Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “PRESSURE VESSEL”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,351 records · Page 75

Progress Report on Alloy 617 Notched Specimen Testing

Creep behavior of Alloy 617 has been extensively characterized to support the development of a draft Code Case to qualify Alloy 617 in Section III division 5 of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code. This will allow use of Alloy 617 in construction of nuclear reactor components at elevated temperatures and longer periods of time (up to 950°C and 100,000 hours). Prior to actual use, additional concerns not considered in the ASME code need to be addressed. Code Cases are based largely on uniaxial testing of smooth gage specimens. In service conditions, components will generally be under multi axial loading. There is also the concern of the behavior at discontinuities, such as threaded components. To address the concerns of multi axial creep behavior and at geometric discontinuities, notched specimens have been designed to create conditions representative of the states that service components experience. Two general notch geometries have been used for these series of tests: U notch and V notch specimens. The notches produce a tri axial stress state, though not uniform across the specimen. Characterization of the creep behavior of the U notch specimens and the creep rupture behavior of the V notch specimens provides a good approximation of the behavior expected of actual components. Preliminary testing and analysis have been completed and are reported in this document. This includes results from V notch specimens tested at 900°C and 800°C. Failure occurred in the smooth gage section of the specimen rather than at the root of the notch, though some damage was present at the root of the notch, where initial stress was highest. This indicates notch strengthening behavior in this material at these temperatures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Nuclear Fuels & Materials Spotlight Volume 5

As the nation's nuclear energy laboratory, Idaho National Laboratory brings together talented people and specialized nuclear research capability to accomplish our mission. This edition of the Nuclear Fuels and Materials Division Spotlight provides an overview of some of our recent accomplishments in research and capability development. These accomplishments include: • Evaluation and modeling of light water reactor accident tolerant fuel concepts • Status and results of recent TRISO-coated particle fuel irradiations, post-irradiation examinations, high-temperature safety testing to demonstrate the accident performance of this fuel system, and advanced microscopy to improve the understanding of fission product transport in this fuel system. • Improvements in and applications of meso and engineering scale modeling of light water reactor fuel behavior under a range of operating conditions and postulated accidents (e.g., power ramping, loss of coolant accident, and reactivity initiated accidents) using the MARMOT and BISON codes. • Novel measurements of the properties of nuclear (actinide) materials under extreme conditions, (e.g. high pressure, low/high temperatures, high magnetic field) to improve the scientific understanding of these materials. • Modeling reactor pressure vessel behavior using the GRIZZLY code. • New methods using sound to sense temperature inside a reactor core. • Improved experimental capabilities to study the response of fusion reactor materials to a tritium plasma. Throughout Spotlight, you'll find examples of productive partnerships with academia, industry, and government agencies that deliver high-impact outcomes. The work conducted at Idaho National Laboratory helps spur innovation in nuclear energy applications that drive economic growth and energy security. We appreciate your interest in our work here at Idaho National Laboratory, and hope that you find this issue informative.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Report on the FY17 Development of Computer Program for ASME Section III, Division 5, Subsection HB, Subpart B Rules

One of the objectives of the high temperature design methodology activities is to develop and validate both improvements and the basic features of ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section III, Rules for Construction of Nuclear Facility Components, Division 5, High Temperature Reactors, Subsection HB, Subpart B (HBB). The overall scope of this task is to develop a computer program to aid assessment procedures of components under specified loading conditions in accordance with the elevated temperature design requirements for Division 5 Class A components. There are many features and alternative paths of varying complexity in HBB. The initial focus of this computer program is a basic path through the various options for a single reference material, 316H stainless steel. However, the computer program is being structured for eventual incorporation all of the features and permitted materials of HBB. This report will first provide a description of the overall computer program, particular challenges in developing numerical procedures for the assessment, and an overall approach to computer program development. This is followed by a more comprehensive appendix, which is the draft computer program manual for the program development. The strain limits rules have been implemented in the computer program. The evaluation of creep-fatigue damage will be implemented in future work scope.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Predictive characterization of aging and degradation of reactor materials in extreme environments. Final report, December 20, 2013 - September 20, 2017

