Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “INTERSTELLAR GRAINS”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,333 records · Page 74

A two-dimensional particle-in-cell model of a dusty plasma

Dusty plasmas are present in comets, in the ring systems of the outer planets, and in the interstellar medium. A two-dimensional particle-in-cell (PIC) model of a dusty plasma is presented in this paper. The PIC code is best suited for modeling the plasma-dust interaction for large grains, with diameters of the order of a centimeter. We have modeled the charging process for an individual dust grain and the associated potential pattern in the surrounding plasma. We have also considered the case of a large number of grains in a plasma, with intergrain separations of the order of the Debye length, and have shown that the plasma becomes depleted and the charge on a dust grain is reduced, as other workers in this field have predicted (cf. C. K. Goertz, 1989). We examine the electron and ion distribution functions in the vicinity of a charged grain and demonstrate that the ions near a grain have clearly been accelerated by the electrostatic potential.

Young, B.↗

An evolutionary system of mineralogy. Part II: Interstellar and solar nebula primary condensation mineralogy (>4.565 Ga)

The evolutionary system of mineralogy relies on varied physical and chemical attributes, including trace elements, isotopes, solid and fluid inclusions, and other information-rich characteristics, to understand processes of mineral formation and to place natural condensed phases in the deep-time context of planetary evolution. Part I of this system reviewed the earliest refractory phases that condense at T > 1000 K within the turbulent expanding and cooling atmospheres of highly evolved stars. Part II considers the subsequent formation of primary crystalline and amorphous phases by condensation in three distinct mineral-forming environments, each of which increased mineralogical diversity and distribution prior to the accretion of planetesimals >4.5 billion years ago. (1) Interstellar molecular solids: Varied crystalline and amorphous molecular solids containing primarily H, C, O, and N are observed to condense in cold, dense molecular clouds in the interstellar medium (10 < T < 20 K; P < 10−13 atm). With the possible exception of some nanoscale organic condensates preserved in carbonaceous meteorites, the existence of these phases is documented primarily by telescopic observations of absorption and emission spectra of interstellar molecules in radio, microwave, or infrared wavelengths. (2) Nebular and circumstellar ice: Evidence from infrared observations and laboratory experiments suggest that cubic H2O (“cubic ice”) condenses as thin crystalline mantles on oxide and silicate dust grains in cool, distant nebular and circumstellar regions where T ~100 K. (3) Primary condensed phases of the inner solar nebula: The earliest phase of nebular mineralogy saw the formation of primary refractory minerals that solidified through high-temperature condensation (1100 < T < 1800 K; 10−6 < P < 10−2 atm) in the solar nebula more than 4.565 billion years ago. These earliest mineral phases originating in our solar system formed prior to the accretion of planetesimals and are preserved in calcium-aluminum-rich inclusions, ultra-refractory inclusions, and amoeboid olivine aggregates.

Shaunna M. Morrison↗

Quantative Measurements of Trace Elements and Three-Dimensional Atomic Scale Characterisation of Presolar O-rich Oxides and Silicates: An Atom Probe Tomography Approach

Presolar grains are recordsof a single moment in stellar evolution which have survived nebula and parent body processingwithin our Solar System. These grains condensed within a range of stellar envi-ronments including asymptotic giant branch stars, red giant branch stars, nova, supernova (SN) and hydrogen burning electron capture supernova(ECSN)[1,2]. Iso-topic and chemical compositions can be used to unravel details about environmental conditions at the time of their condensation and physical and chemical processes occurring at the time. For example,nucleosynthesis, stellar evolution, physical properties of stellar atmos-pheres, mixing from inner core to outer envelope, galac-tic chemical evolution, interstellar medium and parent body processing.NanoSIMS enables detailed characterisation of iso-topic compositions and rapid in situidentification of O-rich presolar oxides and silicates using their character-istic 17O/16O and 18O/16O isotopic ratios.Spectroscopic techniques e.g., auger spectroscopyand transmission electron microscopy, have provided additional details on major and minor chemical signatures. However, due tospatial resolution limitations,interaction volumes and interferencesfrom surrounding grains for in situtech-niques, attaining quantative characterisation of trace el-ements,hasproved challenging[1,3]. As the most sensitive geochemical tracers of envi-ronmental changes, trace elements are essential to un-ravelling the geochemical record of their parent stellar environments and evolutionary pathways[4].We car-ried out correlated in situisotopic and chemical analyses of 13 presolar grains to better understand stellar evolu-tion. In this work, we achieved this using a custom ap-proach, coordinating NanoSIMS, Scanning Electron Microscopy Energy Dispersive X-Ray Spectroscopy (SEM-EDX)and Atom Probe Tomography(APT).Our objective was to develop an approach which could ena-ble precise targeting of presolar grains for atom probe tomography and successfully execute atomic scale anal-yses of presolar oxides and silicates, to achieve quantative analysis of their trace elements for the first time.We also aimed to test the capability for Atom Probe tomography to measure isotopic compositions and stoichiometries of presolar oxide and silicate grains.

