Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “separator”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 127 records · Page 7

Extraction and Separation Modeling of Orion Test Vehicles with ADAMS Simulation

The Capsule Parachute Assembly System (CPAS) project has increased efforts to demonstrate the performance of fully integrated parachute systems at both higher dynamic pressures and in the presence of wake fields using a Parachute Compartment Drop Test Vehicle (PCDTV) and a Parachute Test Vehicle (PTV), respectively. Modeling the extraction and separation events has proven challenging and an understanding of the physics is required to reduce the risk of separation malfunctions. The need for extraction and separation modeling is critical to a successful CPAS test campaign. Current PTV-alone simulations, such as Decelerator System Simulation (DSS), require accurate initial conditions (ICs) drawn from a separation model. Automatic Dynamic Analysis of Mechanical Systems (ADAMS), a Commercial off the Shelf (COTS) tool, was employed to provide insight into the multi-body six degree of freedom (DOF) interaction between parachute test hardware and external and internal forces. Components of the model include a composite extraction parachute, primary vehicle (PTV or PCDTV), platform cradle, a release mechanism, aircraft ramp, and a programmer parachute with attach points. Independent aerodynamic forces were applied to the mated test vehicle/platform cradle and the separated test vehicle and platform cradle. The aero coefficients were determined from real time lookup tables which were functions of both angle of attack ( ) and sideslip ( ). The atmospheric properties were also determined from a real time lookup table characteristic of the Yuma Proving Grounds (YPG) atmosphere relative to the planned test month. Representative geometries were constructed in ADAMS with measured mass properties generated for each independent vehicle. Derived smart separation parameters were included in ADAMS as sensors with defined pitch and pitch rate criteria used to refine inputs to analogous avionics systems for optimal separation conditions. Key design variables were dispersed in a Monte Carlo analysis to provide the maximum expected range of the state variables at programmer deployment to be used as ICs in DSS. Extensive comparisons were made with Decelerator System Simulation Application (DSSA) to validate the mated portion of the ADAMS extraction trajectory. Results of the comparisons improved the fidelity of ADAMS with a ramp pitch profile update from DSSA. Post-test reconstructions resulted in improvements to extraction parachute drag area knock-down factors, extraction line modeling, and the inclusion of ball-to-socket attachments used as a release mechanism on the PTV. Modeling of two Extraction parachutes was based on United States Air Force (USAF) tow test data and integrated into ADAMS for nominal and Monte Carlo trajectory assessments. Video overlay of ADAMS animations and actual C-12 chase plane test videos supported analysis and observation efforts of extraction and separation events. The COTS ADAMS simulation has been integrated with NASA based simulations to provide complete end to end trajectories with a focus on the extraction, separation, and programmer deployment sequence. The flexibility of modifying ADAMS inputs has proven useful for sensitivity studies and extraction/separation modeling efforts. 1

Fraire, Usbaldo, Jr.↗

Computational Study of Vortex-Induced Separation for a 5-Bladed Rotor

This work computationally investigated the rotor blade vortex-induced separation recently observed during an aerodynamic rotor test campaign in the NASA Langley Research Center 14- by 22-Foot Subsonic Tunnel. Two separate approaches (i.e., airfoil modification and blade tip modification) were studied to mitigate the vortex-induced separation. Low-fidelity tools based on blade element momentum theory were shown to mispredict the rotor inflow and were also shown to not capture the vortex-induced separation caused by perpendicular blade-vortex interaction. This misprediction was exploited to isolate the aerodynamic thrust deficit caused by the vortex-induced separation (i.e., 20%) from the thrust deficit due to inflow variation (i.e., 31%). High-fidelity tools were shown to reasonably predict aerodynamic forces within 13% and flow separation when compared to experimental results. The modified airfoil variant of the baseline rotor effectively mitigated the vortex-induced separation while the blade tip modified variant still showed separation, though the size and strength of the vortex was reduced. Acoustic predictions were underpredicted by 10 dB from preliminary measurements taken in the untreated wind tunnel. Broadband noise contributions from different rotor blade sections showed that self-noise due to flow separation and other turbulent boundary layer mechanisms was the dominant noise source for all three rotor cases, followed by blade-wake interaction noise caused by perpendicular blade-vortex interactions.

