Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Irradiation Resistant”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 145 records · Page 8
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

Final report on assessment of molten salt corrosion testing of unirradiated and ion irradiated advanced manufactured high entropy alloys

Generation IV reactors and future fusion reactor designs have led to more demanding materials performance requirements due to their increased operating temperatures, corrosive coolants, and increased radiation doses compared to the current light-water reactor fleet. Among the innovative nuclear technologies under development, molten salt reactors stand out for their potential to offer superior fuel utilization, intrinsic safety characteristics, and economic viability. Of the proposed Generation IV designs, the gas fast reactor operates at 450 to 850°C and the molten salt reactor operates at 565 to 850°C, with the molten salt reactor design needing molten salt corrosion resistant materials [1, 2]. These increased temperatures and more extreme corrosion environments necessitate higher material performance, such as creep strength, radiation-tolerant microstructures, corrosion resistance, and high-temperature tensile properties. Hastelloy-N, a nickel-based alloy with additions of molybdenum and chromium, has been successfully employed to contain molten fluoride salt at temperatures up to 705°C. However, Hastelloy-N becomes embrittled upon neutron irradiation, primarily due to the accumulation of helium produced by (n,a) transmutation reactions. Furthermore, the corrosive nature of molten fluoride and chloride salts presents a formidable challenge, as these salts can react with and dissolve alloying elements such as Cr, Mo, and Fe, leading to selective leaching, loss of protective oxide layers, and accelerated degradation. High entropy alloys (HEAs) and refractory high entropy alloys (RHEAs) have emerged as a prominent area of interest, due to their ability to achieve tailored chemical compositions for specific applications. Unlike conventional alloys, HEAs are characterized by having multiple principal elements in equimolar or near equimolar ratios, leading to an unconventional alloying strategy [3]. This alloying strategy is believed to promote unique properties, such as single-phase stabilization of chemically compatible elements, lattice distortion effects due to atomic radius differences, and proposed sluggish diffusion effects. For extreme-environment applications, RHEAs have garnered much research interest because of the possibility of creating relatively ductile materials that can operate in extremely high-temperature environments, beyond the operating temperatures where other Ni-based superalloys begin to lose strength [4-6]. Idaho National Laboratory (INL) initiated a joint international effort with the Czech Republic to explore the feasibility of manufacturing HEAs for high-temperature nuclear applications using advanced manufacturing. This effort was funded at INL by the United States Department of Energy's Office of Nuclear Energy under the Advanced Reactor Technologies and Advanced Materials and Manufacturing Technologies (AMMT) Program. The HEAs were specifically designed for the corrosive and irradiation environments experienced in gas-cooled fast reactors, molten salt reactors, and fusion power. These alloys have been manufactured by multiple processes to determine the impact of manufacturing processes on the performance of the alloys in corrosive and irradiation environments. Preliminary molten salt corrosion testing showed that equimolar MoNbTiV and MoNbTi alloys exhibit exceptional performance, with arc-melted variants demonstrating only minimal degradation after 1000 hours of exposure to molten chloride salt at 700°C. Conversely, Nb2TiVZr2 showed significant molten salt corrosion susceptibility and microstructural instability during high-temperature molten salt exposures, and was, therefore deemed unfit for molten salt reactor applications. The MoNbTiV, MoNbTi, and Nb2TiVZr2 alloys were further evaluated through ion irradiation experiments conducted at the Michigan Ion Beam Laboratory at the University of Michigan. The microstructural stability and the evolution of irradiation-induced defects were characterized to assess the irradiation resistance of each of these alloys.

36 - MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Carbon nanotube (CNT) metal composites exhibit greatly reduced radiation damage

Radiation damage of structural materials leads to mechanical property degradation, eventually inducing failure. Secondary-phase dispersoids or other radiation defect sinks are often added to materials to boost their radiation resistance. We demonstrate that a metal composite made by adding 1D carbon nanotubes (CNTs) to aluminum (Al) exhibits superior radiation resistance. In situ ion irradiation with transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and atomistic simulations together reveal the mechanisms of rapid defect migration to CNTs, facilitating defect recombination and enhancing radiation tolerance. The origin of this effect is an evolving stress gradient in the Al matrix resulting from CNT transformation under irradiation, and the stability of resulting carbides. Extreme value statistics of large defect behavior in our simulations highlight the role of CNTs in reducing accumulated damage. Furthermore, this approach to controlling defect migration represents a promising opportunity to enhance the radiation resistance of nuclear materials without detrimental effects.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Radiation induced amorphization of carbides in additively manufactured and conventional ferritic-martensitic steels: In-situ experiments on extraction replicas