N D Nevill↗

Visible and ultraviolet /800-130 nm/ extinction of vapor-condensed silicate, carbon, and silicon carbide smokes and the interstellar extinction curve

The extinction curves from 800 to 130 nm (1.25-7.7/micron) of amorphous silicate smokes nominally of olivine and pyroxene composition, carbon smokes, and crystalline SiC smokes are presented. The SiC smoke occurred in the low-temperature (beta) cubic structural form. The SiC smoke showed an absorption edge which occurred at significantly longer wavelengths than the calculated extinction profile of the hexagonal SiC form previously used to calculate the interstellar extinction profile. Neither SiC nor amorphous silicates show an extinction band similar to the observed 6.6/micron astronomical extinction band. The infrared absorption peaks for the silicate and SiC samples near 10 microns and 11-13 microns, respectively, were also measured. The ultraviolet to infrared extinction ratio for the amorphous silicate samples is similar to the observed astronomical extinction ratio. The measured extinction ratios for SiC smokes are significantly below the interstellar extinction ratio. The extinction peak of the carbon smokes occurred at 4.0 and 4.25/micron, for samples of mean radii 13 and 6 nm, respectively. The extinction profile is distinctly different from that predicted for graphite grains of the same size, and is similar to that predicted for glassy carbon grains.

Stephens, J. R.↗

Galactic survey of interstellar abundances and selective extinction with IUE and IRAS

High resolution IUE spectra were used to derive ultraviolet extinction curves in the interstellar medium. Results confirm those of other surveys. The amount of gas, the dust temperature, and infrared cirrus emission do not alter the overall shape of the UV curve, but they do change the zero point. Cloud (grain) history may affect the overall slope of the UV extinction curve. The UV bump strength is related to the amount of far ultraviolet curvature. The bump strength appears to depend on the depletion of Mn and Zn but not on Si or Fe. The bump wavelength varies with the linear background of extinction.

Vansteenberg, Michael E.↗

New Interstellar Dust Models Consistent with Interstellar Extinction, Emission and Abundances Constraints

We present new interstellar dust models that are consistent with both, the FUV to near-IR extinction and infrared (IR) emission measurements from the diffuse interstellar medium. The models are characterized by different dust compositions and abundances. The problem we solve consists of determining the size distribution of the various dust components of the model. This problem is a typical ill-posed inversion problem which we solve using the regularization approach. We reproduce the Li Draine (2001, ApJ, 554, 778) results, however their model requires an excessive amount of interstellar silicon (48 ppM of hydrogen compared to the 36 ppM available for an ISM of solar composition) to be locked up in dust. We found that dust models consisting of PAHs, amorphous silicate, graphite, and composite grains made up from silicates, organic refractory, and water ice, provide an improved fit to the extinction and IR emission measurements, while still requiring a subsolar amount of silicon to be in the dust. This research was supported by NASA Astrophysical Theory Program NRA 99-OSS-01.