aerodynamics↗

Mechanically and thermally robust microporous copolymer separators for lithium ion batteries

Next generation, multifunctional separators can enhance energy storage, power, and safety performance of lithium ion batteries but must be simple to fabricate and incorporate with existing roll-to-roll manufacturing. Here, this study presents a strategy to facilely prepare these separators using UV-initiated polymerization-induced phase separation (PIPS), wherein microporous polymer separators are fabricated directly from constituent monomers and ethylene carbonate (EC) porogen. This enables a wide compositional design space as co-monomers with specific chemical functionality can be readily incorporated into the PIPS precursor mixture. Herein, 1,4-butanediol diacrylate (BDDA) was copolymerized with poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate (PEGDA) to increase the acrylate conversion in the photopolymerization and improve mechanical properties. By tuning the ratio of PEGDA and EC, separators with high porosity (41.3%) and effective ionic conductivity (2.09 mS cm –1 ) were prepared. Inclusion of PEGDA was essential to increasing the elastic modulus to > 345 MPa, which is required for cell assembly by roll-to-roll manufacturing. All separators prepared were shown to enable reversible cycling of lithium metal/LiNi 0.5 Mn 0.3 Co 0.2 O 2 half-cells for 100 cycles. Unlike conventional polyolefin separators, which were shown to melt at 160 °C and shrink by up to 29.8% at elevated temperatures, the PIPS separators possess exceptional, safety-enhancing thermomechanical properties, undergoing no phase transitions or thermal shrinkage.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Protein-based approach for high-purity Sc, Y, and grouped lanthanide separation

Rare earth elements (REEs: Sc, Y, La- Lu) are irreplaceable components in many clean energy and consumer technologies. However, the extraction and subsequent separation of individual REEs from ore-based feedstocks remains a significant economic and environmental challenge. Here in this work, we investigated the intra-REE separation potential of lanmodulin (LanM), a natural protein from Methylorubrum extorquens that has emerged as a sustainable potential alternative to conventional solvent extraction-based separation. By determining the intra-REE selectivity of immobilized LanM and systematically testing pH-based and small chelator-based (i.e., citrate and malonate) desorption processes, we established the framework and methodology for achieving select individual and grouped REE separations from a mixed REE feedstock. We show that Sc forms the tightest complex with LanM among REEs but can be readily and selectively desorbed using malonate to generate high-purity Sc (>99 % purity, >99 % yield) in a single adsorption/desorption cycle. We further show that the intrinsic REE selectivity of LanM is sufficient to achieve heavy REE (HREE) separation from light and middle REEs (L-MREEs), yielding an yttrium-enriched product. This separation effect is further magnified by pairing LanM’s unique M-LREE preference with a HREE-preferring chelator in the desorption process, which enriches HREE and MREE fractions relative to low value, abundant La/Ce. Finally, by combining pH- and citrate-based desorption processes in a two-cycle separation scheme, we demonstrate the generation of fractions highly enriched in Y, Gd-Lu, Pr-Eu, and La-Ce. Collectively, these data support the application of a LanM-based approach for achieving impactful REE separations from mixed REE feedstocks.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Simultaneously Blocking Chemical Crosstalk and Internal Short Circuit via Gel-Stretching Derived Nanoporous Non-Shrinkage Separator for Safe Lithium-Ion Batteries

