Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “LINER”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,405 records · Page 78
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS2018

Measurement of Noise Reduction from Acoustic Casing Treatments Installed Over a Subscale High Bypass Ratio Turbofan Rotor

NASA is continuing to develop over-the-rotor acoustic liners for turbofan applications. A series of low Technology Readiness Level experiments were conducted to better understand the acoustic and aerodynamic effects of these acoustic liners. The final experiment included the evaluation of four acoustic casing treatment concepts and two baseline configurations in an internal flow axial compressor facility with a 1.5 pressure-ratio high-bypass turbofan rotor. An inlet in-duct array was utilized to extract sound power levels propagating forward from the turbofan rotor. The effect of a circumferentially grooved relative to a hardwall fan case was found to reduce the in-duct sound power level by about 1.5dB for frequencies less than 2kHz while increasing noise from 4 to 8kHz by as much as 7.5dB at low fan speeds. The four acoustic treatment concepts were incorporated into the bottoms of the circumferential grooves and found to provide an additional 1 to 2dB sound power level reduction under 2kHz. The sound power level reduction was found to be even greater, 2.5 to 3.5dB, when evaluating the reduction on rotor alone duct modes (co-rotating modes). The acoustic treatments also appeared to reduce multiple pure tone noise at transonic fan speeds. Depending on the acoustic treatment concept, the high-frequency noise created by the circumferential grooves was reduced by 1.5 to 5 dB. The total noise reduction from acoustic treatments embedded into the bottoms of circumferential grooves relative to a hardwall baseline was found to be 2.5 to 3.5dB sound power level. The sound power level reduction for rotor alone (co-rotating) modes was found to be 3.5 to 4.5dB. These results show the potential for significant turbofan noise reduction by incorporating acoustic treatments over-the-rotor.

Aeroacoustics↗
NASA NTRS2018

Channel Wall Nozzle Manufacturing and Hot-Fire Testing using a Laser Wire Deposition Closeout Technique for Liquid Rocket Engines

A regeneratively-cooled nozzle for liquid rocket engine applications is a significant cost of the overall engine due to the complexities of manufacturing a large thin-walled structure that must operate in extreme temperature and pressure environments. NASA has been investigating and advancing methods for fabrication of liquid rocket engine channel wall nozzles to realize further cost and schedule improvements. The methods being evaluated are targeting increased scale required for current NASA and commercial space programs. Several advanced rapid fabrication methods are being investigated for forming of the inner liner, producing the coolant channels, closeout of the coolant channels, and fabrication of the manifolds. NASA Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) completed process development and subscale hot-fire testing of a series of these advanced fabrication channel wall nozzle technologies to gather performance data in a relevant environment. The primary fabrication technique being discussed in this paper is Laser Wire Deposition Closeout (LWDC). This process has been developed to significantly reduce time required for closeouts of regeneratively-cooled slotted liners. It allows for channel closeout to be formed in place in addition to the structural jacket without the need for channel fillers or complex tooling. Additional technologies were also tested as part of this program including water jet milling and arc-based additive manufacturing deposition. Each nozzle included different fabrication features, materials, and methods to demonstrate durability in a hot-fire environment. The results of design, fabrication and hot-fire testing performance is discussed in this paper.

Gradl, Paul R.↗
NASA NTRS2018

Channel Wall Nozzle Manufacturing and Hot-Fire Testing Using a Laser Wire Direct Closeout Technique for Liquid Rocket Engines

A regeneratively-cooled nozzle for liquid rocket engine applications is a significant cost of the overall engine due to the complexities of manufacturing a large thin-walled structure that must operate in extreme temperature and pressure environments. The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) has been investigating and advancing methods for fabrication of liquid rocket engine channel wall nozzles to realize further cost and schedule improvements over traditional techniques. The methods being evaluated are targeting increased scale required for current NASA and commercial space programs. Several advanced rapid fabrication methods are being investigated for forming of the inner liner, producing the coolant channels, closeout of the coolant channels, and fabrication of the manifolds. NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) has completed process development and subscale hot-fire testing of a series of these advanced fabrication channel wall nozzle technologies to gather performance data in a relevant environment. The primary fabrication technique being discussed in this paper is Laser Wire Direct Closeout (LWDC). This process has been developed to significantly reduce the time required for closeouts of regeneratively-cooled slotted liners. It allows for channel closeout to be formed in place in addition to the structural jacket without the need for channel fillers or complex tooling. Additional technologies were also tested as part of this program including water jet milling and arc-based additive manufacturing deposition. Each nozzle included different fabrication features, materials, and methods to demonstrate durability in a hot-fire environment. The results of design, fabrication, and hot-fire testing are discussed in this paper.