In-situ irradiations using 1 MeV Kr 2+ ions in a transmission electron microscope were performed on extraction replica samples containing M 23 C 6 carbides and MX carbonitrides from two ferritic-martensitic (FM) steels: (i) 9%Cr-1%W-TaV based Eurofer97 and (ii) 9%Cr-1%Mo-VNb (all in wt.%) based additively manufactured (AM) Grade91 steel. The irradiations were performed between 100 and 773 K up to a maximum dose of ~2.4 displacements per atom (dpa). The M 23 C 6 carbides are highly susceptible to radiation induced amorphization (RIA), while the MX type nanoprecipitates are highly amorphization resistant across the entire irradiation temperature range. Between 100 and 423 K, RIA of M 23 C 6 carbides occurs very rapidly with critical amorphization doses ranging between ~0.35 and 0.9 dpa, increasing to higher doses at 573 K. Complete amorphization of the M 23 C 6 carbides up to doses of ~2.4 dpa is not possible at 773 K under the present irradiation conditions. The critical amorphization dose of M 23 C 6 carbides increases nearly exponentially with irradiation temperature. The critical temperature for the crystalline-to-amorphous phase transformation (T c→a ) of M 23 C 6 carbides irradiated as replica samples, i.e. without the surrounding metal matrix, was estimated to be ~812 K. Comparing the present results with neutron irradiation data on bulk samples reveals a decrease in the critical amorphization dose for M 23 C 6 and an increase of T c→a , highlighting the effect of dose rate on the amorphization behavior that is qualitatively consistent with literature on other non-metals. Changes in the minor chemistry of M 23 C 6 , such as presence or absence of W, V, Nb, Mo, seems to have little effect on the amorphization behavior. Here, in-situ irradiations on extraction replica samples provide a novel pathway to explore radiation tolerance of nanoprecipitates in nuclear structural materials

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Crack Growth Rate and Fracture Toughness Tests on Irradiated Ex-Plant Materials

The performance of structural materials is critical for the safe and economic operation of light water reactors. Exposed to neutron irradiation during service, the reactor core internal materials can undergo significant microstructural and microchemical changes, leading to irradiation hardening and embrittlement. To ensure the structural integrity and functionality of nuclear reactor components during long-term operation, material degradation and damage mechanisms must be understood and managed adequately. In this work, irradiated materials harvested from the decommissioned Zorita reactor were studied for their cracking susceptibility and fracture resistance as a function of irradiation dose up to 47 displacement per atom (dpa). The material is a Type 304 stainless steel sectioned from the baffle plates of this pressurized water reactor with 38 years of service. Crack growth rate and fracture toughness J-resistance (J-R) curve tests were performed in low-corrosion-potential environments at ~315°C. All samples behaved similarly under cyclic loading, and no deteriorated corrosion-fatigue behavior was observed in the test environments. Under constant stress intensity factors, most samples did not show elevated crack growth rates, suggesting an adequate stress corrosion cracking resistance in the test environments. However, an unstable cracking behavior was observed in a 47-dpa sample, resulting in significantly higher crack growth rates than expected at high stress intensity factors. Crack instability was also observed in a 0.06-dpa sample but did not lead to a sustained high crack growth rate. The impact of neutron irradiation was more evident in the fracture toughness J-R curve tests. As the dose increased, the J-R curve declined considerably and became very shallow at high doses. A fully intergranular fracture morphology was also observed among the high-dose samples ruptured in an air atmosphere at room temperature. This brittle fracture mode in the absence of high temperature water environment confirmed a high degree of embrittlement of this material resulting from its service exposure to neutron irradiation.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2023

Design and development of equi-atomic refractory High Entropy Alloys for use in radiation environments

