Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “REACTOR OPERATION”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 145 records · Page 8

Brittle nature and the related effects of zirconium hydrides in Zircaloy-4

The use of zirconium alloys such as Zircaloy-4 in nuclear reactors is limited by brittle hydride formation, for example in harsh reactor operating conditions such as those in the pressurized water reactors. Even though much research has studied this phenomenon, a more systematic, in-depth study of the effects of hydrides on the properties of Zircaloy-4, using various analytical techniques, can add more details to the understanding of these effects. In the current study, hydrogen charging was performed on Zircaloy-4 at different levels compatible with commercial reactor operating conditions and conditions in accident scenarios. Effects of hydriding on the Zircaloy-4 (α-(hcp)-Zr) tensile properties, together with an in-depth study of any relationship between tensile and the microstructural properties of the material, are discussed. While a moderate pinning effect on the equiaxed α-Zr grain size was observed, no significant change in bulk texture of the Zry-4 was revealed as the hydrogen level increased up to nominally 1230 wppmH. At a nominal value of 490 wppmH, Zircaloy-4 fractured at a low strain value just above the yielding point, and brittle tensile fracture was observed in a sample H-charged to nominally 1230 wppmH. The low ductility and brittle fracture of the samples were attributed to the presence of brittle inter-grain boundary hydrides. Finally, it was observed that brittle fracturing was also supported by intra-grain boundary hydrides that were affected by the tensile deformation of the sample.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Validation of SCALE for High Temperature Gas-Cooled Reactors Analysis

This report documents verification and validation studies carried out to assess the performance of the SCALE code system methods and nuclear data for modeling and analysis of High Temperature Gas-Cooled Reactor (HTGR) configurations. Validation data were available from the International Handbook of Evaluated Reactor Physics Benchmark Experiments (IRPhE Handbook), prepared by the International Reactor Physics Experiment Evaluation Project, for two different HTGR designs: prismatic and pebble bed. SCALE models have been developed for HTTR, a prismatic fuel design reactor operated in Japan and HTR-10, a pebble bed reactor operated in China. The models were based on benchmark specifications included in the 2009, 2010, and 2011 releases of the IRPhE Handbook. SCALE models for the HTR-PROTEUS pebble bed configuration at the PROTEUS critical facility in Switzerland have also been developed, based on benchmark specifications included in a 2009 IRPhE draft benchmark. The development of the SCALE models has involved a series of investigations to identify particular issues associated with modeling the physics of HTGRs and to understand and quantify the effect of particular modeling assumptions on calculation-to-experiment comparisons.

Ilas, Germina↗

Interface Tracking Investigation of Geometric Effects on the Bubbly Flow in PWR Subchannels

We report that absorbing heat from the fuel rod surface, water as coolant can undergo subcooled boiling within a pressurized water reactor (PWR) fuel rod bundle. Because of the buoyancy effect, the vapor bubbles generated will then rise along and interact with the subchannel geometries. Reliable prediction of bubble behavior is of immense importance to ensure safe and stable reactor operation. However, given a complex engineering system like a nuclear reactor, it is very challenging (if not impossible) to conduct high-resolution measurements to study bubbly flows under reactor operation conditions. The lack of a fundamental two-phase-flow database is hindering the development of accurate two-phase-flow models required in more advanced reactor designs. In response to this challenge, first-principles–based numerical simulations are emerging as an attractive alternative to produce a complementary data source along with experiments. Leveraged by the unprecedented computing power offered by state-of-the-art supercomputers, direct numerical simulation (DNS), coupled with interface tracking methods, is becoming a practical tool to investigate some of the most challenging engineering flow problems. In the presented research, turbulent bubbly flow is simulated via DNS in single PWR subchannel geometries with auxiliary structures (e.g., supporting spacer grid and mixing vanes). The geometric effects these structures exert on the bubbly flow are studied with both a conventional time-averaging approach and a novel dynamic bubble tracking method. Lastly, the new insights obtained will help inform better two-phase models that can contribute to safer and more efficient nuclear reactor systems.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Multiscale Investigation of Thermal Transport in UO{sub 2} Fuel using Modeling and Simulation

