DOE OSTI2010
Evaporative condenser pre-cooling expands the availability of energy saving, cost effective technology options (market engagement) and serves to broaden the range of options in upcoming codes and equipment standards (impacting regulation). Commercially available evaporative pre-coolers provide a low cost retrofit for existing packaged rooftop units, commercial unitary split systems, and air cooled chillers. We map the impact on energy savings and peak energy reduction in three building types (medium office, secondary school, and supermarket) in 16 locations with four levels of pad effectiveness and show the effect for HVAC systems using either refrigerants R22 or R410A (See Section 5.4). EnergyPlus simulations are conducted with an improved algorithm for estimating the condenser pre-cooling wet bulb efficiency. EnergyPlus version 5.0.0 provides an option for a curve-fit form of calculating evaporative cooling efficiency (currently available only for evaporative pads used for space cooling, not condenser precooling). This option requires a large body of empirical data to obtain the 11 parameters required in the polynomial equation and, being a general curve fit, it is also not physically meaningful. Our study departs from this approach by presenting an alternative mathematical model that is physically intuitive, simpler in form, and provides better agreement with manufacturer’s data. In this report, we describe the simpler algorithm and provide the metrics that show how it is an improvement over the algorithm used in EnergyPlus version 5.0.0. We then generate performance values that can be directly input into EnergyPlus for simulations. By this process, we examine the annual and peak energy reductions of three building types (medium office, secondary school and supermarket) in 16 locations within the U.S. These three building types were chosen because they have distinctive loads, zones, and equipment. In addition to performing the requisite calculations, computer algorithms were developed for use with EnergyPlus to simulate the performance of commercial units under a variety of operating parameters. Performance maps were generated and estimated energy savings and peak demand reductions were calculated. Performance curves that were used in these EnergyPlus simulations were shared with the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) and with the Florida Solar Energy Center (FSEC) for possible inclusion in the next update to EnergyPlus.