Understanding of reactor material behavior in extreme environments is vital not only to the development of new materials for the next generation nuclear reactors, but also to the extension of the operating lifetimes of the current fleet of nuclear reactors. To this end, this project conducted a suite of unique experimental techniques, augmented by a mesoscale computational framework, to understand and predict the long-term effects of irradiation, temperature, and stress on material microstructures and their macroscopic behavior. The experimental techniques and computational tools were demonstrated on two distinctive types of reactor materials, namely, Zr alloys and high-Cr martensitic steels. These materials are chosen as the test beds because they are the archetypes of high-performance reactor materials (cladding, wrappers, ducts, pressure vessel, piping, etc.). To fill the knowledge gaps, and to meet the technology needs, a suite of innovative in situ transmission electron microscopy (TEM) characterization techniques (heating, heavy ion irradiation, He implantation, quantitative small-scale mechanical testing, and various combinations thereof) were developed and used to elucidate and map the fundamental mechanisms of microstructure evolution in both Zr and Cr alloys for a wide range environmental boundary conditions in the thermal-mechanical-irradiation input space. Knowledge gained from the experimental observations of the active mechanisms and the role of local microstructural defects on the response of the material has been incorporated into a mathematically rigorous and comprehensive three-dimensional mesoscale framework capable of accounting for the compositional variation, microstructural evolution and localized deformation (radiation damage) to predict aging and degradation of key reactor materials operating in extreme environments. Predictions from this mesoscale framework were compared with the in situ TEM observations to validate the model.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Validation Data Acquisition in HTTF during PCC Events

A validation experimental campaign was conducted in an Integral Effect Test (IET) facility of High Temperature Gas Reactors (HTGR), the High-Temperature Test Facility (HTTF) at Oregon State University (OSU). The HTTF simulates Depressurized and Pressurized Conduction Cooldowns (DCC and PCC). This campaign required the development of a new laser spectroscopic diagnostic to measure velocity in the challenging conditions of the HTTF: low speed (~1 m/s) gas flows at HTGR prototypical temperature and 1/10th pressure. This was a collaborative effort between co-PIs at The George Washington University (GW), Oregon State University (OSU), and NASA Langley Research Center. The main accomplishments of this project include the record for dynamic range for velocimetry, highest accuracy obtained with this technique, successful deployment in an IET leading to new validation matrix for CFD. These are detailed below and in manuscript appended to this executive summary. For this project, we introduced a new class of laser spectroscopic diagnostics to Thermal-Hydraulics to measure velocity of gases; furthermore, the diagnostic was demonstrated in-situ in an IET during DCC events. In such scenarios, particles used in mainstream techniques, like Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) are not appropriate as they settle down too rapidly and also contaminate the experimental facility. Molecular tracers stay mixed within the working gas and can seed the flow in a technique called Molecular Tagging Velocimetry (MTV). In MTV a molecular tracer is photo-dissociated by a first (write) laser into radicals or molecules. The pattern created by the write laser is then interrogated with planar laser-induced fluorescence (PLIF), the read pulse(s), which are recorded with a camera. The pattern is probed and matched at two times (interval or probe time, dt), resulting in a time-of-flight velocimetry technique. This project demonstrated a new application range for MTV in gases. MTV has been extensively used for high-speed gas dynamics: molecules do not suffer from inertia associated with particles in regions of high accelerations (such as shock waves). For high-speed flows, the probe time is on the order of 0.1-10 µs. In time-of-flight techniques, the velocity is reconstructed from the recorded displacement, dx, between time interval dt: U = dx/dt. To first order, the resolution of the pattern matching is typically a (fixed) fraction of a pixel; therefore the resolution of the velocity measurement increases with dx and, for a given flow velocity, dt. For the low-speed flows of interest here, this requires long probe time, and therefore finding tracers that are stable for a long time. After an extensive literature survey we identified 6 tracers that would be suitable. We also worked with Spectra Physics to design a custom laser system that is flexible enough to probe these various tracers. The final instrument is made of 4 lasers that are integrated into a compact and movable cart to facilitate the deployment of the instrument off-site. One unique aspect of the laser system is the tunable dye laser (needed to do PLIF of the radicals). By being pumped by two Nd:YAG lasers, this laser is able to provide two pulses with any probe time (dt) for wavelengths between 200 and 900 nm with a linewidth of 3 pm. Accommodating the dual-pulse capability required customizing the pump lasers and the dye laser, making this system unique. Additionally, a custom UV-intensified CCD camera capable of frame-straddling and exposure time as short as 10 ns was acquired. More than two-third of the instrument cost (~$200k) was covered by a cost sharing from the PI’s startup funds. Of the 6 potential tracers identified, two were tested extensively (H2O and N2O) at high-temperature and elevated pressure at GW prior to conducting the tests at OSU. For both tracers, an Ar-F laser (193 nm, 10 ns, 10 mJ/pulse) photo-dissociates trace amounts (0.1 – 5% molar fraction) of the gases into OH and NO. OH is probed at 281.905 nm and NO at 226.186 nm (4-30mJ, 10 ns pulse). NO is very stable in inert environment and we could reconstruct velocities precisely with probe delay times as long at 40 ms, compared to 2 ms for OH, resulting in increased precision. Therefore, for the tests in the HTTF, N2O was selected as the final tracer and its optimal concentration was determined to be 0.5% molar. In the GW laboratory, we obtained a velocity measurement precision of 4 mm/s at conditions mimicking the HTTF tests. We also demonstrated the benefit of molecular tracers over particles and the flexibility of our instrument by continuously measuring velocity from 1000 to 0.1 m/s in a blow down test. This represents a dynamic range on velocity of 80 dB, which is unprecedented for velocimetry! Once the diagnostic was optimized, two two-week campaigns were conducted in the HTTF. This experimental campaign required numerous practical solutions to successfully and rapidly deploy this very sensitive table-top diagnostic in-situ. This was accomplished thanks to very extensive planning from all parties involved in the project. Due to constraints on availability of the HTTF, only adiabatic DCC tests were conducted. Specifically, the velocity was measured at the exit of the hot leg into the Reactor Cavity Simulation Tank (RCST). We were able to record the gas velocity associated with the air ingress for long times (up to one hour). Depending on the initial conditions (density of the gases in the Reactor Pressure Vessel and the RCST) the lock exchange lasted 30-60 s past the valve openings. Large vortices were identified within the shear layer at the interface of the cross flow. These vortices are an indication of shear-driven instability between the counter streams of different density. After the lock-exchange, a small residual flow was still present and its strength decayed exponentially. It finds its source in a buoyancy difference between the gases in both vessels due to the mixing and diffusion of the gases in the cross-over duct and the RPV lower plenum. We did not expect to capture this part of the transient, which would have been less significant (if not negligible) in the presence of a heated core; the precision of our measurement in the HTTF was 6 mm/s, which exceeded our expectations for such a complex test! Using commercial software (Fluent) we simulated the experiment with Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) using Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) turbulence models. We were not able to accurately reproduce the shear layer instability, mixing, and diffusion captured in our experimental data, even with large 3D meshes (>10 M points). We attributed this to the inadequacy of the RANS models for the flow of interest: our experimental Reynolds number was too low and was outside the applicability range of the RANS models. Instead, we should have employed CFD with less modeling, such as Large Eddy (LES) or even Direct Numerical (DNS) simulations. Unfortunately, we did not have the computational resources to do so. Finally, it should be noted that this experimental technique holds great promises for measuring velocity in thermalhydraulics. MTV has an application domain (highlighted in the narrative) that is complimentary to more established (and simpler) techniques, such as PIV. It has attracted the attention of several thermalhydraulics researchers and sponsors to measure velocity in harsh environments. The spectroscopic nature of this technique also enables to expand it to measure temperature and concentration simultaneously to velocity. In lieu of a narrative, 4 detailed journal publications are appended to this executive summary to describe the various development and accomplishments during this project. They include 2 published manuscripts (Experiments in Fluids and Measurement Science and Technology), and two invited contributions following the NURETH-17 conference (Nuclear Science and Technology). Our current Nuclear Engineering and Design draft is not included at this time.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

