Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “complex aqueous solutions”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 145 records · Page 8
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2021

In situ mechanical reinforcement of polymer hydrogels via metal-coordinated crosslink mineralization

Biological organic-inorganic materials remain a popular source of inspiration for bioinspired materials design and engineering. Inspired by the self-assembling metal-reinforced mussel holdfast threads, we tested if metal-coordinate polymer networks can be utilized as simple composite scaffolds for direct in situ crosslink mineralization. Starting with aqueous solutions of polymers end-functionalized with metal-coordinating ligands of catechol or histidine, here we show that inter-molecular metal-ion coordination complexes can serve as mineral nucleation sites, whereby significant mechanical reinforcement is achieved upon nanoscale particle growth directly at the metal-coordinate network crosslink sites.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

The solubility of NdPO 4 and DyPO 4 and stability of Nd and Dy chloride and hydroxyl complexes as a function of pH and salinity to 450 °C

The mobility of rare earth elements (REE) in geological systems is often controlled by the stability of monazite and xenotime, which are important hosts for the light and heavy REE. These REE phosphates constitute important resources and provide information on ore formation conditions and timing due to their uses as geothermometers and geochronometers. While the thermodynamic properties for these minerals are well-established up to high temperature and pressure, the properties for the aqueous REE complexes are not well constrained with limited information up to 300 °C. In this study, the solubility of synthetic NdPO 4 and DyPO 4 endmembers were measured in hydrothermal sub- to supercritical NaCl-bearing aqueous solutions from 350 at saturated water vapor pressure to 450 °C at 700 bar. The speciation of Nd and Dy was determined in acidic to alkaline solutions (pH 25 °C values from 2 to 10), and indicates that the hydroxyl species REE(OH) 2 + and REE(OH) 3 0 predominate at low salinity (0.01 mol/kg NaCl) with some contribution of REE chloride species REECl 2+ and REECl 2 + in acidic fluids. The REE phosphate solubility measured in these experiments is up to two orders of magnitude higher than predicted using existing thermodynamic properties from literature for aqueous species extrapolated from lower temperature data to supercritical conditions. To address this discrepancy, the thermodynamic properties of the REE aqueous species were optimized using GEMSFITS to derive the formation constants for the REE chloride (β Cl ) and hydroxyl (β OH ) complexes in the studied temperature range. This study highlights the importance of the hydroxyl species REE(OH) 2 + and REE(OH) 3 0 over a wide range of pH and temperature. As a result, the revised thermodynamic properties for Dy and Nd chloride and hydroxyl species more accurately predict the solubility of NdPO 4 and DyPO 4 and provide insight into the speciation and mobility of the light and heavy REE in hydrothermal supercritical fluids in the crust.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2025

Fundamental Insights into Cathode Stability: Linking Compositional Tuning and Local Coordination in Complex Metal Oxides under Aqueous Transformations

Compositional tuning of complex metal oxides in Li-ion battery materials influences their performance as well as their end-of-life behavior, in particular, the tendency to release toxic metal cations in aqueous solution. We modeled ternary variants of a parent LiCoO 2 delafossite structure by varying the metal identity and relative amounts. This yielded ten model formulations of Li(A 4/6 B 1/6 C 1/6 )O 2 , where the material is enriched with the A metal and doped with B and C, with Ni, Mn, Co, Fe, Al, V, and Ti as constituent metals. To assess their stability in aqueous conditions, metal release energetics were calculated using a combination of Density Functional Theory calculations and thermodynamics. Metal release in ternary oxides is dictated by subtle variations in the coordination environment of the leaving group. To identify governing chemical features across diverse compositions with varying local coordination environments, we leverage random forest regression and descriptor importance analysis. A key result is that metal–oxygen orbital hybridization, quantified using a projected density-of-states-derived descriptor, H d/p , provides a physically grounded measure of interaction strength that governs metal release energetics. This refined perspective goes beyond conventional oxidation state considerations and offers more robust insights for materials science. Finally, we model defect surface-bound O 2 dimer formation as a proxy for reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation. The results show that Ni-rich compositions more readily stabilize spin-polarized O 2 dimers, corroborating experimental reports of an increased ROS-driven biological response. In conclusion, our results establish a compositional and electronic basis for metal release and surface oxygen reactivity that form a rationale for complex metal oxide design principles.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Hydrothermal solution calorimetry in acidic aqueous solutions and revisiting the standard partial molal thermodynamic properties of Nd 3+ from 25 to 300 °C

