SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
The fatigue and fail-safe behavior of composite-reinforced, integrally stiffened metal panels was investigated. Test results consisting of conventional fatigue lives, fatigue-crack propagation rates, and residual static strength are presented and discussed.
Static and cyclic load tests were conducted to determine the static and fatigue strength of the RIS tile/SIP thermal protection system used on the orbiter of the space shuttle. The material systems investigated include the densified and undensified LI-900 tile system on the .40 cm thick SIP and the densified and undensified LI-2200 tile system on the .23 cm (.090 inch) thick SIP. The tests were conducted at room temperature with a fully reversed uniform cyclic loading at 1 Hertz. Cyclic loading causes a relatively large reduction in the stress level that each of the SIP/tile systems can withstand for a small number of cycles. For example, the average static strength of the .40 cm thick SIP/LI-900 tile system is reduced from 86 kPa to 62 kPa for a thousand cycles. Although the .23 cm thick SIP/LI-2200 tile system has a higher static strength, similar reductions in the fatigue strength are noted. Densifying the faying surface of the RSI tile changes the failure mode from the SIP/tile interface to the parent RSI or the SIP and thus greatly increases the static strength of the system. Fatigue failure for the densified tile system, however, occurs due to complete separation or excessive elongation of the SIP and the fatigue strength is only slightly greater than that for the undensified tile system.
A Mode II test specimen was developed which has potential application in understanding phemonena associated with mixed mode fatigue failures in high performance aircraft engine bearing races. The attributes of the specimen are: it contains one single ended notch, which simplifiers data gathering and reduction; the fatigue crack grous in-line with the direction of load application; a single axis test machine is sufficient to perform testing; and the Mode I component is vanishingly small.
A Mode II test specimen was developed which has potential application in understanding phemonena associated with mixed mode fatigue failures in high performance aircraft engine bearing races. The attributes of the specimen are: it contains one single ended notch, which simplifies data gathering and reduction; the fatigue crack grows in-line with the direction of load application; a single axis test machine is sufficient to perform testing; and the Mode I component is vanishingly small.
Gears, bearings, and similar mechanical elements transmit loads through the surfaces that are in contact with one another. Thus, the fatigue lives of gears can be improved by providing smoother tooth surfaces. At the NASA Lewis Research Center, we completed a metrology evaluation of one method for making gears with a highly polished, mirrorlike surface. The polished gears were measured carefully. The measurement data showed that the polishing process did, indeed, reduce the surface roughness but did not change the overall tooth shape in any harmful way. This work was done as a partnership of NASA, the U.S. Army, and the University of Wales. NASA provided conventionally ground gear specimens and has begun testing to determine the fatigue lives of the superfinished gears. Under contract, the University of Wales superfinished the gears and inspected them before and after the superfinishing operation. The U.S. Army European Research Office provided the funds and procured the contract with the University of Wales.
We report hydride-dehydride (HDH) Ti-6Al-4V alloy with particle size distribution of 50–120 µm is laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) processed using optimum processing parameters and a near-fully dense structure with a density of 99.9 % is achieved. Microstructural observations and phase analyses indicate formation of columnar β grains with acicular α/α' phases in as-built condition. The roughness of the as-fabricated samples is significant with an average roughness of R a = 15.71 ± 3.96 µm and a root mean square roughness of R rms = 108.4 ± 24.9 µm, however, both values are reduced to R a = 0.19 ± 0.04 µm and R rms = 4.9 ± 0.6 µm after mechanical grinding. Mechanical tests are carried out on as-fabricated specimens followed by stress relief treatment. All samples are tested to failure in fatigue, under fully-reversed tension-compression conditions of R = –1. The as-built samples failed from the surface with crack initiation mainly at micro-notches, whereas after mechanically grinding, crack initiation changed to subsurface defects such as pores. Minimizing surface roughness by mechanically grinding eliminates surface micro-notches which improves fatigue strength in the high cycle fatigue region. Fatigue notch factor calculations showed that the effect of surface roughness was significantly lower when HDH powder is used compared to standard spherical powder. X-ray diffraction analysis revealed an in-plane compressive stress, micro-strain and grain refinement on the surface of the mechanically ground samples. Fractography observations (macroscale) revealed a fully brittle fracture in the first stage of crack growth with a transition to a dominantly ductile fracture in the third stage of crack growth. On the other hand, at the micro scale, even the brittle fracture regions showed evidence of ductile fracture within the α' martensite laths.
