Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Entry Systems and Modeling”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 163 records · Page 9

Computation of Effective Mechanical Properties and Mechanical Erosion Modeling of TPS Materials

The goal of this presentation is to provide a general overview of the multi-scale modeling formulation to determine if there is additional surface recession in Thermal Protection Systems (TPS) materials as a result of mechanical erosion due to high shear conditions during atmospheric entry. This modeling process is performed at different scales by leveraging two computational frameworks developed at NASA: the Porous Microstructure Analysis (PuMA) software, and the Porous material Analysis Toolbox based on OpenFOAM (PATO). PuMA specializes in computing effective macro-scale material properties by performing material response simulations on 3D digital micro-scale representations of porous micro-structures. The modeling of TPS materials at the micro-scale is essential to understand how they behave as part of a heat shield assembly. The first part of the presentation will detail the implementation of PuMA’s cell-centered finite volume elasticity solver, which allows the computation of macro-scale effective mechanical properties of heterogeneous and anisotropic materials such as fibrous and woven TPS composites. These homogenized mechanical properties are used by PATO’s mechanical erosion model to predict the TPS material’s recession at a larger scale. This work will also provide some examples of multi-scale analysis from the fiber level up to the unit cell. The second part of the presentation will focus on the macro-scale approach to determine if erosion at the heat shield’s surface occurs due to mechanical and thermal loads experienced during atmospheric entry. To accomplish this, a solid mechanics module was integrated within PATO enabling it to model the potential mechanical erosion in three steps: first, after obtaining the effective mechanical properties with PuMA, the implemented stress analysis solver computes the stress and the displacement fields for the TPS material using the wall shear stress tensor, computed using a CFD solver, as boundary conditions; then, regions on the surface where the stress meets the failure criteria are identified; finally, the failed material is removed and the mesh is redistributed accordingly. The outcome is a model capable of predicting the total recession in the material due to surface chemistry and mechanical erosion.

Mechanical Properties↗

In-situ Nanoscale Ablation

An understanding of the ablation of carbon-based materials is crucial to modeling the behavior of atmospheric entry spacecrafts equipped with thermal protection systems (TPS).Carbon is the backbone of TPS systems such as PICA (phenolic-impregnated carbon ablator).Therefore in the present work we study ablation of highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG)in oxygen at temperatures up to 1000°C done within a gas reaction cell housed in a scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM). Observation of the HOPG oxidation on specimens sectioned parallel and normal to the carbon basal planes in the presence of oxygen are reported.Pitting caused by residual oxygen and/or platinum particles from the sectioning process was observed before oxygen gas flow was established at 750°C in the specimen sectioned with the carbon basal planes parallel to the beam direction. Introduction of oxygen flow caused rapid oxidation moving in a uniform front that completely consumed the HOPG in approximately 1.5minutes. The specimen sectioned with the carbon basal planes normal to the beam direction did not show the same pitting phenomenon but exhibited rapid oxidation at 1000°C that proceeded in a uniform front and completed in approximately 1 minute. All specimens tested had a husk resembling the original specimen shape left over after oxidation. It is concluded that this husk is most likely ash impurity from the HOPG or impurities from the sectioning process or E-chip. A residual gas analyszer (RGA) was successfully used to monitor gas flows during the experiments but was yet unsuccessful in monitoring oxidation gas products produced during the experiment.Future studies will optimize the RGA setup in order to maximize the potential for detecting these species. These in-situ studies successfully show how this highly ordered carbon ablates on a nano- and micro-scopic length scale and can be used to provide fundamental understanding of carbon ablation that can be used to design the next-generation of TPS systems.

Nanoscale Ablation↗

Aeroheating Testing of the Mars Sample Return Earth Entry System with Surface Roughness

The Mars Sample Return Earth Entry System is a mission concept which would be the first NASA entry vehicle to utilize a woven thermal protection system as well as a 52.5 degree sphere-cone forebody geometry. Due to its novel design, historic experimental data sets were insufficient to validate the models used to characterize the expected aerothermal environment. A wind tunnel test campaign was funded by the Mars Sample Return Earth Entry System project in the NASA Langley 20-Inch Mach 6 Air Tunnel in order to obtain validation data. The December 2023 test entry of this campaign sought to obtain thermographic data to capture the impact of supersonic flow near woven surface roughness elements on convective heating augmentation, which was the largest remaining uncertainty in aerothermal design of the Earth Entry System. Data obtained were in family with prior results obtained on identical woven patterns without supersonic flow present at roughness elements, and it was found that this presence of supersonic flow did not have a noticeable effect on surface convective heating augmentation. Data were directly leveraged to support the NASA Mars Sample Return flight program and this data set is valuable for validating computational solutions on roughness-resolved grids.

