under its NSR and D program provided the Mississippi State University Institute for Clean Energy Technology (ICET) finding to initiate a study to determine the effects of aging on AG-1 axial flow filters just prior to actions taken within the AG-1 committee regarding service life. The NSR and D funding facilitated timely development of a national technical working group comprised of members from the regulatory community, DOE complex, and commercial power to resolve uncertainty associated with effects of aging. The Department of Energy Office of Environmental Management (DOE-EM) has been funding the ICET to evaluate the performance envelope for AG-1 HEPA filters. ICET is one of DOE-EM's qualified suppliers. Synergy has been achieved by associating the NSR and D aged filter activities to testing activities evaluating the performance envelopes of separator and separator-less AG-1 HEPA filters funded by DOE-EM. The DOE-EM funded activities establish baseline data for the aged filter study and future EM funding will provide long term support for testing additional aged filters. EM funding of new filters includes analytical evaluation of media tensile strength by thermal analysis to establish baseline values and determine mass loss of moisture resistance and acrylic binders due to use. All of these values can be used for comparison of test results for aged filters. (authors)

07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗

Development of a Research Reactor Protocol for Neutron Multiplication Measurements

Establishing a protocol for measurements on research reactors is the next step in advanced subcritical neutron multiplication inference measurements. Such measurements can help identify deficiencies and quantify uncertainties in nuclear data and validate predictive Monte Carlo radiation transport simulation capabilities related to subcritical neutron multiplication inference techniques. This work expands on previous benchmark-quality efforts performed at the National Criticality Experiments Research Center (NCERC) located in Nevada, including subcritical experiments with a 4.5-kg {alpha}-phase plutonium sphere surrounded by copper, tungsten and nickel. Evaluations of the nickel and tungsten measurements have both been accepted into the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project (ICSBEP) Handbook. The nickel benchmark was the first ICSBEP-accepted evaluation of measurements using the Feynman Variance-to-Mean method based on the Hage-Cifarelli formulism, and was the culmination of many years of subcritical experiment research. To help establish a protocol for research reactor-based subcritical measurements, a series of Critical and Subcritical {Phi}-Power Experiments at Rensselaer (CaSPER) have been designed. This neutron multiplication measurement series will be executed at the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Walthousen Reactor Critical Facility (RPI-RCF) in upstate New York. The RPI reactor facility can provide benchmark-quality integral experimental configurations where different reactivity states can be achieved by varying the control rod height/water height in the reactor. The diversity of achievable configurations are also unique in contrast to previous subcritical benchmark measurements in that they are spatially complex, involve different materials (fuel, moderator), and are characterized by system-specific neutron cross section sensitivities (various energy ranges and neutron reaction contributions). It is worth noting that previous proof-of-concept subcritical measurements have been performed on thermal systems at NCERC, at a variety of reactivity states by separation distance, yet it was not possible to know the reactivity of various configurations accurately for benchmarking (there are no control rod worth curves as there are no control rods). (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Review of CTF's Fuel Rod Modeling Using FRAPCON-4.0's Centerline Temperature Predictions

Coolant Boiling in Rod Arrays-Two Fluid (COBRA-TF), or CTF1, is a nuclear thermal hydraulic subchannel code used throughout academia and industry. CTF's fuel rod modeling is originally developed for VIPRE code. Its methodology is based on GAPCON and FRAP fuel performance codes, and material properties are included from MATPRO handbook. This work focuses on review of CTF's fuel rod modeling to address shortcomings in CTF's temperature predictions. CTF is compared to FRAPCON which is U.S. NRC's steady-state fuel performance code for light-water reactor fuel rods. FRAPCON calculates the changes in fuel rod variables and temperatures including the effects of cladding hoop strain, cladding oxidation, hydriding, fuel irradiation swelling, densification, fission gas release and rod internal gas pressure. It uses fuel, clad and gap material properties from MATPRO. Additionally, it has its own models for fission gas release, cladding corrosion and cladding hydrogen pickup. It allows finite difference or finite element approaches for its mechanical model. In this study, FRAPCON-4.0 is used as a reference fuel performance code. In comparison, Halden Reactor Data for IFA432 Rod 1 and Rod 3. CTF simulations are performed in two ways; informing CTF with gap conductance value from FRAPCON, and using CTF's dynamic gap conductance model. First case is chosen to show temperature is predicted correctly with CTF's models for thermal and cladding conductivities once gap conductance is provided. Latter is to review CTF's dynamic gap conductance model. These Halden test cases are selected to be representative of cases with and without any physical contact between fuel-pellet and clad while reviewing functionality of CTF's dynamic gap conductance model. Improving the CTF's dynamic gap conductance model will allow prediction of fuel and cladding thermo-mechanical behavior under irradiation, and better temperature feedbacks from CTF in transient calculations.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