High-resolution time-resolved experiments on mixing and entrainment of buoyant jets in stratified environments

Fluid jets interacting with a stratified layer play an important role in the safety of several reactor designs. In the containment of nuclear power plants, fluid jets dominate the transport and mixing of gaseous species and consequent hydrogen distribution in case of a severe accident. The mixing phenomena in the containment are driven by buoyant high-momentum injections (jets) and low momentum injection plumes. Mixing near the postulated break is initially dominated by high flow velocities. Plumes with moderate flow velocities are instead relevant in the break compartment during the long-term pressurization phase, or in any of the apertures between two connected compartments if the mass flows are sufficiently high and the density differences between efflux and ambient are sufficiently low. Phenomena of interest include free plumes (as produced by the efflux from the break compartment in a larger room or directly from a break flow), wall plumes (such those produced by low mass flows through inter-compartment apertures), and propagating stratification fronts in the ambient (for any stably stratified conditions). These phenomena have been highly ranked about nuclear reactor design, especially regarding of safety protocols. During a Pressurized Thermal Shock (PTS) scenario, the interaction between the cold ECCS injection plume and the stratified fluid present in the cold (or hot) leg is important in order to determine the temperature at the time-dependent temperature at the inlet of the reactor pressure vessel (RPV) and the potential to cause a thermal shock on the RPV wall. In sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs), core channels are typically hydro-dynamically isolated so that there exists a considerable temperature variation at the exit of adjacent fuel assemblies. All the above phenomena are characterized by the interaction of buoyant jets with the stratified flow. In stratified layers baroclinic forces create significant redistribution of turbulent kinetic energy and scales, which leads to anisotropy. This important physical phenomenon is highly three dimensional and is challenging to capture even with high-fidelity CFD simulations, due in part to lack of sufficiently resolved validation data. Furthermore, the experimental data available in the open literature do not feature the level of fidelity needed for an extensive validation of turbulence models in lower order CFD. To shed new lights into the crucial phenomena object of the present research project, it was proposed to conduct coordinated experiments and simulations at the University of Michigan and the George Washington University. The project has resulted in an experimental database of high-resolution time-resolved measurements of jets in uniform and stratified environments. The novel experimental data will be used to validate computational fluid dynamic (CFD) codes, including both Large Eddy Simulations (LES) and unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes equations (URANS) methodologies. In the Experimental and Multiphase flow (ECMF) laboratory at Univerisity of Michigan, we built two experimental facilities to investigate also the effect of scaling. The first facility, DESTROJER (DEnsity Stratified Turbulent ROund free Jet ExpeRiment), featuring a contoured jet nozzle with a diameter of D=12.7mm and a 1m×1m×1m cubic tank, which is made of acrylic glass for optical access. The ratio between the tank width and the nozzle diameter is equal to 78, which ensures that there is no direct interaction between the jet and the side walls. A second, modular experimental facility, features three different tank sizes of size 10×10×30, 20×20×30, 30×30×30 cm3 respectively (all tanks have the same height of 30 cm), and a jet diameter of 2mm. For the modular facility, tank-to-nozzle ratio of 50, 100, and 150 are obtained respectively. Experiments with different-density jet impactions and sharp interface with a density difference of 3.16% In the Laboratory at George Washington University, complementary experiments have been carried out at a facility featuring the same dimensions as DESTROYER. Experiments with different jet diameters have been carried out as well. High-resolution time-resolved measurements have been performed at all facilities using high-speed particle image velocimetry (PIV) and planar laser-induced fluorescence (PLIF). In this way, simultaneous measurements of velocity and density fields have been carried out. At the University of Michigan, wire-mesh sensors have been designed and built to gather high-resolution, time-dependent data of the stratified front in the tank. These measurements are important to provide accurate initial conditions for the CFD simulations. An important outcome of the project has been the development of novel techniques to achieve refractive index matching (RIM) of acqueous solutions with high density differences. RIM is crucial if optical techniques such as PIV are used to measure velocity fields. Previous to this project, experiments up to 3% density difference had been reported in the literature. With the methodology developed in this project, we have been able to push the envelop to density differences up to 9%. The experiments have been used to validate Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) turbulence models and Large Eddy Simulations (LES) models. Both NEK5000 and the commercial CFD code STAR-CCM+ have been used. The experimental data will be made available to the community through the NE-KAMS databasehave been successfully conducted in the scaled facility.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Status of Metallic Structural Materials for Molten Salt Reactors

