SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Lead optimization”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

SourceResearch connectionFrom yearThrough year

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,567 records · Page 87

All sources NASA NTRS DOE OSTI

DOE OSTI2025

Operational optimization for multi-functional charging station with electric and hydrogen-powered vehicles

The rapid adoption of electric vehicles (EVs) and hydrogen fuel cell vehicles (HFCVs), combined with global efforts to reduce carbon emissions, has accelerated the development of EV charging and hydrogen refueling stations. In response to this demand, this paper introduces the concept of Multi-Functional Charging Station (MFCS) that integrates power generation, EV charging, battery swapping, and hydrogen refueling. A comprehensive operational model is developed for the MFCS that couples electricity and hydrogen conversion and storage technologies to enhance infrastructure utilization and improve overall system efficiency. The model also considers multiple revenue streams, including participation in energy and ancillary markets. To validate the effectiveness of the proposed model and evaluate its performance, a series of numerical experiments are conducted with different charger numbers, different electricity purchase limits, and different charger allocations. Numerical results demonstrate that shared charger configurations can lead to 8.11 % improvement in operational profit by improving resource utilization and reducing the number of depleted batteries at the end of operations compared to allocated charger setups. By varying the number of chargers, sensitivity analysis identifies diminishing marginal returns beyond about 45 chargers, suggesting it as an optimal sizing point under current settings. The integration of electricity and hydrogen conversion is also explored under scenarios with limited external electricity purchases. In conclusion, these findings indicate that optimizing charger allocation and energy management can significantly enhance station productivity and profitability, ultimately supporting the broader adoption of electrified and hydrogen-based transportation solutions.

Charging station↗

DOE OSTI2025

Compare low-gain 1D and 3D models toward a storage ring-based X-ray free-electron-laser oscillator

Fourth-generation diffraction-limited synchrotron light sources (DL-SLS) present a compelling platform for advanced light source applications due to their ultra-low emittance (around tens of picometers), sub-micrometer beam stability, and high repetition rates (greater than 1 MHz). Despite these advantages, fundamental limitations, such as long bunch durations (tens of picoseconds), large relative energy spread (~10⁻³), and low peak current (<300 A), have hindered their effectiveness in free-electron laser (FEL) applications. Using a low-gain three-dimensional (3D) model based on NSLS-II upgrade lattice parameters, we demonstrate that a 6% single-pass gain is achievable with an optimized transverse gradient undulator (TGU). Concurrently, recent advances in X-ray optics—specifically, a four-mirror bow-tie resonator utilizing diamond mirrors and beryllium compound refractive lenses (CRLs)—enable total round-trip losses below 4% and an output coupling efficiency near 1%, rendering a Storage Ring based X-ray FEL oscillator (XFELO) a realistic possibility. In the 3D framework, the TGU effectively mitigates the detrimental effects of large energy spread by spatially dispersing the beam, leading to enhanced gain relative to conventional one-dimensional (1D) models. We establish both analytical and numerical connections between the 1D and 3D descriptions, leveraging GENESIS simulations to map equivalent gain conditions. While 1D resonance is defined in the energy domain, the 3D TGU system shifts the resonance dependence to transverse gradient and dispersion parameters. Once optimized, this framework allows predictive modeling using 1D formulas, which can then be validated through full 3D simulations.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

DOE OSTI2022

Carbazole-Based Hole Transport Polymer for Methylammonium-Free Tin-Lead Perovskite Solar Cells with Enhanced Efficiency and Stability

As the most commonly used hole transport material (HTM) in tin-lead (Sn-Pb) perovskite solar cells (PSCs), poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) polystyrenesulfonate (PEDOT:PSS) limits the power conversion efficiency (PCE) and stability of the PSCs due to its acidic characteristics. Herein, an easily synthesized polymer HTM poly[(phenyl)imino[9-(2-ethylhexyl)carbazole]-2,7-diyl] (CzAn) with a shallow highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) level of -4.95 eV is used in a p-i-n structure, methylammonium-free, Sn-Pb PSC to replace PEDOT:PSS. Upon optimization using doping and surface engineering, high quality Sn-Pb PSCs could be successfully fabricated, boosting the PCE to 22.6% (stabilized PCE of 21.3%) compared with 21.2% for PEDOT:PSS. The perovskite films prepared on the modified CzAn HTM possess improved crystallinity, reduced trap-state density, and larger carrier mobility resulting in PSCs with greatly improved stability.

