Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “amorphization”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,441 records · Page 80
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS2020

Volatile-rich Asteroids in the Inner Solar System

Bennu (101195), target of the Origins, Spectral Interpretation, Resource Identification, Security, Regolith Explorer (OSIRIS-REx) mission, is a type-B asteroid with abundant spectral evidence for hydrated silicates, low thermal inertia “boulders” and frequent bursts of particle emission. We suggest that Bennu’s parent body formed in the outer solar system before it was perturbed into the asteroid belt and then evolved into a near-Earth object. We show that this is consistent with models of planetesimal evolution. Bennu has many characteristics expected for a dormant comet, and could potentially contain a minimum of 1 wt.% adsorbed water if its gross mineralogy is consistent with the Orgueil meteorite. This is in addition to any ice or water contained within the hydrous minerals themselves. Based on this hypothesis, we predict the properties of the samples that will be returned to Earth by the OSIRIS-REx mission, including abundant phyllosilicate minerals, amorphous hydrated silicates and low-density, very high-porosity aggregates, already observed by the OSIRIS-REx instrument suite. We predict enrichments in D/H and 15N/14N, high C/Mg ratios (>∼7 wt%), and a greater range of organic compositions than found in meteorites, including an organic component poor in aromatics, and a more labile organic fraction. Ammonium salts, ranging from NH4Cl to ammonium–organic acid salts could carry much of the nitrogen in comets, yet only NH4CH3COO and heavier salts are sufficiently stable to be found in these returned samples. Water adsorbed onto highly porous grains should also be detected provided that the sample return capsule remains below 300 K during Earth return, and this water should be isotopically heavy.