The mobility of rare earth elements (REE) can be predicted in aqueous fluids using geochemical modeling but the accuracy of these models strongly depends on the availability of robust thermodynamic properties for the REE aqueous species. The REE 3+ aqua ions are important in the derivation of the formation constants of all the major REE complexes including the chloride, sulfate, and fluoride species which predominate in many hydrothermal-magmatic systems. However, the thermodynamic properties of the REE 3+ aqua ions are still commonly derived from the Helgeson-Kirkham-Flowers (HKF) equation of state parameters tabulated several decades ago. The standard state thermodynamic properties at reference conditions (25 °C and 1bar) and their extrapolations to high temperature need to be verified, if not revised, based on hydrothermal experiments. In this study, the enthalpy of solution was measured for synthetic Nd hydroxide from 25 to 150 ºC to retrieve the standard partial molal thermodynamic properties of Nd 3+ as a function of temperature. The experiments were conducted in aqueous perchloric acid based solutions with starting pH of 2 and varying ionic strength (0.01 to 0.09 mol/kg NaClO 4 ). The standard partial molal enthalpy of formation (Δ f H°) of Nd 3+ derived from the experimental study displays differences of up to 10 kJ/mol compared to the enthalpy values derived from the HKF equation of state in the studied temperature range. These inaccuracies are resolved by adjusting the standard partial molal Gibbs energy of formation (Δ f G°) of Nd 3+ at 25 °C and 1 bar from -672.0 to -679.7 kJ/mol. The heat capacity function (C p °) derived between 25 and 150 ºC can be described by: C p ° = a 0 + a 1 ·T + a 2 ·T -2 , with a 0 = 1256, a 1 = -2.68, a 2 = -55.56·10 6 and T in Kelvin. A set of recommended thermodynamic properties is provided for the Nd 3+ aqua ions and corrections are provided for the chloride and fluoride species to remain internally consistent with the experimentally derived properties. These results allow predicting accurately the solubility of monazite between 25 and 300 ºC. Before these corrections, the properties for the Nd 3+ aqua ions derived from the HKF parameters resulted in up to ~1.5 orders of magnitude lower monazite solubility than determined experimentally. Here, a revision of the REE +3 aqua ions properties is necessary to accurately predict the mobility of REE in hydrothermal acidic solutions.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2023

Radiolytic Evaluation of 3,4,3-LI(1,2-HOPO) in Aqueous Solutions

We report the octadentate hydroxypyridinone ligand 3,4,3-LI(1,2-HOPO) (abbreviated as HOPO) has been identified as a promising candidate for both chelation and f-element separation technologies, two applications that require optimal performance in radiation environments. However, the radiation robustness of HOPO is currently unknown. Here, we employ a combination of time-resolved (electron pulse) and steady-state (alpha self-radiolysis) irradiation techniques to elucidate the basic chemistry of HOPO and its f-element complexes in aqueous radiation environments. Chemical kinetics were measured for the reaction of HOPO and its Nd(III) ion complex ([Nd III (HOPO)] - ) with key aqueous radiation-induced radical transients (eaq - , H · atom, and · OH and NO 3 · radicals). The reaction of HOPO with eaq - is believed to proceed via reduction of the hydroxypyridinone moiety, while transient adduct spectra indicate that reactions with the H · atom and · OH and NO 3 · radicals proceeded by addition to HOPO's hydroxypyridinone rings, potentially allowing for the generation of an extensive suite of addition products. Complementary steady-state 241 Am(III)-HOPO complex ([ 241 Am III (HOPO)] - ) irradiations showed the gradual release of 241 Am(III) ions with increasing alpha dose up to 100 kGy, although complete ligand destruction was not observed.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2024