Gradl, Paul R.↗
NASA NTRS2016

Design of a Two-Stage Light Gas Gun for Muzzle Velocities of 10 - 11 km/s

Space debris poses a major risk to spacecraft. In low earth orbit, impact velocities can be 10 - 11 km/s and as high as 15 km/s. For debris shield design, it would be desirable to be able to launch projectiles of known shape and mass to these velocities. The design of the proposed 10 - 11 km/sec gun uses, as a starting point, the Ames 1.28”/0.22” two stage gun, which has achieved muzzle velocities of 10 - 11.3 km/sec. That gun is scaled up to a 0.3125” launch tube diameter. The gun is then optimized with respect to maximum pressures by varying the pump tube length to diameter ratio (L/D), the piston mass and the hydrogen pressure. A pump tube L/D of 36.4 is selected giving the best overall performance. Piezometric ratios for the optimized guns are found to be ~2.3, much more favorable than for more traditional two stage light gas guns, which range from 4 to 6. (The piezometric ratio for a gun is defined as the maximum projectile base pressure divided by the constant projectile base pressure which, acting over the entire barrel length, would produce the same muzzle velocity.) The maximum powder chamber pressures are 20 to 30 ksi. To reduce maximum pressures, the desirable range of the included angle of the cone of the high pressure coupling is found to be 7.3 to 14.6 degrees. Lowering the break valve rupture pressure is found to lower the maximum projectile base pressure, but to raise the maximum gun pressure. For the optimized gun with a pump tube L/D of 36.4, increasing the muzzle velocity by decreasing the projectile mass and increasing the powder loads is studied. It appears that saboted spheres could be launched to 10.25 and possibly as high as 10.8 km/sec, and that disc-like plastic models could be launched to 11.05 km/s. The use of a tantalum liner to greatly reduce bore erosion and increase muzzle velocity is discussed. With a tantalum liner, CFD code calculations predict muzzle velocities as high as 12 to 13 km/s.

Bogdanoff, David W.↗
NASA NTRS2019

Progress in Additively Manufactured Copper-Alloy GRCop-84, GRCop-42, and Bimetallic Combustion Chambers for Liquid Rocket Engines

Additive Manufacturing (AM) has significantly evolved over the last decade for use in the aerospace industry, particularly for liquid rocket engines. AM offers a considerable departure from traditional manufacturing to rapidly fabricate components with complex internal features. High performance liquid rocket engine combustion chambers that operate in a high heat flux environment are fabricated using a copper-alloy liner with a series of integral coolant channels. Copper-alloys provide the necessary conductivity and material strength for adequate design margins offering high performance without the need for film coolant. Copper-alloys present unique challenges to properly melt the powder in laser-based AM processes due to their high reflectivity and conductivity. Starting in 2014, NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC) and Glenn Research Center (GRC) have developed a process for AM of GRCop (Copper- Chrome-Niobium) alloys using Selective Laser Melting (SLM). GRCop, originally developed at GRC, is a high conductivity, high-strength, dispersion strengthened copper-alloy for use in high-temperature, high heat flux applications. NASA has completed significant material characterization and testing, along with hot-fire testing, to demonstrate that GRCop-42 and GRCop-84 alloys are suitable for use in combustion chambers. Additional development and testing has been completed on AM bimetallic chambers using GRCop-84 liners and superalloy jackets, fabricated using two Directed Energy Deposition (DED) processes: Electron Beam Freeform Fabrication (EBF³) and Blown Powder DED. NASA completed hot-fire testing on various AM chambers using GRCop-84, GRCop-42, and bimetallic chambers in Liquid Oxygen (LOX)/Hydrogen, LOX/Methane, and LOX/Kerosene propellants.

