Benchmark Comparisons of Lattice Physics Calculations for Thorium-Based Fuels in Pressure-Tube Heavy Water Reactors
Thorium is a fertile nuclear fuel resource that is nearly three times as abundant as uranium in the earth's crust and that can be exploited and used to extend uranium resources. The pressure tube heavy water reactor (PTHWR) is an excellent existing technology for utilizing thorium-based fuels, due to its high neutron economy achieved by using heavy water as a moderator and coolant, the ability to perform online refueling, and its flexibility in fuel management. Reactor physics studies are underway at the Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) to evaluate several types of thorium-based fuels that could be implemented in PT-HWRs in the near-term and intermediate future, building upon past experience. For preliminary, conceptual studies, deterministic lattice physics and core physics codes such as WIMS-AECL and RFSP are used to provide quick and more approximate estimates of performance and safety characteristics. The objective of this study was to perform 2D lattice physics benchmark comparisons between WIMS-AECL and MCNP5 for several types of thorium-based fuel bundle lattices for potential use in PT-HWRs. Benchmark comparisons will help confirm the validity of deterministic calculation results, and provide estimates of the potential magnitude of calculation errors and uncertainties. Areas for potential improvements in the WIMS-AECL calculations may also be identified. (authors)