The future of Sinbad: learning from the best practices of ICSBEP - 24622

Two projects sanctioned by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Nuclear Energy Agency (NEA) have over two decades of experience established comprehensive data sets in handbooks supporting criticality safety and reactor physics. The International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project (ICSBEP), and later the International Reactor Physics Experiment Evaluation Project (IRPhEP) that was patterned after the success of the ICSBEP, serves as an example of quality and excellence in preserving our nuclear data heritage and establishing benchmark standards upon which current and future modeling, validation, and safety efforts can be supported. Many of the best practices and lessons learned from these benchmark projects can be adopted and adapted for use with the Shielding Integral Benchmark Archive and Database (SINBAD) to prepare higher quality shielding benchmark data to effectively expand the availability of qualified experimental data available to the nuclear community. The unique experiments performed and aggregated within SINBAD represent characteristic measurements, techniques, and applications not captured with the specificity of nuclear criticality safety or traditional reactor physics applications. Application of evaluated SINBAD benchmark data would challenge and enhance our current nuclear data and modeling and simulation strategies. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

The experiment filtering tool in the MACSENS workbench - 14341

The MACSENS (outils Moret d'Aide a la Caracterisation et aux etudes de SENSibilite) workbench is dedicated to the advanced validation work for criticality studies. The aim of this kind of tool is to determine the experiments from a validation database being the 'closest' to an application case and, from there, to evaluate a calculation bias with a related uncertainty. To achieve this goal, the MACSENS workbench relies on different kind of information stored in various databases depending on the origin of the data. Two main kinds of data can be identified. The first one concerns the data used to describe the experiments of the validation database (e.g. the inputs needed to perform a calculation). These values characterize the chemical and geometrical models. They can be considered as constant, as they do not vary once evaluated, and some of them can be from a non-numerical nature (reflector material for example...). The second kind of data gathers the results obtained with the use of a simulation code, such as reaction rates, fluxes and leakages, sensitivities, k{sub eff}, etc. These values depend on the version of the code and are purely numerical. In the early 2000's, regarding the increasing number of experiments evaluated in the ICSBEP handbook, the OECD/NEA (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development/Nuclear Energy Agency), under the ICSBEP (International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project) working group direction, decided to store such information in a database and to provide a software, called DICE (Database for the International Criticality safety benchmark Evaluation project), allowing users to search easily criticality experiments of interest. Up to now, more than 4400 critical or subcritical configurations have been compiled by ICSBEP, described and stored in the DICE database. Over time, a validation work has been done on the data, with the participation of IRSN, and a quality assurance policy has been defined. For these reasons, the DICE database is highly reliable. These features were fundamental for the MACSENS developers, who were looking for a database containing descriptive data of the experiments included in the MORET code validation database. The paper describes the solution chosen by IRSN to take advantage of the DICE database content and to overcome the DICE limits. It also explains the quality assurance policy applied to guaranty the reliability of the stored data. It will also discuss the use of the experiment-filtering module of the MACSENS workbench to select a set of experiments and to examine numerical parameter trends for an application case. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Use of tsunami in the validation of scale 6.1 for the Swedish spent fuel repository - 14381