Development of new structural materials that can withstand the extreme environments of nuclear reactors where the materials are exposed to high dose rate of ~ 30 200 dpa, high temperatures of the order of 500 1000 o C and tens of years of operation is vital for exploiting the “smallest carbon footprint energy source” to its fullest, in order to deal with the energy crisis worldwide. Recently, HEAs have shown superior irradiation properties over conventional alloys like higher resistance to defect formation, lower void swelling, limited irradiation hardening and higher microstructural stability under irradiation, making them potential structural material candidates for reactors. Proper characterization and testing of these materials are essential before they can replace the conventional alloys.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

High Entropy Alloys: Irradiation

High entropy alloys (HEAs) have been considered as structural materials for nuclear applications due to their promising mechanical properties and radiation resistance. For this purpose, irradiation-induced defect evolution and microstructure change have been characterized to evaluate the irradiation performance of different HEAs. This article reviews recent advances in understanding the irradiation response of HEAs, including the effect of disordered states on the defect energy landscape and defect evolution, irradiation-induced microstructure changes, void swelling, phase stability, mechanical properties under irradiation, as well as the He irradiation effects.

Zhao, Shijun↗
DOE OSTI2020

Disorder recovers the Wiedemann-Franz law in the metallic phase of VO 2

At temperatures higher than 341 K, vanadium dioxide (VO 2 ) is a strongly correlated metal with resistivity exceeding the Mott-Ioffe-Regel limit. Its electronic thermal conductivity is lower than that predicted by the Wiedemann-Franz (WF) law, and can be explained by nonquasiparticle transport where heat and charge currents follow separate diffusive modes. In contradiction, the Wiedemann-Franz law is a direct consequence of quasiparticle transport where charge carriers are elastically scattered. In this work, we enhance elastic electron scattering in VO 2 by introducing atomic disorder with ion irradiation. Furthermore, a gradual and eventually full recovery of the WF law is observed at high defect densities. This observation provides an example that connects hydrodynamic quasiparticle transport to nonquasiparticle transport in metallic systems.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2022

High-Throughput Ion Irradiation and Microstructural Characterization of Multi-Principal-Element Alloys

Multi-principal-element alloys (MPEAs) have garnered interest in the nuclear community for their apparent resistance to microstructural damage under irradiation. While both experimentation and simulation have demonstrated reduced hardening and void swelling in MPEAs, the relationship between composition and irradiation response is still poorly understood since a rich experimental database for MPEAs does not yet exist. In this work, to accelerate the generation of experimental irradiation-response data for MPEAs, high-throughput synthesis, irradiation, and characterization techniques have been employed. Specifically, additive manufacturing has been used to produce arrays of various MPEAs (1-cm2 coupons), which have been subsequently irradiated using 4-MeV Ni2+ ions to a peak damage of 200 dpa at 500 °C. Hardening and void swelling have been assessed using nanoindentation and trenching via plasma focused ion beam (PFIB), respectively. Trends in the experimental data relating hardening and void swelling behavior to composition have been analyzed using different machine learning approaches.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Design considerations for high entropy alloys in advanced nuclear applications

The demanding operating environments of advanced nuclear reactors require the development of new nuclear materials that can withstand their increased physical, chemical, thermal, and radiation-related challenges. High-entropy alloys (HEAs) have shown often-impressive mechanical, thermomechanical, and corrosion-resistant properties, and offer a massive, unexplored compositional space which allows for the targeted development of application-specific materials. Furthermore, although still in a nascent stage, research has shown that HEAs may exhibit unique irradiation tolerance, including reduced defect production and resistance to irradiation-induced swelling and hardening. The mechanisms behind this increased tolerance are not yet well-understood, although the HEA-specific attributes of a complex energy landscape, reduced thermal conductivity, and shift in defect migration energies and pathways provide promising explanations. Here this work assesses the current and future challenges faced by structural nuclear materials, identifying the specific applications in which HEAs may provide a competitive advantage compared to industry-standard materials with the aid of Ashby material selection maps. Considerations are provided for the design of future nuclear HEAs, including calculations of nuclear-relevant properties to assist in the initial down-selection of elements depending on application requirements (e.g., low neutron capture for in-core applications), narrowing the existing compositional space of HEAs to a manageable scope.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Laser Powder Bed Fusion Additive Manufacture Nb1Zr Development