carrier mobility↗

NASA NTRS2017

Overview of NASA Electrified Aircraft Propulsion Research for Large Subsonic Transports

NASA is investing in Electrified Aircraft Propulsion (EAP) research as part of the portfolio to improve the fuel efficiency, emissions, and noise levels in commercial transport aircraft. Turboelectric, partially turboelectric, and hybrid electric propulsion systems are the primary EAP configurations being evaluated for regional jet and larger aircraft. The goal is to show that one or more viable EAP concepts exist for narrow body aircraft and mature tall-pole technologies related to those concepts. A summary of the aircraft system studies, technology development, and facility development is provided. The leading concept for mid-term (2035) introduction of EAP for a single aisle aircraft is a tube and wing, partially turbo electric configuration (STARC-ABL), however other viable configurations exist. Investments are being made to raise the TRL (Technology Readiness Level) level of light weight, high efficiency motors, generators, and electrical power distribution systems as well as to define the optimal turbine and boundary layer ingestion systems for a mid-term tube and wing configuration. An electric aircraft power system test facility (NEAT - NASA’s Electric Aircraft Testbed) is under construction at NASA Glenn and an electric aircraft control system test facility (HEIST - Hybrid-Electric Integrated Systems Testbed) is under construction at NASA Armstrong. The correct building blocks are in place to have a viable, large plane EAP configuration tested by 2025 leading to entry into service in 2035 if the community chooses to pursue that goal.

hybrid propulsion↗

DOE OSTI2025

Spatiotemporal Variability in Wind Turbine Blade Leading Edge Erosion

Wind turbine blade leading edge erosion (LEE) reduces energy production and increases wind energy operation and maintenance costs. Degradation of the blade coating and ultimately damage to the underlying blade structure are caused by collisions of falling hydrometeors with rotating blades. The selection of optimal methods to mitigate/reduce LEE are critically dependent on the rates of coating fatigue accumulation at a given location and the time variance in the accumulation of material stresses. However, no such assessment currently exists for the United States of America (USA). To address this research gap, blade coating lifetimes at 883 sites across the USA are generated based on high-frequency (5-min) estimates of material fatigue derived using a mechanistic model and robust meteorological measurements. Results indicate blade coating failure at some sites in as few as 4 years, and that the frequency and intensity of material stresses are both highly episodic and spatially varying. Time series analyses indicate that up to one-third of blade coating lifetime is exhausted in just 360 5-min periods in the Southern Great Plains (SGP). Conversely, sites in the Pacific Northwest (PNW) exhibit the same level of coating lifetime depletion in over three times as many time periods. Thus, it may be more cost-effective to use wind turbine deregulation (erosion-safe mode) for damage reduction and blade lifetime extension in the SGP, while the application of blade leading edge protective measures may be more appropriate in the PNW. Annual total precipitation and mean wind speed are shown to be poor predictors of blade coating lifetime, re-emphasizing the need for detailed modeling studies such as that presented herein.

Pryor, Sara C. (ORCID:0000000348473440)↗

DOE OSTI2022

Kinetic processes of phase separation and aggregation behaviors in slot-die processed high efficiency Y6-based organic solar cells

Morphological optimization has proved to be one crucial factor contributing to the 19% efficiency of Y6-based organic solar cells (OSCs). Although the relationship between component miscibility and film morphology has been established, it has not been clarified how the film formation processes proceed, especially for methods compatible with large-area fabrication, i.e. slot-die coating, which restricts the further optimization of the morphology. Herein, we comprehensively investigate the effect of miscibility and the film-formation kinetic process on film morphology during processing with different solvents. A highest power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 17.38% can be obtained in a D18:Y6 device processed with slot-die coating in an open-air environment. However, due to their relatively poor miscibility, incorporating a trace amount of chlorobenzene (CB) into CF can sufficiently promote Y6 aggregation, leading to increased phase separation and thus the average PCE drops to 15.16%. In contrast, a PM6:Y6 blend shows insensitive changes in the kinetic process as well as the final morphology, and thus in the comparable PCEs when cast with different solvents, which is ascribed to their relatively good miscibility. As a result, this work provides scientific guidelines for device optimization by combining the intermediate gap from miscibility to kinetic process and their impact on final morphology.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