The separator, an ionic permeable and electronic insulating membrane between cathode and anode, plays a crucial role in the electrochemical and safety performance of batteries. However, the commercial polyolefin separators not only suffer from inevitable thermal shrinkage at elevated temperature, but also fail to inhibit the hidden chemical crosstalk of reactive gases such as O 2 , leading to often reported thermal runaway (TR) and hence preventing large-scale implementation of high-energy-density lithium-ion batteries. Herein, a nanoporous non-shrinkage separator (GS-PI) was fabricated via a novel gel-stretching orientation approach to eliminate TR. In situ synchrotron small angle X-ray scattering during heating clearly showed that the as-prepared thin GS-PI separator exhibits superior mechanical tolerance at high temperature, thus effectively preventing internal short circuit. Meanwhile, the unique nanoporous structure design further blocks chemical crosstalk and the associated exothermic reactions. Accelerating Rate Calorimetry test revealed that the practical 1 Ah LiNi 0.6 Co 0.2 Mn 0.2 O 2 (NCM622)/graphite pouch cell using GS-PI nanoporous separator show a maximum temperature rise (dT/dt max ) of only 3.7 °C s -1 compared to 131.6 °C s -1 in the case of Al 2 O 3 @PE macroporous separator. Furthermore, despite the reduced pore size, the GS-PI separator demonstrates better cycling stability than conventional Al 2 O 3 @PE separator at high temperature without sacrificing specific capacity and rate capability.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Topological origin of phase separation in hydrated gels

Depending on their composition, hydrated gels can be homogeneous or phase-separated, which, in turn, affects their dynamical and mechanical properties. However, the nature of the structural features, if any, that govern the propensity for a given gel to phase-separate remains largely unknown. Here, we argue that the propensity for hydrated gels to phase-separate is topological in nature. We employ reactive molecular dynamics simulations to model the early-age precipitation of calcium–alumino–silicate–hydrate (Csingle bondAsingle bondSsingle bondH) gels with varying compositions, i.e., (CaO) 1.7 (Al 2 O 3 ) x (SiO 2 ) 1 – x (H 2 O) 3.7 + x . By adopting topological constraint theory, we investigate the structural origin of phase separation in hydrated gels. We report the existence of a homogeneous-to-phase-separated transition, wherein Si-rich (x ≤ 0.10) Csingle bondAsingle bondSsingle bondH gels are homogeneous, whereas Al-rich (x > 0.10) Csingle bondAsingle bondSsingle bondH gels tend to phase-separate. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this transition is correlated to a topological flexible-to-rigid transition within the atomic network. Finally, we reveal that the propensity for topologically-overconstrained gels to phase-separate arises from the existence of some internal stress within their atomic network, which acts as an energy penalty that drives phase separation.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Functionalized separator for next-generation batteries

Advancements in battery technology have dramatically increased demand for improvements in separator design, as the separator plays a critical role in ensuring the safety and electrochemical performance of the cells. Current separators, either in commercial usage or under investigation, have yet to meet the high stability and lifespan performance standards necessary to prevent deterioration in the efficiency and reliability of the battery technologies. Recently, considerable effort has been devoted to developing functionalized separators, ranging from designing a variety of new materials and modification methods, and increasingly, to optimizing advanced preparation processes. In order to understand how the mechanisms of separator performance are affected by different properties, we will first summarize recent research progress and then have in-depth discussions regarding the separator's significant contribution to enhancing the safety and performance of the cell. Additionally, we then provide our design strategy for future separators, which not only meets the requirements of different type of batteries, but also aims for multifunctionality. We hope such a perspective could provide new inspiration in the development of separator research for future battery technologies.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Elucidating the Microscale Behavior and Phase Separation Kinetics of Thermally Responsive Ionic Liquid–Water Mixtures

Thermally responsive ionic liquids (ILs) exhibit liquid-liquid phase separation into a water-rich (WR) and ionic-liquid-rich (ILR) phase when heated above a lower critical solution temperature (LCST). This phase behavior has been leveraged for applications ranging from forward osmosis (FO) desalination, where the IL acts as a draw solute, to refrigeration and dehumidification cycles, where the IL acts as a liquid desiccant. While significant effort has been devoted to characterizing the thermodynamic and thermophysical properties of LCST ILs, their phase separation kinetics have not been investigated. In this work, we describe the macroscale phase separation kinetics (phase separation time) by gleaning insight into the microscale colloidal behavior of aqueous mixtures of four different materials, P 4444 TFA (tetrabutylphosphonium-2,4-trifluoroacetate), P 4444 DMBS (tetrabutylphosphonium-2,4-dimethyl-benzenesulfonate), N 4444 Sal (tetrabutylammonium salicylate), and P 4444 Sal (tetrabutylphosphonium salicylate) as a function of IL concentration at a separation temperature of 70 °C. We report the discontinuous microscale size distributions for each material and correlate their theoretical settling velocities to experimental phase separation times. The results indicate that a simple Stokes' law model can predict the phase separation time within reasonable accuracy. Overall, this work lays the foundation for understanding the micro- to macroscale phase separation behavior and kinetics of LCST ILs for various water-energy applications.

