Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “saline”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,333 records · Page 74

Assessment of Brine Management for Geologic Carbon Sequestration

Geologic carbon sequestration (GCS) is the injection of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ), typically captured from stationary emission sources, into deep geologic formations to prevent its entry into the atmosphere. Active pilot facilities run by regional United States (US) carbon sequestration partnerships inject on the order of one million metric tonnes (mt) CO 2 annually while the US electric power sector emits over 2000 million mt-CO 2 annually. GCS is likely to play an increasing role in US carbon mitigation initiatives, but scaling up GCS poses several challenges. Injecting CO 2 into sedimentary basins raises fluid pressure in the pore space, which is typically already occupied by naturally occurring, or native, brine. The resulting elevated pore pressures increase the likelihood of induced seismicity, of brine or CO 2 escaping into potable groundwater resources, and of CO 2 escaping into the atmosphere. Brine extraction is one method for pressure management, in which brine in the injection formation is brought to the surface through extraction wells. Removal of the brine makes room for the CO 2 and decreases pressurization. Although the technology required for brine extraction is mature, this form of pressure management will only be applicable if there are cost-­effective and sustainable methods of disposing of the extracted brine. Brine extraction, treatment, and disposal may increase the already substantial capital, energy, and water demands of Carbon dioxide Capture and Sequestration (CCS). But, regionally specific brine management strategies may be able to treat the extracted water as a source of revenue, energy, and water to subsidize CCS costs, while minimizing environmental impacts. By this approach, value from the extracted water would be recovered before disposing of any resulting byproducts. Until a price is placed on carbon, we expect that utilities and other CO 2 sources will be reluctant to invest in capital intensive, high risk GCS projects; early technical, economic, and environmental assessments of brine management are extremely valuable for determining the potential role of GCS in the US. We performed a first order feasibility and economic assessment, at three different locations in the US, of twelve GCS extracted-­water management options, including: geothermal energy extraction, desalination, salt and mineral harvesting, rare-­earth element harvesting, aquaculture, algae biodiesel production, road de-­icing, enhanced geothermal system (EGS) recharge, underground reinjection, landfill disposal, ocean disposal, and evaporation pond disposal. Three saline aquifers from different regions of the US were selected as hypothetical GCS project sites to encompass variation in parameters that are relevant to the feasibility and economics of brine disposal. The three aquifers are the southern Mt. Simon Sandstone Formation in the Illinois Basin, IL; the Vedder Formation in the southern San Joaquin Basin, CA; and the Jasper Interval in the eastern Texas Gulf Basin, TX. These aquifers are candidates for GCS due to their physical characteristics and their close proximity to large CO 2 emission sources. Feasibility and impacts were calculated using one mt-­CO 2 injected as the functional unit of brine management. Scenarios were performed for typical 1000MW coal-­fired power plants (CFPP) that incurred an assumed 24 percent carbon capture energy penalty (EP), injected 90 percent of CO 2 emissions (~9 million mt-­ CO 2 injected annually), and treated extracted water onsite. Net present value (NPV), land requirements, laws and regulations, and technological limits were determined for each stage of disposal, and used to estimate feasibility. The boundary of the assessment began once extracted water was brought to the surface, and ended once the water evaporated, was injected underground, or was discharged into surface water bodies. Results of the assessment were generated, stored, and analyzed using Microsoft Excel spreadsheets and ESRI Geographical Information System (GIS) maps. Conclusions about the relative benefits and impacts of alternative brine-­management strategies were highly sensitive to local climate and weather, and aquifer water chemistry. The NPV of certain scenarios ranged from -­$50/mt-­CO 2 (a cost) to +$10/mt-­CO 2 (revenue). The land footprint of the scenarios in this study ranged from <1 km 2 to 100 km 2 . Brine extraction as a pressure management tool for GCS has potential for improving the economics and for minimizing the environmental impacts of CCS. In order to maximize this potential, careful analysis of each saline aquifer and region must be conducted to determine a regionally appropriate brine use sequence (BUS) at the time of site selection. Models that use GIS will be essential tools in determining such sequences for individual CFPP. Future studies that perform risk and life cycle assessments (LCA) of BUS scenarios, incorporate additional impact metrics into the BUS model, and enhance the temporal sensitivity of the model would improve the robustness of this regional assessment method.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Borehole EM Monitoring at Aquistore: Final Report to the Carbon Capture Project (CCP)