Joseph A. Nuth, III↗
NASA NTRS2021

Understanding the Space Weathering of Mercury Through Laboratory Experiments

Introduction: Airless surfaces across the solar system are continually modified by energetic particles from solar wind and micrometeoroid bombardment [1,2]. This process is known as space weathering, and it alters the chemical, microstructural, and optical properties of surface regoliths on airless bodies, including Mercury. On the Moon and S-type asteroids, the reflectance spectral signatures of space weathering include reddening (increasing reflectance with increasing wavelength), darkening (lowering of reflectance), and the attenuation of characteristic absorption bands [2]. Such spectral changes are driven by the production of Fe-bearing nanoparticles(npFe) through both solar wind irradiation and micrometeoroid bombardment. While our understanding of space weathering for the Moon and near-Earth S-types asteroids is advanced, insight into how these processes operate on other planetary bodies is limited. In particular, Mercury experiences a uniquely intense space weathering environment than planetary counterparts at 1 AU, including a moreintense solar wind flux and higher velocity micrometeoroid impacts [4]. Additionally, Mercury has a surface composition unique in the inner solar system, including regions of the surface with very low albedo known as the low reflectance material (LRM), which is enriched in carbon, likely graphite, up to 4wt.% [5].In addition, the concentration of Fe across Mercury’s surface islow (<2 wt.%) compared to the Moonor S-type asteroids asteroids[6]. Our understanding of the effects of space weathering on C-rich and Fe-poor phases is limited. Since Fe plays a critical role inthe development of space weathering characteristicson other airless surfaces(e.g., npFe), its limited availability may significantly affect the development of space weathering features in Mercury surface materials. We can simulate space weathering processes in the laboratory to explore their effects on the microstructural, chemical, and spectral characteristics of Mercury surface materials[7]. Here we used pulsed laser irradiation to simulate the short duration, high-temperature events associated with micrometeoroid impacts. We performed coordinated analyses including reflectance spectroscopy and electron microscopy to investigate the spectral, chemical, and microstructural changes in these mercurian analog samples. Methods: For these experiments, we usedforsteritic olivine with varying FeOcontents, a mineral phase proposed to be abundant on the surface of Mercury. We mixed each sample with graphite to simulate LRM regions of the surface. Wesynthesized the olivinesamplesat 1-bar at NASA’s Johnson Space Centerand prepared pressed powder pellets for laser irradiation [8].We prepared three samples, each with a base layer of olivineto maintain structural integrity and topped witha surface layer containing the graphite-olivine mixture: 1) Sample SC-001 San Carlos olivine(Fo90.91),2)Sample F-S-002 with0.05 wt.% FeO olivine, and 3) F-T-004 with 0.53 wt.% FeO olivine. Each sample was mixed with 5 wt.% powdered graphite and had grain sizes ranging from 45to 125μm. We irradiated each sample usinga pulsed Nd-YAG laser, (l=1064 nm, ~6 ns pulse duration, energy of 48 mJ/pulse) while undervacuumat Northern Arizona University. The laser was rastered1x and then 5x over the surfaceof each sample to simulate progressive space weathering. We collected in situreflectance spectra from the samples after each laser pulse witha Nicolet IS50 Fourier-Transform Infrared spectrometer (lfrom 0.65-2.5 μm). We used an FEI Nova NanoSEM200scanning electron microscope (SEM) and a Hitachi TM4000 Plus benchtop SEM at Purdue University to image the surface morphology and topography of the samples. We extracted thin sections for analysis in the transmission electron microscope(TEM)using the FEI Helios NanoLab 660 focused ion beam (FIB) SEM at the University of Arizona.We performed analysis of the microstructural and chemical characteristics of the samples using the 200 keV JEOL 2500 scanning TEM at Johnson Space Center. Reflectance Spectroscopy Results:Reflectance spectra for each sample are shown in Fig. 1.SC-001:The spectrum of the unirradiated sample exhibits a weak 1.0 μm absorption feature, associated with Fe2+in the olivine,and low overall reflectance (Fig. 1a). Thereflectance and the depth of the absorption band increases after 1x laser raster but are at their lowest after 5x laser rasters.F-T-004:The unirradiated sample has a blue-sloped spectrum with low reflectance without identifiable absorption features (Fig. 1b). With progressive laser irradiation, the sample reflectance increases and becomes strongly red-sloped.F-S-002:The unirradiated sample exhibits a dark, blue-slopedspectrum. The brightness of the sample increases significantly from <0.2average reflectance over >0.8 reflectance in the most irradiated sampleand thespectral slope also becomesslightly reddened (Fig. 1c). Microstructural and Chemical Analysis: Two primary alteration textures were observed in the samples exposed to simulated space weathering: 1) fluffy C-rich,and 2) vesiculated melt. The fluffy C-rich texture is composed oflow-densitydeposits distributed across the surface of the sample(Fig. 2A). Analysis of a FIB section extracted from a low-density C-rich region in sample SC-001 reveals multiple globule-type deposits, discrete from stacked graphite, likely produced via melting from the laser irradiation [9].The vesiculated melt textureis smooth and uniformly distributed across isolated regions of the sample surface. The vesicles measure up to 100s of nmin diameter. Analysis of a FIB section from this texture was extracted from sample F-T-004 reveals a layer of amorphous melt material, close to 100 nm thick and uniform across the FIB section (Fig. 2B). Isolated regions of this melt layer contain small nanoparticles, <5 nm in diameter. Chemical analysis through energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy reveals the composition of this layer is enriched in Si and depleted in Mg and O compared to the underlying sample. Implications for Space Weathering on Mercury: Previous experiments simulating space weathering of Mercury have showndarkening and reddening of spectra[7,10].However, our use of low-Fe materials and graphite to create a sample set more analogous to the mercurian surface. Our results indicate that sample composition plays a significant and important role in the space weathering of Mercury. In particular, our spectral data demonstrates a strong correlation between spectral slope, Fe content, and simulated space weathering. While the variation in FeO content between samples F-S-002 and F-T-004 is <0.6 wt.%, the spectra deviate from flat to strongly red-sloped(F-T-004). This reddeningmay be linked to the presence of very small nanoparticles observed in the melt textures extracted from sample F-T-004. For the SC-001 sample, the fluffy C-rich textures may be developed by the amalgamation of small graphite particles into these unique morphologies. Such observations indicate that space weathering on Mercury may result in both familiar and new microstructural and chemical characteristics. References: [1]Hapke B. (2001) J. Geophys. Res.-Planet.,106,10039–10073. [2]Pieters C.M. and Noble S.K. (2016) J. Geophys. Res-Planet., 121, 1865–1884. [3] Lucey P.G., and Riner, M.A. (2011) Icarus,212, 451-462.[4]CintalaM.J.(1992)J. Geophys. Res.-Planet.,97,947–973.[5]Klima R.L.et al.(2018)Geophys.Res.Letters, 45, 2945–2953. [6]Nittler L.R., et al. (2011) Science 333, 1847-1850.[7]Sasaki S. and Kurahashi E. (2004) Space weathering on Mercury, Adv.Space Res., 33, 2152-2155.[8] Vander KaadenK.E., et al. (2018) LPSCXLIX, Abstract 1230. [9] McGlaun M.L. et al. (2019) LPSCL, Abstract 2019. [10] TrangD.et al. (2018)LPSCXLIX,Abstract2083

