Star-galaxy classification in the Dark Energy Survey Y1 dataset
Here, we perform a comparison of different approaches to star-galaxy classification using the broad-band photometric data from Year 1 of the Dark Energy Survey. We explore and compare different techniques to address this problem: morphological versus using additional flux information, differences between machine-learning, cut based and template fitting including Hierarchical Bayesian methods and catalogue-based versus image-based analyses. This is done by performing a wide range of tests with and without external ‘truth’ information, which can be ported to other similar datasets. We make a broad evaluation of the performance of the classifiers in two science cases with DES data that are most affected by this systematic effect: large-scale structure and Milky Way studies. In general, even though the default morphological classifiers used for DES Y1 cosmology studies are sufficient to maintain a low level of systematic contamination from stellar mis-classification, contamination can be reduced to the O (1%) level by using multi-epoch and infrared information from external datasets. For Milky Way studies the stellar sample can be augmented by ~20% for a given flux limit. Reference catalogues used in this work are available at http://des.ncsa.illinois.edu/releases/y1a1.