DOE OSTI2021

Optimal surface-tension isotropy in the Rothman-Keller color-gradient lattice Boltzmann method for multiphase flow

The Rothman-Keller color-gradient (CG) lattice Boltzmann method is a popular method to simulate two-phase flow because of its ability to deal with fluids with large viscosity contrasts and a wide range of interfacial tensions. Here, two fluids are labeled red and blue, and the gradient in the color difference is used to compute the effect of interfacial tension. It is well known that finite-difference errors in the color-gradient calculation lead to anisotropy of interfacial tension and errors such as spurious currents. Here, we investigate the accuracy of the CG calculation for interfaces between fluids with several radii of curvature and find that the standard CG calculations lead to significant inaccuracy. Specifically, we observe significant anisotropy of the color gradient of order 7% for high curvature of an interface such as when a pinchout occurs. We derive a second order accurate color gradient and find that the diagonal nearest neighbors can be weighted differently than in the usual color-gradient calculation such that anisotropy is minimized to a fraction of a percent. The optimal weights that minimize anisotropy for the smallest radius of curvature interface are found to be w = (0.298, 0.284, 0.275) for diagonal nearest neighbors for the cases of the interface smoothing parameter β = (0.5, 0.7, 0.99), somewhat higher than the w = 0.25 value derived by Leclaire et al. [Leclaire, Reggio, and Trepanier, Computers and Fluids 48, 98 (2011)] based on obtaining isotropic errors to second order. We find that use of these optimal w values yields over a factor of 10 decrease in anisotropy and over a factor of 30 decrease in mean anisotropy relative to using the standard w = 1 value. And we find a factor of about 2 decrease in the anisotropic error and up to factor 15 decrease in mean anisotropic error relative to the choice of w = 0.25 for small radius of curvature interfaces. The improved CG calculations will allow the method to be more reliably applied to studies of phenomenology and pore scale processes such as viscous and capillary fingering, and droplet formation where surface-tension isotropy of narrow fingers and small droplets plays a crucial role in correctly capturing phenomenology. We present an example illustrating how different phenomena can be captured using the improved color-gradient method. Namely, we present simulations of a wetting fluid invading a fluid filled pipe where the viscosity ratio of fluids is unity in which droplets form at the transition to fingering using the improved CG calculations that are not captured using the standard CG calculations. We present an explanation of why this is so which relates to anisotropy of the surface tension, which inhibits the pinchouts needed to form droplets.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

DOE OSTI2022

Utilization of the CW magnetrons as coherent RF sources for superconducting RF accelerators

CW magnetrons designed and optimized for industrial heaters, driven by an injection-locking signal, were suggested to power Superconducting RF (SRF) cavities. However, the CW magnetrons, which are regenerative generators, are intended to operate in self-excitation mode, so, for reliable starting they use a large regenerative gain, causing a large regenerative instability in operation. Thus, power supply ripple, even shot noise, etc., lead to multiple sidebands forming a quasi-continuous noise spectrum at the carrier frequency. Therefore, in the traditionally used mode of operation and control, such magnetrons are inapplicable for powering high Q-factor SRF cavities. A new approach to operation and control of CW magnetrons considering non-stationary processes during start-up and operation makes it possible to find a mode of almost coherent RF generation of tubes with a significant reduction in regenerative instability and noise and increased efficiency. In our work is presented substantiation for the newly developed mode with an analysis of the new approach based on experimental results. •In this article, for the first time, non-stationary, regenerative processes are considered during the start-up and operation of CW magnetrons for powering high-Q superconducting RF cavities.•An analytical study, confirmed by experiments, showed that the traditionally used modes of starting and operating CW magnetrons are not suitable for powering high-Q superconducting RF cavities.•In fact, to make CW magnetrons suitable for such cavities, the physics of starting and operating CW magnetrons must be changed. This has been demonstrated in our work.•In developing the Stimulated Coherent Generation Mode [NIM A 980 (2020) 164366], we have shown the suitability of this mode for starting and operating CW magnetrons for high-Q superconducting RF cavities.•Analytical analysis, verified experimentally, substantiates in our article the suitability of the “Mode of stimulated coherent generation” of CW magnetrons for powering high-Q superconducting cavities in pulsed and continuous modes.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