In March 2011 SKB applied to the Swedish Radiation Safety Authority (SSM) for a permit to build a final repository for spent Fuel and an encapsulation plant (Clink). The application contained a criticality safety analysis for the canisters to be used in Clink and the copper canister to be used in the final repository. In 2012 SSM requested several updates to the application. One of SSM's concerns was the validation of the codes. SSM emphasized that SKB must improve the method to select critical experiments to the validation suite. To satisfy this demand, SKB used the tool Tsunami in the Scale 6.1 code package to select experiments from the handbook of criticality experiment (IHECSBE). With help of sensitivity files SKB evaluated almost 700 experiments from the LEU-COMP-THERM library. SKB then picked the experiments that most resembled our safety cases. The sensitivity coefficient, ck, from Tsunami has been used to evaluate the similarity between the experiments and the applications. It has been considered that a ck over 0.8 provides a 'good enough' similarity between the experiment and our evaluated safety cases. For the different safety cases between 50-600 experiments satisfied the 0.8 criteria giving a good base of data for statistical analysis. It is worth noticing that PWR-fuel generally receives a higher ck than BWR fuel. Initial analysis shows that the differences in results between BWR and PWR can be explained by a larger sensitivity for the U{sup 238} n,n' part of the cross section in the PWR cases. To make sure the validation covers all materials and required physical parameters a gap analysis was made using engineering judgement by criticality safety experts. From this exercise additional experiments were added to the suite. This paper will discuss the Tsunami results for different safety cases and the reasons for differences between them. It will also present the final results of the validation and discuss experiments that were excluded from the validation suite. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Joint neutron measurements on the flat-top HEU critical assembly machine - 14388

Flat-Top is a critical assembly with a spherical core (either ∼17 kg of HEU or ∼6 kg of δ-phase Pu) surrounded by a spherical 1000 kg natural uranium reflector. In 2013, joint LANL and CEA measurements were conducted to measure Flat-Top configurations with the HEU core using He-3 detector systems. Similar experiments were previously documented in which the Caliban and Godiva critical assemblies were measured. The core and reflector of Flat-Top have a glory hole in which nuclear material or non-nuclear material may be placed. Five configurations were measured and included subcritical configurations at various reactivity states as well as a configuration at delayed critical. The various reactivity states were achieved by varying the placement of the safety blocks and control rods (composed of natural uranium). A description of the assembly and the specific configurations measured will be presented. The subcritical and delayed critical measurements were analyzed using the Hage-Cifarelli formalism of the Feynman Variance-to-Mean method. This analysis can be used to calculate the multiplication of each configuration, from which the multiplication factor and reactivity are determined. These results are compared to the reactivity states based upon control rod worth curves and MCNP simulations. For this work, a new MCNP model was made to accurately represent the measured configurations. The ICSBEP handbook contains a benchmark of Flat-Top but all models are very simple and do not have the required fidelity to accurately represent the measured configurations. This work also examines the number of neutrons emitted per fission for this assembly (which has a significant contribution of induced fissions in U-238 due to the large natural uranium reflector). (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Sensitivities and correlations of critical experiments due to uncertainties of system parameters and nuclear data - 14416

With increasing demand on accuracy of criticality calculations, correlations between benchmark experiments due to system parameter uncertainties become of interest in bias determination. The impact of different interpretations of system parameter uncertainties on the calculation of covariances and correlations of k{sub eff} is discussed in this article. Following the suggestion of the OECD/NEA EGUACSA Benchmark phase IV [1], 21 experiments from the ICSBEP international Handbook of Evaluated Criticality Safety Benchmarks [2] are used for this analysis (LEU-COMP-THERM series 07, exp. 01-04 and 39, exp. 01-17). The experiments share certain assembly and fuel features and were carried out in the same lab. Therefore, correlations in the calculation of k{sub eff} appear. Correlation coefficients between experiments due to nuclear data uncertainties are calculated with TSUNAMI [3] and show high values for most experiments. For the correlation analysis due to system parameter uncertainties mainly two scenarios are considered: In scenario A all uncertain parameters are varied mutually for all fuel rods, representing a systematic deviation of the actual experimental setup from the design value. This analysis is performed for all experiments listed above. In scenario E certain parameters like the outer cladding diameter are varied for each fuel rod individually, representing a random scattering of the varied parameter. Scenarios B, C and D represent intermediate scenarios between A and E, which are discussed shortly. Uncertainty and sensitivity calculations of k{sub eff} on the uncertain experimental parameters based on Monte Carlo sampling are presented and discussed. The calculations were performed with SUnCISTT (Sensitivities and Uncertainties in Criticality Inventory and Source Term Tool [4]) and SCALE 6.1.2 [3]. For the 21 EGUACSA proposed experiments the outer cladding diameter is the leading effect for the uncertainty of k{sub eff} for scenario A. In contrast, for scenario E the impact of the cladding diameter on k{sub eff} cancels out due to rod wise variations leaving the fuel diameter as the leading effect. The correlation analysis based on system parameter uncertainties indicates a significant dependence of the correlation coefficients on the interpretation of the uncertainties. It shows high values for scenario A, if the neutronic features are similar (EALF, H/U). For scenario E the overall correlations are significantly smaller and variations between experiments decrease. The impact of the determined correlations on bias calculations of application cases will be discussed by the authors in the accompanying paper 'Impact of correlated data in validation procedures'. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