Zubko, V.↗

The interstellar medium in the starburst regions of NGC 253 and NGC 3256

We discuss observations of the (C II) 158 micrometers, (O I) 63 micrometers, (Si II) 35 micrometers, (O III) 52,88 micrometers, and (S III) 33 micrometers fine-structure transitions toward the central 45 seconds of the starburst galaxies NGC 253 and NGC 3256. The (C II) and (O I) emission probably originates in photodissociated gas at the surfaces of molecular clouds, although a small (less than or approximately 30%) contribution to the (C II) flux from H II regions cannot be ruled out. The (O III) and (S III) lines originate in H II regions and the (Si II) flux is best explained as originating in H II regions with some contribution from photodissociation regions (PDRs). The gas phase silicon abundance is nearly solar in NGC 253, which we interpret as evidence for grain destruction in the starburst region. We find that the photodissociated atomic gas has densities approximately 10(exp 4)/cu cm and temperature 200-300 K. About 2% of the gas is in this phase. The thermal gas pressure in the PDRs, P(PDR)/k approximately 1-3 x 10(exp 6) K/cu cm, might represent the 'typical' interstellar gas pressure in starburst systems. The Far Ultraviolet (FUV) radiation fields illuminating the clouds are 10(exp 3)-10(exp 4) stronger than the local Galactic FUV field and come from the contribution of many closely packed O and B stars. For the central 250 pc of NGC 253, we find that the H II gas has an average density n(sub e) is approximately 400/cu cm. This corresponds to a thermal pressure P(H II)/k approximately 7 x 10(exp 6) K/cu cm which is approximately P(PDR)/k, suggesting that the ionized gas is in pressure equilibrium with the photodissociated gas at the surfaces of molecular clouds. The H II gas fills a significant fraction, approximately 0.01-0.3, of the volume between the clouds. The effective temperature of the ionizing stars in NGC 253 is greater than or approximately 34,500 K; 2 x 10(exp 5) O7.5 stars would produce the observed Lyman countinuum photon luminosity. The average separation between the stars is approximately 3 pc. Applying the simple model for the interstellar medium in galactic nuclei of Wolfire, Tielens, & Hollenbach (1990), we find the molecular gas in the central regions of NGC 253 and NGC 3256 to be distributed in a large number (5 x 10(exp 3) to 5 x 10(exp 5)) of small (0.5-2 pc), dense (approximately 10(exp 4)/cu cm) clouds (or alternatively 'thin-flattened' structures) with volume filling factors 10(exp -3) to 10(exp -2), very different from the local Interstellar Medium (ISM) of the Galaxy. We suggest a self-consistent scenario for the ISM in NGC 253 in which clouds and H II gas are in pressure balance with a supernova-shocked, hot 1-3 x 10(exp 6) K, low-density (approximately 10(exp 4)/cu cm), all pervasive medium. A feedback mechanism may be indicated in which the pressure generated by the supernovae compresses the molecular clouds and triggers further massive star formation. The similarity of ISM parameters deduced for NGC 253, NGC 3256, and M82 (Lord et al. 1993) suggests that the ISM properties are independent of the luminosity of the starburst or the triggering mechanism, but are rather endemic to starburst systems. The starburst in NGC 3256 appears to be a scaled-up version of the NGC 253 and M82 starbursts.

Carral, P.↗

On the provenance of GEMS, a quarter century post discovery

The provenance of GEMS (glass with embedded metal and sulfides) in cometary type interplanetary dust particles is investigated using analytical scanning transmission electron microscopy and secondary ion mass spectrometry. We review the current state of knowledge and closely examine the densities, elemental compositions and distributions, iron oxidation states, and isotopic compositions of a subset of GEMS in chondritic porous interplanetary dust. We find that GEMS are underdense with estimated densities that are 35–65% of compositionally equivalent crystalline aggregates. GEMS low densities result in a lower contribution to the bulk compositions of IDPs than has been assumed based on their volume fraction. We also find that element/Si ratios, assumed to be primary (indigenous), are instead perturbed by contamination and secondary alteration, including pulse heating during atmospheric entry. Fe in pyrrhotite inclusions was oxidized and Mg, S, Ca, and Fe were depleted relative to lithophile Al and Si, resulting in reduction in element/Si ratios. Because they trap outgassing elements, Fe-rich oxide rims that formed on the surface of GEMS are serendipitous “witness plates” to the changes in composition that accompany atmospheric entry. As a result of alteration, GEMS elemental compositions cannot reliably inform about their provenance. Except for highly anomalous oxygen isotope ratios measured in some large GEMS grains that indicate a contribution from circumstellar dust, oxygen isotope compositions are generally poor indicators of provenance. Prior work indicates that most GEMS fall close to the terrestrial oxygen isotope composition, which, however, does not exclude a presolar interstellar origin. Nitrogen isotopic compositions are more diagnostic. Elevated 15 N/ 14 N ratios indicate that GEMS accreted in conjunction with formation of organic matter by ion–molecule reactions in a cold (<50 K) presolar environment like the extreme outer nebula or interstellar medium. Considering all observations, we conclude that GEMS are most likely processed interstellar silicates.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

