Comparison of the MCNP6 and FLUKA Codes in Shielding Calculation at ProNova Proton Therapy Facility
The Monte Carlo method is a powerful tool to simulate particle transport in materials, and can be effectively used to design radiation shielding. The purpose of this study is to compare the results from two Monte Carlo codes (MCNP6 and FLUKA ) in shielding design. The calculation was also compared with the measured results from the ProNova Superconducting 360 degrees (SC360) installation at the Knoxville Provision Center for Proton Therapy (PCPT) facility. The SC360 230 MeV continue wave (CW) proton beam is produced by an isochronous cyclotron, the Sumitomo P235. The maximum beam that is extracted into the beamline is 300 nA, which is of 60% of the full current generated in cyclotron. The SC360 facility has an energy selection system for adjusting the proton range, one fixed beam and one gantry room for rotating the beam around the stationary patient. At the entrance to each treatment room beamline, a thickness adjustable Beryllium degrader inserted in the beam path is used to achieve the desirable beam energy. When protons interact with beamline components, the secondary neutrons become the dominant source to determine the radiation shielding. In this study, the dose rate outside the lateral wall of the beamline vault was discussed. The calculations from two Monte Carlo codes were compared and they agreed very well. The dose rates measured by a Wendi-II Neutron Detector agreed within a factor of less than seven compared with the calculation results. The difference may be explained by a variety of factors such as the uncertainty in knowing the exact composition of shielding materials, geometry difference, and the measurement uncertainty due to instrumentation. (authors)