The thermal conductivity of the UO{sub 2} fuel in light water reactors (LWRs) defines how efficiently heat is transported from the fuel to the coolant, and thus directly influences the reactor efficiency. Unfortunately, the same fission events that generate heat also cause radiation damage and fission product formation that decreases the thermal conductivity. This reduction in thermal conductivity reduces the safety of the reactor in addition to its efficiency, because excess heat generated during an accident cannot be transported from the fuel, resulting in high temperatures that can result in melting. Because thermal conductivity plays such an important role in reactor efficiency and safety, many experiments have been conducted to measure the thermal conductivity of UO{sub 2} and how it changes during reactor operation. Experiments on unirradiated fuel have resulted in a large set of data indicating how the bulk thermal conductivity changes as a function of temperature, which was used to develop a semiempirical model. Additional experiments have been conducted to determine how the thermal conductivity of UO{sub 2} changes as a function of burnup, leading to burnup dependent models fitted to the data. While these empirical models perform well within the conditions at which the data was collected, they cannot be extrapolated outside of those conditions. In addition, while burnup is a measure of the amount of fissioning that has occurred, it cannot account for the impact of the operating conditions on the thermal conductivity. While experimental data provides an empirical view on the value of the thermal conductivity in the fuel during reactor operation, a more mechanistic understanding of how temperature and burnup impact the transport of heat through the fuel would be extremely valuable. Such an understanding would allow for a more accurate prediction of fuel performance, but it could also be used to direct modifications to the fuel that would raise the thermal conductivity or reduce the impact of burnup. In this work we summarize recent efforts to use modeling and simulation at the atomistic and mesoscales to obtain a mechanistic understanding of thermal transport in UO{sub 2}. The thermal conductivity of LWR fuel is one of the most critical material parameters impacting the efficiency and safety of the reactor. Thus, a significant effort is being made to develop a mechanistic understanding of the impact of temperature and burnup on it. In this work, we have provided a short summary of modeling and simulation efforts being carried out at the atomistic and mesoscale to understand this critical property. These research efforts are providing a fundamental understanding of the thermal transport in unirradiated UO{sub 2}, as well as the impact of radiation damage and fission products on thermal transport. These efforts have been focused on UO{sub 2}, but they also are laying the framework for conducted similar simulations to investigate new accident tolerant fuel concepts. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Determination of uncertainties of PWR spent fuel radionuclide inventory based on real operational history data

A requisite for the official approval of the safe final disposal of SNF is a comprehensive specification and declaration of the nuclear inventory in SNF by the waste supplier. In the verification process both the values of the radionuclide (RN) activities and their uncertainties are required. Burn-up (BU) calculations based on typical and generic reactor operational parameters do not encompass any possible uncertainties observed in real reactor operations. At the same time, the details of the irradiation history are often not well known, which complicates the assessment of declared RN inventories. Here, we have compiled a set of burnup calculations accounting for the operational history of 339 published or anonymized real PWR fuel assemblies (FA). These histories were used as a basis for a 'SRP analysis', to provide information about the range of the values of the associated secondary reactor parameters (SRP's). Hence, we can calculate the realistic variation or spectrum of RN inventories. SCALE 6.1 has been employed for the burn-up calculations. The results have been validated using experimental data from the online database - SFCOMPO-1 and -2. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Exploratory Design of a Reactor/Fuel Cycle Using Spent Nuclear Fuel Without Conventional Reprocessing - 13579

General Atomics has started design of a waste to energy nuclear reactor (EM2) that can use light water reactor (LWR) spent nuclear fuel (SNF). This effort addresses two problems: using an advanced small reactor with long core life to reduce nuclear energy overnight cost and providing a disposal path for LWR SNF. LWR SNF is re-fabricated into new EM2 fuel using a dry voloxidation process modeled on AIROX/ OREOX processes which remove some of the fission products but no heavy metals. By not removing all of the fission products the fuel remains self-protecting. By not separating heavy metals, the process remains proliferation resistant. Implementation of Energy Multiplier Module (EM2) fuel cycle will provide low cost nuclear energy while providing a long term LWR SNF disposition path which is important for LWR waste confidence. With LWR waste confidence recent impacts on reactor licensing, an alternate disposition path is highly relevant. Centered on a reactor operating at 250 MWe, the compact electricity generating system design maximizes site flexibility with truck transport of all system components and available dry cooling features that removes the need to be located near a body of water. A high temperature system using helium coolant, electricity is efficiently produced using an asynchronous high-speed gas turbine while the LWR SNF is converted to fission products. Reactor design features such as vented fuel and silicon carbide cladding support reactor operation for decades between refueling, with improved fuel utilization. Beyond the reactor, the fuel cycle is designed so that subsequent generations of EM2 reactor fuel will use the previous EM2 discharge, providing its own waste confidence plus eliminating the need for enrichment after the first generation. Additional LWR SNF is added at each re-fabrication to replace the removed fission products. The fuel cycle uses a dry voloxidation process for both the initial LWR SNF re-fabrication and later for EM2 discharge reuse. The EM2 waste disposal profile is effectively only fission products, which reduces the mass (about 3% vs LWR), average half life, heat and long term radio-toxicity of the disposal. Widespread implementation of EM2 fuel cycle is highly significant as it would increase world energy reserves; the remaining energy in U.S. LWR SNF alone exceeds that in the U.S. natural gas reserves. Unlike many LWR SNF disposition concepts, the EM2 fuel cycle conversion of SNF produces energy and associated revenue such that the overall project is cost effective. By providing conversion of SNF to fission products the fuel cycle is closed and a non-repository LWR SNF disposition path is created and overall repository requirements are significantly reduced. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Automatic Modeling of VVER-1000 Power Maneuvers