In the US and around the world, significant interest surrounds development and deployment of nuclear systems using molten salts to transfer heat. Several configurations are being explored, including the use of fluoride salts either as the primary coolant of a reactor with solid fuel or with the fissile material dissolved in the salt. Molten Salt Reactors (MSRs) with fluoride salt typically have a thermal neutron spectrum. There are also fast-spectrum reactors that could use chloride salts to transfer heat. As a result of operation of the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory during the 1960s, a system with uranium fuel dissolved in a fluoride-salt medium is the most well-established technology. A nickel alloy with about 6%Cr and molybdenum as a solid solution strengthening agent was developed and deployed for all structural applications in this reactor. The alloy was commercialized as Hastelloy N. During these experiments and in post-decommissioning characterization of material behavior, it was determined that the most significant challenges for structural materials are embrittlement, from helium introduced by transmutation of Ni, and corrosion and grain boundary embrittlement from the fission product tellurium. The MSRE had an outlet temperature of approximately 650°C. The mechanical properties of Hastelloy N are not sufficient to support long-term operation of an MSR above this temperature. Qualification of a material for use in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section III, “Rules for Construction of Nuclear Facility Components,” Division 5, “High Temperature Reactors,” will facilitate licensing with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Hastelloy N has not been qualified for use in nuclear construction, and significant additional characterization would be required for Code qualification. Given that this alloy is susceptible to He embrittlement and has limited high-temperature strength, it is not recommended that Code qualification be pursued. Instead, it is recommended that a systematic development program be initiated to develop new nickel alloys that contain a fine, stable dispersion of intermetallic particles to trap He at the interface between the matrix and particle and with increased solid solution strengthening from addition of refractory elements. Extensive screening of attractive alloy compositions for elevated temperature strength, microstructural stability, weldability, and resistance to He embrittlement (characterized using ion implantation) will lead to an alloy down-selection for commercialization and Code qualification.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Fracture Toughness Characterization of Highly irradiated Reactor Pressure Weld from the ATR-2 Experiment

The UCSB ATR-2 irradiation experiment is designed to generate a new database on a wide variety of irradiated reactor pressure vessel (RPV) steels to fill a critical gap in predicting high fluence embrittlement for extended plant operation up to 80 years. A major focus in this experiment is to characterize the effects of irradiation temperature, neutron flux and fluence, and alloy chemistry on MNSP evolution, and model how these features impact hardening and embrittlement, manifested as shifts in ductile-to-brittle transition temperature. As part of these efforts, disk compact tension (DCT) specimens of three representative materials were included in the ATR-2 experiment to have direct measurement of transition fracture toughness shift and, thus, to have some benchmark data to compare outcoming predictive models with actual fracture toughness shifts. In addition, the attempts would be made to use these fracture toughness data to address the potential effect of high dose irradiation on the shape of the Master Curve for highly embrittled RPV material.This report provides data for the fracture toughness characterization of highly embrittled weld from Palisades steam generator.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Notch Effects on the Short Term Rupture Properties of Alloy 617 Base Metal and Weldments