DOE OSTI2024

Variations in γ′ formers and refractory elements for enhanced creep resistance and phase stability of an advanced Ni-based superalloy

The strong demands on increasing fuel efficiency have continuously driven the optimization of superalloys for high-performance applications. In this study, modifications to the chemistry and heat treatment of HAYNES® 282® alloy (H282) were performed by varying γ′ formers and refractory elements. It was found that increasing Ti and substituting W for some of the Mo in the newly designed alloy (Q) resulted in a significant improvement of creep resistance, up to 130% increase in creep life, compared to standard H282. It was found that Orowan loops and dislocation climb were the dominant creep deformation mechanisms in alloy Q, while extensive dislocation tangling as an additional configuration was observed in the baseline alloy. Moreover, phase stability investigations for up to 5000 h at 800 °C and 900 °C revealed a reduced formation of detrimental σ and μ phases in alloy Q when compared to H282. Atom-probe tomography (APT) revealed that the formation and growth of those phases were responsible for a decrease in Mo content in the matrix, thereby leading to a decrease in solid-solution strengthening in H282 over time. Furthermore, the coarsening of γ′ precipitates was retarded by the substitution of W for Mo, particularly under creep stress. The theoretical and experimental understanding of precipitation strengthening unraveled that higher optimal strengthening occurs at larger particle size for alloy Q, compared to the commercial formulation, further explaining the origin of enhanced creep resistance in the modified alloy.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2020

Reaction Energetics and 13 C Fractionation of Alanine Transamination in the Aqueous and Gas Phases

The alanine transaminase enzyme catalyzes the transfer of an amino group from alanine to α-ketoglutarate to produce pyruvate and glutamate. Isotope fractionation factors (IFFs) for the reaction +H 3 NCH(CH 3 )COO – + – OOCCH 2 CH 2 C(O)COO – ↔ CH 3 C(O)COO – + + H 3 NCH(CH 2 CH 2 COO – )COO – (zwitterionic neutral alanine + doubly deprotonated α-ketoglutarate ↔ pyruvate + zwitterionic glutamate anion) were calculated from the partition functions of explicitly and implicitly solvated molecules at 298 K. Calculations were done for alanine (noncharge separated, zwitterion, deprotonated), pyruvic acid (neutral, deprotonated), glutamic acid (noncharge separated, zwitterion, deprotonated, doubly deprotonated), and α-ketoglutaric acid (neutral, deprotonated, doubly deprotonated). The computational results, calculated from gas phase- and aqueous-optimized clusters with explicit H 2 O molecules at the MP2/aug-cc-pVDZ and MP2/aug-cc-pVDZ/COSMO levels, respectively, predict that substitution of 13 C at the C2 position of alanine and pyruvic acid and their various forms leads to the C2 position of pyruvic acid/pyruvate being enriched in 13 C/ 12 C ratio by 9‰. Simpler approaches that estimate the IFFs based solely on changes in the zero-point energies (ZPEs) are consistent with the higher-level model. ZPE-based IFFs calculated for simple analogues formaldehyde and methylamine (analogous to the C2 positions of pyruvate and alanine, respectively) predict a 13 C enrichment in formaldehyde of 7–8‰ at the MP2/aug-cc-pVDZ and aug-cc-pVTZ levels. A simple predictive model using canonical functional group frequencies and reduced masses for 13 C exchange between R 2 C=O and R 2 CH–NH 2 predicted enrichment in R 2 C=O that is too large by a factor of two but is qualitatively accurate compared with the more sophisticated models. Our models are all in agreement with the expectation that pyruvate and formaldehyde will be preferentially enriched in 13 C because of the strength of their >C=O bond relative to that of ≡C–NH 2 in alanine and methylamine. 13 C/ 12 C substitution is also modeled at the methyl and carboxylic acid sites of alanine and pyruvic acid, respectively.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