Chelator‐Assisted Precipitation‐Based Separation of the Rare Earth Elements Neodymium and Dysprosium from Aqueous Solutions

The rare earth elements (REEs) are critical resources for many clean energy technologies, but are difficult to obtain in their elementally pure forms because of their nearly identical chemical properties. Here, an analogue of macropa, G-macropa, was synthesized and employed for an aqueous precipitation-based separation of Nd 3+ and Dy 3+ . G-macropa maintains the same thermodynamic preference for the large REEs as macropa, but shows smaller thermodynamic stability constants. Molecular dynamics studies demonstrate that the binding affinity differences of these chelators for Nd 3+ and Dy 3+ is a consequence of the presence or absence of an inner-sphere water molecule, which alters the donor strength of the macrocyclic ethers. Leveraging the small REE affinity of G-macropa, we demonstrate that within aqueous solutions of Nd 3+ , Dy 3+ , and G-macropa, the addition of HCO 3 − selectively precipitates Dy 2 (CO 3 ) 3 , leaving the Nd 3+ −G-macropa complex in solution. With this method, remarkably high separation factors of 841 and 741 are achieved for 50 : 50 and 75 : 25 mixtures. Further studies involving Nd 3+ :Dy 3+ ratios of 95 : 5 in authentic magnet waste also afford an efficient separation as well. Finally, G-macropa is recovered via crystallization with HCl and used for subsequent extractions, demonstrating its good recyclability.

Gao, Yangyang↗
DOE OSTI2022

Isotopic Substitution Reveals the Importance of Aluminate Diffusion Dynamics in Gibbsite (Al(OH) 3 ) Crystallization from Alkaline Aqueous Solution

Understanding molecular-scale factors governing the precipitation of aluminum hydroxides, such as gibbsite, under alkaline conditions is important for the formation of laterite deposits, as well as aluminum processing. However, mechanisms enabling tetrahedral aluminate ions to assemble into octahedral sites of the gibbsite lattice remain unclear. Formation of oligomeric complexes has been hypothesized as a critical intermediate step. Here, we report a study of gibbsite solubility in highly alkaline solutions using deuterium substitution to probe equilibrium and kinetic factors that could affect oligomeric intermediate formation, including the reactivity and the diffusivity of aluminate ions. When substituting sodium hydroxide with sodium deuteroxide, solution analysis shows a nearly 40% and 50% increase in gibbsite solubility in 2.4 and 3.3 mol·kg –1 total sodium solutions, respectively. Raman spectroscopy indicated that monomeric aluminate ions are the predominant species in solution irrespective of deuteration. However, both 27 Al and 23 Na nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy revealed significant differences in chemical shifts in deuterated solutions, and analysis of 1 H, 23 Na, and 27 Al diffusion coefficients with pulsed-field gradient, stimulated echo NMR spectroscopy shows a decrease in ion diffusivity with increasing total deuterium in solution, consistent with the notion of increasing strength in the hydrogen/deuterium bonding network. In conclusion, because the relative change in 1 H diffusion coefficients are commensurate with the difference in apparent solubility constants, there is evidence for an oligomeric intermediate whose steady-state concentration is maintained by the collision frequency of aluminate ions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Electrodeposited Mo x S y O z /Ni Tribological Coatings

Deposition of molybdenum disulfide (MoS 2 ) coatings using physical vapor deposition (PVD) and mechanical burnishing has been widely assessed for solid lubricants in space applications but still suffers from line-of-sight constraints on complex geometries. Here, we highlight one of the first demonstrations of electrodeposited Mo x S y O z and Mo x S y O z /Ni thin-film coatings from aqueous solutions of ammonium tetrathiomolybdate for solid lubricant applications and their remarkable ability to provide low coefficients of friction and high wear resistance. Characterization of the coating morphology shows amorphous microstructures with a high oxygen content and cracking upon drying. Even so, electrodeposited Mo x S y O z can achieve low steady-state coefficients of friction (μ ∼ 0.05–0.06) and wear rates (2.6 × 10 –7 mm 3 /(N m)) approaching those of physical vapor deposited coatings (2.3 × 10 –7 mm 3 /(N m)). Additionally, we show that adding dopants such as nickel increased the wear rate (7.5 × 10 –7 mm 3 /(N m)) and initial coefficient of friction (μ i = 0.23) due to compositional modifications such as dramatic sub-stoichiometry (S/Mo ∼ 1) and expression of a NiO x surface layer, although doping did reduce the degree of cracking upon drying.

