Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “equilibrium modeling”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 163 records · Page 9

SCALE Analysis of a Fluoride Salt-Cooled High-Temperature Reactor in Support of Severe Accident Analysis

As part of a US Nuclear Regulatory Commission–sponsored project to assess the modeling and simulation capabilities for accident progression, source term, and consequence analysis for advanced reactor technologies with SCALE and MELCOR, SCALE was used for the modeling and simulation of a fluoride salt-cooled high-temperature reactor (FHR). Based on the preconceptual design for a small modular 236 MWth FHR developed by the University of California, Berkeley (PB-FHR-Mk1), a SCALE model of the PB-FHR-Mk1 reactor core was developed. The reactor was modeled at equilibrium state with different fuel compositions in different regions of the reactor. An iterative approach was used to interpolate and mix the burnup-dependent fuel compositions obtained through the depletion calculation of a core slice model. After demonstrating the applicability of SCALE’s multigroup (MG) approach for the simulation of the PB-FHR-Mk1, the resulting equilibrium core was studied in terms of the power profile, the flux profile, temperature reactivity coefficients, and the xenon reactivity. Furthermore, the tritium production rate in the salt coolant was determined, and the dependence of the one-group cross sections on the burnup and location in the reactor core was studied. The results obtained with SCALE were post-processed to provide the MELCOR team with the core inventory and decay heat of the equilibrium core, a zone-wise power profile, temperature feedback coefficients, the tritium production rate, and the xenon worth.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Initial study on cross section generation requirements for a PBR equilibrium core

A Serpent model of the HTR-PM equilibrium core was developed for use in cross section prepa-ration studies in order to guide methods development for the Griffin reactor multiphysics applica-tion. The model includes detailed isotopics for 10 distinct pebble burnup groups in 126 core zoneswith unique fuel and moderator temperatures obtained from a coupled neutronics-thermal-fluidsequilibrium core calculation using Griffin-Pronghorn. A sensitivity study of the fuel and mod-erator temperatures for various core regions was performed with the MOOSE stochastic tools.The results show that the uncertainties are, not unexpectedly, dominated by the value of the fluidtemperature and that the power level, heat transfer coefficient and effective conduction to neigh-boring pebbles and fluid constitute, at best, second order effects. The temperature uncertaintyrange varies from 28 K to 57 K at the core entry and exit planes, respectively, but these val-ues are probably higher. We still have to quantify the significance of these uncertainties in thepreparation of cross sections, which will be postponed for future work. In addition, we verifythat the single effective pebble approach works well for the preparation of region averaged crosssections in the infinite domain approximation. Nevertheless, there are significant discrepanciesin the cross sections when compared to the multi-pebble model. This could affect the predictionof peak values and in the depletion calculation. We conclude that is highly desirable for futurestudies with Griffin to be able to handle both the ?effective? pebble approximation and the multi-pebble approach for the various pebble burnup groups. This enables Griffin users the flexibilityto perform higher-fidelity studies. Finally, we initiate the preparation of cross sections for variouscore regions from the full core Serpent reference model. We quantify the differences in 26 groupcross sections from infinite domain models. These reference cross sections will serve to validatethe double heterogeneity, self-shielding, and spectrum-correction methods in Griffin.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Oxidized Sulfur Species in Slab Fluids as a Source of Enriched Sulfur Isotope Signatures in Arcs