Alloy 617 is currently undergoing approval for inclusion in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code in Section III Division 5 for use in high temperature nuclear reactors. Prior to use in construction of these reactors, however, it must be approved by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. Several concerns relating to the effects of geometric discontinuities, such as notches and multi-axial stress states (as opposed to uniaxial stress states typically present in laboratory run creep tests), must first be addressed. Alloy 617 has been found to be notch-strengthening in short term (1000-2500 hour) creep testing for both base metal and weld metal and will fail preferentially in a straight gauge section rather than at a sharp notch, provided that the applied stresses are similar in both the straight gauge and notch sections. Additionally, specimens designed with semi-circular notches (or U notches, as they are referred to in this report) to impose multi-axial stress states on the specimen during creep-testing were found to either maintain similar creep-rupture-lives as uniaxial stress specimens tested at similar conditions, or have creep-rupture-lives that were significantly longer. This work shows that notches and multi-axial stress states do not appear to raise concerns with relation to the use of design rules created for Alloy 617 using smooth, straight-gauge test specimens and uniaxial creep tests.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Fundamental Understanding of Creep-Fatigue Interactions in 9Cr-1MoV Steel Welds. Final Report

Ferritic-martensitic steels constitute a vital class of materials for current and future generation of nuclear reactors as well as ultra supercritical coal fired power plants due to their superior creep resistant properties. One particular ferritic-martensitic steel, 9Cr-1MoV (Grade 91) is one of five materials approved for high temperature use in nuclear service by the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code (BPVC). Grade 91 is also a candidate material for proposed fission and fusion reactors such as the sodium cooled fast reactor (SFR). In service, Grade 91 components can be subjected to elevated temperatures and cyclic stresses, leading to the accumulation of creep-fatigue (CF) damage. While the monotonic creep properties of Grade 91 steels have been studied extensively, there is less knowledge concerning the mechanisms governing CF damage of this steel in the creep-dominated failure region. Moreover, the creep failure is especially pronounced in welded Grade 91 components, which are commonly joined using conventional arc welding techniques such as flux-cored arc welding (FCAW). In a Grade 91 weld, the creep failure typically occurs in the outer region of the heat affected zone (HAZ), specifically in the intercritical or fine-grained heat-affected zone (ICHAZ or FGHAZ), a phenomenon known as type IV failure. Currently, there exists a limited knowledge of CF damage mechanisms in Grade 91 welds. Improving the mechanistic understanding of the CF damage and failure of Grade 91 steel and its welds with inhomogeneous microstructure is crucial for the safety and design of key structural components in advanced, high-temperature reactors. The overall objectives of the project were to advance the state of knowledge and understanding of CF damage in both Grade 91 base metal and its welds, especially under loading conditions where creep is the dominant damage mechanism. Uncovering the mechanisms governing the creep-fatigue deformation and damage in Grade 91 base metal in creep-dominated region as well as type IV failure in Grade 91 welds contributes to a new knowledge that may lead to more accurate life prediction models than those currently in use. Moreover, the superior CF properties obtained by low heat input welding has a high potential to develop practical solutions to the premature failure of Grade 91 weld.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Development of Grade 91 inelastic model for incorporation in ASME Division 5

This report describes a unified viscoplastic model for Grade 91 suitable for use with the Section III, Division 5 design by inelastic analysis procedures in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code. The report identifies several key features a successful design inelastic model must capture along with critical aspects of the response of Grade 91 for elevated temperature loading conditions typical of expected reactor operating conditions. An inelastic model for Code design must capture the average response of a material including heat-to-heat and product form variations. This work develops a method for calibrating such a model to a large experimental database using genetic algorithm optimization. Finally, the report compares the final model to several specialized experimental tests to validate that it will be suitable for use in high temperature structural design. The techniques developed here can be applied to the remaining Section III, Division 5, Class A materials to develop a nonmandatory appendix to the Code describing inelastic material models suitable for use with the design by inelastic analysis procedures.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Evaluation of methods to determine strain ranges for use in SMT design curves

This report describes progress on developing a new method for creep-fatigue design that reduces over conservatism, improves the treatment of elastic follow up effects, and simplifies the design procedure, when compared to the existing ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessels Code, Section III, Division 5 method for creep-fatigue design. Specifically, this report describes the development of one of the three components of the new creep-fatigue design method: a design analysis method to represent the steady cyclic strain range in a component in elevated temperature service. The method developed here uses an elastic perfectly plastic (EPP) analysis with a pseudoyield stress selected to bound the width of the steady state stress-strain hysteresis loop. The report also provides a description of the in-development creep-fatigue design method, including a plan to complete the method by developing design curves and a method to account for stress multiaxiality.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Finite element analysis of compliant cladding and base metal systems