Geologic carbon sequestration (GCS) is a technology whose goal is to prevent atmospheric release of greenhouse gases via injection of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) into an underground reservoir for long term storage. GCS is typically part of a program of carbon capture and storage (CCS) that captures CO 2 from point sources such as power plants, transports the CO 2 to a storage site, and operates an injection facility. One recent CCS pilot project is the Aquistore CO 2 sequestration project, near Estevan, Saskatchewan, Canada. The Aquistore project is managed by the Petroleum Technology Research Centre (PTRC) and will be one of the first integrated CCS projects storing CO 2 in a deep saline aquifer from a coal fired power plant (PTRC, 2011). Aquistore is expected to store 500,000 tons of CO 2 during its lifetime (Ministry of Environment, 2012). Assuring the long-term, safe storage of CO 2 requires the development of effective monitoring strategies. As part of the geophysical monitoring effort at Aquistore, there were initial plans for deployment of borehole electrodes for electrical or electromagnetic measurements to monitor CO 2 within the reservoir. The injected CO 2 displaces saline brine in the reservoir, and because CO 2 has a high resistivity compared to brine, the overall resistivity of the formation increases and can be monitored by measuring electric or magnetic fields. Previous work by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL) had indicated that borehole-to-surface electromagnetic monitoring, using an electric dipole source near the bottom of a well penetrating the reservoir, could detect the resistivity change induced by GCS. To assess the potential application of electromagnetic monitoring at Aquistore, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and Multi-Phase Technologies collaborated on a two-part study including (1) numerical forward modeling of a time-lapse, controlled-source electromagnetic (CSEM) monitoring survey, and (2) an initial engineering study of instrumentation and proposed design for a borehole electric dipole source and electrode sensors.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Offsetting Water Requirements and Stress with Enhanced Water Recovery from CO 2 Storage

Carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) operations ultimately require injecting and storing CO 2 into deep saline aquifers. Reservoir pressure typically rises as CO 2 is injected increasing the cost and risk of CCUS and decreasing viable storage within the formation. Active management of the reservoir pressure through the extraction of brine can reduce the pressurization while providing a number of benefits including increased storage capacity for CO 2 , reduced risks linked to reservoir overpressure, and CO 2 plume management. Through enhanced water recovery (EWR), brine within the saline aquifer can be extracted and treated through desalination technologies which could be used to offset the water requirements for thermoelectric power plants or local water needs such as agriculture, or produce a marketable such as lithium through mineral extraction. This paper discusses modeled scenarios of CO 2 injection into the Rock Springs Uplift (RSU) formation in Wyoming with EWR. The Finite Element Heat and Mass Transfer Code (FEHM), developed by Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL), was used to model CO 2 injection with brine extraction and the corresponding pressure tradeoffs. Scenarios were compared in order to analyze how pressure management through the quantity and location of brine extraction wells can increase CO 2 storage capacity and brine extraction while reducing risks associated with over pressurization. Future research will couple a cost-benefit analysis to these simulations in order to determine if the benefit of subsurface pressure management and increase CO 2 storage capacity can outweigh multiple extraction wells with increased cost of installation and maintenance as well as treatment and/or disposal of the extracted brine.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Identifying Differences in Abiotic Stress Gene Networks between Lowland and Upland Ecotypes of Switchgrass (DE-SC0008338)