M S Thompson↗
NASA NTRS2021

An Information Theory Approach to Physical Domain Discovery

The project of physics discovery is often equivalent to finding the most concise description of a physical system. The description with optimum predictive capability for a dataset generated by a physical system is one that minimizes both predictive error on the dataset and the complexity of the description. The discovery of the governing physics of a system can therefore be viewed as a mathematical optimization problem. We outline here a method to optimize the description of arbitrarily complex physical systems by minimizing the entropy of the description of the system. The Recursive Domain Partitioning (RDP) procedure finds the optimum partitioning of each physical domain into subdomains, and the optimum predictive function within each subdomain. Penalty functions are introduced to limit the complexity of the predictive function within each domain. Examples are shown in 1D and 2D. In 1D, the technique effectively discovers the elastic and plastic regions within a stress-strain curve generated by simulations of amorphous carbon material, while in 2D the technique discovers the free-flow region and the inertially-obstructed flow region in the simulation of fluid flow across a plate.

Daniel Shea↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Assessing Organic Preservation and the Implications for Potential Biosignatures in the Bastide Member of the Séítah Formation, Jezero Crater

Introduction: Olivine has the highest CO2 trapping potential of ultramafic minerals, due to its rapid rate of dissolution and high percentage of divalent cations/unpolymerized silicate tetrahedra [1]. It generates divalent carbonates from CO2 and sequesters CO2 into the mineral matrix of the target lithology. The co-occurrence of olivine and carbonate within abraded targets from the Bastide Member of the Séítah Formation (Fm) of the Jezero crater floor [2] suggests the carbonation of olivine occurred within the mineral matrix hosted in a subsurface system. Hydrothermal origins for the subsurface system are hypothesized from orbital data [3]. This is supported by the detection of hydration features within the rock as well as the carbonate features are solely detected within the abrasion patch but not the rock’s surface. Organic preservation potential of abrasion patches: We incorporated the SHERLOC/WATSON results acquired from the Dourbes, Garde, and Quartier abrasion patches in the Séítah Fm to investigate the organomineral associations, and determine the biosignature preservation potential of these rocks. Dourbes is dominated by olivine and has minor amounts of carbonate, hydrated Ca-sulfate, and amorphous or microcrystalline silicate. Fluorescence features (330-340 nm) are detected in discrete locales and could be consistent with double ring aromatic organic molecules; yet, these features do not appear to be associated with an identified mineral phase. Dark subhedral to euhedral olivine grains within the Garde abrasion patch often co-occur with carbonate-consistent spectral signatures in all analyzed scans. The availability of Fe2+ is a known influence on olivine dissolution rates [1] and SuperCam estimates of the olivine composition (Forsterite-60 average for Sols 202-234) may thereby provide a constraint on the carbonation extent. Carbonated olivine phenocrysts within the matrix may be due to aqueous alteration, as the carbonation of nodules is consistent with observations in other hydrothermal systems and within Martian meteorites (ALH84001) [4]. In comparison, the Quartier abrasion patch represents an extensively altered endmember within the Bastide Member of the Séítah Fm. It contains a fluorescence doublet at 305/325 nm that coexists with multiple species of Na-sulfate and Mg-sulfate, Mg-carbonates, olivine [5]. Aqueous alteration and implications for habitability: The identification of primary and secondary mineral phases observed in the Bastide Member suggests the release of cations from primary ultramafic minerals through aqueous alteration. Within Garde, the carbonate detected appears to be Mg-rich and likely formed from the in situ alteration of Mg-rich olivine within the region as carbonate has only been detected within the rock via in situ analysis. Carbonates derived from abiotic and biotic reactions preserve biosignatures (i.e. indices of habitability) on Earth. The detected carbonate phase found in association with fluorescent features within the rock matrix may also indicate potential organic compounds preserved in a putative hydrothermal system. Fluorescent features (~330 nm) are unique to Garde and Dourbes, though they are co-located to carbonate signatures solely within Garde, and between the light toned minerals. Identification of these fluorescent features may be consistent with 1-2 ring aromatic compounds. The limit of detection for Raman is multiple orders of magnitude greater than the limit of detection required for fluorescence [6]. Implications for provenance: Hydrothermal systems represent disequilibrium chemical conditions that are hypothesized to have supported the emergence of life and also preserve ancient carbon within precipitated carbonates [7]. Hydrothermal system associated carbonates are capable of preserving biosignatures up to an estimated ~3.77 – 4.28 Gya [8]. Thus, carbonated olivine found within the Séítah Fm may represent a high-potential biosignature preserving environment on Mars. The formation of carbonates by an aqueous alteration process, such as carbonation of olivine is also consistent with hypotheses for carbonate within the greater regional-olivine bearing unit [2,3], which contains Garde, Dourbes, and Quartier. Acknowledgments: This work was carried out at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, The California Institute of Technology under a contract from NASA. References: [1] Wood et al., (2019) ES&T, 6, 10. [2] Stack, K. et al., (2020) Space Sci Rev, 216, 127. [3] Tarnas, J. et al., (2021) JGR: Planets, 126, 11. [4] Steele et al., (2007) Meteorit. Planet. Sci., 42, 9. [5] Murphy, A.E. et al., (2022) LPSC [6] Bhartia et al., (2021) Space Sci Rev, 217, 58. [7] Luther (2021) GRL, 48, e2021GL094869. [8] Dodd et al., (2017) Nature, 543, 60-64