This report describes a roadmap towards a design method for high temperature nuclear cladded components that does not require long term testing of clad materials. Molten Salt Reactors (MSRs) will operate using corrosive fuel or coolant salts. The existing Class A metallic materials qualified for ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section III, Division 5 design are not optimal for corrosion resistance when exposed to MSR salts. Corrosion could then severely limit the service life of MSRs. One option to alleviate this could be to Code qualify new corrosion resistant materials. However, this is a lengthy and expensive process and MSR developers have a near term need for a design solution that enables reactor designs with long service lives. An alternative would be to use cladded components – overlay some existing Class A material with a thin layer of some corrosion resistant material. This report describes the outlines of a design strategy that would enable this approach. The strategy relies on approximate design analysis methods for certain types of clad/base systems that avoids requiring long-term mechanical properties for the clad materials. This would allow the use of cladded components in the near term, without requiring long testing programs. However, it will limit the types of clad materials that can be used. This report describes the design framework, demonstrates the effectiveness of the approximate analysis methods, and confirms the approach using full scale finite element analysis of prototypical cladded high temperature components. It also describes a roadmap towards a complete design method and surveys available clad materials and bonding methods for suitably, considering only mechanical and not environmental effects.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

The Influences of Neutron Irradiation on Aggregate Induced Degradation of Concrete

Reactor cavity concrete, the primary support structure for the reactor pressure vessel (RPV), is exposed to chronic neutron/gamma radiation during normal operation. During long term operation, the interaction of neutron irradiation with the concrete’s constituents may cause premature degradation of the concrete structure, as highlighted by a review of concrete properties in nuclear power plant environments. At high fluence levels, as in biological shielding, neutron irradiation may cause amorphization of the crystalline components of concrete, i.e., mineral aggregates, and volume changes, which are typically expansive in nature. Volume expansion can generate tensile stresses within concrete which can induce microcracking and/or result in debonding of aggregate with the matrix. On the other hand, structural disordering can result in changes in the stability of the phase in aqueous environments. This report presents the findings of investigations performed over 3 years through the collaboration of researchers from University of California, Los Angeles, Arizona State University, and Oak Ridge National Laboratory. The first part of the study addresses the effect of neutron irradiation on the durability of aggregates. Comparisons of aqueous dissolution rates, as a function of pH and temperature, were performed for aggregates that are either pristine (i.e., non-irradiated) or exposed to Ar+ ion irradiation at specified doses. These experimental results were coupled with molecular dynamics simulations of atomic scale changes in the crystallographic structure of the mineral and any resulting changes in physical properties (e.g., density) that result. The second section focuses on macroscopic effects of such changes in aggregate behavior in concrete degradation, primarily through changes in the concrete’s microstructure. Particularly, the effects akin to those originating from alkali-silica reaction (ASR) were evaluated. The project is structured to encompass 6 main tasks, as follows: Task 1: Selection of aggregates in relation to their abundance and mineralogy, and their irradiation Task 2: Molecular dynamics (MD): The effects of irradiation on the atomic disordering of aggregates Task 3: The influences of irradiation on aggregate reactivity Task 4: Reactive-transport simulation of expansive product formation in concrete microstructures Task 5: X-FEM-based modeling of damage evolution due to irradiation-induced aggregates reactions Task 6: Benchmarking, verification and validation of the simulation modules Thus, a rigorous understanding of irradiation-assisted mineral alterations was used to develop a mechanistic degradation model for concrete exposed to neutrons, while considering aspects of: chemical reaction (dissolution and precipitation), mass and ion transport, and damage evolutions. The models developed were embedded in a multi-physics aging code for nuclear components and structures called Grizzly, which allows for benchmarking, verification, and validation against expansion data acquired on concrete undergoing alkali-silica reaction, a physically/chemically equivalent form of degradation that develops in the absence of radiation. These findings provide insight into the sensitivities of minerals to irradiation, by highlighting characteristics of concretes and power plants subject to such risks. The research will aid the nuclear power industry to anticipate and mitigate such risks in light of second license renewals.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Enhancements to Concrete Modeling Capabilities in Grizzly 2.0

The Grizzly code has been under development for several years with the goal of modeling aging effects in a variety of nuclear power plant systems, components, and structures. Version 2.0 of Grizzly was recently released, including both major improvements to its probabilistic fracture mechanics capabilities for evaluation of irradiated reactor pressure vessels, as well as multiple improvements to its capability for modeling degradation of concrete structures. This report summarizes recent development in the Grizzly code specific to concrete modeling that are included in this release. Major highlights of this work include the release of much of the concrete modeling capabilities of Grizzly in an open-source code called BlackBear, modernization of the models and documentation of the code, support for including nonlinear mechanical constitutive models, including creep and damage, re-architecting the anisotropic expansion model to allow its use for modeling both expansion due to alkali-silica reaction and radiation-induced volumetric expansion, and developing a preliminary capability for modeling connection of reinforcing bars to a concrete matrix.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Solid Oxide Based Electrolysis and Stack Technology with Ultra-High Electrolysis Current Density (>3A/cm 2 ) and Efficiency