The final JEZEBEL evaluation? - 14440

A reevaluation of the {sup 239}Pu Jezebel experiment of 1954-1955 was published in the 2013 edition of the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project (ICSBEP) Handbook. Four high-fidelity benchmark models were included, but assumptions had to be made about the distribution of the mass among the Pu-ally parts. Since then, historic documents have been found that give the as-built Pu-alloy part masses, mass densities, and some dimensions. These quantities are not consistent, and to reconcile them we have retained the masses and densities but varied the dimensions. The final average calculated-to-experiment k{sub eff} of the four detailed models is only 0.00001 greater than in the 2013 reevaluation, and the experimental uncertainty is 0.00017 less. This reevaluation has not yet received an independent external review or approval by the ICSBEP Working Group. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Impact of correlated data in validation procedures - 14483

The increasing demand on accuracy of criticality calculations leads to the question, how to treat correlated data of benchmark experiments correctly. Correlations in the process of validation arise for example if a configuration in a series of experiments shares certain components, e.g. fuel rods. Traditional methods of code validation do not treat correlations explicitly, but give a more conservative estimation of the bias. Including correlations can lead to a more precise estimation. In the work at hand, a method is discussed based on Bayes theorem to include correlations in the experimental data when estimating an application case k{sub eff}. After a short introduction to the applied method and the demonstration of the general capability of it to predict the k{sub eff} correctly, it is shown how the calculated k{sub eff} of an application case depends on correlations in experimental data for a simple Toy Model. The impact of ignoring correlations and taking to account lower and higher correlations is shown and discussed. Further results are shown using a database of correlated experimental data from the International Handbook of Criticality Safety Experiments to estimate the bias of two application cases. The experiments were chosen following the suggestion of the OECD/NEA EGUACSA Benchmark phase IV and consists of 21 experiments from the LEU-COMP-THERM series 007 and 039. With the extracted data results the calculated k{sub eff} values of the application cases are shown and discussed for different examples of correlations. The calculations were done by applying Monte-Carlo sampling methods with the GRS tool SUnCISTT, using ORNL's SCALE 6.1.2. This work discusses a possible way of treating correlations in the recalculation of critical experiments to get a more precise bias estimation of the used code system. It will be shown, that the presented method is capable to treat similarities in experimental setups of data used to calculate the bias correctly, independent of the size of similarities. The presented method is in principle capable of assessing regimes with little experimental data to estimate a bias. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

The application of ICASPA to critical and safe mass calculations - 14586

ICASPA, an Improved Critical and Safe Parameters Algorithm, calculates the size of a fissile body for a given value of k-effective. ICASPA uses an iterative predictor/corrector algorithm in which the MONK9A code is used to derive a precise k-effective value for a given candidate body size; auxiliary equations are then used to adjust the body size. The process is repeated until MONK9A outputs the chosen target value of k-effective. EDF Energy operates eight nuclear power stations comprising one Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) and seven Advanced Gas-cooled Reactor (AGR) stations. At these sites, the term 'fuel route' is used to encompass all of the ex-reactor arrangements for the handling and storage of fuel. The criticality safety cases for these fuel routes are based on the use of geometrically safe arrangements for the required quantities of fuel. The allowed quantities and arrangements of fuel are safely sub-critical, even under the contingency of accidental moderator ingress. The fuel route safety cases consider all credible potential fault conditions, including events such as dropped fuel. Any such events might change the geometry of the fuel elements, but it is difficult to calculate exact k-effective values for realistic models of dropped fuel. This difficulty is overcome by the use of an alternative approach in which limiting safe masses are calculated for bounding (worst-case) rearrangements of fuel rods and moderators, using geometries similar to those covered by criticality handbook data. Where required, the resulting safe masses are used to set safety case limits and conditions. For example, some fire extinguishants, such as water and ABC dry powder, are also effective moderators. Hence, in some fuel route areas, administrative criticality controls are used to either prohibit or limit the permitted quantities of these materials. This paper describes the work that has been carried out to adopt ICASPA as the approved calculation method for these safe mass calculations. The work has been carried out within the company quality assurance requirements for nuclear safety related software. It has involved the development of a configuration controlled version of ICASPA and the local verification and validation of the resulting code. The benefits from the adoption of ICASPA are also presented. These include accuracy improvements and, because the method uses the MONK9A code for k-effective calculations, the ability to use more sophisticated models for limiting case geometries. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Experimental validation of the Cristal V2.0 French criticality calculation package - 14587

