Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Comparison”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,477 records · Page 82
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS1983

Phytoplankton pigment concentrations in the Middle Atlantic Bight - Comparison of ship determinations and CZCS estimates

The processing algorithms used for relating the apparent color of the ocean observed with the Coastal-Zone Color Scanner on Nimbus-7 to the concentration of phytoplankton pigments (principally the pigment responsible for photosynthesis, chlorophyll-a) are developed and discussed in detail. These algorithms are applied to the shelf and slope waters of the Middle Atlantic Bight and also to Sargasso Sea waters. In all, four images are examined, and the resulting pigment concentrations are compared to continuous measurements made along ship tracks. The results suggest that over the 0.08-1.5 mg/cu m range, the error in the retrieved pigment concentration is of the order of 30-40% for a variety of atmospheric turbidities. In three direct comparisons between ship-measured and satellite-retrieved values of the water-leaving radiance, the atmospheric correction algorithm retrieved the water-leaving radiance with an average error of about 10%. This atmospheric correction algorithm does not require any surface measurements for its application.

Gordon, H. R.↗
NASA NTRS1982

High-energy observations of stellar flares - Comparison with the sun

This paper reviews recent observations of flaring activity on flare stars of the UV Ceti type, concentrating on X-ray and radio data in comparison with possible solar analogs. Although detailed differences exist, it is concluded that similar mechanisms may work for both cases. Extending the analogy, the hard X-ray and gamma ray fluxes expected from typical stellar flares are estimated. In the solar case, these radiations give information about accelerated particles in the flare region. Hard X-ray observations of stellar flares may be possible, eventually, but the predicted gamma-ray fluxes are prohibitively weak.

Hudson, H. S.↗
NASA NTRS1982

Comparison of Venusian lightning observations

Spacecraft observations of Venusian lightning are reviewed to determine the energy dissipation rate. Optical sensors provide data on the total energy dissipated per flash, so long as the contributions of atomic oxygen and ionized carbon are accounted for. Radio probes yield information on the total lightning occurrences. Venera 9-12 radio surveys are reviewed, and event rates of 20-30/sec for Venera 11 are mentioned. Venera 9 observed a sole, 70 sec event period on the Venusian nightside. Comparisons are made between the recorded electromagnetic energy levels and terrestrial lightning data. The nightside occurrence rate is calculated to be 0.08 strokes/sq km per year, while the dayside exhibits 85 flashes/sq km per sec. Energy dissipation rates ranging from 0.0012-0.25 W/sq m are calculated for various flash durations. It is suggested that the lightning occurs in the clouds as part of an organized meteorological system.

Borucki, W. J.↗
NASA NTRS1982

A sensitivity/intrusion comparison of mental workload estimation techniques using a flight task emphasizing perceptual piloting activities

In a literature review it was found that little research effort has been directly applied to the problem of specifying a viable workload estimation technique for a given pilot/aircrew problem. Furthermore, the relative sensitivity and intrusion of most techniques has not been studied. The present investigation is concerned with a comparative evaluation of eight workload estimation techniques under identical experimental conditions in a flight simulator. The objective of this comparison was to determine the relative sensitivity and intrusion of each estimation technique in applications to a piloting situation which emphasizes the use of perceptual processes. No differential intrusion could be observed, but six of the eight techniques did show sensitivity to changes in perceptual load. All significant techniques displayed monotonic increases in measured values across the three loading levels considered.

Casali, J. G.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Comparison of phase and amplitude structures of Pc 5 pulsations in the morning and afternoon sectors

North American IMS magnetometer network data are used in comparisons of the spatial phase and amplitude structures of the morning and afternoon Pc 5 pulsations, using cross spectral analysis of phase and amplitude readings between different stations. The spatial phase structures are found to be very similar in the morning and afternoon sectors for each of the three components. Amplitudes are larger in the magnetic north than in the magnetic east components for both sectors. Latitudinal amplitude and phase difference variations between the magnetic north and east components exhibit dissimilarities in the morning and afternoon sectors. These results suggest that compressional mode magnetic field oscillations are not observable on the ground in this time sector. The pulsations in both time sectors are instead seen as caused by transverse mode magnetospheric field oscillations.

Saka, O.↗
NASA NTRS1982

Comparison of candidate IGRF models

Three candidate models for the International Geomagnetic Reference Field (IGRF) for the years 1965, 1970, 1975, and 1980 are evaluated using magnetic observatory and satellite data. The models were submitted by the USGS, the IGS, and NASA. Comparison based on annual means data shows the differences between models to be small, although the NASA model appears slightly more accurate in 1965 and 1975 and the IGS model in 1970. Evaluation with Magsat scalar and vector satellite data at 1980 shows the USGS and NASA models to be of comparable accuracy, while the IGS model displays larger residuals. The NASA model best represents the scalar POGO data at 1965 and 1970. Contoured differences between the models in components X, Y, Z, and F at the earth's surface at 1965, 1970, 1975 and 1980 are displayed and discussed.