Hydrogen, a valuable commodity gas, is increasingly recognized as an important fuel and energy storage pathway of the future. This project aims to develop an innovative solid oxide based electrolysis cell and stack technology with ultra-high steam electrolysis current (>3A/cm 2 ) for potentially ultra-low-cost, highly efficient hydrogen production from diverse renewable sources. In this project, solid oxide based high power density cells (HiPoD cells) were developed. Those cells demonstrated capability of operating at ultra-high electrolysis current density of 6 A/cm 2 at 1.67V. During a long term steady state electrolysis test, a HiPoD cell was operated for more than 1000 hours at 3 A/cm 2 with a low degradation rate of 1.8% per 1000 hours. A 20-cell electrolysis stack was built using HiPoD cells and an ultra-compact, low-cost stack design platform. This stack was used to explore the boundaries of high current density electrolysis operation and achieved an incredible stack current density of 3 A/cm 2 with an average cell voltage of only 1.493 V. The stack was further operated in steady-state electrolysis at 2 A/cm 2 for more than 1000 hours with an overall degradation of 0.57% per 1000 hours. With an improved understanding of electrolysis operation at ultra-high current density, a new compact stack architecture (CSA) design with scalability up to 55 kW (or 38 kg H 2 per day) was tested. A number of 45-cell CSA stack was built and demonstrated 10 kW and 245 g/hr hydrogen production at 1.8 A/cm 2 electrolysis current density. In addition to cell and stack development, a preliminary system design was developed by integrating the inputs from electrochemistry, cell/stack performance data, and system level implications of configuration and operational parameters. A module design was created based on a circular array of six stacks surrounded in a cool pressure vessel. Further architectural and controls strategies such as stack power control and instrumentation were determined through the development of the module. A comprehensive techno-economic study of an ultra-high current density SOEC system integrated with renewable energy sources has been conducted. To determine the estimated cost of hydrogen for the system, the H2A Current Distributed Hydrogen Production Model version 3.101 was applied. Annual system production cases at both commercial and industrial electricity rates as per the H2A model was analyzed. The option of meeting DOE 2020 Advanced Electrolysis Technologies targets were discussed. Feedstock electricity represents the bulk of projected hydrogen cost with either electricity rate. At an annual production volume of 250 units, H2A hydrogen cost of $2.3/kg can be achieved at electricity cost around 3.5¢/kWh.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Materials and Dimensional Reference Handbook for the Boiling Water Reactor Dry Cask Simulator.

The performance of commercial nuclear spent fuel dry storage casks is evaluated through detailed analytical modeling of the system’s thermal performance. A recent investigation has been completed that produced a data set that can be used to test the validity of the modeling presently used to determine cladding temperatures in modern vertical dry casks. To produce these data sets under well-controlled boundary conditions, the dry cask simulator (DCS) was built to study the thermal-hydraulic response of fuel under a variety of heat loads, internal vessel pressures, and external configurations [Durbin and Lindgren, 2017]. The experiments were conducted in Albuquerque, New Mexico where the local ambient atmospheric pressure is typically 83 kPa. The purpose of this handbook is to document the pertinent geometric and material property information needed to perform model validation efforts.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Advanced low-cost intermetallic coatings for molten salt pump impeller. Final report