Switchgrass (Panicum virgatum) is a warm-season C4 grass that is a target lignocellulosic biofuel species for use in the United States due to its local adaption capabilities and high biomass accumulation. Two ecotypes of switchgrass have been described. Members of the lowland ecotype are taller, have narrower leaf blades and generate more biomass compared to individuals from the upland ecotype. Additionally, lowland plants are generally found in the southern United States while upland switchgrass is more typically present in the northern United States. These differences are important as it is envisioned that switchgrass for biofuel production will typically be grown on marginal lands in the northern United States to supplement and diversify farmers' traditional crop incomes. While lowland switchgrass is more productive, it has poor winter survivability in northern latitudes where upland switchgrass is expected to be grown for biofuel use. Abiotic stresses likely to be encountered by switchgrass include drought and salinity. Despite initially being described as preferring wetter environments, members of the lowland ecotype have been characterized as being more drought tolerant than plants of the upland ecotype. Nonetheless, direct trials have indicated that variation for drought tolerance exists in both ecotypes, but prior to this project, only a relatively small number of switchgrass lines had been tested for drought responses. Similarly, switchgrass cultivars have not been widely tested for salt tolerance, but a few studies have shown that even mild salt stress can inhibit growth. The effects of drought and salt stress on plant growth are complex. Both drought and salinity affect the osmotic potential of plant cells and negatively affect plant growth due to reduced water potential and reduced photosynthesis that results from lower stomatal conductance of CO 2 . Plants respond to drought and salt stress by activating genes that directly attempt to reduce the stress (e.g., transmembrane pumps that partition Na + ) and mitigate the effects of the stress (e.g., synthesis of osmoprotectant metabolites and stress-related signaling compounds). Prior to the start of this project, no gene expression analysis had been performed on switchgrass under conditions of drought or salt stress, and therefore, relevant gene networks responding to drought and salt stress were unknown in switchgrass. In this project, we performed drought, salt and alkali-salt screens on 49 switchgrass cultivars (Liu et al 2014; Liu et al 2015; Hu et al 2015; Kim et al 2016). These experiments demonstrated that a wide range of variation exists within switchgrass for drought, salt and alkali-salt tolerance and that, while the lowland ecotype of switchgrass is often considered more tolerant of abiotic stresses, there are some upland switchgrass lines that are also very tolerant of drought, salt and alkali-salt stress. We also conducted drought and salt time course experiments with Alamo and Dacotah. We have identified modules of coexpressed genes that differentiate Alamo and Dacotah drought responses. We are continuing to analyze these results and plan to submit manuscripts describing this work in early 2017. In an effort to show how drought- and salt-related gene modules could be dissected, we generated transgenic switchgrass overexpressing either PvGTγ-1 or ZmDREB2. Increased expression of PvGTγ-1 does confer increased salt tolerance, and we were able to identify genes that are induced and suppressed by PvGTγ-1. Overexpression of ZmDREB2 increases drought tolerance in switchgrass. Analysis of the PvGTγ-1 and ZmDREB2 overexpression work is ongoing, and we plan to prepare manuscripts about these experiments for submission in early 2017.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗

Impact of CO 2 on the Evolution of Microbial Communities Exposed to Carbon Storage Conditions, Enhanced Oil Recovery, and CO 2 Leakage

Geologic carbon storage (GCS) is a crucial part of a proposed mitigation strategy to reduce the anthropogenic carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) emissions to the atmosphere. During this process, CO 2 is injected as super critical carbon dioxide (SC-CO 2 ) in confined deep subsurface storage units, such as saline aquifers and depleted oil reservoirs. The deposition of vast amounts of CO 2 in subsurface geologic formations could unintentionally lead to CO 2 leakage into overlying freshwater aquifers. Introduction of CO 2 into these subsurface environments will greatly increase the CO 2 2 concentration and will create CO 2 concentration gradients that drive changes in the microbial communities present. While it is expected that altered microbial communities will impact the biogeochemistry of the subsurface, there is no information available on how CO 2 gradients will impact these communities. The overarching goal of this project is to understand how CO 2 exposure will impact subsurface microbial communities at temperatures and pressures that are relevant to GCS and CO 2 leakage scenarios. To meet this goal, unfiltered, aqueous samples from a deep saline aquifer, a depleted oil reservoir, and a fresh water aquifer were exposed to varied concentrations of CO 2 at reservoir pressure and temperature. The microbial ecology of the samples was examined using molecular, DNA-based techniques. The results from these studies were also compared across the sites to determine any existing trends. Results reveal that increasing CO 2 leads to decreased DNA concentrations regardless of the site, suggesting that microbial processes will be significantly hindered or absent nearest the CO 2 injection/leakage plume where CO 2 concentrations are highest. At CO 2 exposures expected downgradient from the CO 2 plume, selected microorganisms emerged as dominant in the CO 2 exposed conditions. Results suggest that the altered microbial community was site specific and highly dependent on pH. The site-dependent results suggest a limited ability to predict the emerging dominant species for other CO 2 exposed environments. This study improves the understanding of how a subsurface microbial community may respond to conditions expected from GCS and CO 2 leakage. This is the first step for understanding how a CO 2 -altered microbial community may impact injectivity, permanence of stored CO 2 , and subsurface water quality. Future work with microbial communities from new subsurface sites would increase the current understanding of this project. Additionally, incorporation of metagenomic methods would increase understanding of potential microbial processes that may be prevalent in CO 2 exposed environments.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Enhanced Analytical Simulation Tool (EASiTool) for CO 2 Storage Capacity Estimation and Uncertainty Quantification