DOE OSTI2025

Controlling Preferred Grain Orientation in Vapor-Deposited Metal-Halide Perovskite Thin Films

Metal-halide perovskites are promising semiconductor materials for light-absorber layers in solar cells due to their optimized band gap, defect tolerance, and relative ease of synthesis. In this work, we demonstrate the viability of vapor transport deposition (VTD), a solvent-free processing method, to realize polycrystalline films of both lead iodide (PbI 2 ) and methylammonium lead iodide (MAPbI 3 ) perovskites showing preferential crystallographic orientation. Notable is the difference in perovskite film texturing observed for sequentially and co-deposited VTD films of MAPbI 3 , as well as the lack of strong preferential orientation in solution-processed MAPbI 3 films. While sequential deposition of the perovskite precursors PbI 2 and methylammonium iodide (MAI) leads to a MAPbI 3 film with a limited preferential grain orientation, co-deposited MAPbI 3 films mirror the orientation of excess PbI 2 present in the film. The latter is confirmed by the similar dependence of preferential orientation for PbI 2 and co-deposited MAPbI 3 on underlayer roughness, as well as the emergence of preferential orientation in MAPbI 3 only when excess PbI 2 is present. Both MAPbI 3 and PbI 2 films show a strong preferred lattice orientation on smooth substrates, while on rougher substrates, this orientation is disrupted. Furthermore, these results are interpreted as excess PbI 2 frustrating the diffusion of MAI in the film, which would otherwise disrupt the preferred orientation, pointing to a notable difference in lattice orientation arising from processing technique and conditions.

Deposition↗

DOE OSTI2025

Intermediate-temperature topological Uhlmann phase on IBM quantum computers

A spin-1 system can exhibit an intermediate-temperature topological regime with a quantized Uhlmann phase sandwiched by topologically trivial low- and high-temperature regimes. We present a quantum circuit consisting of system and ancilla qubits plus a probe qubit which prepares an initial state corresponding to the purified state of a spin-1 system at finite temperature, evolves the system according to the Uhlmann process, and measures the Uhlmann phase via expectation values of the probe qubit. Although classical simulations suggest the quantized Uhlmann phase is observable on International Business Machines (IBM’s) noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers, an implementation of the circuit without any optimization exceeds the gate count for the error budget and results in unresolved signals. Through a series of optimization with Qiskit and BQSKit, the gate count can be substantially reduced, making the jumps of the Uhlmann phase more visible. A recent hardware upgrade of IBM quantum computers further improves the signals and leads to a clearer demonstration of interesting finite-temperature topological phenomena on NISQ hardware.

Mastandrea, Christopher [Univ. of California, Merc↗

DOE OSTI2020

Achieving high volumetric EDLC carbons via hydrothermal carbonization and cyclic activation

A novel activation method involving hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) and a pressure-induced low temperature oxidation has been demonstrated for cellulose derived HTC char by using hydrogen peroxide as an active di-oxygen source. The optimized porosity versus gravimetric capacitance results from cellulose derived HTC char synthesized at 220 °C. Almost homogeneous and small particle size micro-ellipse/sphere, relatively high surface area and narrow pore size distributions lead to a high bulk density, i.e. 0.73 g cm -3 , of coating type electrodes, which is much denser than those manufactured from steam activated carbons for supercapacitor industry, i.e., 0.52 g cm -3 . The resulting carbon prepared herein achieves a relatively high volumetric capacitance in an organic electrolyte-based supercapacitor reaching a competitive value of industrial system with the features of environment friendly, cost-effective as well as high yield, and less energy consumption.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

DOE OSTI2022

An economics-by-design approach to a radiant integrated thermophotovoltaic microreactor system

