Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “stability and convergence”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 163 records · Page 9
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

Spectrally Stabilized Interface Capturing Formulation and Implementation in Nek5000/NekRS

This report documents the formulation of a novel level-set method for incompressible two-phase flows in the continuous Galerkin (CG) high order spectral element framework. The overall method hinges on a novel implementation of the spectral vanishing viscosity (SVV) operator for the stabilization of linear/non-linear hyperbolic problems. The multidimensional SVV convolution kernels, which in essence, have a similar effect as a high pass filter applied to the derivatives, are formulated by exploiting the tensor product form, analogous to the construction of the usual stiffness matrix system. The resulting kernels are directionally decoupled and ensure a linear, symmetric positive definite, elliptic matrix operator. The SVV formulation is demonstrated to provide a robust stabilizing mechanism through challenging linear and non-linear hyperbolic problems, including problems pertinent to the level-set formulation. The two-phase framework conceptualized herein is based on the conservative level-set (CLS) method which represents the interface between the fluids by the 0.5 iso-contour of the smoothed Heaviside function. The CLS method is augmented with a preconditioning procedure for interface normals using the signed distance function which precludes the manifestation of spurious oscillations in the vicinty of the interface. Further, the existing mixed explicit-implicit approach for the solution of Navier-Stokes equations in Nek5000, as described in Tomboulides et al, is augmented with a pressure coefficient splitting approach for the Poisson equation, which greatly accelerated the convergence of pressure solver for two-phase systems with large density ratio. The robustness and accuracy of the overall two-phase method is demonstrated through canonical challenging problems involving high density and viscosity ratios, with and without surface tension. The two-phase formulation is wholly implemented in Nek5000 and the SVV stabilization method is implemented in NekRS, which is the essential precursor to the two-phase framework, undergoing active development.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2024

Double cylinder implosion experiments at the National Ignition Facility

Here, cylindrical implosion experiments are used to directly measure instability growth in a convergent geometry, providing a wealth of data for model validation. Double cylinders are a natural extension of the platform and enable measurements at a classically unstable interface, the outer surface of the inner cylinder, which experiences no ablative stabilization from the laser drive. However, the utility of this platform relies upon maintaining adequate axial uniformity of the inner cylinder during the implosion. Although previous smaller-scale double cylinder experiments exhibited acceptable levels of axial uniformity, radiation-hydrodynamics simulations of larger-scale double cylinders predict more axial non-uniformity induced by the impedance mismatch as the shock wraps around the axial ends of the inner cylinder. A mechanism to reduce axial non-uniformity in these larger double cylinder implosions is presented, and preliminary experimental data confirms the efficacy of the selected mitigation approach.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2021

Maximum bound principle preserving integrating factor Runge–Kutta methods for semilinear parabolic equations

A large class of semilinear parabolic equations satisfy the maximum bound principle (MBP) in the sense that the time-dependent solution preserves for any time a uniform pointwise bound imposed by its initial and boundary conditions. Here, the MBP plays a crucial role in understanding the physical meaning and the well-posedness of the mathematical model. Investigation on numerical algorithms with preservation of the MBP has attracted increasingly attentions in recent years, especially for the temporal discretizations, since the violation of MBP may lead to nonphysical solutions or even blow-ups of the algorithms. In this paper, we study high-order MBP-preserving time integration schemes by means of the integrating factor Runge-Kutta (IFRK) method. Beginning with the space-discrete system of semilinear parabolic equations, we present the IFRK method in general form and derive the sufficient conditions for the method to preserve the MBP. In particular, we show that the classic four-stage, fourth-order IFRK scheme is MBP preserving for some typical semilinear systems although not strong stability preserving, which can be instantly applied to the Allen-Cahn type of equations. To our best knowledge, this is the first time to present a fourth-order linear numerical method preserving the MBP. In addition, convergence of these numerical schemes is proved theoretically and verified numerically, as well as their efficiency by simulations of 2D and 3D long-time evolutional behaviors. Numerical experiments are also carried out for a model which is not a typical gradient flow as the Allen-Cahn type of equations.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2023