Gradl, Paul R.↗
NASA NTRS2019

Channel Wall Nozzle Manufacturing Technology Advancements for Liquid Rocket Engines

A regeneratively-cooled nozzle is a critical component for expansion of the hot gases to enable high temperature and performance liquid rocket engines systems. Channel wall nozzles are a design solution used across the propulsion industry as a simplified method to fabricate the nozzle structure with internal coolant passages. The scale and complexity of the channel wall nozzle (CWN) design is challenging to fabricate leading to extended lead times and higher costs. Some of these challenges include: 1) unique and high temperature materials, 2) Tight tolerances during manufacturing and assembly to contain high pressure propellants, 3) thin-walled features to maintain adequate wall temperatures, and 4) Unique manufacturing process operations and tooling. The United States (U.S.) National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) along with U.S. specialty manufacturing vendors are maturing modern fabrication techniques to reduce complexity and decrease costs associated with channel wall nozzle manufacturing technology. Additive Manufacturing (AM) is one of the key technology advancements being evaluated for channel wall nozzles. Much of additive manufacturing for propulsion components has focused on powder bed fusion, but the scale is not yet feasible for application to large scale nozzles. NASA is evolving directed energy deposition (DED) techniques for nozzles including arc-based deposition, blown powder deposition, and Laser Wire Direct Closeout (LWDC). There are different approaches being considered for fabrication of the nozzle and each of these DED processes offer unique process steps for rapid fabrication. The arc-based and blown powder deposition techniques are being used for the forming of the CWN liner. A variety of materials are being demonstrated including Inconel 625, Haynes 230, JBK-75, and NASA HR-1. The blown powder DED process is also being demonstrated for forming an integral channel nozzle in a single operation in similar materials. The LWDC process is a method for closing out the channels within the liner and forming the structural jacket using a localized laser wire deposition technique. Identical materials mentioned above have been used for this process in addition to bimetallic closeout (C-18150–SS347, and C-18150–Inconel 625). NASA has completed process development, material characterization, and hot-fire testing on a variety of these channel wall nozzle fabrication techniques. This paper will present an overview of the various processes and materials being evaluated and the results from the hot-fire testing. Future development and technology focus areas will also be discussed relative to channel wall nozzle manufacturing.

Gradl, Paul R.↗
NASA NTRS2010

TPSAS-NF1676L-10636-DND

A new impedance eduction technique that is void of microphones in the liner test section has been developed. The new impedance eduction technique is ideally suited for curved ducts. When used with synthesized data, the new technique is as robust as the one requiring the use of wall mounted microphones in the liner test section

Willie R Watson↗
NASA NTRS2020

Technology Advancements for Channel Wall Nozzle Manufacturing In Liquid Rocket Engines

A regeneratively-cooled or dump-cooled nozzle is a critical component for expansion of hot gases to enable high temperature and performance in liquid rocket engines systems. Regeneratively-cooled channel wall nozzles are a design solution used across the propulsion industry as a simplified method to fabricate the nozzle structure with internal coolant passages. The scale and complexity of the channel wall nozzle (CWN) design can be challenging to fabricate which results in extended lead times and higher costs. Some of these challenges include: 1) Unique and high temperature materials, 2) Tight tolerances on large parts during manufacturing and assembly to contain high pressure propellants, 3) Thin-walled features to maintain adequate wall temperatures, and 4) Unique manufacturing process operations and complex tooling. The United States (U.S.) National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) and U.S. specialty manufacturing vendors are maturing modern fabrication techniques to reduce complexity and decrease costs associated with channel wall nozzle manufacturing technology. Additive Manufacturing (AM) is one of the key technology advancements under evaluation for channel wall nozzles. Much of additive manufacturing for propulsion components has focused on laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF), but the scale is not yet feasible for application to large scale nozzles. NASA is evolving directed energy deposition (DED) techniques for nozzles including arc-based deposition, blown powder deposition, and Laser Wire Direct Closeout (LWDC). There are different approaches being considered for fabrication of the nozzle, and each of these DED processes offer unique process steps for rapid fabrication. The arc-based and blown powder deposition techniques are used for the forming of the CWN liner. A variety of materials are being demonstrated including Inconel 625, Haynes 230, JBK-75, and NASA HR-1. The blown powder DED process is also being demonstrated for forming an integral channel nozzle in a single operation in similar materials. The LWDC process is a method for closing out the channels within the liner and forming the structural jacket using a localized laser wire deposition technique. Identical materials mentioned above have been used for this process in addition to bimetallic closeout (C-18150–SS347, and C-18150–Inconel 625). NASA has completed process development, material characterization, and hot-fire testing on a variety of these channel wall nozzle fabrication technique. This publication presents an overview of the various channel wall nozzle manufacturing processes and materials under evaluation including results from the hot-fire testing. Future development and technology focus areas is also discussed relative to channel wall nozzle manufacturing.