The deployment of 9-12% Cr steels for elevated temperature applications up to 650 °C presents a cost-effective alternative to more expensive nickel-based alloys in steam turbine power generation. To enhance creep resistance at this temperature range, a novel ferritic-martensitic steel, designated CPJ7, was developed and fabricated at the National Energy Technology Laboratory. The alloy design aimed to mitigate the transformation of strengthening carbides into deleterious phases that degrade creep performance. Results have demonstrated that CPJ7 exhibits favorable creep and oxidation resistance at 650 °C. However, its fatigue performance remains unexplored. This study builds upon prior research by evaluating the low cycle fatigue behavior of CPJ7 and verifying that modifications beneficial to creep performance were not detrimental to the fatigue performance. The alloy was tested at both 650 °C and ambient temperature under fully reversed bending conditions (R = − 1) and a load ratio of 0.05. Furthermore, the alloy exhibits cyclic softening, a behavior consistent with other 9-10 wt.% Cr steels. Analysis of the microstructure and hysteresis loops further corroborate cyclic softening mechanisms typical of ferritic-martensitic steels. Overall, the fatigue performance of CPJ7 meets or exceeds that of P91 steel, demonstrating its potential for high-temperature structural applications.
High-strength aluminum alloys for elevated temperature applications are desirable to replace heavier and more expensive titanium alloys. However, most aluminum alloys lose a large fraction of their strength at temperatures above approximately 200°C. ORNL has designed DuAlumin-3D, an alloy with nominal composition Al-9Ce-4Ni-0.5Mn-1Zr (wt.%), which utilizes the high cooling rates in additive manufacturing (AM) to achieve a refined microstructure, and thermally stable mechanical properties. DuAlumin-3D was fabricated by laser powder bed fusion and tested for its tensile mechanical properties across a range of temperature, and for its room temperature high-cycle fatigue resistance. The alloy was tested in both the as-printed and heat treated conditions, and both parallel and perpendicular to the AM build direction. The alloy was found to have anisotropic mechanical behavior in the as-printed state, but the anisotropy significantly decreased (both for tensile and fatigue properties) following heat treatment. The tensile properties significantly out-performed benchmark wrought 2219-T61 across a wide temperature range. The room temperature fatigue performance was approximately similar to 2219-T61.
An independent assessment was conducted to determine the critical initial flaw size (CIFS) for the flange-to-skin weld in the Ares I-X Upper Stage Simulator (USS). Material characterization tests were conducted to quantify the material behavior for use in the CIFS analyses. Fatigue crack growth rate, Charpy impact, and fracture tests were conducted on the parent and welded A516 Grade 70 steel. The crack growth rate tests confirmed that the material behaved in agreement with literature data and that a salt water environment would not significantly degrade the fatigue resistance. The Charpy impact tests confirmed that the fracture resistance of the material did not have a significant reduction for the expected operational temperatures of the vehicle.