The DESC stellarator code suite. Part 1. Quick and accurate equilibria computations

Three-dimensional equilibrium codes are vital for stellarator design and operation, and high-accuracy equilibria are also necessary for stability studies. This paper details comparisons of two three-dimensional equilibrium codes: VMEC, which uses a steepest-descent algorithm to reach a minimum-energy plasma state, and DESC, which minimizes the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) force error in real space directly. Accuracy as measured by satisfaction of MHD force balance is presented for each code, along with the computation time. It is shown that DESC is able to achieve more accurate solutions, especially near axis. The importance of higher-accuracy equilibria is shown in DESC's better agreement of stability metrics with asymptotic formulae. DESC's global Fourier–Zernike basis also yields solutions with analytic derivatives explicitly everywhere in the plasma volume, provides improved accuracy in the radial direction versus conventional finite differences and allows for exponential convergence. Further, DESC can compute a solution with the same accuracy as VMEC in order-of-magnitude less time.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2020

Beyond Limber: efficient computation of angular power spectra for galaxy clustering and weak lensing

Angular two-point statistics of large-scale structure observables are important cosmological probes. To reach the high accuracy required by the statistical precision of future surveys, some of these statistics may need to be computed without the commonly employed Limber approximation; the exact computation however requires integration over Bessel functions, and a brute-force evaluation is slow to converge. Here, we present a new method based on our generalized FFTLog algorithm for the efficient computation of angular power spectra beyond the Limber approximation. The new method significantly simplifies the calculation and improves the numerical speed and stability. It is easily extended to handle integrals involving derivatives of Bessel functions, making it equally applicable to numerically more challenging cases such as contributions from redshift-space distortions and Doppler effects. We implement our method for galaxy clustering and galaxy-galaxy lensing power spectra. We find that using the Limber approximation for galaxy clustering in future analyses like LSST Year 1 and DES Year 6 may cause significant biases in cosmological parameters, indicating that going beyond the Limber approximation is necessary for these analyses.

weak gravitational lensing↗
DOE OSTI2021

A statistical mechanics approach to macroscopic limits of car-following traffic dynamics

Herein we study the derivation of macroscopic traffic models from car-following vehicle dynamics by means of hydrodynamic limits of an Enskog-type kinetic description. We consider the superposition of Follow-the-Leader (FTL) interactions and relaxation towards a traffic-dependent Optimal Velocity (OV) and we show that the resulting macroscopic models depend on the relative frequency between these two microscopic processes. If FTL interactions dominate then one gets an inhomogeneous Aw–Rascle–Zhang model, whose (pseudo) pressure and stability of the uniform flow are precisely defined by some features of the microscopic FTL and OV dynamics. Conversely, if the rate of OV relaxation is comparable to that of FTL interactions then one gets a Lighthill–Whitham–Richards model ruled only by the OV function. We further confirm these findings by means of numerical simulations of the particle system and the macroscopic models. Unlike other formally analogous results, our approach builds the macroscopic models as physical limits of particle dynamics rather than assessing the convergence of microscopic to macroscopic solutions under suitable numerical discretisations.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2025

Multi-plane moment-of-fluid interface reconstruction in 3D

Moment-of-fluid (MOF) methods for interface reconstruction approximate the region occupied by material in each mesh element only through reference to its geometric moments. Here, we present a 3D MOF method that represents the material (POM) in each cell as the convex intersection of the cell and multiple half-spaces, each selected to minimize the least-squares error between computed moments of the approximated material and provided reference moments. This optimization problem is highly non-linear and non-convex, making the numerical result very sensitive to the initial guess. To create an effective initial guess in each cell, we construct an ellipsoid from 0th–2nd order reference moments such that its shape corresponds with that of the POM. Within this ellipsoid we inscribe a polyhedron, and initialize the minimization problem with the half-spaces defined by each of its faces. The inscribed polyhedron has minimally 4 faces, and using up to 3rd order moments permits optimization over up to 20 unknown values. We therefore define MOF methods that utilize 4, 5, or 6 half-spaces, correspondingly initialized with the faces of a single inscribed tetrahedron, triangular prism, or hexahedron. Stability of the non-linear optimization is further improved with a prepossessing step that normalizes the reference moments according to the axes of the reference ellipsoid. Using this approach, the non-linear least-squares solver reliably converges to a near-global minimum from a single initial guess. We demonstrate accuracy and robustness using single-cell and multi-cell examples over a wide spectrum of geometry. In particular, we demonstrate our ability to exactly reproduce several important and complex features defined by up to four half-spaces, such as corners, filaments, filament tips, and embedded material in the cell.