E L Cardarelli↗
NASA NTRS2020

Bonding to Bulk Metallic Glass using Aerospace-Grade Structural Adhesive

Bulk metallic glasses (BMGs) are non-crystalline metals with growing applications in aerospace. Due to their amorphous nature, BMGs generally exhibit stronger mechanical properties than most crystalline alloys and are more corrosion resistant. The limited reactivity of a corrosion resistant surface may explain the difficulty in establishing robust bonds to certain adhesives, especially commonly used structural adhesives for aerospace applications. Here, an amine cured aerospace adhesive was used for bonding an iron-nickel based BMG satellite component. Various types of processes were explored to avoid adhesive failure and increase bond strength. It was found that the BMG required specific chemical derivatization of the metal surface in order to achieve cohesive failure. Surface analysis was used to determine the mechanisms of adhesion enhancement. The process was optimized to maximize bond strength. This work helps explain the difficulties in bonding BMG materials and provides strategies for design of future bonded BMG components.

Roberts, Rose↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Inefficient Growth of Refractory Grains: Implications for Grains in the Solar Nebula

Introduction: We report the results of a sounding rocket experiment in which SiO nucleation and growth in an argon atmosphere was observed in microgravity starting from a vapor generated by evaporation of waterglass deposited on a heated Ta wire. The temperature and pressure at the point of nucleation was determined using a double wavelength Mach–Zehnder-type interferometer. The particle composition and grain size distribution were measured after payload recovery using a Transmission Electron Microscope (TEM; JEM-2100F. JEOL Ltd., Tokyo). The results were analyzed using Modified Classical Nucleation Theory (MCNT)[1]. We report a measurement of the SiO-silicate grain sticking coefficient of 0.016, indicating very inefficient grain growth from the vapor. In other words, for every 100 SiO molecules that collide with a growing grain only one to two are captured. In the only two previous studies of the growth of solid particles from the gas phase the calculated sticking coefficients were much lower. For zinc atoms colliding with zinc crystals only three out of 100,000 collisions resulted in grain growth [2]. Iron atoms colliding with growing iron particles similarly showed an efficiency of ~0.00002 [3]. For zinc, we can explain inefficient growth due to the difficulty of the colliding atom coming upon a vacancy in the growing crystal lattice before it evaporates from the grain surface. The much higher sticking coefficient of SiO molecules on silica grains is reasonable because the silica grains are highly amorphous or glassy and therefore provide a much higher defect density where SiO molecules can be captured into the grains. In the case of similar Fe experiment, the critical cluster was the dimer. In this case the forming dimer returns to the vapor phase by dissociation due to the excess energy from the formation of the Fe-Fe bond.

Joseph A Nuth↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Geopolymer Concrete – A greener alternative on Earth and a feasible material for the Moon

This research is focused on designing in-situ-based concrete material for extraterrestrial construction. Five regolith lunar simulants varying in their compositions were tested and their mechanical performance tested. The results have shown that the lunar regolith simulants are feasible for such concrete technology but exhibit variability due to their mineralogy, amorphous (glass) content, and particle size and shape distributions.