A collaborative research and development effort in support of the Alloy 709 Code Case qualification in the American Society of Mechanical Engineers Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section III, Division 5, High Temperature Reactors is being conducted at the US Department of Energy’s Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Idaho National Laboratory, and Argonne National Laboratory. A recent assessment on the Alloy 709 development and testing effort concluded that the mechanical properties of Alloy 709 with the precipitation treatment continued to outperform those of Type 316 stainless steel. The assessment also affirmed the recommendation for its Code qualification. This report provides the detailed integrated data generated to date on the two commercial heats of Alloy 709 in plate product form with precipitation treatment condition that were used as the basis for this assessment. Oak Ridge National Laboratory has continued to perform a subset of the Code Case testing for tensile properties, creep rupture, fatigue, and creep-fatigue. This report also updates the key Alloy 709 Code Case testing status and results in FY 2022 at Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
A test program was developed and executed to evaluate the influence of corroded hemispherical notches on the fatigue crack initiation and propagation in aluminum 7075-T7351, 4340 steel, and D6AC steel. Surface enhancements such as shot peening and laser shock peening were also incorporated as part of the test effort with the intent of improving fatigue performance. In addition to the testing, fracture mechanics and endurance limit based analysis methods were evaluated to characterize the results with the objective of challenging typical assumptions used in modeling fatigue cracks from corrosion pits. The results specifically demonstrate that the aluminum and steel alloys behave differently with respect to fatigue crack initiation from hemispherical corrosion pits. The aluminum test results were bounded by the fracture mechanics and endurance limit models while exhibiting a general insensitivity to the residual stress field generated by shot peening. The steel specimens were better characterized by the endurance limit fatigue properties and did exhibit sensitivities to residual stresses from the shot peening and laser shock peening
The effects of stress ratio (R) and crack opening behavior on fatigue crack growth rates (da/dN) for aluminum alloy (AA) 2024-T3 were investigated using constant-delta K testing, closure measurements, and fractography. Fatigue crack growth rates were obtained for a range of delta K and stress ratios. Results show that constant delta K fatigue crack growth for R ranging from near 0 to 1 is divided into three regions. In Region 1, at low R, da/dN increases with increasing R. In Region 2, at intermediate R, fatigue crack growth rates are relatively independent of R. In Region 3, at high R, further increases in da/dN are observed with increasing R.
For a variety of medical and scientific reasons, human bones can be exposed to a wide range of ionizing radiation levels. In vivo radiation therapy (0.05 kGy) is used in cancer treatment, and ex vivo irradiation (25-35 kGy) is used to sterilize bone allografts. Ionizing radiation in these applications has been shown to increase risk of fracture, decrease bone quality and degrade collagen integrity. Past studies have investigated the deleterious effects of radiation on cortical or trabecular bone specimens individually, but to date no studies have examined whole bones containing both cortical and trabecular tissue. Furthermore, a clear relationship between the dose and the mechanical and biochemical response of bone's extracellular matrix has yet to be established for doses ranging from cancer therapy to allograft sterilization (0.05-35 kGy). To gain insight into these issues, we conducted an ex vivo radiation study to investigate non-cellular (i.e. matrix) effects of ionizing radiation dose on vertebral whole bone mechanical properties, over a range of radiation doses (0.05-35 kGy), with a focus on any radiation-induced changes in collagen. With underlying mechanisms of action in mind, we hypothesized that any induced reductions in mechanical properties would be associated with changes in collagen integrity. METHODS: 20-week old female mice were euthanized and the lumbar spine was dissected using IACUC approved protocols. The lumbar vertebrae (L1- S1) were extracted from the spine via cuts through adjacent intervertebral discs, and the endplates, posterior processes, surrounding musculature, and soft tissues were removed (approx. 1.5mm diameter, approx. 2mm height). Specimens were randomly assigned to one of five groups for ex vivo radiation exposure: x-ray irradiation at 0.05, 1, 17, or 35 kGy, or a 0 kGy control. Following irradiation, the vertebrae were imaged using microcomputed tomography (micro-CT) and then subjected to either monotonic compressive loading to failure or uniform cyclic compressive loading. During cyclic testing, samples were loaded in force control to a force level that corresponded to a strain of 0.46%, as determined in advance by a linearly elastic micro-CT-based finite element analysis for each specimen. Tests were stopped at imminent fracture, defined as a rapid increase in strain. The main outcome for the monotonic test was the strength (maximum force); for cyclic testing it was the fatigue life (log of the number of cycles of loading at imminent failure). A fluorometric assay was used on the S1 vertebrae to measure the number of non-enzymatic collagen crosslinks[4]. A one-way ANOVA was performed on mechanical properties and collagen crosslinks; means were compared with controls using Dunnett's method, with a Tukey-Kramer post-hoc analysis when significance was found (p < or = 0.05). RESULTS: Compared to the unirradiated control group, the concentration of non-enzymatic collagen crosslinks was significantly increased for all irradiated groups (p < 0.0001), and being higher by at least 50% (Figure 1a). By contrast, the radiation effects on the collagen were only evident at the higher doses. For irradiation exposures of 17 kGy or more, strength decreased substantially as the radiation level was increased, but no effect was evident below 17 kGy (Figure 1b). There was no significant change in the stiffness or maximum displacement for any radiation dose (p>0.05). The finite element analysis prescribed force level for cyclic loading exceeded the measured (monotonic) strength of the 17 and 35 kGy irradiated groups (mean +/- SD, 20.6 +/- 5.6 N; 13.2 +/- 3.7 N, respectively) and therefore these groups were eliminated from the fatigue study. The fatigue life for the 0.05 and 1 kGy groups were similar to each other and were not statistically significantly different from the control group (Figure 1c).