Next generation fission and fusion nuclear reactors require materials that can withstand operating temperatures greater than 500 °C, neutron irradiation doses of up to 200 displacements per atom (dpa), and potentially corrosive coolants such as the alkali liquid metals sodium, lithium, and NaK (Na33K eutectic alloy). Refractory alloys, such as Nb1Zr (Nb-1wt%Zr) and Molybdenum alloy TZM (Mo-0.5wt%Ti-0.08wt%Zr) have been traditionally considered viable candidates for advanced fission and fusion reactor concepts. However, it is relatively difficult to generate complex geometries of interest from these alloys using traditional manufacturing methods. In addition, there needs to be a concentrated effort to address refractory metal challenges at elevated temperature operation. In order to generate complex geometries of interest, modern manufacturing techniques are considered to increase the technological readiness level (TRL), cost-effectiveness, and schedule savings. This work focused on the continued development of laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) additive manufacturing (AM) to improve both design flexibility, evaluate microstructure and properties, and ultimately accelerate the TRL and qualification of these processes and alloys for components to potentially be put into service. Niobium alloy Nb1Zr was identified through a down-selection process outlined in previous reports as a candidate to develop in L-PBF AM. Historically, Nb1Zr had been explored for high temperature fast spectrum fission reactors for both terrestrial and space applications. Molybdenum alloy TZM has also been considered for these reactor concepts due to exceptional high-temperature strength, creep resistance, and stability under irradiation. L-PBF AM of TZM has previously been investigated at LANL under the Microreactor program, NASA, ORNL, and in academia. However, due to the crack prone nature of TZM, L-PBF AM of TZM resulted in significant microcracking and additional development is required to pursue viable maturation. Other AM methods have been found to be more successful in printing TZM, and those alternatives approaches are discussed in this effort. The efforts detailed in this report focused on continued development of Nb1Zr through L-PBF and development of TZM via L-PBF and electron powder bed fusion (E-PBF). The objective of this work was to further the development of these AM techniques for the chosen refractory alloys, elucidating and addressing associated challenges through characterization of several demonstration builds. At LANL, Nb1Zr builds were completed using an EOS M290 and M400 machines, and a refractory alloy-dedicated L-PBF system, the Xact Metal XM200G, was installed. The XM200G primary purpose was to do the Nb1Zr parameter development process; however, due to difficulties associated with the machine installation and qualification process, it was decided to pivot development to the larger M400 and M290 machines. Although the supply of Nb1Zr powder was limited, it was sufficient to generate sub-scale metallographic specimens for the purpose of parameter development. This was first accomplished on the EOS M400 then the M290 due to machine schedule availability. Further development of TZM has been initiated at the University of Texas El Paso (UTEP) under contract with LANL to use both a heated build envelope L-PBF machine and E-PBF machine that have been found in the literature to mitigate microcracking. UTEP was provided with TZM powder and build plates to support parallel TZM parameter development across both machines. As part of the contract, UTEP will also be conducting microstructural characterization once optimized process parameters have been identified. The optimized process parameters for each machine will be used to generate a series of metallographic, mechanical, and surface finish specimens for subsequent characterization and testing. In the next section, we provide a detailed discussion of the methodology used for investigating the feasibility of leveraging these alloys for use in advanced reactor applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Anisotropic superconductivity of niobium based on its response to nonmagnetic disorder

Niobium is one of the most studied superconductors, both theoretically and experimentally. It is tremendously important for applications, and it has the highest superconducting transition temperature, T c = 9.32 K, of all pure metals. In addition to power applications in alloys, pure niobium is used for sensitive magnetosensing, radio-frequency cavities, and, more recently, as circuit metallization layers in superconducting qubits. A detailed understanding of its electronic and superconducting structure, especially its normal and superconducting state anisotropies, is crucial for mitigating the loss of quantum coherence in such devices. Recently, a microscopic theory of the anisotropic properties of niobium with the disorder was put forward. To verify theoretical predictions, we studied the effect of disorder produced by 3.5 MeV proton irradiation of thin Nb films grown by the same team and using the same protocols as those used in transmon qubits. By measuring the superconducting transition temperature and upper critical fields, we show a clear suppression of T c by potential (nonmagnetic) scattering, which is directly related to the anisotropic order parameter. Here, we obtain a very close quantitative agreement between the theory and the experiment.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2023

