Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “CODING”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,351 records · Page 75

Multi-node and Multi-core Performance Studies of a Monte Carlo code RMC

Over the past 15 years the architecture of high-performance computing systems has become increasingly heterogeneous with individual computing cores being subdivided into nodes and even auxiliary co-processing units such as graphics processing units or the Intel many integrated core co-processors. In fact, future computer platforms is moving toward a larger number of nodes and cores with lower memory available per node. Today, several production Monte Carlo codes use some types of hybrid parallelism strategy that makes use of shared-memory parallelism within a computing node and message-passing parallelism between nodes, which enables the codes to utilize available computing resources as much as possible, both among and within computing nodes on a cluster. The so-called hybrid parallelization is also possible with Reactor Monte Carlo Code RMC by activating both MPI and OpenMP parallel algorithms together. On HPC' which typically consists of several or several-ten thousand nodes equipping 16-32 computing intra-cores per node, simulation of RMC can be carried out in the hybrid parallelization with the MPI inter-node parallelization and the OpenMP intra-node parallelization. RMC has adopted a hybrid message-passing and shared-memory approach to parallelism, which enables the code to utilize available computing resources, both among and within computing nodes on a cluster. Shared-memory parallelism is especially valuable for large-model simulations because it enables multiple compute cores within a node to share common model information such as the geometry description, material, cross section and tally data, thus reducing the memory usage per processor. The calculation on the Tianhe-2 supercomputer took 6144 cores, resulting in a rate of 173,314,000 neutrons/minute for BEAVRS benchmark. While pin-wise full core H-M benchmark burnup calculations with millions of depletion regions was selected using MPI/OpenMP parallelism, the speed of 6,144 cores reach 1,843,200 burnable regions per minute. Keeping up with the continuing trend for increases in the number of computing resources within modern HPC systems is a significant challenge for teams that develop and maintain high-performance MC radiation transport solvers. order to address this challenge, RMC has adopted a hybrid message-passing and shared-memory approach to parallelism, which enables the code to utilize available computing resources, both among and within computing nodes on a cluster. Shared-memory parallelism is especially valuable for large-model simulations because it enables multiple compute cores within a node to share common model information such as the geometry description, material and composition definitions, and cross section data, thus reducing the memory usage per processor. The parallel performance has been studied by using two complex and representative benchmarks, H-M and BEAVRS benchmark. All simulations were run on Intel Xeon E5-2692 12 core, 2.2 GHz processors at MilkyWay-2 Super Computer with up to 12,288 available computing cores. While employing MPI parallelism, excellent parallel efficiency is achieved even above 12,000 processors and RMC reaches the parallel efficiency of 96% on 12,288 cores for the pin-by-pin computation of the BEAVRS benchmark. While BEAVRS criticality benchmark was selected using MPI/OpenMP parallelism, the speed of 6,144 cores reach 173,314,000 particles per minute. While pin-wise full core H-M benchmark burnup calculations with millions of depletion regions was selected using MPI/OpenMP parallelism, the speed of 6,144 cores reach 1,843,200 burnable regions per minute. Results from these studies demonstrate that RMC, using the hybrid parallel model described in this paper, is able to handle pin-wise full core burnup calculations with millions of depletion regions and scales well through thousands of processors. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Uncertainty and Sensitivity Analysis of Reactivity Insertion Accidents using BISON Fuel Performance Code