A new version of the CRISTAL criticality calculation package, named CRISTAL V2.0 [1], has been developed by IRSN and CEA, in collaboration with AREVA and EDF. Four calculation routes are now available, using nuclear data issued from the JEFF-3.1.1 evaluation: two multigroup routes based on 281 groups cross-sections (APOLLO2 - MORET 5 or APOLLO2-Sn calculations), a pointwise Monte Carlo route (TRIPOLI-4{sup R}) and a criticality standard calculation route. The CRISTAL V2.0 package, which will be delivered soon to OECD/NEA data bank, benefits from a broad validation database covering almost all areas of criticality-safety applications, from fuel fabrication to reprocessing, including transportation. 3,127 critical experiments, corresponding to 342 series, either issued from the OECD/ICSBEP Handbook or performed in French facilities (confidential data) were selected for the CRISTAL V2.0 validation database. Currently, more than 2,300 experiments are already part of the validation database. This validation work highlights an overall consistency to experimental data and inter-comparisons between the different calculation routes mainly show good agreements on a large set of common experiments. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Sensitivity studies to Support TEX critical experiments design

In the frame of the ongoing Thermal/Epithermal experiments program, supported by the DOE-NCSP, we are characterizing expected data with analysis of sensitivity coefficients to nuclear data. The computations were performed for detailed and simplified models of the experimental configurations in order to demonstrate their invariance with respect to small geometry variations. The sensitivity coefficients were computed with recently developed precise methodologies using Monte Carlo tools (MCNP-6.1, SCALE 6.1 and MORET 5.C.1) with the following nuclear data libraries: ENDF/B-VII.0, ENDF/B-VII.1, and JEFF3.1. Since the considered experiments are devoted to tantalum data validation, their neutronic characteristics are compared with the relevant integral experiment data collected in the OECD/NEA ICSBEP Handbook. Although analysis of sensitivity coefficients taken alone is insufficient for an entire assessment, we can conclude that TEX experimental results can fill gaps in the available benchmarks to facilitate quantification of uncertainty for plutonium containing systems with epithermal neutron spectra (e.g. wet plutonium-based powders). However, analysis of sensitivity profiles demonstrates that an advanced statistical methodology will be needed to fit tantalum nuclear data or to evaluate the associated uncertainties. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

The Jupiter High-240 Experiment

The Jupiter High-240 experiment was performed in May of 2019 by researchers from Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) at the National Criticality Experiments Research Center (NCERC) in the Device Assembly Facility (DAF) located at the Nevada National Security Site (NNSS). This experiment has previously been mentioned briefly in prior publication related to a collaborative effort with the Japan Atomic Energy Agency (JAEA) to assess lead void coefficients of reactivity in uranium- and plutonium-fueled systems with lead. This series of experiments supports JAEA’s research into the development of an accelerator driven transmutation system for spent nuclear fuel. The Jupiter High-240 experiment built upon the previous Jupiter experiment by incorporating plutonium fuel plates with higher 240 Pu content. Efforts to formally benchmark the original Jupiter experiment have continued for inclusion in the benchmark handbook of the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project (ICSBEP). Whereas there is much similarity between the two Jupiter experiments, there is a desire to also evaluate and benchmark this second experiment to further contribute towards the availability of lead-sensitive benchmarks. The components utilized in these two experiments have also been used to perform other subcritical and Rossi-α measurements.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