Babuska, Tomas F.↗
DOE OSTI2024

Inverse design of pore wall chemistry and topology through active learning of surface group interactions

Design of next-generation membranes requires a nanoscopic understanding of the effect of biologically inspired heterogeneous surface chemistries and topologies (roughness) on local water and solute behavior. In particular, the rejection of small, neutral solutes, such as boric acid, poses a heretofore unsolved challenge. In prior work, a computational inverse design technique using an evolutionary optimization successfully uncovered new surface design strategies for optimized transport of water over solutes in smooth, model pores consisting of two surface chemistries. However, extending such an approach to more complex (and realistic) scenarios involving many surface chemistries as well as surface roughness is challenging due to the expanded design space. In this work, we develop a new approach that uses active learning to optimize in a reduced feature space of surface group interactions, finding parameters that lead to their assembly into ordered, optimal patterns. This approach rapidly identifies novel surface functionalizations that maximize the difference in water and boric acid transport through the nanopore. Moreover, we find that the roughness of the nanopore wall, independent of its chemistry, can be leveraged to enhance transport selectivity: oscillations in the pore wall diameter optimally inhibit boric acid transport by creating energetic wells from which the solute must escape to transport down the pore. Furthermore, this proof-of-concept demonstrates the potential for active learning strategies, in concert with molecular simulations, to rapidly navigate complex design spaces of aqueous interfaces and is promising as a tool for engineering water-mediated surface interactions for a broad range of applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Aqueous electrocatalytic CO 2 reduction using metal complexes dispersed in polymer ion gels

We use fac-[Re(bpy)(CO) 3 Cl] ([Re–Cl]) dispersed in polymer ion gel (PIG) ([Re]–PIG) to carry out electrocatalytic CO 2 reduction in water. Electrolysis at -0.68 V vs. RHE in a CO 2 -saturated KOH and K 2 CO 3 solution produces CO with over 90% Faradaic efficiency. The PIG electrode is readily combined with water oxidation catalysts to generate a full electrochemical cell. Additionally, we provide evidence that the PIG electrode can be implemented with other molecular catalysts.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Evaluation of Density-Functional Tight-Binding Methods for Simulation of Protic Molecular Ion Pairs

In this work, we benchmark the accuracy of the density-functional tight-binding (DFTB) method, namely the long-range corrected second-order (LC-DFTB2) and third-order (DFTB3) models, for predicting energetics of imidazolium-based ionic liquid (IL) ion pairs. We compare the DFTB models against popular density functionals such as LC-ωPBE and B3LYP, using ab initio domain-based local pair-natural orbital coupled cluster (DLPNO-CC) energies as reference. Calculations were carried out in the gas phase, as well as in aqueous solution using implicit solvent methods. We find that the LC-DFTB2 model shows excellent performance in the gas phase and agrees well with reference energies in implicit solvent, often outperforming DFTB3 predictions for complexation energetics. Our study identifies a range of opportunities for use of the LC-DFTB method and quantifies its sensitivity to protonation states and the types of chemical interactions between ion pairs.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Extraction of Ln(III) and An(III) from Alkaline Solutions by Sulfonamide Ligands and Analogs - 20216