The development of Accident Tolerant Fuels (ATF) has expanded into a considerable research program in the wake of the events at the Japanese Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant in 2011. The ATF goal is to insert a test assembly into a commercial reactor by 2022. To support this, testing of the ATF design under off-normal conditions is needed to assess the 'enhanced accident tolerance' capability of the fuel rod design over standard UO{sub 2}-Zircaloy concepts. Transient testing capabilities are necessary for off-normal testing of events such as loss of coolant accidents (LOCA) and reactivity insertion accidents (RIA). A transient testing program has been developed to support the testing of ATF designs. The Transient Reactor Test (TREAT) facility has been chosen as the site to perform the transient testing of the ATF designs. TREAT is a versatile test facility capable of subjecting fuel specimens to various off-normal conditions. Historic TREAT experiments were performed in a variety of experimental test vehicles including static environment capsules, once-through flowing systems, and also recirculating flowing systems. The planned TREAT experiments will be operated under PWR conditions. Therefore, a static capsule vehicle is under development to handle required temperatures and pressures. The static capsule, termed the Static Environment Rodlet Transient Test Apparatus (SERTTA), will be used for irradiation tests in TREAT to subject ATF fuel rodlets to a range of power pulse conditions and environments. To aid in the design and analysis of future tests in TREAT, the fuel performance code BISON is being used. Fuel performance codes capable of accident modeling have been developed for some time and they have shown an ability to reproduce experimental results with some degree of adequacy, but they still require extensive verification and validation. Future experiments in TREAT will add to a limited database of past transient tests performed in transient reactors to support LWR systems. These tests can be used for future verification and validation of fuel performance codes. Understanding the impact of the uncertainty of influential parameters is critical for not only analyzing the results of the experiment but also for modeling and validation of codes. For example, uncertainties associated with the initial manufactured state of the sample, instrument measurements, material property models, and planned experiment conditions can provide important insight into model performance, experimental data, and play an important role in experimental design. The objective of this work is to perform an uncertainty and sensitivity analysis on a simplified RIA case of a standard UO{sub 2}-Zircaloy sample using expected nominal conditions in the SERTTA capsule in TREAT. The BISON fuel performance code is used in conjunction with DAKOTA (Design Analysis Kit for Optimization and Tera-scale Applications) to perform the uncertainty and sensitivity analysis. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Comparison of the Performance of Various Correlated Fission Multiplicity Monte Carlo Codes

When measuring special nuclear material for a large array of national security needs, it is often important to accurately predict outcomes of the physical experiment using Monte Carlo radiation transport codes. Historically, radiation transport codes have uncorrelated fission emissions. In reality, both spontaneous and induced fissions release particles that are correlated in time, energy, and multiplicity. This work investigates the performance of various current Monte Carlo codes that take into account the correlated physics of fission neutrons. Only fission neutrons are of interest and the physics of gamma production in fission is ignored. Because of their large impact on correlated neutron results, underlying fission neutron multiplicity distributions utilized by the different codes are also compared. The codes currently being compared include MCNP{sup R}6, MCNP{sup R}6/FREYA, and MCNPX-PoliMi. By default, MCNP{sup R}6 uses a bounded integer treatment to sample the number of neutrons emitted from each fission event. The FMULT card, an optional input in MCNP that allows for user definition of spontaneous and induced fission parameters, can be utilized to call either built-in or user-specified multiplicities to replace the bounded integer treatment. Similarly, MCNPX-PoliMi utilizes one of a few different built-in multiplicity sets. MCNPX-PoliMi also models the multiplicity dependence of emitted neutron energy in spontaneous fission. It is possible to use an anisotropic model for emitted fission neutrons in MCNPXPoliMi, but this option was not used. For MCNP{sup R}6/FREYA, the FREYA fission event generator determines the number of particles emitted for each fission event and gives the results to MCNP{sup R}6 for transport. The fission event generator uses fission fragment mass and kinetic energy distributions, unbounded statistical evaporation models, and conservation of energy and momentum to generate the number, energy, and direction of neutrons released by each fission event. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Analog neutron transport for nuclear instrumentation applications with the Monte-Carlo code TRIPOLI-4 - Paper 3