THE ORION H ii REGION AND THE ORION BAR IN THE MID-INFRARED

We present mid-infrared photometry of the Orion bar obtained with the Faint Object infraRed Camera for the SOFIA Telescope (FORCAST) on board SOFIA at 6.4, 6.6, 7.7, 19.7, 31.5, and 37.1 μ m. By complementing this observation with archival FORCAST and Herschel /PACS images, we are able to construct a complete infrared spectral energy distribution of the Huygens region in the Orion nebula. Comparing the infrared images with gas tracers, we find that PACS maps trace the molecular cloud, while the FORCAST data trace the photodissociation region (PDR) and the H ii region. Analysis of the energetics of the region reveal that the PDR extends for 0.28 pc along the line of sight and that the bar is inclined at an angle of 4°. The infrared and submillimeter images reveal that the Orion bar represents a swept-up shell with a thickness of 0.1 pc. The mass of the shell implies a shock velocity of ≃3 km s{sup −1} and an age of ≃10{sup 5} years for the H ii region. Our analysis shows that the UV and infrared dust opacities in the H ii region and the PDR are a factor 5 to 10 lower than in the diffuse interstellar medium. In the ionized gas, Ly α photons are a major source of dust heating at distances larger than ≃0.06 pc from θ {sup 1} Ori C. Dust temperatures can be explained if the size of the grains is between 0.1 and 1 μ m. We derive the photoelectric heating efficiency of the atomic gas in the Orion bar. The results are in good qualitative agreement with models and the quantitative differences indicate a decreased polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon abundance in this region.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Effect of Alignment on Polarized Infrared Emission from Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons

Polarized emission from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) potentially provides a new way to test the basic physics of the alignment of ultrasmall grains. In this paper, we present a new model of polarized PAH emission that takes into account the effect of PAH alignment with the magnetic field. We first generate a large sample of the grain angular momentum J by simulating the alignment of PAHs due to resonance paramagnetic relaxation that accounts for various interaction processes. We then calculate the polarization level of the PAH emission features for the different phases of the interstellar medium, including the cold neutral medium (CNM), reflection nebulae (RNe), and photodissociation regions. We find that a moderate degree of PAH alignment can significantly enhance the polarization degree of the PAH emission compared to the previous results obtained with randomly oriented angular momentum. In particular, we find that the smallest negatively charged PAHs in RNe can be excited to slightly suprathermal rotation due to enhanced ion collisional excitation, resulting in an increase of the polarization with the ionization fraction. Our results suggest that an RN is the most favorable environment in which to observe polarized PAH emission and to test the alignment physics of nanoparticles. Finally, we present an explicit relationship between the polarization level of PAH emission and the degree of external alignment for the CNM and RNe. The obtained relationship will be particularly useful for testing the alignment physics of PAHs in future observations.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Physical Characterization of Interstellar Comet 2I/2019 Q4 (Borisov)