3D interface reconstruction↗
DOE OSTI2021

Kinetic equilibrium reconstructions of plasmas in the MAST database and preparation for reconstruction of the first plasmas in MAST upgrade

Reconstructions of plasma equilibria using magnetic sensors were routine during operation of the Mega Ampere Spherical Tokamak (MAST) device, but reconstructions using kinetic profiles were not. These are necessary for stability and disruption analysis of the MAST database, as well as for operation in the upgrade to the device, MAST-U. The three-dimensional (3D) code VALEN is used to determine eddy currents in the 3D vessel structures for vacuum coil test shots, which are then mapped to effective resistances in the two-dimensional vessel groupings in the EFIT equilibrium reconstruction code to be used in conjunction with nearby loop voltage measurements for estimated currents in the structures during reconstruction. Kinetic equilibrium reconstructions with EFIT, using all available magnetic sensors as well as Thomson scattering measurements of electron temperature and density, charge exchange recombination spectroscopy measurements of ion temperature, and internal magnetic field pitch angle measurements from a motional Stark effect (MSE) diagnostic are performed for a large database of MAST discharges. Excellent convergence errors are obtained for the portions of the discharges where the stored energy was not too low, and it is found that reconstructions performed with temperature and density measurements but without MSE data usually already match the pitch angle measurements well. A database of 275 kinetic equilibria is used to test the ideal MHD stability calculation capability for MAST. In conclusion, the necessary changes to conducting structure in VALEN, and diagnostic setup in EFIT have been completed for the upgrade from MAST to MAST-U, enabling kinetic reconstructions to commence from the first plasma discharges of the upgraded device.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2023

Cost-constrained adaptive simulations of transient spray combustion in a gas turbine combustor

Predictive high-fidelity simulations of turbulent spray combustion must capture the combined effects of complex chemistry, multiphase evaporating flow and spray-flame interactions to achieve physical accuracy. Finite-rate chemistry (FRC) combined with a realistic chemical mechanism is a combustion model well-suited for this purpose, but has a high computational cost due to the large number and stiffness of transported chemical species. In contrast, flamelet-based models achieve lower cost by transporting a small number of quantities of reduced stiffness, but assumptions regarding local flame topology, boundary conditions and inter-phase coupling limit their physical accuracy. Recently, the Pareto-efficient combustion (PEC) framework was developed to dynamically assign combustion models based on local cost and accuracy metrics in gas-phase reacting flows. In this work, we extend this PEC framework to spray combustion through the rigorous analysis of the multiphase coupling terms in the governing equations. The derivation shows that spray evaporation causes errors in the prediction of species mass fractions for flamelet-based models due to the sensitivity of the local thermo-chemical state to changes in composition caused by fuel vaporization across combustion regimes present in practical spray combustion devices. Sub-model assignment is formulated as a multiple-choice knapsack problem, where computational cost is directly controlled through the fraction of the domain assigned to the FRC sub-model. The extended PEC formulation is applied to the simulation of a realistic rich-quench-lean gas turbine combustor at steady-state conditions, as well as transient operation resulting in lean blow-out (LBO). Analysis of transient simulations during LBO demonstrates the extended PEC formulation’s capacity to dynamically adapt to changing conditions within the combustor. Transient combustor dynamics are shown to approach convergence with limited increases in computational cost, while retaining substantial computational cost reduction compared to monolithic FRC simulations. Through PEC simulations with increasing fractions of the domain assigned to FRC, monolithic flamelet simulations are shown to over-predict flame stability during LBO. Finally, the extended PEC formulation is thus shown to overcome deficiencies of monolithic models by controlling modeling error for multiphase combustion modeling.