LCST↗

Toward Continuous, Oriented Covalent Organic Framework Membranes for Precise Molecular Separations

The goal of achieving energy-efficient, precise molecular separations has motivated interest in developing and employing porous crystalline frameworks as membrane materials. Covalent organic frameworks (COFs) are ordered crystalline matrices composed of covalently bonded organic monomers and are synthesized via reversible reticular chemistry. COFs possess high porosity, structural tunability, and chemical and thermal stability, making them ideally suited for emerging, high-value membrane separation processes, such as ion separations, organic solvent nanofiltration, and gas separations. Although a range of COF membranes have been fabricated and tested in the past decade, these membranes are primarily polycrystalline, weakly crystalline, and/or discontinuous, resulting in suboptimal performance. In this review, we identify the properties that make COFs well-suited as membrane materials, while critically outlining the shortcomings of existing disordered COF membranes. We then highlight the recent emergence of highly crystalline, continuous, oriented two-dimensional COF membranes as a promising path forward for highly selective molecular separations. These continuous, oriented COF membranes exhibit tunable one-dimensional nanochannels, allowing for ultrafast molecular transport and precise species selectivity, thereby expanding the set of separations that can be practically achieved with membrane systems. We discuss synthesis and modification techniques that result in continuous, oriented COF membranes and evaluate the performance of such membranes for a variety of molecular separations. We conclude by identifying ongoing challenges in the development of COF membranes and outlining the future of their applications in molecular separations, which will necessarily rely on advancements in the synthesis of continuous, oriented membranes.

COF modification↗

Editorial: Future perspectives on separation technologies

Sustainable separation process development is crucial in promoting economic and environmental sustainability. Separation processes can be energy-intensive, and early-stage or emerging separation technologies can also be costly. For instance, separations in biomass-based fuels and chemicals production can account for up to 50% of the production cost, while industrial separations can consume up to 15% of the total energy used in the United States. Separations are essential to many industrial processes and play a crucial role in helping industry achieve several United Nations sustainable development goals (SDG), such as clean energy, responsible production, and climate change mitigation. Therefore, it is imperative to have a comprehensive discussion within the scientific community to identify innovative approaches for sustainable separation processes. This editorial highlights the key insights and research findings presented in this research topic titled "Future Perspectives on Separation Technologies."

42 ENGINEERING↗

Separator Reconnection at the Magnetopause for Predominantly Northward and Southward IMF: Techniques and Results

In this work, we demonstrate how to track magnetic separators in three-dimensional simulated magnetic fields with or without magnetic nulls, apply these techniques to enhance our understanding of reconnection at the magnetopause. We present three methods for locating magnetic separators and apply them to 3-D resistive MHD simulations of the Earth's magnetosphere using the Block-Adaptive-Tree Solar-wind Roe-type Upwind Scheme code. The techniques for finding separators and determining the reconnection rate are insensitive to interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) clock angle and can in principle be applied to any magnetospheric model. Moreover, the techniques have a number of advantages over prior separator finding techniques applied to the magnetosphere. The present work examines cases of high and low resistivity for two clock angles. We go beyond previous work examine the separator during Flux Transfer Events (FTEs). Our analysis of reconnection on the magnetopause yields a number of interesting conclusions: Reconnection occurs all along the separator even during predominately northward IMF cases. Multiple separators form in low-resistivity conditions, and in the region of an FTE the separator splits into distinct branches. Moreover, the local contribution to the reconnection rate, as determined by the local parallel electric field, drops in the vicinity of the FTE with respect to the value when there are none.