Additive manufacturing↗
NASA NTRS2020

Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessel (COPV) Damage Tolerance Life Analysis Methodology and Test Best Practices

The NASA Engineering and Safety Center (NESC) Deputy Director requested an independent assessment to develop data to understand the limitations of linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM) computational methods used to predict fatigue crack growth rate (da/dN) behavior of small detectable cracks in thin metal liners for composite overwrapped pressure vessels (COPVs). The NESC assessment team was also requested to demonstrate a test-based methodology for validating damage tolerance requirements for COPVs with elastically responding metal liners where LEFM methods are not appropriate. This report contains the outcome of the NESC assessment.

Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessels; Linear Ela↗
NASA NTRS2020

Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessel (COPV) Damage Tolerance Life Analysis Methodology and Test Best Practices: Appendices

The NASA Engineering and Safety Center (NESC) Deputy Director requested an independent assessment to develop data to understand the limitations of linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM) computational methods used to predict fatigue crack growth rate (da/dN) behavior of small detectable cracks in thin metal liners for composite overwrapped pressure vessels (COPVs). The NESC assessment team was also requested to demonstrate a test-based methodology for validating damage tolerance requirements for COPVs with elastically responding metal liners where LEFM methods are not appropriate. This document contains the appendices to the main report.

Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessels; Linear Ela↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Fan Acoustic Flight Effects on the PAA & ASN Flight Test

Accurate and reliable prediction of noise emitted from turbofan aircraft engines is an ongoing challenge. For continued progress, it is necessary to assess the performance of the most recent prediction methods in the NASA Aircraft NOise Prediction Program (ANOPP), and to examine the effects of flight condition on fan noise. The assessment is based on an extensive acoustic dataset acquired as part of the Propulsion Airframe Aeroacoustics and Aircraft System Noise (PAA&ASN) Flight Test conducted on a Boeing 787-10 aircraft. Engine operating condition was varied to study the characteristics of fan noise in flight. In a subset of the flight test matrix, the influence of the aft duct acoustic liner was studied by covering the lined area with aluminum tape to simulate a hardwall duct. The combination of test data at different flight conditions, along with rigorous predictions of jet noise, is used in this paper to extract fan noise from the measured total aircraft noise levels. The measured fan noise levels are compared with those predicted using the latest methods for fan source noise, liner attenuation, and PAA effect prediction. Detailed analyses are undertaken to understand agreement between data and various aspects of the prediction models, including spectral shape, directivity, and response to throttle setting. An additional investigation was undertaken to study the effect of aircraft speed on fan noise, as current models do not directly account for this parameter.

Aircraft System Noise↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Validation of Noise Propagation for Lined Inlets

Commercial finite element modeling tools are validated for use on inlet radiated noise predictions for an acoustically lined subsonic aircraft inlet tested in the NASA Glenn 9-foot by 15-foot low-speed wind tunnel. An in-depth review and prediction of the acoustic liner properties on the Advanced Ducted Propulsor were conducted for use in the noise predictions. Agreement between the inlet radiated noise predictions to the measured tones at approach was used as the validation for the prediction tools. Similar follow-up predictions were conducted for an acoustically lined supersonic inlet. A follow-up investigation on the effect of the acoustic liner placement within the supersonic inlet was undertaken.