A special version of the IR code is described. The purpose of this code is to generate recommendations for the reactor operator when operating in a maneuvering regime, automate boron regulation, and study the maneuvering characteristics of VVER-1000 fuel loads. The results of modeling of operation in a daily load schedule are presented for the example of a stationary run of VVER-TOI. The impact of variation of the parameters of power maneuvers (run, operating time a reduced power, loading rate) on the boron regulation parameters is analyzed.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Integration of facility modeling capabilities for nuclear nonproliferation analysis

Developing automated methods for data collection and analysis that can facilitate nuclear nonproliferation assessment is an important research area with significant consequences for the effective global deployment of nuclear energy. Facility modeling that can integrate and interpret observations collected from monitored facilities in order to ascertain their functional details will be a critical element of these methods. Although improvements are continually sought, existing facility modeling tools can characterize all aspects of reactor operations and the majority of nuclear fuel cycle processing steps, and include algorithms for data processing and interpretation. Assessing nonproliferation status is challenging because observations can come from many sources, including local and remote sensors that monitor facility operations, as well as open sources that provide specific business information about the monitored facilities, and can be of many different types. Although many current facility models are capable of analyzing large amounts of information, they have not been integrated in an analyst-friendly manner. This paper addresses some of these facility modeling capabilities and illustrates how they could be integrated and utilized for nonproliferation analysis. The inverse problem of inferring facility conditions based on collected observations is described, along with a proposed architecture and computer framework for utilizing facility modeling tools. After considering a representative sampling of key facility modeling capabilities, the proposed integration framework is illustrated with several examples.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

An Autonomous Critical Data Extrapolator for the AGN-201m

Nuclear nonproliferation serves as a key goal, being undertaken by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). To recognize proliferation there are two pathways that states, who intend to use nuclear material for malicious purposes can take, diversion can misuse. Diversion is when fissile nuclear material is declared to the IAEA for non-weapon purposes, but then covertly removed. If the source of nuclear material, that is not declared and not fissionable, is placed inside the reactor core to create fissile material used to create weapons then the state is using the second pathway of proliferation, misuse. With the emerging development in areas of simulation and machine learning the creation of virtual models of reactor systems, digital twins, serve as a potential method to identify proliferation through detecting anomalous behavior in the reactor. A digital twin for a physical nuclear reactor has never been developed, as digital twins serve as an emerging technology. To investigate the process for development and use of a digital twin for a nuclear reactor Idaho State University’s AGN-201m serves as the nuclear reactor used for development of this digital twin. A data acquisition system has been installed to the reactor system allowing for the transfer of collected data from a reactor operation to Idaho National Laboratory’s Deeplynx data warehouse. When utilizing data to train reactor physics and machine learning models, a significant challenge encountered is the initial state of the data. Nuclear proliferation will have the capacity to be detected when the reactor immediately starts up, nor will it occur after the reactor shuts down. Generally, it will be detected when the reactor is operating at some desired power over a sufficient period for that specific reactor design. For the AGN-201m this will be when the reactor is critical (generally 1 mW or above) for a timespan that is within or less than the range of a regular business day. Datasets sent to Deeplynx have had to be manually cut to when the reactor is critical based on plots of power levels. This method is inefficient and laborious, especially when using multiple datasets at once to train a model. To provide a more streamlined approach an automated critical data extrapolator is developed, with capabilities of recognizing when the reactor operation first reaches criticality, and when the reactor undergoes a SCRAM and is shutdown.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