modeling↗

Printed graphene oxide-based membranes for gas separation and carbon capture

Graphene oxide (GO)-based separation membranes have demonstrated the great potential to separate molecules and ions by the interlayer spacing with tunable nano-sized channels. The scalable fabrication of GO-based gas separation membranes, however, remains challenging, although a few preparation approaches have been reported. Here in this work, we present for the first time that the co-solvent ink-jet printing, as a fast and scalable method, can be utilized for scalable GO-based gas separation membrane preparation. Large-area (>100 cm 2 ), ultrathin, and high-quality GO membrane was successfully deposited on commercial polysulfone (PS) support, and characterized by scanning electron microscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, and X-ray diffraction, et al., Selective hydrogen (H 2 ) and helium (He) transport over carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) and nitrogen (N 2 ) was demonstrated for the printed GO membrane. To further explore the separation potential of the printed GO-based gas membrane, additives for facilitated molecular transport were incorporated during the membrane printing process. By inserting CO 2 -philic agents into the printed GO membrane, highly efficient separation of CO 2 from N 2 was achieved with CO 2 /N 2 selectivity of 70 and CO 2 permeance as high as 2,500 GPU. The strategy proposed here may provide guidance for large-scale GO-based gas separation membrane production and a versatile approach for applying other functional 2-dimensional materials towards the membrane separation application.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Leveraging slow $\mathrm{DOTA}$ f-element complexation kinetics to enable separations by kinetic design

The design of metal-concerned solvent extraction systems frequently leverages thermodynamically derived differences in selectivity. An alternative approach, leveraging kinetic control, has been considered much less seriously. Our recent manuscript describing DOTA (1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-1,4,7,10-tetraacetic acid) complexation kinetics across the lanthanide series shows the observed rate constant steadily increases across the series, with some non-monotonic behavior observed at terbium and thulium. This contrasts the thermodynamic stability constant trend, where lanthanide-DOTA stability constants initially increase and then plateau as a function of ionic radii after samarium. To leverage the kinetic differences of DOTA with the lanthanides across the series, kinetically based separations must be utilized. Since DOTA has very slow complexation kinetics, a separations system must expedite DOTA-metal complexation to allow a separation approximating practical application. Here in this report, a DOTA-based solvent extraction system, where DOTA is the aqueous holdback reagent and bis-2,4,4-trimethylpentylphosphinic acid (Cyanex 272) is the organic phase extractant, is demonstrated and compares the separations chemistry of Nd, Eu and Am. The slowness of DOTA complexation was addressed by heating the system. Results showed, in general, separation between metals is better during early phase contact, and diminishes under longer contact times. Under all conditions, separations are better than would be predicted based on a thermodynamic basis. This report suggests that while slowly complexing ligands classically used for biological applications may not be appropriate for thermodynamically designed metal separations, their use for kinetically based systems may be appropriate and enable a new design basis for f-element separations.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Rare earth separation in voltage-gated 2D MXene membranes

The separation of rare earth elements (REEs) has historically been a complicated and expensive process, producing significant amounts of pollution. To this end, MXene membranes (MXMs) have attracted researchers' interest. It has been demonstrated that MXMs are capable of separating ions and that it is possible to precisely control the separation rate by applying a voltage to the membrane. Indeed, due to their chemical nature, MXenes show outstanding electrical conductivity. However, the effect of applied voltage on the permeation rate and separation effects of iconic species remains an intriguing area of research. In this work, we demonstrate how applying different voltages (gate voltage) to a MXM affects the permeation rate of various REE ions. Our hypothesis to explain MXMs behavior towards REE is that under negative voltage, the interlayer spacing decreases due to attraction between charged MXene surfaces and intercalated cations, increasing the separation factor between REEs. Under positive voltage, the interlayer spacing increases due to repulsion between the MXene surfaces and intercalated cations. However, we demonstrate relatively poor separation capability for REEs at 1mM starting concentration and 1.0 V applied DC voltage (separation factor ~1-3). This study demonstrates the need for future experiments to observe varied experimental conditions and chemical functionalization to determine whether MXene membranes can be an efficient platform for REE separation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Design of Multi-Stage Solvent Extraction Process for Separation of Rare Earth Elements