Mars Sample Return↗

Aeroheating Testing of the Mars Sample Return Earth Entry System with Surface Roughness

The Mars Sample Return Earth Entry System is a mission concept which would be the first NASA entry vehicle to utilize a woven thermal protection system as well as a 52.5 degree sphere-cone forebody geometry. Due to its novel design, historic experimental data sets were insufficient to validate the models used to characterize the expected aerothermal environment. A wind tunnel test campaign was funded by the Mars Sample Return Earth Entry System project in the NASA Langley 20-Inch Mach 6 Air Tunnel in order to obtain validation data. The December 2023 test entry of this campaign sought to obtain thermographic data to capture the impact of supersonic flow near woven surface roughness elements on convective heating augmentation, which was the largest remaining uncertainty in aerothermal design of the Earth Entry System. Data obtained were in family with prior results obtained on identical woven patterns without supersonic flow present at roughness elements, and it was found that this presence of supersonic flow did not have a noticeable effect on surface convective heating augmentation. Data were directly leveraged to support the NASA Mars Sample Return flight program and this data set is valuable for validating computational solutions on roughness-resolved grids.

Mars Sample Return↗

Updates to PATO’s Thermo-Mechanical Model

The solid mechanics module within the Porous material Analysis Toolbox (PATO) material response code was updated to model the stress contribution from both internal pressure and pyrolysis shrinkage as function of material’s decomposition. Incorporating these physical phenomena, alongside the previously included temperature dependent mechanical properties, thermal expansion, and aerodynamic loads, allows for a more accurate thermo-mechanical behavior modeling of Thermal Protection System (TPS) materials, which is critical to assess spallation risks during atmospheric entry. This poster outlines the workflow for obtaining the necessary PATO inputs, derived from dilatometry experiments, which are used to model the stress field in TPS materials due to thermal expansion and pyrolysis shrinkage. Furthermore, to analyze the relevance of the stress contribution from the internal pressure, a study was conducted using TACOT with different permeability values.

TPS↗

Simulation of HyMETS Flowfield Around Baby-SPRITE Entry Probe

Arc-jets are unique facilities used in research, development, and evaluation of high-temperature thermal protection systems for hypersonic vehicles and planetary entry systems. Thermochemical non-equilibrium computational fluid dynamics simulations have been carried out for the Hypersonic Materials Environmental Test System arc-jet facility to determine the size of a capsule model before arc-jet testing by better understanding of the physical phenomena. The results show the effect of the test article geometry and the importance of high-quality grids for accurate solutions. Accurate computational modeling of hypersonic flow fields inside arc-jets under simulated planetary entry conditions would help improve the design of thermal protection systems that may enable human exploration of the Moon, Mars, and beyond.

Ventura Diaz, Patricia↗

Roughness-Dominated Transition on Nosetips, Attachment Lines and Lifting-Entry Vehicles

Modeling of roughness-dominated transition is a critical design issue for both ablating and non-ablating thermal protection systems (TPS). Ablating TPS, used for planetary-entry and earth-return missions, first experience recession under high-altitude, low-Reynolds-number conditions. Such laminar-flow ablation causes the formation of a surface microroughness pattern characteristic of the TPS material composition and fabrication process. For non-ablating TPS, such as the overlapping-tile, metallic heatshields proposed for future reusable launch vehicles, the surface roughness pattern is established a priori by the engineering design and assembly procedure. In both cases, these distributed surface roughness patterns create disturbances within, and alter the mean velocity profile of, the laminar boundary layer flowing over the surface. As altitude decreases, Reynolds number increases, and flow field conditions capable of amplifying these roughness-induced perturbations are eventually achieved, i.e., transition onset occurs. Boundary layer transition to turbulence results in more severe heat-transfer rates. Ablating TPS experience increased recession rates, leading to potential bum-through, while non-ablating TPS experience accelerated temperature rise, leading to potential melting of key components.