Monte-Carlo codes simulating particle transport usually make use of well-known variance reduction techniques, leading to more efficient simulations. Even in configurations which do not deal with deep-penetration, some of these techniques, such as the implicit capture, are actually often used by default. The statistical weight of the simulated particles is then modified in order to take into account the modification of the sampling without introducing any bias in the estimation process. For instance, the implicit capture decreases the statistical weight of the particles at each collision, whereas the sampling of a single outgoing particle increases this statistical weight in case of scattering reactions producing multiple neutrons. In addition, Russian roulette and splitting operations, which are usually also played at each collision, lead to other modifications of the statistical weights. As a result, Monte-Carlo codes provide particle histories that are valid on average, but collect statistical weights which differ from 1, when tallying the estimation of the quantities of interest. Yet, some nuclear instrumentation calculations inherently need to work with statistical weights equal to 1, since either individual events have to be collected (such as the arrival of a particle at a detector, the measurement of a time of flight, etc), or the coincidence of events or also correlations between individual events have to be taken into account. To address these specific applications with Monte-Carlo simulation codes, users need a full analog simulation mode. The continuous-energy Monte-Carlo code TRIPOLI4{sup R} is mainly dedicated to shielding, reactor physics and criticality safety calculations. Its capabilities have recently been extended to widen its use to nuclear instrumentation with the possibility of γ-spectrometry calculations and the simulation of photonuclear reactions for instance. Other features needed by nuclear instrumentation applications have been available in TRIPOLI-4 for a long time, such as the sampling of the time variable and the possibility of tallying in a time grid for most of the available tallies (fluxes, reaction rates, dose equivalent rates, energy depositions, etc). In TRIPOLI-4, the transport between two consecutive collisions is analog if no variance reduction technique is requested by the user to handle deep-penetration configurations. However, up to the version 9 of the code, the collision itself is sampled in a non-analog way. This paper presents a first implementation of a full analog neutron transport mode in TRIPOLI-4, preliminary verification results and an application of this functionality to the simulation of the Nucifer detector located in Saclay, France. It should be noted that only neutron transport is dealt with in this work and that all nuclear data come from JEFF-3.1.1 or ENDF/B-VII.0 evaluations, including fission data when needed. (authors)

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

MONK10: A Monte Carlo Code for Criticality Analysis - 14574

The MONK{sup R} code, if we include its predecessor GEM, has now been in use for 50 years. It is a Monte Carlo code for nuclear criticality and reactor physics analyses which is used extensively in the UK nuclear industry and worldwide. In 2014 a major new version of the code, MONK10A, was released introducing many new features; these are described with example applications presented where appropriate. Experience with MONK9A models indicates that MONK10A has increased run-time performance for all cases and on average runs 2.4 times faster. New geometry options include the direct import of CAD generated models using the new IGES body, POLY body, TETMESH Hole and TETMESH Zone features. Example calculations for a selection of CAD import options are presented and compared with the intrinsic MONK geometry representation, with relative merits discussed. New Features are included to assist with the modeling of distributed parameters; such features include Unified Tally (UT), Action Tallies (AT) in UT and Shannon entropy. The latter is useful in assessing the convergence of distributed parameters, such as scalar neutron flux. As such it is an important tool in determining the appropriate point to stop settling and begin scoring stages in a Monte Carlo simulation. The utility of UT, AT-in-UT and Shannon entropy is demonstrated using calculations employing the new CAD import geometry options. Runtime Doppler broadening is included to allow accurate representation of temperature distributions within models. Example calculations which further demonstrate UT and AT-in-UT are presented for different bodies at different temperatures to evaluate the effects of temperature differences on k-effective and reaction rates. The MONK10A code was issued with a new set of continuous energy and group nuclear data libraries. These include JEFF3.1, JEFF3.1.1, JEFF 3.1.2, ENDF/B-VII.0 and CENDL 3.1 libraries. The inclusion of a range of libraries allows the user to evaluate the impact of different international nuclear data evaluations on their results and an example is provided to illustrate the differences that can arise from the use of different nuclear data evaluations. The code was also issued with a new version of the VisualWorkshop IDE to allow easy construction and editing of input decks, running of calculations and display of geometry and results. Examples are provided of the geometry and results display and showing how results can be superimposed upon the geometry. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Power and Limitations of Linear Programming Decoder for Quantum LDPC Codes

Decoding quantum error-correcting codes is a key challenge in enabling fault-tolerant quantum computation. In the classical setting, linear programming (LP) decoders offer provable performance guarantees and can leverage fast practical optimization algorithms. Although LP decoders have been proposed for quantum codes, their performance and limitations remain relatively underexplored. In this work, we uncover a key limitation of LP decoding for quantum low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes: certain constant-weight error patterns lead to ambiguous fractional solutions that cannot be resolved through independent rounding. To address this issue, we incorporate a post-processing technique known as ordered statistics decoding (OSD), which significantly enhances LP decoding performance in practice. Our results show that LP decoding, when augmented with OSD, can outperform belief propagation with the same post-processing for intermediate code sizes of up to hundreds of qubits. These findings suggest that LP-based decoders, equipped with effective post-processing, offer a promising approach for decoding near-term quantum LDPC codes.