Peter J Collins↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

The CheMin X-ray Diffractometer on MSL Curiosity: A Decade of Mineralogical Observations from Gale Crater, Mars

For more than a decade, the CheMin X-ray Diffraction instrument on the Mars Science Laboratory rover Curiosity has been returning quantitative mineralogical data from Gale crater, Mars. CheMin receives and analyzes sieved soil and powdered rock samples from Curiosity’s Sample Acquisition / Sample Processing and Handling (SA/SPaH) system. To date, 38 samples have been analyzed over the course of a 28 km transit. These samples document more than 600 vertical meters of flat-lying lacustrine, fluvial and aeolian sediments that comprise the lower part of the central mound of Gale crater (commonly called Mt. Sharp).The principal mineralogy of the sediments is basaltic, with evidence of early and late-stage diagenetic overprinting. The rocks in many cases preserve most of their primary mineralogy and sedimentary features, suggesting that they were never strongly heated or deformed. Using aeolian soil composition as a proxy for the composition of the deposited and lithified sediment, it appears that in many cases the diagenetic changes observed are principally isochemical. Exceptions to this include secondary nodules, calcium sulfate veining and rare alteration halos. A striking hematite-rich feature in lower Mt. Sharp called Vera Rubin Ridge is interpreted to be lake sediment diagenetically altered by silica-poor fluids. A surprising and as yet poorly understood observation is that nearly all of the 3.7 Gyr old sedimentary rocks analyzed to date are comprised of 25-50% X-ray amorphous material. Overall, this 600 m vertical section of sedimentary rock explored in lower Mt. Sharp documents a perennial shallow lake environment grading upward into alternating lacustrine/fluvial and aeolian environments. The mineralogical changes observed going up-section include a transition from trioctahedral to dioctahedral clay minerals and a transition from magnetite to hematite. More recently, in the last 150 m of section, CheMin has documented an overall decrease in clay minerals and increase in Fe3+ oxides and oxyhydroxides. The mineralogical changes observed in Gale crater may document the gradual drying out and oxidation of the martian hydrosphere.

CHEMIN↗
NASA NTRS2022

Calculation of Transformer Leakage Inductance by Simplified Flux Path Geometries

Series inductance is a critical energy storage element in isolated power converters. Many have explored methods of estimating the total leakage inductance of transformers as an integrated series inductance without external inductors. However, this poses challenges with medium frequency converters and magnetic ribbon-based cores, e.g., metal amorphous nanocrystalline. The material’s relatively high conductivity allows eddy currents to develop when magnetic flux intersects wide surfaces. These eddy currents result in significant additional losses that increase with increasing power flow. This paper presents a simplified and accurate method of estimating leakage flux while identifying separate leakage flux paths that correlate with the magnetic material surfaces. This enables an understanding the proportion of leakage flux that will contribute to extra losses. The methods presented are applicable to both leakage and fringing (around heterogeneous material interfaces) fluxes. This paper includes detailed FEA studies and 3D flux vector measurements matching the presented analytical models.

transformer↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Carbon Limited Soils of Iceland: Analogs for Identifying Carbon-Mineral Interactions in Gale Crater, Mars Surface Materials

The Mars Science Laboratory’s Curiosity rover mission to Gale Crater, Mars has a goal to search for organic carbon and corresponding evidence of ancient microbiology preserved in clay mineral-rich sedimentary deposits [1]. No clear correlation of clay mineral (smectite) abundances with the Sample Analysis at Mars (SAM) carbon detections (up to 2000 ppm C) [2] has been established, suggesting other phases may preserve organic C in martian sediments. Terrestrial volcanic glass soils can accumulate C due to the C-complexing abilities of poorly crystalline Al- and Fe-oxyhydroxides [3]. The Xray amorphous component (20 to 73 wt. %) in Gale Crater materials [4,5] has received little consideration regarding organic C preservation in Gale Crater. The objectives of this work are to 1) Evaluate C content and level of soil development of basaltic glass-bearing Icelandic soils to determine the role that poorly crystalline phases have in complexing organic C in carbon limited soils and 2) Determine if evolved gas analysis (EGA) of well-characterized Mars analog basaltic materials from Iceland can be used to interpret SAM data to understand the nature of organic-C mineral/geochemical associations in Gale materials.