Reda, Daniel C.↗

Characterization of Titan Entry Radiative Heating in the Low Density Electric Arc Shock Tube

Prediction of aftbody radiative heating for Dragonfly’s entry at Titan requires accurate models to inform the design of its thermal protection systems. Previously reported investigations of shock layer aftbody radiation in the Electric Arc Shock Tube (EAST) at NASA Ames Research Center focused on the lower altitude/higher density part of the trajectory. This paper presents the first optical emission spectroscopy measurements of an ongoing test series in the new aluminum Low Density Shock Tube (LDST), recently installed at EAST, focusing on the radiative heating characterization through the higher altitude portion of Dragonfly’s entry path. Experimental data collected at a fill pressure of 0.1 Torr and shock velocities between 5.2 and 6.2 km/s show favorable agreement to similar conditions previously tested in the 4" High-Velocity Shock Tube, as well as improvements in the signal to noise ratio and available test time. Simulations employing DPLR and NEQAIR underpredict the experimental radiance, with increasing discrepancy from the NIR towards the UV wavelength range, thus motivating further efforts in improving the current non-Boltzmann model for the CN molecule.

A Fagnani↗

Propulsive Reaction Control System Model

This software models a propulsive reaction control system (RCS) for guidance, navigation, and control simulation purposes. The model includes the drive electronics, the electromechanical valve dynamics, the combustion dynamics, and thrust. This innovation follows the Mars Science Laboratory entry reaction control system design, and has been created to meet the Mars Science Laboratory (MSL) entry, descent, and landing simulation needs. It has been built to be plug-and-play on multiple MSL testbeds [analysis, Monte Carlo, flight software development, hardware-in-the-loop, and ATLO (assembly, test and launch operations) testbeds]. This RCS model is a C language program. It contains two main functions: the RCS electronics model function that models the RCS FPGA (field-programmable-gate-array) processing and commanding of the RCS valve, and the RCS dynamic model function that models the valve and combustion dynamics. In addition, this software provides support functions to initialize the model states, set parameters, access model telemetry, and access calculated thruster forces.

Brugarolas, Paul↗

NASA Engineering and Safety Center Technical Bulletin No. 14-02: Aerodynamic Reaction Control System (RCS) Orientation and Jet Interaction (JI) Model Validation

Careful consideration should be given to placement and orientation of RCS jet thrusters on hypersonic entry vehicles in order to minimize adverse RCS JI. Modern state-of-the-art computational fluid dynamics (CFD) tools should be able to predict the RCS effectiveness and JI accurately when coupled with verification and validation studies, including the use of appropriately designed experimental wind tunnel testing.

Aerodynamic Reaction Control System↗

Experimental Investigation of Block-TPS Fence/Gap Roughness Effects on Transition Onset and Turbulent Heating at Mach 6

An experimental investigation of boundary-layer transition and convective surface heating on wind tunnel models that simulated aeroshells comprised of multiple blocks of thermal protection system (TPS) material has been performed. Two representative entry vehicle geometries, a sphere-cone aeroshell and a sphere-cone aeroshell, were considered. Multiple cast ceramic models of each geometry were fabricated with varying fence heights or gap depths to represent gap fillers that either protrude above, or are recessed below, the TPS blocks due to differential ablation during reentry. Wind tunnel testing was performed at Mach 6 over a range of Reynolds numbers sufficient to produce laminar, transitional, and turbulent flow. Convective surface heating and boundary-layer transition onset data were obtained using global phosphor thermography. The experimental heating data are presented herein, as are comparisons to laminar and turbulent smooth-wall heat transfer distributions from computational flow field simulations.

Aerothermodynamics↗

Flow-Tube Reactor Experiments on the High Temperature Oxidation of Carbon Weaves

Under entry conditions carbon weaves used in thermal protection systems (TPS) decompose via oxidation. Modeling this phenomenon is challenging due to the different regimes encountered along a flight trajectory. Approaches using equilibrium chemistry may lead to over-estimated mass loss and recession at certain conditions. Concurrently, there is a shortcoming of experimental data on carbon weaves to enable development of improved models. In this work, a flow-tube test facility was used to measure the oxidation of carbon weaves at temperatures up to 1500 K. The material tested was the 3D carbon weave used for the heat shield of the NASA Adaptive Deployable Entry and Placement Technology, ADEPT. Oxidation was characterized by quantifying decomposition gases (CO and CO2), by mass measurements, and by microscale surface analysis. The current set of measurements contributes to the development of finite rate chemistry models for carbon fabrics used in woven TPS materials.