An enhanced analytical simulation tool (EASiTool) was developed to estimate CO 2 storage capacity in saline aquifers. The tool provides a quantitative estimate of storage capacity for multi-well injection/extraction systems by applying novel analytical models for both closed- and open-boundary saline aquifers and analyzes the potential of enhancing storage efficiency by integrating active brine management (brine extraction technology). Brine extraction would enhance the storage capacity and partially control the pressure buildup. EASiTool includes a user-friendly interface and can be used to provide reservoir and basin-scale storage capacity estimates.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

High Ion-Accessible Surface Area CNT-Ultracapacitors for Groundwater Desalination

Fresh water is a vital resource for human survival, as well as a key component for a wide range of industrial and agricultural needs. However, only 0.65% of the world’s water resources are available as fresh water, and the demand on the world’s water reserves continues to rise, with the demand already beginning to outpace the supply in many areas. A water-energy nexus is being reached that requires low -cost and -energy solutions for various degrees of treated water. Public awareness of the problem has also risen, such that in a 2012 survey, 88% of Americans reported concerns about potential water shortages. Approximately two-thirds of the world’s population could suffer water shortages over the next few years. Seawater and other saline water supplies make up around 98% of the world’s accessible water. Properly treated to reduce the levels of salinity, this represents an almost unlimited supply of fresh water. The high energy requirements, capital costs, and maintenance requirements to remove salts and other unwanted compounds, however, are barriers to widespread implementation of salt-to-freshwater facilities. These facilities most commonly use reverse osmosis (RO) systems that suffer from high required pressures and failures of moving parts; additionally, these facilities consume much grid energy and require constant maintenance, leading to high capital and operational costs. The RO process also generates large volumes of highly concentrated bio-hazardous brine that is costly to safely return to the ocean. In contrast to RO, capacitive desalination or capacitive deionization (CDI) has fewer moving parts (a low-pressure pump and several valves), operates at low pressure, and does not generate large quantities of brine that are hazardous to marine life. The capacitive charge/discharge of a CDI system can be cycled almost indefinitely, and the system has low energy requirements because the capacitive discharge electrical current can be co-generated back to the system. RO must remove the water from the salt while CDI removes the salt from the water. This represents a significant difference in the number of molecules which must be moved and energy required to desalinate water. However, CDI has not seen widespread use for large- or small-scale desalination because electrode efficiency has limited the extraction rate below what is useful for most applications. Mainstream demonstrated the following successes during this SBIR program: Performance - We developed an innovative new electrode structure for the high-efficiency removal of ions from salt-contaminated water samples by CDI. Based on prototype electrochemical tests, our CDI consumes as low as 0.71 kW/m 3 of treated water (compared to 2.9 to 3.7 kW/m 3 for RO). Scalability – During Phase II, we increased the electrode size from 3.8 cm 2 single-sided electrodes to 180 cm 2 double-sided electrodes. Using larger acid baths and CVD furnace, we increased electrode fabrication capacity increased by 315 times. Scalable electrochemical CDI stack design and balance of plant – During Phase II, we demonstrated at scalable low-pressure drop stack design and balance of plant for the continuous removal of ions. Corrosion Resistance – Based on accelerated corrosion testing data, our high-quality graphitic electrodes have a significantly improved corrosion resistance. This was 20 times better corrosion resistance than our Phase I electrodes and significantly higher than typical CDI system electrodes. Flexibility –By tuning the pore size of the electrode materials, we demonstrated the removal of key target ionic contaminants, such as sodium chloride, nitrate, and phosphate salts. These ionic contaminants are common in agricultural and industrial wastewater runoff and are difficult to remove by conventional methods, which require excessive use of reagents.