Langel, R. A.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Experimental comparison of heterodyne and direct detection for pulsed differential absorption CO2 lidar

A pulsed dual-wavelength dual-CO2-laser differential-absorption lidar (DIAL) system has been developed which permits simultaneous heterodyne and direct detection of the same lidar returns. This system has been used to make an experimental comparison of the SNRs and statistical and temporal characteristics of the DIAL returns from several topographic targets. These results were found to be in general agreement with theory and were used to quantify the relative merits of the two detection techniques. The measured parameter values were applied to an analytical treatment to predict system trade-offs for the remote sensing of atmospheric species, with application to both path-averaged and range-resolved measurements.

Killinger, D. K.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Flight effects on fan noise with static and wind tunnel comparisons

A flight test program utilizing a JT15D-1 turbofan engine has been conducted with the objectives of studying flight effects on fan noise and evaluating the simulation effectiveness of both a wind tunnel and a static test configuration that incorporated an inlet control device (ICD). In conjunction with synchronized laser-radar tracking and meteorological profile information, data obtained from a linear array of ground microphones was narrowband-analyzed and ensemble-averaged to yield highly accurate far-field flight acoustic results. Utilizing appropriate corrections, flight, wind tunnel, and static acoustic data were normalized to a static-equivalent, 100-foot radius, lossless reference condition. Data comparisons showed that both the static test with ICD and wind tunnel were generally very effective in simulating flight blade-passage-frequency (BPF) noise levels. However, differences were observed in broadband noise levels and in the details of the multiple-pure-tone harmonics.

Preisser, J. S.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Comparison of measured and predicted flight effects on high-bypass coaxial jet exhaust noise

A recently developed semi-empirical model for predicting the noise generated by conventional-velocity-profile coaxial jets is compared with full-scale flight data and model-scale simulated flight data for high-bypass nozzles. The prediction model has been shown to agree with small-scale static data for primary jet velocities from 215 to 795 m/s for a wide range of area, temperature and velocity ratios between streams. However, there were insufficient model nozzle, simulated flight data available at that time to permit validation of the flight effects prediction. The comparisons presented in this paper demonstrate that the prediction method is also valid in flight.

Stone, J. R.↗
NASA NTRS1982

Comparison of advanced thermal and electrical storage for parabolic dish solar thermal power systems

Parabolic dish solar concentrator cluster concepts are explored, with attention given to thermal storage systems coupled to Stirling and Brayton cycle power conversion devices. Sensible heat storage involving molten salt (NaOH), liquid sodium, and solid cordierite bricks are considered for 1500 F thermal storage systems. Latent heat storage with NaF-MgF2 phase change materials are explored in terms of passive, active, and direct contact designs. Comparisons are made of the effectiveness of thermal storage relative to redox, Na-S, Zn-Cl, and Zn-Br battery storage systems. Molten lead trickling down through a phase change eutectic, the NaF-MgF2, formed the direct contact system. Heat transport in all systems is effected through Inconel pipes. Using a cost goal of 120-150 mills/kWh as the controlling parameter, sensible heat systems with molten salts transport with either Stirling or Brayton engines, or latent heat systems with Stirling engines, and latent heat-Brayton engine with direct contact were favored in the analyses. Battery storage systems, however, offered the most flexibility of applications.

Fujita, T.↗
NASA NTRS1982

Conference on Complex Turbulent Flows: Comparison of Computation and Experiment, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, September 14-18, 1981, Proceedings. Volume 2 - Taxonomies, reporters' summaries, evaluation, and conclusions

Computational techniques for simulating turbulent flows were explored, together with the results of experimental investigations. Particular attention was devoted to the possibility of defining a universal closure model, applicable for all turbulence situations; however, conclusions were drawn that zonal models, describing localized structures, were the most promising techniques to date. The taxonomy of turbulent flows was summarized, as were algebraic, differential, integral, and partial differential methods for numerical depiction of turbulent flows. Numerous comparisons of theoretically predicted and experimentally obtained data for wall pressure distributions, velocity profiles, turbulent kinetic energy profiles, Reynolds shear stress profiles, and flows around transonic airfoils were presented. Simplifying techniques for reducing the necessary computational time for modeling complex flowfields were surveyed, together with the industrial requirements and applications of computational fluid dynamics techniques.

Kline, S. J.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Comparison of CARS combustion temperatures with standard techniques

This paper describes a comparative study of temperatures measured with Coherent Anti-Stokes Raman Spectroscopy (CARS) and those using standard measurement techniques. CARS temperatures from nitrogen vibrational-rotational spectra have been obtained in a premixed hydrogen-air laboratory flame supported on a flat flame burner over a temperature range from about 1000 K to 2100 K. The techniques used for comparison were sodium line reversal, thin wire thermocouples and heat balance calculations. These studies show a good agreement over the entire temperature range studied.