We present a study of interstellar comet 2I/2019 Q4 (Borisov) using both preperihelion and postperihelion observations spanning late September 2019 through late January 2020. The intrinsic brightness of the comet was observed to continuously decline throughout the timespan, likely due to the decreasing effective scattering cross-section as a result of volatile sublimation with a slope of −0.43 ± 0.02 km{sup 2} d{sup −1}. We witnessed no significant change in the slightly reddish color of the comet, with mean values of 〈g−r〉=0.68±0.04, 〈r−i〉=0.23±0.03, and the normalized reflectivity gradient across the g and i bands (S{sup ′})-bar (g,i)=(10.6±1.4)% per 10{sup 3} Å, all unremarkable in the context of solar system comets. Using the available astrometric observations, we confidently detect the nongravitational acceleration of the comet following a shallow heliocentric distance dependence of r{sub H}{sup −1±1}. Accordingly, we estimate that the nucleus is most likely ≲0.4 km in radius, and that a fraction of ≳0.2% of the total mass of the nucleus has been eroded due to the sublimation activity since the earliest observation of the comet in 2018 December by the time of perihelion. Our morphology simulation suggests that the dust ejection speed increased from ∼4 m s{sup −1} in 2019 September to ∼7 m s{sup −1} around perihelion for the optically dominant dust grains with β∼0.01, and that the observable dust grains are no smaller than micron size.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Fe II EMISSION IN ACTIVE GALACTIC NUCLEI: THE ROLE OF TOTAL AND GAS-PHASE IRON ABUNDANCE

Active galactic nuclei (AGNs) have Fe II emission from the broad-line region (BLR) that differs greatly in strength from object to object. We examine the role of the total and gas-phase iron abundance in determining Fe II strength. Using AGN spectra from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) in the redshift range of 0.2 < z < 0.35, we measure the Fe/Ne abundance of the narrow-line region (NLR) using the [Fe VII]/[Ne V] line intensity ratio. We find no significant difference in the abundance of Fe relative to Ne in the NLR as a function of Fe II/H{beta}. However, the [N II]/[S II] ratio increases by a factor of 2 with increasing Fe II strength. This indicates a trend in N/S abundance ratio, and by implication in the overall metallicity of the NLR gas, with increasing Fe II strength. We propose that the wide range of Fe II strength in AGN largely results from the selective depletion of Fe into grains in the low ionization portion of the BLR. Photoionization models show that the strength of the optical Fe II lines varies almost linearly with gas-phase Fe abundance, while the ultraviolet Fe II strength varies more weakly. Interstellar depletions of Fe can be as large as 2 orders of magnitude, sufficient to explain the wide range of optical Fe II strength in AGNs. This picture is consistent with the similarity of the BLR radius to the dust sublimation radius and with indications of Fe II emitting gas flowing inward from the dusty torus.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

HOT HYDROGEN IN DIFFUSE CLOUDS

Laboratory evidence suggests that recombination of adsorbed radicals may cause an abrupt temperature excursion of a dust grain to about 1000 K. One consequence of this is the rapid desorption of adsorbed H{sub 2} molecules with excitation temperatures of this magnitude. We compute the consequences of injection of hot H{sub 2} into cold diffuse interstellar gas at a rate of 1% of the canonical H{sub 2} formation rate. We find that the level populations of H{sub 2} in J = 3, 4, and 5 are close to observed values, and that the abundances of CH{sup +} and OH formed in reactions with hot hydrogen are close to the values obtained from observations of diffuse clouds.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

The PAH Emission Characteristics of the Reflection Nebula NGC 2023

We present 5–20 μ m spectral maps of the reflection nebula NGC 2023 obtained with the Infrared Spectrograph SL and SH modes on board the Spitzer Space Telescope, which reveal emission from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), C{sub 60}, and H{sub 2} superposed on a dust continuum. We show that several PAH emission bands correlate with each other and exhibit distinct spatial distributions that reveal a spatial sequence with distance from the illuminating star. We explore the distinct morphology of the 6.2, 7.7, and 8.6 μ m PAH bands and find that at least two spatially distinct components contribute to the 7–9 μ m PAH emission in NGC 2023. We report that the PAH features behave independently of the underlying plateaus. We present spectra of compact, oval PAHs ranging in size from C{sub 66} to C{sub 210}, determined computationally using density functional theory, and we investigate trends in the band positions and relative intensities as a function of PAH size, charge, and geometry. Based on the NASA Ames PAH database, we discuss the 7–9 μ m components in terms of band assignments and relative intensities. We assign the plateau emission to very small grains with possible contributions from PAH clusters and identify components in the 7–9 μ m emission that likely originate in these structures. Based on the assignments and the observed spatial sequence, we discuss the photochemical evolution of the interstellar PAH family as the PAHs are more and more exposed to the radiation field of the central star in the evaporative flows associated with the Photo-Dissociation Regions in NGC 2023.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