Recycling of oxidized sulfur from subducting slabs to the mantle wedge provides simultaneous explanations for the elevated oxygen fugacity (fO 2 ) in subduction zones, their high hydrothermal and magmatic sulfur outputs, and the enriched sulfur isotopic signatures (i.e., δ 34 S > 0‰) of these outputs. However, a quantitative understanding of the abundance and speciation of sulfur in slab fluids consistent with high pressure experiments is lacking. Here we analyze published experimental data for anhydrite solubility in H 2 O-NaCl solutions to calibrate a high-pressure aqueous speciation model of sulfur within the framework of the deep earth water model. We characterize aqueous complexes, required to account for the high experimental anhydrite solubilities. We then use this framework to predict the speciation and solubility of sulfur in chemically complex fluids in equilibrium with model subducting mafic and ultramafic lithologies, from 2 to 3 GPa and 400 to 800°C at log fO 2 from FMQ-2 to FMQ+4. We show that sulfate complexes of calcium and sodium markedly enhance the stability of sulfate in moderately oxidized fluids in equilibrium with pyrite at fO 2 conditions of FMQ+1 to +2, causing large sulfur isotope fractionations up to 10‰ in the fluid relative to the slab. Such fluids could impart oxidized, sulfur-rich and high δ 34 S signatures to the mantle wedge that are ultimately transferred to arc magmas, without the need to invoke 34 S-rich subducted lithologies.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Adsorption of terbium (III) on DGA and LN resins: Thermodynamics, isotherms, and kinetics

Two commercially available extraction chromatography (EXC) resins containing N,N,N’,N’-tetra-n-octyldiglycolamide (DGA Resin, Normal, 50 – 100 μm) and Bis(2-ethylhexyl) phosphate (LN Resin, 100 – 150 μm) were used as adsorbents to study fundamental adsorption properties such as thermodynamic values, equilibrium isotherms, and kinetic uptake models for terbium(III) adsorption. Weight distribution ratios (D w ) for terbium on DGA and LN resins were measured using a [ 160 Tb]Tb 3+ radiometric tracer in nitric acid as a function of acidity, temperature, initial analyte concentration, and equilibrium time. The D w values showed increasing binding affinity for DGA resin at high nitric acid concentrations and decreasing binding affinity for LN resins. Thermodynamic studies for DGA and LN resins revealed that the Gibbs free energy (ΔG) increased consistently with temperature. To model equilibrium data, increasingly higher parameter equilibrium isotherm models (Henry (1) < Langmuir, Freundlich (2) < Redlich-Peterson (3) < Fritz-Schluender (4)) were compared on their root mean squared errors (RMSE) and adjusted determination coefficients to determine the most applicable model. In all cases, the empirical four-parameter Fritz-Schluender isotherm demonstrated a superior fit. Similar comparisons for reaction-based kinetic models (Pseudo-first-order < Pseudo-second-order < Pseudo-n-order) revealed that the higher-order PNO model yielded a superior fit of kinetic data for both resins. Furthermore, in some cases, adsorption isotherms and kinetic models could also be modeled by a lower-order model with minimal change in error parameters. Weber-Morris plots revealed that two linear sections are observed for each resin, where the first linear segment is attributed to fast (film diffusion) adsorption of terbium, followed by slower intraparticle diffusion of terbium through the pores as the rate-limiting step. Based on the Weber-Morris plot, both film and intraparticle diffusion are involved in controlling the kinetic rate of adsorption for DGA and LN resins.

38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗

Screening of resonant magnetic perturbation fields assuming various plasma flow models

A recently updated version of the MARS-F code [Y. Q. Liu et al., Phys. Plasmas 7, 3681 (2000); L. Li et al., Phys. Plasmas 25, 082512 (2018); and G. L. Xia et al., Nucl. Fusion 59, 126035 (2019)] is utilized to numerically investigate the plasma screening effect on the applied resonant magnetic perturbation (RMP) field, assuming various equilibrium flow models, including the toroidal flow, the parallel flow and their combinations, and poloidal and toroidal projections of the parallel flow. A parallel equilibrium flow with a uniform radial profile is found to have no effect on plasma screening of the RMP field. A sheared parallel flow, however, does change plasma screening. The poloidal projection of the parallel flow weakens plasma screening in the resistive-inertial regime. The effect on the favorable average curvature regime is found, however, to be non-monotonic. With the increasing flow speed, the poloidal projection first weakens Glasser-Green-Johnson (GGJ)-screening. Further increase in the flow speed results in enhanced GGJ-screening again. This non-monotonic behavior is related to the perturbed parallel shielding current, which appears also off the mode rational surface at fast flow due to additional resonances between the RMP perturbation and the sound wave continuum. These results indicate that flow induced plasma screening to the RMP field can have complicated characteristics, which, in turn, can have implications on the RMP field penetration into the plasma in experiments for controlling the edge localized modes.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Investigating nonlinear magnetohydrodynamics in an optimized, reactor-scale quasi-axisymmetric stellarator