Cox, Dr. Philip↗

Case Study: Nuclear-Renewable-Water Integration in Arizona

This document reports the application of the N-R HES software framework to a case study for Arizona Public Service (APS); the manager and part owner of the Palo Verde (PV) nuclear power plant. The case study is a work in progress of which this report presents a detailed description of the current model input data, assumptions and the corresponding results produced by the developed software framework. The goal of the report is, that with this information APS (together with INL) should be able to identify where more detailed data and more accurate model assumptions are necessary to reproduce all driving physical and economic phenomena in order to capture enough complexity of the reality to allow APS to use the results for their strategic decisions. The N-R HES software framework started being developed at INL two years ago [ref]. The framework has reached some level of maturity so that it can be applied to more than simple demonstration cases, e.g. real industry problems. Nevertheless, more capabilities are constantly added to accommodate the special needs of these challenging real life problems. The N-R HES framework is built on top of the RAVEN code [ref] and uses it as driver and workflow manager for all calculations. The framework has specifically been developed for the economic assessment of N-R HES systems. There are four main cornerstones of the N-R HES simulation framework: 1) generation of stochastic time series, 2) a probabilistic analysis and optimization set of algorithms available in RAVEN, 3) a set of models for representation of the physical behavior of N-R HES, and 4) a RAVEN plug-in that maps physical performance into economic performance called CashFlow. Within this framework, a broad spectrum of questions related to N-R HES can be addressed. One of the challenges currently of high interest is that the increasing penetration of variable renewables is altering the profile of the net demand (demand after removing all non curtailable renewable energy sources), with which the other generators on the grid have to cope. The N-R HES software framework is capable to analyze the potential feasibility of mitigating the resultant volatility in the net electricity demand. One possible solution to that problem currently intensively studied by the energy industry is adding stabilizing loads to the grid. These loads can be external industrial processes that are able to ramp production up and down quickly or adding variable internal loads that will lift the base load of the power plant. The latter is a possible solution currently studied by APS. APS if currently anticipating several challenges that will likely arise in the near future. One of them is, as mentioned, coping with the rapid growth of variable renewable energy (VRE) sources put on the grid. Although APS can sell its electricity for a fixed retail price to cover the local demand first, it also sells electricity in excess of the local demand at the Palo Verde energy hub. Due to the growing VRE penetration, the Palo Verde hub electricity spot price is negative more and more frequently. To mitigate this price volatility, APS is seeking to add more base load, so that the quantity of excess energy to be sold for prices potentially less than the internal retail price or even negative prices at the hub is reduced. A second challenge APS is facing is that their cooling water acquisition contract with the Sub Regional Operating Group (SROG) will expire soon and a renewal can only be done for a significantly higher price of the water. Therefore, APS is also seeking for alternative sources for their cooling water. An opportunity currently under investigation is to pump a limited quantity of brackish water from the regional ground water. Although much cheaper than the water from the new SROG contract, the salinity of the brackish water is so high that a blend of brackish and SROG water would need additional treatment to improve its quality for use in the cooling towers. An on-site reverse osmosis (RO) desalination plant is envisaged to reduce the salinity to an acceptable level. This report investigates the economic impact of such an RO plant. As one can see, the RO plant would help with both problems APS is facing: First, it would rise the APS base load helping to mitigate VRE induced hub price volatility. From this perspective, the RO plant can be seen as a stabilizing load on the grid as would be any other industrial process. Second, the RO’s goods, e.g. the clean water produced can be used by APS itself for a (hopefully) lower cost than 100% SROG water would be. The report will first describe the APS water procurement strategy in detail and lay out the possible alternative scenarios studied in this document. This is covered in Chapter 2. Next, in Chapter 3, the APS case model developed within the N-R HES software framework is described. This chapter includes also a description of the needed framework developments to accommodate the APS study.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Carbon Dioxide Storage and Utilization near Mingo County, West Virginia

Six oil fields within 100 miles of the planned coal-to-liquids facility in Mingo County were found to be prospective for miscible CO 2 -EOR. Four of the oil fields fall along a straight line and could, in concept, be developed sequentially along a single CO 2 pipeline. The total demand for purchased CO 2 from these four fields is estimated to be 47 million metric tons (890 Bcf) over 20 years. Four saline formations within Mingo County could accommodate 50 million metric tons of CO 2 (accounts for uncertainty and a &'buffer zone”). The combined storage capacity – EOR within 100 miles of Mingo County and saline within Mingo County – can accommodate 3 million metric tons per year of vented CO 2 for over 30 years Conclusion: there is enough potential for CO 2 utilization and storage that a next level of study is a reasonable course.