Novel materials irradiation and pre-characterization plans for high-power targetry applications

The multi-megawatt proton beams that will be employed at future accelerator complexes introduce many new challenges for next-generation targetry systems, primarily due to the increased levels of beam-induced radiation damage combined with thermal shock effects during a beam pulse. Novel material classes, such as high-entropy alloys and electro-spun nanofibers are currently being investigated as materials that will be more tolerant of these effects in high beam power applications. Low-energy ion irradiation will be used for pre-screening and down selecting candidate novel materials prior to prototypic high-energy irradiation studies. Specific nano and micro-scale characterization techniques will be used to evaluate the radiation damage and thermal shock resistance of the new materials. Irradiation induced lattice spacing alteration and defect concentrations, as well as mechanical and thermal properties of the novel materials will be measured and compared to those of conventional targetry materials. This poster will detail plans for initial low-energy ion irradiation tests, and the post-irradiation examination techniques that will be used to develop and screen these novel target materials.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗
DOE OSTI2023

Ion-Selective Scattering Studied Using the Variable-Energy Electron Irradiation in the Ba 0.2 K 0.8 Fe 2 As 2 Superconductor

Low-temperature variable-energy electron irradiation was used to induce non-magnetic disorder in a single crystal of a hole-doped iron-based superconductor, Ba $1-x$ K $x$ Fe 2 As 2 , $x$ = 0.80. To avoid systematic errors, the beam energy was adjusted non-consequently for five values between 1.0 and 2.5 MeV when sample resistance was measured in situ at 22 K. For all energies, the resistivity raises linearly with the irradiation fluence suggesting the creation of uncorrelated dilute point-like disorder (confirmed by simulations). The rate of the resistivity increase peaks at energies below 1.5 MeV. Comparison with calculated partial cross-sections points to the predominant creation of defects in the iron sublattice. Simultaneously, superconducting $T_c$, measured separately between the irradiation runs, is monotonically suppressed as expected, since it depends on the total scattering rate, hence on the total cross-section, which is a monotonically increasing function of the energy. Our work experimentally confirms an often-made assumption of the dominant role of the iron sub-lattice in iron-based superconductors.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Measuring sub-surface spatially varying thermal conductivity of silicon implanted with krypton

The thermal properties of semiconductors following exposure to ion irradiation are of great interest for the cooling of electronic devices; however, gradients in composition and structure due to irradiation often make the measurement difficult. Furthermore, the nature of spatial variations in thermal resistances due to spatially varying ion irradiation damage is not well understood. In this work, we develop an advancement in the analysis of time-domain thermoreflectance to account for spatially varying thermal conductivity in a material resulting from a spatial distribution of defects. We then use this method to measure the near-surface (≲1 μm) thermal conductivity of silicon wafers irradiated with Kr + ions, which has an approximate Gaussian distribution centered 260 nm into the sample. Our numerical analysis presented here allows for the spatial gradient of thermal conductivity to be extracted via what is fundamentally a volumetric measurement technique. We validate our findings via transmission electron microscopy, which is able to confirm the spatial variation of the sub-surface silicon structure, and provide additional insight into the local structure resulting from the effects of ion bombardment. Thermal measurements found the ion stopping region to have a nearly 50x reduction in thermal conductivity as compared to pristine silicon, while TEM showed the region was not fully amorphized. Our results suggest this drastic reduction in silicon thermal conductivity is primarily driven by structural defects in crystalline regions along with boundary scattering between amorphous and crystalline regions, with a negligible contribution being due to implanted krypton ions themselves.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Parametric Optimization of Nanostructured Alumina Forming Austenitic Alloys