Antcliff, R. R.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Comparison of supercritical airfoil flow calculations with wind-tunnel results

Navier-Stokes calculations have been performed for a supercritical airfoil at a transonic design condition and at a subsonic condition. Wind-tunnel pressure-rail measurements were employed as boundary data in the calculations to account for wall-interference effects. A fine mesh was used so that most details of the flows were resolved, particular attention having been given to the trailing-edge region. Detailed comparisons are made with the experimental data. Good agreement was obtained on the airfoil except at the trailing edge where separation occurred. Flow details in the trailing-edge region are examined and differences are shown to be attributable to the turbulence model employed.

King, L. S.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Comparison of spherical double probe electric field measurements with plasma bulk flows in plasmas having densities less than 1 cm-3

For a three-hour period in the magnetotail over which plasma density varied from less than 0.1 to about 1/cu cm, comparisons of ISEE-1 spherical double probe (dawn to dusk) electric field measurements and ISEE-2 plasma flows (converted to electric fields) show the zero lag cross correlation coefficient between 768 second averages of the two data sets to have been 0.93. A statistical relative uncertainty between pairs of points in the two data sets, estimated by only including counting statistics in the plasma measurement and time variations of the observed electric field over the measurement interval, is able to account for at least 75 percent of the deviations between the two data sets. In agreement with simple Langmuir probe theory, it has been found that the spacecraft potential measured over the three-hour interval by the double probe instrument varied as the log of the product of the plasma density and the square root of the electron temperature.

Mozer, F. S.↗
NASA NTRS1983

El Chichon eruption cloud - Comparison of lidar and optical thickness measurements for October 1982

Sun photometer and lidar backscatter measurements of the El Chichon volcanic cloud were obtained during an airborne latitude survey. The observations were collected between 46 deg N and 46 deg S from Oct. 19-Nov. 7, 1982. Comparisons between these data sets have been performed. An aerosol optical model was developed for the conversion of the lidar measurements to optical thickness values using numerical aerosol size distribution data and index of refraction information collected with coordinated dustsonde balloon flights. The derived lidar optical thickness values were found to agree with the sun photometer optical thickness values within measurement uncertainties. The lidar derived values ranged from 0.16 at the equator to 0.03 at 30 deg S latitude. Peak values were concentrated between 35 deg N and 10 deg S.

Swissler, T. J.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Comparison of heliospheric current sheet structure obtained from potential magnetic field computations and from observed polarization coronal brightness

A comparison is conducted of the structure of the heliospheric current sheet early in sunspot cycle 21 as computed from the observed photospheric magnetic field with a potential field approximation and as inferred from synoptic maps of the observed coronal polarization brightness. On most of the solar rotations compared, the two methods give essentially the same results; the basic shape of the warped current sheet and the amplitude (in solar latitude) of the displacements of the sheet from the solar equator are similar. On one rotation the current sheet computed with the potential field approximation appears to be distorted by a large photospheric region of unbalanced magnetic flux.

Wilcox, J. M.↗
NASA NTRS1983

Comparison of winter-nocturnal geostationary satellite infrared-surface temperature with shelter-height temperature in Florida

Geostationary satellite surface temperatures derived from a Visible and Infrared Spin Scan Radiometer (VISSR) sensor (10.5 to 12.6 microns) were compared with 1.5-m air temperatures collected by a thermocouple on a traversing vehicle along rural highway transects in Florida, and with two fixed thermographs located in rural and agricultural areas. Statistical comparisons between satellite and 1.5-m observations yielded a mean correlation coefficient of 0.87 and an average sample standard deviation from regression of 1.57 C during clear nights for four winters (1978-1981). The satellite-temperature image of Lake Okeechobee was compared with its geographic outline for areal image registration. Manual overlays of temporal images were repeatable to within one pixel. Satellite-sensed water temperature of Lake Okeechobee was used as an indicator of satellite radiometer repeatability and stability.

Chen, E.↗
NASA NTRS1983

A comparison of high resolution optical and radio observations of W3

High resolution maps of the W3 complex for radio continuum and selected optical emission lines are used to derive the visual extinction A(V), the excitation, and the evolutionary state of the component H II regions. A large diffuse H II region in the east, which is the most highly evolved of this type, is found, together with a southern complex of H II regions and a northern complex of young and compact H II regions still embedded in the W3 molecular core. A comparison of the observed dust distribution with ionized and atomic hydrogen and several other molecules in W3 shows the functional relationship between the C-130 column density and A(V) to be in accord with Strohacker's (1978) result for dark clouds.

Dickel, H. R.↗