Gu, Shouzhen [Yale U.]↗

Power and Limitations of Linear Programming Decoder for Quantum LDPC Codes

Decoding quantum error-correcting codes is a key challenge in enabling fault-tolerant quantum computation. In the classical setting, linear programming (LP) decoders offer provable performance guarantees and can leverage fast practical optimization algorithms. Although LP decoders have been proposed for quantum codes, their performance and limitations remain relatively underexplored. In this work, we uncover a key limitation of LP decoding for quantum low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes: certain constant-weight error patterns lead to ambiguous fractional solutions that cannot be resolved through independent rounding. To address this issue, we incorporate a post-processing technique known as ordered statistics decoding (OSD), which significantly enhances LP decoding performance in practice. Our results show that LP decoding, when augmented with OSD, can outperform belief propagation with the same post-processing for intermediate code sizes of up to hundreds of qubits. These findings suggest that LP-based decoders, equipped with effective post-processing, offer a promising approach for decoding near-term quantum LDPC codes.

Gu, Shouzhen [Yale U.]↗

Power and Limitations of Linear Programming Decoder for Quantum LDPC Codes

Decoding quantum error-correcting codes is a key challenge in enabling fault-tolerant quantum computation. In the classical setting, linear programming (LP) decoders offer provable performance guarantees and can leverage fast practical optimization algorithms. Although LP decoders have been proposed for quantum codes, their performance and limitations remain relatively underexplored. In this work, we uncover a key limitation of LP decoding for quantum low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes: certain constant-weight error patterns lead to ambiguous fractional solutions that cannot be resolved through independent rounding. To address this issue, we incorporate a post-processing technique known as ordered statistics decoding (OSD), which significantly enhances LP decoding performance in practice. Our results show that LP decoding, when augmented with OSD, can outperform belief propagation with the same post-processing for intermediate code sizes of up to hundreds of qubits. These findings suggest that LP-based decoders, equipped with effective post-processing, offer a promising approach for decoding near-term quantum LDPC codes.

Gu, Shouzhen [Yale U.]↗

MULTIDIMENSIONAL COUPLED PHOTON-ELECTRON TRANSPORT SIMULATIONS USING NEUTRAL PARTICLE SN CODES

During the past two years a study was underway at ORNL to assess the suitability of the popular SN neutral particle codes ANISN, DORT and TORT for coupled photon-electron calculations specific to external beam therapy of medical physics applications. The CEPXS-BFP code was used to generate the cross sections. The computational tests were performed on phantoms typical of those used in medical physics for external beam therapy, with materials simulated by water at different densities and the comparisons were made against Monte Carlo simulations that served as benchmarks. Although the results for one-dimensional calculations were encouraging, it appeared that the higher dimensional transport codes had fundamental difficulties in handling the electron transport. The results of two-dimensional simulations using the code DORT with an S16 fully symmetric quadrature set agree fairly with the reference Monte Carlo results but not well enough for clinical applications. While the photon fluxes are in better agreement (generally, within less than 5% from the reference), the discrepancy increases, sometimes very significantly, for the electron fluxes. The paper, however, focuses on the results obtained with the three-dimensional code TORT which had convergence difficulties for the electron groups. Numerical instabilities occurred in these groups. These instabilities were more pronounced with the degree of anisotropy of the problem.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Energy Codes at a Glance

Feeling dim from energy code confusion? Read on to give your inspections a charge. The U.S. Department of Energy’s Building Energy Codes Program addresses hundreds of inquiries from the energy codes community every year. This article offers clarification for topics of confusion submitted to BECP Technical Support of interest to electrical inspectors, focusing on the residential and commercial energy code requirements based on the most recently published 2006 International Energy Conservation Code® and ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA1 Standard 90.1-2004.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Use of Forward Sensitivity Analysis Method to Improve Code Scaling, Applicability, and Uncertainty (CSAU) Methodology