B. Sutter↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Hematite Formation and Growth in Gale Crater Seen Through MSL Chemin X-Ray Diffraction Data

For more than 10 Earth years, the Mars Science Laboratory (MSL) Curiosity rover has been studying modern sediments and ancient sedimentary rocks deposited by lacustrine, fluvial, deltaic, and eolian processes in Gale crater. The mineral and X-ray amorphous abundances in rocks and sediments have been quantified via X-ray diffraction (XRD) data from the CheMin instrument. The received data demonstrate significant mineralogical variations within the stratigraphy, including changes in the type and abundances of Fe-oxides/oxyhydroxides silica polymorphs, phyllosilicates, and sulfate minerals. Characterizing Fe-oxides/oxyhydroxide minerals in Gale crater is especially important for constraining past aqueous environments because their formation depends on a variety of conditions, including pH, Eh, temperature, and salinity. Hematite, magnetite, goethite, and akaganeite have been identified by CheMin in different portions of the stratigraphic section. Hematite is the most prevalent Fe-bearing oxide mineral and has been detected (>1 wt.%) in 34 of the studied 36 drill targets. Variations in hematite crystallite size were reported in association with Vera Rubin ridge, which has a strong hematite signature in orbital reflectance spectroscopy. Here, we calculate hematite crystallite sizes and shapes for the entire stratigraphic section to date, to characterize trends and evaluate the processes by which hematite formed and transformed in Gale crater.

M. Szczerba↗
NASA NTRS2023

Characterizing Space Weathering Features in Grains From Asteroid Ryugu

Airless bodies such as asteroids are characterized by a lack of a protective atmosphere to guard against the effects of micrometeorite bombardment and solar wind irradiation. These processes, cumulatively known as space weathering, alter the microstructural and chemical properties of grains on asteroidal surfaces, signatures of which are recognized as vesiculated textures, amorphous grain rims, and fe-bearing nanoparticles. The accumulation of these features also causes changes in the optical properties of the surface regolith, complicating the interpretation of remote sensing data and the characterization of returned samples.

L. E. Melendez↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Learning From Failure: Boosting Cycling Endurance of Optical Phase Change Materials

Chalcogenide phase change materials (PCMs) are a unique class of compounds whose switchable optical and electronic properties have fueled an explosion of emerging applications in microelectronics and microphotonics. Key to any application is the ability of PCMs to reliably switch between crystalline and amorphous states over a large number of cycles. While this issue has been extensively studied in the case of microelectronic memories, current PCM-based optical devices suffer from much inferior endurance. To understand the failure mechanisms limiting endurance of PCMs specifically in microphotonic devices, we have developed an on-chip resistive micro-heater platform and an automatic multi-modal characterization system to analyze cycling performance of optical PCMs. Reversible switching of large-area PCM devices over 50,000 cycles was demonstrated.

Optical phase change material↗
NASA NTRS2020

Reply to “A Comment on ‘an Evolutionary System of Mineralogy: Proposal for A Classification of Planetary Materials Based on Natural Kind Clustering’”

I welcome the “Comment” from Hatert et al. (2021) related to the proposal for an “Evolutionary system of mineralogy” (Hazen 2019) and thank them for their historically informed, conceptually nuanced, and consistently constructive contribution. They offer corrections related to two facets of my paper that seemed unfairly to criticize aspects of the International Mineralogical Association’s Commission on New Minerals, Nomenclature and Classification (IMA-CNMNC) protocols for classifying minerals. First, they note an unfortunate inferred ambivalence with respect to the relationship between the IMA system and the new evolutionary system. If I was once ambivalent, that view has changed. Having spent the past two years in an ongoing effort to develop this new historical approach, I am struck every day by the power of the IMA-CNMNC system of species classification and nomenclature, which is fundamental and indispensable to the science of mineralogy. As Hatert et al. suggest, any new approach to organizing natural solids, including one focused on planetary evolution, must rest on the foundation provided by the IMA-CNMNC and its many volunteers who selflessly bring order to the mineral kingdom. In the best scenario, the evolutionary system may one day emerge as one of several useful approaches that complement and amplify but in no way replace this core IMA-CNMNC foundation, as clearly stated in the abstract of Hazen (2019). Second, Hatert et al. (2021) offer corrections regarding the IMA-CNMNC approach to classification, in particular a mischaracterization of the formal process to incorporate amorphous phases, poorly crystalline materials, and loosely defined “mineraloids.” I am grateful for the clarifications, as well as the implication that IMA protocols may facilitate the embrace of additional such phases in the future. Finally, I welcome the chance to explore further the emerging concept of “natural kinds” as applied to the mineral kingdom. Here, our thoughts differ. I suggest that minerals, considered in their information-rich, idiosyncratic, paragenetic contexts (in contrast to IMA-CNMNC species), have the potential to represent quintessential examples of “natural kinds.” Furthermore, when viewed in their evolutionary context, minerals offer an intriguing opportunity to expand the concept of “historical natural kinds” beyond its present limited and, at times, controversial use in biology, into the realm of the co-evolving geosphere and biosphere.