Acoustics↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Expanding the Capability of A Legacy Combustion Flametube to Test High Temperature Engine Materials in Relevant Environments

New materials and component designs are needed to advance gas turbine engine technology and provide the performance and efficiency needs for future applications. In order to advance these materials, testing in combustion environments is a critical step prior to engine testing. In this work, we detail the design and the fabrication of a materials test sector in a flametube combustor facility. The facility simulates a combustion environment similar to that experienced by components in gas turbine engines. The flow regime is characterized by a combination of high-temperature, high-velocity, high-heat flux, and high-velocity that components experience in gas turbine engines. Exposure of components in this facility allows for the study of combined environmental effects and the impact on both coating and substrate durability. The test facility may operate across a wide range of pressures from 275-400 psig (1,896-2,758 kPa) and an air flow rate of 5 lb/s (2.27 kg/s). While combustion gas temperature is expected in excess of 3,000°F (1,649°C), 900°F (482°C) cooling air may be supplied to the backside of components or test articles. The flametube combustor was previously used to evaluate fuel injectors and combustion products, and the new test configuration will also allow for materials exposure to complex, engine-like conditions. The interior of the Test Section was additively manufactured from GRCop-84 and cryogenically fit and brazed to a stainless steel 304 housing. The use of a copper liner minimizes welds and with active cooling, is expected to provide better durability over traditional hardware using stainless steel or Inconel with a ceramic liner. The Test Section has two opposing removable windows approximately 230 mm x 80 mm that can accommodate articles up to 85 mm tall. This modular design allows for custom platforms to hold coupons, panels, or airfoil shapes to be tested with minimal re-engineering or fabrication. The bolted joint and sealing remains consistent, so any new testing only needs to work within the existing design footprint. This paper will provide an overview of the facility capabilities, design considerations, as well as thermal and structural analysis of the hardware. Future testing of ceramic matrix composite (CMC) airfoils and advanced environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) will also be discussed.

Combustion↗
NASA NTRS2024

Background Turbulence Characterization of the Curved Duct Test Rig

Interest in applying acoustic treatment to nontraditional locations of turbofan engines has led to recent testing of acoustically treated airfoils in the NASA Langley Curved Duct Test Rig. Current testing focuses only on sound attenuation by the sample when exposed to an incident sound field driven by a loudspeaker array. However, there may be much to gain from an aeroacoustic study of the interaction of turbulence with treated airfoils, especially in the case of acoustically treated outlet guide vane designs. Thus, the intent of this study is to take the first step in assessing the aeroacoustic quality of the NASA Langley Curved Duct Test Rig (typically only used for grazing flow studies) by examining the flow quality. The background turbulence levels are measured using hot-wire anemometry just upstream of the test section. Measurements indicate that the turbulence intensity is less than 0.3% in the core region of the flow. The autospectral densities show cavity tones and weak vortex shedding present in the core. The vortex shedding is determined to be from the upstream total pressure probe used to determine flow speed. The cavity tones are found to be the fundamental and harmonic frequencies of a porous ceramic tubular acoustic liner sample that separates the acoustic drivers from the flow region. Recommendations for improving the aeroacoustic quality of the tunnel are provided, such as removing the upstream probe and redesigning the ceramic tubular liner. Future acoustic characterization of the background levels is also recommended to further understand the feasibility of aeroacoustic studies in CDTR.