Code Scaling, Applicability, and Uncertainty (CSAU) methodology was developed in late 1980s by US NRC to systematically quantify reactor simulation uncertainty. Basing on CSAU methodology, Best Estimate Plus Uncertainty (BEPU) methods have been developed and widely used for new reactor designs and existing LWRs power uprate. In spite of these successes, several aspects of CSAU have been criticized for further improvement: i.e., (1) subjective judgement in PIRT process; (2) high cost due to heavily relying large experimental database, needing many experts man-years work, and very high computational overhead; (3) mixing numerical errors with other uncertainties; (4) grid dependence and same numerical grids for both scaled experiments and real plants applications; (5) user effects; Although large amount of efforts have been used to improve CSAU methodology, the above issues still exist. With the effort to develop next generation safety analysis codes, new opportunities appear to take advantage of new numerical methods, better physical models, and modern uncertainty qualification methods. Forward sensitivity analysis (FSA) directly solves the PDEs for parameter sensitivities (defined as the differential of physical solution with respective to any constant parameter). When the parameter sensitivities are available in a new advanced system analysis code, CSAU could be significantly improved: (1) Quantifying numerical errors: New codes which are totally implicit and with higher order accuracy can run much faster with numerical errors quantified by FSA. (2) Quantitative PIRT (Q-PIRT) to reduce subjective judgement and improving efficiency: treat numerical errors as special sensitivities against other physical uncertainties; only parameters having large uncertainty effects on design criterions are considered. (3) Greatly reducing computational costs for uncertainty qualification by (a) choosing optimized time steps and spatial sizes; (b) using gradient information (sensitivity result) to reduce sampling number. (4) Allowing grid independence for scaled integral effect test (IET) simulation and real plant applications: (a) eliminate numerical uncertainty on scaling; (b) reduce experimental cost by allowing smaller scaled IET; (c) eliminate user effects. This paper will review the issues related to the current CSAU, introduce FSA, discuss a potential Q-PIRT process, and show simple examples to perform FSA. Finally, the general research direction and requirements to use FSA in a system analysis code will be discussed.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

Comparison of ICRF-Induced Ion Diffusion Coefficients Calculated with the DC and AORSA Codes

The DC (Diffusion Coefficient) code obtains RF diffusion coefficients by direct numerical integration of the Lorentz force equation for ion motion in the combined equilibrium fields and the RF full wave EM fields from the AORSA full-wave code. Suitable averaging over initial gyro- and toroidal-angle of coordinate 'kicks' after a bounce-period, gives noise-free bounce-averaged diffusion coefficients. For direct comparison with zero-banana-width coefficients from AORSA, perpendicular-drift terms in the Lorentz equation are subtracted off the integration. The DC code has been coupled to the CQL3D Fokker-Planck code. For a C-Mod minority ion ICRF heating test case, the total power absorption using the diffusion coefficients agree well, and the profiles are similarly close. This supports the DC calculation and the Kennel-Engelmann-based, no-correlations, coefficient calculation in AORSA. However, resonance correlations cause large differences in the pitch angle variations of the diffusion coefficients, and in the resulting evolution of the ion distribution functions.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

Feasibility Study on Implementing a Staggered-Grid Finite Volume Method for System Analysis Code Development Under the MOOSE Framework

Here, this work summarizes a feasibility study on testing numerical algorithms that are suitable and efficient for advanced system analysis code development under the mutli-physics framework, MOOSE. The key to the test bed is the implementation of high-order one-dimensional staggered-grid finite volume method (SG-FVM), and its direct interaction with the linear/nonlinear solver, PETSc. The test bed utilized a more flexible code structure to enable the finite volume method implementation and direct interacting with the solver package, instead of using the natively supported finite element method by the framework. Using a suite of selected test problems with different problem sizes and levels of complexity, the implemented SG-FVM demonstrated superior performance improvement against a direct finite element method implementation through MOOSE. On two computer systems, the speedup was observed to be significant, with at least one order of magnitude of solving time reduction. For a complex reactor model, transient simulation was performed using the newly developed finite volume method code, the results of which agree very well with the reference results from the finite element method code. Overall, this study demonstrates a successful feasibility study on the proposed numerical algorithms and software structure to support advanced system analysis tool development.