Philosophy of mineralogy↗
NASA NTRS2017

Imaging a Free-Geometry Magma Reservoir Using FEM-Based Linear Inverse Modeling of InSAR Data: Application to Rabaul Caldera, Papua New Guinea

We test an innovative inversion scheme using Green’s functions from an array of pressure sources embedded in finite-element method (FEM) models to image, without assuming an a-priori geometry, the composite and complex shape of a volcano deformation source. We invert interferometric synthetic aperture radar (InSAR) data to estimate the pressurization and shape of the magma reservoir of Rabaul caldera, Papua New Guinea. The results image the extended shallow magmatic system responsible for a broad and long-term subsidence of the caldera between 2007 February and 2010 December. Elastic FEM solutions are integrated into the regularized linear inversion of InSAR data of volcano surface displacements in order to obtain a 3-D image of the source of deformation. The Green’s function matrix is constructed from a library of forward line-of-sight displacement solutions for a grid of cubic elementary deformation sources. Each source is sequentially generated by removing the corresponding cubic elements from a common meshed domain and simulating the injection of a fluid mass flux into the cavity, which results in a pressurization and volumetric change of the fluidfilled cavity. The use of a single mesh for the generation of all FEM models avoids the computationally expensive process of non-linear inversion and remeshing a variable geometry domain. Without assuming an a-priori source geometry other than the configuration of the 3-D grid that generates the library of Green’s functions, the geodetic data dictate the geometry of the magma reservoir as a 3-D distribution of pressure (or flux of magma) within the source array. The inversion of InSAR data of Rabaul caldera shows a distribution of interconnected sources forming an amorphous, shallow magmatic system elongated under two opposite sides of the caldera. The marginal areas at the sides of the imaged magmatic system are the possible feeding reservoirs of the ongoing Tavurvur volcano eruption of andesitic products on the east side and of the past Vulcan volcano eruptions of more evolved materials on the west side. The interconnection and spatial distributions of sources correspond to the petrography of the volcanic products described in the literature and to the dynamics of the single and twin eruptions that characterize the caldera. The ability to image the complex geometry of deformation sources in both space and time can improve our ability to monitor active volcanoes, widen our understanding of the dynamics of active volcanic systems and improve the predictions of eruptions.

Inverse theory↗
NASA NTRS2019

The Non-Destructive Separation of Diverse Astrobiologically Relevant Organic Molecules By Customizable Capillary Zone Electrophoresis and Monolithic Capillary Electrochromatography

The in situ detection of organic molecules in space is key to understanding the variety and the distribution of the building blocks of life, and possibly the detection of extraterrestrial life itself. Gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GC-MS) has been the most sensitive analytical instrument for organic analyses in flight, and was used on missions from NASA’s Viking, Phoenix, Curiosity missions to ESA’s Rosetta space probe. While pyrolysis GC-MS revealed the first organics on Mars, this step alters or degrades certain fragile molecules that are excellent biosignatures including polypeptides, oligonucleotides and polysaccharides, rendering the intact precursors undetectable. We have identified a solution tailored to the detection of biopolymers and other biomarkers by the use of liquid-based capillary electrophoresis and electrochromatography. In this study, we show that a capillary electrochromatography (CEC) approach using monolithic stationary phases with tailor-made surface chemistry can separate and identify various polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), nucleobases and aromatic acids that could be formed under astrophysically relevant conditions. In order to simulate flyby organic sample capture, we conducted hypervelocity impact experiments which consisted of accelerating peptide-soaked montmorillonite particles to a speed of 5.6 km/sec, and capturing them in an amorphous silica aerogel of 10 and 30 mg/cc bulk density. Bulk peptide extraction from aerogel followed by capillary zone electrophoresis led to the detection of only two stereoisomeric peptide peaks. The recovery rates of each step of the extraction procedure after the hypervelocity impact suggest that major peptide loss occurred during the impact. Our study provides initial exploration of feasibility of this approach for capturing intact peptides, and subsequently detecting candidate biomolecules during flight missions that would be missed by GC-MS alone. As the monolith-based electrochromatography technology could be customized to detect specific classes of compounds as well as miniaturized, these results demonstrate the potential of the instrumentation for future astrobiology-related spaceflight missions.