Alumina-forming austenitic (AFA) alloys provide excellent oxidation resistance through the formation of a stable alumina scale, but their relatively high Ni content might limit application in core structural components because of helium generation and swelling under irradiation. Increasing the density of nanoscale features in the microstructure is a promising route to improve sink strength and mitigate these effects. Conventional oxide dispersion–strengthened (ODS) steels achieve this through mechanical alloying (MA), but the approach is costly and difficult to scale. In this milestone, additive manufacturing was applied as an alternative pathway to fabricate nanostructured AFA (NAFA) alloys with dual precipitation of oxides and nitrides enabled by reactive atmosphere processing. In FY25, two compositions, NAFA-1 (AFA-05) and NAFA-2, were produced and compared. Both alloys achieved densities above 99% of theoretical values, but NAFA-2 exhibited microcracking associated with Nb-rich intermetallic formation, indicating the need for further chemistry optimization. Nitrogen and oxygen uptake was confirmed on selected builds, demonstrating the intended dual-precipitate dispersion. Mechanical testing showed that AM-processed NAFA alloys exceed conventionally produced ODS steels in high-temperature tensile strength and fracture toughness. Preliminary Cu ion irradiation results further suggest improved resistance compared to wrought austenitic alloys. While the current alloys are promising for their compatibility in high-temperature air or liquid Pb environments, modifications to composition will be required for long-term operation in high-temperature impure sodium systems. Future work will focus on refining alloy chemistry to suppress laser powder bed fusion–induced cracking and scaling production to reactor-relevant dimensions using directed energy deposition as a pathway toward net-shape cladding fabrication.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Enhancement of the Curie temperature in single-crystalline ferromagnetic LaCrGe 3 by electron irradiation-induced disorder

LaCrGe 3 has attracted attention as a potential candidate for studies of quantum phase transitions in a ferromagnetic material. The application of pressure avoids a quantum critical point by developing a new magnetic phase. It was suggested that the disorder may provide an alternative route to a quantum critical point. We used low-temperature 2.5 MeV electron irradiation to induce relatively small amounts of pointlike disorder in single crystals of LaCrGe 3 . Irradiation leads to an increase of the resistivity at all temperatures with some deviation from the Matthiessen rule. Hall effect measurements show that electron irradiation does not cause any detectable change in the carrier density. Unexpectedly, the Curie temperature, T FM , increases with the increase of disorder from approximately 90 K in pristine samples up to nearly 100 K in the heavily irradiated sample, with a tendency towards saturation at higher doses. This effect is observed both in resistivity and magnetization measurements. Although the mechanism of this effect is not entirely clear, we conclude that it cannot be caused by effective “doping” or “pressure” due to electron irradiation. Finally, we suggest that disorder-induced broadening of a sharp peak in the density of states, D⁡(E), situated at E p = E F – 0.25 eV below the Fermi energy, E F , causes an increase in D⁡(E F ), leading to an enhancement of T FM in this itinerant ferromagnet.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2022

Possible unconventional pairing in ( Ca , Sr ) 3 ( Ir , Rh ) 4 Sn 13 superconductors revealed by controlling disorder

Here we study the evolution of temperature-dependent resistivity with added pointlike disorder induced by 2.5 MeV electron irradiation in stoichiometric compositions of the “3-4-13” stannides, (Ca,Sr) 3 (Ir,Rh) 4 Sn 13 . Three of these cubic compounds exhibit a proposed microscopic coexistence of charge density wave (CDW) order and superconductivity (SC), while Ca 3 Rh 4 Sn 13 does not develop CDW order. As expected, the CDW transition temperature T CDW is universally suppressed by irradiation in all three compositions. The superconducting transition temperature, T c , behaves in a more complex manner. In Sr 3 Rh 4 Sn 13 , it increases initially in a way consistent with a direct competition of CDW and SC, but quickly saturates at higher irradiation doses. In the other three compounds, T c is monotonically suppressed by irradiation. The strongest suppression is found in Ca 3 Rh 4 Sn 13 , which does not have CDW order. We further examine this composition by measuring the London penetration depth λ(T), from which we derive the superfluid density. The result unambiguously points to a weak-coupling, full single gap, isotropic superconducting state. Therefore we must explain two seemingly incompatible experimental observations: a single isotropic superconducting gap and a significant suppression of T c by nonmagnetic disorder. We conduct a quantitative theoretical analysis based on a generalized Anderson theorem which points to an unconventional multiband s +– -pairing state where the sign of the order parameter is different on one (or a small subset) of the smaller Fermi surface sheets but remains isotropic and overall fully gapped.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