We use the new simulation capabilities of the extended-magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) code, M3D-C1, to investigate the nonlinear MHD properties of a reactor-scale quasisymmetric stellarator equilibrium. Our model captures the self-consistent evolution of the magnetic field, temperature, density, and flow profiles without imposing restrictions on the structure of the first. We include the effects of resistivity using a realistic temperature-dependent Spitzer model, along with a model for heat transport that captures the key physical characteristic, namely, strongly anisotropic diffusion in directions perpendicular and parallel to the magnetic field. We consider a quasi-axisymmetric, finite-pressure equilibrium that was optimized for self-consistent bootstrap current, quasi-symmetry, and energetic particle confinement. Our assessment finds that the equilibrium is highly unstable to interchange-like pressure-driven instabilities near the plasma edge. The initially unstable modes rapidly destabilize other modes in the direction of the N-fold rotational symmetry (toroidal, in this case). For this equilibrium, N = 2, meaning destabilization of a large number of even-numbered toroidal Fourier modes. Thus, field-periodicity is likely to be an important factor in the nonlinear MHD stability characteristics of optimized stellarators.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Retreat and Regrowth of the Greenland Ice Sheet During the Last Interglacial as Simulated by the CESM2‐CISM2 Coupled Climate–Ice Sheet Model

Abstract During the Last Interglacial, approximately 129 to 116 ka (thousand years ago), the Arctic summer climate was warmer than the present, and the Greenland Ice Sheet retreated to a smaller extent than its current state. Previous model‐derived and geological reconstruction estimates of the sea‐level contribution of the Greenland Ice Sheet during the Last Interglacial vary widely. Here, we conduct a transient climate simulation from 127 to 119 ka using the Community Earth System Model (CESM2), which includes a dynamic ice sheet component (the Community Ice Sheet Model, CISM2) that is interactively coupled to the atmosphere, land, ocean, and sea ice components. Vegetation distribution is updated every 500 years based on biomes simulated using a monthly climatology to force the BIOME4 equilibrium vegetation model. Results show a substantial retreat of the Greenland Ice Sheet, reaching a minimum extent at 121.9 ka, equivalent to a 3.0 m rise in sea level relative to the present day, followed by gradual regrowth. In contrast, a companion simulation employing static vegetation based on pre‐industrial conditions shows a much smaller ice‐sheet retreat, highlighting the importance of the changes in high‐latitude vegetation distribution for amplifying the ice‐sheet response.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Data Needs for Modeling Low-Temperature Non-Equilibrium Plasmas: The LXCat Project, History, Perspectives and a Tutorial

Technologies based on non-equilibrium, low-temperature plasmas are ubiquitous in today’s society. Plasma modeling plays an essential role in their understanding, development and optimization. An accurate description of electron and ion collisions with neutrals and their transport is required to correctly describe plasma properties as a function of external parameters. LXCat is an open-access, web-based platform for storing, exchanging and manipulating data needed for modeling the electron and ion components of non-equilibrium, low-temperature plasmas. The data types supported by LXCat are electron- and ion-scattering cross-sections with neutrals (total and differential), interaction potentials, oscillator strengths, and electron- and ion-swarm/transport parameters. Online tools allow users to identify and compare the data through plotting routines, and use the data to generate swarm parameters and reaction rates with the integrated electron Boltzmann solver. In this review, the historical evolution of the project and some perspectives on its future are discussed together with a tutorial review for using data from LXCat.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Thermochemical Nonequilibrium Modeling in a Continuous-Galerkin, Finite-Element Framework

The presented work discusses the implementation, verification, and validation of Park's two-temperature model in a scalable, computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code developed at the US Department of Energy's Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). The implementation of Park's two-temperature model was verified through 0D test cases involving an adiabatic reactor and a nitrogen thermal bath. The implementation was then validated through comparisons with other validated CFD codes and experimental data on a hypersonic cylinder and double cones. These are standard benchmark test cases for thermochemical non-equilibrium (TCNE) modeling, and all data are shared publicly. The verification and validation results showed that ORNL's in-house CFD code could model complex, high-speed flow problems with and without TCNE modeling. This work is essential for future research involving 3D shock wave/boundary layer interactions (SBLIs).