Development of Critical Experiments to Benchmark Moderator Temperature Reactivity Worth

The simulation of nuclear reactors requires being able to accurately model several different interrelated physical processes including neutronics, heat production, fluid/thermal physics, structural mechanics, fuel behavior, chemistry, and balance-of-plant. In order to design and use new types of nuclear reactors, modern codes have been developed which couple together the behavior of these different physical models to accurately consider the feedback effects between different physical effects. The SHARP toolset, part of the Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation (NEAMS) project, is an example of an effort to combine models of neutronics, thermal-hydraulics, and structural mechanics in a coupled simulation to model any type of nuclear reactor as accurately as possible. The validation of multi-physics coupling techniques requires new experimental benchmark experiments specifically designed for that purpose. As a preliminary step towards design of these experiments, a series of measurements have been performed to demonstrate the temperature-dependent neutronic behavior of a well-characterized reactor assembly for comparison with the available codes. The facility adopted for these experiments is Walthousen Reactor Critical Facility (RCF) at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI). The RCF is unique in several aspects and provides several advantages to this type of experiment. Built in 1954 by the American Locomotive Company (ALCO), the RCF has been used to design small compact reactors. RPI acquired the facility in 1963, and the highly-enriched uranium fuel was later swapped for low-enriched fuel pins that were excess from the SPERT facility experiments. Nowadays, The RCF is regarded as a teaching and research facility, permitting the training of licensed Senior Reactor Operators, and offering a critical experiments laboratory course to students. The reactor core standard configuration consists of 332 or 333 UO{sub 2} fuel pins, containing a total of 35.2 grams of U- 235 each (4.81 % enriched). The pins are arranged in a regular lattice with a pitch of 1.6256 cm. The number and configuration of these pins are flexible, and the reactor's overall thermal power is limited to no more than 15 W. As the low thermal output of the reactor does not induce any measurable temperature changes, the effect of temperature in the reactor is observed by applying two 18- kW electric heaters to the water moderator, with mechanical agitators to maintain uniformity in moderator temperature. Before beginning experiments, each fuel pin inside the core was surveyed for mechanical defects (bending or warping) that may contribute to uncertainty in core behavior. Every fuel pin has been individually removed from the core and checked for any irregularities on its surface (caused by shocks or usage). About 12 % of the 333 pins were found to have a small degree of warping and were replaced with excess pins available in the facility. In doing this, we made sure all the pins are identical, thereby increasing the accuracy of future models. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Reactor dosimetry and RPV life management

Reactor dosimetry (RD) is a tool that provides data for neutron fluence accumulated over the reactor pressure vessel (RPV) during the reactor operation. This information, however, is not sufficient for RPV lifetime assessment. The life management of RPV is a multidisciplinary task. To assess whether the RPV steel properties at the current stage (for actual accumulated neutron fluence) of reactor operation are still 'safe enough,' the dependence of material properties on the fluence must be known; this is a task for material science (MS). Moreover, the mechanical loading over the RPV during normal operation and accidence have to be known, as well, for evaluation, if the RPV material integrity in this loading condition and existing cracks is provided. The crack loading path in terms of stress intensity factor is carried out by structural analyses (SA). Pressure and temperature distribution over RPV used in these analyses are obtained from a thermal hydraulic (TH) calculation. The conjunction of RD and other disciplines in RPV integrity assessment is analyzed in accordance with the FFP (fitness for purpose) approach. It could help to improve the efficiency in multi-disciplinary tasks solutions. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Post-quench ductility of zirconium alloy cladding materials - 2016-0088