03 NATURAL GAS↗

Underground Natural Gas Storage – Analog Studies to Geologic Storage of CO 2

This study focuses on underground natural gas storage operations and CO 2 geologic storage in saline-bearing formations; both individually and in relation to each other. This study is the first of three that evaluate analog industries of CO 2 storage (second focuses on deep well waste disposal using U.S. EPA UIC Class I wells and third on CO 2 EOR). Several pieces of information can be found throughout the study including overview of underground natural gas storage history and side-by-side comparisons of major synergistic features between underground natural gas storage and CO 2 storage in saline-bearing formations. Best practices and lessons learned from underground natural gas storage operations can provide perspective from which future CO 2 storage R&amp;D pursuits and field projects can benefit. A summary document providing a high-level overview and key takeaways of this study is available on NETL’s website under the Collection Name: NETL’s Analog Studies to Geologic Storage of CO 2 .

03 NATURAL GAS↗

UIC Class I Injection Wells – Analog Studies to Geologic Storage of CO 2

This study focuses on deep well waste disposal operations (non-hazardous and hazardous) using U.S. EPA UIC Class I wells and CO 2 geologic storage in saline-bearing formations; both individually and in relation to each other. This study is the second of three that evaluate analog industries of CO 2 storage (first focuses on underground natural gas storage and third on CO 2 EOR). Several pieces of information can be found throughout the study including overview of deep well waste disposal history and side-by-side comparisons of major synergistic features between deep well waste disposal and CO 2 storage in saline-bearing formations. Best practices and lessons learned from deep well waste disposal operations can provide perspective from which future CO 2 storage R&D pursuits and field projects can benefit. A summary document providing a high-level overview and key takeaways of this study is available on NETL’s website under the Collection Name:NETL’s Analog Studies to Geologic Storage of CO 2 .

03 NATURAL GAS↗

CO 2 Leakage During EOR Operations – Analog Studies to Geologic Storage of CO 2

This study focuses on CO 2 EOR operations and CO 2 geologic storage in saline-bearing formations; both individually and in relation to each other. This study is the third of three that evaluate analog industries of CO 2 storage (first focuses on underground natural gas storage and second on deep well waste disposal using U.S. EPA UIC Class I wells). Several pieces of information can be found throughout the study including overview of CO 2 EOR history and side-by-side comparisons of major synergistic features between CO 2 EOR and CO 2 storage in saline-bearing formations. Best practices and lessons learned from CO 2 EOR operations can provide perspective from which future CO 2 storage R&D pursuits and field projects can benefit. A summary document providing a high-level overview and key takeaways of this study is available on NETL’s website under the Collection Name: NETL’s Analog Studies to Geologic Storage of CO 2 .

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Integrated Commercial Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) Prefeasibility Study at Dry Fork Station, Wyoming

The study focuses on the Basin Electric Dry Fork Power Station (DFS), the newest coal-fired power plant operating in the lower 48 states. DFS began operation in 2011 and has an operating lifetime of approximately 80 years, is a 420 MW plant, and emits roughly 3.3 million metric tonnes (Mt) of CO 2 per annum. Adjacent to DFS is the Wyoming Integrated Test Center (ITC). The ITC provides space and access to DFS flue gas for researchers to test CO 2 utilization and CO 2 capture technologies. The objective of this study is to identify saline storage opportunities proximal to DFS and the ITC in the Powder River Basin. The objectives of the prefeasibility study were as follows: (1) to establish a CCS coordination team capable of achieving a successful implementation of commercial-scale CCS for the Dry Fork Power Station; (2) to develop site-specific business and execution strategies; and (3) to identify and describe promising saline storage sites capable of storing 50 million metric tons of CO 2 .

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Quality Guidelines for Energy System Studies: CO 2 Impurity Design Parameters

This section of the Quality Guidelines for Energy System Studies (QGESS) provides recommended impurity limits for carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) stream components for use in conceptual studies of CO 2 carbon capture, utilization, and storage systems. These limits were developed from information consolidated from numerous studies and are presented by component and application. Impurity levels are provided for carbon steel pipelines, sequestration through enhanced oil recovery (EOR), saline aquifer sequestration (SAS), and co-sequestration of CO 2 and hydrogen sulfide (H2S) in saline reservoirs. This QGESS is intended as a guideline only for conceptual studies under a generic scenario and should not be used for actual projects, which are likely to have requirements that differ from the generic scenario assumed herein.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Case Study: Integrate Nuclear Water Desalination - Regional Potable Water in Arizona