Nutter, Nicole↗

Coupled neutronics, thermochemistry, corrosion modeling and sensitivity analyses for isotopic evolution in molten salt reactors

This study presents a computational methodology for analyzing isotopic evolution and associated uncertainties in molten salt reactors (MSRs), focusing on both fluoride- and chloride-based fuel salts. The primary goal is to enhance the understanding of isotopic behavior in MSRs and provide data to support future experimental efforts. The methodology integrates transport-coupled depletion calculations using OpenMC, equilibrium thermodynamics modeling with Thermochimica, and a corrosion model. Sensitivity analyses are performed to evaluate the impact of power density, air ingress, and humidity content on isotopic evolution in MSR concepts. This study examines representative F- and Cl-based MSR designs, highlighting the dominant influence of power density on isotopic composition, which significantly affects isotope production and depletion rates, accounting for approximately 76% of the observed variance in element concentration. Air ingress and humidity content also affect the redox potential, solubility of heavier elements, and corrosion rates, thereby altering the expected isotopic evolution in the reactor. On average, air ingress accounts for around 17% of the variance in element concentrations, while humidity explains the remaining 7%. These variances differ significantly from element to element, depending on the element’s role in depletion, redox potential evolution, and galvanic corrosion. The findings indicate that power density, air ingress, and humidity content are all critical factors for optimizing reactor design and operational strategies. Furthermore, the study provides expected ranges for key impurities in the fuel salt, which are crucial for guiding future experimental studies and refining MSR designs. Finally, this study demonstrates the importance of modeling depletion coupled with the evolution of redox potential and chemical interactions in MSR fuel salts.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Tensor train continuous time solver for quantum impurity models

The simulation of strongly correlated quantum impurity models is a significant challenge in modern condensed matter physics that has multiple important applications. Thus far, the most successful methods for approaching this challenge involve Monte Carlo techniques that accurately and reliably sample perturbative expansions to any order. However, the cost of obtaining high precision through these methods is high. Recently, tensor train decomposition techniques have been developed as an alternative to Monte Carlo integration. In this study, we apply these techniques to the single-impurity Anderson model at equilibrium by calculating the systematic expansion in power of the hybridization of the impurity with the bath. Furthermore, we demonstrate the performance of the method in a paradigmatic application, examining the first-order phase transition on the infinite-dimensional Bethe lattice, which can be mapped to an impurity model through dynamical mean field theory. Our results indicate that using tensor train decomposition schemes allows the calculation of finite-temperature Green's functions and thermodynamic observables with unprecedented accuracy. The methodology holds promise for future applications to frustrated multiorbital systems, using a combination of partially summed series with other techniques pioneered in diagrammatic and continuous time quantum Monte Carlo.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Prehydrodynamic evolution in large and small systems

We extend our previous investigation of the effects of prehydrodynamic evolution on final-state observables in heavy-ion collisions [38] to smaller systems. We use a state-of-the-art hybrid model for the numerical simulations with optimal parameters obtained from a previous Bayesian study. By studying p–Pb collisions, we find that the effects due to the assumption of a conformal evolution in the prehydrodynamical stage are even more important in small systems. We also show that this effect depends on the time duration of the pre-equilibrium stage, which is further enhanced in small systems. Finally, we show that the recent proposal of a free-streaming with subluminal velocity for the pre-equilibrium stage, thus effectively breaking conformal invariance, can alleviate the contamination of final-state observables. Furthermore, our study further reinforces the need for moving beyond conformal approaches in pre-equilibrium dynamics modeling, especially when extracting transport coefficients from hybrid models in the high-precision era of heavy-ion collisions.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Large-Eddy Simulation of Flow Over Boeing Gaussian Bump Using Multiagent Reinforcement Learning Wall Model: Preprint