33 ADVANCED PROPULSION SYSTEMS↗
DOE OSTI2026

Single-crystal NMC622 from combustion-assisted solid-state synthesis: Tunable particle size, voltage-dependent stability, and Li-ion diffusion

Cost-effective and scalable synthesis of single-crystal lithium–metal-oxide cathodes with controlled size and morphology remains challenging for advancing high-performance lithium-ion batteries. Here, we demonstrate a solution combustion–assisted solid-state method for producing single-crystal NMC622 with tunable particle size at various lithium stoichiometries. Structural and electronic characteristics were probed using synchrotron-XANES, EXAFS, XRD and XPS, confirming well-defined coordination environments and phase purity up to Li ≈ 1.3. The electrochemical behavior of LixNMC (x = 1.0 and 1.3) single crystals was evaluated across 2.8–4.3 V and 2.8–4.7 V windows to elucidate the effects of lithium content and operating voltage. At 2.8–4.3V, Li1.3NMC exhibits higher initial capacity due to its larger lithium inventory, while Li1.0NMC shows superior long-term retention driven by its larger crystal size and reduced structural distortion. Increasing the cutoff voltage to 4.7 V enhances the initial capacity of both compositions by 17–25%, but long-term capacity retention ultimately converges to values comparable to those at 4.3 V due to voltage-induced degradation, where Li+ diffusion constant remains lying ranging from 10−12 –10−11 cm2s−1. Overall, this study establishes a scalable combustion-assisted route for synthesizing tunable single-crystal NMC622 and highlights the interplay between lithium stoichiometry, particle size, and voltage window in governing cathode stability.

Roy, Subrata C [Jackson State University]↗
DOE OSTI2024

A synthetic strategy for the preparation of alkoxy‐functionalized bis‐1,2,4‐triazinyl‐2,6‐pyridines

Heteroaryl-1,2,4-triazine complexants are commonly utilized in separation science for the selective chelation of minor An from Ln in simulated high-level waste. Furthermore, to facilitate access to relevant chemical entities for hypothesis-driven inquiry toward improved separations performance, a synthetic method to construct various alkoxy-complexant derivatives was required. In this work, a convergent synthetic strategy for the production of 3,3′- and 4,4′-tetraalkoxy-bis-1,2,4-triazinyl-2,6-pyridines from readily available starting materials via a dealkylation/alkylation/condensation approach is described. Synthetic method development, substrate scope, preliminary solubility, and hydrolytic stability data in various process-relevant diluents are reported herein.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2022

Studying the Richtmyer–Meshkov instability in convergent geometry under high energy density conditions using the Decel platform

The “Decel” platform at Sandia National Laboratories investigates the Richtmyer–Meshkov instability (RMI) in converging geometry under high energy density conditions [Knapp et al., Phys. Plasmas 27, 092707 (2020)]. In Decel, the Z machine magnetically implodes a cylindrical beryllium liner filled with liquid deuterium, launching a converging shock toward an on-axis beryllium rod machined with sinusoidal perturbations. The passage of the shock deposits vorticity along the Be/D2 interface, causing the perturbations to grow. Here, we present platform improvements along with recent experimental results. To improve the stability of the imploding liner to the magneto Rayleigh–Taylor instability, we modified its acceleration history by shortening the Z electrical current pulse. Next, we introduce a “split rod” configuration that allows two axial modes to be fielded simultaneously in different axial locations along the rod, doubling our data per experiment. We then demonstrate that asymmetric slots in the return current structure modify the magnetic drive pressure on the surface of the liner, advancing the evolution on one side of the rod by multiple ns compared to its 180° counterpart. This effectively enables two snapshots of the instability at different stages of evolution per radiograph with small deviations of the cross-sectional profile of the rod from the circular. Using this platform, we acquired RMI data at 272 and 157 μm wavelengths during the single shock stage. Finally, we demonstrate the utility of these data for benchmarking simulations by comparing calculations using ALEGRA MHD and RageRunner.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2026