Wind Tunnel Characterization↗
NASA NTRS2024

Hybrid Thermally Efficient Core (HyTEC) HyTEC Phase 1 – Combustor Final Report

The objective of the HyTEC – Combustor Technology project is to develop technology for a compact, low emissions, rich-burn combustor that maintains a high-level of durability. To accomplish this, the combustor will incorporate CMC liners and a CMC Dome to enable improved air utilization for mixing and NOx reduction. In particular, three technology areas were matured: metallic swirler attachment to the CMC dome, Nickel diffusion in CMC, and EBC advancements with improved durability. The maturation of these technology areas is critical to successfully designing a combustor for an engine intended to demonstrate increased thermal efficiency with integrated high-power density-core engine technologies. As part of the project, multiple swirler attachment architectures were matured through the design process, manufactured, and tested in simulated engine conditions. These architectures utilized two different approaches to attachment: a pressure loaded approach and a clamped approach. Each approach required testing at simulated engine conditions to mature the technology. These tests were developed to ensure that the probable failure mechanisms for each architecture were assessed relative to its long-term durability. After successfully testing both approaches, the pressure loaded approach was chosen based on its simplicity and its similarity to the attachment approach used on lean burn combustors. Finally, this successful testing resulted in the swirler attachment technology achieving TRL 4 status. Another aspect of concern with the metallic swirler attachment is the potential for nickel diffusion into the CMC to cause durability shortfalls. A series of tests were completed to understand both the amount of nickel that is expected to diffuse into the CMC and the effect this diffusion will have on mechanical properties of the CMC. After successfully completing this testing, the reduction in local mechanical properties was found to not have an impact on the overall durability of the CMC Dome. To further improve the overall durability, three different EBC coating architectures were also studied. One of these coatings being the current state of the art for CMC liners with the other two being proposed improvements. Coupons were produced using each coating and subjected to a series of laboratory testing. One coating was found to have an overall superior durability in laboratory testing and survived rig testing without indication of degradation. This successful testing resulted in the EBC technology achieving TRL 5 status. Overall, a design approach was successfully down-selected that achieves both the TPM requirements and the need for TRL 4+ status. This design incorporates a pressure loaded swirler attachment with an improved EBC coating (Architecture 1). This combination allows the continued use of a CMC dome and results in an improved durability for the proposed compact core combustor.

CMC↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Beyond Guesswork: Code Verification for Acoustic Duct Mode Prediction

The code used in the work (Swirl) is a frequency-domain linearized Euler equation solver that is designed to predict the effect of acoustic liners on acoustic modes propagating in realistic sheared and swirling mean flows, guiding the design of more efficient liner configurations. The purpose of this study is to validate Swirl using the Method Of Manufactured Solutions (MMS). This study also investigated the effect of the integration and spatial differencing methods on the convergence for a given Manufactured Solution. In addition, the effect of boundary condition implementation was tested. Through rigorous validation of the Swirl code using the MMS, this research underscores the significance of integration and spatial differencing methods on convergence, evaluates boundary condition implementations, and systematically assesses the impact of various filters.

Code Verification↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

An Extension of the Truncated Ingard-Myers Impedance Boundary Condition for High Mach Number Grazing Flows

The Ingard-Myers impedance boundary condition is widely recognized to be prone to hydrodynamic Kelvin-Helmholtz-type instability, primarily due to its use of a vortex sheet to model the flow at the boundary. Recently, a stabilized approximation of the Ingard-Myers condition, called the Truncated Ingard-Myers Impedance Boundary Condition (TIMIBC), has been introduced. This approximation offers a good representation of the Ingard-Myers condition for grazing flows characterized by low to mid subsonic Mach numbers. This paper explores an extension of the TIMIBC, referred to as TIMIBC-ext, designed for liners in grazing flows with high subsonic Mach numbers. The TIMIBC-ext introduces a tunable parameter and demonstrates that by judiciously selecting the parameter value, the accuracy of the TIMIBC can be improved for either upstream or downstream propagating waves in grazing flows with high subsonic Mach numbers. Consequently, the TIMIBC-ext represents an enhancement to the TIMIBC when the location of the source relative to the liner (upstream or downstream) is known. Time domain implementations of the TIMIBC-ext are also provided, employing a multipole expansion model for the impedance function. A numerical example is provided to assess the performance of the TIMIBC-ext, comparing computational results with measurements from a recent set of measurements in the NASA Langley Grazing Flow Impedance Tube.

time domain acoustic scattering↗
DOE OSTI2014

Hanford Double-Shell Tank AY-102 Radioactive Waste Leak Investigation Update - 15302

Tank AY-102 was the first of 28 double-shell radioactive waste storage tanks constructed at the U. S. Department of Energy’s Hanford Site, near Richland, WA. The tank was completed in 1970, and entered service in 1971. In August, 2012, an accumulation of material was discovered at two sites on the floor of the annulus that separates the primary tank from the secondary liner. The material was sampled and determined to originate from the primary tank. This paper summarizes the changes in leak behavior that have occurred during the past two years, inspections to determine the capability of the secondary liner to continue safely containing the leakage, and the initial results of testing to determine the leak mechanism.

Washenfelder, D. J.↗