Woven TPS↗

Thermal Protection System Mass Estimating Relationships for Blunt-Body, Earth Entry Spacecraft

System analysis and design of any entry system must balance the level fidelity for each discipline against the project timeline. One way to inject high fidelity analysis earlier in the design effort is to develop surrogate models for the high-fidelity disciplines. Surrogate models for the Thermal Protection System (TPS) are formulated as Mass Estimating Relationships (MERs). The TPS MERs are presented that predict the amount of TPS necessary for safe Earth entry for blunt-body spacecraft using simple correlations that closely match estimates from NASA's high-fidelity ablation modeling tool, the Fully Implicit Ablation and Thermal Analysis Program (FIAT). These MERs provide a first order estimate for rapid feasibility studies. There are 840 different trajectories considered in this study, and each TPS MER has a peak heating limit. MERs for the vehicle forebody include the ablators Phenolic Impregnated Carbon Ablator (PICA) and Carbon Phenolic atop Advanced Carbon-Carbon. For the aftbody, the materials are Silicone Impregnated Reusable Ceramic Ablator (SIRCA), Acusil II, SLA-561V, and LI-900. The MERs are accurate to within 14% (at one standard deviation) of FIAT prediction, and the most any MER under predicts FIAT TPS thickness is 18.7%. This work focuses on the development of these MERs, the resulting equations, model limitations, and model accuracy.

mass estimating relationship (MER)↗

Progress on Gust Load Alleviation Wind Tunnel Experiment and Aeroservoelastic Model Validation for a Flexible Wing with Variable Camber Continuous Trailing Edge Flap System

This paper discusses a wind tunnel experiment of active gust load alleviation of a flexible wing which took place at University of Washington (UW) in 2019. The experiment performed under a NASA SBIR contract with Scientific Systems Company, Inc (SSCI). The objective of the experiment is to demonstrate active controls of the Variable Camber Continuous Trailing Edge Flap (VCCTEF) system for gust load alleviation and real-time drag optimization. The wind tunnel model is a 8.2% sub-scale Common Research Model (CRM) wing. The wing structure is designed to provide a substantial degree of flexibility to represent that of a modern high-aspect ratio wing. Eight active control surfaces are employed in the VCCTEF. A new gust generator system was designed and installed by UW under a sub-contract with SSCI. The first test entry started in July 2019 and ended in September 2019. During this test entry, many significant issues were found with the hardware and software. The significant issues with the servos prevented the test objective from being completed. A follow-up second test entry in 2020 is being planned. The wing system is being repaired by SSCI. This paper reports on the progress of this experimental effort and the aeroservoelastic (ASE) model validation which was conducted during the test entry.

Nguyen, Nhan↗

Test/Model Correlation for Mars Pathfinder Multi-Body System Drop Tests

A multi-body dynamics computer model was used extensively for the Mars Pathfinder mission to simulate its innovative and uncoventional atmospheric entry, descent and landing approach. To verify the accuracy and validity of this model was vital to the success of this mission, two multi-body system drop tests were performed and augmented by an extensive model correlation effort.

Mars↗

Demonstration of aircraft wing/store flutter suppression systems

A wind tunnel test program was conducted to demonstrate the active wing/store flutter suppression systems on a lightweight fighter aircraft. The program, completed in mid-1978, included the design, analysis, fabrication, and testing of a scale model. The tests were conducted at the NASA Langley 16-ft Transonic Dynamics Tunnel. Three store configurations were selected for testing. Two of these configurations were deliberately designed to exhibit low flutter speeds with rapid reductions in damping at the incipient flutter condition. After initial tunnel entries, which showed the need for certain improvements in the model and the control system design, substantial increases in the flutter speeds were achieved using both leading- and trailing-edge control surfaces, separately. For the most critical configuration, a demonstrated improvement of 18% and a projected improvement of 29% in the dynamic pressure were achieved.

Hwang, C.↗

High-Fidelity Simulations of HyMETS Arc-Jet Flows for PICA-N Modeling

Arc-jet testing is a fundamental tool in the screening of thermal protection systems under atmospheric entry conditions. In this work, high-fidelity computational fluid dynamics simulations coupled with machine learning methods for the Hypersonic Materials Environmental Test System arc-jet facility have been carried out. This effort improves the MEDLI-2 data reconstruction fidelity by understanding the impact of the NuSil coating over the PICA thermocouple plugs. Thermochemical non-equilibrium models are employed to simulate the flows inside the arc-jet nozzle and chamber and machine learning techniques are used to calibrate the arc-jet inflow conditions. The material response is simulated with the recession and in-depth numerical results compared to experimental measurements.

STMD↗

New atmospheric temperature results from the Pioneer Venus entry probes

A new independent determination of Venus atmospheric temperatures, derived from auxiliary engineering measurements of the Small Probe Net Flux Radiometer (SNFR) instruments on board the three small Pioneer Venus entry probes, is presented. The temperature-measurement system and the thermal model needed to convert the raw measurements to atmospheric temperatures are described. The vertical temperature structure and horizontal temperature contrast results are compared graphically measured by the SAS instrument (Seiff et al., 1980), showing a high degree of agreement.

Sromovsky, L. A.↗