As part of our effort to develop advanced separations involving combined extraction of cesium, strontium, and actinides from High-Level Waste (HLW) at the Savannah River Site, we are now reporting highly efficient extraction of Sm(III) from aqueous media of various alkalinity by dichloromethane solutions of several ligands, including tri-sulfonamides, o-mono-sulfonamido-phenols and o-phenylenediamine- derived disulfonamides. Distribution experiments and DFT calculations provide insights on the complexation of Samarium vs Americium by these ligands. Further optimization of these ligands for extraction into highly lipophilic solvents and application to HLW simulants are underway. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗
DOE OSTI2020

Amphiphile Organization in Organic Solutions: An Alternative Explanation for Small-Angle X-ray Scattering Features in Malonamide/Alkane Mixtures

In this work, the role of different intermolecular interactions in the aggregation of amphiphiles in an organic solvent is studied for systems of relevance to liquid-liquid extraction (LLE), a chemical process used to selectively recover metals from complex mixtures. Of specific interest is the role, or lack thereof, of hydrogen bonding, which is often assumed to be a main driver of the organic phase structural organization that has been linked to separation efficacy. Toward that end, a series of malonamide extractants in n-dodecane have been studied in the absence of any extracted aqueous solutes, including water. The series of extractants includes N,N'-dimethyl-N,N'-dibutyltetradecylmalonamide (DMDBTDMA), two of its homologs, and N,N'-dimethyl-N,N'-dioctylhexylethoxymalonamide (DMDOHEMA). This simplified model LLE system enables systematic investigation of the role of dipole-dipole and alkyl tail steric interactions in amphiphile aggregation. Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) profiles computed from molecular dynamics trajectories are in good agreement with experimental SAXS data. Molecular dynamics simulations show that malonamide aggregation results from dipole-driven self-association and lacks characteristic aggregate sizes. Mid-q correlation peaks in the SAXS profiles emerge at high concentration for each malonamide. In those densely packed solutions, the correlation peaks are observed to result from alkyl tail-induced spacing between electron-rich polar head groups, with peak positions determined by the different alkyl tail lengths present in the malonamide molecule. This explanation of the SAXS correlation peaks contrasts with the prevailing literature, which attributes mesoscale features observed in small-angle scattering to the formation of microemulsions. Instead, this work finds that these features are present in the absence of water or any reverse micellar organization of the malonamides. As such, molecular-scale malonamide self-association and packing, rather than microemulsion-based colloidal-scale descriptions, is a more appropriate framework for these LLE systems.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Conclusions from 3 years of continuous capture plant operation without exchange of the AMP/PZ-based solvent at Niederaussem – insights into solvent degradation management

A many times heard mantra of solvent degradation management in amine-based post combustion capture is “keep the solvent clean” to minimize solvent consumption. It is assumed that the amine losses would decrease by the removal of metals, degradation products, and reactive trace components which are captured from the flue gas, like NO 2 (as potentially driving components of the amine degradation besides dissolved O 2 ). However, this theoretical hypothesis – based on results from laboratory experiments typically generated with fresh amines – disregards the complexity of the solvent matrix, interaction of potential metal catalysts with degradation products and oxidizing agents, and specific chemical requirements which must be fulfilled before a degradation mechanism can proceed. Degradation of the solvent CESAR1 (aqueous solution of 3.0 molar 2-amino-2-methylpropan-1-ol (AMP) and 1.5 molar piperazine (PZ)) is investigated in a unique long-time test campaign (testing time up to now 40 months; 24/7 operation) without replacement of the solvent inventory at the capture pilot plant at the lignite-fired power plant in Niederaussem. Three solvent management strategies with different effect mechanisms are investigated and evaluated: (a) removal of only anionic compounds and trace elements (within 75 days solvent inventory treated two times) and anionic as well as cationic compounds and trace elements (114 days, inventory treated four times) from the solvent by ion exchange, (b) adsorptive removal of trace elements from the solvent by active carbon in 35% of the operating time, and (c) removal of >80% NO 2 by flue gas pretreatment with thiosulfate/sulfite solution (dosing for 2,000 h). The results of the testing program clearly show that “solvent cleanliness” is not a well-defined parameter and that results from laboratory tests, tests without fully representative industrial flue gasses, and short-term testing of monoethanolamine cannot be generalized for other solvents and industrial application. Furthermore, these results showcase that specific degradation management considering solvent, capture plant and flue gas quality is reasonable. Overshooting efforts for solvent management are contra-productive and produce unnecessary waste streams, efficiency losses and costs.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Solvent Phase Optimizations Improve Correlations with Experimental Stability Constants for Aqueous Lanthanide Complexes