The Case for and Against a Gadolinium Bias in SCALE: Round 2

The “Opening Arguments” for and against a gadolinium bias in SCALE were presented at the American Nuclear Society Annual Meeting in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, in June, 2018. Some critical experiments included in the Oak Ridge National Laboratory Verified, Archived Library of Inputs and Data (VALID) indicate a significant bias as a function of gadolinium concentration. Other experiments indicate that no significant bias exists. The work presented here develops a larger suite of gadolinium-bearing benchmark models to further examine code, data, and benchmark performance. The new benchmark models have been reviewed for accuracy, but documentation and review for addition to the VALID library have not been completed. The problematic benchmarks included in VALID are HEU-SOL-THERM-014 and -016. These are two evaluations from a series of experiments from the Institute for Physics and Power Engineering (IPPE), Russia, documented in the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project (ICSBEP) Handbook. The entire set of evaluations also includes HEU-SOL-THERM-015, -017, -018, -019, and -025. Each evaluation contains a different uranium concentration, and different configurations within each evaluation include different gadolinium concentrations. These 7 evaluations contain a total of 52 configurations and form the largest subset of experiments considered, and they allow for a more complete assessment of the performance of these benchmarks than has historically been possible using just the HEU-SOL-THERM-014 and -016 results. Additional solution experiments are considered, including MIX-SOL-THERM-006 and -007 and PU-SOL-THERM-034. MIX-SOL-THERM-007 is in the VALID library, whereas MIX-SOL-THERM-006 and PU-SOL-THERM-034 are not. The results for MIX-SOL THERM-007 have not shown a gadolinium trend. These mixed- and plutonium-fueled solutions include 28 configurations. Some experiments including solid fuel and solid gadolinium are also included. These experiments include highly enriched uranium (HEU) foils moderated with polyethylene in HEU-MET-THERM-010, -016, and -034, and low enriched uranium (LEU) pin arrays with gadolinia absorber rods in LEU-COMP THERM-036 and -043. A total 32 cases with solid fuel are included. The IPPE solution benchmarks show a fairly high degree of variability, but no clear trend as a function of gadolinium concentration can be observed. The mixed- and plutonium-fueled solutions show less variability than the HEU solutions and also no trend relative to gadolinium concentration. The solid-fueled experiments also show no trend as a function of gadolinium content. The entire set of benchmarks shows no clear trend on gadolinium content or the energy of the average neutron lethargy causing fission.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Neutron Absorber Plate Characterization Plan for Criticality Experiments Design

After being used in nuclear installations, depleted fuel can still be highly reactive and must be handled securely to prevent any radiological or criticality concerns. In particular, spent fuel from use in nuclear power reactors must be stored and transported in specifically designed containers using neutron absorber materials to prevent criticality. Various neutron absorber material types exist and are manufactured by various entities, as thoroughly described in the Handbook of Neutron Absorber Materials for Spent Nuclear Fuel Storage and Transportation Applications written by EPRI. Presently, one of the most modern and most widely used types of neutron absorber material contains particles of boron carbide, or B 4 C, embedded in aluminum matrix: Boralcan, manufactured by Rio Tinto. It is very important for the community to know as much as possible about such neutron absorber materials. Therefore, in the recent years, a US Department of Energy National Nuclear Security Administration–Nuclear Criticality Safety Program funded project initiated design of an experiment that places Boralcan neutron-absorbing plates in an established critical assembly using low-enriched uranium fuel at the Sandia Pulsed Reactor Facility/Critical Experiments (SPRF/CX) apparatus at Sandia National Laboratories. The goal of the experiment is to produce high-quality benchmark data to submit to the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project (ICSBEP), for use in validating calculational tools and nuclear data by criticality safety analysts. The project, named IER-554, is currently in its final design stage, following a successful preliminary design. In the work documented in the design study, ten critical configurations using Boralcan neutron absorber plates were designed, and the experiment was proven to be feasible, with a predicted low k eff uncertainty around 100 pcm. An overview of the modeled cutout of the critical assembly with a Boralcan plate is shown in Figure 1, representing one of the configurations planned for the critical experiments. Before the plates are inserted in the critical assembly, it is necessary to know more about their composition and uniformity. This summary focuses on the plate characterization plans. Each plate will undergo (1) neutron transmission measurements at different locations to determine the 10 B areal density and (2) an in-depth x-ray computed tomography (XCT) examination to obtain the exact Sizes and distribution of the B4C powder particles inside the plates. In parallel, plate modeling studies are performed with a goal to determine the validity of the currently used approximation of modeling the neutron absorber plates as a homogeneous mixture of Aluminum 1100 alloy and B4C— instead of explicitly modeling the B4C particles. By using the experimental 10 B areal density measurements, and the exact size and location of the B4C particles obtained by XCT, a plate model can theoretically be built that reproduces the plate with extremely high fidelity. The results of this modeling study could increase the confidence of the criticality safety community in its modeling methods when using this type of neutron absorber material, and the industry could use these validations to change the boron loading credit limits from the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission standard review plan for dry cask storage of spent nuclear fuel. The modeling calculations are performed with SCALE 6.3.0 using the KENO V.a sequence for criticality calculations with the ENDF/B-VIII.0 continuous-energy cross section library.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Investigation of the Impact of TSL Data Libraries and Geometry Variations on the MSRE Benchmark