Flowsheet design and stage determination for the separation of rare earth elements (REEs) using solvent extraction (SX) is a challenging task because of the chemical similarity of the REEs. Low separation factors between the elements and complex equilibrium chemistry provide unique challenges to designing an efficient flowsheet for the separation of elements. The multi-stage nature of the SX process adds further complexity, making the assessment of products for a proposed design and stage combination difficult. Therefore, to develop a SX flowsheet, it is essential to quantify the performance for various design and separation conditions. This paper attempts to address the challenge by utilizing an equilibrium and process modeling approach. Results from a bench-scale study performed on a 10 g/L rare earth salt mixture were used in studying the extraction/stripping behavior and developing equilibrium models. DEHPA with TBP as a phase modifier was used as an extractant, while hydrochloric acid was utilized as a stripping agent. The results obtained were used in developing extraction/stripping models, which were integrated into a process framework of a SX train in a Matlab/Simulink environment. The models were programmed as a function block routine and used for developing a flowsheet, which was simulated for differing separation and design conditions. To identify optimum stage combinations, a particle swarm optimization (PSO) routine was developed and implemented for each SX train. Recovery and purity of elements of interest were used as objective function criteria. The stage combination leading to the minimization of the objective function was used to identify the optimum stage combination for a series of SX trains to attempt a balance of purity and recovery. The models and optimization method were implemented to separate a feed mixture containing REEs, which indicated that 99.52 and 85.41 percent purity is achievable for Yttrium and Lanthanum separation using 8-12-3 and 10-3-5 stage combination for loading, scrubbing, and striping. The model also indicated difficult separability between neodymium, praseodymium, and cerium.

Srivastava, Vaibhav (ORCID:0000000212645987)↗

Comparison of several methods for predicting separation in a compressible turbulent boundary layer

Several methods for predicting the separation point for a compressible turbulent boundary layer were applied to the flow over a bump on a wind-tunnel wall. Measured pressure distributions were used as input. Two integral boundary-layer methods, three finite-difference boundary-layer methods, and three simple methods were applied at five free-stream Mach numbers ranging from 0.354 to 0.7325. Each of the boundary-layer methods failed to explicitly predict separation. However, by relaxing the theoretical separation criteria, several boundary-layer methods were made to yield reasonable separation predictions, but none of the methods accurately predicted the important boundary-layer parameters at separation. Only one of the simple methods consistently predicted separation with reasonable accuracy in a manner consistent with the theory. The other methods either indicated several possible separation locations or only sometimes predicted separation.

Gerhart, P. M.↗

Status of flow separation prediction in liquid propellant rocket nozzles

Flow separation which plays an important role in the design of a rocket engine nozzle is discussed. For a given ambient pressure, the condition of no flow separation limits the area ratio and, therefore, the vacuum performance. Avoidance of performance loss due to area ratio limitation requires a correct prediction of the flow separation conditions. To provide a better understanding of the flow separation process, the principal behavior of flow separation in a supersonic overexpanded rocket nozzle is described. The hot firing separation tests from various sources are summarized, and the applicability and accuracy of the measurements are described. A comparison of the different data points allows an evaluation of the parameters that affect flow separation. The pertinent flow separation predicting methods, which are divided into theoretical and empirical correlations, are summarized and the numerical results are compared with the experimental points.

Schmucker, R. H.↗

Evaluation of Production Version of the NASA Improved Inorganic-Organic Separator

The technology of an inorganic-organic (I/O) separator, which demonstrated improved flexibility, reduced cost, production feasibility and improved cycle life was developed. Substrates to replace asbestos and waterbased separator coatings to replace the solvent based coatings were investigated. An improved fuel cell grade asbestos sheet was developed and a large scale production capability for the solvent based I/O separator was demonstrated. A cellulose based substrate and a nonwoven polypropylene fiber substrate were evaluated as replacements for the asbestos. Both the cellulose and polypropylene substrates were coated with solvent based and water based coatings to produce a modified I/O separator. The solvent based coatings were modified to produce aqueous separator coatings with acceptable separator properties. A single ply fuel cell grade asbestos with a binder (BTA) was produced. It has shown to be an acceptable substrate for the solvent and water based separator coatings, an acceptable absorber for alkaline cells, and an acceptable matrix for alkaline fuel cells. The original solvent based separator (K19W1), using asbestos as a substrate, was prepared.

Sheibley, D.↗