Nanosecond Structure of Radical Pair Intermediates from High-Frequency Quantum Oscillations: Insight into the Q A •– to Q B Electron Transfer Step in Purple Bacterial Photosynthesis

We demonstrate the validity of our approach to deduce, from the anisotropy of quantum oscillations, the geometry of short-lived radical pair intermediates in photosynthesis. A global fit of a two-dimensional W-band (94 GHz) electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) experiment provides the same global minimum values for the geometry of the A-side radical pair P 700 •+ A 1A •− in photosystem I (PSI) as observed in a previous Q-band (34 GHz) EPR study, yet with a significantly increased convergence rate of 62%. This demonstrates that the global fit yields the correct radical pair geometry even at Q-band frequencies. With this information, we revisit our previous Q-band study of the cofactor arrangement of P 865 •+ Q A •− , the stabilized charge-separated state in purple bacterial reaction centers (RCs). Analysis of calculated two-dimensional data sets of P 865 •+ Q A •− reveals that the quantum oscillation technique is unaffected by a mirror ambiguity in disordered solids and thus can provide unambiguous solutions for all five Euler angles of the radical pair geometry. This enables us to elucidate the Q A •− to Q B electron transfer step in purple bacterial photosynthesis, the subject of controversial discussions for more than 25 years. Our results show that this electron transfer step involves a gating mechanism requiring a 60° rotation of the headgroup of Q A •− in its binding pocket.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Electronic and Vibrational Contributions to the Bulk Stabilities of Trivalent 3d Transition Metal Oxyhydroxides from Electronic Structure Calculations

Any understanding of the thermodynamic driving forces active in the global cycles of earth abundant metals requires attendant knowledge of the bulk mineral free energies. This can be particularly challenging for metal (oxyhydr)oxide phases which at low temperature aqueous conditions can be produced at a variety of hydration states and particle sizes. Here we present high quality density functional theory calculations of the relative bulk stabilities of a geologically important family of polymorphic trivalent metal oxyhydroxide crystal structures MOOH (M=Cr, Al, Fe). To improve understanding of their relative stabilities we permute the metal cations into the various possible canonical structure types including goethite (isostructural to diaspore and bracewillite), lepidocrocite (isosctructural to boehmite), guyaniite, and grimaldiite. Electronic, vibrational, and magnetic contributions are considered on a consistent theoretical footing using hybrid functionals and converged plane-wave bases. We find the considered bulk structures to be thermodynamically degenerate within the precision of the available theory, despite the fact that the vibrational and magnetic contributions vary substantially among the cations. A significant conclusion is that Cr3+ supports strong hydrogen bonds, low O-H stretching frequencies and facile H movement relative to the other cations.

Prange, Micah P.↗
DOE OSTI2022

Cloud Radiative Effects on MJO Development in DYNAMO

Observed Madden-Julian Oscillation (MJO) events are examined with the aid of regional model simulations to understand the role of cloud radiative effects in the MJO development. The importance of this role is demonstrated by the absence of MJO in the model simulations that contain no cloud radiative effects. Comparisons of model simulations with and without the cloud radiative effects and observation help identify the major processes arising from those effects. Those processes develop essentially from heating in the upper-troposphere due to shortwave absorption within anvil clouds in the upper troposphere and the convergence of longwave radiation in the middle-upper troposphere, with a peak at 300-hPa, during deep convection. First, that heating adds extra buoyancy and accelerates the rising motion in the upper troposphere in deep convection. The vertical acceleration in the upper troposphere creates a vacuum effect and demands for more deep convection to develop. Second, in response to that demand and required by mass balance arises the large-scale horizontal and vertical mass, moisture, and energy convergence. It strengthens deep convection and, with the feedback from continuing cloud radiative effect, creates conditions that can perpetuate deep convection and MJO development. That perpetuation does not occur however because those processes arising from the cloud radiative heating in the upper troposphere stabilize the troposphere till it supports no further deep convection. Weakening deep convection reduces cloud radiative effects. The subsequent reduction of the vacuum effect in the upper troposphere diminishes deep convection completing an MJO cycle. These results advance our understanding of the development of the MJO in the radiative-convective system over warm waters in the tropics. They show that while the embryo of intraseasonal oscillation may exist in the system its growth/development is largely dependent on cloud radiative effects and feedbacks.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2026