Stability constants provide insight into ion complexation in water. While computational studies have been shown to model the energy of the complexation successfully using a thermodynamic cycle approach, it does not extend to calculating the stability constants for 1:1 lanthanide to ligand complexes in solution. Using B3LYP and 6-31+G* Pople basis with small core effective core potential (ECP) on the lanthanum ion, and a solvent model based on the full solute electron density (SMD) solvation model we computed and compared with previously published stability constants of the ligands: acetate, acetohydroximate, acetylacetonate, methanoate, tropolonate, hydroxide, catecholate, malonate, oxalate, phthalate, and sulfate. The best R 2 values for the thermodynamic cycle can only be determined by separating the mono and divalent ions to achieve an R 2 value of 0.86 and 0.74 for mono and divalent ions, respectively. We show that by optimizing the lanthanide-ligand structures in implicit solvent, we achieve an improved correlation between experimental and computed stability constants of R 2 value of 0.89 for the combined mono and divalent ions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Electroanalytical characterization of Np( VI )/Np( V ) redox in a pentadentate ligand environment and stabilization of [Np V O 2 ] + by hydrogen bonding

The redox chemistry of the actinyl cations (AnO 2 n+ ) heavily influences their reactivity and speciation in solution, but the redox properties of the actinyls in non-aqueous media have received far less attention than they deserve. Here, the non-aqueous electrochemistry of a chemically reversible Np(VI)/Np(V) redox manifold is reported in both protic (CH 3 OH) and aprotic (CH 3 CN) organic media. Using a neutral Np(VI) complex supported by a chelating and strongly donating pentadentate ligand that was fully characterized in prior work, a clean Np(VI)/Np(V) redox couple was found to be accessible under ambient conditions. Coupled electrochemical and spectroscopic studies, as well as simulations of cyclic voltammetry data, confirm the 1e− nature of this couple and establish it to be chemically reversible and nearly electrochemically reversible as well. Bulk electrolysis of a solution of the neutral Np(VI) complex facilitated isolation of the corresponding anionic and monomeric Np(V) species. Data from X-ray diffraction analysis as well as optical and vibrational spectroscopies provide strong evidence in support of metal-centered reduction and the Np(V) oxidation state, findings that are in accord with the measured reduction potentials. Distinctive hydrogen bonding interactions between the terminal (yl) oxo groups and water molecules appear to stabilize the isolated Np(V) species in the solid state, providing insight into the features that afford the uncommon chemically reversible redox encountered in this system.

Mikeska, Emily R.↗
DOE OSTI2023

A customized MOF-polymer composite for rapid gold extraction from water matrices

With the fast-growing accumulation of electronic waste and rising demand for rare metals, it is compelling to develop technologies that can promotionally recover targeted metals, like gold, from waste, a process referred to as urban mining. Thus, there is increasing interest in the design of materials to achieve rapid, selective gold capture while maintaining high adsorption capacity, especially in complex aqueous-based matrices. Here, a highly porous metal-organic framework (MOF)–polymer composite, BUT-33–poly(para-phenylenediamine) (PpPD), is assessed for gold extraction from several matrices including river water, seawater, and leaching solutions from CPUs. BUT-33–PpPD exhibits a record-breaking extraction rate, with high Au3+ removal efficiency (>99%) within seconds (less than 45 s), a competitive capacity (1600 mg/g), high selectivity, long-term stability, and recycling ability. Furthermore, the high porosity and redox adsorption mechanism were shown to be underlying reasons for the material’s excellent performance. Given the accumulation of recovered metallic gold nanoparticles inside, the material was also efficiently applied as a catalyst.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