1.0 INTRODUCTION The use of solar energy to produce steam for the generation of electricity is an established technology, with multiple designs for concentrating solar power (CSP) steam generators available commercially and a number of such units currently operating. As part of the effort to improve the overall efficiency of this technology, designers have developed thermal energy storage (TES) mechanisms that employ molten salt to capture a portion of the solar energy available during the day-time hours and make that energy available for steam generation during periods when the sun’s energy is not available. In current TES systems, nitrate salts are used extensively as the medium of energy exchange. However, due to the chemical instability of these salts at temperatures above 600ºC, they are not being considered for use in the next more efficient generation of CSP plants, in which the energy exchange fluids will be required to operate in the range 600ºC to 800ºC. At these higher temperatures, molten chloride salts, such as KCl-MgCl2, are viewed as promising alternatives to the nitrate salts, but, of course, these chloride-based salts are highly corrosive to the engineering alloys commonly used in the construction of pressure vessels, heat exchangers, pumps and piping at high temperatures. Hence, a solution to the problem of material degradation is essential if the next generation of CSP plants is to be commercially viable (Ref 1). In order to effectively address the problem of molten chloride salt corrosion at high temperatures (≥ 750ºC) and thereby to reduce the cost of molten salt tanks and related apparatus, various options have been considered, with one of the most promising being an innovative coatings system developed and applied onto low alloy ferritic or austenitic stainless material. Development of such a coating system would reduce the capital costs of thermal energy storage (TES) and increase the overall efficiency of the concentrating solar power (CSP) system. Although high strength nickel base alloys are well suited for many high temperature applications, they have significant limitations when exposed to molten chloride salt conditions and they are very expensive. Monolithic materials such as the austenitic stainless steels (e.g., SS310 and SS347) and the more common nickel base alloys (e.g., IN625 and IN800H) have exhibited high corrosion rates in molten chloride salt environments (Ref1). Molten salt corrosion of IN625 in salts containing chlorides showed a catastrophic corrosion rate of 1.111”/year at 800ºC (Ref1). Hence, an innovative coatings solution to mitigate molten chloride salt corrosion is needed. Of the many coating techniques available in the market, no one technique appears to be capable of producing effective protection from molten salt corrosion at a relatively low cost. There are thermal spray coating techniques, in particular the twin wire-arc technology, that are attractive when considering the coating of large molten salt tanks because the coatings application rate is high, the overall application cost is low and repairs to the coating can readily be made either in the shop or in the field. However, the twin wire arc coating materials currently available in the market have certain inherent limitations, including porosity and mechanical bonding to the substrate, which limit their effectiveness in providing protection against molten chloride salt corrosion at high temperatures. What is required is an approach that combines the economy and versatility of thermal spray wire-arc technology with the superior resistance of advanced alloys to effectively combat molten chloride salt corrosion at elevated temperatures. Applied Thermal Coatings, Inc. (ATC) has investigated an innovative coatings technology to produce dual layer cermet/ceramic coatings that will be dense and impervious to any corrosive molten salts/fluids, thereby resisting the effects of molten salt corrosion. Development of coatings using this technology will make it possible to fabricate the molten salt systems using a relatively low-cost base material, which will reduce the overall cost of the power generating system and enhance the commercial viability of solar power. 2.0 PROJECT OVERVIEW Of the coating technologies available for the production of a cost-effective method of protection from the effects of high-temperature chloride attack, there are two that offer specific advantages for the CSP/TES application, particularly when used in a way that effectively complements the strengths of each coating method. The first of these is electroless nickel plating, through which a nickel-rich layer is produced on the surface of a component through chemical reduction. The second coating technology is aluminizing, in which aluminum is diffused into the surface of a component and, depending on the composition of the substrate, aluminides are formed. The objective of this project has been to demonstrate the feasibility of a low- cost coating for the protection of pump impellers used for the inductive transport of molten salts. Initial interest focused on an inter-metallic nickel aluminide coating and subsequently, for economic reasons, consideration also was given to a coating composed of iron aluminides. Applying such coatings to low alloy or austenitic stainless-steel substrates will provide the superior resistance to molten chloride salt corrosion and blade tip erosion that normally can be achieved only through the use of more highly alloyed – and, therefore, more expensive - nickel-base materials and it will do so at a substantially lower cost. The coating systems evaluated were designed to take advantage either of the combined strengths of the electroless nickel plating process and the aluminizing process to produce a nickel-aluminide intermetallic coating or to rely solely on the aluminizing process to produce, in conjunction with iron from the substrate, a protective layer consisting of iron aluminides. With respect to the nickel aluminide protection, this has been achieved by first depositing a layer of nickel-rich alloy onto an austenitic stainless substrate using the electroless nickel plating process and then aluminizing the nickel- coated surface to produce the nickel aluminide coating. With respect to the iron aluminide protection, this has been achieved by aluminizing bare austenitic stainless steel. Testing has supported the conclusion that the developed coatings will resist attack by molten chloride salts at high temperatures (550°C to 750°C) and have sufficient hardness to resist blade tip erosion.The steps taken to develop either a low-cost intermetallic nickel aluminide coating using electroless nickel plating and aluminizing or a low-cost iron aluminide coating using aluminizing only, and to demonstrate the quality of the coatings and their effectiveness against molten chloride salt corrosion and erosion at high temperatures (≤ 750ºC) have been as follows: 1. Design of the optimum electroless nickel plating and aluminizing mixtures using advanced thermodynamic analysis; 2. Development of processing parameters for the electroless nickel plating and aluminizing processes, to be used either together or separately; 3. Production of specimens coated using the designated electroless nickel plating process; 4. Production of samples with intermetallic nickel aluminide coating or iron aluminide coating; 5. Investigation of the performance of the intermetallic nickel aluminide coating and the iron aluminide coating when subjected to molten chloride salts corrosion at high temperatures (≥ 750ºC); and, 6. Metallurgical characterization of the microstructure of the coatings, both prior to and after exposure to molten salt environments at elevated temperatures.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