Solvent Reorganization and Surface–Species Interactions Control Transfer Hydrogenation Rates in Sn-Beta Zeolites

Reorganization of confined alcohol networks reshapes adsorption and activation thermodynamics in Lewis acid zeolites, yet the roles of adsorbate sterics and non-H-bonding cosolvents remain unclear. Here, we investigate transfer hydrogenation of methyl- (mCH) and tert-butylcyclohexanone (tbCH) with 2-butanol over hydrophobic Sn-Beta. First-order rates per defect-open Sn site are 2–5× higher for mCH than tbCH, but converge in the zero-order regime (333–393 K), indicating that solvent reorganization entropically drives adsorption, while bond activation is insensitive to ketone structure. Reactions in toluene or acetonitrile (with 1 M 2-butanol) show that intraporous solvent organization governs transition-state stabilization: on hydrophobic Sn-Beta, apparent enthalpies and entropies rise with decreasing solvent polarity, whereas hydrophilic zeolites display nearly constant barriers across solvents. Liquid-phase IR spectroscopy corroborates these trends, showing that hydrophilic pores enforce 2-butanol-like solvation environments even in toluene. Together, these results reveal how zeolite pores regulate the intraporous solvent structure, whose reorganization upon adsorption reshapes the thermodynamic landscape of Lewis acid catalysis

Adsorption↗
DOE OSTI2021

Rapid retreat of the southwestern Laurentide Ice Sheet during the Bølling-Allerød interval

The timing of Laurentide Ice Sheet deglaciation along its southwestern margin controlled the evolution of large glacial lakes and has implications for human migration into the Americas. Accurate reconstruction of the ice sheet’s retreat also constrains glacial isostatic adjustment models and is important for understanding ice-sheet sensitivity to climate forcing. Despite its significance, retreat of the southwestern Laurentide Ice Sheet (SWLIS) is poorly constrained by minimum-limiting 14 C data. We present 26 new cosmogenic 10 Be exposure ages spanning the western Interior Plains, Canada. Using a Bayesian framework, we combine these data with geomorphic mapping, 10 Be, and high-quality minimum-limiting 14 C ages to provide an updated chronology. This dataset presents an internally consistent retreat record and indicates that the initial detachment of the SWLIS from its convergence with the Cordilleran Ice Sheet began by ca. 15.0 ka, concurrent with or slightly prior to the onset of the Bølling-Allerød interval (14.7–12.9 ka) and retreated >1200 km to its Younger Dryas (YD) position in ~2500 yr. Ice-sheet stabilization at the Cree Lake Moraine facilitated a meltwater drainage route to the Arctic from glacial Lake Agassiz within the YD, but not necessarily at the beginning. Our record of deglaciation and new YD constraints demonstrate deglaciation of the Interior Plains was ~60% faster than suggested by minimum 14 C constraints alone. In conclusion, numerical modeling of this rapid retreat estimates a loss of ~3.7 m of sea-level equivalent from the SWLIS during the Bølling-Allerød interval.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2024

Topological Quantum Synchronization of Fractionalized Spins

The gapped symmetric phase of the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki model exhibits fractionalized spins at the ends of an open chain. Here, we show that breaking SU(2) symmetry and applying a global spin-lowering dissipator achieves synchronization of these fractionalized spins. Additional local dissipators ensure convergence to the ground state manifold. In order to understand which aspects of this synchronization are robust within the entire Haldane-gap phase, we reduce the biquadratic term, which eliminates the need for an external field but destabilizes synchronization. Within the ground state subspace, stability is regained using only the global lowering dissipator. These results demonstrate that fractionalized degrees of freedom can be synchronized in extended systems with a significant degree of robustness arising from topological protection. A direct consequence is that permutation symmetries are not required for the dynamics to be synchronized, representing a clear advantage of topological synchronization compared to synchronization induced by permutation symmetries.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