MOOSE↗

A Retrospective Analysis of Commercial Building Energy Codes: 1990 – 2008

Building Energy Codes Program's efforts are designed to result in increased stringency in national model energy codes, more rapid and broader adoption by states and localities of updated codes, and increased compliance and enforcement. Report estimates the historical impact of Building Energy Codes Program in terms of energy savings achieved that are based upon various editions of ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1 (ASHRAE Standard 90.1).

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Assessing Potential Energy Cost Savings from Increased Energy Code Compliance in Commercial Buildings

The US Department of Energy’s most recent commercial energy code compliance evaluation efforts focused on determining a percent compliance rating for states to help them meet requirements under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) of 2009. That approach included a checklist of code requirements, each of which was graded pass or fail. Percent compliance for any given building was simply the percent of individual requirements that passed. With its binary approach to compliance determination, the previous methodology failed to answer some important questions. In particular, how much energy cost could be saved by better compliance with the commercial energy code and what are the relative priorities of code requirements from an energy cost savings perspective? This paper explores an analytical approach and pilot study using a single building type and climate zone to answer those questions.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

An Analysis of Building Energy Code Statewide Adoption Rates by Local Jurisdiction

The purpose of this study is to quantify the energy code adoption rate by local jurisdictions from a sample set of 21 states. Some of the states within this sample have statewide energy codes, while others do not. Using construction starts and weighting results by localities that have or have not adopted energy codes, the findings can suggest a means of identifying which states have “effectively” adopted statewide codes through local adoption and enforcement.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗

Data Analysis of Energy Code Compliance in Commercial Buildings

What percent of newly constructed commercial buildings comply with the energy code? How much energy and cost could be saved if the compliance increased? Which code requirements have both low compliance rates and high savings potential? These are the questions U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) is trying to answer through its Commercial Energy Code Field Study. Previous commercial studies have been very limited and did not result in a widely accepted and tested methodology. DOE’s goal is to create a standardized methodology that can produce actionable results at a reasonable study cost, that can be used by state and local governments and utilities and provides valuable information to policy makers. The field study team implemented the pilot methodology, compiling a data set of 230 office and retail buildings in two climate zones. The approach is based on identifying lost savings on a total energy cost basis rather than simply counting the quantity of measures that do not meet code. This report is focused on the analysis of the collected data. The primary goal was to analyze the data collected during the field study and determine the actual energy cost impact of each measure in a non-compliance situation. The energy impact results allowed for ranking the measures to identify which have the highest potential for lost savings. These results combined with the time required to verify each measure will allow future compliance verification to focus on measures that had a large impact on energy use over the life of the building and those that have the greatest savings recovery potential per verification hour.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗

Data Analysis of Energy Code Compliance in Commercial Buildings (Rev. 1)

What percent of newly constructed commercial buildings comply with the energy code? How much energy and cost could be saved if the compliance increased? Which code requirements have both low compliance rates and high savings potential? These are the questions U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) is trying to answer through its Commercial Energy Code Field Study. Previous commercial studies have been very limited and did not result in a widely accepted and tested methodology. DOE’s goal is to create a standardized methodology that can produce actionable results at a reasonable study cost, that can be used by state and local governments and utilities and provides valuable information to policy makers. The field study team implemented the pilot methodology, compiling a data set of 230 office and retail buildings in two climate zones. The approach is based on identifying lost savings on a total energy cost basis rather than simply counting the quantity of measures that do not meet code. This report is focused on the analysis of the collected data. The primary goal was to analyze the data collected during the field study and determine the actual energy cost impact of each measure in a non-compliance situation. The energy impact results allowed for ranking the measures to identify which have the highest potential for lost savings. These results combined with the time required to verify each measure will allow future compliance verification to focus on measures that had a large impact on energy use over the life of the building and those that have the greatest savings recovery potential per verification hour.

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