On the equivalence between semiempirical fracture analyses and R-curves
The relationship between the R-curves and semiempirical fracture analyses (SEFA) is investigated theoretically using a hypothetical material. Equivalent R-curves (ERC) are developed for real materials using data from the literature. It is shown that for each SEFA there is an ERC whose magnitude and shape are determined by the SEFA formulation and its empirical parameters. The ERC is equivalent in that it predicts exactly the same relationship between the fracture stress and the initial crack length (residual strength) as the SEFA. If the effective R-curve is unique, then the various empirical parameters cannot be constant, and vice versa. However, for one of the SEFA examined, Newman's SEFA, parameter variations are small enough to be within the range of normal data scatter for real materials.