We develop a wall model for large-eddy simulation (LES) that takes into account various pressure-gradient effects using multi-agent reinforcement learning. The model is trained using low-Reynolds-number flow over periodic hills with agents distributed on the wall at various computational grid points. It utilizes a wall eddy-viscosity formulation as the boundary condition to apply the modeled wall shear stress. Each agent receives states based on local instantaneous flow quantities at an off-wall location, computes a reward based on the estimated wall-shear stress, and provides an action to update the wall eddy viscosity at each time step. The trained wall model is validated in wall-modeled LES of flow over periodic hills at higher Reynolds numbers, and the results show the effectiveness of the model on flow with pressure gradients. The analysis of the trained model indicates that the model is capable of distinguishing between the various pressure gradient regimes present in the flow. To further assess the robustness of the developed wall model, simulations of flow over the Boeing Gaussian bump are conducted at a Reynolds number of 2 x 10^6, based on the free-stream velocity and the bump width. The results of mean skin friction and pressure on the bump surface, as well as the velocity statistics of the flow field, are compared to those obtained from equilibrium wall model (EQWM) simulations and published experimental data sets. The developed wall model is found to successfully capture the acceleration and deceleration of the turbulent boundary layer on the bump surface, providing better predictions of skin friction near the bump peak and exhibiting comparable performance to the EQWM with respect to the wall pressure and velocity field. We also conclude that the subgrid-scale model is crucial to the accurate prediction of the flow field, in particular the prediction of separation.

boundary layer↗

Impact of fission product inclusion on phase development in U 3 Si 2 fuel

Due to its high thermal conductivity and uranium density, U 3 S i2 has been considered as a candidate for use as an accident tolerant fuel (ATF). In order to fully assess its suitability and performance as a fuel, the impact of fission products (FPs) on the stability and performance of U 3 Si 2 must be investigated. The interactions of FPs and U 3 Si 2 have had relatively little study until now and require experimental and computational examination. U 3 Si 2 was doped with individual FPs to explore U-Si-FP interactions and phase equilibria that may impact the performance of the ATF during irradiation. Elemental Ce, Mo, Y, or Zr were used to individually dope U 3 Si 2 at a concentration of 5 wt% FP. A diffusion couple of a 1:1 Mo:Zr alloy and U 3 Si 2 was heated to 1200 °C in order to consider the impacts of multiple FPs on the stability and structure of the fuel. Samples were characterized for FP solubility and secondary phase formation using electron microscopy, energy dispersive spectroscopy, and x-ray diffraction. First principles density functional theory calculations complemented the experimental effort to understand FP behavior. Experimental and computational findings were used in the development of a thermodynamic database containing 8 major FPs and their associated silicide phases. Finally, fuel compositions generated from depletion calculations were used to thermodynamically model the equilibrium phases of the fuel undergoing burnup.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Magnetism in the two-dimensional dipolar XY model

Here, motivated by a recent experiment on a square-lattice Rydberg atom array realizing a long-range dipolar XY model [C. Chen et al., Nature (London) 616, 691 (2023)], we numerically study the model's equilibrium properties. We obtain the phase diagram, critical properties, entropies, variance of the magnetization, and site-resolved correlation functions. We consider both ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic interactions and apply quantum Monte Carlo and pseudo-Majorana functional renormalization group techniques, generalizing the latter to a U⁡(1) symmetric setting. Our simulations perform extensive thermometry in dipolar Rydberg atom arrays and establish conditions for adiabaticity and thermodynamic equilibrium. On the ferromagnetic side of the experiment, we determine the entropy per particle S/N≈0.5, close to the one at the critical temperature, S c /N=0.585⁢(15). The simulations suggest the presence of an out-of-equilibrium plateau at large distances in the correlation function, thus motivating future studies on the nonequilibrium dynamics of the system.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