Results of tests conducted on preliminary design polymeric-composite fan blade for the under the wing (UTW) OCSEE engine are presented. During this phase of the program a total of 17preliminary OCSEE UTW composite fan blades were manufactured for various component tests including frequency characteristics, strain distribution, bench fatigue, dovetail pull, whirligig overspeed and whirligig impact. All tests were successfully completed with the exception of whirligig impact tests. Improvements in local impact capability are being evaluated for the OCSEE blade under other NASA and related programs.
Spur gear endurance tests were conducted to investigate the surface pitting fatigue life of noninvolute gears with low numbers of teeth and low contact ratios for use in advanced applications. The results were compared with those for a standard involute design with a low number of teeth. The gear pitch diameter was 8.89 cm (3.50 in.) with 12 teeth on both gear designs. Test conditions were an oil inlet temperature of 320 K (116 F), an oil outlet temperature of 350 K (170 F), a maximum Hertz stress of 1.49 GPa (216 ksi), and a speed of 10 000 rpm. The following results were obtained: the noninvolute gear had a surface pitting fatigue life approximately 1.6 times that of the standard involute gear of a similar design; and the surface pitting fatigue life of the 3.43-pitch AISI 8620 noninvolute gear was approximately equal to the surface pitting fatigue life of an 8-pitch, 28-tooth AISI 9310 gear at the same load but at a considerably higher maximum Hertz stress.
Spur gear endurance tests were conducted to investigate the surface pitting fatigue life of noninvolute gears with low numbers of teeth and low contact ratios for use in advanced applications. The results were compared with those for a standard involute design with a low number of teeth. The gear pitch diameter was 8.89 cm (3.50 in.) with 12 teeth on both gear designs. Test conditions were an oil inlet temperature of 320 K (116 F), an oil outlet temperature of 350 K (170 F), a maximum Hertz stress of 1.49 GPa (216 ksi), and a speed of 10,000 rpm. The following results were obtained: the noninvolute gear had a surface pitting fatigue life approximately 1.6 times that of the standard involute gear of a similar design; and the surface pitting fatigue life of the 3.43-pitch AISI 8620 noninvolute gear was approximately equal to the surface pitting fatigue life of an 8-pitch, 28-tooth AISI 9310 gear at the same load but at a considerably higher maximum Hertz stress.
Tests were performed to determine the damage states in quasi-isotropic graphite/epoxy laminates with center holes caused by cyclic tensile loading. The influence of the stacking sequence on the initiation and interaction of damage modes and the relationship between damage, strength, stiffness, and life of the laminates were also studied. X-ray radiography, moire interferometry, and stiffness change were used to monitor damage. Fatigue damage in both laminates began with matrix cracks around the holes leading to delaminations. In laminates cycled at the same percent of notched tensile strength the stacking sequence influenced the density of the matrix cracks and the modes and distribution of the damage. Ply cracking was also caused by the stacking sequence. The damage states in the two laminates produced stiffness changes of 15 to 20 percent, different rates of change in residual strength, and a factor of two to four difference in fatigue life. It was determined that continued cyclic loading produced matrix cracks which led to fatigue of the laminates.
The mechanical properties of single crystal turbine blade alloys in a gaseous hydrogen environment were determined. These alloys are proposed for use in space propulsion systems in pure or partial high pressure hydrogen environments at elevated temperatures. Mechanical property tests included: tensile, creep, low fatigue (LCF), and crack growth. Specimens were in both transverse and longitudinal directions relative to the casting solidification direction. Testing was conducted on solid specimens exposed to externally pressurized environments of gaseous hydrogen and hydrogen-enriched steam.