This paper presents an application of the economics-by-design approach to the Radiant Integrated Thermo-photovoltaic Microreactor System (RITMS). The RITMS design is unique in that it directly couples a critical fission reactor with thermo-photovoltaic (TPV) panels for high efficiency energy conversion. This significant shift from electric conversion using traditional dynamic heat pumps leads to a simpler and more reliable system without turbomachinery and high pressurization. In working towards wrapping up the early design work, the economics-by-design approach, which centers economic competitiveness as the optimization parameter, is well suited in making a final determination on viability. This paper describes the computational sequence that was developed to couple the radiative and conductive heat transfer and feed operational performance to cost estimation. The framework was applied to maximize the power of the system, while minimizing the fuel enrichment. This method is applied to a reference RITMS design as part of a parametric sensitivity study, which revealed that the system is under moderated and that single unit plants could produce power as low as 300 dollar/MWh. This price point supports the notion that early in the RITMS design implementation, adoption into niche markets as a first-of-a-kind technology is possible. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

DOE OSTI2022

Design of Transition-Metal/Zeolite Catalysts for Direct Conversion of Coal-derived CO 2 to Aromatics

This project introduces a lab-scale, stand-alone process to produce aromatics from CO 2 . Besides reducing the amount of coal-derived CO 2 emission, this process can provide new approaches to produce valuable chemicals such as benzene, toluene, and xylene (BTX). These chemicals are the starting material in various industries such as pharmaceuticals, polymers, paints, and coatings. The focus of the project is on developing a suitable reaction configuration, feed composition, and catalyst combination that leads to high aromatics selectivity and CO 2 conversions. To achieve these objectives, computational catalysis will accompany hands-on experiments to provide insights to potential transition metals or alloys that may serve as optimal active sites for different steps of the reaction mechanism, such as reduction of CO 2 and dehydration (in the case of alcohol intermediates) and oligomerization (in the case of paraffins or olefins) of intermediate hydrocarbons.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

DOE OSTI2022

Design of Transition-Metal/Zeolite Catalysts for Direct Conversion of Coal-derived CO 2 to Aromatics

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

DOE OSTI2023

Investigation on Tuning Power–Frequency Droop for Improved Grid–Forming Inverter and Synchronous Generator Transient Load Sharing

Poor transient load sharing has been observed during the parallel operation of synchronous generators (SGs) and droop-controlled grid-forming (GFM) inverter-based resources (IBRs) in islanded microgrids. This can result in overcurrent protections, causing the inverters to trip, which leads to the collapse of voltage and frequency. In this article, small-signal analysis supported by electromagnetic transients (EMTs) simulation is performed on a detailed model of a microgrid containing IBRs and an SG to identify underdamped modes and their sensitivities to the power–frequency (P-F) droop parameter. Further EMT simulation of a more complex microgrid model with multiple GFM IBRs and SGs is performed to determine whether trends identified from the modal analysis extend to cases where the number of SGs in operation may vary. The objective is to investigate the effectiveness of tuning this parameter to reduce the likelihood of overcurrents in response to load and generation disturbances. The work uncovers both fast and slow modes of concern. Primarily, the findings show that increasing the P-F droop value improves the damping of the slower mode while degrading the damping of the faster mode, leading to an upper limit on the damping improvement of the GFM IBR output current. In EMT simulations of the more complex microgrid, the greatest damping improvement still exhibits significant maximum overshoot. Furthermore, the optimal value of the P-F droop parameter is sensitive to the number of SGs in operation. The conclusion is that tuning the P-F droop parameter is not an effective means to avoid the overcurrent tripping of GFM IBRs during response to large load or generation disturbances when operating in parallel to SGs in islanded microgrids.

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗

NASA NTRS1983

Pressure investigation of NASA leading edge vortex flaps on a 60 deg Delta wing

Pressure distributions on a 60 deg Delta Wing with NASA designed leading edge vortex flaps (LEVF) were found in order to provide more pressure data for LEVF and to help verify NASA computer codes used in designing these flaps. These flaps were intended to be optimized designs based on these computer codes. However, the pressure distributions show that the flaps wre not optimum for the size and deflection specified. A second drag-producing vortex forming over the wing indicated that the flap was too large for the specified deflection. Also, it became apparent that flap thickness has a possible effect on the reattachment location of the vortex. Research is continuing to determine proper flap size and deflection relationships that provide well-behaved flowfields and acceptable hinge-moment characteristics.

Marchman, J. F., III↗