Flyby sample return↗
NASA NTRS2017

Imaging the Complex Geometry of a Magma Reservoir Using Fem-Based Linear Inverse Modeling of InSAR Data: Application to Rabaul Caldera, Papua New Guinea

We test an innovative inversion scheme using Green’s functions from an array of pressure sources embedded in finite-element method (FEM) models to image, without assuming an a-priori geometry, the composite and complex shape of a volcano deformation source. We invert interferometric synthetic aperture radar (InSAR) data to estimate the pressurization and shape of the magma reservoir of Rabaul caldera, Papua New Guinea. The results image the extended shallow magmatic system responsible for a broad and long-term subsidence of the caldera between 2007 February and 2010 December. Elastic FEM solutions are integrated into the regularized linear inversion of InSAR data of volcano surface displacements in order to obtain a 3-D image of the source of deformation. The Green’s function matrix is constructed from a library of forward line-of-sight displacement solutions for a grid of cubic elementary deformation sources. Each source is sequentially generated by removing the corresponding cubic elements from a common meshed domain and simulating the injection of a fluid mass flux into the cavity, which results in a pressurization and volumetric change of the fluid-filled cavity. The use of a single mesh for the generation of all FEM models avoids the computationally expensive process of non-linear inversion and remeshing a variable geometry domain. Without assuming an a-priori source geometry other than the configuration of the 3-D grid that generates the library of Green’s functions, the geodetic data dictate the geometry of the magma reservoir as a 3-D distribution of pressure (or flux of magma) within the source array. The inversion of InSAR data of Rabaul caldera shows a distribution of interconnected sources forming an amorphous, shallow magmatic system elongated under two opposite sides of the caldera. The marginal areas at the sides of the imaged magmatic system are the possible feeding reservoirs of the ongoing Tavurvur volcano eruption of andesitic products on the east side and of the past Vulcan volcano eruptions of more evolved materials on the west side. The interconnection and spatial distributions of sources correspond to the petrography of the volcanic products described in the literature and to the dynamics of the single and twin eruptions that characterize the caldera. The ability to image the complex geometry of deformation sources in both space and time can improve our ability to monitor active volcanoes, widen our understanding of the dynamics of active volcanic systems and improve the predictions of eruptions.

Inverse theory↗
NASA NTRS2018

Reactive Transport and Mass Balance Modeling of the Stimson Sedimentary Formation and Altered Fracture Zones Constrain Diagenetic Conditions at Gale Crater, Mars

On a planet as cold and dry as present-day Mars, evidence of multiple aqueous episodes offers an intriguing view into very different past environments. Fluvial, lacustrine, and eolian depositional environments are being investigated by the Mars Science Laboratory Curiosityin Gale crater, Mars. Geochemical and mineralogical observations of these sedimentary rocks suggest diagenetic processes affected the sediments. Here, we analyze diagenesis of the Stimson formation eolian parent material, which caused loss of olivine and formation of magnetite. Additional, later alteration in fracture zones resulted in preferential dissolution of pyroxene and precipitation of secondary amorphous silica and Ca sulfate. The ability to compare the unaltered parent material with the reacted material allows constraints to be placed on the characteristics of the altering solutions. In this work we use a combination of a mass balance approach calculating the fraction of a mobile element lost or gained, τ, with fundamental geochemical kinetics and thermodynamics in the reactive transport code CrunchFlow to examine the characteristics of multiple stages of aqueous alteration at Gale crater, Mars. Our model results indicate that early diagenesis of the Stimson sedimentary formation is consistent with leaching of an eolian deposit by a near-neutral solution, and that formation of the altered fracture zones is consistent with a very acidic, high sulfate solution containing Ca, P and Si. These results indicate a range of past aqueous conditions occurring at Gale crater, Mars, with important implications for past Martian climate and environments.

Gale crater↗