Markers and Beyond: Categorizing Human Intrusion Situations to be Addressed in Sub-surface Marking Concepts - 16378
Concepts for the use of markers in the post-closure phase of deep geological repositories (DGRs), are often designed to prevent 'inadvertent' human intrusion (HI), while it is common practice not to protect against deliberate intrusion (i.e. 'advertent' HI). In the literature, inadvertent HI prevention studies usually combine future human activity scenarios with the assumption that all memory of the DGR has been lost, and analyze what can be done now to make the possible future intruder 'aware' of the associated risks. In this paper, we show that the classical 'advertent'/'inadvertent' duality classification of HI, as used in the performance assessment context, is not ideal to characterize potential HI situations in the RK and M preservation context. We suggest that the relevant HI categories are expanded and refined to 'un/necessary HI', 'un/intentional HI' and 'un/friendly HI'. Along with refining the taxonomy of HI that way, we refine the assumption relating to the loss of memory of the DGR. Different HI situations are likely to arise in different 'loss-of-memory situations'. We analyze the resulting 5 classes of the proposed HI classification and find that 2 hold the classic 'advertent' and 'inadvertent' HI scenarios while 3 are 'new'. We apply the proposed categories to sub-surface marking concepts from the literature and suggest that, in particular, sub-surface marking concepts would benefit from this new approach to HI and loss-of-memory categorization. (authors)