Development of High-Performance Ni-base Alloys for Gas Turbine Wheels Using a Coprecipitation Approach (Final Technical Report)

In this project, a synergistic approach involving experiments informed by modelling was used to develop γ'/γ'' coprecipitation-strengthened Ni-base superalloys for land-based gas turbine wheels. In thick sections of such turbine wheels, the slow cooling rate normally observed, as well as variations in cooling rate could potentially result in drastically inhomogeneous and coarsened microstructure. Thus, ten alloy compositions were selected based on coprecipitation and sluggish γ’ growth and coarsening during three iterations of alloy development, assisted by extensive CALPHAD modeling. Phase equilibrium calculations, informed by the characterization of early alloys, were successful in predicting suitable aging treatments to obtain bimodal coprecipitate distribution in several alloys. These aging treatments were applied to the subsequent round of alloys and the resulting microstructures were characterized in detail. Two different cooling rates were used during each of these heat treatments to simulate the range of cooling rates observed in a thick section forging. The microstructures were used to calibrate a multi-phase field model (MPF), which was used to study the formation mechanisms of various coprecipitate morphologies observed in the experiments. Following this, the most promising alloys in each round were selected and studied using high temperature tensile and creep tests. Considering that a slower cooling rate would lead to a strength debit, while a faster cooling rate might lead to a decline in creep rupture life of a full-scale wheel, tensile tests were carried out for slower cooled samples, while creep tests were carried out for faster cooled samples. The deformation microstructures were then characterized using advanced characterization techniques such as Diffraction Contrast-Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (DC-STEM) and Electron Channeling Contrast Imaging (ECCI). Further, a mean-field creep model was developed and calibrated using these experimental findings to predict long-term creep behavior of these coprecipitation-strengthened alloys.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Diffusion in intact secondary cell wall models of plants at different equilibrium moisture content

Secondary plant cell walls are composed of carbohydrate and lignin polymers, and collectively represent a significant renewable resource. Leveraging these resources depends in part on a mechanistic understanding for diffusive processes within plant cell walls. Common wood protection treatments and biomass conversion processes to create biorefinery feedstocks feature ion or solvent diffusion within the cell wall. X-ray fluorescence microscopy experiments have determined that ionic diffusion rates are dependent on cell wall hydration as well as the ionic species through non-linear relationships. In this work, we use classical molecular dynamics simulations to map the diffusion behavior of different plant cell wall components (cellulose, hemicellulose, lignin), ions (Na + , K + , Cu2 + , Cl - ) and water within a model for an intact plant cell wall at various hydration states (3-30 wt% water). From these simulations, we analyze the contacts between different plant cell wall components with each other and their interaction with the ions. Generally, diffusion increases with increasing hydration, with lignin and hemicellulose components increasing diffusion by an order of magnitude over the tested hydration range. Ion diffusion depends on charge. Positively charged cations preferentially interact with hemicellulose components, which include negatively charged carboxylates. As a result, positive ions diffuse more slowly than negatively charged ions. Measured diffusion coefficients are largely observed to best fit piecewise linear trends, with an inflection point between 10 and 15% hydration. These observations shed light onto the molecular mechanisms for diffusive processes within secondary plant cell walls at atomic resolution.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Initial Demonstration of New Griffin Capability for Simulating the Running-In Phase of Pebble-Bed Reactors with Multiphysics

Griffin, a MOOSE (Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment) based application targeting transient modelling of advanced reactors, has been used recently to model pebble-bed reactors (PBRs). The modelling effort has focused thus far on modelling the equilibrium core. A new capability to simulate the running-in phase of PBR operation has been added to Griffin. This work demonstrates the newcapability with a sample multiphysics running-in simulation. The basic features of the new running-in capability were documented previously; however, the sample simulation results presented there did not include multiphysics; the fuel temperatures were assumed to be constant. In this work, Griffin computes power densities in the core at each timestep of the running-in simulation and passes these to Pronghorn which models fluid flow and heat transfer to calculate temperatures that are passed back to Griffin and accounted for with temperature dependent cross-sections.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