The present study analyzes the economic viability of an Integrated Energy System (IES) that couples a Reverse Osmosis (RO) water desalination facility with a Nuclear Power Plant (NPP). The case study is conducted in collaboration with Arizona Public Service (APS), the operating owner of the Palo Verde Generating Station (PVGS) NPP. Cooling water for the reactor steam cycle is derived from treated effluent from municipal wastewater treatment plants. APS has established a long-term water resources program to effect a substantial reduction in plant cooling costs through advanced treatment and cooling technologies, and through the use of alternative water sources to replace the increasingly expensive effluent. One possible option is to replace some amount of the annual volume of effluent with brackish groundwater from a local regional aquifer. Although much less expensive than the municipal effluent, the quantity of brackish groundwater that could be used for plant cooling is limited as a result of the salinity and its impact on plant operation. Consequently, supplemental treatment could be required such that a greater amount of brackish groundwater could be used to reduce the demand on effluent. A study was conducted in 2018 by Idaho National Laboratory (INL) to investigate the economics of a PVGS onsite RO desalination plant that would reduce the salinity of a municipal effluent and brackish water blend to an acceptable level. One of the main findings of that study was that the overall economics of water desalination can be greatly improved if, in addition to cooling water for PVGS, potable water could also be produced and sold for profit. In fact, the study concluded that only producing cooling water for PVGS via RO desalination is not economically viable. The present report investigates the economic impact of a large, regional RO desalination plant that could provide potable water for the region, considering the conclusions from the 2018 scoping study. The study looks in particular at the water-market situation for the developing municipalities in the west valley of Phoenix. In addition to providing potable water for the municipalities, the existing infrastructure that conveys effluent to the Palo Verde plant and onsite water treatment facilities could be used to manage the RO concentrate. The processed concentrate could lead to a cost reduction in plant cooling by replacing some amount of effluent. The analysis reported here considers two cases (for various scenarios). First, the Base Case considers that neither the regional nor the onsite RO is built. The 2018 INL study showed that some brackish water can be blended with the municipal effluent water without having to build the onsite RO. That correspond to the maximum economically profitable option. The Base Case is where APS pumps the maximum volume of less-expensive brackish water (limited by water chemistry in the circulating water system), i.e. the case for which cooling water acquisition and treatment cost are lowest (without RO). Second, the proposed RO Case includes two RO plants, one onsite at PVGS and another larger, regional RO plant close to the brackish water wells. The regional RO produces potable water that is sold to the regional municipalities, while the PVGS onsite RO treats (part of) the regional ROs' concentrate and brackish water blend. The desalinated water from the PVGS RO is used in the circulating water system at PVGS. The analysis evaluates the difference in economics, using the Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR), between the cases. By comparing the two cases, in addition to evaluating the economics of the regional RO, we can also assess the impact of the regional RO on PVGS operational costs and, consequently, APS economics. The study shows that there exist combinations of regional RO and PVGS RO sizes for which the total blowdown and water chemistry limits at PVGS (including regional RO concentrate treatment at PVGS) are satisfied. However, such combinations only exist if no additional brackish water is directly mixed in the tertiary water system at PVGS. This leads to higher Levelized Costs of Potable Water (LCOPW) compared to cases where additional brackish water is injected (but violate the physical constraints). Additional studies are suggested to investigate the benefit of additional brackish water injection (lowers cooling water cost) versus the cost of lifting the physical constraints, e.g. building additional evaporation ponds. Staying in the case of no additional brackish water and satisfying the existing PVGS constraints, the lowest LCOPW (~0.5 $/m 3 ) can be achieved with a size of the regional RO of ~1.4e7 m 3 /yr (11000 AF/yr) capacity, which leads to ~8.63e6 m 3 /yr (7000 AF/yr) of potable water while no onsite RO at PVGS is built. Considering the vii residential water demand model developed for the Phoenix west valley, the NPV for this regional RO would be ~$100 million if all municipalities in the vicinity participate from the beginning of the project.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