Observations of diffuse interstellar lines toward stars with low column densities of H2

The diffuse interstellar band at 5780 A has been observed in lines of sight where the column density of H2 is less than 10 to the 16th/sq cm. The strength of 5780 A toward Gamma Cas, Kappa Ori, and Rho Leo argues strongly against a molecular carrier of the 5780 A feature. The interstellar band at 5797 A also appears to be present in Kappa Ori and Rho Leo. Although the exact mechanism remains unclear, it is concluded that the diffuse features at 5780 A and 5797 A are carried by dust grains.

Meyer, D. M.↗

Interstellar dust spectra between 2.5 and 3.3 microns - A search for hydrated silicates

Spectra in the 2.5-3.3 micron wavelength region of VI Cyg 12, AFGL 2205, and AFGL 2885 were obtained in a search for bound water, hydroxyl groups, and hydrated minerals in interstellar dust. No new absorption bands were found. Comparison of expected strengths of bands of serpentine and chlorite-like minerals with the data suggests that less than 25 percent and 50 percent, respectively, of the silicate in the grains is composed of these materials.

Knacke, R. F.↗

Using far-infrared limb brightening to probe isolated dark globules

The problem of radiation transport in dark globules with or without internal heat source, immersed in an isotropic incident interstellar radiation field, is solved. The phenomenon of infrared limb brightening, its dependence on cloud properties, and its observational implications are addressed. Numerical results regarding the dependence of limb brightening on total cloud opacity, luminosity of internal heat source, grain type, dust density distribution, and wavelength of emitted radiation are discussed. Observational implications concerning the use of limb brightening to place an upper limit on the luminosity of an embedded protostar and to determine the grain emissivity law in the far-infrared are examined. For sufficiently large optical depth, the limb-brightening ratio (LBR) is found to be related to the optical depth by a power-law relation in the 140-300 micron wavelength range, where thermal emission from grains peaks. By observing the LBR in this range, this power-law relationship can be exploited to determine the emissivity law of the dust grain in the far-infrared. Both the LBR and the longest wavelength for which limb brightening still occurs are related linearly to the luminosity of the central source.

Leung, Chun Ming↗

Modeling of infrared flux spectra from disk-shaped interstellar dust clouds

Although there is growing observational and theoretical evidence for many disk-shaped objects of astrophysical interest, spherical geometry is assumed in most radiative transfer models. Recently we generalized the quasi-diffusion method developed by Leung (1975, 1976) for spherical geometry to solve the problem of scattering, absorption, and reemission by dust grains in a medium of disk geometry. The method is applicable to a variety of astronomical sources whose dynamics are angular-momentum dominated and hence not accurately treated by spherical geometry, e.g., protoplanetary nebulae, circumstellar disks, bipolar-flow molecular clouds, accretion disks and disk galaxies. Using this technique and realistic grain opacities we construct theoretical models to determine self-consistently the dust temperature distribution and infrared emission from disk-shaped, quiescent dark globules heated externally by the intersteller radiation field. The effects of the following parameters on the temperature structure and the emergent spectrum are studied: grain type (graphite and silicate), optical depth, density inhomogeneity, and degree of disk flattening. The disk models are characterized by an aspect ratio and an optical depth at 0.55 microns. For inhomogeneous models, a gaussian density distribution is assumed such that the ratio of central to surface density is 100. To study the effects of source geometry, we also compare results for models with spherical and disk geometry. In this case both models have the same radius and central optical depth, the disk models having a 1:1 aspect ratio. While the dust temperature distributions in the two cases are very similar, the emergent flux for the disk model depends sensitively on the viewing angle. For clouds which are unresolved, one would expect, since the thermal emission is isotropic in the neighborhood of an emitting grain, and since the emission (in the far infrared) is optically thin, that the emergent flux spectrum should be characteristic only of the dust temperature, and independent of viewing angle. However, because of the lack of complete symmetry and the resulting radiation anisotropy, this is found not to be the case for the disk models. Angle is that it implies a large uncertainty in estimating the radiation dust mass.

Spagna, G. F., Jr.↗