The ductility of zirconium-based alloys after steam oxidation at high temperatures, followed by quenching in water, is of significant interest for the nuclear industry. High-temperature steam oxidation and quenching of nuclear fuel cladding occurs during postulated loss-of-coolant accidents. The industry is currently establishing in-reactor operation limits for peak cladding temperature and time at temperature based on the measured ductile-to-brittle transition of different cladding materials, both in the as-fabricated condition and using hydrogen charging as a surrogate for in-reactor operation. Aiming to study possible differences in post-quench ductility caused by differences in chemical composition, extensive testing on Zircaloy-4, ZIRLO{sup R}, and Optimized ZIRLO{sup TM} cladding materials as a function of hydrogen content, extent of oxidation, and peak cladding temperature was performed. The results showed similar ductile-to-brittle transition for the alloys studied despite differences in chemical composition, with a decrease in the extent of oxidation to reach the ductile to brittle transition with increasing hydrogen content. Microstructural characterization was performed to investigate the evolution of the oxygen-enriched layer that forms underneath the oxide, both during the time at high temperatures and during cooling. Significantly different morphologies of the oxygen-enriched layer were observed with different cooling rates, particularly for alloys containing niobium. Possible mechanisms for the development of the oxygen-enriched layer are discussed. (authors)

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Post quench ductility of Zirconium alloy cladding materials - 6.2 STP-2016-0088

The ductility of zirconium-based alloys after steam oxidation at high temperature, followed by quenching in water, is of significant interest for the nuclear industry. High temperature steam oxidation and quenching of nuclear fuel cladding occurs during postulated loss-of-coolant accidents (LOCA). The industry is currently establishing in-reactor operation limits for peak cladding temperature and time at temperature based on the measured ductile-to-brittle transition of different cladding materials, both in the as-fabricated condition and using hydrogen charging as a surrogate for in-reactor operation. Aiming to study possible differences in post-quench ductility (PQD) caused by differences in chemical composition, extensive testing has been performed on Zircaloy-4, ZIRLO{sup R} and Optimized ZIRLO{sup TM} cladding materials as a function of hydrogen content, extent of oxidation and peak cladding temperature. The results show similar ductile-to-brittle transition for the alloys studied, in spite of the differences in chemical composition, with a decrease in the extent of oxidation to reach the ductile-to-brittle transition with increasing hydrogen content. Microstructural characterization was performed to investigate the evolution of the oxygen enriched layer that appears underneath the oxide, both during the time at high temperature and during cooling. Significantly different morphologies of the oxygen enriched layer are observed with different cooling rates, particularly for alloys containing niobium. Possible mechanisms for the development of the oxygen enriched layer are discussed (authors)

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Assess How Changes in Fuel Cycle Operation Impact Safeguards

Since the beginning of commercial nuclear power generation in the 1960s, the ability of researchers to understand and control the isotopic content of spent fuel has improved. It is therefore not surprising that both fuel assembly design and fuel assembly irradiation optimization have improved over the past 50+ years. It is anticipated that the burnup and isotopics of the spent fuel should exhibit less variation over the decades as reactor operators irradiate each assembly to the optimum amount. In contrast, older spent fuel is anticipated to vary more in burnup and resulting isotopics for a given initial enrichment. Modern fuel therefore should be more uniform in composition, and thus, measured safeguards results should be easier to interpret than results from older spent fuel. With spent fuel ponds filling up, interim and long-­term storage of spent fuel will need to be addressed. Additionally after long periods of storage, spent fuel is no longer self-­protecting and, as such, the IAEA will categorize it as more attractive; in approximately 20 years many of the assemblies from early commercial cores will no longer be considered self-­protecting. This study will assess how more recent changes in the reactor operation could impact the interpretation of safeguards measurements. The status quo for spent fuel assay in the safeguards context is that the overwhelming majority of spent fuel assemblies are not measured in a quantitative way except for those assemblies about to be loaded into a difficult or impossible to access location (dry storage or, in the future, a repository). In other words, when the assembly is still accessible to a state actor, or an insider, when it is cooling in a pool, the inspectorate does not have a measurement database that could assist them in re-­verifying the integrity of that assembly. The spent fuel safeguards regime would be strengthened if spent fuel assemblies were measured from discharge to loading into a difficult or impossible to access location. The primary driver for suggesting this shift in approach is the change in robotic technology and information technology in general. It should be possible, with minimal impact to the facility, to measure each assembly every time that it is moved in the pool, with the first measurements being made at discharge. The following conclusions were reached: The total neutron count rate can be accurately predicted at any future moment in time based upon the measured count rate at discharge, provided the initial enrichment and burnup of the assembly is known at discharge. It is expected that the total neutron count rate measured at discharge will be indicative of the initial enrichment and burnup of that assembly. If the automated robot were to focus on measuring the assemblies in the rack without moving them, the time available would increase immensely.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Plutonium and minor actinide utilisation in a pebble-bed high temperature reactor