The Consortium for Advanced Sorghum Phenomics (CASP). Final report

The goal of CASP was to accelerate breeding of biomass sorghum [Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench] by identifying genotypes exhibiting high yield under well-watered, pre- or post-drought and/or salinity-stress conditions. We did this by combining high-throughput, non-invasive drone phenotyping with genomics and molecular profiling. Field-based phenotyping utilized a multi-modal sensor suite of LiDAR, multispectral cameras, and thermal cameras mounted on a commercial drone to detect traits required for yield prediction and selection of drought and saline tolerant lines of sorghum. Traits of interest included plant height (PH), leaf area index (LAI), wet biomass (BMW), and biomass at 65% moisture (BM65) and were measured from emergence to harvest on a weekly basis over three growing seasons. The final output were measurements of traits on a plot-by-plot basis, identified by the plot ID used by the Proprietary data processing software enabled raw field data to be turned into plant traits and delivered to the PNNL and JGI within the same workday.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Charged Wellbore Casing Controlled Source Electromagnetics (CWC-CSEM) for Reservoir Imaging and Monitoring (Final report)

This project addresses the needs of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) to develop advanced monitoring technologies and protocols to track the fate of subsurface carbon dioxide (CO2) plumes for carbon storage. Specifically, the project seeks to develop and test a unique and novel system of technologies consisting of electromagnetic data acquisition, coupled multiphysics imaging, and reservoir model enhancement to understand the migration and long-term distribution of CO2 in the subsurface. The overarching objective is to develop an integrated approach for long term monitoring of carbon storage. The two main components of the project include the methodology development and the test of the method at a field site. The methodology component consists of 1) developing the field procedure and protocol for collecting time-lapse controlled-source electromagnetic (CSEM) data with source electric current injected into the subsurface through wellbore casings; 2) building of background 3D electrical conductivity utilizing multiple sources of data such as supplemental surface transient EM (TEM) surveys, well-logs, and seismic structural information, for enhancing CSEM signal from reservoir depths; and 3) coupled multiphysics simulations and inversion of CSEM data constrained by production data and by structural information from seismic imaging of the reservoir and overlying formations. The testing component used the field site of Bell Creek Oil Field, which served both as a field laboratory for the method development as well as a test site to evaluate the CSEM signal strengths and the methodology developed in this research project. We have accomplished all the proposed tasks and developed the methodology as planned. These include the procedure for time-lapse CSEM data acquisition, data processing techniques, integration with 3D conductivity model building, fast reservoir simulation for history matching using machine learning, and interpreting CSEM data with coupling to the reservoir modeling. Collectively, the outcome of these tasks form a coherent workflow that can be applied to monitor dedicated carbon storage in saline reservoirs. The testing component evaluated the applicability and limitations of the method, and concluded that the method would be ideal for monitoring dedicated carbon storage sites utilizing saline reservoirs.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

SECARB Regional Project Assessment

The SECARB Cranfield Early Test Project was designed to safely demonstrate large-scale, long-term CO 2 injection and storage in a CO 2 -enhanced oil recovery (EOR) operation and associated saline reservoir. Storage during EOR operations has the potential to offset commercial costs, holding a significant promise for future large-scale deployment in the southeastern United States. Denbury Onshore LLC began CO 2 -EOR operations in July 2008 at the Cranfield oilfield located east of Natchez, Mississippi (Figure 1). The location offered an ideal setting to investigate storage monitoring at a commercial CO 2 -EOR operation. The field team, led by the Gulf Coast Carbon Center of the Bureau of Economic Geology at the University of Texas at Austin, deployed the largest suite of monitoring, verification, accounting (MVA) technologies to collect data to assess long-term CO 2 utilization and storage. The CO 2 injection interval is within the 3,000-meter-deep fluvial lower Tuscaloosa Formation, a large and regionally extensive saline reservoir, at a broad four-way structural closure that defines the Cranfield oilfield. Tests were conducted in the oil-producing area as well as in the non-oil-producing brine aquifer. The CO 2 used during EOR operation was transported via pipeline from the Jackson Dome, a natural source of CO 2 . The study focused on four integrated research areas: (1) the High-Volume Injection Test area (HiVIT); (2) the Detailed Area of Study (DAS); (3) the Geomechanical area; and (4) the near-surface observatory, also called the “P-site.” CO 2 injection occurred at the HiVIT and the DAS (Figure 2 and Figure 3). The DAS was located down-dip of the oil-water interface of the Cranfield oilfield. The well layout included one injection well and two down-dip observation wells. The team was the first of the regional partnerships to monitor more than 1 million metric tons of CO 2 . At the end of the project, the team monitored more than 11 million metric tons of CO 2 injected and 5 million metric tons of CO 2 stored. The Cranfield Project was the fifth project worldwide, and the first such project in the United States, to reach this CO 2 injection volume while being monitored to demonstrate storage effectiveness.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