The increasing demand for green, low-carbon energy solutions has amplified the focus on advanced nuclear reactor technologies. Among these, Molten Salt Reactors (MSRs) have been spotlighted because of their special features. Historically, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) started the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) in 1956. Later, ORNL and the University of California, Berkeley (UCB) jointly developed the MSRE benchmark. This was then reviewed by the International Reactor Physics Experiment Evaluation Project (IRPhEP) committee and added to their 2019 handbook. In the current study, the benchmark model was recreated via the Serpent code. The calculated effective multiplication factor was 1.02087 ± 0.00019, which gives a deviation of about 2000 pcm compared to the benchmark/experimental result. At North Carolina State University (NCSU), recent evaluations were conducted on thermal scattering cross sections for molten salt FLiBe and 20% porous nuclear graphite, anticipated for incorporation in the ENDF/B-VIII.1 library. The influences of these thermal scattering law (TSL) data and geometry changes on the multiplication factor were examined using the ENDF/B-VII.1 and ENDF/B-VIII.0 libraries. Introducing the TSL data for FLiBe and 20% porous graphite resulted in an effective multiplication factor of +270 pcm compared to the reference value obtained with ENDF/B-VII.1 in this study. The adjustment of the reactor vessel dimensions resulted in decrease of -448 pcm in the calculated effective multiplication factor.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Baseline Characterization Database Verification Report ? NBG-17 Billet V104

The purpose of this report is to present data collected in the Baseline Graphite Characterization Program, which is directly tasked with supporting the Idaho National Laboratory’s (INL’s) research and development efforts on the Advanced Reactor Technologies (ART) Program. This program populates a comprehensive database that reflects the baseline properties of nuclear-grade graphite regarding individual grade, billet, and position within individual billets. The physical- and mechanical-property information being collected will be transferred to the Nuclear Data Management and Analysis System (NDMAS), and that database will help populate the handbook of property data available to member nations of the Generation-IV International Forum. Transfer of these data from the applicable technical lead to the dissemination databases available to other end users requires a full review of the test procedures and data-collection efforts through an analysis of the multiple summary spreadsheets and values being collected. This report represents the analysis for NBG-17 Billet V104 and facilitates release of associated data to the NDMAS custodians. Millions of raw data points have been collected during testing and quantification analyses for these billets. The summary scalar property values and supplementary traceability data are collected into comprehensive spreadsheets. Data sets are composed of single billets of graphite for any given grade, organized by mechanical test-specimen type, and further subdivided into individual spreadsheet tabs according to the specific test or evaluation being performed. A direct analysis of properties was not conducted, and this report does not provide information on the validity or performance characteristics of the graphite itself. Rather, this report is intended as a verification of the completeness of actual data collected in accordance with PLN-3467, “Baseline Graphite Characterization Plan: Electromechanical Testing,” [1] and PLN-3348 “Graphite Mechanical Testing” [2] and their representation of the measurement and test results with sole regard to the graphite billets under evaluation.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