This paper contains results of the analysis of the pebble-bed high temperature gas-cooled PUMA reactor loaded with plutonium and minor actinide (Pu/MA) fuel. Starting from knowledge and experience gained in the Euratom FP5 projects HTR-N and HTR-N1, this study aims at demonstrating the potential of high temperature reactors to utilize or transmute Pu/MA fuel. The work has been performed within the Euratom FP6 project PUMA. A number of different fuel types and fuel configurations have been analyzed and compared with respect to incineration performance and safety-related reactor parameters. The results show the excellent plutonium and minor actinide burning capabilities of the high temperature reactor. The largest degree of incineration is attained in the case of an HTR fuelled by pure plutonium fuel as it remains critical at very deep burnup of the discharged pebbles. Addition of minor actinides to the fuel leads to decrease of the achievable discharge burnup and therefore smaller fraction of actinides incinerated during reactor operation. The inert-matrix fuel design improves the transmutation performance of the reactor, while the 'wallpaper' fuel does not have advantage over the standard fuel design in this respect. After 100 years of decay following the fuel discharge, the total amount of actinides remains almost unchanged for all of the fuel types considered. Among the plutonium isotopes, only the amount of Pu-241 is reduced significantly due to its relatively short half-life. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Summary of LWRS Research in Addressing RPV Research Gaps in NRC EMDA Report

Reactor Pressure Vessels (RPVs) are critical components in nuclear reactors, housing the reactor core and coolant under extreme conditions of temperature, pressure, and radiation. These harsh environments contribute to the degradation of RPV materials over time, presenting challenges for extending reactor operations beyond their original design lifespans. The NRC Expanded Materials Degradation Assessment (EMDA) report volume 3 have been instrumental in guiding research to support extending the operational life of light water reactors (LWRs) up to 80 years. It provides a comprehensive framework to address technical challenges related to aging and degradation mechanisms in RPVs. The LWRS program has played a key role in advancing this research, supporting projects such as the UCSB ATR-2 Experiment, material testing from Zion and Palisades reactors, and the development of advanced mini-compact tension testing techniques. These efforts have been crucial in identifying and addressing gaps in our understanding of RPV aging, contributing to the successful subsequent license renewals of eight LWR units in the U.S. The EMDA report volume 3, built on the Phenomena Identification and Ranking Table (PIRT) analysis from earlier versions of the EPRI Materials Degradation Matrix (MDM) and Issue Management Tables (IMTs), provides a detailed assessment of RPV degradation mechanisms. However, as EPRI has updated the MDM and IMT, it is important to revisit research priorities and methodologies to reflect these changes. The revised MDM and IMT may introduce new factors affecting long-term RPV performance and safety, highlighting the need for continued research and updated guidance to ensure the reliable and safe operation of reactors beyond 80 years.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Analog, Digital, or Enhanced Human-System Interfaces? Results of an Operator-in-the-Loop Study on Main Control Room Modernization for a Nuclear Power Plant

The second Operator Study of System Overviews (OSSO-2) was conducted with a three-person reactor operator crew in the Human Systems Simulation Laboratory (HSSL) at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) in August, 2017. The study supported control room modernization at a nuclear power plant and featured a benchmark comparison of three variants of a turbine control system (TCS): the existing analog TCS, a proposed standalone digital TCS with two displays, and the digital TCS with the addition of a third display consisting of a system overview screen. TCS prototypes were developed at INL to allow evaluation of operator performance and preferences during realistic turbine scenarios in the full-scope simulator. The study revealed that completion of turbine startup was several minutes faster with the digital TCS variants than with the conventional analog TCS. Eye tracking scan paths were more widely distributed in the overview vs. standalone TCS condition, suggesting the overview screen was cueing reactor operators to verify values across the boards. There was no significant difference in workload or situation awareness across the three interfaces. Reviewing key plant parameters showed smoother transitions during load following for the digital vs. analog TCS. Despite some performance advantages for the digital TCS variants, operators preferred the existing analog TCS. Open-ended responses suggested this finding may be more an artifact of familiarity than a reflection of dissatisfaction with the new TCS. OSSO-2 provides compelling evidence that the new digital TCS was used successfully by the operators without extensive training of rewriting of the operating procedures, suggesting high usability for the digital TCS design. Further advantages were realized through the addition of the system overview screen to provide crews with at-a-glance indicators of key turbine parameters.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